piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
empty_child (2026-04-02 14:04:53+00:00): > Protected territory laws don't allow wandering off marked trails
> High possibility of unprepared tourists trying to storm the hill injuring themselves
We all have the head on our shoulders not only for eating; it's not the reason to remove data. For difficulties of routes, we have tags

> There are talks of renovating the infra and building a proper trail up
We don't have enough mappers to follow all possible events, and then without evidence - not the reason to remove, construction prefered

> admin would prefer to keep this path off the public map
Well, let's let them prefer anything they want. But if it has a place in reality, we shouldn't remove objects
McKulkin (2026-04-02 20:18:50+00:00): @evgenykatyshev,
Well, that's the issue, the trail per se doesn't exist. We climbed that hill on 3rd Sept '25, almost 2 weeks after the original author's journey (if you trust his tags). We were climbing blind, but we had a general description of what to expect and where to go. Our tracks generally align - possibly because the terrain doesn't allow for alternative routes in the second half of the trail. But the feeling of being off-trail prevailed through the entire trip. It's a very risky path, the climb didn't go smoothly even for us. There's no cell reception in this area.

Original author marked this trail as "impassable". I'd rather keep the situation pre-2026 and leave this trail uncharted.
McKulkin (2026-04-02 20:19:37+00:00): @empty_child,
I appreciate the feedback.

> We all have the head on our shoulders not only for eating

I don't know your age and/or experience, but at some point in life comes the realization that human beings are prone to vastly overestimating their capabilities and doing very stupid things without thinking of the consequences.

This is a touristy place. One might fire off his favorite map app and decide to storm the hill because his favorite app showed there's a trail up to a cave. 

All this is very risky, very dangerous.
evgenykatyshev (2026-04-03 06:23:55+00:00): I reverted it because you deleted the path that actually exists according to your own explanation, but just isn't safe
McKulkin (2026-04-03 10:57:12+00:00): "the trail per se doesn't exist" are my direct words provided in the explanation. Let's have others visit the place and reassess the current situation.
NeisBot (2026-04-02 12:42:45+00:00): Hello, welcome and thank you for your contribution to OSM!

Your changeset was commented because your added description, note or slogan contain detailed text that may be interpreted as promotional or SEO-related. To ensure OSM remains neutral and focused on map data, I recommend keeping descriptions concise, factual, and free from marketing or promotional language.

⚠️️ Problematic element (limit 1):
https://osm.org/node/13701267477 v1

Could you please revise your text accordingly?

✅ For example, a more neutral and factual version of your text could be: "Accounting office"
---
Na przykład, bardziej neutralna i fakticzna wersja Twojego tekstu mogłaby brzmieć: "Biuro rachunkowe"
---
(Auto-translation)

#MapWithoutSpam
stasiu512 (2026-04-02 13:42:00+00:00): Poprawiłem ten punkt zgodnie z zasadami OSM 

https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/13701267477
felipeeugenio (2026-04-02 20:49:05+00:00): Hola.
Ice_road da la impresión de ser totalmente para otra cosa (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:ice_road)

en este camino a lo mas hay nieve unos meses al año. Y no creo que en todo el tramo.

saludos
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/180766334
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 13:02:11+00:00): bonjour,
merci pour le sens, mais les arrêts ont-ils des noms ?

bonne carto d'arrêts :)
nevw (2026-04-03 06:25:45+00:00): Hi, osmi reports this multipolygon that needs repair
https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/10089358#map=15/-35.32051/149.15476

https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=149.15474&lat=-35.31991&zoom=15
marcmarti (2026-04-02 18:38:30+00:00): Hola Salvador,

El tram de la C-31 que canvies és trunk, no motorway. La longitud de les sortides de la carretera són massa curtes per ser considerades "motorway".
swinetown (2026-04-02 13:12:51+00:00): *area
iandees (2026-04-02 13:19:08+00:00): Hello! I noticed that node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/12654233432 was moved a long distance in this changeset. This is a common mistake that happens when you click on a point and drag to move the map. The point moves with your mouse instead of the map.

I moved things back to where they were before in https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/180767797, so no harm done!

To avoid this in the future:
- Try to click on an empty part of the map when you want to move around
- If you see a point move by mistake, press Ctrl+Z (or Cmd+Z on Mac) to undo it

Happy mapping!
Noshiys (2026-04-02 14:20:17+00:00): Извините, случайно удалил лес, не получается откатить из-за размера. Помогите, пожалуйста
LLlypuk82 (2026-04-23 23:53:58+00:00): Исправил.
5m4u9 (2026-04-03 03:02:45+00:00): Hola, creaste mal los distritos en el Alto.

No son areas residenciales, deben ser límites administrativos y debes crearlos "ocultando" todos los otros datos para que no queden pegados.

De todas formas revertí el cambio.
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 13:00:31+00:00): bonjour,
tu as ajouté un bâtiment dans un bâtiment existant  ?

l'idée est de plutôt faire évoluer le batiment existant en lui ajoutant ce qui va permettre de le qualifier de Chapelle et lui donner son nom

voici ma proposition https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/110284361

existe-t-il encore des cérémonies dans cette chapelle ?

bonne cartographie
MattDingui (2026-04-07 12:57:59+00:00): Bonjour et merci, non il n'existe plus de cérémonies, elle est désacralisée et accueille des expositions
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-07 13:07:34+00:00): peut-être à compléter avec cela ? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/FR:Tag:tourism%3Dgallery
MattDingui (2026-04-08 07:14:35+00:00): oui ; tourism gallery est le plus approchant
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-11 10:07:36+00:00): ok, ajout et nettoyage https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/110284361
ajmat (2026-04-03 10:19:11+00:00): Reverted in changeset id: 180803893
NeisBot (2026-04-02 13:30:45+00:00): Hello, welcome and thank you for your contribution to OSM!

Your changeset was commented because your added description, note or slogan contain detailed text that may be interpreted as promotional or SEO-related. To ensure OSM remains neutral and focused on map data, I recommend keeping descriptions concise, factual, and free from marketing or promotional language.

⚠️️ Problematic element (limit 1):
https://osm.org/way/108294636 v7

Could you please revise your text accordingly?

✅ For example, a more neutral and factual version of your text could be: "Hotel building"
---
Например, более нейтральная и фактическая версия вашего текста могла бы быть: "Здание отеля"
---
(Auto-translation)

#MapWithoutSpam
Karpov Dmitry (2026-04-02 13:38:58+00:00): Thank you for the clarification.

Understood. We did not mean to add promotional text. If you could suggest a neutral wording in line with OSM guidelines and publish the update accordingly, we would be happy to accept it.

Thank you for your help.
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 12:48:43+00:00): bonjour,

dans le commentaire, préciser le "type" de point, ici oeuvre de street art.

pour le point, avoir écrit Fresque de StreetArt pour le nom est sans dout eune erreur (à moins que cela soit vraiment le nom de l'oeuvre). Cela ressemble plutôt à une description.

ceux sont les attributs qui vont "définir" que c'est une fresque de street art

voici la v2 https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/13701341431

bonne carto
NeisBot (2026-04-02 13:45:45+00:00): Hello, welcome and thank you for your contribution to OSM!

Your changeset was commented because your added description, note or slogan contain detailed text that may be interpreted as promotional or SEO-related. To ensure OSM remains neutral and focused on map data, I recommend keeping descriptions concise, factual, and free from marketing or promotional language.

⚠️️ Problematic element (limit 1):
https://osm.org/node/13699064229 v3

Could you please revise your text accordingly?

✅ For example, a more neutral and factual version of your text could be: "Boutique store"

#MapWithoutSpam
NeisRevert (2026-04-10 16:33:20+00:00): 🔄🤖 Partly reverted due to either a lack of response from the contributor or remaining promotional text by https://osm.org/changeset/181157270
(Restore previous tags. No changes)
NeisBot (2026-04-02 13:45:47+00:00): Hello, welcome and thank you for your contribution to OSM!

Your changeset was commented because your added description, note or slogan contain detailed text that may be interpreted as promotional or SEO-related. To ensure OSM remains neutral and focused on map data, I recommend keeping descriptions concise, factual, and free from marketing or promotional language.

⚠️️ Problematic element (limit 1):
https://osm.org/node/13701372544 v1

Could you please revise your text accordingly?

✅ For example, a more neutral and factual version of your text could be: "Residential area"

#MapWithoutSpam
NeisReview (2026-04-10 16:33:23+00:00): 🚫 Text removed by https://osm.org/changeset/180929638
iandees (2026-04-02 13:52:21+00:00): Hello! I noticed that node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6987980366 was moved a long distance in this changeset. This is a common mistake that happens when you click on a point and drag to move the map. The point moves with your mouse instead of the map.

I moved things back to where they were before in https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/180769395, so no harm done!

To avoid this in the future:
- Try to click on an empty part of the map when you want to move around
- If you see a point move by mistake, press Ctrl+Z (or Cmd+Z on Mac) to undo it

Happy mapping!
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 12:38:24+00:00): bonjour,
merci pour cela !

dans le commentaire, on explique cela que l'on a fait, par exemple ici ajout de poubelle.

"préfiguration PETR Pays d'Armagnac" ne dit rien de ce que tu as contribué à faire !

ce n'est pas grave, c'est pour expliquer :)

bonne carto
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 12:40:31+00:00): et je pense d'ailleurs que ceux sont des conteneurs de tri, pour le recyclage ?

que peut-on y trier ?
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 12:41:14+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/13701383834
Wildsharky (2026-04-03 12:09:09+00:00): Reverted in changeset id:180796862
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 12:35:47+00:00): Bonjour,
à ce que je vois tu as ajouté une salle des fêtes, une école de musique et un lieu d'exposition ?

il n'est pas nécessaire de mettre la ville
Un nom de ville c'est plutôt Estang
le nom de l'école de musique c'est Premières notes, et pas école de musique Premières notes car dans ce cas tu décris et c'est l'attribut qui définit cela

retour en vrac mais le plus important c'est que personne dans le monde ne savait qu'il y avait cela ici, maintenant cela peut s'améliorer :)

bonne cartographie
Piskvor (2026-04-02 14:16:26+00:00): Ahoj, je to segregated=yes , nebo zase stavba cedulky? Díky za zmapování.
Martin2035 (2026-04-04 12:36:04+00:00): Ahoj, není to segregated, pouze legalizace chodníku. Stezka pro pěší s povoleným vjezdem cyklo
eggie (2026-04-02 14:05:14+00:00): Dag Rutger,

Wanneer er een gootje is hoort het met ramp:bicycle=yes te routeren.
Een route mag dus via een trap lopen. 
bicycle=yes was dus niet verkeerd.
Het traject is dus ook beschikbaar voor fietsers al is dat niet altijd gewenst. 
De hamvraag is dus zit er een gootje naast de trap?

MVG
eggie
eggie (2026-04-02 14:06:43+00:00): Ik heb bicycle=dismount (afstappen) toegevoegd. Dat geeft ook een symbool op sommige kaarten.
rutgerbrf (2026-04-02 14:10:59+00:00): Hi eggie, ja, er zit een gootje naast de trap, maar de tag ramp:bicycle=yes stond er sowieso al op, dus mij leek bicycle=yes dan overbodig of misschien zelfs wel verkeerd (maar ik wist dat niet zo zeker). Op andere trappen vanaf bruggen in de buurt met een fietsgootje (bijv. deze vanaf de Snelbinder, https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/354316584) zie wel ramp:bicycle=yes, maar verder geen normale bicycle tag. Wat is handig/consequent?
eggie (2026-04-02 14:16:43+00:00): Wanneer er een gootje zit.. gewoon het gootje taggen en meestal combineer ik het met bicycle=dismount.
Dan zie je op sommige kaarten een afstappende fietser. Bv de Openfietsmap.
Die geeft dan wel een voorkeur om de trap over te slaan of het moet wel een hele omweg zijn.
In het kort.. dus gewoon het gootje bijtaggen en op de aansluitende voetpaden foot=yes taggen.
Gr eggie
Nakaner (2026-04-03 17:57:10+00:00): Hallo,

zu deiner Eintragung habe ich folgende Hinweise, um deren Beachtung und Umsetzung ich bitten möchte:

1. Da die Praxis laut Beschreibung nicht das komplette Gebäude in Anspruch nimmt, sollte sie nicht am selben Objekt (Way) wie das Gebäude erfasst werden.

2. Damit es eine Physiotherapiepraxis ist, muss es auch als solche erfasst sein. OpenStreetMap ist keine Karte, sondern eine Datenbank. Es genügt daher nicht, einfach nur den Namen zu erfassen. Stattdessen bedarf es maschinenlesbarer Attribute, die angeben, um was es sich handelt (hier healthcare=physiotherapist). https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Tag:healthcare%3Dphysiotherapist

Markiere das Objekt im iD-Editor und klicke dann auf die Objektart in der linken Seitenleiste. Dort kannst du nach "Physiotherapie" suchen.

Viele Grüße

Michael
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 13:09:36+00:00): Bonjour,
merci pour le studio de radio,
j'ai voulu aller voir le site web, il y avait une typo, j'ai corrigé, voici la version sans le www qui fonctionne

https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/13701498626

bonne carto Pépette32
PizzaTreeIsland (2026-04-20 10:16:48+00:00): Hello hozpak and welcome to openstreetmap, 
Unfortunately, I had to revert your edits. I think you tried to add a business, but instead, you edited the street. You added tags like opening hours, email addresses, phone numbers and takeout, which are usual tags for a restaurant, but not for a street. Please refer to the wiki (or feel free to reach out to me) if you are unsure what tags to use. Please also note that certain tags only have specific kinds of values, for example you can't just write the whole address into the name tag and you can't paste geo coordinates into the wikipedia tag. 
If you are interested in making edits in the future, I highly recommend using an editor that has built in quality checks. The ID editor (the one in your browser if you click edit in the top left of the openstreetmap website) is especially beginner friendly. For example, it uses presets for common features like restaurants and auto suggests what information to fill in. 

Thank you and happy mapping!
Jonas
NeisBot (2026-04-02 14:15:42+00:00): Hello, welcome and thank you for your contribution to OSM!

Your changeset was commented because your added description, note or slogan contain detailed text that may be interpreted as promotional or SEO-related. To ensure OSM remains neutral and focused on map data, I recommend keeping descriptions concise, factual, and free from marketing or promotional language.

⚠️️ Problematic element (limit 1):
https://osm.org/node/9980092397 v6

Could you please revise your text accordingly?

✅ For example, a more neutral and factual version of your text could be: "Pub and eatery"

#MapWithoutSpam
NeisAgent (2026-04-02 16:33:17+00:00): 🕵 It looks like you reintroduced text that was previously flagged as promotional and removed after a review. Could you please explain why it was added again?
CAM-Gerlach_Repair (2026-07-04 10:42:52+00:00): Cleaned up blatantly promotional description=* and other malformed tags

https://osm.org/changeset/185084473
NeisBot (2026-04-02 14:15:46+00:00): Hello, welcome and thank you for your contribution to OSM!

Your changeset was commented because your added description, note or slogan contain detailed text that may be interpreted as promotional or SEO-related. To ensure OSM remains neutral and focused on map data, I recommend keeping descriptions concise, factual, and free from marketing or promotional language.

⚠️️ Problematic element (limit 1):
https://osm.org/node/4526550538 v4

Could you please revise your text accordingly?

✅ For example, a more neutral and factual version of your text could be: "Elettrodomestici store"
---
Ad esempio, una versione più neutra e fattuale del tuo testo potrebbe essere: "Negozio di elettrodomestici"
---
(Auto-translation)

#MapWithoutSpam
NeisReview (2026-04-10 16:33:25+00:00): 👍 Thank you for updating the element by https://osm.org/changeset/180772993
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 14:20:40+00:00): bonjour,
instagram n'est pas un website c'est plutôt

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:contact:instagram
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 14:23:35+00:00): mais c'est un doublon en fait :

donc @votresolutiondigitale ajoute website, digitaleo ajoute contact:instagram tout cela pour la même page.

et quel lien entre les 2, à suivre https://forum.openstreetmap.fr/t/digitaleo-point-ou-point-vert/26572
Digitaleo (2026-04-03 14:50:20+00:00): Bonjour et merci beaucoup pour vos retours .

Sur le lien entre  et  : solution_visibilite était un prestataire externe qui avait la charge de publier les données de nos points de vente sur OpenStreetMap pour le compte de Digitaleo. Nous avons depuis développé notre propre solution en interne, et c’est donc désormais le compte  qui publie directement les modifications de nos clients sur OSM.

Sur notre système : Notre outil est en phase de rodage. On est pleinement conscients que contribuer à OSM implique de respecter les conventions et pratiques de la communauté, et vos retours sont précieux pour nous améliorer concrètement.

Le champ website contenant des liens Instagram : je vais modifier notre système pour que les liens de réseaux sociaux soient envoyés dans les champs contact:* appropriés (contact:instagram, etc.) et non dans website.

Je vais aussi faire un retour sur le forum mais mon compte a été provisoirement restreint
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 15:00:52+00:00): merci pour vos retours.

Effectivement le forum est sans doute préférable pour les échanges !
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-02 14:42:14+00:00): Bonjour,
il est plutôt d'usage sur les commerces de maintenir les contact: pour les adresses quand cela existe, rarement de remplacer comme vous l'avez fait.

je pense qu'il serait aussi intéressant de savoir d'où proviennent vos informations ? 

et dans le cas de contributions organisées comme vous faites, une bonne pratique est de présenter le travail https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Organised_Editing/Guidelines

Bonne cartographie

Hello,

It is generally standard practice for businesses to keep contact details as they are – using existing addresses where available – rather than replacing them as you have done.

I think it would also be useful to know where you obtained your information.

And when organising contributions in the way you have done, it is good practice to present the work https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Organised_Editing/Guidelines

Happy mapping,
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-02 14:46:13+00:00): le lien avec le commentaire de @syl https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/179574859
Digitaleo (2026-04-02 15:43:27+00:00): Bonjour, et merci pour le retour !

Vous avez raison concernant le remplacement des tags contact:* par addr:* notre intention n'était pas de supprimer des informations existantes mais bien de compléter la fiche. 

Concernant vos questions, notre page profil détaille notre fonctionnement : https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/Digitaleo

En résumé : Digitaleo est une plateforme SaaS de gestion de présence en ligne. Lorsqu'un commerçant met à jour ses informations (adresse, horaires, téléphone, moyens de paiement…) sur notre plateforme, les modifications sont publiées vers OSM via l'API. Chaque édition correspond à une action utilisateur réelle ce n'est pas un bot autonome.

Il faut que je crée une page dans https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Organised_Editing/Activities pour expliquer également nos activités ?
LySioS (2026-04-02 17:59:40+00:00): Bonjour et bienvenu !

En effet, le passage wiki est obligatoire pour laisser une trace accessible à tout le monde, cette discussion ici reste somme toute assez confidentielle.

Concernant le commerce, comme il est en plus patissier et chocolatier, il faut rajouter :
pastry=yes
chocolate=yes

Bonne continuation
Digitaleo (2026-04-03 07:40:17+00:00): La page est créée : https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Organised_Editing/Activities/Digitaleo

Je regarde si, à partir des informations que nous fournit le client, nous pouvons ajouter cette information.
Vinber-Pro (2026-04-03 08:06:43+00:00): bonjour, merci d'avoir répondu.

il y a vraisemblablement l'ensemble des modifications à reprendre concernant les adresses, cela semble être régulier l'écrasement.

de plus cela vous a été déjà signalé https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/180770734#map=19/43.210061/2.442848

Bonne journée
eggie (2026-04-02 14:44:53+00:00): Dag AD,

Wat bedoel je met overige bewerkingen?
Graag concreet commentaar bij je uploads.
Tip.. Houd ook het gebied van je edits klein.
Mvg,
eggie
eggie (2026-04-02 14:50:58+00:00): Je hebt van een fietspad een pad gemaakt, maar alle eigenschappen van een G13 erop laten staan.
Kijk je nog even?
Je edit https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-change-viz?c=180771215#17/52.08562/6.15487
eggie (2026-04-02 14:52:29+00:00): (Fiets)Doorsteken in wijken zijn eerder highway=path dan highway=footway. Die laatste routeren niet voor fietsers. 
Een footway heeft een G7 bord. Zijn dit wel echt footway's?
無限の刃 (2026-05-20 09:25:12+00:00): >Remember that things may have changed since the photographs were taken; we are trying to map what is there now and not when the photographs were taken.
osm.wiki/Beginners_Guide_1.1.2

>Things change. Imagery gets old. Road layouts change. Buildings get knocked down and rebuilt in different places. Imagery can be many years old. Armchair mapping involves blindly copying this information but in an area where locals have contributed, you should be very careful about this. Look out for tell-tale signs. If the whole area has building outlines drawn in, and you see just one missing, or one drawn in completely the wrong shape, don't just "fix" it. Alarm bells should be ringing.
osm.wiki/Armchair_mapping

Do not edit random place by aerial imageries.

You can check Esri aerial imagery to check construction.
geomaniX (2026-04-08 13:57:52+00:00): Moin und Willkommen bei OSM!

Kurzer Hinweis zu der Hausnummer: Als Trenner bei mehreren Hausnummern wird entweder ein Semikolon ; oder ein Komma , verwendet, siehe auch: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Adressen

Ein abschließender Konsens ob Semikolon oder Komma "richtig" ist, besteht nicht. Das Semikolon ist allerdings der Standardtrenner für alle anderen Aufzählungen. 
Korrekt wäre hier also "24;26" oder "24,26".

VG
geomaniX
vtrtsxlegend (2026-04-13 19:26:26+00:00): Hi UserMap321, I see that you added Alte B13 as the road name to way 52027375.  Can you please share what source you used? Thank you
UserMap321 (2026-04-13 20:25:15+00:00): Hi, i named it based on what it is called here, tough it may be not the "true" name (you may correct me).
I went a bit digging to find a more factually based source for that. Found it at the Bayernatlas (mapping portal of the state of bavaria): It was the old offical route of the Bundesstraße until about 1983 (not too long ago there was even an old yellow signpost at the crossing with Ingolstädter Str). 
https://atlas.bayern.de/?c=680445,5398875&z=16&r=0&l=atkis,zeitreihe_tk&l_o=1,0.75&l_t=,1983&mid=1

Tough i noticed that i did a mistake on the number: It should have been 16, not 13 (the Bundesstraße this road leads to). My mistake, confused that. I will correct it shortly.
vtrtsxlegend (2026-04-19 14:43:35+00:00): Hi Usermap321,  thanks for getting back to me.  Thanks for sharing the history of your edit nd the source.  I think m it is supposed to be 13 as well.

 Cheers
marczoutendijk (2026-04-10 17:36:44+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 181160507 where the changeset comment is: DWG revert for vandalism and bad changeset comments
eggie (2026-04-02 15:12:32+00:00): Welkom bij OSM,

De info heb ik verplaatst naar de adresnode.

MVG
eggie