piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
raccoss (2024-10-04 20:18:13+00:00): Ciao. Sono passato dal ponte Bisantis ed in effetti hanno creato un restringimento alla carreggiata automobilistica con i jersey di cemento e si è creata una corsia che è indicata come pedonale, ma che si può anche agevolmente transitare in bicicletta. Sembra una soluzione temporanea, ma sappiamo che non c'è nulla di più definitivo del temporaneo in Italia.
Mi è stato detto inoltre che qualche anziano ricorda di aver visto dei ciclisti in via Campanella: in effetti se non si considera la sosta selvaggia è abbastanza larga per passarci in bicicletta (ma occhio alle strettoie all'altezza della Chiesa Materdomini e allo svincolo per la tangenziale).
Però trovo incomprensibile che venga indicato di passare per via Orti, stretta strada a doppio senso e sopratutto per via Mastracchi, stradina larga a malapena 2 metri e mezzo, a doppio senso alternato e che termina in uno strettissimo sottopasso dove regolarmente si incastrano i SUV più grandi.
In ogni caso oggi sono passato in queste due strade a piedi e ho fatto attenzione: non esiste nessun tipo di segnaletica, cartelli, frecce, adesivi che indichi un passaggio di una ciclovia. Sembra proprio che si tratti di un lavoro fatto a tavolino e rimasto sulla carta, tanto da poter dire che un punto A e un punto B sono collegati.
tastrax (2024-06-24 08:51:22+00:00): Hi xillo - its best practice to try and square the corners of buildings where its obvious they are square. This helps to make a quality map. I think Vespucci has a menu item to make this easier - https://vespucci.io/help/en/Way%20selected/

Cheers
GanderPL (2024-06-28 08:27:47+00:00): Jeśli budynek był dawniej spichlerzem, możesz dodać tag `building=warehouse`.

Możesz dodać tag heritage=*, jeśli budynek jest oficjalnie uznany za zabytek. Na przykład `heritage=2` dla budynku wpisanego do rejestru zabytków.

Jeśli budynek jest udostępniony do zwiedzania, dodaj `tourism=attraction`.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/153099114
grzegorz75jan (2024-06-28 10:00:42+00:00): To też teren Grupy Azoty. Akurat to miejsce może być użytkowane, dzierżawione przez jakąś inną firmę ale wejścia ot tak z ulicy tam nie ma. 
Dodatkowo użył tu nazwy opisowej.
https://lookmap.eu.pythonanywhere.com/#c=18/50.023427/20.912782&p=50.023427/20.912782&a=299.39/1.96
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/153099114
tastrax (2024-06-24 08:33:42+00:00): Hi Frederick, Many of the Microsoft buildings are poorly aligned so its best practice to adjust them after importing. Some need rotation and others are just plain incorrect. With good imagery in this area it would be great if you align them better to the imagery. Cheers
Frederik (2024-06-24 10:11:08+00:00): Hi, I've aligned the imagery with https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/11617835912. I'm also correcting the most obvious errors from the AI footprints, but that could use some refinement. Main goal is for it to be good enough for a survey to add address info.
grzegorz75jan (2025-01-09 16:10:33+00:00): A od kiedy to malujemy osobne linie dla pieszych i rowerzystów https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/153099474#map=19/50.325942/18.655008 jeżeli to ten sam ciąg potocznie chodnik przynajmniej tam gdzie ewidentnie idą tą samą nitką. Taki wspólny ciąg może mieć różny rodzaj  nawierzchni dla pieszych i rowerów. Ogólnie do tego mamy oznaczenie jako współdzielony lub separowany. W edytorze są linki do dokumentacji pomocy ale trochę trzeba też doszukać samodzielnie. Jest też trochę prawideł gdzie dla dla pieszych lub rowerzystów jest np. dostęp dopuszczalny itp. Jeżeli w terenie nic się nie zmieniło tzn. nie ma fizycznej separacji to to jest błąd edycyjny. Linię https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1295635106 należy usunąć a ta obok (nie mam wiedzy lokalnej) zostaje tak jak jest lub trzeba ją właściwie przerobić. Warto też zajrzeć na forum czy Discorda OSM by trochę o takich sprawach poczytać.

Miłej lektury https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pl:Rowery
SpinOff (2024-07-01 19:20:21+00:00): W stronę Kamionki nie jest on poprowadzony. Już poprawiłem.
phoenixsaigon1698 (2024-12-02 01:11:28+00:00): Oneway = -1 theo mình biết ko có giá trị nên mình sẽ bỏ nhé
Syl (2024-07-22 16:52:10+00:00): Bonjour, je n'arrive pas à comprendre la modélisation de ce bâtiment. Les toits sont mis comme des parties de bâtiment à part entière ?
syntex (2024-06-30 01:00:39+00:00): Budowa to nie jest nazwa własna
GanderPL (2024-06-30 08:23:36+00:00): To jak oznaczać co tutaj jest budowane?
syntex (2024-06-30 20:55:01+00:00): Znacznik name=Budowa i nic więcej to już opisuje tag construction
NaufalFarras (2024-06-24 13:13:35+00:00): Hello. Please mind existing bus stops while adding new ones to prevent duplicates. Thanks
Ritam Saha (2025-03-08 04:53:10+00:00): A lot of your edits in this changeset doesn't use the proper tagging scheme. Please correct. Also would be nice if you had better changeset comments instead of a bunch of hashtags.
lukabułka (2024-06-24 08:49:22+00:00): Górnie*
NLSU (2024-06-24 17:23:59+00:00): How do you make that small squared building thing? And how do you know how many house addresses are there?
Zh9567 (2024-06-25 02:29:22+00:00): You can use the Terracer plugin in JOSM (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/JOSM/Plugins/Terracer).
NLSU (2024-06-26 01:10:20+00:00): Okay. Thanks for the info.
JayTurnr (2024-06-24 09:01:10+00:00): Also worth noting, I updated the access requirements on Chequers Road in response to this letter Costco Derby customers are getting

> Costco Derby: Traffic improvements
> Dear [Redacted],
> 
> Costco, Derby City Council and local bus operators have been working together to try and improve the traffic congestion that regularly builds around the Wyvern Way / Derwent Parade roundabout. 
> 
> From Friday 21st June 2024, new time restrictions will be applied to the bus lane (Chequers Road) that runs westbound adjacent to Costco's warehouse. The new restrictions will be implemented on an experimental basis for up to 18 months and if successful, will become permanent. 
> 
> The bus lane will now operate from 7am until 10am and from 3pm to 6pm, seven days a week. Outside of those times, any vehicle will be able to use the bus lane. 
> 
> The aim is to increase the efficiency with which members can access Costco, therefore reducing the congestion on the main Wyvern Way / Derwent Parade roundabout. At busy times between 10am and 3pm, vehicles may be redirected down the bus lane and asked to enter Costco's car park from the western end. 
> 
> Clear signage will be in place at the start of the bus lane. Please be aware that Derby City Council's camera enforcement within the bus lane's operating hours will still continue.
NicaTopo (2024-06-26 02:36:43+00:00): Hi 
Your building shapes are much bigger than the aerial imagery and they are often not squared. I'm deleting them.
salma_z (2024-06-27 14:19:44+00:00): Hello "TDH"
I noticed you reverted my edit and changed the street name from Rezq Street to Metro Street
Examples:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/99885187
also changed this street from Rezq Street  to 23 Street
Examples:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1282030319
Can you please provide with us the source that you used to change this street?
Regards;
TDH (2024-06-27 22:07:57+00:00): Hi Salma.
Now I live on this street and use the house plates as source data. If need I can make a photo of it.
TDH (2024-06-28 21:59:42+00:00): Name "Resq street" not shown in building plates on place at all.
I think more right way make name Metro street as main and 23 street as alt-name.
salma_z (2024-07-02 06:11:37+00:00): Hello "TDH"
Thank you for the response.
if it is possible send a picture of the signboard,
As for (Rezq Street) this name is from special data for us, if you don't have an official source We can rely on your knowledge of the place
Regards;
TDH (2024-07-05 18:36:16+00:00): How I can send photo to you?
salma_z (2024-07-07 06:25:33+00:00): Hello TDH;
you can use this website:
https://imgbb.com
And upload the photo on it,
Regards
TDH (2024-07-08 11:50:32+00:00): https://ibb.co/bFF2P2P
At north-east buildings have a "Metro street" on plates, at south-west "street 23".|
This two plates placed on one building.
salma_z (2024-07-09 11:50:42+00:00): Appreciate the source that you provided and I fixed it now on this changeset: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/153741201
Regards
salma_z
kmpoppe (2024-06-24 09:15:20+00:00): Change reason visible on https://web.archive.org/web/20240624091405/https://westnordost.de/p/217568.jpg - closed notes only 4283489 and 4283492
kmpoppe (2024-06-24 09:15:44+00:00): Change reason visible on https://web.archive.org/web/20240624091405/https://westnordost.de/p/217568.jpg
Aleh Aliakseyenka (2024-06-24 09:17:52+00:00): My bad and i am sorry, accidentally cited the wrong source, I used Esri World Imagery to add this building.
arjunaraoc (2024-07-06 10:32:13+00:00): Welcome to OSM.  Please visit  India page on OSM wiki (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/India) and  join OSM India Telegram channel (https://t.me/OSMIndia).
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/153101794
archie (2024-06-24 19:54:11+00:00): Lite nyfiken. Här taggade du parking:both=no på gator som endast får trafikeras av bussar i linjetrafik. Vad är meningen med det? Info för busschaffisar att de inte får parkera längs gatan eller var det bara en gata som ännu inte hade den typen av taggningen och skulle taggas oavsett om det är meningsfullt?
Batistacavera (2024-06-25 13:02:13+00:00): Om taggningen är meningsfull eller inte ligger väl i betraktarens ögon? Jag tror inte någon vet vilka dessa ögon kommer att vara.

Ett exempel på hur denna data kan vara användbar är för maskininlärning. Där är uppmärkt data guld. Det behövs både data för när en egenskap föreligger och när den inte gör det. Utan båda finns riak för både typ 1- och typ 2-fel (en modell för att hitta katter missar aldrig en katt om den klassar allt so katter, här behövs data gör vad som inte är en katt).

Kanske långsökt exempel men min poäng är att vi faktiskt inte vet vad databasen kommer att användas till i framtiden.
archie (2024-06-25 17:17:44+00:00): Ännu en gång: detta är en ren bussgata, där annan trafik än buss i linjetrafik inte är tillåten.
Batistacavera (2024-06-25 17:53:38+00:00): Jag ser fortfarande inte riktigt problemet. I https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Street_parking finns avsnittet "Reasons for parking restrictions". Där kan man exempelvis använda sig av parking:both:restriction:bus_lane=no.

Det finns även avsnittet https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Street_parking#Using_OSM_parking_data där ovanstående problematiseras ytterligare - det tycks råda delade meningar om best practice.

Detta är verkligen ingen hjärtefråga för mig, men att det finns ett självklart rätt och fel ser jag inte.
archie (2024-06-25 18:47:42+00:00): På en bussgata får endast bussar framföras. På en gata med busfil (bus_lane) får även andra fordon framföras. Återigen: på en bussgata råder exklusivitet för bussar. 
Så bussgata och en bussfil är inte samma sak. Det finns en avgörande skillnad dem emellan.
Batistacavera (2024-06-25 20:54:39+00:00): Jag tror inte vi kommer vidare. Taggningsrational är till viss del godtycklig. Vi tycker helt enkelt olika i frågan.
CasperGeo (2024-06-27 09:01:57+00:00): press q to square buildings here. Take care to map the buildings shape, which is usually square.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/153103264
CasperGeo (2024-06-27 09:11:10+00:00): Also, please note that there are more buildings in this little area here. I added them
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/153103264
HAmap (2024-06-24 11:42:38+00:00): Have you seen this:
https://www.srf.ch/static/cms/images/1280w/5b4859e.webp
?
Leo Slager (2024-06-24 10:52:38+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privebericht.
MVG,
Leo
Namens de OSM Community
Leo Slager (2024-06-24 10:56:43+00:00): Dag Julian,
Aub nooit beginnen met access=no op een highway. Dat is een absoluut verbod en dat leidt tot fouten bij navigatie apps.

Veel plezier met verder mappen.
Nzau (2024-08-05 18:25:21+00:00): Bonjour Arthur,

Tu vas surement voir passer le sujet sur le forum, je me permets de le remettre ici pour l'historique.

https://forum.openstreetmap.fr/t/bicycle-designated-ou-cycleway-shared-lane/25975

Bonne journée,
Enzo
Mateusz Konieczny (2026-02-04 06:40:12+00:00): Hello! https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/171663550/history has via_ferrata_scale = D that was added in this edit
What via_ferrata_scale = D means? It is not listed at https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:via%20ferrata%20scale
-=|MisterY|=- (2026-02-04 12:50:13+00:00): Hi! Yeah, sorry. It's a grade per Schall Scale (https://www.bergfreunde.eu/via-ferrata-grades-calculator/). I keep forgetting that OSM uses it's own standard.
Mateusz Konieczny (2026-06-09 07:39:40+00:00): created https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/5334747 to remind about fixing
Mateusz Konieczny (2026-06-09 08:06:10+00:00): thanks for fix!
adiatmad (2024-06-25 09:26:30+00:00): Helloo,
Adding a descriptive name like "name=building, house, pond, mosque, etc" to OpenStreetMap might not be recommended. However, don't worry, there are some additional learning resources available to help you out.
Happy mapping!
>> https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/1295672033
>> https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions
>> Beginner's Mapping guide: https://osm.org/wiki/Beginners%27_guide.
>> Self-paced learning modules for intermediate/advanced mappers: https://learnosm.org
Mateusz Konieczny (2024-12-25 19:35:02+00:00): Hello! https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/12006134746/history has shop = safety that was added in this edit (if I checked things correctly)
shop=safety ? What kind of shop, if any is here?  is https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:shop=safety_equipment fitting?
somehundred (2024-12-25 19:41:55+00:00): You're right, this shop sells safety equipment, that's explained in description tag. I added shop=safety because I didn't know what tag would be correct one at the moment of editing. I was in a learning process then.
somehundred (2024-12-25 19:58:23+00:00): Upon researching further, I now think that I had added the wrong name. There is company called Pristis in this address but it doesn't seem to be a shop at all. The shop this element is referring likely has a different name. Will double-check this place in the following days.
nevw (2024-06-30 01:54:30+00:00): Hi
There seems to be a problem to fix here
https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=143.90554&lat=-13.50026&zoom=8
nevw (2024-06-30 05:57:57+00:00): Hi again, not sure if these problems were from your editing as there have been a vast number of reverts around the coastline to beaches due to a unsuitable source used.
I haven’t had a look what the osmi errors involve either.
This changeset comment may be related to the osmi errors…
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/153351828
yelisey90 (2025-09-15 10:29:27+00:00): reverted - unexplained name removal

https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/171957916
literan (2024-06-24 19:22:59+00:00): поаккуратнее, пожалуйста. вы присоединили тропу к полигону луга, слив его с тротуаром. В других правках тоже есть такие ошибки
RaphaelPasloin (2024-06-24 11:03:31+00:00): Hello,

The signs say reception, visitors and collect and go  : so the access is not private but access=customers

https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=688347076184724
SanRemo76 (2024-06-24 13:12:33+00:00): Really? Can be possible, probably changed. The last time I passed it was only for trucks for loading/unloading.
I also have to tell, I'm not yet used wit OSM, I have to learn to work with it.
If you want, you can change the setting again. Otherwise I will try it by myself, but as of the moment no time.
My intention is actually to make that road (what is not a public road anymore) mark as non-accesable for cyclists.
There is a gate in front (mostly closed, also during the day), and on the backside permanently closed.
RaphaelPasloin (2024-06-25 09:53:02+00:00): Thanks for the response, i re-surveyed today ; the gate you refer is here : https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/12009256097 , comming from https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/73491802 there is no signs or gate to restrict access ; i have  set https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/28179985 with access=customers and removed the restriction to the accessible roads.

Have a good day.
5m4u9 (2024-06-25 05:03:21+00:00): Hola, solo una sugerencia, los edificios de departamentos se puede también asignar el tipo a building=apartaments para más detalles.
eisa01 (2024-07-01 16:03:11+00:00): Litt det samem spørsmålet her :)

Path brukes om stier i skogen, og dette ser ut som en grusvei fra satelittbildene? Det er nå blitt umulig å route til Valstad og Valryggen

Ved at du la til surface=gravel så vil rutere ta hensyn til det, og redusere prioriteten på veien når den beregner ruter
Patryk2710 (2024-08-11 12:00:26+00:00): wydaje się, że jest już przejezdna https://hej.mielec.pl/pl/11_wiadomosci/682_inwestycje/87744_polaczenie-jaslany---jozefow-na-nowym-poziomie.html
Tomek | Yanosik (2024-08-12 06:41:17+00:00): Poprawione. Dzięki za info i link :)
Leo Slager (2024-06-24 16:53:04+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privebericht.
MVG,
Leo
Namens de OSM Community
Leo Slager (2024-06-24 16:56:47+00:00): Dag Frank,

Met de editor iD kun je de weg opknippen door de node te selecteren en dan rechtklikken met de muis.

Ik heb het even voor je aangepast.
En het éé´nrichtingsverkeer was niet voor (brom-) fietsers, dus dat heb ik ook even aangepast.

Veel succes met verder mappen.
Frank5698751 (2024-06-27 05:53:44+00:00): Dank je wel voor de informatie. Fijn dat je het wilde controleren en mijn foutjes wilde aanpassen :-) Ga er verder mee aan de slag om het goede kaartmateriaal nog beter te krijgen!
hatul (2024-07-16 07:59:46+00:00): תודה על התוספת אבל כבר היתה נקודה. כדאי למזג אותן.
Leo Slager (2024-06-25 10:42:52+00:00): Dag Frank,

Het bordje met verboden toegang art 461 betekent dat het terreein niet toegankelijk is voor derden.
Dat taggen we dan op de highway met "access=private"
En de weg wordt dan highway=service.

ik pas het even aan.
CasGroenigen (2024-06-24 12:09:45+00:00): I ment that I added a path instead of "added tags"
felipeeugenio (2024-06-24 19:19:01+00:00): Hola.
Hay un tema con como dibujó las direcciones. Tiene el condominio una dirección?
Arreglé algunas cosas, pero para otras necesito más información.

Bienvenido en todo caso si quiere unirse al chat de la comunindad OSM Chile en el link de telegram (app muy similar a whatsapp) https://t.me/OSMcl

saludos
TheNightRider (2024-06-24 12:26:28+00:00): NEXT Gallery, EDGE Gallery, Core New Art Space, and Kanon Collective all moved less than 1 mile east to The HUB Building at 40 West Arts, located at  6501 W Colfax Ave, Lakewood CO 80214
Nathan_A_RF (2024-06-25 18:22:20+00:00): Is this 30 mph now? I remember there being national speed limit signs at the northern end last time I visited.
amosharper (2024-06-25 21:09:56+00:00): I'm fairly sure, was there earlier in the year for a swim. Bing Streetside in iD doesn't have it, so I'll check next time I'm near - but I'm moderately confident.
Leo Slager (2024-06-25 10:47:07+00:00): feedback:
First of all my condolences.

But this kind of private information should not be on the map.
I regret to remove your contribution.
TheNightRider (2024-06-24 12:37:23+00:00): What is the best way to add to this building the several art galleries, the art supply store, and 40 Arts West office?
TheNightRider (2024-06-24 14:13:43+00:00): Never mind. I figured it out. Just add points.
literan (2024-06-24 19:13:22+00:00): и зачем вы name удалили?
aseidel (2024-06-25 12:13:52+00:00): Liebe:r ChMenges,
bitte den benutzungspflichtigen Rad-/Gehweg vollständig taggen, siehe https://osmtools.de/traffic_signs/?signs=240 plus oneway=* und width=* sowie Typos korrigieren. Gleiches gilt für die östlich und westlich anschließenden Abschnitte. Zum Vergleich siehe z. B. https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/358509266 (dort auch das Tagging an der Straße/Hauptlinie beachten).
Danke und herzliche Grüße
Antje Seidel
#lgmaps
domeqasz (2024-08-14 11:25:15+00:00): Komunikacja miejska może jechać aleją rzeczpospolitą
Bolt028 (2024-12-09 16:51:37+00:00): Hi. do you know if there is still construction on  Aleja Rzeczypospolitej (1084359619) ?
trigpoint (2026-03-11 15:14:27+00:00): This changeset has been fully reverted by the DWG in changeset https://openstreetmap.org/changeset/179707075
OSM_RogerWilco (2024-06-25 07:51:41+00:00): Hallo ChMenges,

danke, dass Du mithilfst OSM besser und vollständiger zu machen! :-)

Wie man Geh- und Radwege richtig erfasst, kannst Du mit dem Verkehrszeichentool prüfen:

https://osmtools.de/traffic_signs/

Ein highway=cycleway ist z.B. nur für reine Radwege gedacht. Wenn es sich um einen gemeinsamen Geh- und Radweg handelt, dann verwenden wir dafür highway=path. Gehweg, die mit Zusatzeichen "Rad frei" für Radfahrende freigegeben sind sind highway=footway.

Das o.g. Tool behandelt aber nur Wege mit Verkehrszeichen. Eine vollständige Liste aller möglichen Geh- und Radwege und wie man diese richtig erfasst findest Du hier:

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Bicycle/Radverkehrsanlagen_kartieren

Viele Grüße
Roger Wilco
gileri (2024-06-24 15:36:17+00:00): Bonjour Yves, merci pour la contribution !

J'ai fait des changements en partant du principe que c'est bien une terrasse "en dur", je ne la vois pas via les photos aériennes/satellite :

https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/153118264

Éric
mavl (2024-11-13 06:16:41+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 159077163 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: incompatible sources - https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/16857].
sinek123 (2026-05-01 15:57:56+00:00): Sir please.... dont please please tag your builds as A101 as its tag not just empty tag name A101
custodiankeyy (2025-09-19 19:55:46+00:00): Can you add shop=supermarket to these nodes? They are treated like normal nodes instead shops.
KiloThree (2024-06-25 17:51:51+00:00): To my knolwedge, no entrance to Mem Drive is signed as a limited access highway. Per state law, that's bike accessible, see MGL chapter 85 section 11B, first paragraph: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/mass-general-laws-c85-ss-11b

That said, it definitely shouldn't be encouraged or suggested by routing apps in most cases. bicycle=discouraged might be the more precise value to use, since access denotes the legal right of way
Em Rrrrr (2024-06-25 18:06:37+00:00): That may be; my proposed edit was only based on noticing the surrounding segments being marked as no-bike no-horse, with only these small connecting segments were not, which doesn't seem to make much sense.

It may be more correct to the law to mark the much larger stretch as bike=yes / horse=yes instead per the law. I don't see 'discouraged' as an option in the dropdown.
KiloThree (2024-06-25 18:33:28+00:00): Oh, trust the wiki over the dropdown generally. iD gets updated, but the wiki is generally a more canonical source https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:access#access-discouraged
GinaroZ (2024-06-27 19:38:59+00:00): Hi, are these roads you've tagged as living streets signed as "home zones" on the ground?
Wayward Hayward (2024-06-27 19:41:53+00:00): Hmm no,  there are no pavements on theses side roads and they are intended to be mixed use.

I can change them to be purely side roads
Wayward Hayward (2024-06-27 20:05:03+00:00): Found the plan reference here https://pa.eastlothian.gov.uk/online-applications/files/CC07DFDF3BF77715D71EE60A7EC739BB/pdf/18_01048_AMM-PLANNING_AND_DESIGN_STATEMENT-2651250.pdf