Inductive Permuted: relation (list A) :=
    | permuted_nil : Permuted nil nil
    | permuted_skip : forall (x x': A), R x x' -> forall (l l' : list A), Permuted l l' -> Permuted (x :: l) (x' :: l')
    | permuted_swap : forall (x y: A) (l: list A), Permuted (y :: x :: l) (x :: y :: l)
    | permuted_trans : forall l l' l'' : list A, Permuted l l' -> Permuted l' l'' -> Permuted l l''.Inductive Permuted: relation (list A) :=
    | permuted_nil : Permuted nil nil
    | permuted_skip : forall (x x': A), R x x' -> forall (l l' : list A), Permuted l l' -> Permuted (x :: l) (x' :: l')
    | permuted_swap : forall (x y: A) (l: list A), Permuted (y :: x :: l) (x :: y :: l)
    | permuted_trans : forall l l' l'' : list A, Permuted l l' -> Permuted l' l'' -> Permuted l l''.Inductive Permuted: relation (list A) :=
    | permuted_nil : Permuted nil nil
    | permuted_skip : forall (x x': A), R x x' -> forall (l l' : list A), Permuted l l' -> Permuted (x :: l) (x' :: l')
    | permuted_swap : forall (x y: A) (l: list A), Permuted (y :: x :: l) (x :: y :: l)
    | permuted_trans : forall l l' l'' : list A, Permuted l l' -> Permuted l' l'' -> Permuted l l''.Inductive Permuted: relation (list A) :=
    | permuted_nil : Permuted nil nil
    | permuted_skip : forall (x x': A), R x x' -> forall (l l' : list A), Permuted l l' -> Permuted (x :: l) (x' :: l')
    | permuted_swap : forall (x y: A) (l: list A), Permuted (y :: x :: l) (x :: y :: l)
    | permuted_trans : forall l l' l'' : list A, Permuted l l' -> Permuted l' l'' -> Permuted l l''.Inductive Permuted: relation (list A) :=
    | permuted_nil : Permuted nil nil
    | permuted_skip : forall (x x': A), R x x' -> forall (l l' : list A), Permuted l l' -> Permuted (x :: l) (x' :: l')
    | permuted_swap : forall (x y: A) (l: list A), Permuted (y :: x :: l) (x :: y :: l)
    | permuted_trans : forall l l' l'' : list A, Permuted l l' -> Permuted l' l'' -> Permuted l l''.

Lemma elemsR_permuted l l': elemsR R l l' -> Permuted l l'.