Problem: (1) The poetic cosmogony of Thales , who made water the first element , can be seen as a natural excess of this pre-socratic thinking .
(2) The pre-Socratic cosmogony of Thales , who made water the first element , may be seen as a natural outgrowth of this poetic thinking .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A: no

Problem: (1) The returning Isaac Fontaine , who last played with Sta.Lucia three years ago , replaces Carrawell .
(2) The returning Carrawell , who played with Sta.Lucia for the last time three years ago , replaces Isaac Fontaine .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A: no

Problem: (1) The Bristly Peaks include the Brodie Peak and the Messent Peak .
(2) Bristly Peaks include the Brodie Peak and the Messent Peak .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A: yes

Problem: (1) Hyman ( 2001 ) says Mayer , '' wrote the definitive work on loyalty tests throughout American history . ''
(2) Mayer ( 2001 ) says Hyman , '' wrote the definitive work on loyalty tests throughout the American history .

Do (1) and (2) mean the same thing?
A:
no