TASK DEFINITION: In this task, you are given a short story consisting of exactly 5 sentences where the second sentence is missing. You are given two options and you need to select the one that best connects the first sentence with the rest of the story. Indicate your answer by 'Option 1' if the first option is correct, otherwise 'Option 2'. The incorrect option will change the subsequent storyline, so that at least one of the three subsequent sentences is no longer consistent with the story.
PROBLEM: Sentence 1: Jen believed in God very much.
Sentence 3: She prayed to God and nothing happened
Sentence 4: Her heart closed day by day
Sentence 5: Until eventually she had lost all faith
Option 1: She made her whole family attend church each week.
Option 2: But when she lost her whole family, her dog and her house, she cried.

SOLUTION: Option 2

PROBLEM: Sentence 1: One day, Jacob bought a new baseball glove.
Sentence 3: He would never explain why he always kept his old one
Sentence 4: All his friends decided his old glove must be secretly valuable
Sentence 5: Jacob loved messing with his friends' heads in this way
Option 1: However, Jacob still used his old, dirty, and worn glove.
Option 2: He kept the old one because it felt lucky.

SOLUTION: Option 1

PROBLEM: Sentence 1: Janet's friend Mary had a birthday coming up.
Sentence 3: Janet decided to throw her a surprise party
Sentence 4: She called up all of Mary's friends and invited them over
Sentence 5: Mary went into the house full of people and was pleasantly surprised
Option 1: Mary has always been good to Janet so she wanted to do something.
Option 2: Mary had not been a good friend lately to Janet so she did not want to do anything for her.

SOLUTION:
Option 1