piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 19:27:51+00:00): 1- According to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_practice, your statement applies to tents, not buildings. And my registrations are for buildings, so they are not temporary. It may be considered as abandoned, but you should not delete it because every complication is fixed on the ground and must be recorded.
2- I fully explained about this in the previous note. Your work is wrong and every user can add names to other languages after the main language.
3- My mapping is not imaginary. As I said, I will use documentary images to prove that your claim is false.
End this discussion.
entire
Frans S (2023-09-06 15:04:33+00:00): Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please do not add a layer to a building to hide an error. Just solve the issue.
Best regards and keep mapping
BCNorwich (2023-08-02 07:45:46+00:00): Hi, 
Please look here to see the many duplicated sections of path you've made:- https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=routing&lon=43.39595&lat=14.55690&zoom=16&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=duplicated_edges%2Cduplicated_edges%2Cduplicated_edges_areas

All the dark blue lines are your duplicated highways. Could you please correct your mapping and cease to duplicate highways in this manner?

Thanks.
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:51:53+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 139255358 where the changeset comment is: Revert problematic edits of foreign user 'ChehrehBargi' in Iraq, user did the same problematic edits before and told to not repeat such behaver, he also complained in a foreign telegram group and was told to not do such things.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:12:38+00:00): You keep ruining my edits. Here is a building that I have registered according to the writings on the board above the building. You are not allowed to do this. I have already registered here. And you deleted it again. I have not talked to you in Telegram groups. I have explained to you below these notes, but you have continued your work.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:14:58+00:00): I have seen this way firsthand. For the part that I specified, the car can pass. You have deleted my registration and replaced your data.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:16:44+00:00): The above text is related to note 139253414, which is the path leading to this place.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 10:27:52+00:00): ChehrehBargi, You did the same problematic edits 1 year ago, We, the Iraqi OSM community contacted you, me and other Iraqis, even local ones to this area like Nawfal85, and we asked you to stop this type of edit, you are welcome to edit whatever if it's not harmful and not political and have a religious agenda. And you tried to explain yourself and give examples and names of those who are on the International terrorist list and called them heroes! We asked you to come to OSM Iraq, our local OSM community to discuss if you disagree, you refused and went to a foreign to discuss this, you went to "OSM Iran" and the admins and other members there told you that you are wrong, and should stop doing these types of edits in their country. 3 Days ago you came back with the same type of problematic edits, adding the Iranian general name to our map, and doing the same type of edits. I reverted them all and announced it in our local Iraqi community group.
Any future edits in Iraq you make with political, religious, and provocative will be reverted period.   
Stop.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 12:00:06+00:00): You deleted my registrations 1 year ago without being able to give me a convincing reason. My registration numbers in those years until now are 139253611 - 139253536 - 139253429 - 139253414 - 139253317 - 139252965 - 139249148 - 126535042 - 126534584 - 126490195 - 1 26490129 - 126489098 - 126488377 - 126487173 - 126486938 - 126486726 - 126486709 - 126404473 - 126403896
This is a building and according to wiki rules any complication on the ground can be recorded. It is not necessary to bring the document here to be registered. The name is also written on the top of the building. So it can be added to the map.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 14:15:26+00:00): If you want to know and understand why your political, religious, and provocative edits are not ok and not acceptable in Iraq, please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram and ask for you to understand.        
I suggest to keep your edits in areas that are local or known to you. It is not forbidden to edit globally, I recommend it actually, but it should not be against local communities will, and should not commit such acts.  
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 14:57:34+00:00): Your work is against the rules and you should understand that, not me.
Here is a complication and I have registered it. Your deletion is incorrect.
Keith W Robertson (2023-08-02 05:38:08+00:00): Hi Gruff. Noticed you’d updated the path I created a while ago. Great it’s now officially open :-) I walked ½ of it on Saturday and corrected my original plot to reflect reality. I assumed the rest of it was to be finished. But looks like what’s there is what we get!

Just curious why OSM lists you as the creator, as I did the original plot ?? Not that is really important I guess? 

Cheers, Keith
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:51:47+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 139255358 where the changeset comment is: Revert problematic edits of foreign user 'ChehrehBargi' in Iraq, user did the same problematic edits before and told to not repeat such behaver, he also complained in a foreign telegram group and was told to not do such things.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:15:11+00:00): I have seen this way firsthand. For the part that I specified, the car can pass. You have deleted my registration and replaced your data.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 10:27:58+00:00): ChehrehBargi, You did the same problematic edits 1 year ago, We, the Iraqi OSM community contacted you, me and other Iraqis, even local ones to this area like Nawfal85, and we asked you to stop this type of edit, you are welcome to edit whatever if it's not harmful and not political and have a religious agenda. And you tried to explain yourself and give examples and names of those who are on the International terrorist list and called them heroes! We asked you to come to OSM Iraq, our local OSM community to discuss if you disagree, you refused and went to a foreign to discuss this, you went to "OSM Iran" and the admins and other members there told you that you are wrong, and should stop doing these types of edits in their country. 3 Days ago you came back with the same type of problematic edits, adding the Iranian general name to our map, and doing the same type of edits. I reverted them all and announced it in our local Iraqi community group.
Any future edits in Iraq you make with political, religious, and provocative will be reverted period.   
Stop.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 11:17:07+00:00): In political matters, some disagreed with you and some agreed. Do not extend your personal opinion to the whole community. Anyway, the map is not a good place for political factions. We spend time and precious time to improve the map. We have a duty to record every complication that exists. We better respect each other. Why are you wasting my efforts?
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 11:38:33+00:00): You didn't even spare this edit. While the part that I have registered as a car. I have seen it closely. And they were passing by those cars.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 14:15:32+00:00): If you want to know and understand why your political, religious, and provocative edits are not ok and not acceptable in Iraq, please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram and ask for you to understand.        
I suggest to keep your edits in areas that are local or known to you. It is not forbidden to edit globally, I recommend it actually, but it should not be against local communities will, and should not commit such acts.  
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 15:01:26+00:00): I mentioned in the previous note, my editing is according to the general rules of osm. I have made it very clear that it is not political. You deliberately want to express it in a different way. Anyway, if someone sees impartially, he will understand.
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:51:40+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 139255358 where the changeset comment is: Revert problematic edits of foreign user 'ChehrehBargi' in Iraq, user did the same problematic edits before and told to not repeat such behaver, he also complained in a foreign telegram group and was told to not do such things.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 09:46:34+00:00): You already ruined my edits. I have also reported your work. The general rules of the osm wiki must be followed everywhere.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 09:50:41+00:00): You have also touched my other edits. Any complication can be recorded in the wiki. But you completely delete my records. And according to the law, you do not have this right.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 09:53:57+00:00): The registration I had made here was to add the name here in Farsi and change the type of building here because it is the grave of a prophet.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 10:28:03+00:00): ChehrehBargi, You did the same problematic edits 1 year ago, We, the Iraqi OSM community contacted you, me and other Iraqis, even local ones to this area like Nawfal85, and we asked you to stop this type of edit, you are welcome to edit whatever if it's not harmful and not political and have a religious agenda. And you tried to explain yourself and give examples and names of those who are on the International terrorist list and called them heroes! We asked you to come to OSM Iraq, our local OSM community to discuss if you disagree, you refused and went to a foreign to discuss this, you went to "OSM Iran" and the admins and other members there told you that you are wrong, and should stop doing these types of edits in their country. 3 Days ago you came back with the same type of problematic edits, adding the Iranian general name to our map, and doing the same type of edits. I reverted them all and announced it in our local Iraqi community group.
Any future edits in Iraq you make with political, religious, and provocative will be reverted period.   
Stop.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 11:44:19+00:00): Adding another language to the name of a place is provocative or political?
You act as if we are on the battlefield. No, we are two brotherly nations. Our goal in editing the map is to improve it. Please do not include personal matters in this work. Do you have specific local laws? But do not violate the general rules of osm. Because you are not allowed to do this.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 14:15:38+00:00): If you want to know and understand why your political, religious, and provocative edits are not ok and not acceptable in Iraq, please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram and ask for you to understand.        
I suggest to keep your edits in areas that are local or known to you. It is not forbidden to edit globally, I recommend it actually, but it should not be against local communities will, and should not commit such acts.  
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 14:50:57+00:00): You insist on making my edit political when it is not. The rules according to which I have edited are very clear and specific.
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:34:21+00:00): Hello, what is your source? Is there a sign in that language at the location?
Regards.
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:51:35+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 139255358 where the changeset comment is: Revert problematic edits of foreign user 'ChehrehBargi' in Iraq, user did the same problematic edits before and told to not repeat such behaver, he also complained in a foreign telegram group and was told to not do such things.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:20:25+00:00): The existence of a board for the main name is required. The name of a place in other languages, if it does not interfere with the original name, does not need a sign and can be added to all languages.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:20:58+00:00): My changes were not wrong and I do according to the registration rules.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 10:28:06+00:00): ChehrehBargi, You did the same problematic edits 1 year ago, We, the Iraqi OSM community contacted you, me and other Iraqis, even local ones to this area like Nawfal85, and we asked you to stop this type of edit, you are welcome to edit whatever if it's not harmful and not political and have a religious agenda. And you tried to explain yourself and give examples and names of those who are on the International terrorist list and called them heroes! We asked you to come to OSM Iraq, our local OSM community to discuss if you disagree, you refused and went to a foreign to discuss this, you went to "OSM Iran" and the admins and other members there told you that you are wrong, and should stop doing these types of edits in their country. 3 Days ago you came back with the same type of problematic edits, adding the Iranian general name to our map, and doing the same type of edits. I reverted them all and announced it in our local Iraqi community group.
Any future edits in Iraq you make with political, religious, and provocative will be reverted period.   
Stop.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 11:01:52+00:00): Again, I have to say that my records were not subversive. Tell me if my registration is against the wiki rules or against your opinions? In the Iraqi society, some were against you and some were in agreement. Does adding names in other languages bother you? When the name of a place is registered in different languages. It shows its popularity. Is it necessary to install a board in all languages in order to register a place in other languages? This is really ridiculous..
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 14:15:42+00:00): If you want to know and understand why your political, religious, and provocative edits are not ok and not acceptable in Iraq, please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram and ask for you to understand.        
I suggest to keep your edits in areas that are local or known to you. It is not forbidden to edit globally, I recommend it actually, but it should not be against local communities will, and should not commit such acts.  
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 15:06:33+00:00): What is your purpose of spamming? You send a duplicate note for all my notes. The name I have added here in other languages is correct and removing you is definitely vandalism. You cannot prevent me from registering a public place name in other languages because this permission is issued by osm.
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:31:02+00:00): Hello, what is your source? Is there a sign in that language in the street? 
Regards.
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:51:18+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 139255358 where the changeset comment is: Revert problematic edits of foreign user 'ChehrehBargi' in Iraq, user did the same problematic edits before and told to not repeat such behaver, he also complained in a foreign telegram group and was told to not do such things.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 09:57:16+00:00): Hello
To add a name to the original language, it must be tabula. There is nothing wrong with adding other languages if it gives the meaning of the original name in the board and it is not against the wiki rules.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 09:59:33+00:00): I have not received a message in the foreign Telegram group. Meanwhile, there is no problem with my editing. It is not difficult to add the name of a street in other languages. Rather, there is a problem with your work.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 10:28:11+00:00): ChehrehBargi, You did the same problematic edits 1 year ago, We, the Iraqi OSM community contacted you, me and other Iraqis, even local ones to this area like Nawfal85, and we asked you to stop this type of edit, you are welcome to edit whatever if it's not harmful and not political and have a religious agenda. And you tried to explain yourself and give examples and names of those who are on the International terrorist list and called them heroes! We asked you to come to OSM Iraq, our local OSM community to discuss if you disagree, you refused and went to a foreign to discuss this, you went to "OSM Iran" and the admins and other members there told you that you are wrong, and should stop doing these types of edits in their country. 3 Days ago you came back with the same type of problematic edits, adding the Iranian general name to our map, and doing the same type of edits. I reverted them all and announced it in our local Iraqi community group.
Any future edits in Iraq you make with political, religious, and provocative will be reverted period.   
Stop.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:54:55+00:00): I did not justify my actions. In the group of Osmir Iran, people were of the same opinion as me and did not consider my work to be against the rules. In registering osm maps, we have nothing to do with politics. According to OSM rules, any complication can be recorded on the map. Now, if the registration of a tomb is not liked by a certain number of people, it has nothing to do with the map. However, these complications exist on the ground and should be recorded. You need to stop your unnecessary deletions.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 14:15:47+00:00): If you want to know and understand why your political, religious, and provocative edits are not ok and not acceptable in Iraq, please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram and ask for you to understand.        
I suggest to keep your edits in areas that are local or known to you. It is not forbidden to edit globally, I recommend it actually, but it should not be against local communities will, and should not commit such acts.  
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 14:55:02+00:00): Even when I give you a clear example of a specific case, you still insist on turning it upside down. If you read my text correctly, you will understand that there is no prohibition to register the name of the street in another language, but you are blocking it with your personal taste. This is against the rules and goals of osm.
hauke-stieler (2023-09-30 07:46:56+00:00): Hi,

dieser Kommentar gilt stellvertretend für alle deine Changesets hier in Altona, die die historischen Gleise ergänzen.

Zum einen ist das nichts für OpenStreetMap, da nur Objekte von aktueller Relevanz gepflegt werden (siehe dazu [0]). Es gibt aber genau für historische Dinge das Schwesterprojekt OpenHistoricalMap [1]. Da wäre sowas gut aufgehoben.

Unabhängig davon sind die OSM-Ways (also die Schienen) eher ungenau eingetragen und manche Teilstücke auch doppelt.

Ein zweiter Punkt: Die Lizenz der Daten. Du schreibst "Falk-Plan 1945" (auch wenn es nicht unter "source" im Changeset eingetragen ist, was der Standard-Ort für Quellenangaben ist). Ich nehme an das ist ein gedruckter Stadtplan von 1945? Wenn dem so ist: Ist dieser für die Nutzung in OSM freigegeben, bzw. steht er unter einer kompatiblen Lizenz? Normalerweise sind jegliche gedruckten Pläne für OSM aus rechtlichen Gründen nicht nutzbar. Zum Lizenz-Thema siehe auch [2].

Alleine schon wegen den ersten beiden Gründen werde ich die Änderungen bei Zeiten zurück drehen. Wenn die Lizenz passt, kannst du die Sachen aber gerne in OpenHistoricalMap eintragen, da passt das gut hin.

Grüße
Hauke

[0] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Lifecycle_prefix
[1] https://www.openhistoricalmap.org
[2] https://osmfoundation.org/wiki/Licence
NorbertGroth (2023-09-30 16:26:04+00:00): Hallo Hauke,

vielen Dank für deinen Kommentar.

Die Eintragungen sind entfernt, ich hätte es sonst jetzt selber vorgenommen.

Ob und wie die Nutzungsrechte des genannten Falkplans hier oder auch in OpenHistoricalMap gelten, kann und möchte ich nicht beurteilen. Ich werde den Plan nicht weiter nutzen.

Für mich noch kurz zur Orientierung, wie darf ich dich in diesem Zusammenhang bei OSM einordnen?

Grüße
Norbert
hauke-stieler (2023-10-01 09:32:37+00:00): Hi,

also die Daten waren noch da, habe sie eben entfernt. Ways mit railway=abandoned werden nur - wie viele andere Dinge auch - nicht auf der "Hauptkarte" angezeigt (also hier bei openstreetmap.org).

Zur Lizenz:
Ist ein leidiges Thema. Habe im Wiki [0] keine Eintragungen zu Falk und deren Karten gefunden. Heißt also ohne weiteres erst mal: Die sind Tabu. Gilt im Regelfall für alle möglichen Karten die nicht dort im Wiki als "dürfen wir benutzen" eingetragen sind. Das inkludiert leider auch behördliche Daten und Pläne, weswegen man da für jede Gemeinde, Stadt, Land, etc. nachfragen muss ...

Zu mir:
Bin einfach ein aktiver Mapper hier aus Hamburg (ein paar Details gibts auch in meinem OSM-Profil). Immer, wenn ich beim mappen ungewöhnliche Sachen finde, dann schreibe ich auch schon mal die Leute an. So hab ich eben deine Eintragungen mehr oder weniger durch Zufall gefunden.

Grüße
Hauke

[0] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Contributors
emersonveenstra (2023-08-01 10:54:33+00:00): Hi,

For https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1193554171 and https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1193554172, did you mean to make these footways instead of roads?
Dave Nadolsky (2023-08-01 13:45:46+00:00): As originally built maaaany yrs ago, CR638 was an unpaved 2-lane county road. Somewhere in last 10 yrs (maybe 5?), between M68 & US23, 638's been "closed to thru traffic." Of the 2 small bridges in this section, the W bridge was apparently condemned to car traffic. There is a 4-5' tall (man-made) berm just W of the W bridge & similar berm to E, between the bridges. Berms are full road width. Official "road closed to thru traffic" signs are a) W of the W berm & b) E of the E berm. Between M68 & the W berm, plus between the E berm & US23, 638 remains the same old 2-lane unpaved road. There are unpaved driveways off both these car-accessible sections that remain in use. I gravel biked 638 from US23 to M68 last week, but had to walk between berms. A determined walker can scale both berms & walk along the old 638 roadbed between berms, including walking across the condemned bridge (which easily supports a person - and their bike). Given it's been yrs since this section was closed to thru traffic, vegetation here is 3-4' tall & there are some fallen trees, but it's passable on foot (even lugging a bike). As it sits today, there's no way a motorcycle, or 4-wheel vehicle of any kind, could get thru this overgrown section. Hence, I categorized it as a footway. I'm sure the objective plan is to address the bridge when $ becomes available, opening this 638 section to cars again. I'd update openstreetmaps accordingly at that time.
emersonveenstra (2023-08-03 11:37:24+00:00): Sounds good, thanks for the explanation!
NorthCrab_upload (2023-07-31 13:20:22+00:00): Zauważyłem, że Twoja zmiana zawiera adresy wymagające dodatkowej uwagi. Przygotowałem listę obiektów oraz dodatkowe informacje:

Nazwa ulicy nie istnieje w okolicy.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/11078762001

Pozdrawiam! 🦀
Robhubi (inaktiv) (2023-09-07 22:02:19+00:00): Hi,
Du hast bereits 2x den Namen vom Bahnhofsgebäude https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/233095803 von Bhf „Weststeiermark“ auf Bhf „Deutschlandsberg“ zurückgeändert. 
Was ist deine Quelle für diesen Namen?
Ich war heute vor Ort und habe den Namen „Weststeiermark“ gelesen …
a_nussmueller (2023-09-08 05:51:50+00:00): Hallo,
ich habe leider keine offizielle Quelle dazu, da es sich hier um Insider wissen handelt, da ich bei der ÖBB bin.
Man ist von "Bahnhof Weststeiermark" und "Bahnhof Lavanttal" wohl abgekommen, es werden im derzeitigen Stand die Bezirksnamen werden.
Der GBK Bahnhof wurde bereits von "Deutschlandsberg" in "Deutschlandsberg Stadt" umbenannt. Du hast schon recht, derzeit ist noch alles anders bezeichnet (außer bei Google), ich hab da wohl zu weit vorgegriffen... Man könnte wieder zurück ändern. Was hällst du für sinnvoll?
Robhubi (inaktiv) (2023-09-08 18:37:41+00:00): Hi,
Der Arbeitsname „Weststeiermark“ ist offiziell, der Diskussionsstand fluide, spätestens zur Eröffnung werden wir das Ergebnis wissen. Bis dahin macht „Weststeiermark“ mehr Sinn. Bitte ändere es dahingehend.
LG Robert
a_nussmueller (2023-09-11 05:17:55+00:00): Hi, schon erledigt!
LG Andi