Story needs to be completed:
Kyle was rarely in the kitchen while Hunter constantly was because

My choice:
Hunter loved to cook.

Story needs to be completed:
Derrick was more likely to have an apple at lunch than Neil because

My choice:
Neil rarely ate fruit.

Story needs to be completed:
Justin had eaten Ramen noodles for years, but Joseph had just started, therefore

My choice:
Justin had tried all of the flavors.

Story needs to be completed:
Jeffrey wanted to celebrate the basketball game results but Derrick did not since

My choice:
Derrick was rooting for the team that lost.