<TITLE>906/171/17</TITLE>
<!-- BEGIN METADATA -->
<!-- Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ôàéëà ç ð³øåííÿì -->
<META NAME="FILENAME" CONTENT="5040_604692.html">
<!-- 1,2 ID ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCID, DOCORGID) - íóæíî äëÿ ïîëó÷åíèÿ ïîäòâåðæäåíèÿ ðååñòðàöèè -->
<META NAME="DOCID" CONTENT="604692">
<META NAME="DOCORGID" CONTENT="202">
<!-- [3] Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(COURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="COURTNAME" CONTENT="Ðiâíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä">
<!-- [4] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5040">
<!-- [4.1] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="976">
<!-- [5] Ñïðàâà íîìåð TAGNAME(CAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="CAUSENUM" CONTENT="906/171/17">
<!-- [6] Äàòà ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="CAUSEDATE" CONTENT="04.05.2017">
<!-- [7] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCDATE) -->
<META NAME="DOCDATE" CONTENT="14.06.2017">
<!-- [9] Ôîðìà ð³øåííÿ (ID) TAGNAME(DOCTYPE) -->
<!-- ð³øåííÿ = 2 -->
<!-- ïîñòàíîâà = 3 -->
<!-- óõâàëà ñóäó = 4 -->
<!-- ñóäîâèé íàêàç = 5 -->
<!-- îêðåìà óõâàëà = 6 -->
<META NAME="DOCTYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [10] Ôîðìà ñóäî÷èíñòâà (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSETYPE) -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíà = 1 -->
<!-- êðèì³íàëüíà = 2 -->
<!-- ãîñïîäàðñüêà = 3 -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíà = 4 -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíå ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ = 5 -->
<META NAME="CAUSETYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [11] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSECATEGORY) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECATEGORY" CONTENT="4599">
<!-- [12] Ñïðàâà ðîçãëÿäàºòüñÿ ïî ³íñòàíö³¿ (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSELOCATION) -->
<!-- àïåëÿö³éí³é = A -->
<!-- êàñàö³éí³é = C -->
<META NAME="CAUSELOCATION" CONTENT="A">
<!-- [13] Ïîïåðåäí³é íîìåð ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSENUM) -->
<!-- [14] Ïîïåðåäíÿ äàòà ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSEDATE) -->
<!-- [15] Íîìåð ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSENUM" CONTENT="906/171/17">
<!-- [16] Äàòà ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="24.02.2017">
<!-- [17] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ (ïîñòàíîâëåííÿ) ñóäîâîãî ð³øåííÿ, ùî ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVRESCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVRESCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="06.04.2017">
<!-- [18] Ñóä, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCOURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="PREVCOURTNAME" CONTENT="Ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä Æèòîìèðñüêî¿ îáëàñò³">
<!-- [19] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5007">
<!-- [19.1] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="906">
<!-- [20] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ïîïåðåäíüî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECATEGORY) -->
<!-- [21] Ñåêðåòàð ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ TAGNAME(SECRETARY) -->
<!-- [22] Çàáîðîíà îïðèëþäíåííÿ TAGNAME(HEARINGCLOSED) -->
<!-- íå çàáîðîíåíî = V -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî = Z -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî òèì÷àñîâî = T -->
<META NAME="HEARINGCLOSED" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [23] Ê³ëüê-òü àðêóø³â äîêóìåíòà (ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß) -->
<!-- Ñóää³ â ð³øåíí³: -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME1" CONTENT="Ñàâð³é Â.À.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME2" CONTENT="Äåìÿí÷óê Þ.Ã.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME3" CONTENT="Äóæè÷ Ñ.Ï.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- Ñòîðîíè ð³øåííÿ: -->
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE1" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE1" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME1" CONTENT="Íàö³îíàëüíèé áàíê Óêðà¿íè">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT1" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO1" CONTENT="21575489">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL1" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE2" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE2" CONTENT="">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE2" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE2" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME2" CONTENT="Òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ &quot;Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò&quot; (ì. Ìàëèí)">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT2" CONTENT="Â³äïîâ³äà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO2" CONTENT="37555721">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL2" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE3" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE3" CONTENT="Z">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE3" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE3" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME3" CONTENT="Òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ &quot;Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò&quot; (ì. Ìàëèí)">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT3" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 2">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO3" CONTENT="37555721">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL3" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [38] Âåðñ³ÿ êë³ºíòà TAGNAME(APPVER) -->
<META NAME="APPVER" CONTENT="1.29.1.11">
<!-- [39] Êîä ïðîâàéäåðà ÅÖÏ TAGNAME(CRYPTPROVIDER) -->
<META NAME="CRYPTPROVIDER" CONTENT="DS13">
<!-- END METADATA -->
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Content-Type" CONTENT="text/html; charset=windows-1251">
<META NAME="Author" CONTENT="">
<META NAME="Description" CONTENT="Document">
<META NAME="Document-state" CONTENT="static">
<META NAME="Updated" CONTENT="19.06.2017 15:29:54">
<META NAME="Robots" CONTENT="All">
<META NAME="Keywords" CONTENT="">
<STYLE TYPE="text/css">
margin-right: 10 mm;
margin-bottom: 10 mm;
mso-paper-source: 0;
@charset "Windows-1251";
font-family: Times New Roman;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Times New Roman;
margin-bottom: 0 mm;
white-space: normal;
word-spacing: normal;
margin-bottom: 2 mm;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
<P><FONT class="fs263"> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs261"><IMG src="herb.gif" height=48 width=36></FONT></P>
<P class="ps12"><FONT class="fs163">Ð²ÂÍÅÍÑÜÊÈÉ ÀÏÅËßÖ²ÉÍÈÉ ÃÎÑÏÎÄÀÐÑÜÊÈÉ ÑÓÄ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs141">²ÌÅÍÅÌ ÓÊÐÀ¯ÍÈ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs140">Ï Î Ñ Ò À Í Î Â À</FONT></P>
<P class="ps3"> 14 ÷åðâíÿ 2017 ðîêó<FONT class="fs162"> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT>Ñïðàâà ¹<FONT class="fs161"> 906/171/17 &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs160">Ð³âíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ó ñêëàä³ êîëåã³¿:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs159">Ãîëîâóþ÷îãî &nbsp;ñóää</FONT>³ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<FONT class="fs143">&nbsp;</FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ñàâð³é Â.À.</P>
<P class="ps11"> <FONT class="fs158">ñóää³ &nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs257">&nbsp;</FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Äåìÿí÷óê Þ.Ã. , <BR>
&nbsp;<FONT class="fs157">ñóää³ &nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs256">&nbsp;</FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Äóæè÷ Ñ.Ï. &nbsp;&nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps14">ïðè ñåêðåòàð³ ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ: Ëåâ÷óê ².Î. &nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps14">ðîçãëÿíóâøè ó â³äêðèòîìó ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó â³äïîâ³äà÷à - òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ "Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» íà ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Æèòîìèðñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 06.04.17 ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹906/171/17 </P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs156">çà ïîçîâîì</FONT> Íàö³îíàëüíîãî áàíêó Óêðà¿íè (ì. Êè¿â)</P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs155">äî</FONT> &nbsp;òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» &nbsp;ì. Ìàëèí &nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps2"><FONT class="fs153">çà ó÷àñòþ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â ñòîð³í:</FONT> </P>
<P class="ps2">ïîçèâà÷à  íå ç'ÿâèâñÿ;</P>
<P class="ps4">â³äïîâ³äà÷à - íå ç'ÿâèâñÿ;</P>
<P class="ps13"><FONT class="fs152">ÂÑÒÀÍÎÂÈÂ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps1">Íå ïîãîäæóþ÷èñü ç ïðèéíÿòèì ð³øåííÿì, â³äïîâ³äà÷  òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» ïîäàâ ÷åðåç ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä Æèòîìèðñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó (àðê. ñïðàâè 90-92).</P>
<P class="ps0">Çîêðåìà â àïåëÿö³éí³é ñêàðç³ àïåëÿíò çâåðòàº óâàãó ñóäó íà òå, ùî éîãî àïåëÿö³éíà ñêàðãà ñòîñóºòüñÿ ð³øåííÿ ëèøå â ÷àñòèí³ â³äìîâè ó çàäîâîëåíí³ êëîïîòàííÿ ïðî çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³, â ³íø³é ÷àñòèí³ ð³øåííÿ íå îñêàðæóºòüñÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Òàê, îäí³ºþ ç ï³äñòàâ äëÿ â³äìîâè ó çàäîâîëåíí³ êëîïîòàííÿ ñóä çàçíà÷èâ, ùî ðîçì³ð ïåí³ óçãîäæåíèé ñòîðîíàìè ó äîãîâîð³ º íèæ÷å ð³âíÿ, âñòàíîâëåíîãî ñò.3 Çàêîíó Óêðà¿íè «Ïðî â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòü çà íåñâîº÷àñíå âèêîíàííÿ ãðîøîâèõ çîáîâÿçàíü». &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps20">Òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» íå ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ç âêàçàíèì îá´ðóíòóâàííÿì, âèõîäÿ÷è ç íàñòóïíîãî. </P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ï.3 ñò.83 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä, ïðèéìàþ÷è ð³øåííÿ, ìàº ïðàâî, çîêðåìà, çìåíøóâàòè ó íÿòêîâèõ âèïàäêàõ ðîçì³ð íåóñòîéêè (øòðàôó, ïåí³), ÿêà ï³äëÿãàº ñòÿãíåííþ ç³ îðîíè, ùî ïîðóøèëà çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ñòàòòåþ 233 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ïåðåäáà÷åíî, ùî ó ðàç³ ÿêùî íàëåæí³ äî ñïëàòè øòðàôí³ ñàíêö³¿ íàäì³ðíî âåëèê³ ïîð³âíÿíî ³ç çáèòêàìè êðåäèòîðà, ñóä ìàº ïðàâî çìåíøèòè ðîçì³ð ñàíêö³é. Ïðè öüîìó ïîâèííî áóòè âçÿòî äî óâàãè: ñòóï³íü âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ áîðæíèêîì; ìàéíîâèé ñòàí ñòîð³í, ÿê³ áåðóòü ó÷àñòü ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³; íå ëèøå ìàéíîâ³, àëå é ³íø³ ³íòåðåñè ñòîð³í, ùî çàñëóãîâóþòü íà óâàãó; ÿêùî ïîðóøåííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ íå çàâäàëî çáèòê³â ³íøèì ó÷àñíèêàì ãîñïîäàðñüêèõ â³äíîñèí, ñóä ìîæå ç óðàõóâàííÿì ³íòåðåñ³â áîðæíèêà çìåíøèòè ðîçì³ð íàëåæíèõ äî ñïëàòè øòðàôíèõ ñàíêö³é.</P>
<P class="ps15">Çàçíà÷åíèìè íîðìàìè ïðàâà íå ïåðåäáà÷åíî îö³íêè «âèíÿòêîâîñò³ âèïàäêó» òî÷êè çîðó íåâ³äïîâ³äíîñò³ äîãîâ³ðíîãî ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ äî ð³âíÿ, âñòàíîâëåíîãî çàêîíîì, îñê³ëüêè Çàêîíîì Óêðà¿íè «Ïðî â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòü çà íåñâîº÷àñíå âèêîíàííÿ ãðîøîâèõ çîáîâ'ÿçàíü» ïåðåäáà÷åíî ãðàíè÷íèé ð³âåíü ïåí³, ÿêèé íå ïîâèíåí ïåðåâèùóâàòè ïîäâ³éíî¿ îáë³êîâî¿ ñòàâêè ÍÁÓ, ³ ñàì ëèøå ôàêò óçãîäæåííÿ ñòîðîíàìè â äîãîâîð³ ìåíøîãî ðîçì³ðó íå îáìåæóº ïðàâî â³äïîâ³äà÷à ³ çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ ñóäîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">²íøîþ ï³äñòàâîþ äëÿ â³äìîâè â çàäîâîëåíí³ êëîïîòàííÿ ñóä âêàçàâ ïðî çä³éñíåíå íèì ñï³ââ³äíîøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó çàÿâëåíèõ øòðàôíèõ ñàíêö³é, çîêðåìà ç ìîæëèâèìè çáèòêàìè êðåäèòîðà.Òàêèé âèñíîâîê ñóäó â³äïîâ³äà÷ ââàæàº ïðîòèïðàâíèì âèõîäÿ÷è ç íàñòóïíîãî.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ó â³äïîâ³äíîñò³ äî ïîñòàíîâè Ïëåíóìó Âèùîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Óêðà¿íè ¹ 6 â³ä 23.03.2012 ðîêó «Ïðî ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ» ð³øåííÿ ç ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñïîðó ïîâèííî ïðèéìàòèñü ó ö³ëêîâèò³é â³äïîâ³äíîñò³ ç íîðìàìè ìàòåð³àëüíîãî ³ ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà òà ôàêòè÷íèìè îáñòàâèíàìè ñïðàâè, ç äîñòîâ³ðí³ñòþ âñòàíîâëåíèìè ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì, òîáòî ç'ÿñîâàíèìè øëÿõîì äîñë³äæåííÿ òà îö³íêè ñóäîì íàëåæíèõ ³ äîïóñòèìèõ äîêàç³â ó êîíêðåòí³é ñïðàâ³.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ó ñèëó ÷.2 ñò.82 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè ð³øåííÿ ïðèéìàºòüñÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì çà ðåçóëüòàòàìè îö³íêè äîêàç³â, ïîäàíèõ ñòîðîíàìè òà ³íøèìè ó÷àñíèêàìè ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñó, à òàêîæ äîêàç³â, ÿê³ áóëè âèòðåáóâàí³ ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì, ó íàðàä÷³é ê³ìíàò³. Äîêàçè ïîâèíí³ â³äïîâ³äàòè âèìîãàì íàëåæíîñò³ ³ äîïóñòèìîñò³, âñòàíîâëåíèìè ñò.34 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ç îãëÿäó íà âèêëàäåíå, ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ òà äîêàçóâàííÿ íå ìîæóòü ãðóíòóâàòèñÿ íà ïðèïóùåíí³.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ó äàíîìó âèïàäêó, íà äóìêó àïåëÿíòà, &nbsp;ñóä ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ çä³éñíèâ îö³íêó ðîçì³ðó øòðàôíèõ ñàíêö³é äî ìîæëèâèõ (ïðèïóùåíèõ) çáèòê³â êðåäèòîðà, îäíàê í³ ðîçì³ð, í³ õàðàêòåð, öèõ çáèòê³â íå áóëè ïðåäìåòîì äîñë³äæåííÿ â ñóä³, ïðî ³ñíóâàííÿ ÿêèõ ïîçèâà÷ íå çàÿâëÿâ òà íå ï³äòâåðäæóâàâ íàëåæíèìè äîêàçàìè.</P>
<P class="ps15">Îêð³ì òîãî, ñóä ëèøå ÷àñòêîâî ïåðåðàõóâàâ íàâåäåí³ â êëîïîòàíí³ äîâîäè â³äïîâ³äà÷à, ÿê³ äàþòü ïðàâî íà çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³, îäíàê íå ïðèéíÿâ äî óâàãè ä³éñíó âèíÿòêîâ³ñòü âèïàäêó, çîêðåìà, òå, ùî:</P>
<P class="ps15">- ïîñëóãè, íàäàí³ ÍÁÓ âèêîðèñòîâóâàëèñü ÒçÎÂ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» íå äëÿ âëàñíèõ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;ïîòðåá, à äëÿ &nbsp;íàäàííÿ êîìóíàëüíèõ ïîñëóã &nbsp;öåíòðàë³çîâàíîãî âîäîâ³äâåäåííÿ âñ³ì ñïîæèâà÷àì ì³ñòà;</P>
<P class="ps15">- çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ ç áîêó â³äïîâ³äà÷à âèêîíóâàëèñü áåççàïåðå÷åíî, ó âèçíà÷åíèé ï.5.2 Äîãîâîðó àëüòåðíàòèâíèé ñïîñ³á øëÿõîì çàðàõóâàííÿ çóñòð³÷íèõ îäíîð³äíèõ âèìîã. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;÷àñòèíè &nbsp;&nbsp;çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, &nbsp;&nbsp;ÿêà &nbsp;&nbsp;íå &nbsp;&nbsp;îõîïëþâàëàñü &nbsp;&nbsp;ïåðøèì âçàºìîçàë³êîì, &nbsp;áóëî &nbsp;ïðèïèíåíî &nbsp;÷åðåç &nbsp;íåçíà÷íèé &nbsp;ïðîì³æîê ÷àñó &nbsp;(íå &nbsp;á³ëüøå &nbsp;6 ì³ñÿö³â), à íà ìîìåíò ïðåä'ÿâëåííÿ ïîçîâó äî ñóäó - ïîãàøåíà â ïîâíîìó îáñÿç³;</P>
<P class="ps15">- ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ âèíèêëî ïî ïðè÷èí³ íàÿâíîñò³ çàáîðãîâàíîñò³ áþäæåòó ïåðåä ÒçÎÂ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» çà ð³çíèöþ â òàðèôàõ;</P>
<P class="ps15">- ñêðóòíèé ô³íàíñîâèé ñòàí ÒçÎÂ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò», ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ äîâ³äêîþ ïðî íàÿâí³ñòü çàáîðãîâàíîñò³ ³ç çàðîá³òíî¿ ïëàòè ïðàö³âíèêàì òà íåäî¿ìêîþ äî áþäæåòó ç ïîäàòêîâîãî áîðãó.</P>
<P class="ps15">ÒçÎÂ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» ââàæàº, ùî ñóäîì ïðè âèð³øåíí³ ïèòàííÿ çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ íå â ïîâí³é ì³ð³ áóëè ç'ÿñîâàí³ îáñòàâèíè, ÿê³ ï³äòâåðäæåí³ íàëåæíèìè äîêàçàìè, òà ìàþòü çíà÷åííÿ äëÿ ñïðàâè; ð³øåííÿ âìîòèâîâàíî áåç íàëåæíîãî äîâåäåííÿ îáñòàâèí, ÿê³ ñóä ââàæàâ âñòàíîâëåíèìè (çàñíîâàí³ íà ïðèïóùåíí³); ð³øåííÿ óõâàëåíå ïðè íåïðàâèëüíîìó çàñòîñóâàíí³ íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî ïðàâà (÷.³ ñò.233 ÃÓ Óêðà¿íè. ÷.Ç ñò.551 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè) òà ç ïîðóøåííÿì íîðì ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà (ñò.ñò.32,33,34,43,84 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè), ùî â ñóêóïíîñò³ çã³äíî ñò.104 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè äàþòü ï³äñòàâè äëÿ éîãî ñêàñóâàííÿ â ÷àñòèí³ â³äìîâè â çàäîâîëåíí³ êëîïîòàííÿ ïðî çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³, ç ïîñòàíîâëåííÿì íîâîãî ñóäîâîãî ð³øåííÿ â ö³é ÷àñòèí³ ïðî çàäîâîëåííÿ êëîïîòàííÿ ïðî çìåíøåííÿ ïåí³.</P>
<P class="ps15">Óõâàëîþ Ð³âíåíñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó â³ä 10.05.2017 ð. àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» ïðèéíÿòî äî ïðîâàäæåííÿ òà ïðèçíà÷åíî äî ðîçãëÿäó &nbsp;íà 14.06.2017 ð. (àðê. ñïðàâè 89) </P>
<P class="ps15">Íà àäðåñó Ð³âíåíñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó â³ä ïîçèâà÷à  Íàö³îíàëüíîãî áàíêó Óêðà¿íè íàä³éøîâ â³äçèâ íà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó (âõ. ¹1526/17 â³ä 29.05.17 ð.), â ÿêîìó â³í çàïåðå÷óº ïðîòè äîâîä³â ñêàðæíèêà. Ââàæàº, ùî ð³øåííÿ ïðèéíÿòå ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ º çàêîííèì òà îá´ðóíòîâàíèì, òàêèì, ùî ïðèéíÿòå ç äîòðèìàííÿì íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà (àðê. ñïðàâè 104-106).</P>
<P class="ps15">Ïðåäñòàâíèê àïåëÿíòà ó ñóäîâå çàñ³äàííÿ íå ç»ÿâèâñÿ, ïðîòå íàä³ñëàâ íà àäðåñó ñóäó êëîïîòàííÿ ó ÿêîìó ïðîñèòü ñóä ðîçãëÿíóòè àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó áåç éîãî ó÷àñò³ çà íàÿâíèìè ó ñïðàâ³ ìàòåð³àëàìè. </P>
<P class="ps15">Ïðåäñòàâíèê ïîçèâà÷à òàêîæ ó ñóäîâå çàñ³äàííÿ íå ç»ÿâèâñÿ. &nbsp;&nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps15">Âðàõîâóþ÷è ïðèïèñè ñò. 101 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè ïðî ìåæ³ ïåðåãëÿäó ñïðàâ â àïåëÿö³éí³é ³íñòàíö³¿, ñò. 102 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè ïðî ñòðîêè ðîçãëÿäó àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè òà òîé ôàêò, ùî íåÿâêà â çàñ³äàííÿ ñóäó ïðåäñòàâíèê³â ñòîð³í, íàëåæíèì ÷èíîì òà â³äïîâ³äíî äî çàêîíîäàâñòâà ïîâ³äîìëåíèõ ïðî äàòó, ÷àñ òà ì³ñöå ðîçãëÿäó ñïðàâè, íå ïåðåøêîäæàº ïåðåãëÿäó îñêàðæåíîãî ð³øåííÿ, ñóäîâà êîëåã³ÿ âèçíàëà çà ìîæëèâå ðîçãëÿíóòè àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó çà â³äñóòíîñò³ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â ñòîð³í.</P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs151">Ðîçãëÿäîì ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè âñòàíîâëåíî:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps15">01.06.2016 ì³æ Íàö³îíàëüíèì áàíêîì Óêðà¿íè (âèêîíàâåöü/ïîçèâà÷) òà òîâàðèñòâîì ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ "Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò" (ñïîæèâà÷/â³äïîâ³äà÷) óêëàäåíî äîãîâ³ð ¹ô/16-81-183 ïðî íàäàííÿ ïîñëóã.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ïóíêòó 1.1 äîãîâîðó âèêîíàâåöü çîáîâ'ÿçàâñÿ çàáåçïå÷èòè íàäàííÿ ïîñëóã êàíàë³çàö³éíèõ (âèäàëåííÿ òà îáðîáëåííÿ ñò³÷íèõ âîä), à ñàìå ïðèéìàííÿ ³ î÷èùåííÿ ñò³÷íèõ âîä ñïîæèâà÷à íà î÷èñíèõ ñïîðóäàõ âèêîíàâöÿ çà àäðåñîþ âóë. ×îðíîâîëà, 44à, ì. Ìàëèí, â îá'ºì³ (îð³ºíòîâíî) 1000 òèñ. ì3 ïðîòÿãîì ä³¿ äîãîâîðó, à ñïîæèâà÷ çîáîâ'ÿçóºòüñÿ îïëàòèòè íàäàí³ éîìó ïîñëóãè íà óìîâàõ, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ öèì äîãîâîðîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Çã³äíî ïóíêòó 11.1 ä³ÿ öüîãî äîãîâîðó ïîøèðþºòüñÿ íà â³äíîñèíè, ÿê³ âèíèêëè ç 01.04.2016.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ïóíêòó 5.2 äîãîâîðó ðîçðàõóíêè ïî äàíîìó äîãîâîðó çä³éñíþþòüñÿ:</P>
<P class="ps15">- ïåðåðàõóâàííÿì çàìîâíèêîì íà ðîçðàõóíêîâèé ðàõóíîê âèêîíàâöÿ êîøò³â;</P>
<P class="ps15">- øëÿõîì çàðàõóâàííÿ çàìîâíèêîì çóñòð³÷íèõ îäíîð³äíèõ âèìîã, ÿê³ îôîðìëÿþòüñÿ â³äïîâ³äíèì àêòîì, ùî ï³äïèñóºòüñÿ ïîâíîâàæåíèìè îñîáàìè îáîõ ñòîð³í.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ïóíêòó 5.3 äîãîâîðó ðîçðàõóíêîâèì ïåð³îäîì º êàëåíäàðíèé ì³ñÿöü.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ïóíêòó 5.4 äîãîâîðó ðîçðàõóíêè çà ïîñëóãè çã³äíî öüîãî äîãîâîðó ïðîâîäÿòüñÿ íà ï³äñòàâ³ ðàõóíêó, ÿêèé âèêîíàâåöü âèñòàâëÿº ñïîæèâà÷ó ï³ñëÿ çàê³í÷åííÿ ðîçðàõóíêîâîãî ïåð³îäó. Ñïîæèâà÷ çîáîâ'ÿçàíèé îïëàòèòè öåé ðàõóíîê ïðîòÿãîì 5 (ï'ÿòè) áàíê³âñüêèõ äí³ ç äàòè éîãî îäåðæàííÿ (íåçàëåæíî â³ä ôîðìè çä³éñíåííÿ ðîçðàõóíê³â).</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî óìîâ äîãîâîðó ñòîðîíè ïðîâåëè çàðàõóâàííÿ çóñòð³÷íèõ îäíîð³äíèõ âèìîã, ïðè öüîìó ñóìà çàáîðãîâàíîñò³ ñïîæèâà÷à ïåðåä ïîçèâà÷åì çà íàäàí³ ïîñëóãè ñêëàëà: 217108,27 ãðí.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ó âåðåñí³ òà æîâòí³ 2016 â ðàõóíîê âêàçàíî¿ çàáîðãîâàíîñò³ áóëî ïðîâåäåíî äîäàòêîâèé âçàºìîçàë³ê, ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ àêòàìè ïðî çàðàõóâàííÿ çóñòð³÷íèõ âèìîã ¹8 â³ä 30.09.2016 òà ¹9 â³ä 31.10.2016 (à.ñ. 26, 27).</P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs150">Ðîçãëÿíóâøè äîâîäè àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè, âèâ÷èâøè ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè, íàÿâí³ â í³é äîêàçè, ïåðåâ³ðèâøè ïðàâèëüí³ñòü çàñòîñóâàííÿ ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà, Ð³âíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ïðèéøîâ äî âèñíîâêó ïðî íàñòóïíå: </FONT></P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ñò. 901 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè ïåðåäáà÷åíî, ùî çà äîãîâîðîì ïðî íàäàííÿ ïîñëóã îäíà ñòîðîíà (âèêîíàâåöü) çîáîâ'ÿçóºòüñÿ çà çàâäàííÿì äðóãî¿ ñòîðîíè (çàìîâíèêà) íàäàòè ïîñëóãó, ÿêà ñïîæèâàºòüñÿ â ïðîöåñ³ â÷èíåííÿ ïåâíî¿ ä³¿ àáî çä³éñíåííÿ ïåâíî¿ ä³ÿëüíîñò³, à çàìîâíèê çîáîâ'ÿçóºòüñÿ îïëàòèòè âèêîíàâöåâ³ çàçíà÷åíó ïîñëóãó, ÿêùî ³íøå íå âñòàíîâëåíî äîãîâîðîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">×àñòèíîþ 1 ñò. 903 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè ïåðåäáà÷åíî, ùî ÿêùî äîãîâîðîì ïåðåäáà÷åíî íàäàííÿ ïîñëóã çà ïëàòó, çàìîâíèê çîáîâ'ÿçàíèé îïëàòèòè íàäàíó éîìó ïîñëóãó â ðîçì³ð³, ó ñòðîêè òà â ïîðÿäêó, ùî âñòàíîâëåí³ äîãîâîðîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ïðèïèñàìè &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;÷. 1 ñò. 193 ÃÊ Óêðà¿íè ïåðåäáà÷åíî, ùî ñóá'ºêòè ãîñïîäàðþâàííÿ òà ³íø³ ó÷àñíèêè ãîñïîäàðñüêèõ â³äíîñèí ïîâèíí³ âèêîíóâàòè ãîñïîäàðñüê³ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ íàëåæíèì ÷èíîì â³äïîâ³äíî äî çàêîíó, ³íøèõ ïðàâîâèõ àêò³â, äîãîâîðó, à çà â³äñóòíîñò³ êîíêðåòíèõ âèìîã ùîäî âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ - â³äïîâ³äíî äî âèìîã, ùî ó ïåâíèõ óìîâàõ çâè÷àéíî ñòàâëÿòüñÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷. 1 ñò. 530 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, ÿêùî ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³ âñòàíîâëåíèé ñòðîê (òåðì³í) éîãî âèêîíàííÿ, òî âîíî ï³äëÿãàº âèêîíàííþ ó öåé ñòðîê (òåðì³í).</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷. 1 ñò. 612 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè áîðæíèê ââàæàºòüñÿ òàêèì, ùî ïðîñòðî÷èâ, ÿêùî â³í íå ïðèñòóïèâ äî âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ àáî íå âèêîíàâ éîãî ó ñòðîê, âñòàíîâëåíèé äîãîâîðîì àáî çàêîíîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Çã³äíî ï. 3 ñò. 611 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè ó ðàç³ ïîðóøåííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ íàñòàþòü ïðàâîâ³ íàñë³äêè, âñòàíîâëåí³ äîãîâîðîì àáî çàêîíîì, çîêðåìà ñïëàòà íåóñòîéêè.</P>
<P class="ps15">×àñòèíîþ 3 ñò. 549 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè ïåðåäáà÷åíî, ùî ïåíåþ º íåóñòîéêà, ùî îá÷èñëþºòüñÿ ó â³äñîòêàõ â³ä ñóìè íåâèêîíàíîãî ãðîøîâîãî çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ çà êîæåí äåíü ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ âèêîíàííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Íàâåäåí³ íîðìè ñâ³ä÷àòü, ùî çà ïîðóøåííÿ ãðîøîâîãî çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ áîðæíèê íà âèìîãó êðåäèòîðà &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;çîáîâ'ÿçàíèé &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;ñïëàòèòè íåóñòîéêó (øòðàô, ïåíþ).</P>
<P class="ps15">ßê âáà÷àºòüñÿ ç ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè, çîêðåìà ï. 6.2 äîãîâîðó ó ðàç³ çàòðèìêè ïëàòåæ³â, ñòðîêè ÿêèõ çàçíà÷åíî â äîãîâîð³, ñïîæèâà÷ âèïëà÷óº âèêîíàâöþ íà éîãî âèìîãó ïåíþ â ðîçì³ð³ îáë³êîâî¿ ñòàâêè Íàö³îíàëüíîãî áàíêó Óêðà¿íè, ùî ä³ÿëà â ïåð³îä, çà ÿêèé ñïëà÷óºòüñÿ ïåíÿ, â³ä ñóìè çàáîðãîâàíîñò³ çà êîæåí äåíü ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷. 1 ñò. 625 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè áîðæíèê íå çâ³ëüíÿºòüñÿ â³ä â³äïîâ³äàëüíîñò³ çà íåìîæëèâ³ñòü âèêîíàííÿ íèì ãðîøîâîãî çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ. </P>
<P class="ps15">Ó â³äïîâ³äíîñò³ äî ÷. 2 âêàçàíî¿ ñòàòò³ áîðæíèê, ÿêèé ïðîñòðî÷èâ âèêîíàííÿ ãðîøîâîãî çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, íà âèìîãó êðåäèòîðà çîáîâ'ÿçàíèé ñïëàòèòè ñóìó áîðãó ç óðàõóâàííÿì âñòàíîâëåíîãî ³íäåêñó ³íôëÿö³¿ çà âåñü ÷àñ ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ, à òàêîæ òðè ïðîöåíòè ð³÷íèõ â³ä ïðîñòðî÷åíî¿ ñóìè, ÿêùî ³íøèé ðîçì³ð ïðîöåíò³â íå âñòàíîâëåíèé äîãîâîðîì àáî çàêîíîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Òàêîæ êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ³ç ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿, ùîäî ðîçðàõóíêó 3% ð³÷íèõ. Â ö³é ÷àñòèí³ ïîçîâíèõ âèìîã îá´ðóíòîâàíèìè äî ñòÿãíåííÿ ñóä &nbsp;ââàæàº 2992,21 ãðí. Â ñòÿãíåíí³ 8,21 ãðí. 3% ð³÷íèõ ñóäîì â³äìîâëåíî ïðàâîì³ðíî.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ó ñóä³ ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ â³äïîâ³äà÷ ïîäàâ êëîïîòàííÿ ïðî çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ íà 50%, ìîòèâóþ÷è öå òèì, ùî ÒçÎÂ "Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò" º ï³äïðèºìñòâîì êîìóíàëüíî¿ ôîðìè âëàñíîñò³ òà çä³éñíþº ãîñïîäàðñüêó ä³ÿëüí³ñòü ó ñôåð³ íàäàííÿ æèòëîâî-êîìóíàëüíèõ ïîñëóã, â ò. ÷. öåíòðàë³çîâàíîãî âîäîâ³äâåäåííÿ äëÿ çàáåçïå÷åííÿ ïîòðåá òåðèòîð³àëüíî¿ ãðîìàäè. Òàêîæ â³äïîâ³äà÷ â îá´ðóíòóâàííÿ êëîïîòàííÿ çàçíà÷èâ, ùî ïåðåáóâàº â äóæå âàæêîìó ô³íàíñîâîìó ñòàíîâèù³, îñê³ëüêè òàðèô íà òåïëîâó åíåðã³þ âñòàíîâëåíèé íèæ÷å ¿¿ ñîá³âàðòîñò³, àëå êîìïåíñàö³¿ ð³çíèö³ òàðèô³â íå ïåðåäáà÷åíî. Ïðåäñòàâíèê â³äïîâ³äà÷à ïðîñèâ âðàõóâàòè ñòóï³íü âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ áîðæíèêîì, íåçíà÷í³ñòü ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ òà íåâ³äïîâ³äí³ñòü ðîçì³ðó íåóñòîéêè çàïîä³ÿíèì íàñë³äêàì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ðîçãëÿäàþ÷è äàíå êëîïîòàííÿ, ì³ñöåâèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ïðàâîì³ðíî ïðèéøîâ äî íàñòóïíîãî âèñíîâêó.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷àñòèíè 3 ñòàòò³ 551 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ðîçì³ð íåóñòîéêè ìîæå áóòè çìåíøåíèé çà ð³øåííÿì ñóäó, ÿêùî â³í çíà÷íî ïåðåâèùóº ðîçì³ð çáèòê³â, òà çà íàÿâíîñò³ ³íøèõ îáñòàâèí, ÿê³ ìàþòü ³ñòîòíå çíà÷åííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Çã³äíî ÷àñòèíè 1 ñòàòò³ 233 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ó ðàç³ ÿêùî íàëåæí³ äî ñïëàòè øòðàôí³ ñàíêö³¿ íàäì³ðíî âåëèê³ ïîð³âíÿíî ³ç çáèòêàìè êðåäèòîðà, ñóä ìàº ïðàâî çìåíøèòè ðîçì³ð ñàíêö³é. Ïðè öüîìó ïîâèííî áóòè âçÿòî äî óâàãè: ñòóï³íü âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ áîðæíèêîì; ìàéíîâèé ñòàí ñòîð³í, ÿê³ áåðóòü ó÷àñòü ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³; íå ëèøå ìàéíîâ³, àëå é ³íø³ ³íòåðåñè ñòîð³í, ùî çàñëóãîâóþòü íà óâàãó.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ñòàòòÿ 83 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè íàäàº ãîñïîäàðñüêîìó ñóäó ïðàâî, ïðèéìàþ÷è ð³øåííÿ, çìåíøóâàòè ó âèíÿòêîâèõ âèïàäêàõ ðîçì³ð íåóñòîéêè (øòðàôó, ïåí³), ÿêà ï³äëÿãàº ñòÿãíåííþ ç³ ñòîðîíè, ùî ïîðóøèëà çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ïðàâîâèé àíàë³ç íàçâàíèõ ñòàòåé ñâ³ä÷èòü, ùî âîíè íå º ³ìïåðàòèâíèìè òà çàñòîñîâóþòüñÿ çà âèçíà÷åíèõ óìîâ íà ðîçñóä ñóäó.</P>
<P class="ps15">Âèð³øóþ÷è ïèòàííÿ ïðî çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ òà øòðàôó, ÿêà ï³äëÿãàº ñòÿãíåííþ ç³ ñòîðîíè, ùî ïîðóøèëà çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, ñóä ïîâèíåí îá'ºêòèâíî îö³íèòè, ÷è º äàíèé âèïàäîê âèíÿòêîâèì, âèõîäÿ÷è ç ³íòåðåñ³â ñòîð³í, ÿê³ çàñëóãîâóþòü íà óâàãó, ñòóïåíÿ âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàíü, ïðè÷èíè íåíàëåæíîãî âèêîíàííÿ àáî íåâèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, íåçíà÷íîñò³ ïðîñòðî÷åííÿ ó âèêîíàíí³ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, íåâ³äïîâ³äíîñò³ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ íàñë³äêàì ïîðóøåííÿ, íåãàéíîãî äîáðîâ³ëüíîãî óñóíåííÿ âèííîþ ñòîðîíîþ ïîðóøåííÿ òà éîãî íàñë³äê³â.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ïðè âèð³øåíí³ ïèòàííÿ ïðî ìîæëèâ³ñòü çìåíøåííÿ íåóñòîéêè, ñóä áåðå äî óâàãè ìàéíîâèé ñòàí îáîõ ñòîð³í, à òàêîæ ðîçì³ð ïåí³, ùî ñòàíîâèòü íèæ÷å ð³âíÿ, âñòàíîâëåíîãî ñò. 3 Çàêîíó Óêðà¿íè "Ïðî â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòü çà íåñâîº÷àñíå âèêîíàííÿ ãðîøîâèõ çîáîâ'ÿçàíü"</P>
<P class="ps15">Ç îãëÿäó íà âèêëàäåíå, îö³íèâøè ñï³ââ³äíîøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó çàÿâëåíèõ øòðàôíèõ ñàíêö³é, çîêðåìà, ç ìîæëèâèìè çáèòêàìè êðåäèòîðà, âðàõîâóþ÷è ³íòåðåñè îáîõ ñòîð³í, â ò.÷. ìàéíîâ³, ì³ñöåâèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ä³éøîâ âèñíîâêó ïðî â³äñóòí³ñòü ï³äñòàâ äëÿ çìåíøåííÿ ðîçì³ðó ïåí³ äî 50% òà â³äìîâèâ ó çàäîâîëåíí³ äàíîãî êëîïîòàííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15">ßê âèçíà÷àº ñò. 32 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, äîêàçàìè ó ñïðàâ³ º áóäü-ÿê³ ôàêòè÷í³ äàí³, íà ï³äñòàâ³ ÿêèõ ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä âñòàíîâëþº íàÿâí³ñòü ÷è â³äñóòí³ñòü îáñòàâèí, íà ÿêèõ ´ðóíòóþòüñÿ âèìîãè ³ çàïåðå÷åííÿ, à òàêîæ ³íø³ îáñòàâèíè, ÿê³ ìàþòü çíà÷åííÿ äëÿ ïðàâèëüíîãî âèð³øåííÿ ñïîðó. </P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ñò. 34 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè oáñòàâèíè ñïðàâè, ÿê³ â³äïîâ³äíî äî çàêîíîäàâñòâà ïîâèíí³ áóòè ï³äòâåðäæåí³ ïåâíèìè çàñîáàìè äîêàçóâàííÿ, íå ìîæóòü ï³äòâåðäæóâàòèñÿ ³íøèìè çàñîáàìè äîêàçóâàííÿ. </P>
<P class="ps15">Äîâîäè ñêàðæíèêà çàçíà÷åí³ â àïåëÿö³éí³é ñêàðç³, àïåëÿö³éíèì ñóäîì íå âèçíàþòüñÿ òàêèìè, ùî ìîæóòü áóòè ï³äñòàâîþ çã³äíî ñò.104 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè äëÿ ñêàñóâàííÿ ÷è çì³íè îñêàðæóâàíîãî ð³øåííÿ, òîìó ñóä àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ ââàæàº, ùî ð³øåííÿ ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó ïðèéíÿòå ó â³äïîâ³äíîñò³ äî íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà ³ éîãî ñë³ä çàëèøèòè áåç çì³í, à àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó  áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs149">Êåðóþ÷èñü, ñò.ñò. 33, 43, 99, 101, 103, 105 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, Ð³âíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä  </FONT></P>
<P class="ps18"><FONT class="fs148">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÈÂ</FONT>:</P>
<P class="ps15">Àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó â³äïîâ³äà÷à  òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ «Ìàëèí Åíåðãî³íâåñò» íà ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Æèòîìèðñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ &nbsp;â³ä 06.04.2017 ðîêó ó ñïðàâ³ ¹906/171/17  çàëèøèòè áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ, à ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿  áåç çì³í.</P>
<P class="ps9">Ïîñòàíîâà íàáèðàº çàêîííî¿ ñèëè ç äíÿ ¿¿ ïðèéíÿòòÿ ³ ìîæå áóòè îñêàðæåíà â êàñàö³éíîìó ïîðÿäêó.</P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs147">Ãîëîâóþ÷èé &nbsp;ñóääÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ñàâð³é Â.À. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs146">Ñóääÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Äåìÿí÷óê Þ.Ã. &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<FONT class="fs145">Ñóääÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Äóæè÷ Ñ.Ï. &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"> </P>