Story needs to be completed:
A very single Christopher wanted Matthew's boyfriend, so

My choice:
Christopher broke them up by spreading rumors about them.

Story needs to be completed:
On New Year's Eve, Justin goes out, but Logan stays home because

My choice:
Logan is more timid.

Story needs to be completed:
Christine tried to rest after breaking their toe, but Cynthia was unsympathetic.

My choice:
Christine knew how much pain a broken toe was.

Story needs to be completed:
The chef wanted to store the apricots inside the bottles but the

My choice:
apricots were too large.