Story needs to be completed:
Katrina was splashed with paint by Betty, and

My choice:
Betty was regretful because the new clothes were ruined.

Story needs to be completed:
Justin had a hobby they really liked but not Joseph because

My choice:
Justin kept doing the hobby.

Story needs to be completed:
Eric impressed Hunter by doing a wheelie on his BMX bike,

My choice:
Eric thought he would be joining him.

Story needs to be completed:
Christine didn't pass the lie detection test that Jessica did because

My choice:
Christine had something to hide.