Title: Unlearning Evaluation through Subset Statistical Independence
Primary area: unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords: Machine Unlearning

Abstract: Evaluating machine unlearning remains challenging, as existing methods typically require retraining reference models or performing membership inference attacks—both rely on prior access to training configuration or supervision label, making them impractical in realistic scenarios. Motivated by the fact that most unlearning algorithms remove a small, random subset of the training data, we propose a subset-level evaluation framework based on statistical independence. Specifically, we design a tailored use of the Hilbert–Schmidt Independence Criterion to assess whether the model outputs on a given subset exhibit statistical dependence, without requiring model retraining or auxiliary classifiers. Our method provides a simple, standalone evaluation procedure that aligns with unlearning workflows. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach reliably distinguishes in-training from out-of-training subsets and clearly differentiates unlearning effectiveness, even when existing evaluations fall short.