Problem: S1: James the Fat would never return to his native Scotland . He remained an exile in Ireland until his death . His widowed mother and sister remained in Scotland .
S2: James the Fat would never return to his native Scotland , he remained in exile in Scotland until his death , his widowed mother and sister in Ireland .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: no

Problem: S1: His father has called him Ali , and his nickname was Murtaza .
S2: His father called him Ali and his nickname was Murtaza .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: yes

Problem: S1: The logical fallacy is a historical fallacy originally described by philosopher John Dewey in '' The Psychological Review '' in 1896 .
S2: The historical fallacy is a logical fallacy that was described in '' The Psychological Review '' in 1896 by the philosopher John Dewey .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A:
no