Problem: Laura thrived in the sunlight, but Amy preferred the dark, so

My choice: Amy tended to stay inside during the day.

Problem: The man prays for Aaron way more than Matthew right now because

My choice: Matthew is very healthy.

Problem: William liked their meat well done, but Lawrence fancied their meat mostly rare.

My choice: William asked the chef to put a heavy char on their steak.

Problem: Randy had never crashed their car in any way whereas Matthew had because

My choice:
Randy was very careful.