Problem: (1) Kathryn Lindskoog , an independent Lewis scholar , argued that Hooper 's scholarship is not reliable and that he made false statements and attributed counterfeit works to Lewis .
(2) Kathryn Lindskoog , an independent Lewis scholar , argued that Hooper 's scholarship is not reliable and that he has made false statements and attributed forged works to Lewis .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A: yes

Problem: (1) This quite common species can be found in the Indo-West Pacific , the Red Sea , the Indian Ocean and the Australian coast .
(2) This fairly common species can be found in the Indo-West Pacific , the Indian Ocean , the Red Sea and the Australian coast .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A: yes

Problem: (1) David Burliuk was born on March 15 , 1886 in Kharkiv , the younger brother of Wladimir Burliuk .
(2) Wladimir Burliuk was born in Kharkiv , the younger brother of David Burliuk , on March 15 , 1886 .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A: no

Problem: (1) Tatem McLellan was born in Marietta , Georgia , as daughter of Leander and Alice Josephine McLellan .
(2) Alice Josephine McLellan was born in Marietta , Georgia , as the daughter of Leander and Harriet Tatem McLellan .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A:
no