You are given a paragraph, with numbered sentences, and a question. Write the numbers of the sentences needed to answer the given question. Separate multiple sentence numbers with a comma (", "). E.g. "1, 2" would be the correct response if Sent 1 and Sent 2 are needed to answer the given question (do not include sentences that contain no information that is necessary to answer the question). Sort the sentence numbers in an increasing order (i.e., '1, 2', instead of '2, 1'). Your answer should not contain anything than the sentence numbers separated by a comma (e.g. '1, 2, 3, 4'). The given question requires more than one sentence to answer. So, your answer must contain at least one comma (", ").

Paragraph- Sent 1: Mr. Neville ( ( ( Anthony Higgins , a young and arrogant artist and something of a Byronic hero , is contracted to produce a series of 12 landscape drawings of an estate by Mrs. Virginia Herbert for her absent and estranged husband .
Sent 2: Part of the contract is that Mrs. Herbert agrees '' to meet Mr. Neville in private and to comply with his requests concerning his pleasure with me . ''
Sent 3: Several sexual encounters between them follow , each of them acted in such a way as to emphasise reluctance or distress on the part of Mrs Herbert and sexual aggression or insensitivity on the part of Mr Neville .
Sent 4: Meanwhile , whilst living on the estate , Mr. Neville gains quite a reputation with its dwellers , especially with Mrs. Herbert 's son-in-law , Mr. Talmann .
Sent 5: Mrs. Herbert , wearied of meeting Mr. Neville for his pleasure , tries to terminate the contract before all of the drawings are completed and orders Mr. Neville to stop .
Sent 6: But he refuses to void the contract and continues as before .
Sent 7: Then Mrs. Herbert 's married , but as yet childless , daughter , Mrs. Talmann , who has apparently become attracted to Mr. Neville , seems to blackmail him into making a second contract in which he agrees to comply with what is described as her pleasure , rather than his a reversal of the position in regard to her mother .
Sent 8: A number of curious objects appear in Neville 's drawings , which point ultimately to the murder of Mr. Herbert , whose body is discovered in the moat of the house .
Sent 9: Mr. Neville completes his twelve drawings and leaves the house .
Question: Who is Mrs. Herbert's son-in-law?.
4.

Paragraph- Sent 1: Starting from Scratch: Whoever first stepped ashore on Madeira discovered no signs of previous habitationno Stone-Age natives, as the Spanish found on the Canary Islands, and no mysterious monuments to the past, as on the Balearics.
Sent 2: Occupation of Madeira began in the early 1420s as a decidedly minimalist project: colonists arrived with only as much as they could carry from mainland Portugal.
Sent 3: They found plenty of water pouring down from the mountains, and more timber than anyone knew what to do with.
Sent 4: So they set about clearing the land for agriculture, setting fire to massive tracts of forest.
Sent 5: Legend says that a great fire burned for seven years on the island, leveling it of all its trees.
Sent 6: The fire provided the soil with a rich ash fertilizer, which complemented the luxuriant growing conditions of tropical sun and plentiful water.
Sent 7: The Portuguese saw valuable economic opportunity in their new possession and ordered Malvasia grapes from Crete and sugar cane from Italy in an effort to seed the island's first cash crops.
Sent 8: The project was not a simple one.
Sent 9: Colonists had to locate enough level ground to grow crops on and solve the issue of irrigating them.
Sent 10: Brute strength, without aid of machinery, carved flat surfaces out of the mountains, and settlers built the terracesstill seen todayon the steep slopes.
Sent 11: The problem of watering crops was solved by the irrigation system known as levadassimply-designed water channels that wound down from water sources on the verdant mountain tops.
Sent 12: The levadas were largely built by slave laborers from Africa, whose primary employment was on sugar plantations.
Sent 13: New Madeirans traded sugar, the era's dominant luxury item, with Britain and Flanders, and they proved skillful in the art of winemaking.
Sent 14: The island's burgeoning economic significance propelled population growth, and by the middle of the 15th century Madeira was home to 800 families.
Sent 15: A 1514 census recorded 5,000 inhabitants.
Sent 16: In 1478 Madeira welcomed a visitor who would greatly assist the island's future wine trade.
Sent 17: Christopher Columbus, not yet a sailor of any renown, sailed to Madeira on an assignment to buy sugar cane.
Sent 18: His sojourn was unsuccessful, as money failed to arrive for part of the shipment.
Question: According to the census taken in 1514, what was the total population and total number of families in Madeira?.
15, 16.

Paragraph- Sent 1: (CNN) -- Declaring 2010 "the best year in safety performance in our company's history," Transocean Ltd., owner of the Gulf of Mexico oil rig that exploded, killing 11 workers, has awarded its top executives hefty bonuses and raises, according to a recent filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
Sent 2: That includes a $200,000 salary increase for Transocean president and chief executive officer Steven L. Newman, whose base salary will increase from $900,000 to $1.1 million, according to the SEC report.
Sent 3: Newman's bonus was $374,062, the report states.
Sent 4: Newman also has a $5.4 million long-term compensation package the company awarded him upon his appointment as CEO in March 2010, according to the SEC filing.
Sent 5: The latest cash awards are based in part on the company's "performance under safety," the Transocean filing states.
Sent 6: "Notwithstanding the tragic loss of life in the Gulf of Mexico, we achieved an exemplary statistical safety record as measured by our total recordable incident rate and total potential severity rate," the SEC statement reads.
Sent 7: "As measured by these standards, we recorded the best year in safety performance in our Company's history."Sent 8: The company called that record "a reflection on our commitment to achieving an incident-free environment, all the time, everywhere," the SEC filing states.
Sent 9: The company did not respond to an e-mail from CNN seeking comment.
Sent 10: The April 20, 2010, explosion on the Deepwater Horizon rig injured 17 workers and killed 11 others, including nine Transocean employees, according to the SEC filing.
Sent 11: It has been called the worst spill in U.S. history.
Sent 12: The well was capped three months later, but not before millions of barrels of oil spilled into the Gulf.
Sent 13: In January, President Barack Obama's National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling released a report that spread blame for the accident among Transocean, BP -- which leased the rig -- and Halliburton, which installed the rig's cement casing.
Question: How long after the well was capped did the National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling apportion the blame for the oil spill between Transocean, BP, and Hallibuton?.
10, 12, 13.