An Act To Create Indeterminate Sentencing and a Forensic Review Board for Repeat Sexual Assault Offenders and Sexually Violent Offenders
Maine Legislature, Session 123, LD 1749
Committee: Criminal Justice and Public Safety
Sponsors: DIAMOND, McCORMICK, GREELEY, TIBBETTS
Amends: 5 MRSA §12004-G, 17-A MRSA §1152, 17-A MRSA §1253, 34-A MRSA §5404

Legislative Document 
No. 1749 
S.P.616 
March 27,2007 
An Act To Create Indeterminate Sentencing and a Forensic Review 
Board for Repeat Sexual Assault Offenders and Sexually Violent 
Offenders 
Submitted by the Department of Corrections pursuant to Joint Rule 204. 
Reference to the Committee on Criminal Justice and Public Safety suggested and ordered 
printed. 
Presented by Senator DIAMOND of Cumberland. 
JOY J. O'BRIEN 
Secretary of the Senate 
Cosponsored by Senator: McCORMICK of Kennebec, Representatives: GREELEY of Levant, 
TIBBETTS of Columbia, 
Printed on recycled paper 
Be it enacted by the People of the State of Maine as follows: 
Sec. 1. 5 MRSA §12004-G, sub-§36 is enacted to read: 
36. 
Corrections 
Sex Offender 
Forensic Review 
Board 
Expenses Only 
34-AMRSA 
§5301 
Sec. 2. 17-A MRSA §1152, sub-§2,~, as amended by PL 2005, c. 527, §12, is 
further amended to read: 
M. 
A split sentence of imprisonment with administrative release as authorized by 
chapter 54-G; ef 
Sec.3. 17-A MRSA §1152, sub-§2,~, as enacted by PL 2005, c. 527, §12, is 
amended to read: 
N. 
A term of imprisonment followed by a period of supervised release as authorized 
by chapter 50~,;""m: 
Sec. 4. 17-A MRSA §1152, sub-§2, ~O is enacted to read: 
O. An indeterminate sentence of imprisonment as authorized by chapter 54-H. 
Sec. 5. 17-A MRSA §1253, sub-§14 is enacted to read: 
14. For any person who is sentenced pursuant to chapter 54-H, up to 5 days per 
calendar month may be deducted from the sentence, calculated from the date of 
commencement of that sentence as specified under subsection 1, whose conduct, 
participation in programs and fulfillment of assigned responsibilities during that month 
are such that the deduction is determined to be warranted in the discretion of the chief 
administrative officer of the state facility. 
A. 
Deductions under this subsection must be calculated as follows for partial 
calendar months: 
Days of partial month 
to 6 days 
to 12 days 
to 18 days 
to 24 days 
to 31 days 
Maximum deduction available 
up to 1 
up to 2 
up to 3 
up to 4 
up to 5 
B. Any portion of the time deducted from the sentence of any person pursuant to this 
subsection may be withdrawn by the chief administrative officer of the state facility 
for a disciplinary offense or for the violation of any law of the State in accordance 
II 
with Title 34-A, section 3032 and the rules adopted under that section. Deductions 
may be withdrawn for months already served or yet to be served by the person up to 
and including the maximum authorized for that sentence. 
C. The chief administrative officer of the state facility may restore any portion of 
deductions that have been withdrawn if the later conduct, participation in programs 
and fulfillment of assigned responsibilities of any person pursuant to this subsection 
are such that the restoration is determined to be warranted in the discretion of the 
chief administrative officer. 
D. This subsection supersedes subsections 3, 3-B, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 and 10 for a person 
sentenced pursuant to chapter 54-H. 
Sec. 6. 17-A MRS A c. 54-H is enacted to read: 
CHAPTER 54-H 
INDETERMINATE SENTENCES FOR REPEAT SEXUAL ASSAULT 
OFFENDERS AND SEXUALLY VIOLENT OFFENDERS 
§1350-A. Indeterminate sentences 
1. 
Notwithstanding any other provision in this Title, if the State pleads and proves 
that the defendant is a repeat sexual assault offender, the court may impose an 
indeterminate sentence with a minimum of not less than 20 years, which may not be 
suspended, and a maximum of life. 
A. As used in this section, "repeat sexual offender" means a person who, on or after 
October 1, 2007, commits a new gross sexual assault after having been convicted 
previously and sentenced for any of the following: 
(1) Gross sexual assault, formerly denominated as gross sexual misconduct; 
(2) Rape; 
(3) Attempted murder accompanied by sexual assault; 
(4) Murder accompanied by sexual assault; or 
(5) Conduct substantially similar to a crime listed in subparagraph 1, 2, 3 or 4 
that is a crime under the laws of the United States or any other state. 
The date of sentencing is the date of the oral pronouncement of the sentence by the 
trial court, even if an appeal is taken. 
B. "Accompanied by sexual assault," as used with respect to attempted murder, 
murder and crimes involving substantially similar conduct in other jurisdictions, is 
satisfied if it was definitionally an element of the crime or was pleaded and proved 
beyond a reasonable doubt at tri;:tl by the State or other jurisdiction. 
2. Notwithstanding any other provision in this Title, if the State pleads and proves 
that the defendant is a sexually violent offender, the court may impose an indeterminate 
sentence with a minimum of not less than 20 years, which may not be suspended, and a 
maximum of life except that the minimum term for a defendant who commits murder 
accompanied by gross sexual assault must be 25 years, which may not be suspended. 
A. As used in this section, "sexually violent offender" means a person who, on or 
after October 1, 2007, commits any of the following: 
(1) Murder accompanied by gross sexual assault; 
(2) Attempted murder accompanied by gross sexual assault; 
(3) Elevated aggravated assault accompanied by gross sexual assault; 
(4) Elevated aggravated assault on a pregnant person accompanied by gross 
sexual assault; 
(5) Aggravated assault accompanied by gross sexual assault; or 
(6) Conduct substantially similar to a crime listed in subparagraph 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5 
that is a crime under the laws of the United States or any other state. 
B. "Accompanied by gross sexual assault," as used with respect to a crime listed in 
subparagraph 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 or 6, is satisfied if it was definitionally an element to the 
crime or was pleaded and proved beyond a reasonable doubt at trial by the State or 
other jurisdiction. 
§1350-B. Sentencing process 
In setting the minimum term of imprisonment pursuant to this chapter, the court shall 
use the 3-step sentencing process and assign special weight to the factors set out in 
section 1251 and section 1252, subsections 5-B and 5-C, as applicable. In setting the 
appropriate length of the minimum term, as well as the appropriate length of the 
maximum term, the court may not consider the potential impact of deductions under 
section 1253, subsection 14 except in the context of a plea agreement in which both 
parties are recommending to the court a particular disposition under the Maine Rules of 
Criminal Procedure, Rule ll-A. 
Sec. 7. 34-A MRSA c. 5, sub-c. 2-A is enacted to read: 
SUBCHAPTER 2-A 
SEX OFFENDER FORENSIC REVIEW BOARD 
§5301. Establishment 
.. 
There is established, by Title 5, section 12004-G, subsection 36, within the 
Department of Corrections, the Sex Offender Forensic Review Board, referred to in this 
subchapter as "the board," consisting of 5 members. 
§5302. Appointment 
The Governor shall appoint as the 5 members of the board a psychiatrist, a 
psychologist, a sex offender community treatment provider, a prosecutor from the 
Attorney General's office and a defense attorney, all of whom must be citizens and 
residents of the State. The board members must be appointed no later than 2 years prior 
to the date on which the first person sentenced under this chapter becomes eligible for a 
review by the board. 
§S303. Terms 
The terms of the members of the board are 4 years plus the time period until their 
successors have been appointed and qualified or at the pleasure of the Governor. The 
members of the board are eligible for reappointment at the discretion of the Governor. 
§S304. Vacancy 
A vacancy on the board may be filled for the unexpired term in the same manner in 
which an appointment is made. 
§S30S. Expenses 
The members of the board are compensated according to the provisions of Title 5, 
chapter 379. 
§S306. Meetings 
1. Chair. The members of the board shall elect a chair who shall preside at all 
meetings of the board when the chair is present. 
2. Frequency. The board shall meet as often as necessary, at such times and places 
as the chair may designate. 
3. Quorum. Any 3 members constitute a quorum for the exercise of all powers of 
the board. 
§S307. Cooperation 
The Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Corrections and 
officers and staffs of correctional facilities and law enforcement agencies in the State 
shall cooperate with the board in exercising its powers and duties. The Department of 
Corrections shall provide clerical staffto assist the board as necessary. 
§S308. Annual report 
1. Preparation of report. Beginning with the first year in which the board conducts 
a review, after June 30th of each year, the commissioner shall prepare a detailed report of 
the work of the board for the preceding fiscal year. 
2. Commissioner's duty. The commissioner shall send the annual report to the 
Governor for submission to the Legislature. 
§S309. Duties 
The board shall: 
1. Detennine whether and, if applicable, under what conditions a person who is 
eligible for a review by the board and who applies for a review may be released to 
community supervision; and 
2. Revoke community supervision when warranted due to a violation of a condition 
of release to community supervision. 
§5310. Powers 
1. Rules. The board may adopt rules, in accordance with Title 5, chapter 375, 
subchapter 2-A, pertaining to its functions set out in this chapter. The rules are routine 
technical rules. 
2. Restitution. The board may authorize and impose as a condition of release to 
community supervision that the person make restitution to the person's victim or other 
authorized claimant in accordance with Title 17-A, chapter 54. 
3. 
Quasi-judicial powers. The board or any member of the board may in the 
performance of official duties: 
A. Issue subpoenas; 
B. Compel the attendance of witnesses; 
C. Compel the production of books, papers and other documents pertinent to the 
subject of its inquiry; and 
D. Administer oaths and take the testimony of persons under oath. 
4. Hearing. The board shall afford a person eligible for review under section 5311 a 
hearing before the board and the board may not deny release to community supervision or 
revoke release without affording the person a hearing. 
§5311. Review by the board 
1. A person who is sentenced and who has served the minimum term of years 
imposed by the court, after consideration of any deductions that the person has received 
and retained under Title 17-A, section 1253, is eligible for a review by the board. The 
person may apply to the department for a review by the board no earlier than one year 
prior to eligibility for the review. 
2. Upon receipt of an application from a person eligible for a review, the department 
shall prepare a report, which must include the facts and circumstances of the crimes 
committed by the person, including, if possible, a victim impact and sentiment statement; 
the results of the initial sex offender risk assessment instrument evaluation performed 
upon the person's commitment to the department; a description of the department's 
individualized case plan and any amendments to the case plan for the person; a 
description of the person's participation in sex offender treatment and the outcome of the 
treatment; the person's disciplinary and other relevant institutional history; the results of 
any other sex offender risk assessment instrument evaluations performed by the 
department, the most recent of which may be no older than 3 months prior to the date of 
the application; and any other relevant information requested by the board. 
All 
• 
information obtained under this subsection, and any report furnished to the board under 
this subsection, is confidential. 
3. Upon receipt of the report from the department, the board shall convene a hearing 
to review the application at a time and place designated by the chair. After the hearing, 
the board members shall deliberate outside the presence of the participants and shall 
make its decision by majority vote. The board shall reconvene with the participants 
present and announce its decision, which must consist of a decision that either the person 
continues to be imprisoned or is released to community supervision. 
4. If the decision under subsection 3 is for continued imprisonment, the board shall 
set the conditions and a date for the next review, with that date to be set not later than 5 
years from the date of decision. 
5. If the decision under subsection 3 is that the person is released to community 
supervision, the board shall set conditions of supervision, which may include any 
condition that may be imposed as a condition of probation pursuant to Title 17-A, section 
1204 and any other condition that is appropriate. The conditions imposed may be as 
stringent or restrictive as, but not more stringent or restrictive than, those that could be 
constitutionally imposed if the person were actually housed in a maximum security 
institution. The period of release to supervision in the community must equal the period 
remaining until the expiration of the maximum term of the indeterminate sentence. 
Supervision of the person in the community must be conducted by probation and parole 
officers of the department. 
§5312. Revocation by the board 
1. If a probation and parole officer has probable cause to believe that a person 
released by the board to supervision in the community has violated a condition of that 
person's supervised release, that officer shall arrest the person or cause the person to be 
arrested for the alleged violation and return the person to a correctional facility. An 
administrative preliminary hearing meeting the requirements of due process must be held 
before an official designated by the commissioner within 5 days after the arrest, 
excluding Saturdays, Sundays and holidays. 
2. After hearing, the board may revoke the release to community supervision for a 
person who violates a condition of that release. If the board revokes the release, it shall 
require the person to serve time in prison under the custody of the Department of 
Corrections. This time in prison may equal all or part of the period remaining until the 
expiration of the maximum term of the indeterminate sentence, without credit for time 
served on release in the community. Any portion of the period that is not required to be 
served in prison remains in effect and is subject to revocation at a later date. 
Sec. 8. 34-A MRSA §5404, sub-§2, as amended by PL 2005, c. 488, §§23 and 
24, is further amended to read: 
2. Arrest. Arrest, after completing the entry level and orientation training course 
prescribed by the commissioner, in the following circumstances: 
A. 
Arrest violators of probation or supervised release for sex offenders aHd~ parole 
violators and violators of conditions of release imposed by the Sex Offender Forensic 
Review Board under subchapter 2-A and return parole violators and violators of 
conditions of release imposed by the Sex Offender Forensic Review Board upon 
request of the commissioner; 
B. 
Arrest and return to a correctional facility persons released from the correctional 
facility under section 3035 or transferred from the facility under section 3036-A; aHd 
C. 
If the officer has probable cause to believe that a person under the supervision of 
the department has violated a condition of that person's probation, supervised release 
for sex offenders, parole or intensive supervision, the officer may arrest that person; 
and 
D. If the officer has probable cause to believe that a person under the supervision of 
the department has violated a condition of that person's release imposed by the Sex 
Offender Forensic Review Board under subchapter 2-A, the officer shall arrest that 
person or cause that person to be arrested; 
Sec. 9. 34-A MRSA §5404, sub-§3, ~C, as amended by PL 1995, c. 502, Pt. F, 
§ 3 9, is further amended to read: 
C. 
Keep informed of the conduct and condition of each person placed under the 
officer's supervision and use suitable methods to encourage the person to improve 
that person's conduct and condition; aHd 
Sec. 10. 34-A MRS A §5404, sub-§3, ~F is enacted to read: 
F. 
Supervise each person released to supervision in the community by the Sex 
Offender Forensic Review Board under subchapter 2-A and placed under the officer's 
supervision; and 
SUMMARY 
This bill implements the recommendations of the Department of Corrections made as 
directed by Resolve 2005, chapter 132. 
..