Problem: Given the question: Generate a question that has the following answer: selfish for the following movie plot: From the time they were young, Barbara always gave in to the will of her sister Ruth. Because of her love and devotion to Ruth, she would do anything for her. But Ruth was a very selfish girl who often took advantage of Barbaras kindness. When they grew to be young women, Barbara found the love of her life in Nick. Unfortunately, Ruth could not allow her sister to be happy. She decided she wanted Nick for herself. As a result, she told Barbara that if she could not have Nick for herself, she would kill herself.This left poor Barbara with a crushing decision. Once again she stepped aside from her own chance of happiness and allowed her selfish sister to marry the man that Barbara loved. In her pain, Barbara moved to the United States from the Philippines to allow the young couple to begin their lives together without her.Years later, Barbara received a shocking phone call from her home country. She was told that her sister committed suicide, leaving her young daughter Karen motherless. Barbara returned to the Philippines to grieve the loss of her sister and help care for her niece Karen. She soon discovered the motivation for her sisters suicide. Apparently, although she lived with her husband Nick for years, and even had a child with him, she was convinced that Nick never really loved her. She began to believe not only that he still loved Barbara, but that he was traveling to the United States to have an affair with her. Although she died, the rage she felt toward her sister lives on. The evil in Ruth has stayed on to haunt those who have remained behind. Barbara must do all she can to bring comfort to the life of her emotionally scarred niece and protect them both from the evil spirit of Ruth.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The answer is:
Barbara was kind to Ruth, but Ruth was what to Barbara?

input question: Generate a question that has the following answer: Waitress for the following movie plot: The movie's protagonist, Mark Watson (Howell), is the pampered son from a rich family who is about to attend Harvard Law School along with his best friend Gordon (Gross). Unfortunately, his father's neurotic psychiatrist talks his patient into having more fun for himself instead of spending money on his son. Faced with the horrifying prospect of having to pay for law school by himself, Mark decides to take up a scholarship, but the only suitable one is for African-Americans only. He decides to cheat by using tanning pills in a larger dose than prescribed to appear as an African-American. Watson then sets out for Harvard, naively believing that blacks have no problems at all in American society. However, once immersed in a black student's life, Mark finds that people are less lenient than he imagined and more prone to see him as a black person instead of a fellow student. He meets a young African-American student named Sarah Walker (Chong), whom he first only flirts with; gradually, however, he genuinely falls in love with her. As it turns out, she was the original candidate for the scholarship which he had usurped, and now she has to work hard as a waitress to support herself and her son George while studying. Slowly, Mark begins to regret his deed, and after a chaotic dayin which Sarah, his parents (who are not aware of his double life) and his classmate Whitney (Melora Hardin), who is also his landlord's daughter, make surprise visits at the same timehe drops the charade and openly reveals himself to be white. The film ends with Mark declaring to his professor (Jones) that he wishes to pay back the scholarship and do charity work to make amends for his fraud. When asked what he has learned, he says that he realizes that he could have changed back to being white at any time and so does not really know what it means to be black. Sarah decides to give him another chance, and the movie ends with him deciding to just work his way through college.???
output answer: What kind of work does Sarah Walker do?

Please answer this: Generate a question that has the following answer: The beasts for the following movie plot: After spending a few years in Los Angeles, Sarah Tyler (Isabella Calthorpe) returns to her home in England. She arrives to find her brothers having a party in the barn, among which are Stephen Moore (Peter Gadiot), his girlfriend Emily (Gemma Atkinson), Charlie Moore (Gabriel Thomson), Gary Ashby (Tom Felton), Doug Walker (Joshua Bowman), their youngest brother Luke Moore (Antony De Liseo) and their dog, Stoner. Luke tells Sarah about their parents' arguments over bills, and their mother's supposed love affair. When Sarah inquires about this, Stephen reveals that her stepfather has accused her mother of having an affair with a man to whom she is paying large sums of money. The brewing storm outside causes a power outage. The group notice blood at the top of the stairs. Gary leaves the group to look for candles; meanwhile the group sees that the blood is coming from their father's room. They find his lifeless body, which appears to have been attacked by some wild animal. At the same time, Gary discovers Stoner's bloody remains. The group encounters a beast-like creature and narrowly escape. When Gary calls to them, it catches and kills him. The group flees to the bathroom, and Sarah discovers a passageway leading up to the attic. Momentarily safe, the group contemplate their situation. Emily sees a pathway leading to another room, and the group decides that Sarah shall go down and distract the beast while Charlie goes to call for help on their father's phone. While Sarah distracts the monster, Charlie contacts the police. However, the beast kills and devours him. When Sarah witnesses this, the monster pursues her, and manages to bite her leg. On the other side of town, McRae, a trained dog-catcher, is picked up by police officer May, who believes the call is a hoax, on the way to investigate Charlie's call. Back in the attic, as Doug tends to Sarah's leg, Stephen and Emily discover another passageway into a room containing a shotgun. Armed with a stake, Sarah makes her way down and injures the beast before it...
++++++++
Answer:
Who kills Charlie?