An Act To Protect the Rights of Property Owners
Maine Legislature, Session 127, LD 0162
Committee: Judiciary
Sponsors: O'CONNOR, COLLINS, CRAFTS, FARRIN, FOLEY, LONG, PICCHIOTTI, POULIOT, WINSOR, BURNS

Legislative Document 
No. 162 
H.P. 120 
House of Representatives, January 27, 2015 
An Act To Protect the Rights of Property Owners 
Reference to the Committee on Judiciary suggested and ordered printed. 
ROBERT B. HUNT 
Clerk 
Presented by Representative O'CONNOR of Berwick. 
Cosponsored by Senator COLLINS of York and 
Representatives: CRAFTS of Lisbon, FARRIN of Norridgewock, FOLEY of Wells, LONG of 
Sherman, PICCHIOTTI of Fairfield, POULIOT of Augusta, WINSOR of Norway, Senator: 
BURNS of Washington. 
Be it enacted by the People of the State of Maine as follows: 
Sec. 1.  1 MRSA c. 22 is enacted to read: 
CHAPTER 22 
PROTECTION OF RIGHTS OF PROPERTY OWNERS 
§851.  Definitions 
As used in this chapter, unless the context otherwise indicates, the following terms 
have the following meanings. 
1.  Compensation.  "Compensation" means a payment of money to an owner of 
privately owned land equal to the amount of fair market value that is taken by a public 
entity. 
2.  Family member.  "Family member" means a spouse, child, parent, sibling, 
grandparent, grandchild, brother-in-law, sister-in-law, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, 
mother-in-law, father-in-law, aunt, uncle, niece, nephew, stepparent or stepchild of an 
owner.  "Family member" includes an estate of or a legal entity owned by one or a 
combination of persons listed in this subsection. 
3.  Land use regulation.  "Land use regulation" means: 
A.  A statute restricting the use of or interest in privately owned land; 
B.  A state administrative, departmental or agency rule that restricts or prohibits the 
use of or interest in privately owned land; or 
C.  A municipal comprehensive plan, ordinance or code that restricts or prohibits the 
use of or interest in privately owned land. 
4.  Owner.  "Owner" means the owner of record of or an interest in privately owned 
land. 
5.  Public entity.  "Public entity" means the State, a political subdivision of the State, 
a department or agency of the State or of any political subdivision of the State or a quasi-
governmental entity established or authorized by the State, including but not limited to a 
public water or sewer district, a public housing authority or a public transportation 
agency. 
6.  Taking.  "Taking" means the reduction in fair market value created by restricting 
the use of or an interest in privately owned land through the operation of a land use 
regulation enacted by a public entity. 
§852.  Taking of private property 
A public entity may not create a taking without providing compensation to the owner.  
A public entity may not enact a land use regulation without a provision for compensation 
to an affected owner if the land use regulation will create a taking.  Except as provided in 
section 853, subsection 8, a public entity may not enforce a land use regulation that 
creates a taking without first providing compensation to an affected owner. 
§853.  Remedy 
1.  Remedy for taking.  An owner of privately owned land subject to a taking in 
violation of section 852 may seek a remedy pursuant to this section. 
2.  Written demand.  An owner who seeks a remedy under this section must provide 
a written demand for remedy to the public entity creating the taking. 
3.  Public entity to determine remedy.  The public entity responsible for the taking 
shall determine the remedy for an owner making a written demand under subsection 2, 
which must be provided to the owner within 180 days of the written demand and include 
one of the following: 
A.  Repealing the land use regulation; 
B.  Modifying the land use regulation to eliminate the taking; 
C.  Exempting the owner from the land use regulation and providing the owner a 
written and attested confirmation of the exemption, which must remain in effect until 
the land use regulation is repealed or modified so that it no longer creates a taking; or 
D.  Providing compensation to the owner. 
4.  Procedure for processing written demands.  A public entity may adopt a 
procedure to process a written demand under subsection 2, but the procedure may not be 
used to establish a prerequisite for filing a written demand, and the failure of the owner to 
file an application for a land use permit may not serve as grounds for dismissal, 
abatement or delay of a remedy under this section. 
5.  Cause of action.  An owner who made a written demand under subsection 2 who 
has not received a remedy under subsection 3 within 180 days of making a written 
demand has a cause of action to compel the remedy with the Superior Court of the county 
in which the privately owned land subject to the taking is located.  An owner who 
prevails in a cause of action under this subsection is entitled to reasonable attorney's fees, 
expenses and costs incurred in compelling a remedy under this section. 
6.  Failure to remedy.  If a public entity has failed to provide a remedy under 
subsection 3 within 180 days from the date of the written demand under subsection 2, the 
owner may use the privately owned land in accordance with the land use regulation in 
effect at the time the owner or a family member first acquired the privately owned land, 
and the land use regulation creating the taking may not be enforced against the owner. 
7.  Statute of limitations.  A written demand under subsection 2 must be made 
within 3 years of the effective date of this chapter or of the date on which a public entity 
applies a land use regulation creating the taking as a criterion for approval of a land use 
permit application submitted by the owner. 
8.  Exceptions.  Subsection 1 does not apply to a land use regulation: 
A.  Restricting or prohibiting an activity commonly and historically recognized as a 
public nuisance under common law.  This paragraph must be construed narrowly in 
favor of finding a remedy under this section; 
B.  Restricting or prohibiting activities for the protection of public health and safety, 
including fire codes, health and sanitation regulations and solid and hazardous waste 
or pollution control regulations; 
C.  Enacted prior to the date of acquisition of the privately owned land by the owner 
or a family member; or 
D.  To the extent that the land use regulation is consistent with the powers authorized 
under the United States Constitution and the Constitution of Maine and in accordance 
with the intent of the people at the time the constitutions and any relevant 
amendments were ratified by the states or by the people. 
9.  Construction.  This section must be construed to strictly limit the powers and 
duties of a public entity under the United States Constitution and the Constitution of 
Maine in any taking of private property rights, directly or indirectly, in whole or in part, 
and to provide a remedy for owners when private property rights have been taken or 
restricted without due process as a result of enactment and enforcement of land use 
regulations. 
SUMMARY 
This bill requires that any entity enacting or enforcing a land use regulation that 
creates a taking of privately owned land, defined as a reduction in fair market value of the 
land, provide compensation in the amount of the reduction in fair market value to the 
owner of the land or repeal or not enforce the regulation against that owner.  The bill 
provides a remedy and cause of action for owners of privately owned land who are 
subject to a taking by a land use regulation, with a statute of limitations of 3 years of the 
effective date of this legislation or when a land use regulation creating a taking is used as 
a criterion for approval of a land use permit application by an owner of privately owned 
land, whichever comes later.  Exceptions to the compensation requirements include 
common law nuisances, public health and safety protections, regulations enacted prior to 
the date of acquisition of the property by the owner or a family member of the owner and 
regulations consistent with the original intent of the United States Constitution and the 
Constitution of Maine.