Question:
S1: In Lytle Creek Canyon , a 4-foot-high mud flow crossed a road , trapping a car .
S2: In Lytle Creek Canyon , the rain caused several mudslides , including a 4-foot-high flow across a road that trapped a car .
Are S1 and S2 the same?
Answer:
no

Question:
S1: The broad Standard & Poor 's 500 < .SPX > fell 10.75 points , or 1.02 percent , to 1,039.32 .
S2: The S & P 500 index was up 1.26 , or 0.1 percent , to 1,039.32 after sinking 10.75 yesterday .
Are S1 and S2 the same?
Answer:
no

Question:
S1: Mr. Bankhead said the crime scenes indicated that the killer was " very methodical . "
S2: GBI spokesman John Bankhead said the murder scenes showed that the killer was very methodical .
Are S1 and S2 the same?
Answer:
yes

Question:
S1: Smith found the cigarette tax falls on the tobacco consumer , not the tribe , meaning the tribe is simply an agent for collecting a tax .
S2: Smith ruled that the state 's tax falls on the tobacco consumer , not the tribe , making the tribe simply an agent for collecting the tax .
Are S1 and S2 the same?
Answer:
yes