Two stars because I really have had better. It could have been because my boyfriend and I did not follow the golden rule...we ordered hoagies at a pizza place and that's what we get for not ordering the pizza....which is the specialty at the Mellow Mushroom. The service was pretty good considering this place was not that busy at all on a Sunday night. We were seated rather quickly and in a nice roomy booth at that. Right away our server was very attentive and explained the menu. We ordered the hoagies, which she explained would take 20 minutes to prepare and would be served hot. 20 minutes later our hoagies came out but where not hot, they were more like room temp. This didn't really bother me because I ordered the meatball hoagie and I didn't think it was too bad. But my bf ordered the Italian with lots of salami and pepperoni with no melted cheese...so we asked if they could reheat it for us. Our server did this with no hesitation and a few minutes later it was back on the table very heated up. The hoagies were just okay--nothing too great here. Mine could have used a little more sauce.
OPTIONS:
- negative
- positive

negative

Stopped in looking for a great breakfast. Ordered the salmon hash. It tasted more like cat food than something edible by humans. The hash browns had no flavor and the eggs were served cold. The biscuit was rock hard and the service was mediocre. For having such a good reputation this restaurant was an exceptional disappointment. I'd advise others to look elsewhere for breakfast.
OPTIONS:
- negative
- positive

negative

I admit that I was cynical. In a town full of spectacular restaurants, how could this one be known to the masses as the best breakfast joint on the island? It was impossible. I mean, didn't someone ever have a bad experience here? We got there around 930am on a Monday. No lineup. Seated quickly. Attentive service. Massive choice. I orderted the Huevos Rancheros. I've never had better. Damn you popular opinion. You win everytime.
OPTIONS:
- negative
- positive

positive

I am a wee bit obsessed with here. Ive only eaten one thing and it's the fish taco. I eat one bc one is enough. One time I came very late right before closing and some of the rice was hard and I almost threw up but I still like this place.
OPTIONS:
- negative
- positive
positive