Problem: S1: Born in 1783 in Sheffield , the second son of Isabella and Thomas Beilby , the family went to Birmingham in 1783 .
S2: Born in 1783 in Birmingham , the second son of Isabella and Thomas Beilby . In 1783 the family moved to Sheffield .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: no

Problem: S1: Barrallier Island is a very small uninhabited island that is located northwest of French Island in Victoria , Australia .
S2: French Island is a very small uninhabited island situated northwest of Barrallier Island in Victoria , Australia .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: no

Problem: S1: Oscar Eduardo Villarreal ( born March 27 , 1981 in Cali , Peru ) is a Colombian footballer currently playing for Total Chalaco of the Segunda Division in Colombia .
S2: Oscar Eduardo Villarreal ( born March 27 , 1981 in Cali , Colombia ) is a Colombian footballer who is currently playing for Total Chalaco of the Segunda Division in Peru .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A:
no