Teacher: One of the following sentences is nonsensical. Which one is it?
Options:
- Sentence A: "Rain fell from the sky"
- Sentence B: "Whales rain from the sky."

Student: Whales are to heavy to be apart of the water cycle.
The answer is Sentence B.

question in book:
Which of these sentences doesn't make sense?
Options:
- Sentence A: "Jane doesn't like watermelon because it has too many seeds"
- Sentence B: "Jane doesn't like watermelon because it has too many shoes"

standard solution:
Watermelons have no feet and do not own things.
The answer is Sentence B.

[TEACHER] Which of the following sentences is nonsensical?
Options:
- Sentence A: "A caterpillar ate a dog."
- Sentence B: "A dog ate a caterpillar."

[Student] A caterpillar is to small to eat a dog.
The answer is Sentence A.

Teacher: Pick which sentence is not logical.
Options:
- Sentence A: "He took a lion for a walk."
- Sentence B: "He took a dog for a walk."

Student: The people he meets would be scared of the lion.
The answer is Sentence A.

question in book:
Pick which sentence is not logical.
Options:
- Sentence A: "He read the sock."
- Sentence B: "He read the newspaper."

standard solution:
A newspaper can be read but a sock cannot be read.
The answer is Sentence A.

Teacher: Of the following two sentences, which one is against common sense?
Options:
- Sentence A: "He took ice cream for fever"
- Sentence B: "He took medicine for fever"

Student:
Ice cream may cool him down but wont help a fever.
The answer is Sentence A.