Problem: The coffee that Natalie makes tastes a lot weaker than Erin's because

My choice: Erin uses more coffee grounds.

Problem: Steven thought twice before expressing his discomfort aloud, Michael seemed so happy,

My choice: Steven didn't want to spoil that.

Problem: Benjamin used dish soap for an emergency load of laundry while William used water, and so

My choice: William had spotted clothes.

Problem: Jeffrey had perfect vision but Brian did not, so

My choice:
Jeffrey did not need to buy any eye glasses.