piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
osm915 (2022-11-10 20:37:13+00:00): Weiter gehts:
Verteilerkästen haben hat idR keine Telefonnummer, keine Webseite und auch keine Adresse.
Bitte lösche die entspr. Felder.
SekeRob (2022-11-11 09:52:29+00:00): Ciao,

Per vostra consapevolezza, ho cancellato tutti i doppi e i tripli modi relativi all'Anello delle Bregonze. Come con il tuo set di modifiche e il precedente che hai fatto, centinaia di avvisi di mappatura di percorsi non collegati e sovrapposti, quindi questo deve essere rifatto da zero come una corretta relazione di percorso, NON vie in cima, né parallele perché semplicemente non esistono.

Ci scusiamo per la perdita del tuo duro lavoro cercando di correggere, ma la rimozione doveva essere

PS Stesso messaggio inviato da PM
eggie (2022-11-10 17:40:21+00:00): Dag Ard..
Je vraagt Feedback..  Schoolstraat zie ik inderdaad ook niet in de BGT
De zendmast heb ik teruggeplaast.
Je edits
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=128737327

MVG
eggie
Lola Fox (2024-12-29 12:12:11+00:00): c'è un breve binario (doppio) della metropolitana che sembra essere in superficie nei pressi della fermata Abbiategrasso Chiesa Rossa. È un errore? Se si puoi correggere?
eggie (2022-11-10 16:09:58+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privebericht. 

Feedback.. Lijkt me oke.. alleen de format van phone is in OSM altijd +31...... 

MVG, 

Eggie 

Namens de OSM Community
MxxCon (2022-11-12 05:39:27+00:00): Hello.
When mapping pools please pay attention not to accidentally glue pool to nearby buildings, unless they are actually attached to each other.👍
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128738138
Vil4ckc (2022-11-10 16:02:37+00:00): Будь ласка не робіть по одній зміні в наборі змін
Sylvain M (2022-11-24 12:54:41+00:00): Hello,
I think there is a problem with the number of levels in the tower, which should not be 2104 (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/532793725).
It must be a typo: I let you correct it.
Have a nice day.
miroslavuzice87 (2022-11-24 13:03:24+00:00): Hello Sylvain M, thank you for pointing this out, yes, this was a typo. It is corrected now. Happy mapping.
soshial (2024-03-27 21:13:08+00:00): Hey Martin. I realized that you added this residential area with a name a year before I added neighbourhood point here. I was thinking that maybe this name "Janezova vas" probably belongs to the neighborhood more than the residential area, that could be several inside neoghbourhood... What do you think about having a neighbourhood relation like this: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/149243221
martianfreeloader (2024-03-29 12:17:43+00:00): Hi,

Thanks for reaching out. The residential area relation https://www.osm.org/relation/14869357 (Janezova vas) originated from an area that I did not create or name myself: https://www.osm.org/way/280874901/history

I simply converted it from an area to a multipolygon -- without properly documenting my work, sorry!

I totally share your view that it would be preferable to name the neighbourhood, not the residential area. Feel free to do so!
soshial (2024-04-06 06:54:39+00:00): OK, thanks. I resolved that and added other neighbourhoods as subareas to the Vrhnika town.
martianfreeloader (2024-04-06 13:11:59+00:00): Great, thanks!
Piskvor (2022-12-01 16:02:15+00:00): Kruhák vrácen z deklu od kanálu (?!?) zpátky na kruhák: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/129609939

Líbit se mi tam nemusí, ale mapujme svět, jak opravdu vypadá, ne jaký bychom ho chtěli.

Díky.
5m4u9 (2022-11-10 18:58:12+00:00): Hi, motorcar=yes is very generic, the neighbours who live on the side of the national road (highway=truck) requested these barriers to prohibit the entry of trucks...
HurricaneGator (2022-11-11 22:11:29+00:00): Hello 51114u9. I looked back at https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=505954887430596 and https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=3882359275204255 and see the signage restricting heavy vehicles on https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/10052649891 and https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5735073074. I'll go ahead and add hgv=no tags on https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/10052649891 and https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5735073074 to disallow trucks from entering these access points. Thank you for reaching out and happy mapping!
NorthCrab (2022-11-11 22:25:07+00:00): Witaj,

Kiedy ścieżka rowerowa oraz ścieżka pieszych są rozdzielone na OSM, nie używa się tagów: foot=designated, segregated=yes. Teraz nawigacja pieszych będzie prowadzić bo obu trasach, gdzie piesi nie powinni w tym przypadku iść po ścieżce rowerowej. bicycle=designated jest ok ale jest to zbędne.

Zmiany jakie wprowadzasz są okej jeśli na OSM ścieżka rowerzystów i pieszych jest złączona w 1 linię.

Bogaty przykład użyć znajdziesz w tej okolicy: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/52.20921/20.98801&layers=N
NorthCrab (2022-11-11 22:47:00+00:00): Założyłem notkę aby nie zginęło:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3438099
NorthCrab (2022-11-21 19:13:20+00:00): Lista zmian do poprawy:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128894934
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128894440
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128802568
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128738975
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128737050
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128689299
Mateusz Konieczny (2025-04-23 09:41:28+00:00): Hello! https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/10173811210/history has amenity = fixme that was added in this edit
What kind of object is here? Is it a shop? What kind of a shop? (see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:shop )
DressyPear4 (2022-11-23 16:20:44+00:00): Olá, não crie edições fictíceas
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128739062
Ropino (2022-11-17 17:44:52+00:00): Hi,
please check/correct:
maxspeed=705 --> very fast.
Thx in advance
MxxCon (2022-11-12 05:46:30+00:00): Hello.
As documented in https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions name tags should not be used as description. Is this POI actually named "Fruit Stand" or is this just a name you came up with?
Also looking at the satellite imagery this doesn't appear to be a supermarket. It seems to be just a few temporary popup tents. Perhaps a more appropriate tag would be shop=farm(https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:shop%3Dfarm) or shop=greengrocer (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:shop%3Dgreengrocer)
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128739425
A67-A67 (2022-11-11 02:41:29+00:00): Turborotonde was correct ingetekend met lanes-tags. Na deze wijziging klopte er niets meer van de voorsorteervakken en rijstroken.

Daarom teruggedraaid.
Rocket Racoon (2022-11-11 15:59:02+00:00): Excuses van voorsorteervakken en rijstroken, over het hoofd gezien
luiswoo (2022-11-10 19:25:51+00:00): Не понимаю, зачем превращать линки в магистраль, видимо в этом какой-то глубинных смысл.
user_2045215 (2022-11-11 01:44:10+00:00): В том то и дело - нет здесь линков. Здесь единая Федеральная траса А-135 отвод от М-4 к Ростову на Дону. Не понимаю что с чем здесь соединять линками. А-135 с А-135? Фигурный изгиб дороги, формальный уход трассы с прямолинейного направления не является основанием для превращения Федеральной трассы в куски из trunk и trunk_link.
luiswoo (2022-11-11 14:07:54+00:00): "Формальный" уход с трассы на развязке и есть линк (с лимитом скости 80км\ч или сколько там). Восточное шоссе и Северный подъезд к Батайску они соединяю. Линк не изолятор, ни чего с "федеральной трассой" не случиться.
user_2045215 (2022-11-11 15:28:48+00:00): Натянутый стереотип. Восточное шоссе не участвует в соединении.  Линк не меняет даже направления движения. Trunk остаётся trunk,ом. Федеральная трасса следует непрерывно и в соединениях не нуждается. Это очевидно. Линк в данном случае не соответствует правилу. "Спасибо" Архитектору который накрутил фигурные петли по ходу трассы.
Линки существенно занижают важность трассы А-135, что ломает построение маршрута по А-135.
luiswoo (2022-11-11 16:57:40+00:00): »Восточное шоссе не участвует в соединении
Шта? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1111773583#map=16/47.1664/39.7544
Линк не меняет даже направления движения
Шта2? Он должен реверсировать движение? Тут движение изменяется как в Т-образном перекрёстке — на 90°.
»Федеральная трасса следует непрерывно и в соединениях не нуждается.
Шта3? Ещё раз — линк НЕ изолятор. Он такой же важности, что и трасса.
»Линки существенно занижают важность трассы А-135
Шта4? Относительно А-135 или А-135? https://cyclowiki.org/wiki/%D0%90135_(%D0%B0%D0%B2%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%B0)
luiswoo (2022-11-11 17:15:35+00:00): "Снижение важности": https://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=graphhopper_car&route=47.0360%2C39.7410%3B47.2722%2C39.5219#map=11/47.1356/39.6486
user_2045215 (2022-11-14 05:55:07+00:00): Странная логика. Дороги сделать линками и тут же за счёт Key:maxspeed поднять скорость до 90?! Не менее странно звучит обоснование когда приоритет оттается дорогам регионального значения, а Федеральная трасса ну типа - ничего с ней
user_2045215 (2022-11-14 05:56:04+00:00): не произойдет?:
user_2045215 (2022-11-14 06:01:33+00:00): Рекомендую не упорствовать. Нет здесь никаких линков. На лицо Федеральная трасса - единая и не делимаяя. А вот с региональными  Восточное шоссе и Северный подъезд к Батайску как раз ничего не произойдет если они останутся без линков. Их вообще следует отправить в тень А-135. Дабы не путались под ногами (колёсами).
luiswoo (2022-11-14 12:19:37+00:00): На лицо Федеральная трасса - единая и не делимаяя.
»ШУЕ ППШ? Что бы такое утверждать — нужно доказать, что линк есть изолятор (дорога с меньшим приоритетом, в данном случае). По-нормальному — дорога не может так ветвиться, т-образным перекрёстком, и называться одинаково. Но если есть развязка, значит есть линки — без вариантов.
»Не менее странно звучит обоснование когда приоритет оттается дорогам регионального значения, а Федеральная трасса ну типа - ничего с ней
То есть ни странно, что "южный подъезд к г.Ростов-на-Дону от автомобильной дороги М-4 "Дон"" идёт через "Северный подъезд к г. Батайску", да?
user_2045215 (2022-11-14 15:02:34+00:00): То что дорога ветвится не значит что это линк. Иногда линком должен стать прямолинейный уасток дорги. Удивительно? Не привычно?
Линк это что? Это прежде всего сьезд. Где здесь сьезды? Как ехали по А-135, так и едем.
А вот где тот линк соединяющий региональные дороги с Федеральной трассой А-135? Это надо поискать.
От М-4 к Ростову идет А-135 - Федеральная трасса, а не какой то там "южный подъезд".
user_2045215 (2022-11-14 15:10:58+00:00): Не может одна и таже дорога быть одновременно Федеральной трассой и Дорогой регионального значения.
Кто ремонтировать будет? Федералы или Регионалы?
А у вас 60К-58 сидит на А-135. Бред.
60К-58 должна заканчиваться перед А-135 и начинаться при необходимости сразу на выезде с А-135. И не как иначе.
MxxCon (2022-11-12 05:53:16+00:00): Hello.
It would be greatly beneficial if you know and could add address, phone and biz hours of this place.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128740488
eggie (2022-11-10 20:48:03+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privebericht. 

MVG, 

Eggie 

Namens de OSM Community
pitscheplatsch (2022-11-12 09:56:35+00:00): reverted by https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128740936
pitscheplatsch (2022-11-12 09:56:44+00:00): revert of https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/128740914
MxxCon (2022-11-12 06:04:17+00:00): Hello.
Please note that for the width= tag (and some other tags) if the units of measure is not specified, it is assumed meters. Also it is a measure of the whole road width, curb to curb. 16 meters is ~52feet. And looking at the satellite imagery this road doesn't appear to be 52feet wide nor 16feet wide.

You can see more documentation of this tag at https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:width
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128741012
JayMontana36 (2022-11-12 19:39:43+00:00): Yeah, I read and understood that it was in meters, and used iD's measurement tool (several times, drawing a line from one curb to the next and deleting/cancelling that line, and then averaging/rounding the collected measurements); on average it was between 51-52 ft, and since the width is stored in meters I rounded the converted value to 16 (up from 15.5+).
MxxCon (2022-11-13 00:56:38+00:00): Hmm. For way 5698108 I just measured 34-35ft here's a screenshot
https://imgur.com/a/F4gnHzk
Are you measuring at 90' perpendicular to the road?
JayMontana36 (2022-11-13 01:43:38+00:00): No, you and I both measured in the same way, just measured different parts/areas that apparently have a different width (I measured the West-most part over by Westchester Avenue's intersection with Middletown Road) - https://imgur.com/Y4GSRY4
MxxCon (2022-11-13 01:46:32+00:00): But that's not the shortest path :)
JayMontana36 (2022-11-13 02:27:21+00:00): Yeah, I'll adjust it in a few hours if it isn't already adjusted by then, originally I didn't notice that the width shrinks, especially with the number of lanes remaining the same and just overall being in a rush.
MxxCon (2022-11-13 23:58:32+00:00): Looking at nyc's official road width records, Middeltown Road between HR and I95 varies between 42 and 48ft.
And between I95 and Stadium Ave, it varies between 32 and 35ft depending on which block.
Joseph R P (2022-11-20 03:46:28+00:00): Hello, I recommend using Bing Aerial Imagery in most of Northern Virginia when making edits to natural wood, as the Mapbox imagery is outdated by about 5 years while Bing is only about 2 years. Part of this forest was removed for new development at the winery, as per the Bing imagery of this location.
Abdullah Abdulrhman (2022-11-24 11:17:39+00:00): هذه خريطة عامة أرجوا منكم عدم إضافة أماكنك الشخصية إلى الخريطة العامة واستخدم البرامج الشخصية لحفظ أماكنك الشخصية
kechan (2022-11-10 18:50:00+00:00): can you try keeping your changesets local to prevent large edits that end up in the history tab?
brightj (2022-11-10 19:35:52+00:00): I would, but I don't know how to do that with MapComplete
brightj (2022-11-10 19:37:10+00:00): Specifically, https://kletterspots.de/
kechan (2022-11-10 21:56:05+00:00): ok, thanks!
shamraevahelen (2022-11-11 07:36:57+00:00): The link was attached accidentally,
according to the drivers feedback and Bing Maps Aerial delete access Motor Vehicles no
chris66 (2023-02-12 20:16:26+00:00): Muss "Münster (67) - Münster (83)" unbedingt in den Namen? Meiner Meinung sollte das in description...

Grüße
Chris
nurdafur (2023-02-13 06:28:35+00:00): Hallo Chris

Dem ersten Knotenpuktnetzwerk in Deutschland bin ich vor einigen Jahren begegnet. Danach immer wieder da und dort. Überall wird es nach diesem Schema kartografiert. Dies entspricht auch dem Wiki:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Tag:network:type%3Dnode_network

Liebe Grüße
Urs
dmich9 (2023-06-08 03:39:49+00:00): This changset reverts some or all of the changes in the following changesets:
129055508,129055480,129055161,129054923,129054469,129053916,129053455,129053048,129052174,129002878,129002773,129001787,129000838,128741374
This was a project I was going to take on, however there was so much bad data I had to figure out who added it.

https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/137077601
archie (2022-11-10 18:39:04+00:00): Snyggt! building=terrace för radhus. Mycket bra!
5m4u9 (2022-11-10 19:05:56+00:00): hola, a la jardinera de la ayacucho puse un barrier=planter lineal porque me parece que se ajusta más a eso, un purista de barrier=jersey no lo vería como uno.
JJIglesias (2022-11-26 06:17:25+00:00): Una barrera de Concreto elevada, aun con jardinera es un barrier=jersey.
Aunque quieras llamarlo planter:

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:barrier%3Dplanter

Eso NO es lo que hay en la Ayacucho, pero pon como te guste. Mientras aparezca me da igual.

Saludos
5m4u9 (2022-11-26 21:11:58+00:00): Lo veía más como barrier=planter porque el cajón de plantas es más que el muro inferior, pero como dices al final la estructura es un jersey porque fue construido para eso, las plantas son solo adorno.

Se quedan como jersey barrier + man_made=planter, algún rato lo cambio junto a la aroma, ayacucho y villazón.
DressyPear4 (2022-11-11 23:22:42+00:00): Por que deletar essa linha de energia?
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128742772
DressyPear4 (2022-11-11 23:18:53+00:00): Olá, não crie edições fictíceas.
Adicione apenas o que existe.
            ---
            #REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128742778
Andrea Musuruane (2022-11-12 09:51:00+00:00): Ciao. Questo nodo non va messo sul percorso del sentiero ma in corrispondenza di dove si trova la panchina. Ciao, Andrea
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128742793
silversurfer83 (2022-11-19 18:34:17+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/129134331
Revert. Hier wurden Straßen geöffnet und ein Parkplatz verzogen.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128742848
felipeeugenio (2022-11-11 13:43:22+00:00): Hola Juan. Comenté este changeset en el chat. Por favor conversemos esto. Pienso que te estás tomando demasiado en serio una fuente que encontraste. Hay cosas que funcionan en OSM un poco distinto.
saludos
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/128743090
ma-rt-in (2022-11-15 18:58:05+00:00): Hallo,

ich habe die Adresse wieder entfernt, da diese an dieser Relation falsch ist.
Die Relation bildet alle Standorte der Uni Mainz ab und ist daher nicht allgemein gültig.

vg
bxl-forever (2022-11-10 21:03:43+00:00): Hello,

I reverted this.
Osmose gives tons of false positives when it comes about streets around the border between Belgian regions.  This is because Osmose is quite a simple tool and cannot manage cases like this when the street is exactly on the border.  The best action is to ignore them.

Otherwise, names in Brussels use FR - NL, names in Flanders are NL (or NL - FR in municipalities with facilities) but definitely not FR only. ;-)
paulbrunner (2022-11-23 21:02:44+00:00): Ciao Giuseppe, 
benvenuto su OpenStreetMap! Non ho visto questa rotonda sulle immagini aeree di Bing, hai forse un' altra fonte che possiamo usare? 
Sto sistemando un po' le strade in questa zona e mi aiuterebbe avere le informazioni e fonti più recenti.
Grazie e un saluto,
Paul
Giuseppediff (2022-11-23 21:14:50+00:00): Ciao Paul,
l'unica fonte aggiornata è Google street view, li potrai vedere la rotonda in costruzione. Non ci sono al momento immagini aeree che puoi utilizzare, è molto recente, vivo in zona.
Un saluto.
Giuseppe
Giuseppediff (2022-11-23 21:16:59+00:00): Google Maps ha già aggiunto la nuova rotonda sulle sue mappe.
Un saluto.
Giuseppe
ualios (2022-11-23 22:37:03+00:00): Su Esri world imagery si vede, anche se non ancora operativa
http://osmz.ru/imagery/#18/41.01575/16.80645/esri
Sandal man (2022-11-16 12:12:34+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1112080224#map=17/38.36030/-3.57006
Estimado, se olvidó de etiquetar el camino.
Saludos Jan
CHINORRI (2022-11-16 16:02:09+00:00): Hola,efectivamente,¿Me podrías indicar cómo etiquetarlo después de haberlo subido?
Sandal man (2022-11-16 16:12:00+00:00): Hola, abre con josm, selecciona el camino y luego da la etiqueta correcta.
Luego sube upload.
CHINORRI (2022-11-16 16:12:58+00:00): Ok,muchas gracias.
CHINORRI (2022-11-16 16:40:19+00:00): Etiquetados,espero haberlo hecho bien.Muchas gracias
Sandal man (2022-11-16 19:12:22+00:00): Lo siento, pero eso no es correcto, una carretera siempre es una "Highway", consulte https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Highway_tagging_samples/out_of_town (lo siento, no es español)
camino=unclassified por lo tanto no es correcto.
Un camino también solo tiene un nombre si es oficialmente así (signo de nombre)
¿Hay también una señal de que no se permiten vehículos?
SherbetS (2022-12-01 04:40:40+00:00): Where was this import discussed?

Where was this import documented?

Why are you using what I'm assuming to be OBJECTID as a ref value?

Why aren't you using an import account?
Allison P (2022-12-01 07:12:52+00:00): Bad data values as well (start date 1970/01/01 = beginning of Unix epoch)
Mateusz Konieczny (2022-12-01 08:33:31+00:00): @Zluuzki

Can you list all imports you made without discussion?

Also, please cease making imports without discussion. That just wastes everyones time.
zluuzki (2022-12-01 15:49:04+00:00): - Waste of mine & your time.
No one else edits offshore platforms in the Gulf of Mexico, what do you want to discuss?
- Added to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue#One-Time_Imports

- ID for https://www.data.boem.gov/Platform/PlatformStructures/Default.aspx, not objectid

- Because I had the wrong account logged into JOSM


"That just wastes everyones time"
BIG misunderstanding. YOU could just let me do my editing in peace, you are the ones wasting my and your own time. 

The 23x start_date=1970/1/1 are the only actual problem (out of 2100 overall in the database ... you know). I will fix those.
SherbetS (2022-12-01 16:15:14+00:00): The entire reason that I found this undiscussed import was because I was preparing to import the HIFLD’s offshore platform dataset. The HIFLD has more information available that can be translated, as well as the fact that I have actually done the work required to document and get permission to perform that import.

You are using an external dataset with no documentation, and without discussing it on the mailing list as required by the Import guidelines.

You have already been told by the community at least 6 times to follow the import guidelines in the past, and have ignored that instruction every time. Not including the numerous low quality building imports that were also not discussed and clearly are not sufficiently manually reviewed as you claim.

This data is good, and I’ll probably consider importing it myself in the future, but ignoring the community and disregarding the import guidelines is completely unacceptable as we have told you before.

These problems such as the start_date issue you were running into could’ve been avoided if you contacted the mailing list as required and addressed feedback before uploading, but I have no reason to believe that is within your capabilities.

We do have to waste our time constantly fighting you over these continuous dumps of data that you refuse to import correctly.

Please leave us alone with these messy imports! We’re tired of having to clean up after you!