Problem: After completely totaling the car, Neil, but not Ian, was arrested because

My choice: Ian did not cause a fatality in the crash.

Problem: Sarah had painful hemorrhoids but Megan does not.

My choice: Megan had to have an operation on their heart.

Problem: Katrina gave Christine a stuffed animal for their birthday, but

My choice: Christine already had this one.

Problem: Ian climbed the tree but could not convince Steven to join because

My choice:
Steven was scared of heights.