Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

an honest attempt to get at something

positive

Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

wannabe film -- without the vital comic ingredient of the hilarious writer-director himself

negative

Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

of good stuff

positive

Would the following phrase be considered positive or negative?

then his tone retains a genteel , prep-school quality that feels dusty and leatherbound
negative