Title: Decision Making under Imperfect Recall: Algorithms and Benchmarks
Primary area: reinforcement learning
Keywords: Game Theory, Imperfect Recall, Extensive-form Games, Regret Matching, Nonlinear Optimization

Abstract: In game theory, imperfect-recall decision problems model situations in which an agent forgets information it held before. They encompass games such as the "absentminded driver" and team games with limited communication. In this paper, we introduce the first benchmark suite for imperfect-recall decision problems. Our benchmarks capture a variety of problem types, including ones concerning privacy in AI systems that elicit sensitive information, and AI safety via testing of agents in simulation. Across 61 problem instances generated using this suite, we evaluate the performance of different algorithms for finding first-order optimal strategies in such problems. In particular, we introduce the family of regret matching (RM) algorithms for nonlinear constrained optimization. This class of parameter-free algorithms has enjoyed tremendous success in solving large two-player zero-sum games, but, surprisingly, they were hitherto relatively unexplored beyond that setting. Our key finding is that RM algorithms consistently outperform commonly employed first-order optimizers such as projected gradient descent, often by orders of magnitude. This establishes, for the first time, the RM family as a formidable approach to large-scale constrained optimization problems.

TL;DR: We create the first benchmark suite of decision problems under imperfect recall and evaluate the performance of a range of algorithms on these problems. We find that regret matching algorithms are very performant first-order optimizers.