Problem: Matthew recently received a diagnosis from Samuel, and

My choice: Samuel provided all the encouragement in the world to keep going.

Problem: The signs painted by Neil were more ugly than those of Jeffrey, since

My choice: Jeffrey was an artist.

Problem: Dennis noticed who committed the murder at the party while Steven had no idea.

My choice: Dennis was observant.

Problem: Justin had a passion for furry costumes but Hunter dug superhero costumes.

My choice:
Hunter went to Comic-con dressed as Deadpool.