piebro/osm-data huggingface dataset:
Frans S (2019-10-17 13:27:34+00:00): Hi Miroslav Suchý
I have a remark on your validation work on this task.
I would check the empty field on the right side of the task you've validated and did a validation check on this task (28)
You did not solve the issues which were reported, like roads crossing buildings, squaring buildings.
Validating means that you solve the common issues as mentioned. We ( validators) are the last check to deliver quality work. 
Would you be so king to go over this task again 
Thanks
Frans S (sr validator)
Miroslav Suchý (2019-10-17 14:40:56+00:00): I did not check the objects out of the tile. This particular task is about buildings only. So I did not check the roads  - thou I just fixed that clear mistake on road 413 - which evens runs through building. At the start of mapathong I did not run JOSM validation, just checked that manualy. This was my first batch of validation. I have been told by my mentor on mapathon, that there is no need to squaring of every building, just those that are clearly not good-aligned. I welcome any comments or suggestions, which can improve my skills as this was my first validation session.
Frans S (2019-10-17 16:48:04+00:00): Hi. Thanks for your reaction.
The tile next to this one is not listed as a task which can be selected. There is a bug in the system. Nothing to do with your work.

about validation.
Indeed this is a buildings only project. But that includes to solve issues which comes up when highways crossing buildings or connects with nodes of a building.
Connecting buildings to other objects or landuse, areas etc are always errors which has to be solved. The validation tool shows all kind of errors. In this project only the building related errors should be solved.
About squaring. Squared buildings are a quality item for HOTOSM and need attention. When you have the scripting tool to look for non squared items it makes your work easier.
In iDeditor the non squared buildings are flagged as well (when they are rather close to the 90 degr angle) So mappers have to be trained to solve them before uploading.
Anyhow thanks for your contribution as a validator. There is a huge shortage on validators.
There are training sessions for new validators and also quite a lot of documents and videos.
Are you on Slack? HOT OSM has several channels where you can get information or ask for help. Let me know .(I assisted  quite a number of new validators to improve their skills)
Best regards
Miroslav Suchý (2019-10-18 05:39:42+00:00): I googled the script to check squarity of buildings and I found it at https://www.missingmaps.org/assets/downloads/MissingMaps_validation_josm_en.pdf Thanks for pointers.
mavl (2019-12-21 16:04:12+00:00): This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 78713278, 78715571 where the changeset comment is: The changesets are reverted [DWG has the request to revert the changesets. Reason: an incompatible source].
Myazyk (2020-03-31 10:29:39+00:00): Шо за немудре редагування було?
Пам'ятник Леопольд Мазоху?
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:07:35+00:00): Hello! Please don't add three relation for one bus.
sommerluk (2019-10-14 20:49:17+00:00): Bonsoir OCI2017.

Merci bien pour les noms des bâtiments. C’est vraiment une information importante en Côte d’Ivoire.

Pourrais-tu mettre les noms en minuscule, c’est-à-dire « Immeuble Zorogbé » au lieu de « IMMEUBLE ZOROGBE » ? Ça serait génial.

Merci encore et à bientôt !
iWowik (2019-10-15 19:59:33+00:00): Рад вас приветствовать в проекте, я заметил, что вы рисуете домики, а также вносите адресную информацию.
Обычно ее сложно найти.
Скажите, пожалуйста, а откуда вы ее берете?
iWowik (2019-11-23 15:40:58+00:00): Здравствуйте!
Возможно вы пропустили уведомления о комментарии, который меня тоже интересует.
Откуда вы берете информацию об адресах домиков?
eggie (2019-10-14 20:16:20+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privébericht.
MVG,
Eggie
eggie (2019-10-14 20:22:03+00:00): Dag Emile.. Eigenlijk hoort een adres niet op een vlak getagd te worden. Er is al een adresnode. 
De clubs kun je evt bijtaggen op de BAG adresnodes
met club=sport
sport=?
MVG,
Eggie
eggie (2019-10-14 20:33:00+00:00): De info . website email phone kan ook op de bestaande adresnode.
PT-53 (2019-10-15 11:05:45+00:00): Hallo tüfingen,
Willkommen bei OSM.

Eine Bitte:
Das Merkmal Name sollte nur für wirkliche Eigennamen verwendet werden.
Wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Names#name_ist_nur_der_Name
"Hinter Zaun" ist wohl eine Standort-Beschreibung. Dafür gibt es "fire_hydrant:position=*"
Wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Tag:emergency=fire%20hydrant?uselang=de
und description, das Du ja schon verwendet hast.
Schaust Du Dir das nochmal an?
Fragende Grüße
PT-53 (2019-10-28 10:10:59+00:00): Hallo tüfingen, 
Schaust Du Dir das nochmal an?
Fragende Grüße
PT-53 (2019-11-04 07:21:41+00:00): Falsche Name-Verwendung gelöscht
Frans S (2019-10-19 14:34:29+00:00): Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
Your mapping has been reviewed to check if they comply with the requirements and quality issues of HOTOSM
A few remarks.
Please square all rectangular buildings you map with the Q key in iD editor in future mappings. You can also keep the Q key pressed down and select the buildings each after  each other (except the round buildings) You squared none.
Don't let nodes of buildings connect to other objects, like buildings, highways and area nodes.
Sometimes rooflines are hidden by overhanging trees. Please extrapolate the line of the roof in that cases
Your mappings are rather precise, when you square them next mapping they will be very good.

Best regards and keep mapping
MapMakerGal (2019-10-14 19:51:41+00:00): Esta vai á vencida. Equivoqueime.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/75686213
xogalla (2019-10-16 09:04:28+00:00): Hello Andrew,

this import has many flaws:
* skewed buildings, e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/734594686
* bad segmentation https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/734594169
* temporary structures (already deleted by me)

And may you please help adding building types?

Best regards
viloan (2019-10-14 19:51:24+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
Hjart (2019-10-15 08:31:05+00:00): Bemærk at wikidata tags bør være på den tilhørende ruterelation, hvor de iøvrigt allerede er. Derfor ruller jeg lige denne ændring tilbage.
Claus Hindsgaul (2019-10-15 18:17:43+00:00): OK, det var jeg ikke opmærksom på. Jeg har tilføjet Wikidata-tags til resten af M1/M2 ruten i andre changesets. Bør de også fjernes?
En anden har i øvrigt sat wikidata-tag på M3. Den skal vel også væk (eller flyttes til en ruterelation)?
Hjart (2019-10-15 18:22:46+00:00): Jeg har tilladt mig allerede at slette/flytte alle disse tags :-)
Claus Hindsgaul (2019-10-15 18:30:12+00:00): Helt fint, tak! Jeg rettede i øvrigt farvekoderne i Wikidata så de svarede præcis til dem der benyttes på m.dk.
marc__marc (2020-05-25 12:28:02+00:00): Hello,
what did you mean with admin_level=1 ? a marketplace is not the boundary of a super-national organization
Regards,
Marc
ForstEK (2019-10-14 21:32:16+00:00): https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/10155761 - зачем простой полигон рисовать мультиполигоном? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relation:multipolygon : The same could be done with a multipolygon but this would just complicate a simple case. / "То же самое можно было бы сделать с мультиполигоном, но это только усложнило бы простой случай." Можно ещё так разбить все линии на отрезки из двух точек и лепить монструозные отношения из них, это тоже не запрещено, но зачем так делать?
Sowa1980 (2019-10-15 19:14:21+00:00): За тем что к нему еще будут примыкать другие полигоны , там еще до идеала дорисовывать долго пока. И перестаньте тролить я уже дал вам комментарий. Если вы не согласны меняйте правила в вике на каждой странице, По площадным объектам.
Sowa1980 (2019-10-15 19:16:32+00:00): Свои намерения в отношения Ваших вандальных правок я высказал предельно ясно и четко и сказал, повторюсь они все будут откачены без разбору, где будет найдено удаление подобного рода и прочие вандальные действия.
Sowa1980 (2019-10-15 19:21:11+00:00): Так что будьте готовы что пересмотр ваших правок по Тамбовской области будет полный. остальные области пусть DWG проверяет и выносит решение. А нам надоело из за Вам подобных, что мы не можем пользоваться данными внесенными у себя в области, мы только рисуем, и исправляем , за такими как Вы у которых руки в лучшем случае чешуться от делать нечего.
mapper999 (2019-11-01 22:35:53+00:00): Hallo maction,
kann man an diesem Briefkasten (https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6879698948) wirklich Briefe versenden oder ist das vielleicht eher amenity=letter_box?
maction (2019-11-03 09:51:25+00:00): Treffer, versenkt! ;-)
Da liegst du natürlich absolut richtig.
Das ist der Briefkasten der Stadt S'see ... 
Korrigiert mit  Änderungssatz 76546560.
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:13:20+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please don’t delete private ways, if the exists. You can mark them with access=private (see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:access) .
Frans S (2019-10-17 13:07:51+00:00): Hi. As mentioned in my comment on your mappings on TM3 I will show you how you mapped and how it should be
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=75832754
You can find your work back at the left side. When you hoover over an object you can see the maker etc.
The legend shows more.
Red coloured are your mappings, Green are my modifications and yellow mappings of overlooked buildings.
Can you understand that this not complies with the standards of  HOTOSM? 
Please take a look  here
https://learnosm.org/en/hot-tips/imagery/
Best regards
Marych_ (2019-10-15 05:05:43+00:00): Hi Roolet,
I advice to postpone road alignment around Namangan. We didn't have enough GPS track to be sure that we use correct offset on satellite imaginary.
Roolet (2019-10-15 19:07:06+00:00): Привет Marych_,
Спасибо за информацию, я буду иметь это в виду!
eggie (2019-10-14 21:07:46+00:00): Welkom bij OpenStreetMap. Ik heb een uitgebreid welkomstbericht met wat handige tips en links gestuurd als privébericht.
MVG,
Eggie
viloan (2019-10-14 20:52:21+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
viloan (2019-10-14 21:03:41+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
mor (2019-10-23 18:37:02+00:00): ¡Cuidado! Av. también puede significar Avinguda
mor (2019-10-23 18:54:38+00:00): Perdón, el comentario era para el conjunto de cambios anterior
iWowik (2019-11-23 18:00:05+00:00): Рад вас приветствовать в проекте!
Я заметил, что вы ставите номера домов, а их обычно не просто найти.
Скажите, пожалуйста, а откуда вы их берете?
Alex-Sander (2019-11-24 08:35:47+00:00): Это моё родное село, я в нём вырос. Всё в нём исходил, вдоль и поперёк.
iWowik (2019-11-25 21:58:55+00:00): Добрый вечер, вы так и не отвечаете прямо на вопрос об адресах.
Вы все их помните на память?
Alex-Sander (2019-11-26 19:02:08+00:00): Я понял суть проблемы, куча задвоенных адресов. Я поправлю эту правку в течении недели.
iWowik (2019-11-28 18:30:08+00:00): Вопрос не задвоенности, а в источнике адресов?
Ну вы их с адресных табличек берете или еще откуда?
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:17:56+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Did you see the building https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/240250897 ? Your entry is a duplicate entry.
literan (2019-10-15 17:27:29+00:00): there is no secondary traffic on this road. It  (traffic) cannot start from nowhere. Fixing it
viloan (2019-10-14 22:11:07+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
DaveF (2019-10-15 14:48:09+00:00): Any idea where this is?:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/1941123#map=18/51.44356/-2.56655&layers=N
ndm (2019-10-15 21:32:45+00:00): Only a very rough idea.
DenisJu (2019-10-25 17:41:16+00:00): Hello ReedtheRiver,
in this changeset i see over achavi service that you deleted some node, so the geometry of the way is now lost.

[1]-https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6813634676
[2]-https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6813634677

I see that a footway is deleted too.
[3]-https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/734635058#map=19/41.32347/19.81858 
I can't see a difference between the changes! So the history of this way is getting lost.

Here you can see your changes:
[4]-https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=75691355

If you see something that is done and need change, please don't delete it, improve it!

Regards
Denis
ACarlotti (2019-11-13 00:24:36+00:00): I've just noticed this changeset, and it looks like you've changed a lot of ways to highway=bus_guideway where these sections are not guided (and in some cases are used by unguided buses as well). I think this is incorrect tagging - highway=bus_guideway should be reserved for sections that are physically guided (including perhaps brief road crossings where the guidance resumes immediately after the crossing). The wiki suggests (and I agree) that highway=service would be more appropriate, perhaps in combination with access=no and bu=designated (or something else consistent with local usage).

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dbus_guideway
ACarlotti (2019-11-13 00:27:25+00:00): I think this is also an issue in changesets 76617069 and 76685993; I haven't checked to see if you've made similar edits in any other changesets.
doublah (2019-11-23 15:39:55+00:00): Hi, I only changed ways to highway=bus_guideway when it seemed applicable (all of them had and still have name=Cambridgeshire Guided Busway), but if you think a way is more appropriate as a highway=service, the name tag should also be removed.
ACarlotti (2019-11-23 15:49:47+00:00): The most obvious issue is the bit by Cambridge North station which is used by the Citi 2 buses as well as the busway buses. Beyond that it comes down to a question of whether the tag "bus_guideway" is appropriate for routes that are restricted to guided buses but physically guided. I disagreed with Borbus about this on changeset 71344354; I'd be interested to hear your opinion too.
viloan (2019-10-14 23:42:28+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
sansmapper (2019-10-15 07:17:13+00:00): The Edit  is good. However, when checked w.r.t the background imagery, some part of the way seems to be correct previously at node 6553589781 and now it seems shifted w.r.t imagery.
            ---
            
            Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/75691608
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:33:33+00:00): Hello! There is no necessary to add a key project to the data and also the description of a footway isn't necessary.
Arlo James Barnes (2019-10-17 05:24:04+00:00): I apologise - could you specify which way(s) you mean?
user_5359 (2019-10-17 06:17:54+00:00): Please have a look on https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/606256105.
Arlo James Barnes (2019-10-18 13:19:21+00:00): I see. The 'open sidewalks' thing predates my edit, and isn't it indeed a sidewalk? I had only touched it to deal with where it was near the stream.

Goes to show how I missed the existence of https://openstreetmap.org/node/5562252104 not too far away...
OrionX (2019-10-15 00:04:41+00:00): 74908056
OrionX (2019-10-15 00:04:57+00:00): Исправлено
skquinn (2019-12-04 20:28:01+00:00): It is great to see someone else out there using Keypad Mapper to enter address data. Please note that this program does not enter the road/street names, and that the .osm file it gives you needs to be edited prior to uploading as often the address nodes are in wildly incorrect places. I have a lot of experience with this program (mapping in the Houston area) if you have further questions.
alexey_zakharenkov (2019-11-06 20:47:18+00:00): Hi.
Name of neighborhood on each house is definitely not correct. And what does tag "neighborhood=yes" on a building mean?

BR, Alexey
MilkManHere (2019-11-07 03:22:11+00:00): Hi,

Correct them if needed. I spent too many hours outlining and updating everything from nothing. Why hadn’t you already mapped if you are so critical now? A few tips would have been nice. I contributed and probably won’t anymore because of your tone.
alexey_zakharenkov (2019-11-08 14:12:17+00:00): I'm sorry if I made you uncomfortable. I'd like to apologize, but I still don't see much rudeness in my comment. I'm worrying mostly about map quality, not smbd's personal feelings and ambition.
phidauex (2019-11-08 18:24:57+00:00): Hi MilkmanHere, a number of us have been trying to reach you on the issues with the very large relations you've been creating. I think the problem is that you are adding all of the properties in a neighborhood to a neighborhood boundary relation, which isn't how those relations are meant to work - the relation is just for an actual boundary line, not the members.

Can you please delete the Summerlake relation, and other similar neighborhood relations you've created? They are breaking the rendering and map in the area due to their high member count.
viloan (2019-10-15 00:43:20+00:00): Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)

Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Brasil

Enquanto você está se acostumando com o OpenStreetMap, é recomendado que sempre pergunte aos usuários mais experientes antes de remover ou modificar objetos do mapa, especialmente aqueles que são aparentemente "estranhos" ou "fora do lugar".

Além disso, pedimos que não copie dados de mapas proprietários (como nomes de ruas do Google Maps, por exemplo) e que mapeie apenas o que existe na realidade.

Se você está mapeando por causa do Pokémon, dê uma olhada em https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/12/01/dicas-para-novos-mapeadores-pokemon-go/?lang=pt-pt
Se você está mapeando por causa do jogo do Harry Potter, as dicas e explicações na página anterior também são úteis para você.

Se tiver qualquer tipo de dúvida você pode entrar em contato com a comunidade brasileira através de algum dos canais disponíveis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pt:Contact
O canal "Comunidade" do Telegram costuma ser o mais movimentado.

Abraço e boa diversão com suas edições!
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:43:56+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please be careful when editing the map data. You moved the restaurant node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1676946830/history over 100 meters, on the middle of a street. Please check and correct this.
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:38:45+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please don't mark the whole property as building. Only mark the building as building.
user_5359 (2019-10-16 13:47:17+00:00): Welcome to OSM! Please notice the difference between description and name. "Chicken house" is a description not a name.