Problem: What would be an example of an positive review?

Answer: While the prices are a little high (if it wasn't for Happy Hour, I would have blanched at the prices) the service was very friendly and the food was good. We got three HH plates at $6 each - chicken street tacos, Fuego nachos and the meatloaf sliders. The meatloaf was a little spicier than I could handle (I'm really sensitive when it comes to hot spices) but the nachos and tacos were awesome. Three plates and a margarita came to about $26, with the nachos being the best deal. I wouldn't go out of my way to get here but it's a nice spot downtown.

Problem: What would be an example of an positive review?

Answer: First time having caviar, it was very salt good. =)

Problem: What would be an example of an negative review?

Answer:
Went there after several years, nothing really has changed. The location is still the prime draw. Menu had a few off the wall mains including shrimp curry with mango chutney, which really is a bit out of place given the average price of mains is $40+. Server seemed already overwhelmed while the crowd had just begun to file in, and forgot the drinks of two people out of a party of six at the table. Steaks are still the best bet, my filet mignon was perfectly cooked med-rare, but was not as juicy as you would expect for $50 hunk of meat. Monte Carlo potato is overrated, and so is the famous Gibby's salad. Bottom line: if you are looking for overpriced but undersized portions with an underwhelming service in a picture perfect setting, Gibby's is the place to go.