Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
From the given sentence, extract the phrase (often noun or verb) that carries the given relationship. The generated phrase should be present in the sentence.
Example: Given Relationship: 'make', Sentence: 'Jenny made the announcement that her baby was an alien.'
Output: made
The output relationship - made, is a correct verb form of the given relationship - make, and it is also used in the given sentence

New input case for you: Given Relationship: 'appear to', Sentence: 'Proceed to Nazareth where you will visit the Basilica of the Annunciation enclosing the remains of the house of Joachim and Ann and the site where the Angel Gabriel appeared to the Virgin Mary to announce that she was to become the mother of God .'
Output:
appeared