Problem: Carrie finished their meal after Jennifer because

My choice: Carrie chewed their food for a longer period of time.

Problem: The flowers in the garden of Jason were prettier than Kyle's because

My choice: Jason put a lot of effort into tending the garden.

Problem: Jason showed Michael how to get rid of bed bugs because

My choice: Michael currently had an infestation.

Problem: Robert thought Randy was a player, because

My choice:
Robert saw him with lots of different girls at the same time.