Title: PRISMM-Bench: A Benchmark of Peer-Review Grounded Multimodal Inconsistencies
Primary area: datasets and benchmarks
Keywords: Large Multimodal Models, Scentific document understanding, evaluation benchmark

Abstract: Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) are increasingly applied to scientific research, yet it remains unclear whether they can reliably understand and reason over the multimodal complexity of papers. A central challenge lies in detecting and resolving inconsistencies across text, figures, tables, and equations, issues that are often subtle, domain-specific, and ultimately undermine clarity, reproducibility, and trust. Existing benchmarks overlook this issue, either isolating single modalities or relying on synthetic errors that fail to capture real-world complexity. We introduce PRISMM-Bench (Peer-Review-sourced Inconsistency Set for Multimodal Models), the first benchmark grounded in real reviewer-flagged inconsistencies in scientific papers. Through a multi-stage pipeline of review mining, LLM-assisted filtering and human verification, we curate 262 inconsistencies from 242 papers. Based on this set, we design three tasks, namely inconsistency identification, remedy and pair matching, which assess a model's capacity to detect, correct, and reason over inconsistencies across different modalities. Furthermore, to address the notorious problem of \emph{choice-only shortcuts} in multiple-choice evaluation, where models exploit answer patterns without truly understanding the question, we further introduce structured JSON-based answer representations that  minimize linguistic biases by reducing reliance on superficial stylistic cues. We benchmark 21 leading LMMs, including large open-weight models (GLM-4.5V 106B, InternVL3 78B) and proprietary models (Gemini 2.5 Pro, GPT-5 with high reasoning). Results reveal strikingly low performance (26.1–54.2\%), underscoring the challenge of multimodal scientific reasoning and motivating progress towards trustworthy scientific assistants. We provide the source code and dataset viewer in the appendix, and will release the full source code, dataset, and annotation tool publicly upon acceptance.

TL;DR: PRISMM-Bench is the first benchmark of real reviewer-flagged multimodal inconsistencies in scientific papers, revealing that even state-of-the-art LMMs struggle to detect and resolve them.