What is the most logical next event?

How to repair textured drywall
Purchase pre-mixed drywall mud from a home supply store.
This is what most people consider traditional drywall mud, sold in either boxes or buckets. The most common types are " all purpose ", " lightweight all purpose ", and " topping " mixed drywall.
Use this to repair minor drywall damages and to create your texture. Purchase a piece of drywall if you are repairing a larger hole.