Question:
Junk food was a favorite of Maria but not Monica which is why

Answer:
Continue the sentence -- Monica was not fat.

Question:
Elena thought strawberries were delicious but Natalie hated their taste.

Answer:
Continue the sentence -- Elena had strawberry shortcake for their dessert.

Question:
Tim replied to an email from Cynthia and not Mary since

Answer:
Continue the sentence -- Cynthia wrote her email to Tim full of compliments.

Question:
Since Rachel had a washer in a laundry room and Jennifer did not,

Answer:
Continue the sentence -- Jennifer needed to go to a laundromat.