Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

a faulty premise , one it follows into melodrama and silliness

negative

Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

as obnoxious as tom green 's freddie got fingered

negative

Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

fails in making this character understandable , in getting under her skin , in exploring motivation ...

negative

Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

sub-formulaic slap
negative