Is the premise "A bearded man at a fair wearing a black tank top and a plaid hat." true if "The man was at the county fair."?
yes
Is the premise "A boy in a creek throwing a rock." true if "A boy is playing in the creek"?
it is not possible to tell
Is the premise "A group of young men and women laying on sunbathing chairs." true if "People are snow skiing."?
no
Is the premise "A couple is playing in the snow and he has either fallen or is going to make an angel." true if "Two goldfish are riding bikes in a giant pile of mashed potatoes."?
no