<TITLE>922/3669/16</TITLE>
<!-- BEGIN METADATA -->
<!-- Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ôàéëà ç ð³øåííÿì -->
<META NAME="FILENAME" CONTENT="5039_1330589.html">
<!-- 1,2 ID ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCID, DOCORGID) - íóæíî äëÿ ïîëó÷åíèÿ ïîäòâåðæäåíèÿ ðååñòðàöèè -->
<META NAME="DOCID" CONTENT="1330589">
<META NAME="DOCORGID" CONTENT="107">
<!-- [3] Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(COURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="COURTNAME" CONTENT="Õàðê³âñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä">
<!-- [4] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5039">
<!-- [4.1] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="978">
<!-- [5] Ñïðàâà íîìåð TAGNAME(CAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="CAUSENUM" CONTENT="922/3669/16">
<!-- [6] Äàòà ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="CAUSEDATE" CONTENT="13.01.2017">
<!-- [7] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCDATE) -->
<META NAME="DOCDATE" CONTENT="16.03.2017">
<!-- [9] Ôîðìà ð³øåííÿ (ID) TAGNAME(DOCTYPE) -->
<!-- ð³øåííÿ = 2 -->
<!-- ïîñòàíîâà = 3 -->
<!-- óõâàëà ñóäó = 4 -->
<!-- ñóäîâèé íàêàç = 5 -->
<!-- îêðåìà óõâàëà = 6 -->
<META NAME="DOCTYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [10] Ôîðìà ñóäî÷èíñòâà (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSETYPE) -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíà = 1 -->
<!-- êðèì³íàëüíà = 2 -->
<!-- ãîñïîäàðñüêà = 3 -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíà = 4 -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíå ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ = 5 -->
<META NAME="CAUSETYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [11] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSECATEGORY) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECATEGORY" CONTENT="4069">
<!-- [12] Ñïðàâà ðîçãëÿäàºòüñÿ ïî ³íñòàíö³¿ (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSELOCATION) -->
<!-- àïåëÿö³éí³é = A -->
<!-- êàñàö³éí³é = C -->
<META NAME="CAUSELOCATION" CONTENT="A">
<!-- [13] Ïîïåðåäí³é íîìåð ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSENUM) -->
<!-- [14] Ïîïåðåäíÿ äàòà ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSEDATE) -->
<!-- [15] Íîìåð ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSENUM" CONTENT="922/3669/16">
<!-- [16] Äàòà ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="31.10.2016">
<!-- [17] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ (ïîñòàíîâëåííÿ) ñóäîâîãî ð³øåííÿ, ùî ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVRESCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVRESCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="21.12.2016">
<!-- [18] Ñóä, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCOURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="PREVCOURTNAME" CONTENT="Ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä Õàðê³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³">
<!-- [19] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5023">
<!-- [19.1] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="922">
<!-- [20] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ïîïåðåäíüî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECATEGORY) -->
<!-- [21] Ñåêðåòàð ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ TAGNAME(SECRETARY) -->
<!-- [22] Çàáîðîíà îïðèëþäíåííÿ TAGNAME(HEARINGCLOSED) -->
<!-- íå çàáîðîíåíî = V -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî = Z -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî òèì÷àñîâî = T -->
<META NAME="HEARINGCLOSED" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [23] Ê³ëüê-òü àðêóø³â äîêóìåíòà (ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß) -->
<!-- Ñóää³ â ð³øåíí³: -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME1" CONTENT="Øåâåëü Î. Â.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME2" CONTENT="Êðåñòüÿí³íîâ Î.Î.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME3" CONTENT="Ôîì³íà Â. Î.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- Ñòîðîíè ð³øåííÿ: -->
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE1" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE1" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME1" CONTENT="ÒÎÂ &quot;ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT1" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO1" CONTENT="35559557">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL1" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE2" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE2" CONTENT="Z">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE2" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE2" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME2" CONTENT="ÒÎÂ &quot;ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT2" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 2">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO2" CONTENT="35559557">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL2" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE3" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE3" CONTENT="">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE3" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE3" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME3" CONTENT="ÒÎÂ &quot;ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT3" CONTENT="Â³äïîâ³äà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO3" CONTENT="37092469">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL3" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [38] Âåðñ³ÿ êë³ºíòà TAGNAME(APPVER) -->
<META NAME="APPVER" CONTENT="1.28.3.18">
<!-- [39] Êîä ïðîâàéäåðà ÅÖÏ TAGNAME(CRYPTPROVIDER) -->
<META NAME="CRYPTPROVIDER" CONTENT="DS13">
<!-- END METADATA -->
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Content-Type" CONTENT="text/html; charset=windows-1251">
<META NAME="Author" CONTENT="">
<META NAME="Description" CONTENT="Document">
<META NAME="Document-state" CONTENT="static">
<META NAME="Updated" CONTENT="21.03.2017 10:04:26">
<META NAME="Robots" CONTENT="All">
<META NAME="Keywords" CONTENT="">
<STYLE TYPE="text/css">
margin-right: 10 mm;
margin-bottom: 10 mm;
mso-paper-source: 0;
@charset "Windows-1251";
font-family: Times New Roman;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Times New Roman;
margin-bottom: 0 mm;
white-space: normal;
word-spacing: normal;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
margin-right: -1 mm;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
<P class="ps22"><FONT class="fs32"> <IMG src="herb.gif" height=72 width=54></FONT></P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs124">ÕÀÐÊ²ÂÑÜÊÈÉ ÀÏÅËßÖ²ÉÍÈÉ ÃÎÑÏÎÄÀÐÑÜÊÈÉ ÑÓÄ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs123">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÀ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs122">²ÌÅÍÅÌ ÓÊÐÀ¯ÍÈ</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs274"> "16" áåðåçíÿ 2017 ð.</FONT><FONT class="fs153"> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs273">Ñïðàâà ¹ 922/3669/16</FONT><FONT class="fs152"> &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps1"><FONT class="fs139">Êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ó ñêëàä³: ãîëîâóþ÷èé ñóääÿ</FONT><FONT class="fs272"> Øåâåëü Î. Â.</FONT><FONT class="fs138">, ñóääÿ</FONT><FONT class="fs271"> Êðåñòüÿí³íîâ Î.Î.</FONT><FONT class="fs137"> , ñóääÿ</FONT><FONT class="fs270"> &nbsp;Ôîì³íà Â. Î.</FONT><FONT class="fs136"> </FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs269">ïðè ñåêðåòàð³ Êóð÷åíêî Â.À.,</FONT></P>
<P class="ps3"><FONT class="fs268">çà ó÷àñòþ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps3"><FONT class="fs267">ïîçèâà÷à  íå çÿâèâñÿ,</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs266">â³äïîâ³äà÷à - &nbsp;íå çÿâèâñÿ,</FONT></P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs265">ðîçãëÿíóâøè ó â³äêðèòîìó ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ ó ïðèì³ùåíí³ Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé, ì. Êè¿â (</FONT><FONT class="fs151">âõ ¹ 230 Õ/2</FONT><FONT class="fs264">) íà ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Õàðê³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 21.12.2016 &nbsp;ó ñïðàâ³</FONT><FONT class="fs150"> </FONT><FONT class="fs263">¹ 922/3669/16</FONT></P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs135">çà ïîçîâîì</FONT><FONT class="fs156">&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs262">Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé, ì. Êè¿â</FONT></P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs134">äî </FONT><FONT class="fs261">Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð, ì. Õàðê³â,</FONT></P>
<P class="ps15"><FONT class="fs133">ïðî</FONT><FONT class="fs155"> </FONT><FONT class="fs132">ñòÿãíåííÿ</FONT><FONT class="fs260"> </FONT><FONT class="fs131">1074000,00 ãðí.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps20"><FONT class="fs149">ÂÑÒÀÍÎÂÈËÀ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs259">Ð³øåííÿì ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Õàðê³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 21.12.2016 (ñóääÿ Ñâåòë³÷íèé Þ.Â.) â³äìîâëåíî ó çàäîâîëåíí³ ïîçîâó ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé äî ÒÎÂ ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð ïðî ñòÿãíåííÿ 1074000,00 ãðí. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs258">ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé ³ç ð³øåííÿì íå ïîãîäèëîñü, ïîäàëî àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó, â ÿê³é ïîñèëàþ÷èñü íà ïîðóøåííÿ ì³ñöåâèì ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî ïðàâà òà íåïîâíå çÿñóâàííÿ îáñòàâèí, ùî ìàþòü çíà÷åííÿ äëÿ ñïðàâè, ïðîñèòü îñêàðæóâàíå ð³øåííÿ ñêàñóâàòè òà ïðèéíÿòè íîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêèì çàäîâîëüíèòè ïîçîâ ó ïîâíîìó îáñÿç³; ñóäîâ³ âèòðàòè ïîêëàñòè íà â³äïîâ³äà÷à. Àïåëÿíò ïîñèëàºòüñÿ íà òå, ùî ÒÎÂ ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð ïðîòèïðàâíî òà âñóïåðå÷ óìîâàì óêëàäåíîãî ì³æ ñòîðîíàìè äîãîâîðó óõèëÿëîñÿ â³ä íàëåæíîãî âèêîíàííÿ äîãîâîðó â ÷àñòèí³ ïðèéíÿòòÿ òà îïëàòè òîâàðó òà/àáî çì³íè ì³ñöÿ äîñòàâêè, àáî æ âíåñåííÿ çì³í äî äîãîâîðó. ²ç ïîñèëàííÿì íà âêàçàí³ îáñòàâèíè àïåëÿíòîì íàðàõîâàíî äî ñòÿãíåííÿ çáèòêè ó ðîçì³ð³ 1074000,00 ãðí. (939913,20 ãðí. ôàêòè÷íèõ çáèòê³â òà 134086,80 ãðí. óïóùåíî¿ âèãîäè).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs257">Óõâàëîþ Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó â³ä 16.01.2017 âêàçàíó àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó áóëî ïðèéíÿòî äî ïðîâàäæåííÿ òà ïðèçíà÷åíî ¿¿ ðîçãëÿä íà 02.02.2017. Çîáîâÿçàíî ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé íàäàòè ñóäó îðèã³íàë ïëàò³æíîãî äîðó÷åííÿ ¹159 â³ä 29.12.2016. Çàïðîïîíîâàíî ó÷àñíèêàì ïðîöåñó íàäàòè ñóäó àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿: ïîçèâà÷ó  ïèñüìîâ³ ïîÿñíåííÿ ç ïîñèëàííÿì íà â³äïîâ³äí³ íîðìè ÷èííîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà â îá´ðóíòóâàííÿ ñâîº¿ ïîçèö³¿ ó ñïðàâ³ òà äîêàçè íà ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ôàêò³â, âèêëàäåíèõ â àïåëÿö³éí³é ñêàðç³, â³äïîâ³äà÷ó  â³äçèâ íà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó ç ïîñèëàííÿì íà â³äïîâ³äí³ íîðìè ÷èííîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà â îá´ðóíòóâàííÿ ñâîº¿ ïîçèö³¿ ó ñïðàâ³ òà äîêàçè íà ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ñâî¿õ çàïåðå÷åíü. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs256">Óõâàëîþ Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó â³ä 02.02.2017 ðîçãëÿä ñïðàâè â³äêëàäåíî íà 01.03.2017. Çîáîâÿçàíî ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé âèêîíàòè âèìîãè óõâàëè ñóäó â³ä 16.01.2017 ùîäî íàäàííÿ îðèã³íàëó ïëàò³æíîãî äîðó÷åííÿ ¹159 â³ä 29.12.2016. Çàïðîïîíîâàíî ó÷àñíèêàì ïðîöåñó íå ï³çí³øå í³æ çà òðè äí³ äî ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ íàäàòè ñóäó: â³äïîâ³äà÷ó  â³äçèâ íà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó, ïîçèâà÷ó  ìîòèâîâàí³ ïîÿñíåííÿ ùîäî ïðàâîâî¿ ïîçèö³¿ â äàí³é ñïðàâ³, ç óðàõóâàííÿì ïèòàíü, ÿê³ áóëè ïðåäìåòîì ðîçãëÿäó â ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ 02.02.2017.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs255">28.02.2017 ïîçèâà÷, ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé íàä³ñëàâ åëåêòðîííîþ ïîøòîþ (âõ. ¹ 2254) êîï³þ ïëàò³æíîãî äîðó÷åííÿ ¹159 â³ä 29.12.2016 ³ç çàçíà÷åííÿì òîãî, ùî îðèã³íàë ïëàò³æíîãî äîðó÷åííÿ áóâ â³äïðàâëåíèé êóðºðñüêîþ ïîøòîþ íà àäðåñó Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps19"><FONT class="fs254">Óõâàëîþ Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó â³ä 01.03.2017 ó çâÿçêó ³ç íåÿâêîþ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â ñòîð³í òà çà ïèñüìîâèì êëîïîòàííÿì â³äïîâ³äà÷à ðîçãëÿä ñïðàâè â³äêëàäåíî íà 16.03.2017. Çîáîâÿçàíî ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé âèêîíàòè âèìîãè óõâàëè ñóäó â³ä 16.01.2017 ùîäî íàäàííÿ îðèã³íàëó ïëàò³æíîãî äîðó÷åííÿ ¹159 â³ä 29.12.2016. &nbsp;Çàïðîïîíîâàíî ó÷àñíèêàì ïðîöåñó íå ï³çí³øå, í³æ çà òðè äí³ äî ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ íàäàòè ñóäó: â³äïîâ³äà÷ó  â³äçèâ íà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó, ïîçèâà÷ó - ìîòèâîâàí³ ïîÿñíåííÿ ùîäî ïðàâîâî¿ ïîçèö³¿ â äàí³é ñïðàâ³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps19"><FONT class="fs252">Ñòîðîíè, ïîâ³äîìëåí³ íàëåæíèì ÷èíîì ïðî ÷àñ òà ì³ñöå ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ 16.03.2017, íå íàïðàâèëè ñâî¿õ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â äëÿ ó÷àñò³ ó âêàçàíîìó çàñ³äàíí³ òà íå ïîâ³äîìèëè ñóä ïðî ïðè÷èíè ¿õ íåÿâêè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs251">Çâàæàþ÷è íà òå, ùî â õîä³ àïåëÿö³éíîãî ðîçãëÿäó äàíî¿ ñïðàâè Õàðê³âñüêèì àïåëÿö³éíèì ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì, ó â³äïîâ³äíîñò³ äî ÷.3 ñò.4-3 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè, áóëî ñòâîðåíî ñòîðîíàì íåîáõ³äí³ óìîâè äëÿ âñòàíîâëåííÿ ôàêòè÷íèõ îáñòàâèí ñïðàâè ³ ïðàâèëüíîãî çàñòîñóâàííÿ çàêîíîäàâñòâà  çîêðåìà, â ìåæàõ ñòðîê³â, âñòàíîâëåíèõ ÷. 1 ñò.102 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè áóëî íàäàíî äîñòàòíüî ÷àñó òà ñòâîðåíî â³äïîâ³äí³ ìîæëèâîñò³ äëÿ ðåàë³çàö³¿ êîæíèì ó÷àñíèêîì ñâî¿õ ïðîöåñóàëüíèõ ïðàâ, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ ñò. 22 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ââàæàº çà ìîæëèâå çàê³í÷èòè ðîçãëÿä àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè â äàíîìó ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps18"><FONT class="fs250">Äîñë³äèâøè ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè, ïðîàíàë³çóâàâøè äîâîäè àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè òà çàïåðå÷åíü íà íå¿, ïåðåâ³ðèâøè ïðàâèëüí³ñòü çàñòîñóâàííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà, à òàêîæ ïîâíîòó âñòàíîâëåííÿ îáñòàâèí ñïðàâè òà â³äïîâ³äí³ñòü ¿õ íàäàíèì äîêàçàì, òà ïîâòîðíî ðîçãëÿíóâøè ñïðàâó â ïîðÿäêó ñò. 101 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè íà ï³äñòàâ³ íàÿâíèõ ó ñïðàâ³ äîêàç³â, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó âñòàíîâèëà íàñòóïíå.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs353">02.09.2013 ì³æ </FONT><FONT class="fs249">ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé</FONT><FONT class="fs352"> (ïîñòà÷àëüíèê) òà ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs248">ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð</FONT><FONT class="fs351"> (ïîêóïåöü) &nbsp;áóëî óêëàäåíî äîãîâ³ð ïîñòàâêè ¹ 02/09/13-ÍÀ (äàë³ â òåêñò³ - äîãîâ³ð), çà óìîâàìè ÿêîãî ïîñòà÷àëüíèê çîáîâ'ÿçóºòüñÿ ïåðåäàòè ïîêóïöåâ³ òîâàð, à ñàìå, àñôàëüòîáåòîí (à.ñ.15).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs350">Ó â³äïîâ³äíîñò³ äî ï. 3.1. äîãîâîðó ö³íà çà îäèíèöþ òîâàðó, ùî ïîñòàâëÿºòüñÿ çà öèì äîãîâîðîì, ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ñòîðîíàìè çàëåæíî â³ä óìîâ ïîñòàâêè ³ âêàçóºòüñÿ ó ñïåöèô³êàö³ÿõ. Çàãàëüíà ö³íà äîãîâîðó ñòàíîâèòü 1741500,00 ãðí. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs349">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ïóíêòó 2.1. äîãîâîðó, ïîñòàâêà ïðîäóêö³¿ çä³éñíþºòüñÿ ó ïîãîäæåí³ ñòîðîíàìè ñòðîêè òà ê³ëüêîñò³. Òîâàð ìîæå ïîñòàâëÿòèñÿ îêðåìèìè ïàðò³ÿìè, îá 'ºì ÿêèõ ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ñòîðîíàìè. Ìàðêà òîâàðó, éîãî ê³ëüê³ñòü, ÿê³ñòü, óìîâè ïîñòà÷àííÿ, âàðò³ñòü ïàðò³¿ òîâàðó âêàçóþòüñÿ íà êîæíó îêðåìó ïàðò³þ îêðåìî â ñïåöèô³êàö³ÿõ, ï³äïèñàíèõ ñòîðîíàìè, ÿê³ ñêëàäàþòü íåâ³ä'ºìíó ÷àñòèíó öüîãî äîãîâîðó (ï.2.2 äîãîâîðó).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs348">Çã³äíî ç ïóíêòîì 3.2. äîãîâîðó, ïîêóïåöü ïåðåðàõîâóº ïîñòà÷àëüíèêó ïîïåðåäíþ îïëàòó â ðîçì³ð³ 100% â³ä âàðòîñò³ ïàðò³¿ òîâàðó, ùî ïîñòàâëÿºòüñÿ.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs347">Òàêèì ÷èíîì, ñòîðîíàìè äîãîâîðó óçãîäæåíî, ùî ïîñòàâêà ïåðåäáà÷àº ¿¿ çä³éñíåííÿ ð³çíèìè îêðåìèìè ïàðò³ÿìè, ðîçì³ðè, ÿê³ñòü, ê³ëüê³ñòü òîâàðó çà êîæíîþ îêðåìîþ ïàðò³ºþ óçãîäæóºòüñÿ ñòîðîíàìè äîäàòêîâî. Îáîâ'ÿçîê ïîñòàâèòè ïðîäóêö³þ ó ïîçèâà÷à âèíèêàº ëèøå ï³ñëÿ îòðèìàííÿ 100% ïåðåäïëàòè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs247">ßê âáà÷àºòüñÿ ç ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè òà ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ îáîìà ñòîðîíàìè, 25.09.2013, íà âèêîíàííÿ óìîâ äîãîâîðó, </FONT><FONT class="fs346">ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs246">ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð</FONT><FONT class="fs345"> </FONT><FONT class="fs245">ñïëàòèëî ÒÎÂ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé 1200000,00 ãðí. â ÿêîñò³ ïåðåäîïëàòè çà äîãîâîðîì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps12"><FONT class="fs244">Ó ïåð³îä ç 31.10.2013 ïî 23.05.2014 ïîçèâà÷åì ïîñòàâëåíî, à â³äïîâ³äà÷åì ïðèéíÿòî òîâàð - àñôàëüòîáåòîí ãðóáîçåðíèñòèé ù³ëüíèé òèï À ìàðêà 1 ó ê³ëüêîñò³ 534 ò íà çàãàëüíó ñóìó 667501,20 ãðí., ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ êîï³ÿìè âèäàòêîâèõ íàêëàäíèõ, ÿê³ äîëó÷åíî äî ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè (à.ñ. 31  40).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs243">17.03.2015 </FONT><FONT class="fs344">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs242"> íàïðàâëåíî </FONT><FONT class="fs343">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs241"> âèìîãó ïðî ïåðåäàííÿ òîâàðó íà ñóìó 511248,81 ãðí., ïðîòå çàëèøîê îïëà÷åíîãî òîâàðó ïîêóïåöü íå îòðèìàâ.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs338">Ó ñâîþ ÷åðãó, ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs236"> ñòâåðäæóº, ùî ç ìåòîþ íåäîïóùåííÿ ïîðóøåííÿ âçÿòèõ íà ñåáå çîáîâÿçàíü çà äîãîâîðîì, òà çàáåçïå÷åííÿ ìîæëèâîñò³ ïåðåäàííÿ òîâàðó, 03.03.2015 ðîêó íèì áóëî îðãàí³çîâàíî âè¿çä ñïåö³àë³ñò³â ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs337">"</FONT><FONT class="fs235">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs336">"</FONT><FONT class="fs234"> çà àäðåñîþ, âèçíà÷åíîþ ó Äîãîâîð³, à ñàìå: ì. Äîíåöüê, ïðîñïåêò Êè¿âñüêèé, 95à, ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ òîâàðíî-òðàíñïîðòíîþ íàêëàäíîþ (à.ñ. 42), îäíàê ïðåäñòàâíèê³â â³äïîâ³äà÷à íà ì³ñö³ íå áóëî, ïðî ùî áóëî ñêëàäåíî àêò â³ä 03.03.2015 (à.ñ.43).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs233">06.04.2015 </FONT><FONT class="fs335">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs232"> íàïðàâèëî íà àäðåñó ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs334">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs231"> ëèñò ç âèìîãîþ ïðî ïðèéíÿòòÿ òîâàðó, ùî çàëèøèâñÿ, à ñàìå: àñôàëüòîáåòîí äð³áíîçåðíèñòèé òèï À ê³ëüê³ñòþ 249 ò òà àñôàëüòîáåòîí òèï ÙÌÀ ê³ëüê³ñòþ 565 ò (à.ñ.44). Â³äïîâ³äíó âèìîãó íå áóëî çàäîâîëåíî </FONT><FONT class="fs333">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs230">. Çà òâåðäæåííÿì ïîçèâà÷à, äîãîâ³ð óêëàäàâñÿ ì³æ ñòîðîíàìè ç ìåòîþ çàáåçïå÷åííÿ â³äïîâ³äà÷à ìàòåð³àëàìè äëÿ ïðîâåäåííÿ ï³äðÿäíèõ ðîá³ò ç áóä³âíèöòâà àâòîñàëîíó ó ì.Äîíåöüêó, àëå ó çâÿçêó ç ïðîâåäåííÿì ÀÒÎ ó </FONT><FONT class="fs332">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs229"> â³äïàëà íåîáõ³äí³ñòü ó çàâåðøåíí³ òàêèõ ðîá³ò, à îòæå é ïîòðåáà â ìàòåð³àë³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs228">Çà òàêèõ îáñòàâèí, </FONT><FONT class="fs331">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs227"> ââàæàº, ùî ä³ÿìè </FONT><FONT class="fs330">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs226"> éîìó áóëî çàâäàíî çáèòê³â.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs225">Ïðåäìåòîì ïîçîâíèõ âèìîã </FONT><FONT class="fs329">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs224">, íà çàäîâîëåíí³ ÿêèõ äàíèé ó÷àñíèê ïðîöåñó íàïîëÿãàº â õîä³ àïåëÿö³éíîãî ïðîâàäæåííÿ, º ñòÿãíåííÿ ç â³äïîâ³äà÷à ñóìè çáèòê³â çà äîãîâîðîì ó ðîçì³ð³ 1074000,00 ãðí., ùî ñêëàäàºòüñÿ ç ñóì ôàêòè÷íèõ çáèòê³â (939913,20 ãðí.) òà óïóùåíî¿ âèãîäè (134086,80&nbsp; ãðí.) </FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs223">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ïîçîâíî¿ çàÿâè (à.ñ.8), ôàêòè÷í³ çáèòêè â ðîçì³ð³ 939913,20 ãðí. ðîçðàõîâàíî ïîçèâà÷åì ÿê ð³çíèöþ ì³æ ñóìîþ 1607413,20 ãðí., íà ÿêó </FONT><FONT class="fs328">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs222"> áóëî ïðèäáàíî ó ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs327">"</FONT><FONT class="fs221">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs326">"</FONT><FONT class="fs220"> òîâàð, ùî, çà òâåðäæåííÿì ïîçèâà÷à, ïðèçíà÷àâñÿ äëÿ ïîñòàâêè </FONT><FONT class="fs325">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs219"> çà äîãîâîðîì </FONT><FONT class="fs324">¹ 02/09/13-ÍÀ</FONT><FONT class="fs218"> â³ä 02.09.2013, òà ñóìîþ 667501,20 ãðí., íà ÿêó ôàêòè÷íî áóëî ïîñòàâëåíî â³äïîâ³äà÷åâ³ òîâàð çà äîãîâîðîì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs217">Óïóùåíó âèãîäó ïîçèâà÷åì âèçíà÷åíî ÿê ð³çíèöþ ì³æ çàãàëüíîþ ö³íîþ óêëàäåíîãî ç â³äïîâ³äà÷åì äîãîâîðó </FONT><FONT class="fs323">1741500,00 ãðí.</FONT><FONT class="fs216"> òà ñóìîþ 1607413,20 ãðí., íà ÿêó </FONT><FONT class="fs322">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs215"> áóëî ïðèäáàíî òîâàð ó ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs321">"</FONT><FONT class="fs214">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs320">"</FONT><FONT class="fs213">.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs212">Íàäàþ÷è ïðàâîâó îö³íêó âèùåâêàçàíèì âèìîãàì, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â çàçíà÷àº íàñòóïíå.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps0"><FONT class="fs319">×àñòèíîþ 2 ñò.22 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè âñòàíîâëåíî, ùî çáèòêàìè º: </FONT><FONT class="fs211">1) âòðàòè, ÿêèõ îñîáà çàçíàëà ó çâ'ÿçêó ç³ çíèùåííÿì àáî ïîøêîäæåííÿì ðå÷³, à òàêîæ âèòðàòè, ÿê³ îñîáà çðîáèëà àáî ìóñèòü çðîáèòè äëÿ â³äíîâëåííÿ ñâîãî ïîðóøåíîãî ïðàâà (ðåàëüí³ çáèòêè); 2) äîõîäè, ÿê³ îñîáà ìîãëà á ðåàëüíî îäåðæàòè çà çâè÷àéíèõ îáñòàâèí, ÿêáè ¿¿ ïðàâî íå áóëî ïîðóøåíå (óïóùåíà âèãîäà). </FONT></P>
<P class="ps0"><FONT class="fs210">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷.1 ñò.225 ÃÊ Óêðà¿íè, äî ñêëàäó çáèòê³â, ùî ï³äëÿãàþòü â³äøêîäóâàííþ îñîáîþ, ÿêà äîïóñòèëà ãîñïîäàðñüêå ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ, âêëþ÷àþòüñÿ: âàðò³ñòü âòðà÷åíîãî, ïîøêîäæåíîãî àáî çíèùåíîãî ìàéíà, âèçíà÷åíà â³äïîâ³äíî äî âèìîã çàêîíîäàâñòâà; äîäàòêîâ³ âèòðàòè (øòðàôí³ ñàíêö³¿, ñïëà÷åí³ ³íøèì ñóá'ºêòàì, âàðò³ñòü äîäàòêîâèõ ðîá³ò, äîäàòêîâî âèòðà÷åíèõ ìàòåð³àë³â òîùî), ïîíåñåí³ ñòîðîíîþ, ÿêà çàçíàëà çáèòê³â âíàñë³äîê ïîðóøåííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ äðóãîþ ñòîðîíîþ; íåîäåðæàíèé ïðèáóòîê (âòðà÷åíà âèãîäà), íà ÿêèé ñòîðîíà, ÿêà çàçíàëà çáèòê³â, ìàëà ïðàâî ðîçðàõîâóâàòè ó ðàç³ íàëåæíîãî âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ äðóãîþ ñòîðîíîþ; ìàòåð³àëüíà êîìïåíñàö³ÿ ìîðàëüíî¿ øêîäè ó âèïàäêàõ, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ çàêîíîì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps0"><FONT class="fs209">Ïîðÿäîê â³äøêîäóâàííÿ çáèòê³â ó ñôåð³ ãîñïîäàðþâàííÿ ïåðåäáà÷åíèé ñòàòòÿìè 224  229 ÃÊ Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps0"><FONT class="fs318">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ñèñòåìíîãî àíàë³çó íîðì ÷èííîãî öèâ³ëüíîãî òà ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà, äëÿ çàñòîñóâàííÿ òàêî¿ ì³ðè â³äïîâ³äàëüíîñò³ ÿê ñòÿãíåííÿ çáèòê³â </FONT><FONT class="fs208">íåîáõ³äíîþ º íàÿâí³ñòü óñ³õ åëåìåíò³â ñêëàäó öèâ³ëüíîãî ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ, à ñàìå: ïðîòèïðàâíî¿ ïîâåä³íêè, çáèòê³â, ïðè÷èííîãî çâÿçêó ì³æ ïðîòèïðàâíîþ ïîâåä³íêîþ áîðæíèêà òà çáèòêàìè, âèíè. Çà â³äñóòíîñò³ õî÷à á îäíîãî ³ç öèõ åëåìåíò³â öèâ³ëüíî-ïðàâîâà â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòü íå íàñòàº. Çàçíà÷åíå óçãîäæóºòüñÿ ç ïðàâîâîþ ïîçèö³ºþ Âåðõîâíîãî Ñóäó Óêðà¿íè, âèêëàäåíîþ ó ïîñòàíîâ³ â³ä 22.01.2013 ó ñïðàâ³ ¹3-72ãñ12. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs207">Ïðîòèïðàâíîþ º ïîâåä³íêà, ÿêà íå â³äïîâ³äàº âèìîãàì çàêîíó, òÿãíå çà ñîáîþ ïîðóøåííÿ (çìåíøåííÿ, îáìåæåííÿ) ìàéíîâèõ ïðàâ (áëàã) ³ çàêîííèõ ³íòåðåñ³â ³íøî¿ îñîáè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs206">Íà äîêàç òâåðäæåíü ïðî ïðîòèïðàâí³ñòü ä³é â³äïîâ³äà÷à ïîçèâà÷ ïîñèëàºòüñÿ íà òå, ùî 03.03.2015 ðîêó </FONT><FONT class="fs317">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs205"> áóëî îðãàí³çîâàíî âè¿çä ñïåö³àë³ñò³â ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs316">"</FONT><FONT class="fs204">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs315">"</FONT><FONT class="fs203"> çà àäðåñîþ, âèçíà÷åíîþ ó äîãîâîð³, à ñàìå: ì. Äîíåöüê, ïðîñïåêò Êè¿âñüêèé, 95à, ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ òîâàðíî-òðàíñïîðòíîþ íàêëàäíîþ (à.ñ. 42), îäíàê ïðåäñòàâíèê³â â³äïîâ³äà÷à íà ì³ñö³ íå áóëî, ïðî ùî áóëî ñêëàäåíî àêò â³ä 03.03.2015 (à.ñ.43), òîáòî, íà äóìêó ïîçèâà÷à, â³äïîâ³äà÷ â îäíîñòîðîííüîìó ïîðÿäêó â³äìîâèâñÿ â³ä âèêîíàííÿ ñâîãî çîáîâÿçàííÿ ùîäî ïðèéíÿòòÿ òîâàðó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs202">Äîñë³äèâøè íàäàí³ ïîçèâà÷åì äîêàçè, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â çàçíà÷àº, ùî òîâàðíî-òðàíñïîðòíà íàêëàäíà â³ä 03.03.2015 íå â³äïîâ³äàº âèìîãàì Íàêàçó Ì³í³ñòåðñòâà ³íôðàñòðóêòóðè Óêðà¿íè â³ä 05.12.2013 ¹ 983 "Ïðî çàòâåðäæåííÿ Çì³í äî Ïðàâèë ïåðåâåçåíü âàíòàæ³â àâòîìîá³ëüíèì òðàíñïîðòîì â Óêðà¿í³", ùîäî çàïîâíåííÿ ôîðìè ¹ 1-ÒÍ  à ñàìå, äàíà íàêëàäíà íå ì³ñòèòü òàêèõ îáîâÿçêîâèõ ðåêâ³çèò³â ÿê íîìåð, âèä ïåðåâåçåíü, ïåðåë³ê ñóïðîâ³äíèõ äîêóìåíò³â íà âàíòàæ òîùî. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs195">Îêð³ì òîãî, ÿê çàçíà÷åíî ñàìèì ïîçèâà÷åì, çà íàêëàäíîþ â³ä 03.03.2015 áóëî äîñòàâëåíî â³äïîâ³äà÷åâ³ ëèøå àñôàëüòîáåòîí äð³áíîçåðíèñòèé òèï À ó ê³ëüêîñò³ 35 ò, òîä³ ÿê çàãàëüíèé çàëèøîê íåïîñòàâëåíîãî òîâàðó ñòàíîâèâ 249 ò àñôàëüòîáåòîíó äð³áíîçåðíèñòîãî òèï À òà 565 ò àñôàëüòîáåòîíó òèï ÙÌÀ.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs194">Çà òàêèõ îáñòàâèí, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ä³éøëà âèñíîâêó ïðî òå, ùî ïîçèâà÷åì íå äîâåäåíî ôàêò ïðîòèïðàâíîñò³ ïîâåä³íêè â³äïîâ³äà÷à. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs193">ßê áóëî âñòàíîâëåíî âèùå, ïðè çä³éñíåíí³ ðîçðàõóíêó ñóìè çáèòê³â ïîçèâà÷ ïîñèëàâñÿ íà ïðèäáàííÿ íèì òîâàðó ó ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs309">"</FONT><FONT class="fs192">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs308">"</FONT><FONT class="fs191"> äëÿ ïîñòàâêè â³äïîâ³äà÷åâ³.</FONT><FONT class="fs307"> </FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs190">²ç íàäàíèõ ïîçèâà÷åì äî ñóäó ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ êîï³é âèäàòêîâèõ íàêëàäíèõ òà ðàõóíê³â-ôàêòóð (à.ñ. 19  30) ä³éñíî âáà÷àºòüñÿ, ùî ³ç 31.10.2013 ïî 07.12.2013 </FONT><FONT class="fs306">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs189"> áóëî ïðèäáàíî ó ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs305">"</FONT><FONT class="fs188">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs304">"</FONT><FONT class="fs187"> òîâàð (àñôàëüòîáåòîí ãðóáîçåðíèñòèé ù³ëüíèé òèï À ìàðêà 1  783&nbsp; ò, ÙÌÀ-20  565 ò) çàãàëüíîþ ê³ëüê³ñòþ 1348,00 ò íà ñóìó 1607413,20 ãðí. Ïðîòå í³ âèùåçàçíà÷åíèìè äîêóìåíòàìè, í³ æîäíèìè ³íøèìè íàÿâíèìè ó ñïðàâ³ äîêàçàìè íå ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ, ùî äàíèé òîâàð áóëî ïðèäáàíî ñàìå äëÿ ïîñòàâêè </FONT><FONT class="fs303">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð"</FONT><FONT class="fs186"> çà äîãîâîðîì </FONT><FONT class="fs302">¹ 02/09/13-ÍÀ</FONT><FONT class="fs185"> â³ä 02.09.2013. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs184">Óìîâè äîãîâîðó òàêîæ íå ì³ñòÿòü ïîëîæåíü, ÿê³ á çîáîâÿçóâàëè ïîñòà÷àëüíèêà ïðèäáàòè äëÿ ïåðåäàííÿ ïîêóïöåâ³ îäðàçó âåñü òîâàð (îð³ºíòîâíó ê³ëüê³ñòü ÿêîãî ñòîðîíàìè ó ï.1.1 äîãîâîðó âèçíà÷åíî ÿê 1350,00 ò). Íàòîì³ñòü </FONT><FONT class="fs301">ñòîðîíàìè äîãîâîðó óçãîäæåíî, ùî ïîñòàâêà ïåðåäáà÷àº ¿¿ çä³éñíåííÿ ð³çíèìè îêðåìèìè ïàðò³ÿìè, ïðè öüîìó ðîçì³ðè, ÿê³ñòü, ê³ëüê³ñòü òîâàðó çà êîæíîþ îêðåìîþ ïàðò³ºþ óçãîäæóºòüñÿ ñòîðîíàìè äîäàòêîâî; îáîâ'ÿçîê ïîñòàâèòè ïðîäóêö³þ ó ïîçèâà÷à âèíèêàº ëèøå ï³ñëÿ îòðèìàííÿ 100% ïåðåäïëàòè. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs300">ßê âáà÷àºòüñÿ ç ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè, ï³ñëÿ çä³éñíåííÿ â³äïîâ³äà÷åì </FONT><FONT class="fs183">25.09.2013 </FONT><FONT class="fs299">ïåðåäîïëàòè</FONT><FONT class="fs182"> íà âèêîíàííÿ óìîâ äîãîâîðó ó ðîçì³ð³ 1200000,00 ãðí. </FONT><FONT class="fs298">òà ï³ñëÿ ÷àñòêîâîãî âèêîíàííÿ ïîçèâà÷åì çîáîâÿçàííÿ ùîäî ïîñòàâêè òîâàðó çà äàíîþ ïåðåäîïëàòîþ, ñòîðîíè íå óçãîäèëè äàòó íàñòóïíî¿ ïîñòàâêè, à òàêîæ ÿê³ñòü, òà ê³ëüê³ñòü ïðîäóêö³¿; ïîêóïöåì íå áóëî çä³éñíåíî ïåðåäïëàòó. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs297">Âñòàíîâèâøè âèùåâêàçàí³ îáñòàâèíè, ì³ñöåâèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä çàçíà÷èâ â îñêàðæóâàíîìó ð³øåíí³, ùî ï³ñëÿ âèêîíàííÿ â³äïîâ³äà÷åì éîãî çîáîâÿçàíü ñòîñîâíî îïëàòè ïåðøî¿ ïàðò³¿ òîâàðó ó ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð" íå âèíèêëî íîâèõ çîáîâ'ÿçàíü ïåðåä ïîçèâà÷åì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs296">Êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â çàçíà÷àº, ùî äîâîäè àïåëÿíòà ñòîñîâíî âèçíà÷åííÿ ñòîðîíàìè çàãàëüíî¿ ö³íè äîãîâîðó â ðîçì³ð³ 1741500,00 ãðí. íå ñïðîñòîâóþòü âèùåíàâåäåíîãî âèñíîâêó ñóäó ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿, îñê³ëüêè äîãîâ³ðí³ óìîâè ùîäî ñïîñîáó çä³éñíåííÿ ïîñòàâêè (îêðåìèìè ïàðò³ÿìè) º ñïåö³àëüíèìè ³ òàêèìè, ùî êîíêðåòèçóþòü íîðìó ïðî çàãàëüíó ê³ëüê³ñòü ³ âàðò³ñòü òîâàðó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs295">Çà òàêèõ îáñòàâèí, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ââàæàº íåäîâåäåíèìè òâåðäæåííÿ ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé" ïðî íàÿâí³ñòü ó ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð" áåççàïåðå÷íîãî îáîâÿçêó ïðèéíÿòè â ïîâíîìó îáñÿç³ òîâàð, ïðèäáàíèé ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé" ó </FONT><FONT class="fs181">ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs294">"</FONT><FONT class="fs180">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs293">". Â³äïîâ³äíî, ñóìà âàðòîñò³ âêàçàíîãî òîâàðó </FONT><FONT class="fs179">(1607413,20 ãðí.) íå ìîæå âèêîðèñòîâóâàòèñÿ ïðè ðîçðàõóíêó çáèòê³â, ùî, ÿê ââàæàº ïîçèâà÷, çàâäàíî éîìó ä³ÿìè â³äïîâ³äà÷à  îñê³ëüêè ïîçèâà÷åì </FONT><FONT class="fs292">íå äîâåäåíî íåîáõ³äíîãî çâÿçêó ì³æ âèòðàòàìè ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé" â ðîçì³ð³ </FONT><FONT class="fs178">1607413,20 ãðí. òà áóäü-ÿêèìè ä³ÿìè </FONT><FONT class="fs291">ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð" àáî ¿õ íàñë³äêàìè. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs290">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷.4 ñò.623 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè, </FONT><FONT class="fs177">ïðè âèçíà÷åíí³ íåîäåðæàíèõ äîõîä³â (óïóùåíî¿ âèãîäè) âðàõîâóþòüñÿ çàõîäè, âæèò³ êðåäèòîðîì ùîäî ¿õ îäåðæàííÿ. Àíàëîã³÷íà ïðàâîâà ïîçèö³ÿ âèêëàäåíà, çîêðåìà, â ïîñòàíîâ³ ÂÃÑÓ â³ä 18.11.2014 ó ñïðàâ³ ¹910/1887/14.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs289">Ó çâÿçêó ç öèì ñóä àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ âðàõîâóº, ùî </FONT><FONT class="fs176">ïîçèâà÷åì íå íàäàíî äîêàç³â âæèòòÿ </FONT><FONT class="fs288">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs175"> â ïåð³îä ç òðàâíÿ 2014 ðîêó (òîáòî &nbsp;ç ìîìåíòó çä³éñíåííÿ îñòàííüî¿ ïîñòàâêè òîâàðó çà äîãîâîðîì), äî áåðåçíÿ 2015 ðîêó áóäü-ÿêèõ çàõîä³â ñòîñîâíî ïåðåäàííÿ òîâàðó </FONT><FONT class="fs287">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs174">, à òàêîæ íå íàäàíî ïîÿñíåíü ñóäó ïåðøî¿ òà àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ ùîäî ïðè÷èí íåâæèòòÿ òàêèõ çàõîä³â.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs286">Îêð³ì òîãî, </FONT><FONT class="fs173">ÿê âáà÷àºòüñÿ ç ëèñòà ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs285">"</FONT><FONT class="fs172">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs284">"</FONT><FONT class="fs171"> äî </FONT><FONT class="fs283">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs170"> â³ä 20.07.2015 (à.ñ. 41), 249 ò àñôàëüòîáåòîíó òèï À (ìàðêà 1) òà 565 ò àñôàëüòîáåòîíó òèï ÙÌÀ çíàõîäÿòüñÿ íà çáåð³ãàíí³ ó ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs282">"</FONT><FONT class="fs169">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs281">"</FONT><FONT class="fs168">  òîáòî â³äïîâ³äíå ìàéíî íå º âòðà÷åíèì, ïîøêîäæåíèì àáî çíèùåíèì. Îäíàê </FONT><FONT class="fs280">ïîçèâà÷åì íå äîâåäåíî íåìîæëèâîñò³ ðåàë³çàö³¿ ïðèäáàíîãî ó </FONT><FONT class="fs167">ÒÎÂ </FONT><FONT class="fs279">"</FONT><FONT class="fs166">Äîíñïåöïðîì</FONT><FONT class="fs278">" òîâàðó ³íøèì ïîêóïöÿì (ï³ñëÿ òîãî, ÿê â³ä ÒÎÂ "ÑÊ Àëüòà³ð" íå íàä³éøëî íîâèõ çàìîâëåíü òà ïåðåäîïëàò çà íàñòóïí³ ïàðò³¿ òîâàðó). </FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs277">Òîáòî ôàêòè÷íî ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé" íå íàäàíî äîêàç³â âæèòòÿ íèì çàõîä³â â ïîðÿäêó âèùåíàâåäåíèõ ïðèïèñ³â ÷.4 ñò.623 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs165">Òîìó, çâàæàþ÷è íà òå, ùî âñóïåðå÷ ïðèïèñàì ñò.33 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè, </FONT><FONT class="fs276">ÒÎÂ "ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé"</FONT><FONT class="fs164"> íå äîâåäåíî íàÿâíîñò³ òàêèõ åëåìåíò³â ñêëàäó öèâ³ëüíîãî ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ ÿê ïðîòèïðàâíà ïîâåä³íêà â³äïîâ³äà÷à, çáèòêè, ïðè÷èííèé çâÿçîê ì³æ ïðîòèïðàâíîþ ïîâåä³íêîþ òà çáèòêàìè  êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â çàçíà÷àº, ùî äîâîäè àïåëÿíòà íå ñïðîñòîâóþòü âèñíîâêó ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó ïðî â³äñóòí³ñòü ôàêòè÷íèõ ³ ïðàâîâèõ ï³äñòàâ äëÿ çàäîâîëåííÿ ïîçîâó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs163">Çà òàêèõ îáñòàâèí, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ä³éøëà âèñíîâêó ïðî òå, ùî îñêàðæóâàíå ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ ìàº áóòè çàëèøåíî áåç çì³í, à àïåëÿö³éíà ñêàðãà  áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps17"><FONT class="fs162">Êåðóþ÷èñü ñòàòòÿìè 99, 101, ïóíêòîì 1 ñòàòò³ 103, ñòàòòåþ 105 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ñóäîâà êîëåã³ÿ Õàðê³âñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó, -</FONT></P>
<P class="ps13"><FONT class="fs148">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÈËÀ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps14"><FONT class="fs161">Àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ ßëòà ãðàä ñòðîé çàëèøèòè áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps2"><FONT class="fs160">Ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Õàðê³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 21.12.2016 ó ñïðàâ³</FONT><FONT class="fs147"> </FONT><FONT class="fs159">¹922/3669/16 &nbsp;çàëèøèòè áåç çì³í.</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs158">Ïîâíèé òåêñò ïîñòàíîâè ñêëàäåíî &nbsp;&nbsp;21.03.17 </FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs146">Ãîëîâóþ÷èé ñóääÿ </FONT><FONT class="fs130">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs145">&nbsp;&nbsp;Øåâåëü Î. Â.</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs144">Ñóääÿ </FONT><FONT class="fs129">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs143">&nbsp;&nbsp;Êðåñòüÿí³íîâ Î.Î.</FONT><FONT class="fs128"> &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs142">Ñóääÿ</FONT><FONT class="fs127"> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs141">&nbsp;&nbsp;Ôîì³íà Â. Î.</FONT><FONT class="fs126"> &nbsp; </FONT></P>