Problem: Justin likes to eat magic mushrooms, while Hunter is against it, so

My choice: Hunter is likely a police officer.

Problem: Kevin was able to thread a needle easily, but Nelson was not, because

My choice: Kevin had very good eyesight.

Problem: Craig was able to get their totaled car replaced, while Aaron was not, because

My choice: Aaron had inferior insurance.

Problem: Leslie really enjoyed being able to play volleyball but Craig did not because

My choice:
Leslie was very sporty.