Home About Us Insurance Find an Agent Make a Payment Agents Claims Mortgagee Blog Contact Us Find an Agent Find an Agent Search A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0-9 Search Keywords Start Search From location or Locate Me Within a radius of miles Make a Payment Use our Secure Portal to pay with card or check, set up a Monthly EFT Payment Plan or set up a Third Party Designee. Pay Now Like us! Contact Us Mailing Address: P.O. Box 40 Burlington Flats, New York 13315 Telephone: (607) 965-8211 Fax: (607) 965-9848 Quick Links About Us Contact Us Make a Payment File a Claim Find an Agent Disclaimer Privacy Policy For Agents Agents Login Become an Agent Otsego Rating System Otsego Billing Inquiry Copyright 2021 Otsego Mutual. All Rights Reserved.