Agents Policyholders Our Blog Careers COVID-19 Contact Us HOME PRODUCTS ABOUT US FIND AN AGENT MAKE A PAYMENT REPORT A CLAIM SEARCH SAFE@HOME Member donations are at work in our communities! Click below for details. LEARN MORE WORKING TO EARN YOUR TRUST EVERY DAY LEARN HOW FIND AN AGENT We have agents in the following areas: Enter an address, city or zip code to find an agent near you. SEARCH Currently in EIGHT states, our mission is to provide comprehensive property and casualty insurance products of the highest quality and to conduct our business by biblical principles of love, justice and integrity. AUTO LEARN MORE HOME LEARN MORE BUSINESS LEARN MORE CHURCH LEARN MORE FARM LEARN MORE UMBRELLA LEARN MORE CURRENT POLICYHOLDERS Our goal is to provide you with great service. If you have questions or need to discuss an insurance need we encourage you to contact your local agent. MAKE A PAYMENT CHANGE PAYMENT PLAN REPORT A CLAIM POLICY INFORMATION GET AN ID CARD NEW TO GOODVILLE MUTUAL We'd be happy to help you with your insurance needs. To get a quote contact a local, independent agent. FIND AN AGENT WHY DO I NEED AN AGENT? ABOUT GOODVILLE WORDS OF APPRECIATION... Goodville's services exceeded our expectations. - Javan S., Ohio SEE WHAT OTHERS HAVE TO SAY FIRE SAFETY FOR CHILDREN Keep your child's bedroom door closed. If a hallway fire occurs, a closed door may hinder the smoke from over powering your baby or toddler, giving firefighters extra time for rescue. VIEW MORE SAFETY TIPS April is Distracted Driving Awareness Month! Learn more about how to avoid distractions while driving. VISIT US ON FACEBOOK SECURE EMAIL Confidential information can be sent using our secure message center. SIGN IN TALK WITH US Questions? Contact one of our representatives today! CONTACT US PRODUCTS AUTO HOME BUSINESS CHURCH FARM UMBRELLA QUICK LINKS ABOUT US CAREERS SAFETY TIPS FEEDBACK TERMS & CONDITIONS PRIVACY POLICY RESOURCES FIND AN AGENT MAKE A PAYMENT REPORT A CLAIM LOCATIONS Headquarters New Holland, PA Great Lakes Branch Office Napoleon, OH CONTACT US Mon - Fri 8am to 4:30pm ET Phone (717) 354-4921 Toll Free (800) 448-4622 Fax (717) 354-5158 Emergency Claims (877) 445-5780 All Glass Claims (877) 445-5780 DOWNLOAD MOBILE APP © Copyright 2021 Goodville Mutual Casualty Company, New Holland PA, All rights reserved.