Here is a goal: How do I patch up holes in vinyl wall art after I've put up my design?

How would you accomplish this goal?

Available options:
[I] cut out scraps of vinyl to patch up the center area, trimming a bit so the connection curve smoothly into each other.
[II] cut out scraps of vinyl to patch up the center area, tearing a bit so the connection curve smoothly into each other.
[I]