piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
opened by Grinbert 🙂 (2025-09-07 08:09:15+00:00): Unable to answer "Are these steps completed?" – Road Under Construction – https://osm.org/way/1270613762 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Dieser Weg kann wieder entfernt werden.
opened by StreetCompleter86 (2025-09-07 08:10:16+00:00): Unable to answer "Do these traffic lights have a button to request a walk signal?" – Crossing With Pedestrian Signals – https://osm.org/node/7859293992 via StreetComplete 61.3:

The second ones are for bicycles
closed by StreetCompleter86 (2025-09-07 13:19:15+00:00): Checked, but found no obvious tag like "crossing with bicycle signals", so leaving this open
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:11:12+00:00): Path has been closed! Seems dangerous to go upwards.

#LocusMap
closed by K12230LF (2026-03-02 14:37:16+00:00): access=no added
opened by romario61 (2025-09-07 08:11:43+00:00): Мешкання П.І.Р.
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:12:18+00:00): Path has been closed! Seems dangerous to go upwards.

#LocusMap
closed by K12230LF (2026-03-02 14:37:20+00:00): access=no added
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:12:38+00:00): changes in store name (il gelatiere)
opened by atchisson (2025-09-07 08:12:51+00:00): Ajouter la Photo Panoramax sur la BàL

via StreetComplete_ee 61.1
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:13:10+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
نام: آکادمی زهرا صادقی
addr:housenumber=۶۰
addr:street=خیابان ائل گلی
addr:place=فلکه آبیاری
addr:city=تبریز
شماره تماس: 09148771752
شبکه‌های اجتماعی: anil-beautytbz
ساعات کاری: شنبه تا پنج شنبه ۱۰تا ۱۷
دسترسی با ویلچر: unknown
دسته‌بندی: بهداشت و پزشکی
توضیحات: پوست وزیبایی
روش های پرداخت پذیرفته شده:
opened by mbethke (2025-09-07 08:14:00+00:00): In context of overlay "Surfaces" – Residential Road – https://osm.org/way/512514027 via StreetComplete 61.3:

This is a riverbed

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303664.jpg
closed by mbethke (2026-06-02 05:58:54+00:00): fixed
opened by romario61 (2025-09-07 08:14:10+00:00): автовокзал
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:14:41+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
Name: کیف و کفش اچ ام
addr:street=Shariati Street
addr:city=Babol
Phone number: +989111152243
Website: https://kafshhm.ir
Social Network: @kafsh_hm
Opening Hours: sat-fri 10am-11pm
Wheelchair accessibility: limited
Category: Shoe Stores
Description: فروشگاه کیف و کفش
Accepted payment methods: Cash,Bank card
delivery=yes
takeaway=no
closed by Mateusz Konieczny (2025-11-07 04:50:52+00:00): to person creating thousands upon thousands of this notes - have you considered actually editing OpenStreetMap? You cannot copy shops locations from Google Maps, but you can go on walk and add some of them. Or map remotely, there is Bing Streetside imagery in some places. Or map buildings remotely.

Creating note flood is simply not useful, or even harmful.

close not needed onosm note

Iran is simply flooded with them - with so many that people started closing notes in Iran solely for being old, and over 60 000 notes were closed in 2023. It is better to close just this not needed flood and notes with higher chance of being useful will remain.

Note that notes about missing shops are nearly useless - they do not speed up mapping, it is trivial to find missing shops nearly anywhere.

See https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-notes-country?c=Iran&stats=full and https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-notes-country-custom?c=Iran&query=open
opened by peyot (2025-09-07 08:14:49+00:00): La démolition est presque terminée : https://www.leparisien.fr/hauts-de-seine-92/clichy-la-barre-sanzillon-sera-demolie-a-lautomne-et-presque-tous-les-locataires-sont-reloges-dans-la-ville-20-07-2024-JJ6HR3GQ4NAQXP6EXWW53OGHUE.php

via StreetComplete 61.3
commented by K12230LF (2025-09-08 08:00:11+00:00): J'ai passé le bâtiment en demolished:building=apartments
Est-ce que le bâtiment également au sud-est où il y a le magasin Lagarrigue et les deux restaurants est aussi démoli ?
commented by peyot (2025-09-08 15:36:13+00:00): Non ce bâtiment n'est pas concerné.
closed by K12230LF (2025-09-08 15:38:37+00:00): Parfait, je ferme cette note du coup
opened by Geovelo_Notes (2025-09-07 08:15:55+00:00): b (This note has been created from Geovelo: https://amenagements-cyclables.fr/fr/contributions/103431)
closed by K12230LF (2025-09-08 07:57:27+00:00): Note de poche ?
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:18:15+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
نام: سرزمین زبان/ lingoland
addr:housenumber=۷
addr:street=۱۷ شهربور
addr:place=جنب پاساژ خلیج فارس، فرعی ۳/۱
addr:city=شاهرود
addr:postcode=3615645554
شماره تماس: 09025737272
شبکه‌های اجتماعی: @lingoland_institute 
ساعات کاری: شنبه تا چهارشنبه صبح ها ۹ تا ۱۲ عصرها ۱۷ تا ۲۱
دسترسی با ویلچر: no
دسته‌بندی: مراکز آموزشی
توضیحات: آموزشگاه زبانهای خارجه
روش های پرداخت پذیرفته شده:
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:18:23+00:00): Si chiama davvero pizzzeria con tre zeta?
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:19:14+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
نام: ماه سنگ سپاهان
addr:street=چهلم
addr:place=شهرک صنعتی محمودآباد
addr:city=شاهین شهر
شماره تماس: 03133808044
وب‌سایت: Www.mahstone.com
شبکه‌های اجتماعی: @mahsangstone
ساعات کاری: شنبه تا چهارشنبه 8 -18
دسته‌بندی: لوازم ساختمانی
توضیحات: تولید سنگ ساختمانی
روش های پرداخت پذیرفته شده:
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:19:45+00:00): closed
closed by user_8y978a (2026-01-09 13:12:56+00:00): rimosso
opened by astrojuanlu (2025-09-07 08:20:35+00:00): "No hay"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-08-08T13:08:07Z
POI has no name
POI types: amenity-drinking_water
 #organicmaps android
closed by sanchi (2025-09-07 14:07:06+00:00): eliminada
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:21:11+00:00): Panchina

#OsmAnd
opened by StreetCompleter86 (2025-09-07 08:21:15+00:00): Unable to answer "How many car lanes does this road have?" – Van Meterenstraat (Tertiary Road) – https://osm.org/way/1127526376 via StreetComplete 61.3:

These are one way sections

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303665.jpg
closed by StreetCompleter86 (2025-09-07 13:17:30+00:00): made an edit
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:22:29+00:00): Nicht mehr B27, siehe https://www.geoportal-bw.de/#/(sidenav:menu)
Gilt auch für alle anderen Umwidmungen zum 1.1.2025.
closed by redd (2025-12-19 14:49:08+00:00): Das Geoportal nach meinem Verständnis nicht kompatibel. Daher sollte so etwas anhand von Überprüfung vor Ort stattfinden

Hinweis schließe ich daher
opened by j307 (2025-09-07 08:22:29+00:00): "Pendelbåtsstoppet borttaget"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-06-08T00:18:23Z
POI name: Fridhem
POI types: amenity-ferry_terminal
 #organicmaps android
opened by j307 (2025-09-07 08:22:29+00:00): "Pendelbåtsstoppet borttaget"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-06-08T00:18:23Z
POI name: Mälarhöjdsbadet
POI types: amenity-ferry_terminal
 #organicmaps android
opened by j307 (2025-09-07 08:22:30+00:00): "Pendelbåtsstoppet borttaget"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-06-08T00:18:23Z
POI name: Stora Essingen
POI types: amenity-ferry_terminal
 #organicmaps android
commented by Cactooz (2025-10-07 14:30:20+00:00): It existed but it's no longer trafficked.
opened by j307 (2025-09-07 08:22:30+00:00): "Pendelbåtsstoppet borttaget"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-06-08T00:18:23Z
POI name: Lindholmen
POI types: amenity-ferry_terminal
 #organicmaps android
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:22:39+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
نام: ماه سنگ سپاهان
addr:street=40
addr:place=شهرک صنعتی محمودآباد
addr:city=شاهین شهر
شماره تماس: 03133808044
وب‌سایت: Www.mahstone.com
شبکه‌های اجتماعی: @mahsangstone
ساعات کاری: شنبه تا چهارشنبه ۸ تا ۱۸ و پنج شنبه ۸تا ۱۶
توضیحات: تولید سنگ ساختمانی
روش های پرداخت پذیرفته شده:
opened by meeuw (2025-09-07 08:24:10+00:00): In context of overlay "Bike paths" – Track / Land-Access Road – https://osm.org/way/258961688 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Dit is door begroeiing niet te fietsen
opened by SchleswigHolzsteiner (2025-09-07 08:26:04+00:00): Doppelhaus, links 5, rechts 5a

via StreetComplete 61.3
closed by Ygramul (2025-09-07 09:25:59+00:00): Resolved with changeset https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/171574747 by noteSolver_plugin/0.5.0
opened by Seat Ibiza (2025-09-07 08:27:01+00:00): Lijn 3 rijdt op de route van Wolder naar Nazareth / P+R Noord vanaf de halte Wilhelminasingel rechtsaf via de Stationsstraat en de Parallelweg naar het busstation. Vanaf de halte Wilhelminasingel is rechtdoor voor bussen die de halte hebben aangedaan niet eens mogelijk. Kan iemand dit corrigeren?
closed by Leo Slager (2025-09-07 15:24:32+00:00): aangepast
opened by Seat Ibiza (2025-09-07 08:28:05+00:00): Lijn 3 volgt hier dezelfde route als lijn 10, dus via de parallelweg. Kan iemand dit corrigeren?
closed by Leo Slager (2025-09-07 15:19:32+00:00): aangepast
opened by spa10 (2025-09-07 08:31:30+00:00): Unable to answer "What type of bicycle barrier is this?" – Cycle Barrier – https://osm.org/node/1609054006 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Nur eine Barriere

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303666.jpg
closed by Im Fokus (2025-09-11 06:11:32+00:00): Ist korrekt beobachtet, ABER:
- wir differenzieren nicht, ob da ein, zwei oder drei Gitter stehen
- der Weg scheint so schmal, dass ein Gitter den beabsichtigten Zweck erfüllt
- die Natur erledigt im vorliegenden Fall den Rest (oder täuscht der Eindruck, dass der Radweg zumindest an dieser Stelle ziemlich zugewachsen ist?)
--> keine Änderung nötig
closed by Znaika (2025-09-11 07:49:48+00:00): geändert
cycle_barrier=double
traffic_sign=DE:239
bicycle=no
footway=designated
surface=ground
closed by Im Fokus (2025-09-11 10:18:09+00:00): So kann man sich täuschen!!!

Ich habe mich über die virtuellen Möglichkeiten von OSM getäuscht, denn man kann doch darstellen, wie viele Barrieren den Weg versperren.

Du @spa10 hast Dich getäuscht, wie viele Barrieren da real den Pfad versperren. Ich vermute, die zweite Sperre ist schon völlig überwuchert.

Fazit für beide von uns: Holzauge, sei wachsam!!!
commented by Znaika (2025-09-11 11:55:18+00:00): Hi, ich habe das neueste Bild von @spa10 genau aungeschaut und mit den alten verglichen. Es sieht so aus als wäre die zweite Barriere nicht vorhanden zu sein (demontiert? verschwunden). Ich ändere es noch von double zu single. Der Fußweg ist aber wirklich stark mit Gras zugewachsen
commented by spa10 (2025-09-12 06:16:51+00:00): Ich bin heitr nochmal da vorbei. Da ist wirklich nur eine Barriere

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/304603.jpg
closed by Znaika (2025-09-12 07:05:49+00:00): Danke dir fürs Nachschauen. Dann ist alles nun richtig gemappt. Ich schließe diesen Hinweis
closed by Im Fokus (2025-09-12 07:10:00+00:00): Wollte ich auch gerade schreiben. 
Danke & manchmal geht's um Sekunden [wo ich in desem Thread gerade mit Weisheiten um mich werfe :-)]
opened by OpenAlfred (2025-09-07 08:31:44+00:00): Unable to answer "Are these opening hours still correct?" – King Style (Hairdresser) – https://osm.org/node/10089750883 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Aroma Parfum
Mo-Sa 10-19 Uht
Freitags 13:00-14:30 geschlossen
commented by herbsti (2026-02-06 14:16:32+00:00): King Style existiert nicht mehr. Neu: Aroma Parfum. Öffnungszeiten wie von OpenAlfred angegeben
closed by thom_bike_bln (2026-03-24 23:03:45+00:00): Öffnungszeiten wie beschrieben angepasst
opened by Marc Bx (2025-09-07 08:32:22+00:00): "Borie traditionnelle en parfait état"
OSM snapshot date: 2025-06-08T00:18:23Z
POI name: Borie
POI types: tourism-attraction
 #organicmaps ios
opened by PlayGuide (2025-09-07 08:32:29+00:00): Il existe ici une aire de jeux (structure, springy) et un équipement sportif (city_stade) signalés via l'appli #PlayGuide :
 https://playguide.eu/app/playground/2eab930f-ef0b-476f-ba39-3b8679b132eb
closed by PlayGuide (2025-09-07 08:33:02+00:00): Erreur, emplacement déjà présents, je cloture
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:33:16+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
نام: چاپ ترانه
addr:housenumber=17
addr:street=خیابابان اقتصاد
addr:city=Qods
addr:postcode=0
شماره تماس: 09038602311
شبکه‌های اجتماعی: https://t.me/taranehprint1
ساعات کاری: همه روزه 8الی 19
دسترسی با ویلچر: yes
دسته‌بندی: خدمات چاپی
توضیحات: چاپ  صحافی
روش های پرداخت پذیرفته شده:
opened by JeanSebastien (2025-09-07 08:33:38+00:00): Unable to answer "What’s the height of the curbs at this crossing?" – Unmarked Crossing – https://osm.org/node/6564682614 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Pas de passage piéton non marqué
closed by Britzz (2025-09-19 22:12:04+00:00): passage piéton supprimé
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:35:01+00:00): Help
closed by mavl (2025-09-08 13:14:29+00:00): This note does not contain a useful information for OpenStreetMap.
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:35:56+00:00): Parking 🅿
closed by gosgtan (2025-10-27 22:43:32+00:00): Ajouté à OSM. Merci pour votre note.
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:38:22+00:00): https://www.hofveldzicht.nl
Bauernhof museum 't Hof Veldzicht Vrouwenpolder
closed by fietswim (2025-09-12 08:48:56+00:00): Op de kaart gezet
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:38:45+00:00): pad is afgesloten
closed by Thierry1030 (2025-09-07 18:20:18+00:00): without proove/source this note is useless. Please make an account and make a new note
opened by OnFranz (2025-09-07 08:38:45+00:00): Next to the Kasperl is the Wiener Rösthaus Café & Shop

via StreetComplete 61.3

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303667.jpg
closed by Helium314 (2025-10-07 10:59:31+00:00): ist inzwischen eingezeichnet https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/13197542901
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:39:42+00:00): One house missing
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:39:51+00:00): this path doesn't exist anymore
closed by Thierry1030 (2025-09-07 18:20:08+00:00): without proove/source this note is useless. Please make an account and make a new note
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:41:20+00:00): path is closed for public and is a dead end
closed by Thierry1030 (2025-09-07 18:20:24+00:00): without proove/source this note is useless. Please make an account and make a new note
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:41:28+00:00): Road missing that leads to Östergården
opened by Kingigi (2025-09-07 08:42:25+00:00): Unable to answer "What’s the surface here?" – Steps – https://osm.org/way/246347559 via StreetComplete 57.1:

Metaal
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:43:01+00:00): Three houses missing, nearby
opened by olecky (2025-09-07 08:43:18+00:00): In context of overlay "Bike paths" – Rue de Jehanster (Residential Road) – https://osm.org/way/43023784 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Bus 390 passed this street on the way up, then turned right on the roundabout
closed by multimob (2025-09-08 07:16:22+00:00): OK but a temporarily relocation should better not be mapped.
opened by OnFranz (2025-09-07 08:43:43+00:00): Wiener Rösthaus

via StreetComplete 61.3

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303668.jpg
closed by Helium314 (2025-10-07 10:59:36+00:00): ist inzwischen eingezeichnet https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/13197542901
opened by chasp1k (2025-09-07 08:43:58+00:00): "https://elementsuites.gr/yellow-suite/"
OSM snapshot date: 2025-08-08T13:08:07Z
POI has no name
POI types: building
 #organicmaps android
closed by Lumikeiju (2025-10-13 05:05:49+00:00): Closing - duplicate of https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/4950378
opened by chasp1k (2025-09-07 08:43:58+00:00): "Rental appartament "element suites - yellow suite"
https://elementsuites.gr/yellow-suite/"
OSM snapshot date: 2025-08-08T13:08:07Z
POI has no name
POI types: building
 #organicmaps android
opened by Veryshka (2025-09-07 08:44:21+00:00): "дорога к орлиной полке"
OSM snapshot date: 2025-05-11T16:17:16Z
POI has no name
POI types: tourism-picnic_site
 #organicmaps android
closed by s777n (2025-09-07 10:12:54+00:00): Дорога уже отмечена
opened by EZéquiel2014 (2025-09-07 08:45:49+00:00): Bonjour, sur ce point, juste en dessous de la passerelle qui traverse "Le Grand Estey", il y a une petite cale de mise à l'eau.
closed by K12230LF (2026-01-27 18:09:00+00:00): ajoutée
opened by yrichard (2025-09-07 08:47:36+00:00): public toilets
closed by Ewen Hill (2026-07-16 09:44:48+00:00): Added - thank you
opened by f1[_]ff3}{ (2025-09-07 08:49:03+00:00): Unable to answer "Is this still here?" – Cofetăria Talla (Candy Maker) – https://osm.org/node/10759732086 via StreetComplete 61.3:

Not sure exactly where it was but there are several things here now, like money exchange and fornetti
closed by AlexTopoRO (2026-01-27 10:01:26+00:00): No
opened by pangoSE (2025-09-07 08:49:16+00:00): verkar vara hål i upplandsleden här
commented by Hovastro (2025-10-17 23:06:06+00:00): Enligt Naturkartan innehåller relationen en stig som inte var inritad. Flygfotot svårtytt, kan behöva justeras med GPS-data.
opened by stopthiscrazy (2025-09-07 08:49:34+00:00): Supermercado Pague Menos
opened by Geovelo_Notes (2025-09-07 08:50:00+00:00): la rue de l’Indienne à Corbeil Essonnes est en sens interdit (This note has been created from Geovelo: https://amenagements-cyclables.fr/fr/contributions/103434)
commented by Geovelo_Notes (2025-09-08 13:56:54+00:00): Un commentaire a été ajouté par un cycliste Geovelo : "Bonjour,
Merci pour ces précisions.
Les données ont été mises à jour sur la carte / OpenStreetMap et sera visible prochainement sur Geovelo.
Cyclablement,"
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:50:13+00:00): onosm.org submitted note from a business:
Name: کافه رستوران زیتون
addr:street=جاده سد دز
addr:city=Andimeshk
Phone number: +989164147300
Opening Hours: 24 hours
Category: Coffee Shops
Description: coffee shops and restaurant
Accepted payment methods: 
delivery=yes
opened by radnaj (2025-09-07 08:50:16+00:00): access=no

The parking and access to the beach hace been closed, with signs of "dangerous cliff. Keep away". The area has been fenced

#OsmAnd
opened by EZéquiel2014 (2025-09-07 08:50:35+00:00): A ce point, existe un escalier qui descend jusqu'au lit du Grand Estey. Il est situé au bord du Chemin de l'Estey, juste après le croisement  avec la rue François Mauriac.
commented by K12230LF (2026-01-27 18:11:59+00:00): Bonjour, auriez-vous une photo à partager ?
closed by Britzz (2026-06-21 11:26:20+00:00): ajouté avec ce que nous avions, donc approximativement.
@EZéquiel2014 : merci pour ce signalement et bienvenue parmi les contributeurs OpenStreetMap (OSM).
N'hésitez pas à passez la vitesse supérieure avec l'éditeur en ligne (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/FR:ID) via le "Modifier" en haut à gauche de cette page. Aide en ligne : https://learnosm.org/fr.
opened by yrichard (2025-09-07 08:50:47+00:00): Big W
closed by tastrax (2025-10-25 11:17:51+00:00): already mapped
opened by openstreetmap_zug (2025-09-07 08:51:05+00:00): robi

via StreetComplete 61.3

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303669.jpg
closed by Piagno (2025-09-08 08:13:08+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/171620168
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:51:24+00:00): Cuca's bar
opened by openstreetmap_zug (2025-09-07 08:52:35+00:00): hydrant

via StreetComplete 61.3

Attached photo(s):
https://streetcomplete.app/p/303670.jpg
closed by Piagno (2025-09-08 08:12:27+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/171620134
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:52:47+00:00): POI has no name
POI types: tourism-apartment
OSM data version: 2025-06-06T15:20:16Z
 #mapsme
opened by DanielAgos (2025-09-07 08:54:37+00:00): Service road to bus stop

via StreetComplete 61.3
opened by DanielAgos (2025-09-07 08:54:38+00:00): Max 3.5t

via StreetComplete 61.3
opened by DanielAgos (2025-09-07 08:54:38+00:00): Max 7t

via StreetComplete 61.3
opened by DanielAgos (2025-09-07 08:54:39+00:00): Brasafina.pt

via StreetComplete 61.3
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:54:48+00:00): One house Marydsvägen 117 missing, and one building Ekåsaryd
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:54:49+00:00): Die Anschlussstelle heißt seit jeher Wertheim/Lengfurt mit "/". Die Angaben Miltenberg und Tauberbischofsheim entsprechen nicht der Anschlussstellenbezeichnung.
closed by cuzi (2025-09-14 20:49:49+00:00): stimmt, geändert.
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:55:57+00:00): Km 29+470 (sulla cantoniera)
closed by Urbis13 (2025-09-11 19:36:05+00:00): Nota mia. Ok
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:56:28+00:00): Seems closed (no fuel stations)
opened by  (2025-09-07 08:57:14+00:00): Start ETCS L1 (LS) eastbound (as is)
Everything west ETCS L2 (to be)
closed by Jakka (2025-09-07 09:27:10+00:00): etcs 1 or 0 to 2 until Puurs
commented by M_V_W (2025-09-08 08:34:54+00:00): From ping to Puurs, lets only put L2 here. The only places with both L1+2 are two HSL lines.
closed by Jakka (2025-09-08 08:40:14+00:00): Send PMessage
commented by Sikal (2025-09-08 21:50:44+00:00): Hello,

ETCS L2 FS zone start at Puurs entry signal (K-Q.19, https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3195755183).

From K-Q.19 to here, the transition to ETCS 1 LS takes place and ETCS L2 is no longer the level used in both directions, so the track must be tagged with railway:etcs=1.

If you know the exact location of the signal carrying the Start of ETCS Level 1 Limited Supervision zone sign, can you tag it like described in https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/OpenRailwayMap/Tagging_in_Belgium ? :)

Thank you !
commented by M_V_W (2025-09-09 09:14:27+00:00): Hi Sikal!

We've had a similar discussion before: https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/4568267#map=11/50.6645/5.5042&layers=N

While you are mostly* right in the direction of Puurs, the level transition 2->1 in the direction of Boom happens at the signal, which is located directly under my ping**.
“Vanaf het sein XXXX richting Boom is op L52 ETCS L1 Limited Supervision van toepassing.”

In any case, the level transition depends on the direction you're travelling. Going forward, neither is more correct than the other. If you can find OSM guidelines for this issue, please let me know.


*Mostly because the transition 1-2 happens at a balise, not a signal (nor IBG/SBG). The signal simply tells the driver where he must be in the indicated level by the latest. However a transition from 2-1 indeed happens at a signal.

**I am not mapping signals, as I have requested Infrabel to provide their data (they have their own GIS) but they declined on the basis of security (read sabotage etc).
commented by M_V_W (2025-09-09 10:34:11+00:00): You may scrap the 'mostly' part ;) as this is LS
commented by Sikal (2025-09-14 00:41:45+00:00): Hi M_V_W, 
Thank you for your response ! :)

As far as I know, there is no OSM guideline for this issue. Using the tag 'railway:etcs:forward/backward=*' should be possible, but I think creating a new tag for such a minor case is excessive.

Personally, I use the most restrictive tag : A section that can be travelled under two ETCS levels is tagged with the lower one. ETCS L2 > ETCS L1 FS > ETCS L1 LS. This is a personal choice.

In my opinion, the better way to provide a clear overview of a track's situation is to add signalling with personal knowledge, survey or cabrides (with the authorization of the author).
commented by M_V_W (2025-09-19 09:10:33+00:00): I am certainly not a fan of extra tags either. 

While choosing the most restrictive is generally a good practice, there's a reason to choose the opposite here.

While trains may not receive movement authorities in ETCS L2 yet, a connection to the RBC is established (much) earlier/"disconnect" later. This has some benefits, and could be a reason to choose ETCS L2 tagging over  L1(LS)
commented by H4N5-antw (2025-11-15 11:58:12+00:00): May I offer as my opinion that -given restricted public access to railtracks in general, and use of those tracks for travel other than in trains operated by mostly NMBS- the presence of ETCS and the limits of particular supervision levels and extent of zones is of limited significance?