piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
literan (2023-08-01 06:27:20+00:00): не понимаю, при чем здесь автоматизация. Во фразе "importing combines an existing dataset with the OSM dataset and thus typically includes a complex merging process" нет ничего про автоматизацию.
literan (2023-08-03 17:45:26+00:00): насколько я понял по отсутствию ответа, этот импорт нигде не обсуждался.

еще один вопрос. Вы пишете: "Во-вторых, документы на сайтах поселений в нашей переписке я упомянул лишь как один из общедоступных источников." Можете написать, какие еще источники вы использовали в этой правке?
Ivanerr (2023-08-03 17:50:54+00:00): С какой целью интересуешься?
ig4map (2023-07-31 15:26:50+00:00): No police here. Please choose some value for hazard tag instead. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:hazard?uselang=en
ig4map (2023-07-31 15:30:47+00:00): hazard=dog is rare value, but it much more better then police in this case 
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/hazard=dog#overview
eggie (2023-07-31 11:37:12+00:00): Verkeerde adres verwijderd. Markt 24 is waar het museum heen gaat verhuizen.
Het  museum is nu gesloten
MxxCon (2023-08-02 00:04:27+00:00): Way 972138872 seems to be a dragged node or is that how it actually is?
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139250333
daniel_solow (2023-08-02 01:50:42+00:00): it is a wheelchair ramp with one less node than it probably should have. It was an attempt at micro mapping the entrance to this building.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139250333
快乐的老鼠宝宝 (2023-08-01 06:46:46+00:00): 紧跟时事
MKnight (2023-07-31 14:47:52+00:00): Moin, und willkommen bei OSM.
Zugangsbeschränkungen werden in OSM über access-tags gelöst.
Siehe: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Key:access
Ich habe dein Edit rückgängig gemacht, da es vorher korrekt war.
Mateusz Konieczny (2025-05-15 17:54:18+00:00): Hello! https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/218655853/history has roof = hipped that was added in this edit
Maybe roof:shape=hipped was intended here?

See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:roof:shape and https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:roof
aTarom (2023-07-31 18:26:46+00:00): Hola VLanzarote,
gracias por editar, hay un consenso sobre las abreviaturas en los name, en el caso de
"name"="Instituto de Educación Secundaria Lobetano"
"short_name"="IES Lobetano"
es correcto tenerlo separado con sus respectivos tags
en
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/334038999/history
tienes más información al respecto en
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Buenas_pr%C3%A1cticas_en_Espa%C3%B1a#Name_con_abreviaturas
Dime que opinas, saludos
_Pax_ (2023-11-18 21:23:59+00:00): This trail is only temporarily closed and should not be deleted as it might get re-opened someday....
Map of permanently and temporarily clsoed tracks here:
https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/environment/plants-animals/protect-trees-disease/protect-our-kauri-trees/Pages/default.aspx
NastassiaKalesnikava (2023-11-20 14:10:29+00:00): Hello! Thank you very much for the useful source! I really appreciate it, will come in handy for situations like this. 
This edit has been reversed. Thank you for comment!
aseidel (2023-08-02 15:57:29+00:00): Liebe Alina142,
bitte bei den Verkehrszeichen-Punkobjekten auf das korrekte Tagging achten, z. B. bei https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/11078666304 (traffic_sign=DE:239,1022-10); bei https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/11078666608 endet der gemeinsame Rad-/Fußweg (traffic_sign=DE:240,1012-31). Bitte auch die anderen VZ-Punktobjekte in diesem Änderungssatz korrigieren.
Danke und herzliche Grüße
Antje Seidel
#lgmaps
Timmy_Tesseract (2023-08-01 05:57:03+00:00): In this and other changesets you've added the tag motor_vehicle=yes on a large number of gates.

In mapillary image from 2021 it is clearly visible that those gates are closed to traffic. Did you conduct a more recent survey where you found out that this is no longer the case?

Also, the current combination of access=no + motor_vehicle=yes means that cars/motorcycles are allowed to use these gates but pedestrians/bicycles are not. This seems quite unlikely. If the gates are really open now it would be better to modify the access=* tag than to additionally add motor_vehicle=*.
wambacher (2023-08-01 14:08:20+00:00): Hi, wie kommst du auf diese völlig falsche PLZ?
Siehe https://wambachers-osm.website/Postcodes_1_5_3.html?map=15/50.280921/7.756884&base=OSM&data=PCDE,WPCDE
Schweighausen bei Nassau hat die  56377 und nicht die 21762 von Osterbruch a.d. Niederelbe.

Was ist denn da schief gelaufen?
Gruß
walter
AndySchulte (2023-08-01 14:17:28+00:00): Moin Walter, ich kann die nicht sagen, was da schiefgelaufen ist. Wie ich sehe, hast du die PLZ schon angepasst. Danke dir.

Gruß Andy
martinst (2023-09-16 12:34:56+00:00): Bein name=* werden nur Eigennamen eingetragen, siehe https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:name
Bei description=* oder note=* können weitergehende Infos angegeben werden.
Dawid2849 (2023-07-31 21:56:44+00:00): Dzięki!
literan (2023-07-31 20:25:35+00:00): не надо мусорить
Kovoschiz (2023-07-31 13:23:32+00:00):  Please don't change classification based on some appearance. Tag For Renderer is discourage. This is the responsibility of the map style author. Raster picture tiles can't shown everything together. If you use proper map applications, names will be shown on vector lines, and upon clicking.  
But upon checking again, I agree it should be `=tertiary`.
BCNorwich (2023-07-31 14:51:26+00:00): Hi, If this is an unclassified highway then how can it be a toll road? Where are the tolls collected and by whom?

Are you sure you've tagged the correct speed limit, when was it reduced to 30? 
 
Where is the maxspeed:advisory=20 posted on this highway, because all OSM data must be verifiable? 

I'm pretty sure the max-width is much more than 2.5m (8.25 feet). 

The tag passing=difficult is subjective depending on the vehicle and at the passing places it's very easy.

Regards Bernard
wielandb (2025-01-10 04:13:18+00:00): Hi :)

Woher kommen die Infos in den Destination-Tags? Auf dem Wegweiser der dort steht kann ich sie nicht finden.

VG
9ix (2025-01-12 11:44:14+00:00): Hey,

ich entnehme die Angaben üblicherweise eigenen Fahrten vor Ort. Fehlende Informationen ergänze ich mit Mapillary.

Was passt denn nicht?

VG, 9ix
wielandb (2025-01-12 12:32:51+00:00): Auf 

https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=50.845531569086745&lng=12.941991523043498&z=16.545763435795546&pKey=1189439974811050&focus=photo&x=0.8046898067201971&y=0.5747126694294492&zoom=1.830055058433829

kann man das Schild sehen, dass auch aktuell da noch steht.

Ich wollte gerade die destination-Tags eintragen, als mir aufgefallen ist, dass du sie schon eingetragen hast. Allerdings konnte ich "Klinikum" und das Symbol nicht auf dem Schild finden. Stand da vorher ein anderes Schild?
9ix (2025-01-12 16:33:03+00:00): Du, sorry! Das ist schon ein paar Tage her. Ich habe es nach besten Wissen und Gewissen eingetragen. Wenn es nicht korrekt ist, stell es doch bitte richtig.

VG, 9ix
wielandb (2025-01-13 10:06:40+00:00): Kein Problem, werde ich tun. :) Wollte nur sichergehen, dass ich nichts übersehen habe.
Kovoschiz (2023-07-31 13:17:42+00:00): Please add back `construction=` , or change it to `construction:highway=`
LockOnGuy (2023-07-31 13:51:58+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 139255358 where the changeset comment is: Revert problematic edits of foreign user 'ChehrehBargi' in Iraq, user did the same problematic edits before and told to not repeat such behaver, he also complained in a foreign telegram group and was told to not do such things.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:06:31+00:00): You have recorded this message repeatedly in all my edits. According to the rules of the wiki, any editor can register any complication that exists on the ground. osm maps are not your father's property or a special stratum to register according to personal taste.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 10:08:41+00:00): Here is a memorial and a tomb, and I posted it a year ago, but you deleted it. This is against the rules. There is no need to bring a document to register the taxes on the land. osm maps are according to evidence. Do not repeat this.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 10:27:48+00:00): ChehrehBargi, You did the same problematic edits 1 year ago, We, the Iraqi OSM community contacted you, me and other Iraqis, even local ones to this area like Nawfal85, and we asked you to stop this type of edit, you are welcome to edit whatever if it's not harmful and not political and have a religious agenda. And you tried to explain yourself and give examples and names of those who are on the International terrorist list and called them heroes! We asked you to come to OSM Iraq, our local OSM community to discuss if you disagree, you refused and went to a foreign to discuss this, you went to "OSM Iran" and the admins and other members there told you that you are wrong, and should stop doing these types of edits in their country. 3 Days ago you came back with the same type of problematic edits, adding the Iranian general name to our map, and doing the same type of edits. I reverted them all and announced it in our local Iraqi community group.
Any future edits in Iraq you make with political, religious, and provocative will be reverted period.   
Stop.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 11:47:03+00:00): This is just the grave of a commander. Does the memorial registration of a person upset you so much? Registration of this grave does not conflict with OSM rules.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-02 14:15:58+00:00): If you want to know and understand why your political, religious, and provocative edits are not ok and not acceptable in Iraq, please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram and ask for you to understand.        
I suggest to keep your edits in areas that are local or known to you. It is not forbidden to edit globally, I recommend it actually, but it should not be against local communities will, and should not commit such acts.  
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-02 15:15:17+00:00): In the case of this grave, as in similar cases, such registrations have been made in this cemetery and in other areas, and the rules of Wiki did not prohibit the registration of graves, so my registration was correct. Even in the original name, I have registered in Arabic language and Arabic letters. I have included the Persian language in a separate tag.
SomeoneElse (2023-08-05 10:57:22+00:00): @LockOnGuy There are a number of problems here.

I got here via the link from your changeset that removed a language from https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/966067085 .  It is not OK to remove names for political reasons.  It is also not OK to refer to other mappers as "foreign users" as a perjorative when they are apparently mapping from survey (which is I suspect is more than you have ever done here).

With regard to the object here, I can confirm that "Registration of this grave does not conflict with OSM rules."

With regard to the request to "please come to the Iraqi OSM community group in telegram" that is not OK.  While mappers from any community should use some private channel and not one that is open to all is discriminatory.  I'd suggest instead using the community forum https://community.openstreetmap.org/tag/iraq - that is open to all with an OSM account.  There's not much there right now but that is a much more open forum for discussions going forward.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.
SomeoneElse (2023-08-05 11:16:20+00:00): The sentence above should have read " While mappers from any community can discuss OSM wherever they like, suggesting that discussions should only use some private channel and not one that is open to all is discriminatory"
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 11:21:05+00:00): Hello
Many thanks to the OSMF Data Working group
And also dear user SomeoneElse for your time.
SomeoneElse (2023-08-05 12:55:18+00:00): @LockOnGuy You're making a number of accusations here, but is any information to support any of what you've said available in public?  If not, please move the discussion to the public realm on c.osm.org .
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 13:01:51+00:00): User LockOnGuy
I have not registered my data for review. You talk about the way. Although most of my discussion is about your inappropriate omissions about buildings and graves, as well as electric light poles that exist on the road to Karbala and Najaf. I will definitely send you some pictures of the buildings and electric lights that you removed within the next month.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 13:09:46+00:00): User LockOnGuy
Does it bother you that we use the phrase "peace be upon us" for our imams? If so, I will enter it only in Farsi name. In addition, the war you mentioned had other reasons and it is definitely not what you say. Also, regarding the name in another language that is not on the board: translating the original name to other languages is not against the rules of the wiki and removing you is illegal.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 13:18:47+00:00): LockOnGuy
It is true that respected users from Iraq sent me messages. After talking with them, we decided not to discuss with you any more. And my work was not wrong. I did not have any opposition from other admins in Iran's osm group. What you are saying is a lie. Of course, some people told me to end the discussion because LockOnGuy will ruin my work again.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-05 14:20:36+00:00): @SomeoneElse, you said "but is any information to support any of what you've said available in public?       
The protests: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932021_Iraqi_protests         
The quotes from you: https://t.me/OpenStreetMapOrg          
Andy reverted all of the changesets by problematic mappers in subject area: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/124425633      
Sören Authorized OSM Iraq: https://t.me/OSM_Iraq/184            
And, you blocked me for deleting this: https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/966067085 Which you should know it's not a local or on signs as we don't have such language in Iraq and the user said above it's translated. And you looked away from deleting the "religion" tag from https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/1097262196 which is definitely a vandal. DWG should always be neutral.      
Regards.     
            
            
@ChehrehBargi, You mentioned "electric light poles", yes I do remember you adding wrong numbers as electric light poles numbers and I and other mappers told you that Electrict light poles do not has the type of numbering that you added, and the numbering of the electric light poles outside the cities are made by the distance example "kilo 14" or "kilo 136" etc. which that mean it's 136 kilometers from the city gate. Keep in mind some of the electric light poles that are now inside the city still has these numbers as the city got bigger and these numbers are measured from the original city arch gates.             
You added objects that were temporary for only 1 week a year and is not gurnteed to be at the same exact location the next year, like the resting tents in the streets, You know this very well and I gave you the osm wiki link that say we shall not add temp objects, but you kept arguing to have them in.        
Again ChehrehBargi, please do not add names that are not local or on the ground.    
You said "It is true that respected users from Iraq sent me messages. After talking with them, we decided not to discuss with you any more. And my work was not wrong." you are making this sound like Iraqis agreed with you on something, while infact they told you to not map like this, I believe Nawfal is the one you are referring to, while Nawfal just replied to my message few days ago and agreeing to remove your edits and told me good job after I reverted your edits and stated it in our Public OSM Iraq group which you can go and see.          
Regards.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-05 14:29:28+00:00): Also, something to add, @ChehrehBargi, in this changeset you added Way: 1193549241, which is this I believe: https://i.ibb.co/48xNMsZ/image.png is this really a "historic=monument"? And what's the difference between it and the other 6 millions in this cemetery?    
Also you added "inscription" where is this inscription?         
What you did is considered as fictional mapping.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 14:59:03+00:00): LockOnGuy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932021_Iraqi_protests
This link, like the one you sent last year, is from Wikipedia. Biased things are written in Wikipedia according to certain political goals. Iran has never been as you say. It seems that you are not enough. Anyway, I have already said that the map is not a suitable place for political orientation and exploitation.
Is there a sign somewhere to write the name of the country of Iraq in other languages? Definitely not.
The fact that I have added the name of a street or a place in Farsi is not against the rules. It is necessary to know that if the original name on the board is the criterion when adding a name in another language, there is no problem in registering it.
You probably have an enmity with Imam Ali, Imam Hussein or some of them. If there is a problem with this work in Arabic, I will only add it in Persian so that you don't have an excuse.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 15:05:53+00:00): Regarding the electric poles, you were the only one who warned about them, not others. In addition, I recorded their numbers according to the signs that were installed on the poles. You have removed all the lightning rods. You could register the original number with the name tag and the numbers that I registered according to their table with the loc_name tag. But you didn't. Meanwhile, the buildings you call temporary are not tents. They were all buildings. According to Wiki rules, every building and complex can be registered on the map. So your work was illegal.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 15:14:43+00:00): LockOnGuy@
due to the
  https://i.ibb.co/48xNMsZ/image.png
It turns out that you have not seen there at all. The photo you sent is an old photo. It is built as a building that has a foundation and a roof. So that you don't have any more excuses and that your words are proven to be false, I will upload clear pictures from here on the file.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 15:20:10+00:00): In general, my whole problem with you is in the osm rules. But you are eager to drag it into a religious and political fight. Even if a building is closed for a long time, it can still be registered in the map. I definitely know the difference between a tent and a building. And my records from Karbala to Najaf were fixed buildings. I have not registered the tents.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 15:24:03+00:00): Regarding the inscription: In the new stone that was used, the summary is stated and my explanation is a more complete description. If the problem is only that, you should have corrected the inscription instead of erasing every place that I record.
LockOnGuy (2023-08-05 15:43:21+00:00): @ChehrehBargi The article I linked explains such things will lead to such events, and might get hundreds of people killed and tens of thousands injured. You added a grave of an Iranian general as a monument and said previously "they are brave like general xxx" and General xxx is on the international terrorist list in the US and EU! and fought against Iraq in the war and killed the protesters in the protest I linked above, and they burned their the general's photos. And even if we looked away from all of that chaos, you added such thing as a "monument" which is not, you added "inscription" which is not on the ground, and this considers as fictional mapping that we should always remove.     
The same goes for the translated names you added for POI, if it's not there, it should not be up, and especially the names that are translated with 3rd party translators are forbidden entirely.     
As I told you last year, you shall not add temporary objects period! Imaging I did not delete the temporary resting tents you added and someone used navigation apps that use OSM data to find some place to rest, he will go there and see nothing! just an empty road! this is not acceptable. And even let's say the objects you still want to add are not just tents, it's still and closed the whole year, and only open in one week in the year, So, it is temporary, and if it's a building, it should be mapped as building=yes only without the rest area tags as it's not for resting for the whole year due to it being closed for the whole year except 1 week.       
Same scenario for the poles, let's say someone driving on the road and his car broke down in the desert, do you want him to give fake numbers on the navigation map he uses that were up as guide posts for the one-week event in the year or go to the pole and see the actual correct number on the plate cover to know how far he is in kilometers away from the city?       
Regarding the grave you added as a monument in this changeset, you did not answer my questions, is it really a monument? Show us how different it is from the other 6 million graves in the cemetery.      
Again, we map only what is on the ground, and should not use translated names not on the ground. And should not map temporary objects like festive season POIs.      
I really hope you understand this.           
Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2023-08-05 18:51:34+00:00): LockOnGuy@
Your article is not a reliable source. What happened is completely different. Earlier, you tried to divert the issue with the same words with wrong sources. Each of us has our own opinions. You are not allowed to turn the map into a political religious battlefield. I'm talking about map rules, not your political opinions. The war you are talking about was not against the people of Iraq. Do not spread rumours. If you have something new, say it. As I said, I will definitely add pictures to prove your lies. Which POI? If you say the graves of the imams, you are wrong, read the rules. It is not a violation to add a name in another language under the original language. In addition, it does not conflict with the original name. I have not added a tent. I had added the building and its name. Of course, not as a resort. And you removed buildings without being sure they were tents. Because you have only seen it from satellite images. But I passed by and saw the buildings. You could use the open time tag instead of removing them. That road is not empty. It is partly a building and partly a tent. I did not register the tents.
My previous note about electric poles is clear. Read it again. You deleted it instead of editing it. In addition, the signs on the electric poles that I registered are still installed on them. Regarding the grave, my explanation was clear. I will take a picture of it so that everyone will know that it is a building. You haven't even seen it up close. You have also obtained the old photo by searching a site. Regarding your last sentence: This is exactly my problem with you. I record what is on the floor and you remove it. Saying that the name of the translation should not be against the rules. We have the original name and add the same name to other languages. For example, Fulton Street for English
, خیابان فولتون for Farsi,
 and شارع الفولتون for Arabic are translated without interfering with the original name and its prefix.
I completely see where you are trying to push the discussion.
Let's edit the map without breaking OSM rules.
With respect
LockOnGuy (2023-08-05 19:15:35+00:00): @ChehrehBargi, Again,
1- If you add temporary objects, they will be removed, and yes, 1 week a year is considered temporary, read here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_temporary_events_and_temporary_features         
2- If you add names in a language that are not on the ground in a sign it should be removed especially if it's not local and translated by 3rd party services.       
3- If you map anything not on the ground in reality, like inscriptions, monuments, and others, and you assume is this fine, even with good faith, it will be removed as it's considered as fictional mapping.        
Bye.