An Act To Establish a Moratorium on the Approval and Operation of Virtual Public Charter Schools
Maine Legislature, Session 126, LD 0995
House Amendment HA_A_H828 (House)
Amends: 20-A MRSA §2405, 20-A MRSA §2407, 20-A MRSA §2413, 20-A MRSA §2413-A, 20-A MRSA §15683-B, 20-A MRSA §15689-B, 20-A MRSA §15689-C, 20-A MRSA §15689-D, 20-A MRSA §15689-E

HOUSE AMENDMENT ,,/I " to S.P. 340, L.D. 995, Bill, "An Act To Establish a 
Moratorium on the Approval and Operation of Virtual Public Charter Schools" 
Amend the bill by striking out the title and substituting the following: 
'An Act To Establish a Moratorium on the Approval and Operation of Virtual 
Public Charter Schools and To Amend the Laws Related to Public Funding of 
Charter Schools' 
Amend the bill by striking out everything after the title and before the summary and 
inserting the following: 
'Emergency preamble. Whereas, acts and resolves of the Legislature do not 
become effective until 90 days after adjournment unless enacted as emergencies; and 
Whereas, implementation of Maine's recently enacted charter school law has 
resulted in substantial budgetary challenges for certain school administrative units that 
are located within the catchment areas of public charter schools recently approved by the 
Maine Charter School Commission; and 
Whereas, these challenges demonstrate the need for more timely and transparent 
funding provisions enacted as part of the education statutes related to public charter 
schools authorized and approved by the Maine Charter School Commission; and 
Whereas, the funding mechanism proposed by this Act must be initiated as soon as 
possible in order to enable school boards to make practicable budgetary decisions that 
will not be constrained by funding reductions that result from students emolling in public 
charter schools after school administrative units have approved their budgets for the 
2014-2015 school year; and 
Whereas, in the judgment of the Legislature, these facts create an emergency within 
the meaning of the Constitution of Maine and require the following legislation as 
immediately necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety; now, 
therefore, 
Be it enacted by the People of the State of Maine as follows: 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
~ fJ't ~ HOUSE AMENDMENT ,j(, to S.P. 340, Ln. 995 
Sec. 1. 20-A MRSA §2405, sub-§4, as amcnded by PL 2011, c. 570, §§5 and 6, 
is further amended to read: 
4. Reporting and evaluation. An authorizer shall submit to the commissioner and 
the Legislature an annual report within 60 days of the cnd of each school fiscal year 
summanzmg: 
A. The authorizer's strategic vision for chartering and progress toward achieving that 
VISIOn; 
B. 
The performance of all operating public charter schools overseen by the 
authorizer, according to the performance measures and expectations specified in the 
chartcr contracts; 
C. The status of the authorizer's public charter school portfolio of approved charter 
applications, identifying all public charter schools within that portfolio as: 
(1) Approved, but not yet open; 
(2) Operating; 
(3) Renewed; 
(4) Transferred; 
(5) Terminated; 
(6) Closed; or 
(7) Never opened; 
D. 
The oversight and services provided by the authorizer to the public charter 
schools under the authorizer's purview; and 
E. The total amount of funds collected from each public charter school the authorizer 
authorized pursuant to subsection 5, paragraph B and the costs incurred by the 
authorizer to oversee each public charter school. 
Sec. 2. 20-A MRSA §2407, sub-§5, ~C, as amended by PL 2013, c. 272, §1, is 
further amended to read: 
C. Within 10 days of rendering a decision on an application, the authorizer shall 
report to the commissioner and the Legislature the action it has taken. The authorizer 
shall provide a copy of the report to the applicant at the same time that the report is 
submitted to the commissioner and the Legislature. 
Sec. 3. 20-A MRS A §2411, sub-§7, as enacted by PL 2011, c. 414, §5, is 
amended to read: 
7. Notification to commissioner and the Legislature. Within 10 days of taking 
action to renew, not renew or revoke a charter under this section, the authorizer shall 
report to the commissioner and the Legislature the action taken and shall provide a copy 
of the report to the public charter school at the same time that the report is submitted to 
the commissioner and the Legislature. The report must include a copy of the governing 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
~ 
oft ~ HOUSE AMENDMENT 1/ "to S.P. 340, LD. 995 
I 
entity of the authorizer's resolution setting forth the action taken and reasons for the 
decision. 
Sec. 4. 20-A MRSA §2413, sub-§3 is enacted to read: 
3. Funding for public charter schools authorized by the commission. Beginning 
with fiscal year 2014-15, this section no longer applies to public charter schools 
authorized by the commission. 
Sec. 5. 20-A MRSA §2413-A is enacted to read: 
§2413-A. Funding for public charter schools authorized by the commission 
Beginning with fiscal year 2014-15, this section applies to public charter schools 
authorized by the commission. 
1. Pupil count. Students enrolled in and attending public charter schools must be 
reported to the department, for attendance and funding purposes, as provided in section 
15683-B, subsection 2 and department rules amended or adopted pursuant to this chapter. 
2. Revenue provisions. State allocation funds follow each student to the public 
charter school attended by the student. 
A. For each public charter school, the total allocation must be determined as follows. 
(1) The total allocation must be calculated pursuant to section 15683-B, based on 
the student's grade level and adjusted as appropriate for economically 
disadvantaged students and limited English proficiency students pursuant to 
section 15675, subsections I and 2. Debt service and capital outlays may not be 
included in the calculation of these allocations. The department shall adopt rules 
governing how to calculate per-pupil allocations, including those for targeted 
funds for assessment, technology and kindergarten to grade 2 programs. 
(2) For students attending public charter schools, the payments for public charter 
schools must be made pursuant to section 15683-B, subsection 6. 
(3) For transportation expenses, the transportation operating allocation must be 
the statewide per-pupil essential programs and services transportation operating 
allocation multiplied by pupil counts under section 15683-B, subsection 2, 
paragraph A multiplied by the percentage established by the commission for the 
public charter school but not to exceed 100%. 
(4) 
The department shall pay to the public charter school any additional 
allocation assigned to the public charter school for gifted and talented students 
pursuant to section 15681-A, subsection 5 in the year in which the allocation is 
assigned. 
B. The following provisions govern special education funding. 
(1) 
For each enrolled special education pupil, a public charter school must 
receive the average additional allocation calculated by the department under 
section 15681-A, subsection 2 for its special education students. 
These 
allocations must be paid on the same basis as the per-pupil allocations for 
operating funds. 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
\)~~ 
~ 
HOUSE AMENDMENT ,,11 "to S.P. 340, L.D. 995 
(2) The deRartment shall Ray directly to the public charter school any federal or 
state aid attributable to a student with a disability attending the Rublic charter 
school in RroRortion to the level of services for the student with a disability that 
the Rublic charter school Rrovides directly or indirectly. 
(3) 
The department shall pay to the public charter school any additional 
allocation assigned to the public charter school because of a high-cost in-district 
special education placement in accordance with section l5681-A, subsection 2, 
paragraph B in the year in which the allocation is assigned as an adjustment to 
the public chartcr school's state contribution. 
(4) 
The department shall Ray to the public charter school any additional 
allocation assigncd to the school administrative unit because of a high-cost out-
of-district special education Rlacement in accordance with section 15681-A, 
subsection 2, paragraph C in the year in which the allocation is assigned. 
C. 
Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, the State shall send applicable 
federal funds directly to public charter schools attended by eligible students. Public 
charter schools with students eligible for funds under Title I of the federal Elementary 
and Secondary Education Act of 1965, 20 United States Code, Section 630 1 et seq. 
must receive and use these funds in accordance with federal and state law. During 
the first year of operation, a public charter school must receive Title I funds on the 
basis of an estimated enrollment of eligible students, as agreed with its authorizer. 
D. A public charter school may receive gifts and grants from private sources in any 
manner that is available to a school administrative unit. 
E. 
A public charter school may not levy taxes or issue bonds secured by tax 
revenues. 
F. Any money received by a public charter school from any source and remaining in 
the school's accounts at the end of any budget year remains in the school's accounts 
for use by the school during subsequent budget years and may not revert to the 
authorizer or to the State. 
G. Nothing in this chapter may be construed to prohibit any person or organization 
from providing funding or other assistance for the establishment or operation of a 
public charter school. The governing board of a public charter school may accept 
gifts, donations or grants of any kind made to the school and expend or use such gifts, 
donations or grants in accordance with the conditions prescribed by the donor except 
that a gift, donation or grant may not be accepted if subject to a condition that is 
contrary to any provision of law or term of the charter contract. 
Sec. 6. 20-A MRSA §15683-B is enacted to read: 
§15683-B. 
Public charter schools; calculation of total allocation and state 
contribution 
Beginning with fiscal year 2014-15, this section applies to public charter schools 
authorized by the Maine Charter School Commission in accordance with the funding 
provisions established in section 2413-A. 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
~i~ 
~ 
1 
HOUSE AMENDMENT" f(., to S.P. 340, L.D. 995 
1. 
Calculation of EPS per-pupil rates. 
For a public charter school, the 
commissioner shall calculate that school's EPSJ2~I-pupil rate for each year as follows. 
A. The EPS per-pupil rate for elementary grades is calculated by multiplying the 
number of students from the resident school administrative unit by the resident school 
administrative unit's elementary EPS per-pupil rate; then the total elementary cost for 
students from each resident school administrative unit is added and the result divided 
by the total elementary student counts in the public charter school. The result is the 
average elementary grade EPS per-pupil rate for the public charter school. 
B. The EPS per-pupil rate for secondary grades is calculated by multiplying the 
number of students from the rcsident school administrative unit by the resident school 
administrative unit's secondary EPS per-pupil rate; thcn thc total secondary cost for 
students from each resident school administrative unit is added and the result divided 
by the total secondary student counts in the public charter school. The result is the 
average secondary grade EPS per-pupil rate for the public charter school. 
2. Pupil counts. For a public chalier school, the commissioner shall determine that 
school's student counts for each year as follows. 
A. The basic student count for a public charter school is the average of the 2 pupil 
counts for the school for April 1 st and October 1 st of the most recent calendar year 
prior to the year of funding. 
B. 
The number of economically disadvantaged students for each public charter 
school is detennined by multiplying the number of pupils by the most recent 
available elementary free or reduced-price meals percentage. The elementary free or 
reduced-price meals percentage may be applied to determine the number of 
economically disadvantaged students in the public charter school secondary grades. If 
the public charter school does not operate elementary grades, the most recent 
available secondary free or reduced-price meals percentage must be used in place of 
the elementary free or reduced-price meals percentage. 
C. The number of limited English proficiency students for each public charter school 
is the number of limited English proficiency students from the most recent October 
count prior to the year of funding. 
D. The number of special education students for each public charter school is the 
number of special education students from the most recent October count prior to the 
year of funding. 
3. 
Operating allocation. 
For a public charter school, the commissioner shall 
determine that school's operating allocation for each year as the sum of: 
A. 
The base allocation, which is the pupil counts in subsection 2, paragraph A 
multiplied by the public charter school's EPS per-pupil rates in subsection 1; 
B. 
The economically disadvantaged allocation, which is the pupil counts in 
subsection 2, paragraph B multiplied by the additional weight for each economically 
disadvantaged student pursuant to section 15675, subsection 2; 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
,,~~ 
~ 
lO 
HOUSE AMENDMENT "if" to S.P. 340, L.D. 995 
C. The limited English proficiency allocation, which is the pupil counts in subsection 
2, paragraph C multiplied by the additional weight for each limited English 
proficiency student pursuant to section 15675, subsection 1; 
D. The targeted funds for standards-based system allocation, which is based on the 
per-pupil amount pursuant to section 15683, subsection 1, paragraph C multiplied by 
pupil counts in subsection 2, paragraph A; 
E. The targeted funds for technology resource allocation, which is based on the per-
mmil amount pursuant to section 15683, subsection 1, paragraph D multiplied by 
pupil counts in subsection 2, paragraph A; and 
F. The targeted funds for public preschool to grade 2 student allocation, which is 
based on the preschool to grade 2 pupil counts in subsection 2, paragraph A 
multiplied by the public charter school's elementary EPS per-pupil rates in subsection 
L 
The operating allocation calculated pursuant to this subsection must be adjusted by 
mUltiplying it by the appropriate transition percentage in accordance with section 15671, 
subsection 7. 
4. 
Other subsidizable costs allocation. 
For a public charter school, the 
commissioner shall determine that school's other subsidizable costs allocation for each 
year as the sum of: 
A. 
The gifted and talented allocation pursuant to section 2413-A, subsection 2, 
paragraph A, subparagraph (4); 
B. 
The special education allocation pursuant to section 2413-A, subsection 2, 
paragraph B; and 
C. The transportation operating allocation, which is the statewide per-pupil essential 
programs and services transportation operating allocation multiplied by pupil counts 
in subsection 2, paragraph A multiplied by the percentage established by the Maine 
Charter School Commission for that public charter school but not to exceed 100%. 
A public charter school does not pay for its students to attend career and technical 
education programs, and therefore is not entitled to career and technical education 
funding. The school administrative unit in which the public charter school student resides 
must pay the cost of attendance for the student at a career and technical education 
program. 
5. 
Total allocation and state contribution. 
For a public charter school, the 
commissioner shall determine that school's total allocation as the sum of the school's 
operating allocation and other subsidizable costs allocation, and this amount is the state 
contribution. 
6. Payment of state contribution. For public charter schools, the commissioner 
shall authorize state subsidy payments to be made in accordance with the same schedule 
of payments for school administrative units pursuant to section 15689-B. 
7. MaineCare seed. For public charter schools, the commissioner may deduct from 
a public charter school's state subsidy and pay on behalf of the public charter school 
allowable school-based costs that represent the public charter school's portion of 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
\)~~ 
~ 
HOUSE AMENDMENT "It" to S.P. 340, LD. 995 
MaineCare Rayments. A transfer of payment by the department to the Department of 
Health and Human Services must be made pursuant to a schedule agreed upon by the 
Department of Health and Human Services and the department and based on 
documentation of payments made from MaineCare funds. 
8. Curtailment adjustment. In any funding year, if general purpose aid for local 
schools funding is curtailed, the public charter school state contribution under this chapter 
must be curtailed by the proportional percentage that school administrative units have 
been curtailed. 
9. Phase-in procedures for new or newly expanded public charter schools. For a 
new or newly expanded public charter school, the commissioner shall make a preliminary 
calculation of total allocation based on the following: 
A. Estimated student counts not to exceed the enrollment limit established by the 
Maine Charter School Commission; 
B. Estimated rates and weights based on statewide averages; and 
C. 
The preliminary calculation of total allocation, which must be replaced with 
actual student data once students have been enrolled for the new school year. The 
new or newly expanded public charter school must enroll new students no later than 
August 1 st in the State's student information system. 
Sec. 7. 20-A MRSA §15689-B, sub-§2-A is enacted to read: 
2-A. 
Notification of state contribution to public charter schools. 
The 
commissioner shall annually, prior to February 1 st, notify the governing board of each 
public charter school of the estimated amount of state contribution to be allocated to the 
public charter school pursuant to section 15683-B. 
Sec. 8. 20-A MRSA §15689-C, sub-§2, ~A, as enacted by PL 2005, c. 2, Pt. D, 
§61 and affected by §§72 and 74 and c. 12, Pt. WW, §18, is amended to read: 
A. The requested funding levels for the operating allocation under se€tien sections 
15683 and 15683-B; 
Sec. 9. 20-A MRSA §15689-D, as amended by PL 2013, c. 368, Pt. C, §18, is 
further amended to read: 
§15689-D. Governor's recommendation for funding levels 
1. Annual recommendations. The Department of Administrative and Financial 
Services, Bureau of the Budget shall annually certify to the Legislature the funding levels 
that the Governor recommends under sections 15683, 15683-A, 15683-B, 15688-A, 
15689 and 15689-A and the amount for any other components of the total cost offunding 
public education from kindergarten to grade 12 pursuant to this chapter. The Governor's 
recommendations must be transmitted to the Legislature within the time schedules set 
forth in Title 5, section 1666 and in the form and manner described in subsection 2. The 
commissioner may adjust, consistent with the Governor's recommendation for funding 
levels, per-pupil amounts not related to staffing pursuant to section 15680 and targeted 
funds pursuant to section 15681. 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
~~ 
~ 
~ 
HOUSE AMENDMENT "ff" to S.P. 340, L.D. 995 
2. 
Funding level computations. 
The Governor's recommendations under 
subsection 1 must specify the amounts that are recommended for the total operating 
allocation pursuant to section 15683, the total of other subsidizable costs pursuant to 
section 15681-A, the total debt service allocation pursuant to section 15683-A, the total 
allocation pursuant to section 15683-B, the total costs of enhancing student performance 
and opportunity pursuant to section 15688-A, the total adjustments pursuant to section 
15689, the total miscellaneous costs pursuant to section 15689-A, the amount for any 
other components of the total cost of funding public education from kindergarten to grade 
and the total cost of funding public education from kindergarten to grade 12 pursuant 
to this chapter. 
The Governor's recommendations regarding the adjustments and 
miscellaneous costs components also must delineate each amount that is recommended 
for each subsection and paragraph under sections 15689 and 15689-A and the purposes 
for each cost in these sections. 
For each amount shown in the Governor's 
recommendations, the Governor's recommendations must also show the amount for the 
same component or purpose that is included in the most recently approved state budget, 
the differences between the amounts in the most recently approved state budget and the 
Governor's recommendations and the reasons for the changes. 
Sec. 10. 20-A MRSA §15689-E, sub-§I, ~B, as amended by PL 2013, e. 368, 
Pt. C, § 19, is further amended to read: 
B. 
The state share of the total operating allocation and the total debt service 
allocation described in sections 15683 aHd~ 15683-A and 15683-B; 
Sec. 11. Reports to the Legislature. Beginning on the effective date of this 
section and until one year after the effective date of this section, a virtual public charter 
school shall also submit to the Legislature each report that the virtual public charter 
school is required to submit to the Commissioner of Education or to the Department of 
Education. 
Sec. 12. Moratorium on operations of virtual public charter schools. 
Notwithstanding the Maine Revised Statutes, Title 20-A, chapter 112 or any other law to 
the contrary, the Maine Charter School Commission may not approve, authorize or 
execute a contract for a virtual public charter school during the period between the 
effective date of this section and one year following the effective date of this section. 
Nothing in this section may be construed to limit the operation of a virtual public charter 
school that, prior to the effective date of this section, was approved or authorized by the 
Maine Charter School Commission or that executed a contract with the Maine Charter 
School Commission. 
Sec. 13. 
Review. 
The Maine Charter School Commission shall review the 
requirements of the Maine Revised Statutes, Title 20-A, chapter 112 and the virtual 
public charter school models that have been implemented in other states and shall 
develop a model for virtual public charter schools that will best serve the academic and 
developmental needs of Maine students. The Maine Charter School Commission shall 
submit a report on the review of virtual public charter schools to the joint standing 
committee of the Legislature having jurisdiction over education and cultural affairs no 
later than December 3, 2014. The report must include the commission's findings and 
recommendations and any necessary implementing legislation regarding the authorization 
and operation of virtual public charter schools in the State. The committee is authorized 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
()i~ 
~ 
HOUSE AMENDMENT:ff "to S.P. 340, L.D. 995 
to report out a bill to the First Regular Session of the 127th Legislature related to the 
recommendations includcd in this rcport. 
Emergency clause. 
In view of the emergency cited in the preamble, this 
legislation takes effect when approved.' 
SUMMARY 
This amendment strikes the bill and replaces it with the following. 
1. It establishes provisions to fund public charter schools that are authorized by the 
Maine Charter School Commission beginning in fiscal year 2014-15. The amendment 
establishes provisions that calculate the total allocation of funds to be provided under 
general purpose aid for local schools for public charter schools that are authorized by the 
Maine Charter School Commission and establishes that the Commissioner of Education 
must adjust the operating allocation calculated for public charter schools by mUltiplying 
the operating allocation by thc appropriate transition percentage in accordance with the 
Maine Revised Statutes, Title 20-A, section 15671, subsection 7. 
2. 
It also provides that, beginning in fiscal year 2014-15, the Commissioner of 
Education's recommendations for funding levels under the Essential Programs and 
Services Funding Act must include funding level computations for the total operating 
allocation of funds to public charter schools authorized by the commission in accordance 
with the provisions of this amendment. 
3. Like the bill, this amendment establishes a moratorium on virtual public charter 
schools, but the amendment changes the period during which the moratorium applies to 
the period between the effective date of this legislation and one year following the 
effective date of this legislation. 
4. _ Like the bill, this amendment requires the commission to develop a model for 
virtual public charter schools and to submit a report, but the amendment removes the 
requirements that the model apply only to part-time students in grades 9 to 12 and place 
an emphasis on blended learning. 
5. 
This amendment requires that virtual public charter schools and authorizers 
include the Legislature among the recipients of certain of their reports. 
FISCAL NOTE REQUIRED 
(See attached) 
SPONSORED BY: ~ 
~/J tL 
(Representative HUBBELL) 
TOWN: Bar Harbor 
HOUSE AMENDMENT 
Approved: 04110114 
~ac 
LD995 
LR 122(09) 
An Act To Establish a Moratorium on the Approval and Operation of Virtual Public Charter Schools 
Fiscal Note for House Amendment ,~, to Original Bill 
Sponsor: Rep. Hubbell of Bar Harbor 
Fiscal Note Required: Yes 
Fiscal Note 
No State fiscal impact 
Undetermined impact - local school administrative units 
Fiscal Detail and Notes 
This amendment will result in a redistribution of State subsidy provided to local school administrative units (SAU's) 
with some SAU's receiving less State subsidy for the 2014-2015 school year then would have been received had this 
provision not been place and some SAU's receiving more. The impact to individual school administrative units can 
not be determined at this time. 
LROl22(09) - Fiscal Note - Page 1 of 1