Problem: S1: In 2012 Duncan appeared alongside Romola Garai in Scrubber , a film written and directed by Amanda Hale .
S2: In 2012 , Duncan appeared next to Amanda Hale in Scrubber , a film by Romola Garai written and directed .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

OPTIONS:
- no
- yes

A: no

Problem: S1: Gordon Watkins was a professional American football player who played offensive lineman for two seasons for the Minneapolis Red Jackets , Frankford Yellow Jackets , and Brooklyn Dodgers .
S2: Gordon Watkins was an American football player who played Offensive Lineman for the Minneapolis Red Jackets , Frankford Yellow Jackets and Brooklyn Dodgers for two years .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

OPTIONS:
- no
- yes

A: yes

Problem: S1: Kiernan was an English footballer ( May 22 , 1925 in Croydon -- April 3 , 2006 in Pembury ) .
S2: William E. Kiernan ( 22 May 1925 , in Pembury -- 3 April 2006 , in Croydon ) was an English footballer .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

OPTIONS:
- no
- yes

A:
no