piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
mapman44 (2019-08-10 02:10:31+00:00): Wiki says an islet is a maximum of one square kilometer. Some of those you change look bigger than that.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/73203094
Adam Schneider (2019-08-10 04:25:07+00:00): The island/islet distinction isn't a hard-and-fast rule. If I demoted larger ones, it's because they have no special prominence locally.  Some weren't even islands anymore (those I changed to "locality"), and some didn't have names so really didn't need to be tagged as places at all.
Marych_ (2019-08-10 07:00:15+00:00): Добрый день.

Какой смвсл ставить точку котороая дублирует информацию из полигона школы?
user_5359 (2019-08-10 05:57:24+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Can we delete the key description as well?
aduxas (2019-08-10 13:46:31+00:00): Yes please.
user_5359 (2019-08-10 14:00:05+00:00): Done :)
muralito (2019-08-09 19:09:47+00:00): Hola sEzequiel98.

Para clasificar la poblacion como "city" tiene que tener mas de 100000 habitantes segun lo convenido. Ver https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Argentina/L%C3%ADmites_pol%C3%ADtico-administrativos
muralito (2019-08-09 19:16:32+00:00): ¿Cual es la fuente que usas para los 25000 habitantes? El ultimo censo dice 13.088.
stedewa (2020-08-01 13:36:55+00:00): ⚠️ ne pas confondre avec le bar voisin La Paillote.
look4book (2020-03-02 13:02:24+00:00): Kamera wieder aufgetaucht -> reaktiviert!
Palolo (2019-08-09 20:19:51+00:00): Thank you for the nice edits and cleaning up the poor mapping left by others.
maraf24 (2019-08-10 17:06:11+00:00): Bo jak ma nazwę, to jest residential?
Ta droga nie sięga tak daleko, jeszcze nie zbudowali.
maro21 (2019-08-22 02:04:37+00:00): Ja nie rysowałem ani nie przedłużałem drogi, dodałem tylko nazwę.
maraf24 (2019-09-01 20:00:05+00:00): Nieprawda, zmieniłeś kategorię z service na residential.
maro21 (2019-09-02 02:30:46+00:00): Tak, też zmieniłem, bo wg wiki "highway=service jest drogą dojazdową, która nie jest drogą publiczną". Czy uważasz, że ulica która ma nazwę nie jest drogą publiczną? Jest tam co prawda dojazd do chyba tylko jednej na razie firmy, ale nie ma bramy ani podobnych. Co sprawia że to ma być =service?
Omnific (2019-08-09 19:38:04+00:00): More spam from PolyGang, now under a new account. IP ban may be necessary.
Omnific (2019-08-09 19:42:54+00:00): Looking through old changesets, this user has been repeatedly called out for vandalism and spam. We need a permanent ban on this account.
mapman44 (2019-12-30 20:52:17+00:00): There are many nodes marked only "abandoned." What was abandoned? Can these be deleted? Are they just orphan nodes?
skoocoom (2020-02-26 00:54:48+00:00): Does not look intentional.  WestCoastTrekker, there is something off with your process.  Every individual node in many (all?) of the roads and streams that you have edited in the vicinity of Concrete are marked with abandoned=yes.  See this overpass query for reference:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/R4n
mapman44 (2020-02-26 04:48:18+00:00): Since there was no response to the questions I have fixed the problems.
fmarier (2019-08-12 17:19:54+00:00): Hi Nordpfeil, it looks like you and Matthew are both modifying the phone numbers in different ways: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/56205824

which according to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:phone?uselang=en#Usage are both valid (ITU NANP).
Nordpfeil (2019-08-13 06:30:54+00:00): Thank you for your hint. obviously maproulette is misleading users by showing the hyphen option (xxx-xxx-xxx) as to be corrected.
fmarier (2019-08-13 15:34:51+00:00): Ah, I hadn't realized it was coming from Maproulette. Thanks!
Matthew Darwin (2019-08-14 03:06:51+00:00): The maproulette challenge tells them to use it https://maproulette.org/challenge/2710

Really the maproulette challenge should be more clear on exactly the requested format.
Matthew Darwin (2019-08-14 03:25:49+00:00): I will see about getting maproulette challenge updated/cancelled.
Matthew Darwin (2019-08-21 16:05:24+00:00): The maproulette task will not be handed out to new folks automatically (if you know about it you can still access it).
Palolo (2019-08-09 20:13:52+00:00): Thank you for helping map Tanzania. Please make square corners on the buildings. Right click and choose the square option, or use the q key.
BCNorwich (2019-08-10 06:19:50+00:00): Hi, Welcome to OpenStreetMap.

Why mark a crossing on a footpath which is not mapped as nor look like a crossing point?
Also is the graffiti really formal artwork or just vandalism? I'm sure OSM would not wish to promote vandalism.

Regards Bernard.
Gazer75 (2019-08-11 08:14:30+00:00): Please describe what you did and not just use a generic "minor mods" for all changes.
literan (2019-08-10 09:51:20+00:00): и зачем вы поверх уже отрисованной трассы еще одну нарисовали?
Viki Van (2019-08-12 21:05:21+00:00): замкнул в единый круг, цель - что бы трасса отобразилась на общедоступной карте.
literan (2019-08-12 21:12:51+00:00): от круга ничего не зависит. Какая именно карта вас интересует, http://www.opensnowmap.org/ ?? Там все прекрасно отображается
abrensch (2019-08-11 16:29:36+00:00): Soll das hier mal eine Brücke werden?

https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/712378732

so hat die K 7130 jetzt erstmal ein Loch
mtb-vamp (2019-08-11 18:42:28+00:00): Hast natürlich Recht; da fehlte noch was...
Recoil16 (2021-08-11 21:02:38+00:00): Hi Lukas,

Sorry dass ich hier so ne alte Sache ausgrabe. Du hast hier am Telefon Bülowallee Ecke Strandstraße ein fixme gesetzt: "Welche Referenznummer ist die richtige? Beide stehen dran. Überprüfen durch SMS."
Ich bin nun nochmal dort vorbeigelaufen und habe folgendes vorgefunden:
Die ...00000472er ref wurde durchgestrichen und die 09919194er drübergeschrieben. Auch wurde der Standort "Poststr. 1" durchgestrichen und durch "Strandstr. 4" ersetzt.
Da die Poststraße 1 ja das ehemalige Postamt ist (jetzt Rossmann und so drin), was ja schon ein Stück weit weg ist, nehme ich an das entweder die ganze Telefonsäule oder auch nur der "Infozettel" hier in der Strandstraße wiederverwendet wurden und dementsprechend diese leidlich "korrigierten" Angaben die korrekten sind. Hier auch noch ein Foto: https://recoil.nrw/img/osm/PXL_20210804_132626797.jpg

Was meinst Du?

Grüße
Moritz
user_3022894 (2021-08-12 14:25:09+00:00): Hallo Moritz,

ach Du, das ist überhaupt kein Problem. Gerade wenn es um dieses Thema geht, aber nein, auch generell, ist es sicherlich sinnvoll, über solche Sache nochmal drüberzuschauen.

So, jetzt zur Sache:
Jap, das sieht in der Tat so aus. Da hast du Recht. Stimmt auch, die Telefonsäule (oder der Zettel) waren früher bestimmt vor dem Postamt.

Jap, okay, dann können wir ja die "drübergeschriebenen" Angaben nehmen, würde ich sagen. Vielen Dank, dass du da nochmal nachgeschaut hast!

Viele Grüße
Lukas
Recoil16 (2021-08-12 16:04:06+00:00): Alles klar, habe das dann so umgesetzt!
viloan (2019-08-09 20:38:18+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
Alexey Vazhnov (2019-08-10 07:38:44+00:00): Здравствуйте!
Я перемещу добавленную вами одностороннюю дорогу, чтобы она стала продолжением Привокзального переулка, мне кажется что так будет логичнее для навигаторов.
Владимир К (2019-08-10 08:49:37+00:00): Добрый день! 
Да, конечно, если там можно развернуться с переулка, то надо исправить
Alexey Vazhnov (2019-08-10 09:06:04+00:00): Да, там автобусы всё время так и выезжают.
Поправил: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/73216242
viloan (2019-08-09 20:51:29+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
eggie (2019-08-09 22:27:36+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privébericht.
eggie (2019-08-09 22:30:45+00:00): Dit is wel een een aantal stappen hoger op de ladder .. van track naar tertiaryroad. Er staat ook nog tracktype=grade2 op?  Dat is half verhard. 
Weet je het zeker?
De voorgaande mapper Allroads is een zeer ervaren mapper.
MVG,
Eggie
eggie (2019-08-09 22:51:06+00:00): reverted by changeset  #73209696
eggie (2019-08-09 22:58:30+00:00): Dit waren je edits.. https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=73207724
Hier kun je klikken op de naam van de voorgaande mapper en even overleggen. MVG,
Eggie
PaulRomkes (2019-08-10 07:38:54+00:00): Hoi Eggie, het was een track inderdaad. Maar het wordt wel onderhouden, het is gebroken asfalt onderhouden door de gemeente. Ook wordt het vooral gebuikt door de bewoners en niet door agrarische voertuigen. Je kan er vanaf het West in en vanaf de Peelrug. In het midden zit een tussen, welke een fietstunnel is.
De titel track is naar mijn idee dus onjuist.
eggie (2019-08-09 22:33:07+00:00): tracktype=grade2 geeft de hoedanigheid aan van de track en hoort niet bij een highway=tertiary
Gr eggie
eggie (2019-08-09 22:35:38+00:00): Hoe zit het ,et de verbinding met t West?
Klopt dit wel?
eggie (2019-08-09 22:42:20+00:00): Je edits zijn niet geloofwaardig. Ik draai de mutaties terug. Wanneer je nog vragen hebt stel ze gerust. Het was hier goed getagd.
Niet zomaar edits van andere mappers veranderen. Het lijkt erop dat je zomaar wat doet. Realiseer je dat al  je veranderen ook daadwerkelijk op de kaart komen. 
MVG,
Eggie
eggie (2019-08-09 22:50:16+00:00): reverted  by changeset #73209685
eggie (2019-08-09 22:56:33+00:00): Neem svp contact op met de voorgaande mapper wanneer je ingrijpende zaken veranderd. 
Dit waren je edits.  Je kunt klikken op de naam van de mapper.
MVG,
Eggie
PaulRomkes (2019-08-10 07:41:36+00:00): Hoi Eggie, als je aan kan geven wat het dan wel  zou moeten zijn? Een track is het niet naar mijn mening. Wat bedoel je met de verbinding met het West?

Groeten,

Paul
eggie (2019-08-10 08:05:56+00:00): Dag Paul,

Om met het laatste te beginnen. Je had alles veranderd, maar het laatste stukje niet. Dat is uiteraard nu niet meer te zien.
Een highway=track is niet per definitie een bosweg. 
De tracktype geeft de status van de weg aan.
Zo is tracktype=grade1 gewoon beton of geasfalteerd. tracktype=grade2 is halfverhard  (wellicht hier van toepassing)
Zie ook..
Nederlandse wiki wegentagging
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/NL:The_Netherlands_roads_tagging

tertiaryroads zijn ontsluitingwegen in wijken. Dat is hier niet het geval.
Je zou zo'n weg die wat smaller is ook als highway=unclassified kunnen taggen en dan met een surfacetag. 
surface=asphalt , smoothness=bad

Maar nogmaals.. track wordt in Nederland niet alleen voor boswegen gebruikt. 
highway=track  tracktype=grade1  (dus verhard) rendert op een aantal kaarten als een "unclassified". 
Wanneer je er unclassified van maakt dan wel de tracktype weghalen en een surfacetag toevoegen. 
Up to you. :)
Wanneer je een berichtje stuurt naar Allroads krijg je vast antwoord terug.
Er wordt vaak onderling overlegt en van Allroads kun je veel leren.
Succes en bedankt voor je reactie,
Eggie
eggie (2019-08-10 08:25:28+00:00): Hier uitleg over de tracktypes. Je ziet dat highway=track tracktype=grade1 of 2 ook wellicht overeenkomt met jouw situatie
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:tracktype
Gr Eggie
ToniE (2019-08-10 12:05:38+00:00): Hallo oberleg,

willkommen bei OSM.

Ich hätte da eine Anmerkung zu den drei Häusern:

- Sattler Huber

- Haus Laubmeier

- Haus Wolfgang Koller

Aus Datenschutzgründen und auch sonst ist es in OSM nicht erwünscht, die Adressen von Privatpersonen zu mappen.
Die Angaben sollten dann deshalb gelöscht werden.

Sollte es sich jedoch um Geschäfte, Firmen, ... oder dergleichen von Allgemeinintersse handeln, so würde ich hier noch den Typ des Geschäftes, ... mappen.

Siehe auch:

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Map_Features#Gesch.C3.A4fte

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Map_Features#Handwerk

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Map_Features#Amt_.2F_B.C3.BCro_.2F_Dienststelle_.2F_Gesch.C3.A4ftsstelle

und so weiter.

Viele Grüße und viel Spaß noch
Toni
aquarix (2019-08-11 07:23:12+00:00): Also der Wolfgang Koller ist zumindest in Glonn eine lokale Bekanntheit. Siehe https://marktgemeinde-glonn.de/2016/01/26/wolfgang-koller/

Die anderen beiden Namen sagen mir aber nichts.
Gazer75 (2019-08-09 21:49:52+00:00): Welcome to OSM. Please do not add more tags to the address tags. These are imported from Kartverket. If you want to add a business then make a new node with the relevant tags. Thank you.
bjerka (2019-08-09 22:41:39+00:00): How do I undo the changes that I did to the Address tag?
Gazer75 (2019-08-10 00:44:38+00:00): I've reverted the edit for you ;) You'd have to simply delete the new tags. The node was probably never moved.
There is a script that is run to check for new/updated addresses from Kartverket and a separate user account (add2osm) that basically do the update. For many office buildings there are multiple companies on the same address so it is best to add a new node ;)
zzptichka (2019-08-13 17:12:05+00:00): Hi, this intersection was fully reconfigured 2 years ago and it was properly mapped before you "fixed" it. See Bing (at lower zoom levels), Esri imagery. 
I'll restore it but please don't do it again. Thanks.
LogicalViolinist (2019-08-13 17:40:55+00:00): I have reverted your changeset as you obviously DID NOT survey the area locally, it's been updated 2 years ago. You are just arm chair mapping and passing it off as local survey. If you remodify this intersection again I will be reporting you to the data working group

J'ai reverté ton changement parce que tu n'as évidemment PAS VISITÉ la place en personne parce que ca FAIT 2 ANS IL A ÉTÉ MISE À JOUR. Tu fait juste du cartographiage de ton sofa et a évidemment pas fait de recherche. Si tu modifies cette intersection encore, je vais contacter le data working group
lacxavier (2019-08-14 03:07:16+00:00): Hello to both of you
A clarification I do not want to make a debate between us. I went to this intersection in the week of July 28, 2019 with my GPS (application maps.me iphone 8 +) and I did not quite the right road. I am pointing out that there is a secondary exit (Riverdale to Main) and a secondary entrance (Main to Riverdale)
(In OSM we call them highway secondary_link)
I would like you to check with BING because we see very well these TWO missing paths on OSM.
Let's work together to have the right result for the good of all.
Ottawa What a beautiful city. I'm going back this fall
Waiting for an answer.
To excuse my English, it's bad
lacxavier

Bonjour a vous deux
Une précision je ne veux surtout pas faire un débat entre nous.J'ai passer à cette intersection dans la semaine du 28 juillet 2019 avec mon gps (application maps.me iphone 8 +) et je n'avais pas tout a fait la bonne route. Je vous précise qu'il manque une sortie secondaire(Riverdale to Main) et une entrée secondaire(Main to Riverdale) 
(Dans OSM on les nomme highway secondary_link)
J'aimerais que vous vérifier avec BING car on voit très bien ces DEUX chemins manquant sur OSM.
Travaillons ensemble pour avoir le bon résultat pour le bien de tous. 
Ottawa Quelle belle ville. J'y retourne cet automne
En attente d'une réponse.
Excuser mon anglais , il est nul
lacxavier
LogicalViolinist (2019-08-14 10:53:18+00:00): The way you mapped it dates back to <July 2016 when they started construction on a new bike friendly intersection(https://www.google.com/maps/@45.4028782,-75.6743584,3a,75y,284.9h,86.14t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s7toKRFb2wDuvPIDp5zXBTQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656) The intersection now looks like this(https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=45.4026998&lng=-75.674418&z=19.689613798196362&pKey=E-_xPNzw_yYqtLvZVnd23g&focus=photo) in 2019. Don't insult our intelligence sir. Bing satellite imagery is 3+ years out of date. ESRI World Imagery has a more up to date version for that intersection

La façon tu l'as carthographié date de <Juillet 2016 quand ils ont commencer la construction pour une intersection pro-bicycle(https://www.google.com/maps/@45.4028782,-75.6743584,3a,75y,284.9h,86.14t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s7toKRFb2wDuvPIDp5zXBTQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656) L'intersection a maintenant l'aire de ceci (https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=45.4026998&lng=-75.674418&z=19.689613798196362&pKey=E-_xPNzw_yYqtLvZVnd23g&focus=photo) en 2019. Ne parles pas de ton cul. L'imagerie de Bing est 3+ ans de vieux. ESRI World Imagery a l'imagerie plus à jour pour cette intersection
lacxavier (2019-08-15 22:57:07+00:00): Hello LogicalViolinist
Thank you for your excellent information.
I see very well the configuration of the intersection on ESRI
My goal is not to change it, but to allow
GPS applications using OSM data for
 their maps work well. Which is not
 the case currently at this intersection.
From OSM I give you the link with a little bit of journey and you will see the left turn and not right
https://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=fossgis_osrm_car&route=45.40156%2C-75.67576%3B45.40210%2C-75.67406#map=17/45.40241/-75.67511
While traveling on Riverdale Avenue to
Main street I had to go right towards Smyth Road
Off as you see it at this intersection my Gps was turning me left
then do a 180 degree turn on main street to continue my
travels to Smyth road. This is a major mistake
and that's why I'm looking for the solution
if not all applications that use this data
OSM will have this error here.
I may have just found it. With JOSM I see
that there is a restriction to turn right at this intersection Ca may be from the old configuration.
If we take away this restriction, which is false, it may be that the journey will be good.
I did not delete it because I want to have your opinion on this subject.
You could take it off and we'll see you later.
We must absolutely eliminate this mistake and turn right
I will be away for a few weeks.
I keep the contact.
Thank you for your collaboration.
lacxavier
Bonjour LogicalViolinist
Merci pour tes excellents renseignements.
Je vois très bien la configuration de l'intersection sur ESRI 
Mon but n'est pas de la modifier, mais de permettre à des 
applications GPS utilisant les données OSM pour
 leurs maps de bien fonctionner. Ce qui n'est pas
 le cas actuellement à cette intersection.
À partir OSM je te donne le lien avec un petit bout de trajet et tu verra le virage à gauche et non à droite
https://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=fossgis_osrm_car&route=45.40156%2C-75.67576%3B45.40210%2C-75.67406#map=17/45.40241/-75.67511
Lors de mon trajet sur l'avenue Riverdale vers
Main street je devais aller à Droite vers Smyth Road 
Hors tel que tu le voit à cette intersection mon Gps me faisait tourner à gauche
puis fait un Virage à 180 degrés  sur main street pour continuer mon 
parcourt vers Smyth road. C'est une erreur majeur
et c'est la raison pour laquelle je cherche la solution
sinon toute les applications qui utilises ces données 
OSM auront cette erreur à cet endroit.
Je viens peut être de la trouver. Avec JOSM je constate 
qu’il y a une restriction de tourner à droite à cette intersection Ca vient peut être de l’ancienne configuration.
Si on enlève cette restriction qui est fausse peut être que le parcourt sera bon.
Je ne l’ai pas supprimer car je veux avoir ton avis sur ce sujet.
Tu pourrais l’enlever et on verra par la suite.
Nous devons absolument éliminer cette erreur et tourner à droite
Je serai absent pour quelques semaines.
Je garde le contact.
Merci pour ta collaboration.
lacxavier
LogicalViolinist (2019-08-16 00:12:16+00:00): it's old turn restrictions, I've corrected the way split around median as well as removed the old turn restrictions that were preventing right turns.

C'était des vieilles restrictions de tournage. J'ai corrigé la rue où elle vire autours de la médianne et j'ai ôté les restrictions qui t'empêchait de virer à droite
Gazer75 (2019-08-09 22:01:40+00:00): Welcome. Few things. For the road there are some tagging mistakes and some useless ones. Foot and bicycle tags are not needed as "yes" would be default anyway. Motor_vehicle=no would most likely be private instead as the road is used for service personnel going to antenna. The ford tags are not accurate as the stream is probably going in pipes under the road at these points. Covered tag is also pointless to add for this.
bjerka (2019-08-09 22:06:43+00:00): Hi and thanks for the constructive feedback :)
Gazer75 (2019-08-09 22:26:31+00:00): You're welcome. Did you see my comment on the first change you did adding a business?
OttawaHiking (2019-08-13 18:41:00+00:00): Hello! Thank you for improving the map. Additional roads, including driveways and parking roads are expected to be connected to existing roads. i.e., they have to have a connecting node with them. Navigational software would then be able to provide meaningful driving direction. Thanks again!
Luzandro (2019-08-10 05:52:12+00:00): what kind of attraction is there on the field?
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/73209192
user_5359 (2019-08-10 05:17:37+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please do not enter information twice (as nodes and buildings).
SpaLeo (2021-07-21 10:40:11+00:00): tracktype=grade1 und surface=cobblestone sind doch irgendwie ein Widerspruch?
Vor allem wenn dann auch noch smoothness=very_bad/bad dabei steht.
JochenB (2021-07-21 20:25:44+00:00): Nein ist es nicht, tracktype=grade1 hat wenig mit der Ebenheit der Oberfläche zu tun sondern sagt vor allem aus, dass sie befestigt ist. Das muss nicht Asphalt sein, es geht auch Pflaster oder Betonsteine, siehe https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Key:tracktype
SpaLeo (2021-07-22 07:18:05+00:00): Im allgemeinen wird tracktype als Hauptwert betrachtet, was sich ja auch im carto Rendering zeigt. tracktype=grade1 wird im allgemeinen als glatte Oberfläche gesehen.
Kopfsteinpflaster (in der Form wie es dort liegt) lässt sich aber schlechter befahren als die meisten Erd oder Graswege. Im Wiki steht leider nicht in welche Kategorie Kopfsteinpflaster gehört.