piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
zstadler (2023-02-18 13:40:53+00:00): Dear Rawad,

The Israeli community does a lot of OSM mapping and quality improvements in the west bank. This community has noticed this improper import within a day of its start.
I encourage you to put aside the complex middle-eastern politics and leverage the knowledge and expertise of the OSM Israel community.
Rawad (2023-02-18 14:24:25+00:00): Dear Zstadler,

But this does not mean that in order to update Palestine data we need to get back to this community! 
We can do our own community and work to update our map.
By the way this change is is for my house if I want to update it I have to get back to this community!
zstadler (2023-02-18 14:47:54+00:00): Good Luck!
habi (2023-02-18 19:23:56+00:00): Rawad, as I’m living in middle Europe I know far to less to comment anything about politics; I just saw that your import here is completely wrong in regards to how the complete OSM community everywhere maps buildings.
You introduce undocumented key/value combinations like status=P, type=V, model= connect.building.
Other keys like number_of_apartments are modeled as `building:flats` in OSM. 
area_m2 Is completely useless, as it can be calculated from the data.
Additionally you simply dumped your data over already existing data, essentially duplicating already present data (albeit with worse geometry).

What’s the source of your data; is OpenStreetMap legally allowed to globally provide it under the ODBL?

It is these things that struck my eye, not where on the globe they happened!
Rawad (2023-02-19 12:10:22+00:00): Habi, thanks for your feedback, well the source of data is an official website for postal codes and building from the ministry of telecommunication in Palestine https://postcode.palestine.ps/
Regarding the undocumented tags I will fix it this is wrong data export.
Meanwhile the layers for buildings on OSM and postal codes for my area are really weak and wrong as it is since it is not accurate and not fully at all and the aim from this bulk import is to have a clear official free data on OSM so that everyone in Palestine can use this data.
Meanwhile it will be great if you help us in enriching our map and having it enhanced.
Also as I know OSM is an open platform made to enhance maps all around the world and that's why I relay on it in all my apps so it the ability to update it must be supported from all parties and users.
habi (2023-02-19 16:40:12+00:00): > the source of data is an official website for postal codes and building from the ministry of telecommunication in Palestine

- Are you allowed to import this data in OSM? Freely available data is not necessarily data that OpenStreetMap is allowed to redistribute globally.
- Did you follow the import guidelines specified here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Import
- Did you document this import somewhere?
- Did you discuss this with the (local) community?
- Are you taking care to conflate this data with already present buildings?

If all these questions are answered with yes, then we would not have this discussion *here*.
Rawad (2023-02-19 17:29:50+00:00): Well I'm the owner of the data and the one who is responsible for it and I have the right to redistribute it
Unfortunately there is no official community for Palestine but I'm working to have one in osm 
And yes for all other questions and I will work to have all data in the right way without going with this discussion with you and with others 😉
habi (2023-02-19 17:41:06+00:00): > Well I'm the owner of the data and the one who is responsible for it and I have the right to redistribute it

Cool, then you can easily document this on the OSM Wiki officially, which is the first step for an import!
Dennis Kjær Jensen (2023-02-14 14:13:56+00:00): Hjerm Østre kirke - not Hjerm Vestre Kirke
Fizzie-DWG (2023-03-05 05:21:13+00:00): Reverted by DWG as personal information given: changeset/133313122
Rawad (2023-03-05 19:57:22+00:00): This is my house and I want it to be on the map what is you problem with that!
Fizzie-DWG (2023-03-06 03:11:23+00:00): It is OSM policy that personal names on private residences are not shown on the map.
Frans S (2023-02-14 14:47:56+00:00): Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please square each rectangular building with the Q key. You missed 19 out of 58 .
Best regards
Robin Bourgeon (2023-04-09 08:53:42+00:00): La classification highway=trunk, en France, ne correspond-elle pas à la présence d'un panneau C107 ? Il ne me semble pas que ce soit le cas pour la nationale 10 entre Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines et Rambouillet.
AurélienQ (2023-04-09 14:33:35+00:00): Oui et non. En fait pour plus d'info tu peux aller voir ici : https://forum.openstreetmap.fr/t/definition-des-routes-en-highway-trunk/12769 
C'est une discussion sur la définition des routes trunk en France, et la conclusion c'est que c'est impossible de mettre une limite précise entre trunk et primary.
En l'occurrence cette route est rapide (avec un maxspeed généralement autour de 110km/h), possède un terre plein central, des BAU, comme seul type d'intersection des brettelles, et enfin une interdiction d'accès aux circulations "douces". De fait ces critères sont proches des routes au panneau C107. 
Mais vous me faites remarquer que la section environnant Les Essarts-le-Roi ne correspond pas à ces critères...
Peut-être faudrait-il rectifier cette section ? 
En tous cas la majorité de cette route doit, a mon avis, être considérée comme trunk. 
Franchement, après la discussion que j'ai eut (dont je vous ai passé le lien ci-dessus), je n'intervient plus dans la classification de routes, car cela est pour moi une chose beaucoup trop floue. Donc faites ce que vous pensez être bien.
Niels Elgaard Larsen (2023-02-21 15:20:35+00:00): Hedder den virkelig Hesselballe Bæl
og ikke bæk?
b-holdet (2023-02-21 17:20:26+00:00): Nej da :-)
Jeg har nu rettet det i følge SDFI Stednavne
mavl (2023-02-15 04:37:30+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 132563159 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: poog mapping - https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/6861].
pyram (2023-02-26 08:35:36+00:00): Hallo chaosbauer13,

leider muss ich Dich dringend darauf hinweisen, dass für OSM derzeit der Bayernatlas (noch) keine zulässige Quelle ist. Aus Lizenzgründen ist es daher unverzichtbar, alle von dort übernommenen Daten wieder zu löschen. Machst Du das bitte selber?

Gruß
pyram
chaosbauer13 (2023-02-26 16:57:21+00:00): Änderung sollte rückgängig gemacht sein (ist das erste Mal, dass ich das mache).
Ich bin derzeit der Suche nach besseren Quellen.
Gäbe es eine Möglichkeit die Änderungen dann wieder einzuspielen?
pyram (2023-02-26 20:30:21+00:00): Danke.
In Bayern gibt es derzeit keine mir bekannte legale Quelle. Auch deshalb fehlt noch vieles.
Theoretisch kann man Änderungsdatensätze auch wieder herstellen. (Streng genommen müsste man diese Adressen aber "redacten" - also unwiederherstellbar löschen. Wegen der hier wenigen Datensätze wird das aber eher nicht gemacht werden).
Ein wichtiges Ziel von OSM ist, das abzubilden, was tatsächlich vor Ort ist...
Also: Raus an die frische Luft ;-)
trial (2023-02-21 20:22:02+00:00): Bonjour, et bienvenu dans OpenStreetMap.
J'annule votre modification en effet :
- Maison n'est pas un nom propre
- les autres modifications sont inutiles.
En effet : 
- le 70 fait partie de la rue, inutile de l'indiquer une seconde fois (qui plus est de manière erronée : Kerulvé s'écrit avec une majuscule et un accent).
- la position du point implique que ce bâti se trouve à Lorient, https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/30305
- le fait que ce soit à Lorient implique que le code postal soit 56100 (toujours indiqué par https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/30305).
Frans S (2023-02-14 15:15:21+00:00): Hello. Thanks for mapping on this project.
Please read this wiki where and how to tag highways.
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Highways
Tracks are not used in settlements / villages.
Tag residential are to be used in urban areas, not on small settlements like here.
You connected lots of buildings to each other with the nodes. Each building need to be mapped as a single building and squared with the Q key.
There are still buildings to be mapped.
Best regards
map per (2023-02-14 17:11:53+00:00): Hallo CarstenM,

ich kenn mich nicht so gut mit Bus Routen aus aber an irgendeiner Stelle der Bushaltestelle sollte doch schon highway=busstop stehen oder? Bei (1) steht das jetzt an keinem Punkt mehr.

Viele Grüße
map per

(1) https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/873500978
map per (2023-02-22 15:12:52+00:00): Bitte die Frage nicht vergessen

Viele Grüße
map per
map per (2023-02-27 12:14:59+00:00): Hallo CarstenM,

danke für die Antwort in der PM.

Ich hab noch mal ToniE gefragt, der sich gut mit ÖPNV Mapping auskennt.

Es gibt keinen Konsens und es ist auch nicht üblich highway=bus_stop zu löschen. Der Tag sollte für die Rückwärtskompatibilität weiterhin getagged werden, da z.B. die OSM "Standardkarte" (OSM Carto) nur highway=bus_stop unterstützt.

Und auch im angeführten Probosal für Public Transport Version 2 (1) steht im Abschnitt Compatibility das well known Tags wie bus_stop nicht ersetzt werden.

Ich würde vorschlagen bei den Bushaltestellen highway=bus_stop wieder hinzuzfügen.

Danke und viele Grüße
map per


(1) https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Proposed_features/Public_Transport&oldid=625726#Compatibility_with_well_known_tags
map per (2023-04-15 11:27:29+00:00): Hallo CarstenM,

ich bin jetzt noch mal alle deine Änderungen der letzten Monate durchgegangen und hab alle highway=bus_stop und highway=platform Fehler korrigiert (war viel Arbeit). Sei doch bitte in Zukunft beim Löschen von Tags (auch bei maxheight und shelter) vorsichtiger.

Danke und viele Grüße
map per
Hufkratzer (2023-02-15 20:52:24+00:00): Hi,
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1145167730 is probably not a horse racecourse but a riding arena, see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:leisure=pitch#Riding_arena
NorthCrab_upload (2023-02-14 15:20:23+00:00): 🗺️ Witaj na OpenStreetMap!

Zauważyłem, że Twoja zmiana zawiera niepoprawne adresy. Przygotowałem listę obiektów do poprawy oraz dodatkowe informacje:

Duplikat adresu w okolicy. Adres można oznaczyć na dwa sposoby: na obszarze (dokładniejsze) albo na punkcie. Aktualizując adres, należy się upewnić, czy w okolicy nie pozostały żadne duplikaty.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1940976061
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/152330134

Dokumentacja adresów (po polsku):
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pl:Key:addr:*

W razie problemów lub pytań, proszę pisać. Chętnie pomogę.
Pozdrawiam! 🦀
NorthCrab (2023-02-15 09:47:38+00:00): Już poprawiłem zduplikowaną informację, pozdrawiam!
Carto'Cité (2023-04-06 07:02:32+00:00): Bonjour EUMapper,
Merci pour tes améliorations sur les pistes cyclables sur ce secteur :
https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=20/49.21250/-1.53534&layers=Y
J'ai vu effectivement sur l'ortho express 2022 que la traversée cyclable était plus à l'ouest maintenant : 
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1160127476
Je me suis permis de faire le découpage des traversées (cycleway=crossing) pour améliorer la précision des « vraies » portions de piste en les distinguant des traversées ; c'est une pratique de plus en plus courante qui a pas mal d'intérêt.
N’hésite pas à me contacter si tu as la moindre question ou remarque.
Charles de Carto’Cité pour #VeloNormandie
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:11:55+00:00): Which "this area" are you referring to? Your changeset covers most of Atlantic Ocean and Africa.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132542422
hagent (2023-02-16 04:42:43+00:00): Not sure how this happened.  My other edits appear as small rectangles as expected.  How can I correct this? How do I avoid this in the future?
MxxCon (2023-02-16 04:47:40+00:00): Avoid this by making sure that you submit your changes grouped in small geographic areas, such as neighborhoods, cities, counties or states at most.

You fix this by changing a street that you turned into a powerline, back into street https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/597061696/history
MxxCon (2023-02-16 04:48:43+00:00): Sorry, this is the correct link https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/597061696
hagent (2023-02-16 05:14:15+00:00): Should be OK now, still not sure how I did this. Don’t recall being anywhere near Johannesburg while I was editing!
Frans S (2023-02-20 11:23:30+00:00): Hello. Thanks for mapping on this project.  
Each building needs to be mapped individually. Please don't cluster them.
Best regards and keep mapping
axi (2023-02-14 15:32:24+00:00): had a conflict on a road, not sure I solve it well (sorry)
Mahdi Nameghi (2023-02-15 06:31:49+00:00): دوست عزیز
اسم های معابر روی نقشه باید چیزی که روی تابلو ها هست باشد. لطفا این نامها رو در تگ loc-name استفاده کنید
marczoutendijk (2023-02-15 08:38:08+00:00): All your comments are: "this is true".
That is not very helpful to other mappers. Pleas read this:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Can you start using better comments?

Marc Zoutendijk  
OpenStreetMap Foundation  
Data Working Group
illogict (2026-06-22 08:41:04+00:00): Cette section n’est PAS une voie express. Il y a des panneaux de fin de route pour automobile à son entrée comme rappelé dans les modifications 91008824.
AurélienQ (2026-06-22 17:46:46+00:00): Bonjour,

Il n'y a aucune réglementation française qui définit ce qu'est une voie express, et encore moins de règle unique sur OSM.

Si les panneaux auxquels tu fais référence sont les panneaux de "routes pour automobile" (C107), sur OSM on cartographie ça avec le tag motorroad=yes/no

Le seul consensus (dans la communauté OSM France) c'est qu'un highway=trunk correspond à une route ayant des caractéristiques proche de celle d'une autoroute (2x2 voies min, vitesse élevée, croisements dénivelés,...).
Par contre aucun consensus précis, notamment à cause de ce panneau C107 qui ne correspond pas à toutes les voies rapides de France.

Je reste à ta disposition pour de plus ample informations (liens vers le wiki, débats sur le forum menant au consensus,...).

Bonne journée,
Aurélien
literan (2023-02-14 20:51:32+00:00): похоже, маршрут поломали: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/1186671
Bobropiton (2023-02-15 13:54:10+00:00): Пожалуйста, прекращайте использовать бинг карты и править по ним пути. В городах выбирайте подложку от максара, за пределами городов используйте Есри!
Bobropiton (2023-02-15 13:56:11+00:00): Желательно, при этом использовать JOSM :)
Leo Slager (2023-02-14 17:44:05+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privébericht.
Sylvain M (2023-03-15 08:18:43+00:00): Salut La Voie de la Raison :-)
Je voulais te signaler que tu as passé ce chemin [https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/35337987] en trunk, alors qu'il a un tag note="Pas Trunk , pas de panneau C107".
Je ne suis pas très calé en trunk / C107, mais je te laisse voir s'il faut supprimer la note ou modifier la valeur de highway ?
AurélienQ (2023-03-15 10:40:58+00:00): Alors 😅 :
Vas voir sur le https://forum.openstreetmap.fr/
car, c'est un sujet qui n'a actuellement pas de consensus, qui fait toujours débat, qui n'est pas documenté, ... en bref, un sujet très compliqué.
Franchement j'en ai mare de ces débats, fais ce que tu veux, tant pis si on n'a pas de coordination sur le sujet en France. Ce qui fait perdre énormément de temps à énormément de contributeurs.
Je préfère contribuer ailleurs et ne plus m'en occuper.
Leo Slager (2023-02-14 18:11:06+00:00): Dag ydmr,
De adressen staan nu dubbel op de kaart en dat zorgt voor een foutmelding bij de validatie.
Op de ingangen is het huisnummer aanwezig als ref=xxxx
Dat is voldoende. Het complete adres is als een aparte adresnode aanwezig op de kaart en wordt altijd rechtstreeks geïmporteerd vanuit de BAG van het Kadaster.
ik zal de zaak even herstellen.

Veel plezier met verder mappen.
Rps333 (2023-06-03 21:08:34+00:00): this is not Kichi Sibi station https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1145188988#map=18/45.39351/-75.75764

It is https://devapps.ottawa.ca/en/applications/D01-01-20-0013/details
Nakaner (2023-02-16 18:09:52+00:00): Hallo,

seit wann hat Lüdenscheid ein Spurbus-System? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1145190186

Meintest du vielleicht highway=busway?

Ist die Übersetzung des Tags in den Presets von Go Map!! vielleicht verbesserungswürdig?

Viele Grüße

Michael
Mazda05 (2023-02-14 19:31:02+00:00): https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Russian–Ukrainian_war
GerdP (2023-02-14 16:16:53+00:00): ... und falschen Namen "SteinZeitspuren-Route" nach ""SteinZeitspuren-Tour" korrigiert.
luca sski (2023-02-14 21:44:00+00:00): I don't think this hotel exists, at least it's not listed here: https://www.hotel-bb.com/de/stadt/hotels-duesseldorf
Frans S (2023-02-24 16:53:50+00:00): Thanks for your contribution to this project.
This changeset is reviewed by a Global Validator, during the validation process
I noticed that you are a new mapper. Welcome to HOTOSM.
We cannot expect that you are already familiar with all issues around mapping. therefore, I inform you about the most issues,

Please pay attention to next points:
Buildings are in general rather rectangular. just 4, 6 or 8 nodes are sufficient.
Each rectangular building need to be squared. !! 
Nodes of buildings may not connect to other buildings or features.
The shadow of a building is not a part of the building. 
Do not cluster buildings. Each building need to be mapped individually.





Explanation can be found on this document what  might be helpful to improve your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit


Best regards and keep mapping !
Frans S
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545043
NorthCrab_upload (2023-02-14 16:40:22+00:00): Zauważyłem, że Twoja zmiana zawiera niepoprawne adresy. Przygotowałem listę obiektów do poprawy oraz dodatkowe informacje:

Adres jest niekompletny, brakuje informacji o nazwie ulicy.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1063571024

Pozdrawiam! 🦀
lokalson (2023-02-14 17:01:31+00:00): Numer został nadany wczoraj. Mam nawet pismo.
lokalson (2023-02-14 17:02:21+00:00): Tam nie ma nazwy ulicy, jest taki sam jak nazwa miejscowości czyli Wierzbanowa.
NorthCrab (2023-02-15 05:48:28+00:00): Witaj, adresy bez ulic oznaczamy zatem jako addr:place - a nie addr:city. Już poprawiłem :-). Pozdrawiam!
Myazyk (2024-04-03 20:05:03+00:00): Мені здається, що стоматологія "Усмішка" є на вул. Мазепи, 24
VictorIE (2026-06-05 06:46:23+00:00): Hi,

https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/298410089/

The eastern end of this looks more 'road' than 'track'.
ramthelinefeed (2026-06-05 09:14:19+00:00): well, if you look on https://dfi-ni.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=f8a42fc35a3d48788e651a1d47865ce1 you'll it's not one of the DfI's 'adopted roads', so public access is for walkers only (it's PRoW) - it's not tarmaced, it's just a load of gravel.   Kind of a moot point, really?
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:42:16+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545343
ovruni (2023-02-15 05:09:17+00:00): Hola, no existe las etiquetas como "fuel:84_octanos" o "fuel:90_octanos", por favor revise en la wiki las etiquetas relacionadas con las grifos.  https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dfuel
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:43:03+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545456
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:44:07+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545492
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:44:12+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545549
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:44:31+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545600
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:44:37+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545649
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:44:44+00:00): Hello.
Please note that this feature is already mapped in OSM. The fact that you mapped it again goes against https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element guideline. As such this edit is going to be reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132545695
Mashin (2023-02-14 19:06:32+00:00): Hi and welcome to OSM!
Just a small tip, when you finish drawing a building outline press "Q" and this will adjust all angles to 90˚. Buildings then look nicer.
Cheers
PovilasDew (2023-03-29 23:43:10+00:00): Jau sudėjo dviračių takų kontūrus palei Lukšio g.
Ten jau tikrai bus dviračių takas. Galima būtų gražinti buvusį mano pakeitimą.
Aišku palei Žemkalnio g. liks paprastas šalgatvis, ten berods nieko nerausė.
ygcgjp5 (2023-03-30 09:00:17+00:00): čia dėl to Žemkalnio kampuko? Aš maniau ten iš senų laikų klaida, jeigu ten pakeitimas pagal dabartinį projektą, tai susipainiojau.
PovilasDew (2023-03-30 22:43:54+00:00): taip,
esu lyg keitęs, bet atgal grįždavo, tik jau nepamenu ar 1 ar 2 kartus taip.
SekeRob (2023-02-14 16:56:33+00:00): More work needs done on the forest relation https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/10962910 to resolve more areas with forest rendering through scrub and agricultural lands.
wolfbert (2023-07-20 06:55:34+00:00): addr:place wird nur gesetzt, wenn es keine addr:street gibt. addr:state wird in Österreich gar nicht verwendet.
Baloo Uriza (2023-02-16 01:03:13+00:00): This is kind of a large area to edit in one go, especially with little to go on in the change comment.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132546022
MxxCon (2023-02-16 02:36:33+00:00): Hello.
Please note that all tag values in OSM must be in lower case (there are a few exceptions, such as names).
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/132546037