Problem: Joel had to put on multiple layers of clothes unlike Logan because

My choice: Logan lived in a hot area.

Problem: Christine played spin the bottle and had to kiss Betty after their turn, because

My choice: Betty was the the one who got picked by the bottle.

Problem: Michael liked to play the piano. Randy did not.

My choice: Randy thought the piano was a terrible instrument.

Problem: Benjamin was trying to get in shape and bought a bicycle instead of a treadmill because with the

My choice:
treadmill he couldn't be outdoors.