Personal Commercial Claims Safety Careers Company Contact Us Claims for Errors and Omissions We pride ourselves on fast, effective, and fair claims service. Claims may be made 24/7/365 in a way that is convenient for you. Our dedicated claims staff only handles Agents’ E&O professional liability. And, you have direct access to Underwriters and Claim Specialist when you need input regarding an E&O exposure or potential claim situation. To report a claim, follow these guidelines, review the First Notice of Loss Form, and contact us: Telephone: 800-598-8422 (800-59-UTICA) Fax: 888-538-2018 Email Mail: Utica National Insurance Group Attn: E&O Claims PO Box 6610 Utica, NY 13504-6610 Not a policyholder with Utica National? Start an application today. Claims Customer Care Center Claims Contacts & Existing Claims Claims for Errors and Omissions Claims for Educational Institutions Direct Repair Program Fraud Hotline Report a Claim Find An Agent Utica Mutual Insurance Company, its affiliates and subsidiaries, 180 Genesee St., New Hartford, NY 13413 © 2021 Copyright Utica Mutual Insurance Company Legal Notices For Agents Make a Payment