MarketWatch Site Logo A link that brings you back to the homepage. .mwA1{fill:#ffffff;} .mwA2{fill:#4db74d;} Home Markets Market Extra Market Extra Here’s what a 1970s inflation-fighting fiasco says about the battle against rising prices Last Updated: Nov. 22, 2021 at 11:04 a.m. ET First Published: Nov. 17, 2021 at 12:23 p.m. ET By William Watts No surge in demand for ‘Whip Inflation Now’ memorabilia, collectors say MarketWatch photo illustration/iStockphoto Email icon Facebook icon Twitter icon Linkedin icon Flipboard icon Print icon Resize icon Referenced Symbols DJIA +0.55% SPX +0.17% EBAY -2.61% Surging inflation is stirring memories of the 1970s, but isn’t doing much to boost the value of a piece of political memorabilia that’s an artifact of an ill-fated fight against rising prices. Art Hogan said he scrambled last month to find a “Whip Inflation Now,” or WIN, button. The chief market strategist at B. Riley National said he wears the button, which he bought on eBay for less than $10, during video calls with financial advisers to help rebut concerns that current price pressures are comparable to the stagflation that came to define the 1970s. But ironic interest in the red-and-white buttons produced in bulk as part of a public-service campaign launched in 1974 by President Gerald Ford, and widely viewed as a flop, isn’t likely to turn the souvenirs into anything resembling an inflation hedge. Advertisement “They don’t sell for a lot of money,” said Curtis Lindner, director of Americana at Heritage Auctions, a Dallas-based auction house. “At one time they were very popular with collectors.” Stagflation redux? As for inflation, Hogan said the 1970s comparisons aren’t surprising, with the Consumer Price Index rising to a nearly 31-year high in October at 6.2%. But like many investors and economists, Hogan contends that the similarities are only skin-deep. The 1970s saw even higher stretches of double-digit U.S. inflation than this year, after the supply shock caused by OPEC quadrupling crude oil prices, while unemployment also rose and the economy foundered — a condition that came to be known as “stagflation.” The current inflation surge, in contrast, is due in large part to surging demand for goods as government stimulus payments helped the economy bounce back from business shutdowns during the pandemic which also caused some supply chain disruptions. “That was inflation with no economic benefit to it,” Hogan said of the 1970s, in a phone interview last week. Now, inflation is rising “because demand came back faster than supply” in the wake of the shutdowns caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. The Dow Jones Industrial Average DJIA, +0.55% fell nearly 28% in 1974, while the S&P 500 SPX, +0.17% dropped nearly 30% before both gauges bounced back sharply in 1975. Stocks saw a negative 11.6% real return over the high-inflation period stretching from 1969 to 1982, according to DataTrek Research. The Dow is up more than 17% year to date, while the S&P 500 SPX, +0.17% has risen around 25%, with major indexes hitting numerous records over the course of 2021. Read: Why the hottest inflation in 3 decades isn’t rattling stock-market bulls That doesn’t mean inflation isn’t a concern. Though many economists emphasize the differences between the 1970s and now, there is debate over how quickly those inflation pressures are likely to fade. See: High inflation is eating up the budgets of American households Political toll For politicians, the pain inflicted by inflation can be costly. President Joe Biden’s approval ratings have suffered, with a Washington Post/ABC News poll released Sunday showing that 55% of respondents disapproved of his handling of the economy, 6 percentage points more than former President Donald Trump’s worst showing in September 2017. Advertisement Related: ‘We’ll see lower prices’: Biden says passage of his agenda will tame inflation Ford was feeling the heat in 1974. WIN buttons were introduced in October as inflation accelerated in the wake of the first Arab oil embargo; the Consumer Price Index rose at an annual rate of more than 11% that year. With the economy mired in recession, Ford, in a speech, proposed a raft of measures aimed at squelching inflation, including removing acreage limits on a number of crops and overhauling energy regulations. But the heart of the effort, and what’s most remembered today, was Ford’s description of the fight against inflation as a moral battle, invoking comparisons to the home-front efforts of World War II and exhorting citizens to spend less and save more. “Every housewife knows almost exactly how much she spent for food last week. If you cannot spare a penny from your food budget — and I know there are many — surely you can cut the food that you waste by 5%,” Ford said. Needless to say, the effort had little impact. Inflation wouldn’t be tamed until the early 1980s when the Paul Volcker led the Federal Reserve to mercilessly hike interest rates to double-digit levels, sparking a deep recession. Advertisement The performance of the economy was blamed in part for Ford’s election loss to Jimmy Carter in 1976. Carter, who appointed Volcker as Fed chair, would lose his 1980 re-election bid to Ronald Reagan, a defeat also blamed partly on inflation and other economic woes. ‘Unbelievable stupidity’ As for the WIN campaign, it largely fizzled out by Christmas 1974 as the recession deepened. Even Ford’s economic advisers later disparaged the effort. In his memoirs, Alan Greenspan, who was chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers at the time and would go on to serve five terms as chairman of the Federal Reserve, recalled Ford’s speechwriting team proposing the campaign at a senior staff meeting: “I was the only economist present, and I said to myself, ‘This is unbelievable stupidity. What am I doing here.'” The campaign left behind ample supplies of memorabilia, including the red-and-white buttons emblazoned with the “WIN” logo. Many buttons were distributed free. Pins could also obtained by simply mailing the White House a form, printed in newspapers, agreeing to enlist in the battle against inflation. Would-be inflation fighters could also don sweaters, swig from coffee cups or even play with footballs fashioned with the WIN logo, which were often produced by companies hoping to cash in on the government campaign. ‘Slow movers’ Hogan, who began collecting political souvenirs as a child, said he searched for the WIN button he had acquired in the 1970s in vain, eventually going to eBay. They’re not hard to find. Despite renewed inflation worries and a whiff of ironic nostalgia, WIN memorabilia isn’t exactly back in vogue. Advertisement There’s been a “minor pickup” in purchases of the buttons, but they’ve remained “slow movers,” said Steve Ferber of Lori Ferber Collectibles, a Scottsdale, Ariz.-based dealer in political collectibles. On eBay EBAY, -2.61%, meanwhile, listings of WIN buttons rose earlier this year, but sales fell by around 40% in the third quarter, according to data provided by the auction site. “I don’t know that it struck a chord with collectors any more or less than it did with the general public,” Ferber told MarketWatch. “Gerald Ford, in general, is one of the least collected presidents in the modern era.” Ferber said he has around 1,000 of the buttons in stock, noting that they move in bulk for as low as 50 cents each while individual buttons rarely sell for more than $10. Lukewarm collectors aside, what do economists make of the effort nearly a half decade later? William Polley, associate professor of economics at Western Illinois University — Quad Cities in Moline, said that while the campaign clearly failed, the reasoning behind it wasn’t “totally misguided.” Advertisement “Their thinking was in the right place, but I think they overestimated consumers’ ability to really follow through and do it,” he said, in an interview. In the end, asking consumers to walk to work and waste less food wasn’t a match for M2 money stock, a measure of money supply including cash, checking deposits and easily convertible near-money assets, that was growing at a double digit rate, Polley said. Volunteers The volunteer approach at the center of the WIN campaign should also be viewed in relation to the more interventionist attempts to squelch inflation that preceded it, and failed, including the wage and price controls instituted by President Richard Nixon in 1971, said Rebecca Spang, a professor of history at Indiana University in Bloomington. In contrast, the volunteer-focused WIN campaign appeared to reflect “very deep skepticism” by Ford and his advisers “that there was anything governments could do,” she said in an interview. Meanwhile, investors probably shouldn’t expect WIN buttons to see a lasting surge in value regardless of what happens with inflation in the near term, said Ferber, the collectibles dealer, though they do offer a basic lesson in economics. After all, he noted, it takes two things — scarcity and demand — to make a collectible valuable. “They’re certainly not scarce,” he said, “and there’s not a tremendous demand.” Read Next Oil bounces as reports indicate Biden, OPEC+ near showdown over crude reserves Oil ends higher after a news report said OPEC+ was rethinking plans to boost output as the U.S. leads a coordinated effort to release reserves. More On MarketWatch Why oil prices jumped despite the U.S. tapping the Strategic Petroleum Reserve Oil prices end higher after U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve release Barron's: XPeng Earnings Beat Estimates. That Wasn’t the Biggest Surprise. Barron's: Tech Stocks Fall, Covid Surges in Europe — and What Else Happened in the Stock Market Today About the Author William Watts William Watts is MarketWatch’s senior markets writer. Based in New York, Watts writes about stocks, bonds, currencies and commodities, including oil. He also writes about global macro issues and trading strategies. Before moving to New York, he reported for MarketWatch from Frankfurt, London and Washington, D.C. Advertisement Advertisement Partner Center Most Popular These are the most important things to check on a stock’s quote page before deciding whether to buy or sell When is it worth hiring someone to manage your money? No matter your age, here’s how to tell if your finances are on the right track Why the new tax law caused a 'perfect storm' for Roth IRA conversions Will Biden administration releasing 50 million barrels of oil lower gas prices? Don’t hold your breath PARTNER CONTENT PARTNER CONTENT BACK TO TOP MarketWatch logoGo to the homepage Copyright © 2021 MarketWatch, Inc. All rights reserved. By using this site you agree to the Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use, Privacy Notice, and Cookie Notice. Facebook Twitter Linkedin MARKETWATCH Customer Center Contact Us Newsroom Roster Virtual Stock Exchange BigCharts Copyright Policy Manage Notifications COMPANY Dow Jones Code of Conduct Corrections Reprints & Licensing Your Ad Choices Corporate Subscriptions DOW JONES NETWORK The Wall Street Journal Barron's Financial News London realtor.com Mansion Global Intraday Data provided by FACTSET and subject to terms of use. Historical and current end-of-day data provided by FACTSET. All quotes are in local exchange time. Real-time last sale data for U.S. stock quotes reflect trades reported through Nasdaq only. Intraday data delayed at least 15 minutes or per exchange requirements.