Problem: Kyle gained 20 pounds last year while Randy gained 2, because

My choice: Kyle ate higher calories food.

Problem: Aaron was really upset that they had treated their friend Ian badly, so to make it for it

My choice: Aaron gave a gift to them.

Problem: The windows were open in Jeffrey's room, but not in Justin's because

My choice: Justin used air conditioning.

Problem: Although Samuel was more of a sneakerhead than Robert,

My choice:
Robert found a great pair of Converse.