skip to footer MENU CATERING THE SMOKE SHOP ABOUT US Visit Us Photos Dinner Menu All of our meats have a pinkish tint. Not to worry though, we smoke all of our meats to proper temperature. Appetizers Brothers Cheese Fries $11.95 Fresh-cut fries smothered with melted monterey jack and cheddar cheeses and topped with applewood bacon. Add chili $2. Hungry Helpers $9.95 Smoked sausage wrapped in applewood bacon tossed in our BBQ sauce. Sausage Cheese Plate $10.95 A delicious selection of cheeses served with smoked sausage and pepperonicini. Uncle Bo's Shrimp $14.00 Buttermilk-fried then tossed in our homemade Buffalo sauce. Southern Fried Pickles $9.95 Sour dill pickles breaded and fried golden brown. Sticky Ribs $15.00 Smoked ribs caramelized in your choice of our house BBQ sauce or our Asian BBQ sauce Beaufort Shrimp $14.00 Our delicious shrimp seasoned with our rub and glazed with our famous BBQ sauce. Brothers Wings (Traditional or Boneless) $12.95 Wings smoked with hickory wood 'til juicy and tender, deep fried 'til crispy then tossed in one of our homemade sauces: BBQ, Spicy BBQ, Mild, Smoked Garlic Thyme, Hot, or Smoken Hot. Soups and Salad Caesar Salad $10.00 Brothers Greens $10.00 Our house salad greens and veggies. Additions Grilled Chicken $4.95 Brothers Brisket $6.95 Bothers Chopped BBQ $5.95 Grilled Shrimp $6.95 Brothers Pulled Pork $5.95 Bothers Ribs 6.95 Greek Salad $11.00 Dad's Iceburg Wedge $12.00 Half a head of lettuce with diced tomatoes, applewood bacon, blue cheese dressing and crumbles. Sandwiches All sandwiches come with choice of one side and pickles. Smoken Rooster $14.00 Chicken breast seasoned with our rub, grilled and glazed in our famous BBQ sauce. Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich $14.95 Buttermilk-dipped fried chicken cutlet on a brioche bun topped with cheddar and applewood bacon. Frankie Boy $15.95 House-smoked sweet Italian sausage served on a hero with smoked onions and peppers. Add provolone $2. Gavino Gunslinger $16.95 Juicy grilled chicken breasts topped with applewood bacon, fresh-cut fries and melted American cheese, finished with mayo, lettuce and tomatoes, piled high on a hero. Shrimp Po' Boy $14.95 Buttermilk-fried gulf shrimp on a hero topped with dijonniase, iceberg lettuce and tomatoes. Burgers Our classic half pound burger topped with cheese on a brioche bun is a premium mix of Black Angus chuck, Porterhouse tips, and beef brisket. All our burger are a half-pound and served with fries and choice of cheese. Lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, onions and mayo can be added at your request. Additions: Applewood Bacon $2 | Chili $2 | Caramelized Onions $1.50 Brothers Classic $12.95 Our classic burger with cheese on a bun. Stuffed Burger $14.95 Half-pound burger with your choice of cheese stuffed inside and on top, served on a brioche bun. Perfectly melted to ooze when you sink your teeth in. The Porko Burger $16.95 Half-pound burger topped with pulled pork and drizzled with BBQ sauce, applewood bacon, cheddar and fried onions. The Smokehouse $15.95 Half-pound burger, applewood bacon, smoked onions and smoked jalapenos with age cheddar on a brioche bun. The Big Tex Melt $16.95 Half-pound burger topped with cheese and applewood bacon then sandwiched between two grilled cheese sandwiches. From The Pit All of our meats are smoked fresh daily using our special blend of woods and spices. All of our meats will have a pinkish tint due to the smoking process. All sandwiches come with choice of one side. All of our plates are served with choice of two sides and pickles. Brisket Sandwich $17.00 Hand-carved pepper-crusted beef brisket piled on a brioche bun. Chopped BBQ Sandwich $15.00 Our slow-smoked pork chopped and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar-based sauce, then topped with fresh slaw and pickles on a brioche bun. Smoked Rooster Plate $16.95 Chicken breast seasoned with our rub, grilled and glazed in our famous BBQ sauce. Pulled Pork Plate $18.95 Tender pork smoked low and slow, then hand-pulled to order and drizzled with BBQ sauce. Brothers Famous Brisket $23.00 Texas-style dry rub smoked low and slow for over 15 hours 'til it's mouth-watering tender. Smoked Sausage Plate $17.00 Links of juicy, sweet Italian sausage smoked 'till juicy then kissed on the grill. (3) Meat Combo $28.99 Choose 3 smoked meats. Brisket, Ribs, Pulled Pork, Chopped BBQ, Smoked Chicken, or Sausage. Pulled Pork Sandwich $15.00 Our tender pork pulled fresh to order, lightly drizzled with our BBQ sauce and piled high on a brioche bun. Bro Ribber $15.00 Chunks of tasty rib meat caramelized in our BBQ sauce and served on a brioche bun. Smoked Chicken Plate $17.95 Half chicken seasoned with our dry rub, then smoked under tender and juicy. Caramelized in BBQ sauce - Add $1 Chopped BBQ Plate $18.95 A southern favorite. The Brothers grew up on chopped. Our fresh-smoked pork, chopped and dressed with our eastern Carolina vinegar-based sauce. Brothers Ribs Your choice of either St. Louis or baby back seasoned with our dry rub then smoked 'till tender and juicy. Half Rack $22 | Full Rack $32 (2) Meat Combo $24.00 Choose 2 smoked meats. Brisket, Ribs, Pulled Pork, Chopped BBQ, Smoked Chicken, or Sausage. The Uncle Dave $35.00 A sampler of our fine smoked meats: Ribs, pulled pork, brisket, chicken and sausage. Made From Scratch Sides Small $4.50 / Large $8.00 Mac-n-cheese Collard Greens Candied Yams Fresh Cut Fries Smokey Baked Beans Southern Green Bean Fresh Slaw Family Meals Eat Like a King $70.00 Serves 2 - 4 Full rack of ribs, half a chicken, half pound of brisket and half pound of pulled pork served with two large sides. Eat Like The Brothers $125.00 Feeds 3 brothers or 4 - 6 regular sized people. 2 racks of ribs, 1 pound of brisket, 1 whole chicken (smoked or fried), choice of 1 pound of chopped BBQ or pulled pork, choice of 3 large sides, 1 large slaw and pickles. Southern Specialties Some of our family's favorite dishes to share around the dinner table. Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken $17.00 Just like our great-aunt used to make for us, crispy, golden brown, juicy and delicious with a choice of two sides. Aunt Carline's Fried Shrimp $18.95 Gulf shrimp dredged in our seasoned flour, then fried golden brown and delicious with a choice of two sides. Mama's Shrimp-n-Grits $19.95 Gulf shrimp sauteed with bacon, onions and peppers served on a bed of cheese grits. Mmmm, just like Mama makes. Beverages Brothers Southern Sweet Tea Home-style Lemonade Diet Coke Dr. Pepper Hi-C Fruit Punch Ginger Ale Unsweetened Tea Coca-Cola Cherry Coke Sprite Orange Fanta Catering Menu Half Pan Feeds 12-15 Full Pan Feeds 24-30 Smoked Meats Pulled Pork Half Pan $75 Full Pan $140 Smoked Chicken Half Pan $70 Full Pan $120 Brisket Half Pan $150 Full Pan $245 Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken Half Pan $65 Full Pan $120 Shrimp Beaufort, Fried, Grilled and Cocktail $19.99 Per Dozen (Minimum 3 Dozen) Chopped BBQ Half Pan $75 Full Pan $140 Ribs Choice of Baby Racks or St. Louis Half Pan $85 Full Pan $170 Smoked Sausage Half Pan $65 Full Pan $125 Wings Spicy BBQ, BBQ, Mild, Hot, Garlic Thyme, Smoken Hot Half Pan $55 Full Pan $100 Made From Scratch Sides Brothers Famous Mac N Cheese Half Pan $55 Full Pan $80 Smokey Baked Beans Half Pan $55 Full Pan $80 Fresh Cut Slaw Half Pan $45 Full Pan $65 Candied Yams Half Pan $55 Full Pan $80 Potato Salad Half Pan $55 Full Pan $70 Southern Green Beans Half Pan $55 Full Pan $80 Cheese Grits Half Pan $50 Full Pan $75 Big Jay's Collard Half Pan $55 Full Pan $80 Fresh Cut Fries Half Pan $55 Full Pan $65 Cornbread Half Pan $40 Full Pan $60 Off-Site Catering Menu Off-Site Catering There is a 50 person minimum on all packages an added gratuity of 20% as well as tax. Beverages are available at $3 per person. Packages include paper goods! The Whole Hog A Whole Pig smoked o by our Pitmaster. $22 Per Person Each additional Smoked Meat: $5.95 Per Person Each Hot Side: $2.50 Per Person Each Cold Side: $1.50 Per Person Oh So Smoken BBQ $55.95 Per Person A Whole Pig smoked on site by our Pitmaster. Cheeseburgers & Hot Dogs cooked on site with all the Fixins. Choice of Two Smoked Meats. Choice of Two Hot Sides & One Cold Side. The Cook Out $37.95 Per Person Cheeseburger & Hotdogs cooked on site with all the Fixins. Choice of Two Smoked Meats. Choice of Two Hot Sides & One Cold Side. Served with BBQ Sauce, Cornbread & Pickles. Follow Us Navigation Home Brother's Smokehouse BBQ Menu Catering Menu Catering Contact Us Order Online The Smokin Shop About Us Visit Us Photos Terms and Conditions Login Hours Closed. Opens on Thursday at 3:00PM EST Tuesday - Thursday 3:00PM - 8:00PM Friday 3:00PM - 9:00PM Saturday 12:00PM - 9:00PM Sunday 12:00PM - 8:00PM Monday Closed. Contact 2402 Route 32 New Windsor, NY 12518 Phone: 845-534-4227 info@smokenallday.com Join Our Mailing List Join Now Copyright © 2021 All Rights Reserved. OrderezeLogin