piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
LockOnGuy (2022-09-17 19:02:03+00:00): @ChehrehBargi again, Iraq do not have text names on residential street, only numbers, the address for the houses are like District 900, Alley 10, House 20, there is no text name for the street. I'm talking about local knowledge of my country this is for all of Iraq. you are forging not local and you probably misunderstood what you saw.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-18 05:38:23+00:00): I recorded what I saw. Official signs with the name Tariq al-Jannat were written all along the path of this alley.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-18 06:19:50+00:00): Read my comments again. you don't have knowledge of the numbering and naming system in Iraq, WE DO NOT HAVE TEXT NAMES FOR RESIDENTIAL STREETS! read my comments again and try to understand.
Nawfal85 (2022-09-18 11:59:26+00:00): Hi ChehrehBargi,
What you see on the signs on the road that says “طريق الجنة” were placed by the owners of the Husseini processions, and it is not an official name for this alley, as the alleys in Iraq do not have names but numbers, and in general, every road in Iraq from north and south leads to Karbala It really is the way to heaven, also I would like to note that طريق written as "Tareeq" not "Tariq" which mean طارق, This proves that these signs are placed by ordinary people, not the government.
Finally, I wish you an acceptable ziyarat al-arbaeen, and have a nice time in Iraq.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-19 16:27:59+00:00): Dear user @Nawfal85
Accept my thanks and gratitude. My goal was to help complete the map and I didn't know that the boards were not official. I appreciate your courtesy and attention.
Nawfal85 (2022-09-19 16:56:00+00:00): Thank you, ChehrehBargi for your understanding of the rules and principles of naming and numbering streets and alleys in Iraq.
We appreciate your efforts to improve the map, but modifications must be appropriate, agreed upon locally, and conform to the terms of OpenStreetMaps.
good luck...
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-23 05:49:37+00:00): All of our efforts are for legal registration and the fruition of the efforts of all editors.
Thank you for your attention
SekeRob (2022-09-19 13:37:54+00:00): Ciao,

v.v. l'area di costruzione, strade o  inclusivo i terreno nel triangolo?
Penso che sia solo una rotatoria e alcune strade secondo la tua descrizione sull'oggetto dell'area di costruzione.

Ho notato che le linee degli autobus che passano lì sono apparentemente tutte interrotte.
SimonTheGolds (2022-09-19 17:06:08+00:00): Hi. I don't quite understand what you mean: I prefer to speak English. The construction area refers to the land in the triangle, in which they are going  to building a parking lot. The 8-shape roundabout is almost done, so I've already drawn it. Yeah... the bus lines are interrupted, but they are all wrong and need to be redone (they have not been updated for at least 7 years).
SekeRob (2022-09-19 17:41:47+00:00): OK, in that case the construction=motorway needs to change to construction=amenity, add a note= tag with your description of the planned work (parking lot), and if you have start date and an (magnana magnana) delivery/completion date, fill those out as well. Then the system will ask when it's time if the work is done.

If the work has not started, (start date in future)  than actually it's not construction but proposed.

Bus 19 I've fixed with chg of name per convention. Bus Rimini 1 is unclear whether it runs clock or anticlock. The part on the 8-roundabout suggests it's clock wise. The other 2 lines I did not check what wrong with those.

cheers
eggie (2022-09-17 09:42:09+00:00): Tip. 212 D zit ergens rechts op het gebouw. ..
Maar ik vermoed dat het met organic maps wat lastig is om het dan op de juiste plek te krijgen.
Dan toch met een reguliere editor samenvoegen.
Gr eggie
eggie (2022-09-17 16:08:39+00:00): Info samengevoegd met adresnode
mavl (2022-09-24 04:59:41+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 126568781 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [Reason: wrong statuses of the roads - https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/6393].
gnlpfth (2022-09-17 17:49:09+00:00): Hallo,

bitte beachte 
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Namen#name_ist_nur_der_Name

Konkret beziehe ich mich unter anderem auf die von dir mit "name=Klinik Hietzing" versehenen Parkanlagen, die diesen Namen eben nicht haben. LG
Girolamo (2022-09-17 18:30:16+00:00): Das ist doch die Klinik Hietzing!
gnlpfth (2022-09-18 14:04:33+00:00): Eben nicht! Die Klinik Hietzing ist die Klinik, und nicht der Park
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-17 18:10:21+00:00): The names of these columns are not temporary. Registered by official boards. You delete these on purpose. You have a problem with Hosseini's Arbaeen ceremony. You have ruined my efforts in change packages 126289353 and 126289362 and 126289165 and 126288821 and 126288860 and 126289205 and 126289375 and 126289381 and 126290421 and 126290035 and 126289402
LockOnGuy (2022-09-17 18:19:54+00:00): @ChehrehBargi read changeset comment. These numbers are not official, the numbers from the ministry of electricity are kilometer based. these are mades unofficially.     
You can not add them as electricity pole number as that's would be horribly wrong.     
You might be okay to map as information=guidepost but never pole number because that's wrong.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-17 18:55:54+00:00): These are put by the government so they are official. Regarding the name approved by the Ministry of Electricity, that name can be added instead of erasing the entire issue. It just looks like vandalism.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-17 18:58:32+00:00): No street lamps dont have such numbing. The government and the ministry of electricity have different numbering system, you are not local and do not know what you are talking about.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-18 05:36:11+00:00): Instead of deleting the light towers that I registered, you could have added the numbers or names that the Ministry of Energy has given. The map is improved with the cooperation of all editors. You are tyrannical and tyrannical. You have no right to ruin other people's efforts. For these columns, the government has numbered them (of course, I agree that this numbering was done specifically for Arbaeen, but it was done by the Iraqi government and can be registered)
LockOnGuy (2022-09-18 06:17:08+00:00): Stop spam commenting, I already answered you in https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/126290750
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-19 16:19:16+00:00): Our difference is in numbering. According to wiki rules, I can record anything on earth, and deleting you is considered vandalism.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-19 16:22:51+00:00): You added a “street lamp” with “xxx” number. Is that correct? The answer is no.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-23 05:55:21+00:00): Do you answer your own question?
We have explained in your previous posts, instead of removing the electric pole, you could have left the number of the green signs and added the number of the Ministry of Energy.
mavl (2022-09-24 04:59:44+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 126568781 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [Reason: wrong statuses of the roads - https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/6393].
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-17 18:11:34+00:00): The names of these columns are not temporary. Registered by official boards. You delete these on purpose. You have a problem with Hosseini's Arbaeen ceremony. You have ruined my efforts in change packages 126289353 and 126289362 and 126289165 and 126288821 and 126288860 and 126289205 and 126289375 and 126289381 and 126290421 and 126290035 and 126289402
LockOnGuy (2022-09-17 18:16:18+00:00): @ChehrehBargi read changeset comment.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-17 18:56:53+00:00): These are put by the government so they are official. Regarding the name approved by the Ministry of Electricity, that name can be added instead of erasing the entire issue. It just looks like vandalism.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-17 18:59:25+00:00): No street lamps dont have such numbing. The government and the ministry of electricity have different numbering system, you are not local and do not know what you are talking about.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-18 05:34:14+00:00): Instead of deleting the light towers that I registered, you could have added the numbers or names that the Ministry of Energy has given. The map is improved with the cooperation of all editors. You are tyrannical and tyrannical. You have no right to ruin other people's efforts. For these columns, the government has numbered them (of course, I agree that this numbering was done specifically for Arbaeen, but it was done by the Iraqi government and can be registered)
LockOnGuy (2022-09-18 06:13:13+00:00): The numbering of ministry of electricity is based on kilometer distance from the city gate. like , pole 25km then pole 26km etc... these are the official numbering by the ministry of electricity.    
This numbering system was made since tens of years and still in use, some of the poles was outside the city so even now with the city getting bigger, it still have the old numbering. I do not have the numbers for each pole but this one was innocent so I removed it. please stop arguing and try to understand, you are not local, we are.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-19 16:15:27+00:00): You could have put both names instead of removing the location of the power tower. But due to the absence of the number of the Ministry of Electricity, you have completely deleted it. According to the rules of wiki, everything on earth can be recorded.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-19 16:24:50+00:00): No, we don’t put fake names/numbers.    
If someone put a fake number on his house, should we add the fake number to osm? No.
iriman (2022-09-19 17:01:03+00:00): > Instead of deleting the light towers that I registered, you could have added the numbers or names that the Ministry of Energy has given. The map is improved with the cooperation of all editors

Hi ChehrehBargi, I agree with you. In addition to what you said,
I see that mappers add the number of these poles in their addressing:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5692924022/history
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6698816686
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4682002789
They are so useful and easy-to-use for addressing specially on long highways like this. 
Probably there were more of this addressing but deleted in his massive mechanical cleanups.

Also each number is written on two separate green boards in Arabic and English scripts for example ۲۰ and 20.
 
Sometimes there is another single old board in white with same number that remained from past on the same pole but the green ones are newer.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-19 17:21:49+00:00): >you could have added the numbers or names that the Ministry of Energy has given. The map is improved with the cooperation of all editors        

Hi, I do not know the exact numbering of them but I know the one that was added is wrong.          
The ministry of electricity uses kilometer based numbering, like "pole killo40" or "pole killo50" etc..     
The number your added is "guide post" not the number of the pole.      

>but deleted in his massive mechanical cleanups.        
I adviced you to read and understand the words your using before saying it, as I do examine each single node I edit.     
read: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_edits      
My cleanups of spam are approved and requested by the Iraqi OSM community, if you disagree? head up to @osm_iraq to complain.            
        
Regards.
iriman (2022-09-19 18:02:18+00:00): > I adviced you to read and understand the words your using before saying it, as I do examine each single node I edit. 

I'm the translator of that page in Persian. 

Some examples:

you removed a wall from https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/126248699
because you say places are unregistered. Even removing the main features is wrong and you should add more attributes to describe the existing features. What you do with other closed map platforms that you don't have freedom like here?

Also you think mechanical:

On https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/120182604 you said that "بین الحرمین" is a descriptive name while I recently saw the sign of that place on a big blue board in three languages: ar, fa, en.
No need to repeat that you reverted that changeset fully, i.e. without keeping the changes that in your opinion were good.

https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/121515664
You removed the name:fa of Najaf airport because "it doesn't match with the name on wikidata"!

Aren't these mechanical and without use of common sense?

> head up to @osm_iraq to complain.
Why should I come to a group that a vandal "lockdownguy" invited someone to join there? Search in group for lockdownguy.
LockOnGuy (2022-09-19 18:56:44+00:00): > I'm the translator of that page in Persian.     
Translating and understanding is totally different things.          
       
The examples you gave should read the comments again if you still do not understand, or tell me what do you no understand yet.         
               
About the group, if a user invited another user to a group, that will make you don't want to join a group?         
We the Iraqi user invite people to join our community to discuss and to help them if they have a problem.       
             
I advice you to stick with things you have local or at least some knowledge of, as I had fixed many errors you made here in my country.  it's not wrong to map without local knowledge it is absolutely fine but local knowledge is always the way to go.             
             
Here in OSM we should all be bold and edit and fix errors, we shall not hesitate to edit the map.         
               
Best Regards.
ChehrehBargi (2022-09-23 05:16:50+00:00): Hello and thank you dear @iriman
Ditto for your efforts Mr. @LockOnGuy
Note that the problem is caused by @LockOnGuy removing it instead of fixing it. In addition, I have seen electricity poles and the numbers of the Ministry of Energy are not visible on them. Only the numbers of the green boards are visible. In the case of other boards, such as Najaf airport or Bin al-Haramain, this is not a descriptive term and it is the specific name of those places that can be registered there, but you delete them.
FJili (2022-09-21 02:31:52+00:00): 
您好，我对这个变更有异议，城市快速路仍然有出入口编号与目的地路牌，这个标注目的应该是这个原因，并且主要道路使用motorway_junction也是可以的，详见
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dmotorway_junction
我会希望回退变更，望您知悉
85Bas (2022-09-17 10:01:22+00:00): Korte argumentatie:

Bij vergelijking van de Diepenring en aansluitende wegen met "echte" secondary-wegen als Stationsweg en Petrus Campersingel (qua wegbeeld en rol die vervuld wordt) is er steeds meer een duidelijk onderscheid te maken. Recente veranderingen in wegprofiel (twee naar één rijstrook met fietsstroken), wegomgeving (van verkeers- naar verblijfsgebied) en maximumsnelheid (deels van 50 naar 30) hebben hieraan bijgedragen en er komen meer veranderingen aan die dezelfde lijn volgen.

Hoewel er aan de Bedumerweg niets veranderd is heb ik deze ook deels naar tertiary omgezet om een "doodlopende" secondary te voorkomen.
85Bas (2022-09-17 10:02:28+00:00): Zie ook de reacties op deze changeset: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/123977297
Jan Wilts (2022-09-17 11:02:26+00:00): Lijkt me goed!
martiensch (2022-09-18 11:35:29+00:00): Top!
user_5359 (2022-09-22 19:28:26+00:00): Hello! Please have a look on http://www.osm.org/way/1095349142. what is the meaning of the tag di = di?
Leo Slager (2022-09-25 10:36:25+00:00): no reaction of mapper.
removed non-existing key.
Ropino (2022-09-29 18:50:06+00:00): Hallo,
warum hast du in der tmc-Relation aus "class" -> "highway" gemacht?
Welche Bedeutung soll highway=P3.3 haben?
VG
AmmoBox (2022-09-30 16:52:42+00:00): Ich hab eigentlich nur ein Zufahrtsweg auf oneway gestellt sonst habe ich keine Änderungen vorgenommen.
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=126292235
Ropino (2022-10-06 09:32:39+00:00): Ich habe es jetzt auf den vorherigen Stand zurükcgesetzt.
Jbah (2024-02-12 17:08:42+00:00): Moin, warum hast du das access=permissive zu access=no geandert auf https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/930465509/ ?
Vor Ort gibt es keine entsprechende Beschilderung fuer "access=no", ausser ich hab sie uebersehen.
Hab es wieder zu access=permissive geaendert
limes11 (2022-10-07 20:03:24+00:00): Hi, 

du hast hier viele footways mit bicycle=designated ausgezeichnet. Das kann so nicht stimmen. 

Sind das ausgezeichnete Rad- und Fußwege? Dann hw=path+bicycle=designated+foot=designated

Sind das einfache Gehwege mit Fahrrad frei? Dann highway=footway+bicycle=yes

Und falls da überhaupt nichts stehts, dann nur highway=footway, dann sind Räder nicht erlaubt.

VG, Limes
DCA (2022-10-08 05:43:34+00:00): die Friedensallee hat komplett separate Fahrradwege, also segregated. Mir kam es neulich so vor, als hätte jemand eingezeichnete Radwege zurückgezeichnet, entfernt. Vielleicht herrscht da jetzt kuddelmuddel? hab's mir nicht im Detail angesehen.
limes11 (2022-10-08 10:36:49+00:00): Habe mir gerade die Mapillary-Bilder angesehen. Der Radweg/Radfahrstreifen verläuft mal auf der Straße, mal separat. Hier müsste man tatsächlich Zeit investieren, um dies entlang der Friedensallee korrekt zu erfassen, ggf. auch mit leichten Abweichungen, um die Sache nicht zu unübersichtlich zu gestalten
DCA (2022-10-08 11:27:11+00:00): Ich wohne da. Die Friedensallee hat komplett separate von der A7 bis BHF Bahrenfeld, nördlich teilweise sogar baulich getrennt vom Fußweg verlaufend. Unter der S-Bahnbrücke verschwenk auf Fahrbahn. dann wieder ab Griegstraße Fahrradwege. Ich bin der Meinung, das war auch alles so schon eingezeichnet...
limes11 (2022-10-08 20:58:39+00:00): Nein. Hier sind nur parallel verlaufende Gehwege eingezeichnet, auf denen Fahrräder in Schrittgeschwindigkeit toleriert werden ("Fahrrad frei"), keine Fahrradwege. Und seit Deiner Änderung auch Gehwege mit bicycle=designated, was nicht stimmen kann.
eggie (2022-09-17 13:58:18+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privebericht. 

MVG, 

Eggie 

Namens de OSM Community
OttoR (2022-09-18 09:54:06+00:00): Dag Teek,
Wordt hier een zo'n groot huis gebouwd half over het eiland / half in het water?

Ook heb je de wegstructuur aangepast; terwijl dit juist bedoeld was om onderscheid te maken tussen het karrepad, de formele wandelpaden en de olifantenpaadjes.

Tot slot weik je met de embankement af van wat er door landmeters in de BGT is gezet en wat ook op de AHN te zien is als hoogteverschil.

Groet,

Otto
silversurfer83 (2022-09-27 09:46:41+00:00): Moin Joma,

bei dieser ehemaligen Haltestelle https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1095355106 wäre dann doch ein Lifecycle Prefix angebracht, oder?
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Lifecycle_prefix
Andernfalls denken die Datenauswerter, dass diese noch genutzt wird.

Grüße
silversurfer83
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/126293413
SomeoneElse (2022-09-17 12:14:17+00:00): Hello Пивчанський,
Please use changeset comments that explain what you actually changed.  See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Uk:Good_changeset_comments .
Best Regards,
Andy
SomeoneElse (2022-09-17 12:14:45+00:00): Привіт Півчанський,
Будь ласка, використовуйте коментарі до набору змін, які пояснюють, що ви насправді змінили. Перегляньте https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Uk:Good_changeset_comments.
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді
Frans S (2022-09-19 10:31:11+00:00): Thanks for your contribution to this project. 
I am a Sr Validator and review mapped tasks at random or as requested. 
You also did not tag the buildings here.
Please be sure to square each building with the Q key as well.



Explanation can be found on this document what  might be helpful to improve your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit


Best regards and keep mapping !
Frans S
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/126294046
Frans S (2022-09-19 10:20:18+00:00): Thanks for your contribution to this project. 
I am a Sr Validator and review mapped tasks at random or as requested. 
I am sorry to say, but your mappings are not that accurate and in according to the HOT/ OSM quality standards.
Please pay attention to next points:
* Buildings not always accurately drawn and squared. Please pay more attention to follow the outlines of a building (with extensions).

You did not tag the buildings as building=yes




Explanation can be found on this document what  might be helpful to improve your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit


Best regards and keep mapping !
Frans S
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/126294149
NieWnen (2022-09-17 11:18:20+00:00): *nie te źródło (zostało z poprzedniego)
literan (2022-09-18 19:12:12+00:00): Название памятника указывается в следующем формате[1]:

если памятник имеет имя собственное (например, node «Тысячелетие России»), то в теге name в любом случае указывается именно оно: name=Тысячелетие России.
если памятник имени собственного не имеет, то указывается name без слова «памятник/стела/бюст/…», например:
name=Воинам-интернационалистам,
name=Жертвам политических репрессий.
Если он посвящён (установлен в память об) определённой личности, в теге name указывается фамилия с инициалами в дательном падеже:
name=В. И. Ленину.
Дополнительно, независимо от того, имеет ли памятник имя собственное или нет, указывается, кому (или чему) он посвящён, причем ФИО человека указывается развернуто в именительном падеже:
memorial:subject=Владимир Ильич Ленин.

поправил
literan (2022-09-18 10:31:57+00:00): добрый день

правильный формат адреса - 30 с1 (а не 30 ст1).

поправлю.
osmviborg (2022-09-17 12:18:55+00:00): Navner var i forvejen tilføjet landuse=farmyard
osmviborg (2022-09-17 12:19:05+00:00): * Navnet
Mateusz Konieczny (2025-05-04 06:14:03+00:00): Hello! https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/10031438132/history has shop = vegetables that was added in this edit
shop=vegetables ? Maybe shop=greengrocer was intended? If they truly sell solely only vegetables then maybe extra tag like greengrocer=vegetables would be better? If they sell also fruits then https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:shop=greengrocer is definitely better.

shop=greengrocer is far more widely used and supported and does fit even if only variety of vegetables is sold.

But maybe another shop tag would fit better? Maybe shop=farm? ( https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:shop=farm )
barnes38 (2025-05-05 23:44:19+00:00): Hello

 Thank you for your question

Vegetables seem appropriate and greengrocer does not seem appropriate, but they sell as well some plants. Is is not a general farm neither, a farm sellings vegetables and some plants only
Vinber-Pro (2022-09-26 09:58:26+00:00): Salut,
j'avais vu passer un article, même pas le temps de l'ajouter que cela y ait déja ! trop classe. Merci ! je me suis permis de le mettre dans le batiment, si j'ai bien compris le principe et de préciser qu'il faut être "client" pour y avoir accès. Qu'en penses-tu ?
bonne journée
Shohreh (2022-09-26 11:45:33+00:00): Hello

Comme tu veux, je ne suis pas un local de l'étape
38446 (2022-09-25 17:01:09+00:00): Bitte gib die Quellen der (historischen) Namen an, vgl. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:place%3Dlocality
Das schützt auch den Bestand deiner Arbeit, falls jemand sich sagt: "Noch nie gehört, dass das hier so genannt wird, steht auch kein Schild irgendwo, also weg damit!"
pitscheplatsch (2022-11-17 10:50:36+00:00): Hi Семён Семёнов,

may we know the source of your mapping? Thanks.
Семён Семёнов (2022-11-17 11:34:20+00:00): https://cgkipd.ru/science/names/reestry-gkgn.php
pitscheplatsch (2022-11-19 16:43:56+00:00): Thanks for your answer.

Do you know the following pages?

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines
pitscheplatsch (2022-11-17 10:50:51+00:00): Hi Семён Семёнов,

may we know the source of your mapping? Thanks.
pitscheplatsch (2022-11-17 10:51:08+00:00): Hi Семён Семёнов,

may we know the source of your mapping? Thanks.