Story needs to be completed:
Damien's cat was dying and he needed to decided rather to let it live or put it to sleep. The

My choice:
put it to sleep then it would be peaceful.

Story needs to be completed:
After the accident, Benjamin wanted a used car but Brian wanted a new car.

My choice:
Brian thought used cars were a waste of money.

Story needs to be completed:
Steven loved the taste of squash but William hated it's flavor.

My choice:
William ordered the broccoli casserole with their dinner.

Story needs to be completed:
Matthew grinds their teeth a lot in their sleep, and Hunter does not, so

My choice:
Hunter is likely more relaxed.