Problem: S1: Bignell gave his first-class debut for Warwickshire against Hampshire in the 1904 County Championship .
S2: Bignell made his first-class debut for Warwickshire against Hampshire in the 1904 County Championship .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: yes

Problem: S1: With support from the Carnegie Foundation and the Rockefeller Foundation , Carter conterred .
S2: Carter countered with support from the Carnegie Foundation and the Rockefeller Foundation .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: yes

Problem: S1: Considerable resistance from established Vignerons against American vines remained , and official policy still favoured the eradication of the vineyards affected .
S2: Considerable resistance remained from affected vignerons to official vines and American policy still favoured the eradication of established vineyards .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A:
no