You will be given a context, a subject and a relation. Your task is to generate a question based on the subject and relation. The generated question should include the given subject. Try to use a minimum number of words that are not present in either context, subject or relation while generating question.

Q: Context : Edward Hatch (December 22, 1832 -- April 11, 1889) was a career American soldier who served as a general in the Union Army during the American Civil War.
Subject : Edward Hatch
Relation : military branch

A: What military branch was Edward Hatch in?
****
Q: Context : ''The Bolt Who Screwed Christmas'' is an independent animated short film and a parody or satire of ''How the Grinch Stole Christmas!'' written and directed by John Wardlaw and animated by Adny Angrand.
Subject : The Bolt Who Screwed Christmas
Relation : based on

A: Which is the basis of The Bolt Who Screwed Christmas?
****
Q: Context : Jacques-Christophe Valmont de Bomare (born 17 September 1731, Rouen; died 24 August 1807, Paris) was a French botanist and naturalist.
Subject : Jacques-Christophe Valmont de Bomare
Relation : occupation

A:
What was Jacques-Christophe Valmont de Bomare's occupation?
****