Question: One was a chestnut, a warm, well-groomed red.
One was a chestnut, well-groomed red. The other one, was blue.

Answer: it is not possible to tell

Question: Karpathos is a rugged and wild island lying between Rhodes and Cete, almost at the foot of the Aegean.
Karpathos is the biggest island in the Aegean sea.

Answer: it is not possible to tell

Question: The other one, I don't remember."
It is this one, I recall.

Answer:
no