piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
xronos (2020-04-21 23:07:48+00:00): а пока ведется дискуссия мне бы хотелось чтоб вы восстановили удаленные тэги.
flohoff (2021-08-27 10:28:06+00:00): Moin,
du hast hier am Geringshof die zufahrten alle mit "access=no" getagged. Warum? Wie sind die denn Beschildert?

Flo
kartonage (2020-04-11 23:01:46+00:00): Hej s_Frantz,

in this changeset you have copied the contents of an anymous note with the description containing "nicht die Verkäufer bespucken !" which roughly translates to "don't spit on the salesperson!".
Do you think this low quality comment is appropriate or valuable for OpenStreetMap? Since this seems like a somewhat automated process of converting anonymous notes to OSM data, what checks are there to verify validity of that information and is there any qualitative measure to filter descriptions/comments? Do you translate the description to understand their meaning? A check on the Radthaus Steglitz website for instance shows me that they also are open for sale and not only for repairs, as the description you have added now claims.

Best regards
s_Frantz (2020-04-12 06:31:21+00:00): Hallo,

Für den zweiten, "Werkstatt geöffnet" ist nicht "*Nur* Werkstatt geöffnet".
Für den ersten, "Abstand halten, Hände waschen" ist Perfekt, "nicht die Verkäufer bespucken !" ist vielleicht übermäßig, aber ich kenne nicht die Schlossstrasse in Berlin. Oder Humor ? ;)

Das original caresteouvert.fr oder das Projekt bleibtoffen.de geben schnelle und vorübergehende Informationen.
Manchmal nicht die Beste, ich stimme zu.
Wir können nicht alles controlieren, nur eine schnelle Sortierung machen. Wieviel shop=* in Deutschland ?

Ich hoffe mein deutsch ist verständlich ;)

Bon dimanche / Guten Sonntag / Good Sunday !
mapman44 (2020-04-11 21:50:07+00:00): Please do not delete existing objects and then re-draw essentially the same objects. Instead edit the existing objects so the editing history is preserved.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83411943
Frans S (2020-04-13 12:13:54+00:00): Hello.
A remark here.
Please square all rectangular buildings you map with the IDeditor Q key, 
You did not square a single building 
 A building can be recognized by the shadow it gives. No or a very tiny shadow means the object is very low (little wall) or no object at all ( piece of farmland)
Please correct these issues
Girabawe (2020-04-13 15:58:26+00:00): I am afraid I don't understand what you mean by "squaring". Can you give me an example or is there any tutorial I can refer to?
Frans S (2020-04-13 17:08:18+00:00): please take a look here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1YJV6I_rhY&list=PLb9506_-6FMHZ3nwn9heri3xjQKrSq1hN&index=8&t=0s  
Squaring of buildings is mentioned on 1.20 minute
please take the time to review this as well
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/
best regards
mapman44 (2020-04-11 21:49:36+00:00): Please do not delete existing objects and then re-draw essentially the same objects. Instead edit the existing objects so the editing history is preserved. This was mentioned to you a few days ago.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83412013
Frans S (2020-04-13 12:08:22+00:00): Hello, Thanks for mapping here
Please search the area on a 30-40mtr scale to locate buildings.
When mapping a highway which continues in another task block, please map it over the edge so other mappers can continue in that block.
Best regards
Vinber-Pro (2020-04-12 07:36:47+00:00): Bonjour,
j'ai l'impression qu'il y a une fusion de la boite aux lettres, de la poste et de l'office de tourisme :)
Est-ce le cas ?

Car tout est sur un seul point ?
yoyoatvg (2020-04-12 07:46:40+00:00): bonjour Vincent
oui c'est exactement ça. que ce soit à Gavarnie  ou Gèdre le point poste communal est situé dans le bâtiment de l'OT. 
les boîtes aux lettres extérieures sont collées aux bâtiments. 
c'est pour ça que j'ai tagé comme ça. 
Par contre j'ai pas trouvé le tag point poste communal, donc j'ai mis post_partner mais ce n'est sans doute pas bon
Vinber-Pro (2020-04-12 09:39:11+00:00): de préférence donc :
amenity=post_box devant (je le fais)

et pour le point poste communal, je réfléchis :)

Disons que les amenity, amenity_1, amenity_2 sont rarement employés car en particulier peu exploitables, sans doute est-il préférable de faire plusieurs points !

Dans tous les cas on complète, on améliore, cela s'affine, merci
Vinber-Pro (2020-04-12 09:43:24+00:00): j'ai retiré également un wikipedia fr milaris, car ne renvoie à aucune page sur wikipếdia (du moins aucune page trouvée) !
yoyoatvg (2020-04-12 09:48:06+00:00): oui je l'ai vu hier soir mais je ne sais pas qui l'a mis. je n'ai pas créé cette fiche avec le nom milaris, juste mis à jour ...si c'est moi qui ai fait alors je ne m'en suis même pas rendu compte. mais j'ai du enfaire d'autres comme ça sans vouloir. en voulant aller vite...ou en cherchant des astuces...
Vinber-Pro (2020-04-12 10:06:28+00:00): yep, je vais essayer de regarder cela.
Attention à ne pas aller trop vite, car outre le fait que cela peut faire quelques bugs et que ceux sont des erreurs, c'est aussi que cela ne peut pas être utilisé derrière :)
à plus
yoyoatvg (2020-04-12 10:09:15+00:00): oui c'est pour ça que je ne serai jamais informaticien...je suis trop impatient et j'aime trop fouiné pour trouver des astuces...mdr
bon appétit
Sowa1980 (2020-05-20 18:19:10+00:00): Привет, сделайте свои правки пожалуйста, более компактными, что бы другие участники могли их просмотреть, доступными средствами, для контроля правок в OSM, по чему они накрывают весь земной шар?  Надеюсь в преть Ваши правки будут менее глобальными. Согласовывайте импорт, перетегирование и удаление тегов с местным сообществом. В противном случае будет откачено
Спасибо за понимание.
praeteritum (2023-08-01 12:00:30+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 139296682.
mapman44 (2020-04-12 12:37:05+00:00): Hello, athlonwirez, and thanks for your edits and your interest in OSM. Just a tip...you can square up the corners of houses by selecting and pressing the "Q" key. Makes them look much neater.
athlonwirez (2020-04-14 17:16:00+00:00): Thanks!
sskalyan (2020-04-15 11:37:29+00:00): Hi,

Greetings for the day.
This changeset created lot of unintended errors https://snipboard.io/0ZAHm8.jpg like this one. And many driveways are now connected to side path, which completely restricts motor vehicle routing into driveways
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/375425004 like this one. This was earlier a proper dual carriageway, what is the reason behind reverting the edit? Please let us know the inconsistency with this road so that we can fill in gaps, instead of reverting the complete edit.

Thanks,
Kalyan
compdude (2020-05-02 17:10:05+00:00): Yes, please revert this edit. There was a reason why this road was dual carriageway because it shows that you can't cross the median. This is very important for proper routing because you don't want people to be directed to turn left across the median when this is physically impossible to do.

Again, please change this back to how it was before. Thanks!
compdude (2020-05-02 17:11:45+00:00): Also I think you broke the intersection with 85th and 132nd. I'm going to fix that, but please make this road divided again.
compdude (2020-05-02 17:17:42+00:00): You also deleted the name of this road. You really need to be more careful about this when you make edits to OSM.
praeteritum (2023-07-31 04:03:28+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 139233405.
aixbrick (2020-04-14 09:51:14+00:00): Hier lautet die Frage: Warum wurde der auf Luftbildern eindeutig sichtbare Weg gelöscht?
feingeist (2020-04-14 10:37:59+00:00): Region wurde heute nochmal überarbeitet - mit Parkplatz und Weg
aixbrick (2020-04-14 09:48:57+00:00): Hallo,
warum wurde das Restaurant aus dem Gebäudeumriss heraus verschoben?
Gruß
feingeist (2020-04-14 10:39:15+00:00): Region wurde heute nochmal überarbeitet - mit Restaurantdaten, position und Wege-Typen
Frans S (2020-04-13 12:47:25+00:00): Hello. Thanks for mapping here,
A few remarks, 
You forgot to square a lot of buildings.,
Please square all buildings with the Q key in IDeditor
Not all buildings have been mapped either,
You add tag layer=1 to some buildings. Why?
This tag is used at bridges to show the river is a nivo lower than the street, of at a service station that the roof Layer+1 is above the under laying service road
Please pay also attention on the issues reported by the Issue triangle at the righthand menu. Please solve the issues before uploading your work.
Best regards
btw This task will be invalidated
UKChris (2020-05-18 11:59:58+00:00): Hi, did you mean to set this area as a retail area rather than a very large cafe?
user_3022894 (2020-05-30 12:01:39+00:00): Hi TS-R,
vielen Dank für das Hinzufügen der Schwebebahnstützen. Ich wollte dir nur kurz Bescheid geben, dass ich bei einigen von diesen die Position nach einem aktuellen Orthofoto nochmal verfeinert habe, das dortige Luftbild ist noch genauer als Bing oder Esri. Nur als Info, damit du dich nicht später eventuell wundern würdest, falls du auf das Bing-Bild schaust und die Stützen dann verschoben aussehen. Viele Grüße, Lukas
TS-R (2020-05-30 16:28:08+00:00): Hallo Lukas,
vielen Danke für die Verbesserungen. Ich hatte letztens schon gelesen, dass für NRW die Orthofotos jetzt in 10cm Auflösung zur Verfügung stehen. Das ist wohl noch etwas um was ich euch, neben der Schwebebahn, beneide ;-).

Viele Grüße
Thomas
user_3022894 (2020-05-30 19:08:33+00:00): Oh ja, es gibt leider noch einige Regionen ohne solch "schöne" Luftbilder und ohne solch eine schöne Schwebebahn. Grüße zurück!
Warin61 (2020-05-02 03:56:02+00:00): Phillip Island Nature Park boundary restored to position.
mapman44 (2020-04-12 01:37:47+00:00): Hello, BBAROO, and thank you for your interest in OSM. Could you please explain why you deleted Crockett Springs Road and the parking aisles for the golf course?
mapman44 (2020-04-12 19:01:36+00:00): Please review this page in the Wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Vandalism
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83414429
mapman44 (2020-04-13 14:08:14+00:00): This changeset has been partially reverted in changeset 83481701 to restore data that should not have been deleted.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83414429
marczoutendijk (2020-04-14 13:12:12+00:00): User blocked until hi replies to DWG.

Marc Zoutendijk  
OpenStreetMap Foundation  
Data Working Group
marczoutendijk (2020-04-15 21:08:31+00:00): User replied. Block removed.

Marc Zoutendijk  
OpenStreetMap Foundation  
Data Working Group
mapman44 (2020-04-12 01:44:25+00:00): Please review the Terms of Use for Zillow at: https://www.zillow.com/corp/Terms.htm

It appears that any data acquired from their website can be used for personal use only.

Also see the Wiki page about using copyrighted data: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Copyright
mapman44 (2020-04-13 20:23:43+00:00): Thanks for your edit but your changeset raises questions. What needed fixing? What did you do to fix it? Good changeset comments help other editors understand your edits, and are a basic good practice in OSM. Please take a look at this Wiki article:  https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
martinrpayne1993 (2020-04-13 20:57:40+00:00): Howdy Mapman! Thank you for the notes. I've left a response with some questions on my other changes. Looking forward to hearing/learning form you, and thank you for reaching out!
tux67 (2020-04-15 09:57:03+00:00): Hi jpohl1,
du hattest ein Review requested. Nach dem, was du eingetragen hast waren noch weitere Beschränkungen nötig um's komplett zu machen.
Schau mal ob's so passt:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/83582591
Gruß
tux67
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83414553
praeteritum (2023-07-31 04:02:29+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 139233389.
praeteritum (2023-07-30 06:15:01+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 139196360.
mapman44 (2020-04-12 12:47:55+00:00): Why did you delete Andrew Crockett Court and driveways? This is map data that people use and deleting it because you preparing the golf course for a game is unacceptable. Please restore the streets you have deleted.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83414971
mapman44 (2020-04-12 19:01:49+00:00): Please review this page in the Wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Vandalism
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83414971
mapman44 (2020-04-13 14:04:50+00:00): This changeset has been partially reverted in changeset 83481315 to restore data that should not have been deleted.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83414971
marczoutendijk (2020-04-14 13:12:20+00:00): User blocked until hi replies to DWG.

Marc Zoutendijk  
OpenStreetMap Foundation  
Data Working Group
marczoutendijk (2020-04-15 21:07:33+00:00): Reply received. Block removed.

Marc Zoutendijk  
OpenStreetMap Foundation  
Data Working Group
tastrax (2020-05-07 02:05:14+00:00): Hi folks FYI - Phone numbers in Australia should be added according to the following format +61 x xxxx xxxx, or use the phone:AU key if a 1300 or 1800 number as per the wiki guidelines https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Australian_Tagging_Guidelines - I have just updated a recent addition that you made to OSM – Cheers
woodpeck (2020-05-04 19:57:16+00:00): Hello archie, it is correct that a semicolon is the default separator for multiple values, however the addr:housenumber field does not use this default. See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/House_numbers/Karlsruhe_Schema for a documentation of the Karlsruhe Schema which mandates the use of a comma.
archie (2020-05-05 01:43:38+00:00): Thank you. Most intressting. This leads to two questions:

1.) why isn't this pointed out more clearly in https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Addresses "Buildings with multiple house numbers"?

2.) why is there a separat delimiter for address? Are there any other instances where semicolon is not the valid delimiter?
woodpeck (2020-05-05 07:34:53+00:00): I think the reason for this discrepancy might be that the "Karlsruhe Schema" for addresses predates the establishment of the semicolon as a default separator. The reason why I became aware of the issue is that the OSM inspector flags house numbers containing semicolons as errors, and when I checked with the developers the answer was that the semicolon is indeed wrong (https://github.com/ltog/osmi-addresses/issues/118). I shall update the wiki page you pointed to with that information.
archie (2020-05-05 15:10:25+00:00): Ok, thanks for clarification. Thanks also for the mail :-)
tomasy (2020-06-16 05:17:22+00:00): Please revert your changes
tomasy (2020-04-13 21:59:51+00:00): Men enligt https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Addresses kan man använda kommatecken "Separate the numbers by commas (e.g., 11,13,15) or semicolon (e.g., 11;13;15)". Om man använder kommatecken så blir det också enklare att använda "OSM Inspector"
archie (2020-04-14 00:51:33+00:00): Jag känner väl till vad wikin säger om saken, men på vilket sätt påverkas osmi?
tomasy (2020-04-14 04:41:36+00:00): OSM Inspector föredrar kommatecken och på så sätt så får man mindre varnngar och hittar lättare fel. Men eftersom det inte är fel att ha kommatecken kan du väl gör revert på dina ändrinar. Det är dessutom vanligare att använda kommatecken än semikolon
archie (2020-04-14 06:10:34+00:00): På vilket sätt "föredrar" osmi kommatecken?
tomasy (2020-04-14 09:47:19+00:00): Please Archie, revert your changes. What I did was not wrong according to the page above. I do not see what is the purpose of your changes.
archie (2020-04-14 10:24:22+00:00): tomasy, please, answer my latest question, thank you.
tomasy (2020-04-14 21:13:29+00:00): I did some updates. Most of the address I changed was created by me. I changed from semicolon to comma to separate addresses. This is the most common way to do to. See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Addresses It is also OK to use semicolon, but I want to do it in the most common way. I just ask you to revert your changes. 
If you will not do this please tell me why you are reverting my changes.
archie (2020-04-15 05:30:06+00:00): I am still awaiting your answer to my question in what way does Openstreet Inspector "like" comma (,) as seperator för mulitple values better than semicolon (;)?
You brought up this argument yourself along with the statement that comma-seperation is more common (allthough wiki states that semicolon is standard and doesn't say anything about commas on how much more common). 
In your latest comment - which did not answer my request for claification about OSM inspector - you supplement your originally two arguments by alluding that you have some sort of ownership of those cs or addresses because you have edited them before and that no-one else should dare to touch "your" edits. I must confess that I was not aware that this kind of exclusiveness existed in osm. 
In order to answer your request for revert, I have to know all facts. 
Hence: in what way does OSM inspector prefer comma-seperating above semicolon-seperating?
tomasy (2020-04-15 18:01:08+00:00): You are always so nice. I did not say I had ownership of something. I have put a lot of effort to add addresses so I try to keep the in a good shape. I often use OSM Inspector to find faults. The inspector did not like the semicolons and I checked if this was a fault or not.  I found that that commas was also  accepted and changed to see if this was a better. So now I had explained why I did this. 
Are you satisfied? Please, can you now answer why you did the change so I can understand why I can not use commas.
archie (2020-04-16 10:47:27+00:00): Dear tomasy, thanks for explaining (at last) and thank you for your devoted work with addresses! As you know - and as has been pointed out often - third-party applications (such as editor's auto-error-detection or as in this case OMS inspector) do not govern the choice of wich tags to use. As to your question in your latest comment (in fine); might the comment of the changeset give you a clue (just scroll up)?
tomasy (2020-04-16 17:42:14+00:00): As always, no answer. You say that semicolon is default, but the page say you can use both commas and semicolon. I don't think it is good if you change to what you prefer if both are accepted.  "Just because you would like to tag in another way, doesn't mean you are right."
archie (2020-04-17 09:05:09+00:00): Autch, watch your argumentation! This argument could as well be applied to your own cs, changing from valid semicolon to comma. Housenumbers were correctly and validly tagged (multiples seperated by semicolon) before you changed. To cite from your latest comment "I don't think it is good if you change to what you prefer if both are accepted. "Just because you would like to tag in another way, doesn't mean you are right." (citation: tomasy)".
tomasy, you should really ponder on the sentence "Cogito, ergo sum"
tomasy (2020-04-17 20:08:22+00:00): Still no answer. Is it allowed to use commas or not? How hard can it be to answer.
archie (2020-04-17 20:32:53+00:00): Cogito, ergo sum - apparently you havn't given any thought about it.
tomasy (2020-04-19 09:12:07+00:00): I think this is a type of vandalism.

I do a mapping and you revert my change without telling what was incorrect of my change. Sometimes you can do a mapping in 2 different ways and both are correct. I gave a motivation and my change was not a change of what someone else has done. (I do not say I "own" my mapping, just telling I did a change of what I have added before). The answers I got from you are not understandable. If I change again will you revert it? Please do not revert without first check with the contributor.

And... why do you create changesets without telling why. There are a VERY lot of changesets with comment "Puts - adjustments" with source "Aggregate". It is very hard to understand what those changesets add for type of value more than just a changeset to your list of number of changesets that you have produced. Please, stop with this. Use Comments and Source in a meaningful way.
archie (2020-04-19 12:21:38+00:00): go for it
vhoff (2020-11-12 14:05:24+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/2317584 is still broken
mapman44 (2020-04-12 06:28:02+00:00): This changeset has been reverted. Please do not experiment on the map.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83415339
Apexpromgt (2020-04-12 19:07:01+00:00): Hello,

I'm really sorry about that. I was testing out the system to see what it could do.
mapman44 (2020-04-12 19:25:20+00:00): No problem. It's fixed now and all is well.
mapman44 (2020-04-12 03:22:17+00:00): Hello, Apexromgt, and thank you for your interest in OSM. What are you testing? You have changed a street into a tram so what is the source of your information? When did Salem get a tram? Please understand that the only things put on OSM should actually exist in the real world and anything else will be deleted. Please respond. Thanks
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83415392
mapman44 (2020-04-12 06:27:33+00:00): This changeset has been reverted.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/83415392
chachafish (2020-04-17 04:13:27+00:00): Howdy :) I noticed you changed the name, "Union Station", to "Denver Union Station". Do you have a source for this? The name is simply, "Union Station". The wikidata source you added here reflects this as does the National Register of Historic Places. Thanks :) https://npgallery.nps.gov/AssetDetail/NRIS/74000571
clay_c (2020-04-18 20:24:07+00:00): Different train operators often have different names for the same station. Amtrak refers to the same station as just "Denver, Colorado" with "Union Station" as a subtitle, as is common with other major central stations around the country: https://www.amtrak.com/stations/den.html

Also, the Wikipedia article has it named this way: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denver_Union_Station

Of course, most other union stations are officially called just "Union Station" as well. But they're typically tagged with name="[city] Union Station" to avoid adding ambiguity in the national network. A train route may pass through multiple union stations, so it'd be frustrating to work on keeping the route relations sorted without having names be nationally unique.

To this end, I typically tag the building itself as close to the official name as possible. So in this case I'd have the historic train hall be named "Union Station". Sometimes I might even add the building's name to the label node (i.e. railway=station) under alt_name to help people find it with Nominatim, like Icicle Station in Leavenworth, WA: https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6997575339

But the label node could just as well just be named "Denver"! Of course, there are other railway stations in Denver, so that doesn't help data consumers disambiguate. If you choose to change the name back, please make sure people can still search for it by keeping "Denver Union Station" in another tag, such as alt_name or nat_name.

Best,

Clay
chachafish (2020-04-19 01:26:27+00:00): No problem. I'll change the name back to Union Station and add alt_name=Denver Union Station. Cheers.
AkuAnakTimur (2020-04-12 03:25:09+00:00): Error: 2.50, -7.50
hvalentim (2020-04-12 04:21:38+00:00): Reverted per changeset 83416086 due to out of sync conflicts.
marczoutendijk (2021-12-20 14:36:45+00:00): Hi GeoDave5280,
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/7393934680
What do you mean with natural=house
Must be a mistake!
Marc.
GeoDave5280 (2021-12-20 15:01:34+00:00): Fixed it.
-Dave