An Act To Establish the Mining Advisory Panel
Maine Legislature, Session 128, LD 0685
Committee: Environment and Natural Resources
Sponsors: CHAPMAN
Amends: 5 MRSA §12004-I, 38 MRSA §490-U

Legislative Document
No. 685
H.P. 476
House of Representatives, February 28, 2017
An Act To Establish the Mining Advisory Panel
Reference to the Committee on Environment and Natural Resources suggested and ordered 
printed.
ROBERT B. HUNT
Clerk
Presented by Representative CHAPMAN of Brooksville.
Be it enacted by the People of the State of Maine as follows: 
Sec. 1.  5 MRSA §12004-I, sub-§24-G is enacted to read: 
24-G.   
This subsection is repealed January 1, 2020. 
Sec. 2.  38 MRSA §490-UU is enacted to read: 
§490-UU.  Mining Advisory Panel 
1.  Establishment and purpose.  The Mining Advisory Panel, referred to in this 
section as "the panel," established by Title 5, section 12004-I, subsection 24-G, is created 
for the purpose of designing and submitting to the Legislature recommendations 
regarding the establishment of a statutory and regulatory framework for metallic mineral 
mining in the State. 
2.  Membership.  The panel consists of between 3 and 7 members as provided in this 
subsection. 
A.  Two members of the panel must be individuals with expertise in the mining of 
volcanogenic massive sulfide deposits, one appointed by the President of the Senate 
and one appointed by the Speaker of the House of Representatives. 
B.  The members appointed under paragraph A shall appoint the 3rd member of the 
panel, who must also have expertise in the mining of volcanogenic massive sulfide 
deposits. 
C.  The members appointed under paragraphs A and B shall jointly, by unanimous 
consent, appoint up to 4 additional members of the panel, at least one of whom must 
have expertise in the mining of volcanogenic massive sulfide deposits. 
D.  If the members appointed to the panel under paragraph A are unable to agree on 
the appointment of a 3rd member as provided in paragraph B, they shall 
communicate their disagreement to the President of the Senate and the Speaker of the 
House of Representatives, who shall rescind the appointments made under paragraph 
A and shall each make a new appointment to the panel consistent with paragraph A. 
3.  Chairs.  The members of the panel appointed under subsection 2, paragraph A are 
the cochairs of the panel. 
4.  Staff assistance.  Within the limits of its budget, the panel is authorized to 
contract with and employ staff members to assist the panel in carrying out its duties. 
5.  Quorum.  For purposes of holding a meeting, a quorum is a simple majority of all 
members appointed to the panel in accordance with subsection 2.  A quorum must be 
present to start a meeting or to vote but not to continue or adjourn a meeting. 
Environment: 
Natural Resources 
Mining Advisory 
Panel 
Legislative Per 
Diem and Expenses 
MRSA §490-UU 
6.  Terms; vacancies.  Members of the panel serve for a term of 2 years and may be 
reappointed.  A vacancy must be filled in the same manner as the original appointment.  
Members may continue to serve until their replacements are appointed.  A member may 
designate an alternate to serve on a temporary basis. 
7.  Consultation.  Whenever the panel considers it appropriate, the panel may seek 
the advice of experts in fields related to its duties. 
8.  Powers and duties.  The panel: 
A.  Shall meet at least 4 times annually; 
B.  Shall review, study and analyze the State's current and historical statutory and 
regulatory frameworks for metallic mineral mining as well as those in place in other 
jurisdictions, including the mining laws and regulations adopted by other nations; 
C.  May hold public hearings or other public meetings to receive testimony and 
recommendations from members of the public, state agencies and qualified experts 
on matters related to metallic mineral mining; and 
D.  Shall design a statutory and regulatory framework for metallic mineral mining in 
the State that contains all standards necessary to protect the public health and safety 
and the environment, including, but not limited to, standards regulating effects on 
groundwater quality, control of noise, preservation of historic sites, preservation of 
unusual natural areas, effects on scenic character and protection of wildlife and 
fisheries.  The statutory and regulatory framework for metallic mineral mining 
designed by the panel must, at a minimum: 
(1)  Comply with all applicable federal environmental laws and standards, 
including, but not limited to, the federal Clean Air Act of 1963 and the federal 
Clean Water Act of 1977; 
(2)  Require that all mining areas be left in or returned to a geologically stable 
condition following remediation and closure; 
(3)  Require a permittee to provide a specific plan for ensuring that all mining 
areas will be left in or returned to a geologically stable condition following 
remediation and closure; 
(4)  Require a permittee to demonstrate that the environmental quality and 
security of a mining site will be protected through the use of proven technologies 
and best available practices and require use of these technologies and practices as 
a permit condition; 
(5)  Require that all remediation costs related to a mining area be paid by a 
permittee and not by the State; 
(6)  Require that the financial assurance method approved for and financial 
assurance amount required for a permittee be determined by an independent 3rd-
party expert with a background in mining; 
(7)  Prohibit mining operations using in situ leaching, heap leaching and block 
caving; 
(8)  Prohibit the granting of a permit to an applicant if the applicant or an 
affiliate, subsidiary or parent corporation of the applicant has ever been listed in 
the World Bank Listing of Ineligible Firms & Individuals or successor listing, has 
ever abandoned any mining site resulting in nonremediable or unremediated 
environmental or economic damages or has ever engaged in any ocean dumping 
of mining tailings regardless of the legality of such dumping; and 
(9)  Implement a framework for permitting a mining activity that includes several 
well-defined decision points, both prior to the commencement of and during the 
conduct of mining activities, allows for and requires additional review of the 
permit and mining plan by the regulatory agency, with the agency retaining the 
authority to require the amendment of permit conditions or the immediate 
cessation of previously permitted mining activities. 
For the purposes of this subsection, "geologically stable" means impervious for a period 
of at least 1,000 years to physical, chemical or biological weathering processes that could 
otherwise form a toxic metal transport mechanism that can result in off-site 
contamination. 
9.  Accounting; outside funding.  All funds appropriated, allocated or otherwise 
provided to the panel must be deposited in a legislative account separate from all other 
funds of the Legislature and are nonlapsing.  Funds in the account may be used only for 
the purposes of the panel.  The panel may seek and accept outside funding, and any 
outside funds accepted must be forwarded to the Executive Director of the Legislative 
Council, along with an accounting that includes the amount received, the date that 
amount was received, from whom that amount was received, the purpose of the donation 
and any limitation on use of the funds.  The executive director shall administer all funds 
received in accordance with this subsection.  At the beginning of each fiscal year, and at 
any other time at the request of the cochairs of the panel, the executive director shall 
provide to the panel an accounting of all funds available to the panel, including funds 
available for staff support. 
10.  Repeal.  This section is repealed January 1, 2020. 
Sec. 3.  Mining Advisory Panel; report.  By December 31, 2019, the Mining 
Advisory Panel, established in the Maine Revised Statutes, Title 38, section 490-UU, 
shall submit to the joint standing committee of the Legislature having jurisdiction over 
environment and natural resources matters a report and recommendations, including draft 
legislation, regarding the establishment of a statutory and regulatory framework for 
metallic mineral mining in the State. 
SUMMARY 
This bill establishes the Mining Advisory Panel, the purpose of which is to design 
and submit to the Legislature recommendations regarding the establishment of a statutory 
and regulatory framework for metallic mineral mining in the State.  The panel consists of 
between 3 and 7 members, some of whom must have expertise in the mining of 
volcanogenic massive sulfide deposits.  On or before December 31, 2019, the panel must 
submit a report to the joint standing committee of the Legislature having jurisdiction over 
environmental 
and 
natural 
resources 
matters 
containing 
its 
findings 
and 
recommendations, including draft legislation, regarding the establishment of a statutory 
and regulatory framework for metallic mineral mining.  The Mining Advisory Panel is 
eliminated January 1, 2020.