Story needs to be completed:
Rebecca cherished each birthday they had while Elena dreaded their birthday every year.

My choice:
Rebecca was majorly thrilled at their surprise birthday party.

Story needs to be completed:
Eric received essential oils as a birthday present from Brian, because

My choice:
Eric had been having health issues.

Story needs to be completed:
Kyle loves to get into a good fight but Matthew does not.

My choice:
Matthew goes to church very often.

Story needs to be completed:
Joel spent more time with their son than Randy did because

My choice:
Joel had primary custody of the boy.