Problem: Jeffrey ate fresh seafood more often than Hunter because

My choice: Jeffrey lived near the coastal area.

Problem: Christopher got to the store faster than Donald although

My choice: Donald rode on a horse instead of walking.

Problem: Justin was a lot more comfortable around horses than Hunter was, because

My choice: Justin had grown up on a farm.

Problem: Jason made a positive identification on Joel for stealing a purse, so

My choice:
Joel definitely did the crime.