piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
Hjart (2018-10-23 13:35:58+00:00): Ja, jeg har regnet ud at det er Bing han har brugt. Jeg prøver bare at opdrage lidt på folk, så jeg ikke behøver at bruge for meget tid på det og fordi at der kan være andre situationer (ikke mindst i udlandet) hvor det kan være meget sværere at regne ud.
Hjart (2018-10-23 13:38:26+00:00): Please note that I have reverted some of your changes, based on the fact you have used outdated imagery (the national danish SDFE aerial imagery is much more recent).
user_8331873 (2018-10-29 12:30:59+00:00): Thank you Hjart, will use SDFE next time!
erickdeoliveiraleal (2022-04-17 13:43:52+00:00): Porque renomeou esta via para sem nome? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/635633956/history Se ela não tem nome, deixe em branco.
sejohnson (2018-11-10 18:04:15+00:00): Hi! Really good job tagging here. Keep up the good work!
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63794741
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:25:07+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий, мультиполигонов, что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 20:55:54+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 20:47:12+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:24:55+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий, мультиполигонов, что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 21:01:05+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
sejohnson (2018-11-09 20:36:09+00:00): Hi! Tagging looks very good, but you should trace the building outline so it corresponds to the building shape.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63794835
pangoSE (2018-10-26 20:07:11+00:00): Välkommen till OSM.
Visst är det kul?
Jag reagerar på din användning av leisure_1 här. Kan du utveckla.
Dessutom ska nog byggnaderna hänga ihop och rätas upp. Vet du hur man grejar det?
Mvh
Egil
PS: Gå gärna med i en Telegram-chat, https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/List_of_OSM_centric_Telegram_accounts
Finns även en specifikt för SE.
mueschel (2018-10-24 09:47:28+00:00): Hi,
you added 36 objects with the tag 'widht' instead of 'width'. Could you have a look and fix this?

Thanks, Jan
sejohnson (2018-11-10 18:05:52+00:00): Hi! Really good job tagging here. While you're editing these buildings, zoom in and realign the building outline, too, so that the corners match up. Happy mapping!
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63794884
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:24:34+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий, мультиполигонов, что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 21:00:04+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 20:47:21+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 20:49:06+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:24:16+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий, мультиполигонов, что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 20:53:15+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 20:58:11+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:24:02+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий, мультиполигонов, что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:23:48+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий, мультиполигонов, что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 21:02:37+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:23:05+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий и что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 21:03:53+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 20:56:08+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 21:01:57+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:22:47+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий и что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 20:48:42+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
mavl (2019-07-23 20:58:44+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Anakil (2018-10-23 21:22:03+00:00): Bonjour Himanthalia, l'école de langue vivante est déjà taggée sur l'entrée ici https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4898179605

Bien à toi,
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:22:32+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий и что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 20:53:31+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:22:18+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий и что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 20:52:44+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
BeKri (2018-10-24 15:03:13+00:00): Hallo,
kannst Du kurz erklären, was es soll auf dem Gebäudeumriss der Siemens-Zentrale eine power=line = Hochspannungsleitung
zu legen ?
Und was sollte Dein 2. edit für einen Sinn haben ?
Gruss derBeKri
sejohnson (2018-11-06 21:48:39+00:00): Either your building has not been squared, or tags are missing, or the digitizing is not good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63796264
Sowa1980 (2019-07-22 15:22:02+00:00): Привет, поясни причину массового удаления, и слом геометрии зданий и что ты творишь с адресацией, свои комментарии к пакетам правок, которые не соответствуют действительности и твоим действия? В противном случае , если не ответишь , буду вынужден написать жалобу в DWG, о твоем массовом вандализме, с просьбой заблокировать , тебя навсегда и откатить твои все пакеты правок в исходное состояние, до правок.
mavl (2019-07-23 20:56:17+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 72564652, 72570564, 72574884 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: damage, copyrighted source].
sejohnson (2018-11-06 21:47:53+00:00): Either your building has not been squared, or tags are missing, or the digitizing is not good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63796835
sejohnson (2018-11-06 21:47:42+00:00): Either your building has not been squared, or tags are missing, or the digitizing is not good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63796858
sejohnson (2018-11-06 21:47:05+00:00): You need to faithfully trace each building outline, rather than drawing a loop around them.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/63796888
deuzeffe (2018-10-31 14:26:50+00:00): Bonjour,

Bienvenue parmi les contributeurs d'osm. Un peu d'aide ? C'est par ici : https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/FR:WikiProject_France/bienvenue

Si le restaurant est fermé pour pouvez éventuellement supprimer le point ou bien utiliser les valeurs vacant ou disused ou abandonned comme proposé ici : https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/FR:Tag:shop%3Dvacant

Bonne cartographie avec osm !
4b696d (2018-10-24 11:53:41+00:00): Yes but it is part of the ocean and thus not natural=water. The taxiways are bridges and not dams. I mapped it accordingly some days ago but the rendering of the ocean will still take some time.
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Coastline#Rendering_in_Standard_tile_layer_on_openstreetmap.org
xkillah (2022-01-23 13:22:07+00:00): дзынь https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/2890736
Nakaner-repair (2018-10-23 16:07:36+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 63801823 where the changeset comment is: Revert changeset 63797656 due to adding fictional data near (0,0) in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. OSM is no sandbox, vandalism not tolerated.
Nakaner (2018-10-23 16:09:00+00:00): Hi Lathifah AI,

welcome to OpenStreetMap.

I have reverted this changeset (and therefore deleted your additions and restored your deletions). Please do not add fake data (e.g. roads in the Atlantic Ocean) to OpenStreetMap. OSM is a serious project, not a sandbox. Your contributions go live immediately and millions of users rely on it.

Best regards

Michael
Diego Krein (2018-12-15 14:56:08+00:00): Estimado Usuario Steenbuck. Le quiero solicitar por favor, si va a cambiar algunos tag de mapeo de terceras personas, por favor no borres o elimines los demás tag. Muchas gracias
muralito (2018-12-16 00:01:57+00:00): Diego, es correcto lo que plantea Steenbuck, los parques eolicos se mapean como relaciones y los miembros de esa relacion son los aerogeneradores, las subestaciones y otros elementos que la componen, tal cual se plantea en la wiki que acompaña su cambio.
muralito (2018-12-16 00:03:49+00:00): La justificacion de eso es que los aerogeneradores son algo disperso, y ademas usualmente el suelo se continua usando para produccion agricola/ganadera.
Nakaner (2018-10-25 13:40:18+00:00): Hi,

you have added Estonian names for various locations all over the world from a third party source in this changeset.

When did you discuss this import on the Imports mailing list as required by the Import Guidelines? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines

Where is the explicit permission of the copyright owner documented which allows us to use the data? The license statement at the source you linked is not compatible with our licensing:

"The data of KNAB may be freely used provided that the source is quoted. Extensive usage of the data (e.g. if a monograph, gazetteer or a map is based on the data of KNAB) will be possible on the presumption that the compiler of the database be informed of this usage beforehand. There will be no charge for the use of data, instead the user might receive information on the completeness and reliability of the data he/she needs."

Please pause your import until these issues are resolved.

Best regards

Michael
Pikse (2018-10-25 20:29:56+00:00): This is the source that I've used for copying/checking individual names. I didn't consider this as an import. I've queried nodes based on place/population key value and then I've tried to provide adequate localized names. In order to make sure that names are reliable I've checked names from this database or from print atlas (referenced in another changeset).

I'm not sure what extent of use of this database amounts to "extensive usage". I've verified a few hundreds of names based on it, which is a tiny portion of about 478K names that the database has. I didn't copy any additional name variants for individual places nor other metadata specific to this database. So I'd rather think I haven't infringed rights of the maker of database.

For the most part these names are romanized based on rules that are not exclusive to this database nor is any general idea on how to romanize names copyrightable. So I could romanize these names myself based on the same rules. This would be just considerable more time consuming for me. And if I did then it'd be still favourable to check the result against source like this database.

Are you sure you are not overly rigid about this? Or what would be more preferable way to localize place names then? After all, individual names are not copyrighted and it should be possible to localize every single place name without acquiring any permission.
Nakaner (2018-10-25 22:45:24+00:00): Hi,

if it is not clear how to understand the terms of use, OSM usually takes a whiter than white view and refrains from using the data.

The terms of use describe a gazetter as "extensive usage". OSM allows any use of its data, a gazetter is quite common (e.g. Nominatim). The terms require us to informed the compiler of the database before any use. Our license does not require that. It does not require a credit to KNAB.

The license is not compatible with OSM from my point of view. Could you please revert your edits (remove added tags, change modified tags back, …)?

You are free to disagree with me. I appreciate it if you use the Talk or Legal-talk mailing list in that case.

Best regards

Michael
Pikse (2018-10-26 07:46:48+00:00): Terms of use that you refer to do not really tell that using, say, ten names or a few hundred names in a product like gazetter is "extensive use". I discussed this aspect above you haven't explained where in this matter lies the reasonable doubt that given use might be extensive.

I've read import guidelines and I now also read some other copyright related OSM documentation. To sum up my previous comment I don't see why do you think that import guidelines apply here in the first place. This in my opinion is not aligned with common sense.

Should someone really copy significant amount of data from KNAB, say, including coordinates for place name placement, specific selection of name variants for objects etc. that'd allow recognizing KNAB as data source then sure, I'd understand why you'd think that sui generis database rights or other sorts of rights of the maker of database might be infringed. In this case however use of this database amounts to merely checking what is the common place name in Estonian for individual places.

Another way to go would be to not provide any source at all, and say that name variants given are common/preferred in Estonian. So that anyone knowing the language and subject can compare the data addition with any reliable source that they like (or re-romanize them using appropriate rules). However, I believe it's more friendly towards other OSM contributors wanting to review to provide some particular direction for review (as I did here).

Note that there can be two distinct purposes for providing a source. One is verifiability and another is attributing the author. My intended use for source key here was the first one. To my understanding use of source key is not restricted to attribution.

I've also checked histories for various place name label nodes that I've touched. For name variants added in other languages I generally don't see reference to any source or permission. Source would be nice for these, but making into a legal problem probably wouldn't be reasonable as an individual name variant used in a language usually really is a common knowledge.

So, I don't think that I've really violated a policy or some other reasonable and common practise here, and I don't see a good reason for revert. As explained above, currently it's unclear what the actual legal problem might here, and I don't know what exactly should be discussed in a mailing list. If you still think that there is reasonable doubt about infringing someone's rights, then I'd be grateful if you did bring this up in an appropriate venue, so that my comments given above were reflected and so that it would be referenced here.
Nakaner (2018-10-26 11:37:38+00:00): Hi Pikse,

I contacted the OSMF Data Working Group and would like to ask you to pause the "import" until they respond.

Best regards

Michael
Pikse (2018-10-26 13:25:56+00:00): I haven't added any localized names after your first comment here. I also wasn't planning to add more names at the moment since I'm more or less done with providing Estonian names for major cities (based on place/population key value). However I expect that work on adding localized names should continue in future and I still expect that in order to ensure data quality some sort of source should be provided for verification.

For further background information, my work on these names relates to Wikimedia's effort to provide localized map tiles for its projects. Compared to larger languages number of names available for Estonian is rather low at the moment. There's a Wikimedia blog post about it [1].

Regarding data working group's input on this, am I going to be contacted about this as a related party? Or should I make my own enquiry? So that I'd know what exactly did you ask, and in order to know how to provide a source for verification so that it wasn't mistaken for an import source.

[1] https://blog.wikimedia.org/2018/06/28/interactive-maps-now-in-your-language/
Nakaner (2018-10-26 13:31:03+00:00): If you come from the Wikimedia community, please read https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Welcome_to_Wikipedia_users It describes the main differences between Wikipedia/Wikidata and OSM.

Please also note that name:<lang>=* should not be added if it is a transliteration only which can be generated by a computer programme automatically. That is done already for the map at openstreetmap.de which transliterates all non-Latin names if no German, English or French name is tagged. (It's open source)

The map service of WMF does not transliterate automatically but that's a problem of their service and must not be a reason to add names to OSM. Such issues have to be resolve by the consumer. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer

The Data Working Group will comment to this changeset. You don't have to do anything yourself.