SUBSCRIBE HomeNews & Opinion 2,000-Year-Old Salmon DNA Reveals Secret to Sustainable Fisheries Genomic analysis of ancient chum salmon bones and cultural knowledge from the Tsleil-Waututh Nation suggest that people in the Pacific Northwest managed fisheries for thousands of years by harvesting males and releasing females. Dan Robitzski Nov 29, 2021 64 ABOVE: Ancient chum salmon (Oncorhynchus keta) bones collected from ancient fisheries HUA ZHANG A team of scientists partnering with the Tsleil-Waututh Nation, one of the Coast Salish peoples that have inhabited the northwest coast of North America for millennia, has uncovered how local Indigenous communities managed salmon fisheries for thousands of years without exhausting them. Based on ethnographic surveys and genetic data from ancient remains: the key was that fishers harvested mostly males, the researchers report November 10 in Scientific Reports. “Without the DNA stuff, we wouldn’t be able to trace the history of this Indigenous practice,” says Simon Fraser University archaeologist and lead study author Thomas Royle. “And without the Indigenous knowledge, if we just discovered a bunch of male salmon, we wouldn’t have known what happened.” “These types of collaborations are the future of ecological studies and require an investment of time and an openness to new ways of seeing the world around us,” Lia Chalifour, a salmon ecology and conservation doctoral student at the University of Victoria who didn’t work on the study, tells The Scientist over email. See “Opinion: Western Canada Must Stop Clearcutting Its 'Mother' Trees” Study coauthor and University of British Columbia archaeologist Jesse Morin tells The Scientist over email that he designed the project for the Tsleil-Waututh Nation, which secured funding from the Port of Vancouver to pursue work that would validate its historical records. As part of the project, Royle and his team conducted archeological research on salmon bones collected from four historic settlements along Burrard Inlet, a fjord just northeast of Vancouver. They extracted ancient DNA (aDNA) from the bones to confirm historical accounts that the primary species that was harvested by people in the settlements was the chum salmon (Oncorhynchus keta), they explain in a June paper in Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. But then, collaborators unearthed other historical records that suggested Indigenous fishers preferentially harvested male salmon over females, so the team conducted a second genetic analysis to determine whether that was similarly reflected in the ancient remains. Male and female chum salmon are easy to tell apart when they’re alive, but it becomes all but impossible to do so when only looking at vertebrae, explains Portland State University anthropologist Virginia Butler, who didn’t work on the study. That’s why “being able to extract that ancient DNA is essential” for determining sex. Obtaining that genetic information was itself, no small feat, says Royle. The research relied on a PCR technique to amplify DNA extracted from the ancient bones that he developed as part of his PhD dissertation. The technique allows analysis of aDNA that’s been damaged over time by using primers that are sensitive enough to amplify DNA fragments that, like the aDNA they obtained from salmon remains, are only 100 base pairs or so long. The technique was specifically designed to amplify a gene called sdY, which research from 2012 identified as the male sex-determining gene among salmon, says Royle. A brown bear with a freshly caught chum salmon © ISTOCK.COM, SARKOPHOTO The bones were overwhelmingly male at two of the four sites and more balanced between male and female at the others, indicating that different fisheries used different strategies. One of the two male-dominated sites had twice as many male fish remains as female, and the other didn’t have any female fish bones at all. However, whether this harvest bias was intentional was unclear. So the Western-trained academics worked with members of the Tsleil-Waututh Nation to conduct an extensive ethnographic study of the nation’s historic and contemporary practices. Among the findings of that research was that while fishers in the community trapped both male and female salmon as they headed upriver to spawn, they did, indeed, preferentially smoke and eat male salmon, which they identified by their size, coloration, and enlarged frontal teeth. It’s not clear when or how this practice originated, but oral histories suggested that the Coast Salish recognized that male fish can fertilize the eggs of multiple females, so a depletion in males upstream during spawning would have a minimal impact on the total volume of viable offspring produced. In short, they realized fishers could take the food without depleting the salmon population’s fecundity. While the ethnographic data and genetic data line up well, both Butler and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Fisheries Ecology Division Director Steve Lindley tells The Scientist that determining exactly why so many male chum salmon were extracted from some of the sites would require a time machine, even if, as Lindley put it, “this [study] gets close to that.” Butler says it can’t be definitively determined whether the fishery practices of the ancient Tsleil-Waututh community had conservation as a goal or if they simply preferred the male fish because they were larger. The end result—a sustainable harvest—was accomplished either way. She adds that a behavior with multiple benefits, in this case extracting more food per fish and managing a sustainable harvest, is more likely to be reinforced and cemented within a society. “These layers of benefits are important to a behavior getting fixed and moving along,” Butler says. Simon Fraser University archaeologist Thomas Royle extracting DNA from salmon remains at SFU’s ancient DNA lab DONGYA YANG Experts tell The Scientist that the paper would have been stronger with a larger sample size of ancient bones. While the oldest usable remains were 2,000 years old, there weren’t enough fossils from different time points to evaluate how consistent these practices were across generations, Butler explains. Furthermore, the DNA in 29 of the 116 samples analyzed in the paper was too degraded to be useful, leaving plenty of room for future follow-up studies—assuming scientists can get their hands on more and better-preserved samples. “The oldest samples—2,000 years old—happen to be the ones available,” Morin says. “Some of the sites have older deposits, but not much salmon remains preserved in those deposits.” Lindley notes that it’s difficult to obtain usable samples of these “incredibly valuable” remains, and says that the researchers conducted the most robust analysis they could with the resources available to them. Still, Chalifour cautions that the small sample size could skew the results, though she acknowledges the difficulties of collecting and analyzing ancient DNA and commends the authors for processing as many samples as they did, adding that “in this case, these advanced scientific techniques are strengthened by the additional data derived from oral histories.” Going forward, the researchers say they hope to continue expanding on the work and generate a more complete picture of Indigenous resource management practices dating even farther back in time. Royle explains that he also hopes to explain whether the practice of selecting male chum salmon emerged as an adaptive response to a scarcity crisis or whether it emerged gradually as people started to learn about ecosystem interactions. The work may also have an immediate impact of importance to the Tsleil-Waututh Nation in the meantime. The impetus for the research into ancient salmon fishing practices stems from the Tsleil-Waututh Nation’s desire to be granted greater treaty rights by the Canadian government, specifically to comanage fisheries in the area rather than to have the entire system managed by the federal government in a top-down way, Royle explains, adding that demonstrating sustainable practices dating back to before European contact will help strengthen the case. Lindley isn’t yet convinced that harvesting male salmon makes sense as a strategy now, as it may not be as effective when scaled up to the catch volume of modern fisheries. Furthermore, he adds, selective fishing can lead to artificial selective pressures that impact a species’ viability or cause traits preferred by fishers to vanish from the population. While all fisheries are selective in some way, he says, “there are some concerns on the impact of a sex-selective fishery that I’d want to understand before recommending this as a management strategy”—though he adds that the practices in the paper probably aren’t extreme enough to have a deleterious effect on the wild population. Overall, Lindley says he’s excited by the way the paper blends modern science with the knowledge engrained in Indigenous histories. “It’s heartening to see that we’re taking those perspectives more seriously,” Lindley says. “For too long, this kind of information was not valued as much as it should have been.” Keywords: ancient DNAanthropologyarchaeologycommunity cultureDNA analysisfish farminggeneticsgenomicsindigenousNews Related Articles Prominent Plant Geneticist Accused of Sexual Harassment Stephen Warren, Icon of Fragile X Research, Dies at 67 When Researchers Sound the Alarm on Problematic Papers Book excerpt from CRISPR People Related Research Resources Technique Talk: CRISPR for Genome Engineering in Drosophila Webinars The Scientist Speaks - Molecular Farming: The Future of Pharmaceuticals Podcasts Biomarkers on the Brain: From Sequencing to Functional Imaging Webinars The Scientist Speaks - Ancient Secrets of the Plague Podcasts Trending Moderna vs. Pfizer: Is There a “Best” mRNA Vaccine? Omicron Is WHO’s Fifth Variant of Concern, Experts Urge Patience 2021 Top 10 Innovations Over the Counter Antihistamines Could Help Against Cancer Multimedia December 2021 Interactive Crossword Infographic: How Worms that Reside in the Gut Could Influence Health DECEMBER 2021 Return of the worms Researchers are carefully considering the therapeutic potential of helminths SUBSCRIBE TODAY Return of the Worms Immunologists and parasitologists are working to revive the idea that helminths, and more specifically the molecules they secrete, could help treat allergies and autoimmune disease. 2021 Top 10 Innovations The COVID-19 pandemic is still with us. Biomedical innovation has rallied to address that pressing concern while continuing to tackle broader research challenges. Sponsored ContentLabQuizzesWebinarsVideosInfographicseBooks Sponsored Interactive Crossword Puzzle Focus on Structure to Verify Protein Function Scientists analyze a therapeutic protein’s secondary structure to confirm drug efficacy and safety. Technique Talk: CRISPR for Genome Engineering in Drosophila Discover how CRISPR is revolutionizing gene editing in a classic genetics research model. A Library at Your Fingertips Scientists explore big questions and expand their knowledge with digital books. MarketplaceSponsored Product Updates An Early Start: The Impact of the Microbiome on Pediatric Development in the First Year of Life A better understanding of early childhood microbiome shifts offers a unique window for detecting disease risk and intervening appropriately. Dr. Aletta Schnitzler Joins TurtleTree as Chief Scientific Officer Cell-based nutrition company TurtleTree welcomes Dr. Aletta Schnitzler as its new Chief Scientific Officer (CSO). With her world-class expertise in cellular bioprocessing, Dr. Schnitzler’s appointment marks a significant stride in TurtleTree’s journey towards sustainable and efficient cellular food production. Streamlining Quality Control for Cultured Human Cells Guidelines for maintaining human cells grown ex vivo Understanding Cytokine Release Syndrome in COVID-19 Patients Researchers detect aberrant cytokine activity in response to SARS-CoV-2 infection. Stay Connected with E-NEWSLETTER SIGN-UP Subscribe to receive The Scientist Daily E-Newsletter in your inbox! Country* Please Select United States Canada United Kingdom Afghanistan Aland Islands Albania Algeria American Samoa Andorra Angola Anguilla Antarctica Antigua & Barbuda Argentina Armenia Aruba Australia Austria Azerbaijan Bahamas Bahrain Bangladesh Barbados Belarus Belgium Belize Benin Bermuda Bhutan Bolivia Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba Bosnia & Herzegovina Botswana Bouvet Island Brazil British Indian Ocean Territory British Virgin Islands Brunei Bulgaria Burkina Faso Burundi Cambodia Cameroon Cape Verde Cayman Islands Central African Republic Chad Chile China Christmas Island Cocos (Keeling) Islands Colombia Comoros Cook Islands Costa Rica Croatia Cuba Curacao Cyprus Czech Republic Democratic Republic of the Congo Denmark Djibouti Dominica Dominican Republic Ecuador Egypt El Salvador Equatorial Guinea Eritrea Estonia Ethiopia Falkland Islands Faroe Islands Fiji Finland France French Guiana French Polynesia French Southern Territories Gabon Gambia Gaza Strip Georgia Germany Ghana Gibraltar Greece Greenland Grenada Guadeloupe Guam Guatemala Guernsey Guinea Guinea-Bissau Guyana Haiti Heard & McDonald Islands Honduras Hong Kong Hungary Iceland India Indonesia Iran Iraq Ireland Isle of Man Israel Italy Ivory Coast Jamaica Japan Jersey Jordan Kazakhstan Kenya Kiribati Kosovo Kuwait Kyrgyzstan Laos Latvia Lebanon Lesotho Liberia Libya Liechtenstein Lithuania Luxembourg Macau Macedonia Madagascar Malawi Malaysia Maldives Mali Malta Marshall Islands Martinique Mauritania Mauritius Mayotte Mexico Micronesia Moldova Monaco Mongolia Montenegro Montserrat Morocco Mozambique Myanmar Namibia Nauru Nepal Netherlands Netherlands Antilles New Caledonia New Zealand Nicaragua Niger Nigeria Niue Northern Mariana Islands Norfolk Island North Korea Norway Oman Pakistan Palau Palestine Panama Papua New Guinea Paraguay Peru Philippines Pitcairn Poland Portugal Puerto Rico Qatar Republic of the Congo Reunion Romania Russia Rwanda Saint Helena Saint Barthelemy Saint Kitts & Nevis Saint Lucia Saint Martin Saint Pierre & Miquelon Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Samoa San Marino Sao Tome & Principe Saudi Arabia Senegal Serbia Seychelles Sierra Leone Singapore Sint Maarten Slovakia Slovenia Solomon Islands Somalia South Africa South Georgia & South Sandwich Islands South Korea South Sudan Spain Sri Lanka Sudan Suriname Svalbard and Jan Mayen Swaziland Sweden Switzerland Syria Taiwan Tajikistan Tanzania Thailand Timor-Leste Togo Tokelau Tonga Trinidad & Tobago Tunisia Turkey Turkmenistan Turks & Caicos Islands Tuvalu Uganda Ukraine United Arab Emirates Uruguay US Minor Outlying Islands US Virgin Islands Uzbekistan Vanuatu Vatican City State Venezuela Vietnam Wallis and Futuna West Bank Western Sahara Yemen Zambia Zimbabwe FACEBOOK PAGES THE SCIENTISTCANCER AND GENOMIC SCIENCECELL AND MICROBIAL SCIENCETHE NEUROSCIENTISTTHE SCIENTIST CAREERS ABOUT & CONTACTEDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARDEDITORIAL POLICIESPRIVACY POLICY JOB LISTINGSSUBSCRIBEADVERTISE NOW PART OF THE LABX MEDIA GROUP:LAB MANAGER MAGAZINE|LABX|LABWRENCH © 1986–2021 THE SCIENTIST. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. We’ve updated our Privacy Policy to make it clearer how we use your personal data. Please read our Cookie Policy to learn how we use cookies to provide you with a better experience. I UNDERSTAND