[Q]: How does the sentence end?

After Samuel made the best brownies ever and gave one to Nick,

[A]: Nick decided to eat.

[Q]: How does the sentence end?

When Jeffrey had a book accepted by a publisher, Eric said nothing but

[A]: Jeffrey was exhilarated because of countless prior rejections.

[Q]: How does the sentence end?

Joel was a romantic unlike Robert, so

[A]:
Joel was the one that developed a crush on a fellow classmate.