Gonçalo Matos (2025-07-24 10:31:31+00:00): Hi, DrF_Master7, 👋

I am afraid there are more inconsistencies. At Técnico we are working at an R package that matches GTFS shapes with OSM routes (https://u-shift.github.io/GTFShift/reference/osm_shapes_match_routes.html) and we are identifying the following routes with invalid stop orders for Carris Metropolitana network:
> `osm_id` 3080576 (`route_short_name` 3508)
> `osm_id` 13677615 (`route_short_name` 3508)
> `osm_id` 13678105 (`route_short_name` 3508)
> `osm_id` 14510851 (`route_short_name` 3508)
> `osm_id` 19101429 (`route_short_name` 3508)
> `osm_id` 19101430 (`route_short_name` 3508)
> `osm_id` 3090499 (`route_short_name` 3509)
> `osm_id` 13678109 (`route_short_name` 3509)
> `osm_id` 13678131 (`route_short_name` 3509)
> `osm_id` 13678132 (`route_short_name` 3509)
> `osm_id` 14455710 (`route_short_name` 3511)
> `osm_id` 14257287 (`route_short_name` 3513)
> `osm_id` 3092106 (`route_short_name` 3515)
> `osm_id` 13609428 (`route_short_name` 3515)
> `osm_id` 18244142 (`route_short_name` 3521)
> `osm_id` 18244143 (`route_short_name` 3521)
> `osm_id` 3351339 (`route_short_name` 3526)
> `osm_id` 3117949 (`route_short_name` 3527)
> `osm_id` 18247065 (`route_short_name` 3615)
> `osm_id` 18247068 (`route_short_name` 3615)
> `osm_id` 18172505 (`route_short_name` 3635)
> `osm_id` 18172506 (`route_short_name` 3635)
> `osm_id` 18022518 (`route_short_name` 1209)
> `osm_id` 18024300 (`route_short_name` 1211)
> `osm_id` 18025151 (`route_short_name` 1215)
> `osm_id` 18032690 (`route_short_name` 1219)
> `osm_id` 18032889 (`route_short_name` 1220)
> `osm_id` 18045574 (`route_short_name` 1231)
> `osm_id` 18075864 (`route_short_name` 1240)
> `osm_id` 18491982 (`route_short_name` 1634)
> `osm_id` 17888000 (`route_short_name` 1724)
> `osm_id` 18504182 (`route_short_name` 2117)
> `osm_id` 18504183 (`route_short_name` 2117)
> `osm_id` 18504184 (`route_short_name` 2117)
> `osm_id` 18504185 (`route_short_name` 2117)
> `osm_id` 18504186 (`route_short_name` 2117)
> `osm_id` 18496440 (`route_short_name` 2120)
> `osm_id` 18496441 (`route_short_name` 2120)
> `osm_id` 18496411 (`route_short_name` 2121)
> `osm_id` 18496412 (`route_short_name` 2121)
> `osm_id` 14517710 (`route_short_name` 2125)
> `osm_id` 18561075 (`route_short_name` 2134)
> `osm_id` 18561076 (`route_short_name` 2134)
> `osm_id` 18561348 (`route_short_name` 2135)
> `osm_id` 18561349 (`route_short_name` 2135)
> `osm_id` 18623231 (`route_short_name` 2138)
> `osm_id` 18623232 (`route_short_name` 2138)
> `osm_id` 18623600 (`route_short_name` 2144)
> `osm_id` 18623601 (`route_short_name` 2144)
> `osm_id` 18623602 (`route_short_name` 2144)
> `osm_id` 18623603 (`route_short_name` 2144)
> `osm_id` 19101946 (`route_short_name` 2150)
> `osm_id` 19101947 (`route_short_name` 2150)
> `osm_id` 19101948 (`route_short_name` 2150)
> `osm_id` 19101943 (`route_short_name` 2152)
> `osm_id` 19101944 (`route_short_name` 2152)
> `osm_id` 18585223 (`route_short_name` 2504)
> `osm_id` 18585224 (`route_short_name` 2504)
> `osm_id` 13515072 (`route_short_name` 2518)
> `osm_id` 18787114 (`route_short_name` 2525)
> `osm_id` 18787111 (`route_short_name` 2627)
> `osm_id` 18787112 (`route_short_name` 2627)
> `osm_id` 18787113 (`route_short_name` 2627)
> `osm_id` 12626053 (`route_short_name` 2750)
> `osm_id` 12849088 (`route_short_name` 2750)
> `osm_id` 13456273 (`route_short_name` 2774)
> `osm_id` 13466927 (`route_short_name` 2780)
> `osm_id` 13502490 (`route_short_name` 2780)
> `osm_id` 13417967 (`route_short_name` 2796)
> `osm_id` 18456506 (`route_short_name` 2796)
> `osm_id` 18456507 (`route_short_name` 2796)
> `osm_id` 18456508 (`route_short_name` 2796)
> `osm_id` 18496533 (`route_short_name` 2806)
> `osm_id` 18496534 (`route_short_name` 2806)
> `osm_id` 18535532 (`route_short_name` 2910)
> `osm_id` 18535533 (`route_short_name` 2910)
> `osm_id` 18535534 (`route_short_name` 2910)
> `osm_id` 18535535 (`route_short_name` 2910)
> `osm_id` 18546029 (`route_short_name` 2911)
> `osm_id` 18546030 (`route_short_name` 2911)
> `osm_id` 18546031 (`route_short_name` 2911)
> `osm_id` 19098135 (`route_short_name` 2913)
> `osm_id` 13505124 (`route_short_name` 2824)
> `osm_id` 18524365 (`route_short_name` 4441)
> `osm_id` 17440122 (`route_short_name` 4501)
> `osm_id` 13972384 (`route_short_name` 4516)
> `osm_id` 13664405 (`route_short_name` 4620) 

Despite not all, some were updated by you on other edition batches, such as https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/165945247.

I also found identical problems with Carris Municipal network. Do you want me to share it with you?

Do you want to escalate this conversation to the OSM Forum? That way, we could further discuss the issues identified and keep track of the problems and the best way to approach them. I was thinking about opening a tread for Public Transit updates at https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/pt/176. Since I am new to this OSM community, I would like to have your opinion before proceeding.

Thanks and sorry for the amount of information shared in this comment 😅,
Gonçalo