This place had just okay sushi. The prices are good. HOWEVER, the service is the absolutely worse! The waitress/hostess was unaware of people waiting to even turn in their order. When I received the wrong roll I approached the cook and his response was not that he was sorry but that I should have told him exactly what I wanted. I thought that was what the menu was for? Worse ever. Don't waste your time here. Three tables were used and all three while I was there complained about the service.

negative

Disclaimer: I am giving this place four stars for very particular reasons. Many foodies will hate this place. The food comes from Sysco. The fish is NOT fresh, although their fish fry is as good as most of the other places in town that serve unfresh fish fry. If you come to Brother's Three, you are coming for the atmosphere. This place is not attempting to be something it's not. Here's why I love this place and go with friends weekly: 1. The staff is awesome. I tend to go in the mornings, and the server/bartender behind the bar is friendly and quick. All of the staff, though, are genial and on the ball. 2. This is a very, very, local, kitschy Wisconsin bar. You will be treated well. The jukebox has a great selection from country to rock. There is a great rectangular bar that you can sit at for every meal, and you are treated well regardless of whether you come alone or sit with friends. The place is filled with regulars at all times. The morning server makes up crazy awesome soups that the regulars love (I once stayed through breakfast and lunch doing work, and person after person came in ordering the "Chicken Cordon Bleu soup.") So, if you like cheap prices, great service, and Wisconsin kitsch, you will really like this place. My friends and I go weekly. Order your eggs over easy if you care about getting fresh eggs. If you are really concerned with sustainability or are expecting very fresh food, you are going to be disappointed.

positive

I actually worked at this location in high school. It's even where I met my husband (we worked there together). We went back over the weekend to see Ides of March (which is great by the way) and were so disappointed to see what it has become. First of all it says a lot that it was completely dead on a Saturday night. I couldn't believe they'd closed off the entire east wing of the theater as well as the concession stand over in the west wing. Granted they're not regularly open, it just looks tacky to have a fake wall and some game machines in front of it. I came for a movie not a trip to the arcade. There has clearly been a change in management since our last visit and since we worked there because this is not a theater worth heading to anymore. Cold popcorn, service so bad that I had to remind them to get or soda, and charge my card and return it to me. How about we don't take my card unless we're going to charge it and hand it to me? No sitting on the counter while you figure out how to grab a soda and popcorn.

negative

I've been eyeing this place for awhile and got my chance to a few days ago. Love the concept and the friendliness of the staff. She was really patient with us since this was our first time. So many sauces, cheeses, meats, veggies and fresh herbs. The choices makes your head spin so just take a deep breath and go for it cause it's all you want on this 11 inch pizza. Best part it's only $8.59 including taxes. They have the dough already for you and you just pick, pick and pick. I had the tomato and buffalo sauce with meatball, sausage and some veggies. Actually I forgot what I put on it and went a little crazy. It was a nice thin crust pizza with a nice little kick to the pizza with the buffalo sauce. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was actually good. I was able to gobble the whole thing without stuffing myself. My daughter was able to eat her whole pizza too. Not a bad place to pick up a quick pizza. They even have salads if you like. Overall, I thought that the service was very friendly and patient, fresh ingredients, and good pizza. Love the custom made pizza without the extra charges. Nice change of pace where everyone is trying to nickel and dime you every time. I enjoyed it and will be back for sure.
positive