Question: The fortress-town of Cetelsardo stands high on a spectacular promontory overlooking the gulf.
The town is high up on a cliff.

Answer: yes

Question: They were repulsed at Hispaniola by a strong Spanish force and decided to take Jamaica as a consolation prize.
Jamaica was taken as a secondary option to show strength.

Answer: yes

Question: But evangelical leaders, who are, in my experience, uniformly kind and generous in their personal relations, can also be terribly obnoxious in their relations with Jews.
Evangelicals are anti-Semitic.

Answer:
it is not possible to tell