Story needs to be completed:
Preserving strawberries into the mason jars was common for Lindsey but not Jessica because

My choice:
Lindsey was an expert at canning.

Story needs to be completed:
Lawrence was out walking their dog when they ran into Donald who they did not like very well, so

My choice:
Donald got scared of the dog.

Story needs to be completed:
Jennifer was a better Chinese Checkers than Erin, and

My choice:
Erin lost every time when they played.

Story needs to be completed:
Kelly decided to fertilize the lilies with coffee instead of compost because the

My choice:
coffee is more acidic and lilies thrive in acidic conditions.