She bequeathed her personal library and family papers to the University of Tulsa, where they became part of the collection of the McFarlin Library. The papers include Creek translations by her parents and her grandfather, Samuel Austin Worcester. Robertson Hall, a dormitory at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma in Chickasha was named in her honor. In Muskogee, the Alice Robertson Middle School is home to the 8th and 9th Grade Center of the town. She is one of only five Republicans to have ever held the 2nd district seat in Congress.