piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
MxxCon (2023-11-17 01:22:00+00:00): This changeset will be reverted in full since you deleted correctly mapped data.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144034544
woodpeck (2023-11-15 08:27:03+00:00): Dear AlexVDP, welcome to OSM! You have made many tiny uploads of one house each. You don't need to hit the "save" button after every house - it is easier to accumulate a few edits and then save them together!
bernardo60 (2023-11-18 07:01:33+00:00): w586178172 is not a residential road, it is a concrete path only wide enough for motorbikes. Please do not re-tag my original classifications based on ground survey. I live with 100m of this place!
amtplskaart (2023-11-19 06:41:46+00:00): Hi, you have better judgement if you live there. The reason for my editing was an impossible routing in one of the segment connected to this way. I only have satellite image and Kartaview photos, so thanks to your comment here to make it clear.
seav (2023-12-28 09:50:32+00:00): Hi! May I know why you tagged the Quiapo Church grounds as a boundary=national_park? This tag is only used for actual natural parks usually enjoyed for outdoor activities and environmental preservation and not cultural/religious heritage.
DP24PH (2024-01-05 11:32:50+00:00): Given the upcoming National Shrine status for the Quiapo Church, we should properly place the entire church grounds, including Plaza Miranda, under the protected land area. This will be subjected to further discussion.


DP24
NKA (2023-11-15 11:16:34+00:00): Comments:
- You have created an alpine hut in the ocean, clearly not the correct location.
- "alpine hut" is likely not correct, rather tourism=chalet
Abdullah Abdulrhman (2023-12-07 06:23:41+00:00): لماذا قمت بحذف وسم:
boundary=administrative
من محاظفة الخبر ؟؟
Cripto (2023-11-15 19:54:22+00:00): Wtf ??
woodpeck (2023-11-15 08:24:30+00:00): Dear charlottejohnson, welcome to OSM. In this changset you have deleted more than 50 buildings without specifying any reason for it (the comment you provided on upload was "#hotosm-project-13149 #KLL #MapGive #mappingtheunmapped #mapforcause #osmnepal" which sadly does not help anyone understand why buildings need to be deleted). As a general rule, if you want to re-draw an existing object, we prefer it if you can simply move the existing object into place rather than deleting and re-doing it. Of course if the buildings you have deleted have actually ceased to exist then it would be good to mention that on the changeset comment ("deleting buildings that have been destroyed" or something like that).
arjunaraoc (2024-01-05 01:35:51+00:00): Welcome to OSM.  Please visit  India page on OSM wiki (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/India) and  join OSM India Telegram channel (https://t.me/OSMIndia).
Check my update: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/145902748
Happy mapping!
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144038125
emersonveenstra (2023-11-17 13:50:00+00:00): Hi,

Could you please explain more about why you changed toll to fee on roads? Since toll is defined as "indicating that a fee must be paid by general traffic to use a road, road bridge or road tunnel", i'm not sure how to understand your change. thanks!
SD Mapman (2023-11-17 15:52:20+00:00): That was based on feedback from the OSM Americana group, essentially the idea was if it's more like a park where you can buy an annual pass it would be fee, but if you have to pay every time you use the road it would be toll. The distinction to me seems kinda flexible, but the way I'm conceptualizing it is that state parks, national parks, etc. would be fee and turnpikes/toll bridges would be toll.
emersonveenstra (2023-11-18 12:50:59+00:00): Okay, then you should probably update the wiki to reflect that, since right now it says that fee shouldn't be on highways
silversurfer83 (2023-11-15 18:18:23+00:00): Gude und Grüße :)

Kurze Frage: Du hast hier https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/11350448801 einen Wendekreis von eim Fußweg getrennt. Warum? Kann man nicht vom Fußweg in die Ostpreußenstr. gehen?

silversurfer83
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144038502
Langlaeufer (2023-11-16 10:04:37+00:00): Ich hab die Verbindung erstmal wieder hergestellt und nebenan auch. Bitte vor Ort prüfen. Weiter westlich gibt es noch eine Stelle, die potentiell eine Verbindung sein könnte. Dazu Hinweis erstellt. Grüße Langläufer.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144038502
Mtwok (2023-11-16 10:47:37+00:00): Guten Tag ihr zwei,

die Verbindung gibt es, ich hatte sie wohl versehentlich gelöst.
Ich bin aktuell unterwegs und kann nicht genau nachsehen oder editieren, aber Langläufer hat bereits geholfen. Den Hinweis weiter westlich schaue ich mir später auch an.

Vielen Dank euch beiden.
zstadler (2023-11-16 11:23:42+00:00): שלום
T_Sade

תודה על העדכונים שאתה עורך למפה!

בעריכה זו שינית את סוג הדרך של
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/803221341
מדרך עפר לשביל אופניים

האם הדרך לא עבירה יותר לג'יפים?

תודה,
זאב
T_Sade (2023-11-17 15:56:44+00:00): זאב שלום,
כן, קטע זה נסלל כשביל אופניים משדה בוקר למדרשה.
והוא לא ניתן לכניסה של רכבים.
יש דרכי עפר שונות ליד.
בנוסף כל השביל הסלול החדש תחום בסלעים גדולים.
zstadler (2023-11-17 16:49:52+00:00): שוב תודה
InsertUser (2023-11-15 17:54:13+00:00): Why delete and recreate and existing building rather than just edit the existing one and keep the history?
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144039073
mikimapbuilder (2023-11-16 12:46:29+00:00): Hi InsertUser. Thank you for pointing this out. You are absolutely right, and this is something that is my mistake. I overlooked it and we will improve our work with this in mind so in the future similar mistakes aren't made.
Zunyu (2024-05-08 22:50:47+00:00): 駐車場名は知識ですか？
user_17429136 (2024-07-08 05:15:39+00:00): 現地確認をしたものとストリートビューで確認したものがあります。
woodpeck (2023-11-15 08:43:28+00:00): Dear Bikon8, welcome to OSM! You are using what we call "descriptive names". The "name" tag on an object is there to record the name of a building, not the purpose. For example, there is a specific tag for a library that you should use when mapping a library, rather giving the building a "name" of "Library". Also "Academic" is not a proper name for a building, and "School Path" an unlikely name for a footpath!
NeisBot (2023-12-29 11:07:08+00:00): Hello, thank you very much for your contribution to the OSM project.

It would be great if you could use the comment field to describe your changes. This makes it easier for others to understand and follow your adjustments on the map more quickly.

Thanks!

#HappyMapping
#ADescriptionSaysMoreThanASingleChar
快乐的老鼠宝宝 (2023-11-15 08:10:51+00:00): Oh no, why does it span the entire Southern Hemisphere! Is it because they are separated by 180° longitude?

I means I don't intent to make this large boundary box.
Supaplex (2023-11-20 17:11:04+00:00): Is the status change. Patrolling doesn't mean switch or change, should remain disrupt territory 
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Thomas_Shoal
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144039802
windblewer (2023-11-20 17:55:59+00:00): Nope, an academic article published in US Naval War College Review clearly state that coast guard patrolling can be 
"defenders of sovereignty".
Source: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1016&context=nwc-review
SomeoneElse (2023-12-29 00:28:04+00:00): Hello windblewer,
Please don't make disputed political edits without prior discussion.  Please does at the forum https://community.openstreetmap.org/ before doing so in future.  If you have any comments please email them to the Data Working Group at data@openstreetmap.org with a subject line of "[Ticket#2023122910000031] windblewer".
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, from the DWG
Anim Mouse (2023-11-16 16:16:09+00:00): Hello, the "Doña Helen Avenue" you edited is a road that is shared by the two subdivisions named Doña Helen Subdivision and North Matrix Ville I that forms a boundary between them. On the Doña side, it is named "Doña Helen Avenue" while on the Matrix side it is named "Matrix Loop." As stated on the wiki https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:name:left using the name "Doña Helen Avenue / Matrix Loop" is more appropriate in this case as Doña is not the only one that is using this road.
GOwin (2023-11-17 05:36:02+00:00): Hello @Anim Mouse.

Thank you for checking this out. I noticed that tags already had name:left and name:right, but  remembered the wiki convention for this incorrectly. 

The former street name has been restored.
Anim Mouse (2023-11-17 07:30:20+00:00): Thanks!
user_5359 (2023-11-16 14:50:29+00:00): Hello! Please have a look on https://www.osm.org/way/1223713117. What ist the mean of the tags
AFB_ID = 615
ERZEUGT_AM = 2023-01-15
GMDE_BZ = Großalmerode
GMDE_NR = 636004
GMK_BZ = Weißenbach
GMK_NR = 2237
ID1 = 1284.0
KREIS_BZ = Werra-Meißner
KREIS_NR = 636
REGBEZ_BZ = Kassel
REGBEZ_NR = 6
(no other OSM keys)
?
surveyor54 (2023-11-17 07:17:55+00:00): Oh, da lagen zwei Linien übereinander. Danke für die Info. 👍
winterm (2024-07-21 09:51:25+00:00): Die Brücke ist seit Ende Juni fertig und für Radfahrer und Fußgänger wieder benutzbar. Die Rampe auf der Ostseite hoch zum Damm wurde neu gestaltet. Es gibt jetzt nach Norden eine Rampe für Radfahrer, geradeaus nach Osten eine Treppe, nach Süden eine Rampe für Radfahrer und eine zweite, geteerte Rampe mit Geländer für Rollstuhlfahrer. Außerdem befindet sich oben am Damm eine neue Fahrrad-Servicestation. Der Hundekot-Mülleimer mit Tütenspender ist noch nicht aufgebaut (kommt hoffentlich bald). Siehe auch https://www.rosenheim.de/pressemitteilungen/bruecke-ueber-den-hammerbach-in-der-lortzingstrasse-fertig/
Champ0815 (2024-07-21 12:00:19+00:00): Danke für den Hinweis - ich dachte eigentlich, dass ich die Markierung als Baustelle schon vor Monaten entfernt habe. Hatte ich wohl das Speichern vergessen...
Hufkratzer (2023-11-15 21:50:21+00:00): No, the most fitting tag combination for an outdoor riding arena is leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, this is set by preset "Horseback Riding / Rodeo Arena". I noticed that, if you searched for "equestrian arena", this preset was not listed. This will hopefully be improved in the next release, see https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/pull/1055
Oskarst_ (2023-11-16 13:44:32+00:00): Do you think the current tagging as done in my changeset should be changed?
Hufkratzer (2023-11-16 14:56:26+00:00): Yes. Search for "arena" and you can select the appropriate preset.
Oskarst_ (2023-11-17 06:54:46+00:00): Great, thanks for the feedback!
silversurfer83 (2023-11-28 20:38:14+00:00): Hi :)

herzlich willkommen bei OSM und danke, dass du mithilfst die Karte aktuell zu halten.

Du hast bei deinen drei Änderungen darum gebeten, dass sich jemand anguckt, was du getan hast. Ich handele mal eben alle drei in diesem Kommentar ab:

Die sehen alle ziemlich gut aus :)
Gibt nur ein, zwei Schönheitsfehler, einen hab ich schon korrigiert:
- Tippfehler bei den Hausnummern 😄
- bei dieser Änderung hier: Dass du die Daten vor Ort erhoben hast, hast du in der Quelle schon drin. Da wäre ein Kommentar, wie in den ersten zwei Änderungen schöner gewesen.

Wie gesagt: Schönheitsfehler. Gute Änderungen ansonsten. Bitte weiter machen.

Grüße
silversurfer83
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144042215
Jordi MF (2023-11-15 18:20:25+00:00): Hola Mikel,

He visto que has cambiado el nombre de un camino porque en la placa está escrito "Camino l'Estang". Hablo catalán y sé que es un error ortográfico. La palabra Estang no existe. Se escribe "Estany". Por tanto, el nombre correcto es "Camí de l'Estany". La preposición "de" siempre debe escribirse en catalán aunque no aparezca en la placa porque también es un error ortográfico. Mira el siguiente enlace y verás el nombre bien escrito: https://visor.gva.es/visor/?extension=777416,4457453,778794,4458108&nivelZoom=17&capasids=Topografico;,Toponimia;&tcapas=1.0,1.0

Saludos,
Jordi
Jordi MF (2023-11-15 18:27:04+00:00): Aquí tienes otra placa de ese camino que está bien escrita:
https://www.google.com/maps/@40.2292848,0.2616089,3a,15y,133.37h,83.85t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1scZj7uaOa5y--cFv7OOdqlQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656?entry=ttu
Mikel Ortega (2023-11-15 18:30:30+00:00): Hola Jordi,

Gracias, lo tendré en cuenta otra vez. He usado los nombres de esta placa: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.2232848,0.2701884,3a,15y,329.83h,89.48t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sWIl46aMs5ZNFy8WPzvaz-A!2e0!5s20140601T000000!7i13312!8i6656?entry=ttu

Gracias por revisar mis cambios.
Mikel Ortega (2023-11-15 18:41:36+00:00): Entiendo que la traducción correcta sería "estanque" y que la palabra Estang de la placa no existe. Vaya una placa, no han dado una :)
Jordi MF (2023-11-15 19:14:11+00:00): Sí, me lo he imaginado porque me sonaba haber estado allí. Porncierto, últimamente también estoy por Torreblanca mapeando algunos elementos. Edité unas calles peatonales que tú también habías mapeado. Verás que he modificado la unión con otras calles porque vi que los bordillos estaban rebajado y permitían que un vehículo pudoese acceder (lo explico en el conjunto de cambios). Seguí esa forma de mapear porque se lo leí a otros usuarios de la comunidad en el grupo de Telegram que existe.

Saludos.
Jordi MF (2023-11-17 17:38:16+00:00): Hola Mikel,
Acabo de ver tu mensaje sobre la posible traducción. Podría ser "Camino del Estanque" o "Camino del Estaño" (el elemento químico). Si hay que apostar, yo apostaría por "estanque", aunque no sé dónde está el estanque... Obviamente, tampoco sé si hay alguna mina antigua de extracción de estaño (lo dudo mucho).

Ese es el problema de traducir los topónimos. Por eso, la mayoría de lingüistas y de gente que trabaja con mapas (con los que he hablado) no son partidarios de las traducciones. Si se decide traducir, muchas veces se decide traducir únicamente el nombre genérico "Camino" y mantener el nombre específico con la palabra original "Estany" en aquellos casos en los que no haya una traducción con tradición histórica (se debería consultar la bibliografía o a la gente del lugar). Esta última opción parece ser que es la que decidió el Ayuntamiento de Alcalà de Xivert (mantener el nombre específico y traducir el genérico).

Dicho esto y siendo partidario de no traducir todos los topónimos, procede como prefieras. No conozco en detalle el lugar y no entraré en la discusión. ;)

La verdad es que me cuesta imaginar cómo han podido cometer esa falta ortográfica en valenciano... En fin.

Saludos!
AurélienQ (2024-01-20 17:29:50+00:00): Bonjour, 
j'ai remarqué que vous avez changé les attributs de la voie du tram-train, passant de 'railway=light_rail' à 'railway=rail'. 
Même si c'est en effet une voie d'apparence classique, elle est dimensionnée que pour les trams-trains, et n'est presque pas relié au réseau national. 
Elle devrait donc garder l'étiquette 'railway=light_rail'.
Je corrige cela, 
Bonne journée,
Aurélien
Taya_S (2023-11-15 17:24:22+00:00): Hallo ZuidWestDrenthe,

Het hele bos ten oosten van de Ruinerweg/Echterweg heet Echtenerveld. Een naam toevoegen aan slechts 1 klein stukje bos is niet correct.

Wat je het beste kunt doen is er een locality van maken zoals bijvoorbeeld hier https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/15937223

Groeten,
Taya
ZuidWestDrenthe (2023-11-15 20:05:52+00:00): Dank voor je feedback, is wist niet dat dit kon. Ik zal het 1 deze dagen recht zetten op de manier die je aangaf.
KiloThree (2023-11-16 07:09:45+00:00): Hi, it looks like you somehow moved an instrument landing aid in Florida slightly in this changeset
0x4248 (2023-12-19 18:41:05+00:00): Sorry mistake whilst editing
MarcoR (2023-11-16 14:48:28+00:00): Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap!

It seems they were not ski lifts but lifts for conveying goods: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:aerialway=goods

Are you sure that they are not still there?

Happy mapping,
Marco.
aTarom (2023-11-15 14:15:51+00:00): Parece que no has tenido en cuenta el idioma en algunos centros de Catalunya? cuando puedas revisa estos:
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria Sant Jordi    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/575906340/history
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria Torres de Balàfia    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/654414295/history
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria Puig D´en Valls    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/867769453/history
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria Sant Ferran de ses Roques    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1143635435/history
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria S'Olivera    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/867769452/history
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria Santa Gertrudis    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/867769454/history
Colegio de Educación Infantil y Primaria Pràctiques    https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/162778428/history

Saludos
kapazao (2023-11-15 14:59:07+00:00): Claro, hay que darle un repaso general a los nombres que no están en castellano. No podía hacerlo todo a la primera pasada porque me ha dado problemas el plugin para sustituir. Lo tengo en cuenta. Evidentemente no tiene sentido usar name y name:ca en castellano cuando prima el catalán jeje.
Gracias por el comentario.
Un saludo
kapazao (2023-11-15 15:45:22+00:00): En principio deberían estar ya corregidos https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/144056962
garaolaza (2023-11-27 07:17:59+00:00): Hola, lo mismo en Euskadi. No puede ser que hagas ediciones de este tipo de forma automática.
kapazao (2023-11-27 16:42:02+00:00): Hola garaolaza, antes de nada las ediciones se han comentado en la comunidad y están hechas a partir de atributos que ya eran incorrectos, por lo que el problema no lo he causado yo para empezar. Simplemente he corregido los nombres que estaban en siglas a su forma correcta. Que estén en el idioma correcto o no ya es otra historia que está pendiente y que tampoco tiene que ser tarea mía exclusivamente.
Dudo mucho que los colegios sean lo único que OSM está en castellano en Euskadi u otros sitios de España donde también se habla castellano.
Cada comunidad debería dedicarse a traducir lo que considere necesario en base a los nombres existentes.
Un saludo
stillhart (2023-11-19 10:21:41+00:00): thanks
NorthCrab_upload (2023-11-15 10:10:23+00:00): 🗺️ Witaj na OpenStreetMap!

Zauważyłem, że Twoja zmiana zawiera adresy wymagające dodatkowej uwagi. Przygotowałem listę obiektów oraz dodatkowe informacje:

Nazwa ulicy nie istnieje w okolicy. Jeśli adres ma nazwę ulicy, upewnij się, że jest ona poprawna. Jeśli nie, usuń addr:street, a nazwę miejscowości przekaż w addr:place.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/11350668118

Dokumentacja adresów (po polsku):
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pl:Key:addr:*

W razie problemów lub pytań, proszę pisać. Chętnie pomogę.
Pozdrawiam! 🦀
eggie (2023-11-15 11:05:13+00:00): Wanneer disused: .......... hebt aangepast zal het nog wel oke zijn. Zodra je een route aanpast gaat het met iD verkeerd.
Dat kan alleen met editor JOSM.
Zie PB. 
MVG
eggie
tastrax (2023-11-15 22:41:07+00:00): Hi folks FYI - Phone numbers in Australia should be added to OSM according to the following format with the country code +61 x xxxx xxxx, (+61 xxx xxx xxx for mobiles) or use the phone:AU key if a 1300 or 1800 number.
For freecall numbers that work whilst overseas (ie 13 13 13) use +61 XX XX XX as per the wiki guidelines https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Australian_Tagging_Guidelines/Australian_features .  I have just updated a recent addition that you made to OSM – Cheers
ul2739 (2023-11-15 23:56:59+00:00): Thanks for the info; I was wondering how to handle 1300 numbers.
Filip009 (2023-11-17 10:15:15+00:00): "image" z wikipédie sa dáva do wikimedia_commons. Opravte to prosím.
felipeeugenio (2023-11-15 11:49:44+00:00): Hello. The main difference between a path and a track, is that on a track a 4 wheel vehicle can circulate and on a path not. I highly doubt of some paths you converted to track. Could you please reconsider them?
Another thing: please always add the surface to these kind of roads. in case you don´t know the exact surface, you can add the generic (paved/unpaved).

regards
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144044825
supsup (2023-11-15 11:59:54+00:00): Oh, yeah, no tracks, sorry, must have been hallucinating, the paths around Planchon are paths (and imaginary as well in places). I will fix that.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144044825
felipeeugenio (2023-11-15 12:03:56+00:00): ok, thanks for your response. 
Now, since you are using JOSM, we, as a Chilean community have a special chat in Telegram to instruct people to use strava traces.
strava traces, for mapping hiking road purposes is a real bomb regarding how useful it is.
please contact me in Telegram and I can redirect you to that chat. o join the Chilean chat.
the instructions are in Spanish, but with a translator, you will find out how to reach the desired result in 5 minutes.
supsup (2023-11-15 12:04:55+00:00): Ok, I fixed it now, did you see any other instances but the paths around Planchon (the volcano)? I think the presets in josm and late hour must have fooled me, sorry.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144044825
supsup (2023-11-15 12:06:14+00:00): This changeset https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/144048779#map=15/-35.1924/-70.5647
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144044825
felipeeugenio (2023-11-15 12:09:38+00:00): this is the link to the chat:

https://t.me/+euUYepTmEu0wOWFh
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144044825
supsup (2023-11-15 12:10:56+00:00): my number is +420602320084 and I have telegram there, not sure how to contact you from my side:-).

However, I am not really adding many paths.  I am mainly adding water bodies and then doing little changes here and there based on my notes when I walked there last southern-hemisphere summer (This particular one around the volcano I walked and it is non-existent. It was mapped in a completely crazy and hazardous way. I changed it to where we walked (roughly) based on satelite and my memory and a gps trace, but I hand-drew the path. I also set the visibility to none to indicate that there is no actual trail.
felipeeugenio (2023-11-15 12:28:07+00:00): ok, thank you very much.
strava traces are all GPS traces collected around the world and it is crazy if you want to map hicking trails.

The instructions to be able to see them on JOSM are in the link I sent you. It is very easy.
regards
felipeeugenio (2023-11-17 20:17:07+00:00): Hello Tomas. And please do not use descriptive names... Laguna Teno is Laguna Teno, Please do not explain what are you drawing in the name, the tag to so do is descrption=

Besides, It is clear in the pictures that there are two bodies of water... is that temporal? usually, they form a single body.
regards
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/144044825
supsup (2023-11-17 20:26:18+00:00): I was following the suggestion here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:water%3Dreservoir#Mapping_partial_intermittency

to me it sounds like a good system, that way when searching for example, one is not confused by two seemingly identical entries.
felipeeugenio (2023-11-17 20:35:59+00:00): Hello.
This is not the issue. The issue is not the tags used.
The issue is: 
1) Does that lagoon, at some point, constitute a single body?
2) the tag name= is only for names, not descriptions. (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names)

regards