piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
marc__marc (2020-01-15 16:00:09+00:00): as said before, a hard rule in josm or at the api level would not solve the problem because there are usecases where a huge bbox is justified. if you change the train relation in moscow-paris https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/7363930, if you change the relation France https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/2202162 , that 'll use a hudge bbox size. but in this case you don't change a bar in London and a restaurant in Brazil in the same changeset, make it easy for mapper to understand what's modified.
i will however consider making a ticket to josm to cause a "huge bbox" alert when that happens.
however if you don't understand the remark about mecanical edit and if this alert exists, i guess you'll click "ok continue, I don't care". 
I 'll also start a thread in talk mailing if ppl agree to add itin https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_practice

Regards,
Marc
pangoSE (2020-01-15 16:20:36+00:00): Good idea to both create an alert and discuss it in a wider forum and add it to good practice. I refer beginners a lot to read good practice. It would also be easier for you to comment linking there on any annoying changeset like this.
SomeoneElse (2020-01-17 13:45:08+00:00): @pangoSE In this changeset discussion you seem to be "victim-blaming" all of the people who have commented on your change here.  Please don't do this.  OpenStreetMap is a shared project - we need to work together to create the best map, and telling people that are trying to help you that "there is a problem with the QA tools that they are using" is not helpful.
pangoSE (2020-01-17 16:02:20+00:00): @SomeoneElse thanks for the heads up. I never heard about this before. 
This is a quote from the Wikipedia page: "A typical expression of victim blaming is the "asking for it" idiom, e.g. "she was asking for it" said of a victim of violence or sexual assault."
I have no intention of projecting such an attitude, but I was interesed in finding effective solutions to the problem.
Even though these changesets don't personally bother me much (as I seldom do QA because there are almost noone else editing in my main interest areas) I see that the deficiencies in our tooling makes it hard to do QA when these changesets muddy the water.
I hope we can increase the awareness of this, because I think effective QA is very very important to keep the quality high on the data.
BTW is there a way in OSM to say monitor all changes made to objects with certain tags like amenity=shelter within an area?
SomeoneElse (2020-01-17 16:22:54+00:00): > BTW is there a way in OSM to say monitor all changes made to objects with certain tags like amenity=shelter within an area?

I cant think of any service that provides that effectively at the moment, to be honest.
Timur_Crimea (2020-01-14 19:45:19+00:00): По данным Википедии Юбилейное озеро также имеет название Бирюзовое - https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/79578847#map=17/44.59337/34.31841
Timur_Crimea (2020-01-14 19:50:26+00:00): Вот фото схемы Запрудного, которая расположена на ул.Советская -
https://prnt.sc/pfhzgd
там написано про двойное название озера
Слава Ляшук (2020-01-15 04:07:54+00:00): Я сейчас пытаюсь это исправить. Получается замкнутый круг, Википедия ссылается на карту а карта на википедию. У нашего озера всегда было и есть только одно название (историческое) Юбилейное. Бирюзовое это ошибка которую быстро распространили разные источники копирующие информацию друг у друга. Пытаюсь это исправить
Слава Ляшук (2020-01-15 04:08:36+00:00): Этот стенд сделал я, теперь понимаю что допустил ошибку указав неверное название - бирюзовое. Хотел постепенно вернуть историческое название Юбилейное для всех туристов. Теперь на стенде будет указанно только одно название - Юбилейное. Знаю людей которые в 1975 году трудились над строительством этого озера (водохранилища), и считаю недопустимым самовольно каверкать, переименовывать исторические названия объектов и топонимов.
Timur_Crimea (2020-01-17 08:08:23+00:00): Ответил вам в личные сообщения.
IgorEliezer (2020-01-17 18:50:32+00:00): Olá,

Preciso informar algo: estes pedaços não são construções separadas, mas partes da edificação que contém dados da altura, forma, telhado e acabamento, e compõe o 3D da igreja, como se pode ver aqui
https://demo.f4map.com/#lat=-23.4458958&lon=-46.9138420&zoom=20&camera.theta=54.454&camera.phi=-136.546

Não se preocupe, isso já corrigimos e aproveitamos as suas edições que são muito mais que bem-vindas.

Quando tiver dúvidas ou precisa de ajuda, fique a vontade de nos contactar no nosso grupo do Telegram ou no fórum: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Canais_para_contato.
nickvet419 (2020-01-16 12:06:56+00:00): had to fix broken relations along the lake
nickvet419 (2020-01-16 12:08:02+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/79649254
Arnaud Champollion (2020-01-14 21:47:04+00:00): Je crois que tu peux ajouter le nom de l'oeuvre :
L’eau et l'homme ou la transcendance de  ses  substance
si c'est bien celle-là : view-source:http://www.musee-de-faykod.com/wa_p_albums/p_album_iqe3oy3r0/iu44vow21dtttcl5hc/thumb/sans%20titre-5_(1).jpg

J'ai trouvé le nom dans le code source de la page view-source:http://www.musee-de-faykod.com/sculptures.html
lefanahp (2020-01-15 10:39:06+00:00): ok, j'ai ajouté "marbre" mais concernant les autres modifs que tu proposes, je ne sais pas bien faire. Tu peux les faire toi-même si tu veux.
lefanahp (2020-01-15 10:43:06+00:00): concernant le nom de la sculpture, je n'ai trouvé que "fontaine sculpture" sur son site. Modifie si tu as qqchose de mieux (l'eau et l'homme...")
Arnaud Champollion (2020-01-15 21:41:54+00:00): En fait ça n'apparaît pas directement sur la partie visible du site, mais si on fait CTRL-U, on peut lire le code HTML de la page, et on voit :
<a href="wa_p_albums/p_album_iqe3oy3r0/iu44vow21dtttcl5hc/sans%20titre-5_(1).jpg" title="Digne-les-Bains : 
									1990 - Fontaine sculpture :
									" L’eau et l'homme ou la transcendance de  ses  substance "  
									Hauteur : 3m 
									Marbre de Carrare
kreuzschnabel (2020-01-25 17:08:58+00:00): Danke für den zügigen Revert. Leider kam der Export von Magic Earth dazwischen, da ist der Fehler jetzt bis zum nächsten Kartenupdate drin :( bin da heute durchgefahren und hab mich schwerst gewundert.
mueschel (2020-01-16 17:33:06+00:00): Please make sure you add street names with the proper name tag.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/763213564/history
Be careful using copy and paste, this ends up as its own tag.
Mel_1 (2020-01-17 15:42:02+00:00): Thank you for correcting this for me. I appreciate the feedback. I will keep an eye out for that.
viloan (2020-01-14 19:33:33+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
iandees (2020-01-14 20:11:23+00:00): Hiya! Welcome to OSM. Thanks for editing the map and adding this sidewalk. This is right in my neighborhood, so if you ever have any questions please let me know.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79580216
BS97n (2020-01-14 20:14:09+00:00): Hello, I have uploaded a change shortly after you did, which overwrote your changes. I tried to fix this, but can you please check if everything is correct?
Jrachi (2020-12-25 14:34:51+00:00): Sul serio?
Il sentiero si chiama così?
Jrachi (2020-12-25 14:39:50+00:00): Se fa parte di un percorso mtb ti invito ad usare una relazione e non di mettere un nome "inventato".
Grazie e Buone feste!
Constable (2020-12-25 18:27:37+00:00): Sul serio?
dovresti chiedere a chi ha inserito quel nome perché lo ha fatto, io con questa modifica ho semplicemente modificato l'attacco del sentiero all'estremità sud, ignorando completamente il nome già presente.
Il gruppo di modifiche che dovrebbe interessarti è il https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=65989894
Grazie per aver corretto l'errore.
Jrachi (2020-12-25 18:38:57+00:00): Grazie a te.
E Buone feste mappanti
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:09:04+00:00): The PAWS shelter building looks bigger than anything in the imagery. Can you adjust the size to the imagery?
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79581017
TheGamerInq (2020-01-18 19:50:41+00:00): Thanks for the help. I just altered the size to what think the exact main building was. I didn't know where it started so I just mapped what I believed to be the whole complex.
Glassman (2020-01-18 23:31:51+00:00): That looks great! Happy mapping!
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:50:05+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Don't add any private information from residential or owner to a residential building!
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:48:54+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please noticed: An address is part of the (main) building, not of the highway or property.
andrewwiseman (2020-01-14 23:26:40+00:00): Thanks for mapping! When mapping buildings make sure to click the q on your keyboard, that will make sure the buildings have 90 degree corners
Andrej S (2020-01-15 10:59:01+00:00): Что здесь находится?
Кто знает, подскажите пожалуйста.
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:10:24+00:00): Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it look good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79581213
yumean1119 (2020-01-15 04:28:54+00:00): Thank you so much for fixing road connection errors which I have made!
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:10:34+00:00): Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it look good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79581456
furiouso (2020-01-14 22:07:38+00:00): Happy to discuss!
Cebderby (2020-01-16 11:00:44+00:00): I've reverted this changeset as a section of Hawksley Avenue, and also a short section of Saltergate, got dragged sideways along with ways connected to them, see https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=79581556

I can't see what change was intended (changeset comment refers to post office??) so any intended change would need to be re-applied, regards Cebderby (Clive)
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:47:25+00:00): Welcoem to OSM! Please use the standard values for access (see https://wiki.osm.org/wiki/Key:access)
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:10:41+00:00): Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it look good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79581578
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:11:13+00:00): Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it look good.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79581703
andrewwiseman (2020-01-15 01:20:35+00:00): Thanks for mapping. The "name" field should be the proper name of the thing, like McDonald's or Main Street, not a description like "House on White Ct." If you don't have a proper name you can just leave that field blank. Hope this helps!
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:12:12+00:00): You might want to look at opensidewalks.com for tips on adding sidewalks. It's a project by UW's Taskar Center for Accessible Technology.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79581870
user_5359 (2020-01-15 04:28:44+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please save your work before you change the area.

Please notice a playground isn't a park. See https://www.osm.org/node/7131956984

What is the meaning of delivery=F14 on https://www.osm.org/node/7131959991? (see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:delivery)

You add no standard keys (contains spaces and upper charactes) on https://www.osm.org/way/763227942 and https://www.osm.org/way/763227947: What ist the meaning?
InsertUser (2020-01-14 21:27:31+00:00): This deletes the wikidata tag too. Might be a good idea to transfer it to the new relation?
cartogram (2020-01-14 22:00:18+00:00): Thanks, I added it!
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:41:45+00:00): Welcome to OSM! 
The address and an additional description of use is usually not the name of a building. 
Is the parking lot really a building or just a surface parking lot (see Tag:amenity=parking). 
We also have a tag for a restaurant (amenity=restaurant) and the name belongs to the restaurant and not to a corner of the building.
I recommend the web site http://wiki.openstreetmap.org.
tordans (2020-01-14 21:03:21+00:00): Geoportal Berlin / Berlin Zoom
Anakil (2020-01-15 18:03:14+00:00): Bonjour Miloose,

Comme tu le demandes, j'ai regardé ton édit ici et à première vue aucun soucis ! C'est très bien fait pour une édition basée sur l'imagerie (évite d'utiliser bing (je vois dans le changeset qu'il est indiqué que tu l'as regardée aussi ;-) ) car elle est vraiment TRES vieille en Belgique). Pour améliorer encore, quelques pistes à regarder :

- Tu peux tagger les bâtiments avec leur type (par exemple, un bâtiment résidentiel "building=residential"; une maison "building=house"; des appartements "building=apartment"; un magasin "building=retail"; "building=garage" pour un garage de maison; ... voir le wiki OSM [https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:building] pour plus d'infos sur les valeurs possibles). A noter que pour ce qui est des bâtiments résidentiel, il y a une hiérarchie allant de "je sais juste que c'est résidentiel" à "je sais exactement quel type de bâtiment il s'agit" (building=residential est plus générique; building=house ou building=appartement sont déjà plus spécifiques par exemple. Et il y a des valeurs plus spécifiques que "house" aussi si tu veux indiquer plus de détails. Encore une fois, le wiki a plus d'infos). 
- Tu peux aussi évidemment ajouter d'autres informations si tu les connais comme le nombre d'étage ("building:levels"=*), l'adresse (seul le numéro et la rue suffise par chez nous), ... Un peu ce que tu veux et qui t'intéresse et connait sur les lieux. :-) 

- Au delà de ça, si tu veux tracer le plus précisément possible, tu peux te baser aussi en Wallonie sur la donnée de plan de la région Wallonne - nommée "PICC" - et disponible dans JOSM dans la catégorie d'imagerie "map" (ou "carte" j'imagine en français). Cette donnée est disponible pour tracer et a une précision <25 cm, mais par contre elle peut parfois dater d'il y a plusieurs années. Donc, il est toujours conseillé de vérifier l'imagerie wallonne (qui elle date de l'année passée au pire). Si jamais le bâtiment a changé ou est trop récent, il faut donc se "contenter" de le tracer sur l'imagerie comme tu l'as fait ici. Mais dans le cas où il est disponible sur le PICC, autant se baser dessus car cela sera plus précis. ;-) 

Happy mapping,
Anakil

PS: J'ai eu le réflexe de corriger la géométrie de ces bâtiments-ci avec le PICC, donc ils sont déjà légèrement bougé pour correspondre au PICC plus précis. Je me suis dis seulement après que tu aurais peut-être voulu éditer toi-même. :p
Miloose (2020-01-15 20:27:04+00:00): Merci pour ces explications. En effet, le PICC est bien plus facile que la carte du SPW. Je vais me baser là-dessus.
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:31:37+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Note that in OSM classification of the objects has the highest priority. Objects that have only name and description, have little sense. As home page for the question "How do I describe you?" I recommend the web site http://wiki.openstreetmap.org.
See also https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dbicycle_parking
Glassman (2020-01-15 03:13:30+00:00): All of your edits look good. Good luck in class.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79582629
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:29:27+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please be careful when editing the map data. You moved the node https://www.osm.org/way/106993287/history over 100 meters, so there were problems with the corresponding way.I move the node back to the original position.
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:26:24+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please notice the difference between description and name. You didn't need a tag name=playground if you has the tag leisure=playground (for example).
andrewwiseman (2020-01-14 23:23:13+00:00): Thanks for mapping! Keep it up. For restaurants, you can also add the cuisine, like mexican, pizza etc.
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:23:45+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please be careful when editing the map data. You moved the node https://www.osm.org/node/6369014603/history over 100 meters, so there were problems with the corresponding way. I move the node back to the original position.
jharpster (2020-01-14 23:39:55+00:00): Looks like E Kelso Lane doesn't align very well next to the river and other nearby roads. Might want to go back and have another look.
user_5359 (2020-01-15 05:18:31+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please be careful when editing the map data. You moved two nodes over 100 meters, so there were problems with the corresponding way. I completely reversed your change set.
See https://www.osm.org/node/4932664721/history and https://www.osm.org/node/6907754543
ndm (2020-01-14 21:32:02+00:00): Did you check these -- the N Bristol one still had signage visible yesterday -- please revert your change.
UKChris (2020-01-15 19:05:59+00:00): Hi ndm,

I'm sorry if you're not happy with my edit. Mothercare no longer trade in their own stores (https://osm.mathmos.net/ghosts/mothercare/) and only now appear as a stock selection in select Boots stores.

I don't think it's accurate mapping to have store data attached to a node or way if the store data, in this case for Mothercare, is out of date and the store doesn't actually trade there.

If you feel this is incorrect, for example if OSM protocol has another way of marking out stores that have ceased trading, then do let me know what this is, or feel free to re-add the data yourself, but I'm not prepared to revert old data back into an edit if I don't believe it represents up to date information, again, unless a different approach is preferred.
ndm (2020-01-15 20:46:51+00:00): Mostly reverted in https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/79621483
UKChris (2020-01-16 18:58:24+00:00): Was hiding a personal jib as the source of a revert to a changeset that you didn't agree with really necessary? Rather than, for example, something like "here's a preferred way of doing things"?
ndm (2020-01-16 21:40:12+00:00): Nope, it's my default source for edits which don't use surveys / satellite data or other imagery, e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/79169813

This is the approach some Bristol mappers have been using: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Bristol#Lifecycle -- like everything in OSM there are other opinions.
skquinn (2021-12-26 17:35:23+00:00): Hi,

When converting a road to divided, please remember to update the lane counts and lane use. In addition to validator warnings being thrown when others map the area, note that GPS navigation software uses this data and will no longer be able to make logical lane choice recommendations if it is out of date or clearly erroneous. Thanks!
Polarbear-repair (2020-03-06 01:27:19+00:00): Deleting large landuse relations without any refinement; leaving outer ways orphaned.
DWG Ticket#2020022910000011
Polarbear-repair (2020-03-06 01:25:11+00:00): Deleting large landuse relations without any refinement; leaving outer ways orphaned.

DWG Ticket#2020022910000011
!bm (2020-01-15 18:39:42+00:00): Hey alxpa!
Und wie sieht der Zugang von der anderen Seite (v Norden) aus? access=no für den gesamten Weg? Bauzaun permanent/temporär? Evt dort auf node als barrier=fence,fence_type=construction,access=no? Außerdem: name="Michis Weg"?
--besteGrüße!bm
Leo Slager (2020-01-14 22:02:04+00:00): ik heb het een klein beetje aangepast:
amenity=atm
name=   verwijderd, daardoor wordt het juiste symbool en de naam Rabobank zichtbaar op de  kaart.
M!dgard (2020-02-08 12:47:34+00:00): Hoi, conversie is een specifieke term: omzetting tussen gelijk- en wisselstroom. Hier gebeurt dat niet, voor zover ik kan zien op de luchtbeelden en infosites over Gemini. Daarom kan dit volgens mij geen converterstation genoemd worden.
phidauex (2020-01-14 22:41:34+00:00): Hi, welcome to the map! A few suggestions - square up your buildings by using the "q" shortcut, and don't use the "name" tag for personal information - remember that this is a public map - you don't want the entire world knowing that this is "Brett's House". :)
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79584090
andrewwiseman (2020-01-14 23:22:23+00:00): Thanks for mapping. Is Chinese Kitchen still in the same location?
AlaskaDave (2021-09-20 23:21:00+00:00): Hi,

I came across a node you added called Franklin Perch tagged with natural=cliff in Eugene near the Spliff Cliff. I cannot find any reference to it on the Internet. Perhaps it's a local name for this place?

If it's not officially named Franklin Perch I'd suggest changing the "name" tag to "loc_name" and changing the natural=cliff tag to either tourism=viewpoint or tourism=attraction.

What do you think?
phidauex (2020-01-14 22:39:48+00:00): Hi, welcome to the map! Don't forget to square your buildings by using the "q" shortcut, and please don't use the "name" tag to add your name, or things like "My garage" - this is the public map open to the whole world, and you don't want personal information or notes like that included.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/79584289
andrewwiseman (2020-01-14 23:21:12+00:00): Looks good, thanks for mapping
ndm (2020-01-14 23:26:46+00:00): Looking on Bing Streetside:
1). There's no signage for a no U-turn.
2). The traffic lights / road markings do have straight ahead only arrows though.
andrewwiseman (2020-01-14 23:28:22+00:00): Thanks for mapping! When mapping buildings don't forget to click the q on your keyboard, that will make the corners 90 degrees
viloan (2020-01-14 22:34:20+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!