<TITLE>902/287/14</TITLE>
<!-- BEGIN METADATA -->
<!-- Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ôàéëà ç ð³øåííÿì -->
<META NAME="FILENAME" CONTENT="5040_434389.html">
<!-- 1,2 ID ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCID, DOCORGID) - íóæíî äëÿ ïîëó÷åíèÿ ïîäòâåðæäåíèÿ ðååñòðàöèè -->
<META NAME="DOCID" CONTENT="434389">
<META NAME="DOCORGID" CONTENT="202">
<!-- [3] Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(COURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="COURTNAME" CONTENT="Ðiâíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä">
<!-- [4] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5040">
<!-- [4.1] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="976">
<!-- [5] Ñïðàâà íîìåð TAGNAME(CAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="CAUSENUM" CONTENT="902/287/14">
<!-- [6] Äàòà ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="CAUSEDATE" CONTENT="10.07.2015">
<!-- [7] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCDATE) -->
<META NAME="DOCDATE" CONTENT="08.09.2015">
<!-- [9] Ôîðìà ð³øåííÿ (ID) TAGNAME(DOCTYPE) -->
<!-- ð³øåííÿ = 2 -->
<!-- ïîñòàíîâà = 3 -->
<!-- óõâàëà ñóäó = 4 -->
<!-- ñóäîâèé íàêàç = 5 -->
<!-- îêðåìà óõâàëà = 6 -->
<META NAME="DOCTYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [10] Ôîðìà ñóäî÷èíñòâà (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSETYPE) -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíà = 1 -->
<!-- êðèì³íàëüíà = 2 -->
<!-- ãîñïîäàðñüêà = 3 -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíà = 4 -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíå ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ = 5 -->
<META NAME="CAUSETYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [11] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSECATEGORY) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECATEGORY" CONTENT="4069">
<!-- [12] Ñïðàâà ðîçãëÿäàºòüñÿ ïî ³íñòàíö³¿ (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSELOCATION) -->
<!-- àïåëÿö³éí³é = A -->
<!-- êàñàö³éí³é = C -->
<META NAME="CAUSELOCATION" CONTENT="A">
<!-- [13] Ïîïåðåäí³é íîìåð ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSENUM) -->
<!-- [14] Ïîïåðåäíÿ äàòà ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSEDATE) -->
<!-- [15] Íîìåð ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSENUM" CONTENT="902/287/14">
<!-- [16] Äàòà ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="13.03.2014">
<!-- [17] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ (ïîñòàíîâëåííÿ) ñóäîâîãî ð³øåííÿ, ùî ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVRESCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVRESCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="10.06.2015">
<!-- [18] Ñóä, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCOURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="PREVCOURTNAME" CONTENT="Ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³">
<!-- [19] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5003">
<!-- [19.1] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="902">
<!-- [20] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ïîïåðåäíüî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECATEGORY) -->
<!-- [21] Ñåêðåòàð ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ TAGNAME(SECRETARY) -->
<!-- [22] Çàáîðîíà îïðèëþäíåííÿ TAGNAME(HEARINGCLOSED) -->
<!-- íå çàáîðîíåíî = V -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî = Z -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî òèì÷àñîâî = T -->
<META NAME="HEARINGCLOSED" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [23] Ê³ëüê-òü àðêóø³â äîêóìåíòà (ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß) -->
<!-- Ñóää³ â ð³øåíí³: -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME1" CONTENT="Ãóëîâà À.Ã.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME2" CONTENT="Ìàö³ùóê À.Â.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME3" CONTENT="Ïåòóõîâ Ì.Ã.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- Ñòîðîíè ð³øåííÿ: -->
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE1" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE1" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME1" CONTENT="Òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ &quot;Îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ &quot;Øëÿõ&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT1" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO1" CONTENT="24045154">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL1" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE2" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE2" CONTENT="">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE2" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE2" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME2" CONTENT="Òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ &quot;Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT2" CONTENT="Â³äïîâ³äà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO2" CONTENT="20118399">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL2" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE3" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE3" CONTENT="Z">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE3" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE3" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME3" CONTENT="Òîâàðèñòâî ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ &quot;Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT3" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 2">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO3" CONTENT="20118399">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL3" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [38] Âåðñ³ÿ êë³ºíòà TAGNAME(APPVER) -->
<META NAME="APPVER" CONTENT="1.24.1.200">
<!-- [39] Êîä ïðîâàéäåðà ÅÖÏ TAGNAME(CRYPTPROVIDER) -->
<META NAME="CRYPTPROVIDER" CONTENT="DS13">
<!-- END METADATA -->
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Content-Type" CONTENT="text/html; charset=windows-1251">
<META NAME="Author" CONTENT="">
<META NAME="Description" CONTENT="Document">
<META NAME="Document-state" CONTENT="static">
<META NAME="Updated" CONTENT="11.09.2015 12:50:13">
<META NAME="Robots" CONTENT="All">
<META NAME="Keywords" CONTENT="">
<STYLE TYPE="text/css">
margin-right: 10 mm;
margin-bottom: 10 mm;
mso-paper-source: 0;
@charset "Windows-1251";
font-family: Times New Roman;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Times New Roman;
margin-bottom: 0 mm;
white-space: normal;
word-spacing: normal;
margin-bottom: 2 mm;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
<P class="ps20"><FONT class="fs237"> </FONT><FONT class="fs235"><IMG src="herb.gif" height=72 width=54></FONT></P>
<P class="ps13"><FONT class="fs102">Ð²ÂÍÅÍÑÜÊÈÉ ÀÏÅËßÖ²ÉÍÈÉ ÃÎÑÏÎÄÀÐÑÜÊÈÉ ÑÓÄ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs101">²ÌÅÍÅÌ ÓÊÐÀ¯ÍÈ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs100">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÀ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps2"> "08" âåðåñíÿ 2015 ð.<FONT class="fs125"> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</FONT>Ñïðàâà ¹902/287/14<FONT class="fs124"> &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps12"><FONT class="fs123">Ð³âíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ó ñêëàä³ êîëåã³¿:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps12"><FONT class="fs122">Ãîëîâóþ÷èé ñóääÿ</FONT> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<FONT class="fs104">&nbsp;</FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ãóëîâà À.Ã.</P>
<P class="ps12"> <FONT class="fs121">ñóääÿ &nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs231">&nbsp;</FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ìàö³ùóê À.Â. , <BR>
&nbsp;<FONT class="fs120">ñóääÿ &nbsp;</FONT><FONT class="fs230">&nbsp;</FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ïåòóõîâ Ì.Ã. &nbsp;&nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps3">ïðè ñåêðåòàð³ ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ Êðàâ÷óê Î.Â.</P>
<P class="ps3"><FONT class="fs108">çà ó÷àñòþ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â ñòîð³í:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps1">â³ä ïîçèâà÷à:Êðàâöîâî¿ Þ.Ì. - ïðåäñòàâíèêà çà äîâ³ðåí³ñòþ â³ä 06.04.2015ð. ¹20/15;</P>
<P class="ps1">Áàáåëþêà Â.À. - ïðåäñòàâíèêà çà äîâ³ðåí³ñòþ â³ä 10.08.2015ð. ¹28/10;</P>
<P class="ps1">Ñòåïàíþêà À.Â. - ïðåäñòàâíèêà çà äîâ³ðåí³ñòþ â³ä 02.07.2015ð. ¹20/15</P>
<P class="ps1">â³ä â³äïîâ³äà÷à: íå ç`ÿâèâñÿ</P>
<P class="ps1">ðîçãëÿíóâøè ó â³äêðèòîìó ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ ó ïðèì³ùåíí³ Ð³âíåíñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà" </P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs119">íà ð³øåííÿ</FONT> ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 10.06.2015ð. </P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs118">ó ñïðàâ³</FONT> ¹902/287/14 (ãîëîâóþ÷èé ñóääÿ Ò³ñåöüêèé Ñ.Ñ., ñóää³ Áàðàíîâ Ì.Ì., Ìàòâ³é÷óê Â.Â.)</P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs117">çà ïîçîâîì</FONT> Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ "Øëÿõ", ì.Ïîïàñíà Ëóãàíñüêî¿ îáëàñò³</P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs116">äî</FONT> Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà", ì.Â³ííèöÿ</P>
<P class="ps1"><FONT class="fs115">ïðî</FONT> ñòÿãíåííÿ 339741,00ãðí.</P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs114">ÂÑÒÀÍÎÂÈÂ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10">Ð³øåííÿì ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 10.06.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹902/287/14 çàäîâîëåíî ïîçîâ Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ "Øëÿõ" äî Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà" ïðî ñòÿãíåííÿ 339741,00ãðí. Ñòÿãíóòî ç â³äïîâ³äà÷à íà êîðèñòü ïîçèâà÷à 339 741,00ãðí.  ïîïåðåäíüî¿ îïëàòè, 6794,82ãðí.  â³äøêîäóâàííÿ âèòðàò ïîâÿçàíèõ ç³ ñïëàòîþ ñóäîâîãî çáîðó òà 15 800,00ãðí.  â³äøêîäóâàííÿ âèòðàò íà îïëàòó ïîñëóã àäâîêàòà.</P>
<P class="ps10">Íå ïîãîäæóþ÷èñü ç ïðèéíÿòèì ð³øåííÿì, â³äïîâ³äà÷ çâåðíóâñÿ äî ñóäó ç àïåëÿö³éíîþ ñêàðãîþ, â ÿê³é ïðîñèòü îñêàðæåíå ð³øåííÿ ñêàñóâàòè òà ïðèéíÿòè íîâå ð³øåííÿ - ïðî â³äìîâó ó çàäîâîëåíí³ ïîçîâó.</P>
<P class="ps10">Ìîòèâóþ÷è àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó, â³äïîâ³äà÷ çàçíà÷àº, çîêðåìà, íàñòóïíå:</P>
<P class="ps10">- ôàêò â³äâàíòàæåííÿ òîâàðó â³äïîâ³äà÷åì ïîçèâà÷ó ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ ð³øåííÿì Â³ííèöüêîãî ì³ñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³, äå âñòàíîâëåíî ôàêò â³äâàíòàæåííÿ òîâàðó íà ï³äñòàâ³ ïîêàç³â ñâ³äê³â Âàòàõà Î.Ì. òà Ãàâðèëþêà ª.Â., ùî íå áóëî âçÿòî äî óâàãè ì³ñöåâèì ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì ïðè ïðèéíÿòò³ îñêàðæåíîãî ð³øåííÿ;</P>
<P class="ps10">- íàÿâíèìè ó ìàòåð³àëàõ ñïðàâè äîãîâîðàìè ïåðåâåçåííÿ òà ï³äïèñàíèìè âîä³ÿìè ÒÒÍ ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ ôàêò ïåðåäà÷³ òîâàðó ïåðåâ³çíèêó äëÿ äîñòàâêè éîãî ïîçèâà÷ó;</P>
<P class="ps10">- âèñíîâîê åêñïåðòà Â³ííèöüêîãî â³ää³ëåííÿ Êè¿âñüêîãî íàóêîâî-äîñë³äíîãî ³íñòèòóòó ñóäîâèõ åêñïåðòèç ¹123/124/15-21 â³ä 30.01.2015ð., ÿêèì âñòàíîâëåíî, ùî ï³äïèñè íà îðèã³íàëàõ âèäàòêîâèõ íàêëàäíèõ òà ÒÒÍ âèêîíàí³ íå Çáîðîâñüêèì ²ãîðåì Ìèêîëàéîâè÷åì, à ³íøîþ îñîáîþ, à ï³äïèñè íà äîâ³ðåíîñòÿõ âèêîíàíí³ íå Êóçíåöîâèì Âîëîäèìèðîì Îëåêñàíäðîâè÷åì, à ³íøîþ îñîáîþ, íå â³äïîâ³äàº ä³éñíîñò³, îñê³ëüêè çà ñóêóïí³ñòþ äîêàç³â â³äïîâ³äà÷åì äîâåäåíî ôàêò â³äâàíòàæåííÿ òîâàðó ïîçèâà÷ó.</P>
<P class="ps10">Ïîçèâà÷ ó ïèñüìîâîìó â³äçèâ³ â³ä 25.08.2015ð. ¹14/8 íà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó òà éîãî ïðåäñòàâíèêè ó ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ çàïåðå÷èëè ïðîòè äîâîä³â òà âèìîã ñêàðãè, ïðîñÿòü çàëèøèòè îñêàðæåíå ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 10.06.2015ð. ó äàí³é ñïðàâ³ áåç çì³í, à àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó - áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps10">Â³äïîâ³äà÷ ïîâíîâàæíîãî ïðåäñòàâíèêà ó ñóäîâå çàñ³äàííÿ íå íàïðàâèâ, ïðî ïðè÷èíè íåÿâêè ñóä íå ïîâ³äîìèâ.</P>
<P class="ps10">Âðàõîâóþ÷è íîðìè&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;ñò.101 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;ïðî ìåæ³ ïåðåãëÿäó ñïðàâ â àïåëÿö³éí³é ³íñòàíö³¿ òà òîé ôàêò, ùî íåÿâêà â çàñ³äàííÿ ñóäó ïðåäñòàâíèêà â³äïîâ³äà÷à, íàëåæíèì ÷èíîì òà â³äïîâ³äíî äî çàêîíîäàâñòâà ïîâ³äîìëåíîãî ïðî äàòó, ÷àñ òà ì³ñöå ðîçãëÿäó ñïðàâè, íå ïåðåøêîäæàº ïåðåãëÿäó îñêàðæåíîãî ñóäîâîãî ð³øåííÿ, ñóäîâà êîëåã³ÿ ðîçãëÿíóëà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó çà â³äñóòíîñò³ ïðåäñòàâíèêà îñòàííüîãî.</P>
<P class="ps10">          Çàñëóõàâøè ïîÿñíåííÿ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â ïîçèâà÷à, îáãîâîðèâøè äîâîäè àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè, äîñë³äèâøè ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè, ïåðåâ³ðèâøè ïîâíîòó ç'ÿñóâàííÿ òà äîâåäåí³ñòü âñ³õ îáñòàâèí, ùî ìàþòü çíà÷åííÿ äëÿ ñïðàâè, â³äïîâ³äí³ñòü âèñíîâê³â, âèêëàäåíèõ ó ð³øåíí³ ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó, îáñòàâèíàì ñïðàâè, ïðàâèëüí³ñòü çàñòîñóâàííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà ïðè ïðèéíÿò³ îñêàðæåíîãî ð³øåííÿ, ñóäîâà êîëåã³ÿ ââàæàº, ùî àïåëÿö³éíà ñêàðãà íå ï³äëÿãàº çàäîâîëåííþ, âèõîäÿ÷è ç íàñòóïíîãî.</P>
<P class="ps14">ßê óáà÷àºòüñÿ ç ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè, ÒÎÂ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà" âèñòàâëåíî ÒÎÂ Îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ "Øëÿõ" ðàõóíêè íà îïëàòó òîâàðó íà çàãàëüíó ñóìó 356 913,00 ãðí., à ñàìå : </P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000058 â³ä 15.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 34 344,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000063 â³ä 22.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 35 640,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000067 â³ä 28.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 35 640,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000077 â³ä 16.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 32 400,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000083 â³ä 18.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 29 430,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000093 â³ä 24.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 29 484,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000131 â³ä 25.07.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 21 600,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000148 â³ä 15.09.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 34 101,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000153 â³ä 26.09.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 35 100,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000160 â³ä 17.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 35 289,00 ãðí.;</P>
<P class="ps14">- 00000164 â³ä 24.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 33 885,00 ãðí..</P>
<P class="ps14">Â çàçíà÷åíèõ ðàõóíêàõ âêàçàí³ íàñòóïí³ â³äîìîñò³: ïîñòà÷àëüíèê - ÒÎÂ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà"; ïîêóïåöü - ÒÎÂ Îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ "Øëÿõ"; ÒÌÖ - áî÷êà êîíóñíà (àðò).</P>
<P class="ps14">Ó ïîäàëüøîìó, íà ï³äñòàâ³ âêàçàíèõ ðàõóíê³â, ïîçèâà÷åì áóëî ñïëà÷åíî â³äïîâ³äà÷ó êîøòè â çàãàëüí³é ñóì³ 339 741,00 ãðí., ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ íàñòóïíèìè êâèòàíö³ÿìè: </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6277132 â³ä 28.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 10 000,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 5901.355.1 â³ä 21.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 1 344,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 1071ç21 â³ä 03.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 270,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6045.392.1 â³ä 25.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 29 484,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6045.167.1 â³ä 16.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 17 158,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6490.454.1 â³ä 19.09.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 32 400,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 5603.511.3 â³ä 19.09.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 1 701,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6045.244.12 â³ä 18.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 29 430,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 5603.779.4 â³ä 25.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 25 289,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 5603.811.1 â³ä 26.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 33 885,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6045.397.9 â³ä 27.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 25 640,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 100.35.4 â³ä 29.07.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 21 600,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 249.1.4 â³ä 03.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 29 700,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6045.426.1 â³ä 28.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 21 600,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6242542 â³ä 21.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 1 360,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6263490 â³ä 27.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 10 000,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14">- ¹ 6241980 â³ä 21.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 8 640,00 ãðí., </P>
<P class="ps14">òà ïëàò³æíèìè äîðó÷åííÿìè: ¹ 97 â³ä 20.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 5 000,00 ãðí.; ¹ 95 â³ä 15.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 18 000,00 ãðí.; ¹ 99 â³ä 28.04.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 4 000,00 ãðí.; ¹ 104 â³ä 16.05.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 3 200,00 ãðí.; ¹ 188 â³ä 25.10.2011 ðîêó íà ñóìó 10 000,00 ãðí.; </P>
<P class="ps14"> Ó âêàçàíèõ êâèòàíö³ÿõ çàçíà÷åíî ïðèçíà÷åííÿ ïëàòåæó : ñïëàòà çà òîâàð çã³äíî ðàõóíê³â ÷/ç Çáîðîâñüêîãî ².Ì.</P>
<P class="ps14">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷.1 ñò.181 ÃÊ Óêðà¿íè ãîñïîäàðñüêèé äîãîâ³ð çà çàãàëüíèì ïðàâèëîì âèêëàäàºòüñÿ ó ôîðì³ ºäèíîãî äîêóìåíòà, ï³äïèñàíîãî ñòîðîíàìè. Äîïóñêàºòüñÿ óêëàäåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèõ äîãîâîð³â ó ñïðîùåíèé ñïîñ³á, òîáòî øëÿõîì îáì³íó ëèñòàìè, ôàêñîãðàìàìè, òåëåãðàìàìè, òåëåôîíîãðàìàìè òîùî, à òàêîæ øëÿõîì ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ïðèéíÿòòÿ äî âèêîíàííÿ çàìîâëåíü, ÿêùî çàêîíîì íå âñòàíîâëåíî ñïåö³àëüí³ âèìîãè äî ôîðìè òà ïîðÿäêó óêëàäåííÿ äàíîãî âèäó äîãîâîð³â. </P>
<P class="ps14">Àíàë³çóþ÷è âêàçàí³ äîêàçè, ñóäîâà êîëåã³ÿ ä³éøëà âèñíîâêó, ùî ì³æ ñòîðîíàìè âèíèêëè ïðàâîâ³äíîñèíè êóï³âë³-ïðîäàæó.</P>
<P class="ps14">25.12.2013 ðîêó ïîçèâà÷, ïîñèëàþ÷èñü íà ÷.2 ñò.530 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè, íàä³ñëàâ íà àäðåñó â³äïîâ³äà÷à ïèñüìîâó âèìîãó ¹25/9, äå âêàçàâ, ùî ÒÎÂ Îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ "Øëÿõ" ïåðåðàõîâàíî ÒÎÂ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà" êîøòè ó ñóì³ 339 741,00ãðí. ï³ä ïîñòàâêó áî÷êè êîíóñíî¿, îäíàê äàíèé òîâàð íå ïîñòàâëåíî òà ïèñüìîâèé äîãîâ³ð íå óêëàäåíî, à òîìó ïðîñèòü ïîñòàâèòè âêàçàíèé òîâàð àáî ïåðåðàõóâàòè çàçíà÷åíó ñóìó çàáîðãîâàíîñò³.</P>
<P class="ps9">Îäíàê, âêàçàíà âèìîãà çàëèøåíà â³äïîâ³äà÷åì áåç â³äïîâ³ä³ òà çàäîâîëåííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps10">Çà âêàçàíèõ îáñòàâèí, ÒçÎÂ îïòîâà êîìïàí³ÿ "Øëÿõ" ïîñèëàþ÷èñü, çîêðåìà, íà ñò.ñò.205, 509, 526, 610, 693 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè òà ÷.7 ñò.179, ñò.181, ÷.1 ñò.193 ÃÊ Óêðà¿íè, çâåðíóëîñÿ äî ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó ç ïîçîâîì ïðî ñòÿãíåííÿ ç ÒçÎÂ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà" 339741,00ãðí. ïîïåðåäíüî¿ îïëàòè.</P>
<P class="ps10">          ßê çàçíà÷àëîñÿ âèùå, ð³øåííÿì ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 10.06.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹902/287/14 ïîçîâ çàäîâîëåíî. </P>
<P class="ps9">          Êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â Ð³âíåíñüêîãî àïåëÿö³éíîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ç âèñíîâêîì ñóäó ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ ïðî çàäîâîëåííÿ ïîçîâó, âèõîäÿ÷è ç íàñòóïíîãî.</P>
<P class="ps9">Çã³äíî ç³ ñò.11 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè öèâ³ëüí³ ïðàâà òà îáîâ'ÿçêè &nbsp;âèíèêàþòü ³ç &nbsp;ä³é îñ³á, ùî ïåðåäáà÷åí³ àêòàìè öèâ³ëüíîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà, à òàêîæ ³ç ä³é îñ³á, ùî íå &nbsp;ïåðåäáà÷åí³ &nbsp;öèìè &nbsp;àêòàìè, àëå çà àíàëîã³ºþ ïîðîäæóþòü öèâ³ëüí³ ïðàâà òà îáîâ'ÿçêè. Ï³äñòàâàìè âèíèêíåííÿ öèâ³ëüíèõ ïðàâ òà îáîâ'ÿçê³â, çîêðåìà, º äîãîâîðè òà ³íø³ ïðàâî÷èíè, ³íø³ þðèäè÷í³ ôàêòè.</P>
<P class="ps15">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÷.1 ñò.509 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿì º ïðàâîâ³äíîøåííÿ, â ÿêîìó îäíà ñòîðîíà (áîðæíèê) çîáîâ'ÿçàíà â÷èíèòè íà êîðèñòü äðóãî¿ ñòîðîíè (êðåäèòîðà) ïåâíó ä³þ (ïåðåäàòè ìàéíî, âèêîíàòè ðîáîòó, íàäàòè ïîñëóãó, ñïëàòèòè ãðîø³ òîùî) àáî óòðèìàòèñÿ â³ä ïåâíî¿ ä³¿, à êðåäèòîð ìàº ïðàâî âèìàãàòè â³ä áîðæíèêà âèêîíàííÿ éîãî îáîâ'ÿçêó. </P>
<P class="ps15">×àñòèíîþ 1 ñò.173 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè âñòàíîâëåíî, ùî ãîñïîäàðñüêèì âèçíàºòüñÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, ùî âèíèêàº ì³æ ñóá'ºêòîì ãîñïîäàðþâàííÿ òà ³íøèì ó÷àñíèêîì (ó÷àñíèêàìè) â³äíîñèí ó ñôåð³ ãîñïîäàðþâàííÿ ç ï³äñòàâ, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ öèì Êîäåêñîì, â ñèëó ÿêîãî îäèí ñóá'ºêò (çîáîâ'ÿçàíà ñòîðîíà, ó òîìó ÷èñë³ áîðæíèê) çîáîâ'ÿçàíèé â÷èíèòè ïåâíó ä³þ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ÷è óïðàâë³íñüêî-ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî õàðàêòåðó íà êîðèñòü ³íøîãî ñóá'ºêòà (âèêîíàòè ðîáîòó, ïåðåäàòè ìàéíî, ñïëàòèòè ãðîø³, íàäàòè ³íôîðìàö³þ òîùî), àáî óòðèìàòèñÿ â³ä ïåâíèõ ä³é, à ³íøèé ñóá'ºêò (óïðàâíåíà ñòîðîíà, ó òîìó ÷èñë³ êðåäèòîð) ìàº ïðàâî âèìàãàòè â³ä çîáîâ'ÿçàíî¿ ñòîðîíè âèêîíàííÿ ¿¿ îáîâ'ÿçêó. </P>
<P class="ps15">Çã³äíî ç ÷.1, 2 ñò.193 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ñóá'ºêòè ãîñïîäàðþâàííÿ òà ³íø³ ó÷àñíèêè ãîñïîäàðñüêèõ â³äíîñèí ïîâèíí³ âèêîíóâàòè ãîñïîäàðñüê³ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ íàëåæíèì ÷èíîì â³äïîâ³äíî äî çàêîíó, ³íøèõ ïðàâîâèõ àêò³â, äîãîâîðó, à çà â³äñóòíîñò³ êîíêðåòíèõ âèìîã ùîäî âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ - â³äïîâ³äíî äî âèìîã, ùî ó ïåâíèõ óìîâàõ çâè÷àéíî ñòàâëÿòüñÿ. Äî âèêîíàííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèõ äîãîâîð³â çàñòîñîâóþòüñÿ â³äïîâ³äí³ ïîëîæåííÿ Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ç óðàõóâàííÿì îñîáëèâîñòåé, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ öèì Êîäåêñîì. Êîæíà ñòîðîíà ïîâèííà âæèòè óñ³õ çàõîä³â, íåîáõ³äíèõ äëÿ íàëåæíîãî âèêîíàííÿ íåþ çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ, âðàõîâóþ÷è ³íòåðåñè äðóãî¿ ñòîðîíè òà çàáåçïå÷åííÿ çàãàëüíîãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ³íòåðåñó. Ïîðóøåííÿ çîáîâ'ÿçàíü º ï³äñòàâîþ äëÿ çàñòîñóâàííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèõ ñàíêö³é, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ öèì Êîäåêñîì, ³íøèìè çàêîíàìè àáî äîãîâîðîì. </P>
<P class="ps15"> Íîðìàìè ñò.ñò. 525, 526 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè âñòàíîâëåíî, ùî îäíîñòîðîííÿ â³äìîâà â³ä çîáîâÿçàííÿ àáî îäíîñòîðîííÿ çàì³íà éîãî óìîâ íå äîïóñêàºòüñÿ, ÿêùî ³íøå íå âñòàíîâëåíî äîãîâîðîì àáî çàêîíîì. Çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ ìàº âèêîíóâàòèñÿ íàëåæíèì ÷èíîì â³äïîâ³äíî äî óìîâ äîãîâîðó òà âèìîã öüîãî Êîäåêñó, ³íøèõ àêò³â öèâ³ëüíîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà, à çà â³äñóòíîñò³ òàêèõ óìîâ òà âèìîã - â³äïîâ³äíî äî çâè÷à¿â ä³ëîâîãî îáîðîòó àáî ³íøèõ âèìîã, ùî çâè÷àéíî ñòàâëÿòüñÿ. </P>
<P class="ps9">Çã³äíî ç³ ñò.610 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ïîðóøåííÿì çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ º éîãî íåâèêîíàííÿ àáî âèêîíàííÿ ç ïîðóøåííÿì óìîâ, âèçíà÷åíèõ çì³ñòîì çîáîâ'ÿçàííÿ (íåíàëåæíå âèêîíàííÿ).</P>
<P class="ps15">Ó ìàòåð³ëàõ ñïðàâè íàÿâí³ ðàõóíêè - ôàêòóðè çà ïåð³îä ç 15.04.2011 ðîêó ïî 24.10.2011 ðîêó, íà ï³äñòàâ³ ÿêèõ ïîçèâà÷åì áóëî ñïëà÷åíî â³äïîâ³äà÷ó ãðîøîâ³ êîøòè ó ñóì³ 339 741,00 ãðí., ùî ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ âêàçàíèìè âèùå ïëàò³æíèìè äîðó÷åííÿìè òà êâèòàíö³ÿìè ç ïðèçíà÷åííÿì ïëàòåæó: ñïëàòà çà òîâàð çã³äíî ðàõóíê³â ÷/ç Çáîðîâñüêîãî ².Ì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ñë³ä çàçíà÷èòè, ùî îòðèìàííÿ âêàçàíèõ âèùå ãðîøîâèõ êîøò³â íå îñïîðþºòüñÿ ÒÎÂ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà", ùî çíàõîäèòü ñâîº ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ó â³äçèâ³ íà ïîçîâ á/í â³ä 08.04.2014 ðîêó.</P>
<P class="ps9">Ç³ çì³ñòó çàçíà÷åíèõ âèùå ðàõóíê³â òà ïëàò³æíèõ äîêóìåíò³â âáà÷àºòüñÿ, ùî ïîçèâà÷åì áóëà çä³éñíåíà ïåðåäîïëàòà íà ðàõóíîê â³äïîâ³äà÷à çà òîâàð - áî÷êè, ÿêèé âêàçàíèé ó ðàõóíêàõ. </P>
<P class="ps9">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ñò.693 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè ÿêùî äîãîâîðîì âñòàíîâëåíèé îáîâ'ÿçîê ïîêóïöÿ ÷àñòêîâî àáî ïîâí³ñòþ îïëàòèòè òîâàð äî éîãî ïåðåäàííÿ ïðîäàâöåì (ïîïåðåäíÿ îïëàòà), ïîêóïåöü ïîâèíåí çä³éñíèòè îïëàòó â ñòðîê, âñòàíîâëåíèé äîãîâîðîì êóï³âë³-ïðîäàæó, à ÿêùî òàêèé ñòðîê íå âñòàíîâëåíèé äîãîâîðîì, - ó ñòðîê, âèçíà÷åíèé â³äïîâ³äíî äî ñòàòò³ 530 öüîãî Êîäåêñó. Ó ðàç³ íåâèêîíàííÿ ïîêóïöåì îáîâ'ÿçêó ùîäî ïîïåðåäíüî¿ îïëàòè òîâàðó çàñòîñîâóþòüñÿ ïîëîæåííÿ ñòàòò³ 538 öüîãî Êîäåêñó. ßêùî ïðîäàâåöü, ÿêèé îäåðæàâ ñóìó ïîïåðåäíüî¿ îïëàòè òîâàðó, íå ïåðåäàâ òîâàð ó âñòàíîâëåíèé ñòðîê, ïîêóïåöü ìàº ïðàâî âèìàãàòè ïåðåäàííÿ îïëà÷åíîãî òîâàðó àáî ïîâåðíåííÿ ñóìè ïîïåðåäíüî¿ îïëàòè.</P>
<P class="ps9">Òàêèì ÷èíîì, îòðèìàâøè 10.01.2014ð. âèìîãó ïîçèâà÷à â³ä 25.12.2013ð. ¹25/9 ïðî âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâ`ÿçàííÿ ïî ïîñòàâö³ îïëà÷åíîãî òîâàðó, â³äïîâ³äà÷ â ñèëó ÷.2 ñò.530 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè çîáîâ`ÿçàíèé áóâ ïåðåäàòè òîâàð ïðîòÿãîì 7 äí³â â³ä äíÿ îòðèìàííÿ âèìîãè, òîáòî âèêîíàòè çîáîâ`ÿçàííÿ äî 18.01.2014ð., îäíàê âèìîãà ïîêóïöÿ íå âèêîíàíà. </P>
<P class="ps9">Òâåðäæåííÿ ñêàðæíèêà, âèêëàäåí³ â àïåëÿö³éí³é ñêàðç³ íà ðàõóíîê òîãî, ùî ïðàâîâ³äíîñèíè ì³æ ñòîðîíàìè ùîäî ïîñòàâêè òîâàðó â³äáóâàëèñÿ íà ï³äñòàâ³ äîãîâîðó êóï³âë³-ïðîäàæó ¹á/í â³ä 12.04.2011ð. îö³íþþòüñÿ ñóäîì êðèòè÷íî, îñê³ëüêè âêàçàíèé äîãîâ³ð â îðèã³íàë³ ñóäó íå íàäàíî, à ó íàÿâíèõ ó ìàòåð³àëàõ ñïðàâè ðàõóíêàõ-ôàêòóðàõ òà ïëàò³æíèõ äîêóìåíòàõ â³äñóòí³ ïîñèëàííÿ íà äàíèé äîãîâ³ð, à òîìó íàäàíà â³äïîâ³äà÷åì êîï³ÿ äîãîâ³ðó êóï³âë³-ïðîäàæó ¹á/í â³ä 12.04.2011ð., ó ðîçóì³íí³ ñò.34 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè, íå º íàëåæíèì òà äîïóñòèìèì äîêàçîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ðàçîì ç òèì, ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè ì³ñòÿòü âèñíîâîê åêñïåðòà Â³ííèöüêîãî â³ää³ëåííÿ Êè¿âñüêîãî íàóêîâî-äîñë³äíîãî ³íñòèòóòó ñóäîâèõ åêñïåðòèç ¹123/124/15-21 â³ä 30.01.2015 ðîêó, â³äïîâ³äíî äî ÿêîãî, ï³äïèñè ó ãðàô³ "Çáîðîâñüêèé ²ãîð Ìèêîëàéîâè÷" íà íàäàíèõ äëÿ äîñë³äæåííÿ îðèã³íàëàõ âèäàòêîâèõ íàêëàäíèõ òà òîâàðíî-òðàíñïîðòíèõ íàêëàäíèõ, íà ÿê³ ïîñèëàºòüñÿ â³äïîâ³äà÷ íà ï³äòâåðäæåíÿ ïåðåäà÷³ òîâàðó óïîâíîâàæåí³é îñîá³, âèêîíàí³ íå Çáîðîâñüêèì ²ãîðåì Ìèêîëàéîâè÷åì, à ³íøîþ îñîáîþ, à ï³äïèñè â³ä ³ìåí³ êåð³âíèêà òîâàðèñòâà "Øëÿõ", ïðîñòàâëåí³ íà äîâ³ðåíîñòÿõ íà îòðèìàííÿ ÒÌÖ, âèêîíàí³ íå Êóçíºöîâèì Âîëîäèìèðîì Îëåêñàíäðîâè÷åì, à ³íøîþ îñîáîþ.</P>
<P class="ps15">Çà íàâåäåíèõ îáñòàâèí, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿, ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ç âèñíîâêîì ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó, ùî íàäàí³ â³äïîâ³äà÷åì îðèã³íàëè âêàçàíèõ äîêóìåíò³â íå ï³äòâåðäæóþòü ôàêò ïîñòàâêè òîâàðó ïîçèâà÷ó.</P>
<P class="ps15">Ç îãëÿäó íà âñòàíîâëåí³ âèùå îáñòàâèíè ñïðàâè, â³äñóòí³ñòü ó ìàòåð³àëàõ ñïðàâè ³íøèõ äîêàç³â íà ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ôàêòó çä³éñíåííÿ ïîñòàâêè òîâàðó â³äïîâ³äà÷åì ïîçèâà÷ó òà ïîâåðíåííÿ â³äïîâ³äà÷åì ïîïåðåäíüî¿ îïëàòè ïîçèâà÷ó, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ä³éøëà âèñíîâêó, ùî ïîçîâíà âèìîãà ïîçèâà÷à ïðî ñòÿãíåííÿ ç â³äïîâ³äà÷à 339741,00ãðí. ïðàâîì³ðíî çàäîâîëåí³ ì³ñöåâèì ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì.</P>
<P class="ps15">Äîâîäè ñêàðæíèêà ñòîñîâíî òîãî, ùî â³äâàíòàæåííÿ òîâàðó â³äïîâ³äà÷åì ïîçèâà÷ó ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ ð³øåííÿì Â³ííèöüêîãî ì³ñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³, äå âñòàíîâëåíî ôàêò â³äâàíòàæåííÿ òîâàðó íà ï³äñòàâ³ ïîêàç³â ñâ³äê³â Âàòàõà Î.Ì. òà Ãàâðèëþêà ª.Â. íå ïðèéìàþòüñÿ êîëåã³ºþ ñóää³â äî óâàãè, îñê³ëüêè â ðåçóëüòàò³ ïåðåãëÿäó ð³øåííÿ Â³ííèöüêîãî ì³ñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 20.08.2014ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹127/9539/14-ö àïåëÿö³éíèé ñóä Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ âèêëþ÷èâ ³ç ìîòèâóâàëüíî¿ ÷àñòèíè ð³øåííÿ Â³ííèöüêîãî ì³ñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 20.08.2014ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹127/9539/14-ö îáñòàâèíè, ùîäî îòðèìàííÿ òîâàðó ÒçÎÂ "Øëÿõ", ÿê òàê³, ùî íå º âñòàíîâëåíèìè (ð³øåííÿ àïåëÿö³éíîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 13.11.2014ð.).</P>
<P class="ps15">Çã³äíî ç ÷.3 ñò.48 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè âèòðàòè, ùî ï³äëÿãàþòü ñïëàò³ çà ïîñëóãè àäâîêàòà, âèçíà÷àþòüñÿ ó ïîðÿäêó, âñòàíîâëåíîìó Çàêîíîì Óêðà¿íè "Ïðî àäâîêàòóðó".</P>
<P class="ps15">×àñòèíîþ 5 ñò.49 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè âñòàíîâëåíî, ùî ñóìè, ÿê³ ï³äëÿãàþòü ñïëàò³ çà ïðîâåäåííÿ ñóäîâî¿ åêñïåðòèçè, ïîñëóãè ïåðåêëàäà÷à, àäâîêàòà òà ³íø³ âèòðàòè, ïîâ'ÿçàí³ ç ðîçãëÿäîì ñïðàâè, ïîêëàäàþòüñÿ ïðè çàäîâîëåíí³ ïîçîâó - íà â³äïîâ³äà÷à.</P>
<P class="ps15">Çà çì³ñòîì ÷àñòèíè òðåòüî¿ ñòàòò³ 48 òà ÷àñòèíè ï'ÿòî¿ ñòàòò³ 49 ÃÏÊ ó ¿õ ñóêóïíîñò³ ìîæëèâå ïîêëàäåííÿ íà ñòîðîíè ó ñïðàâ³ ÿê ñóäîâèõ âèòðàò ò³ëüêè òèõ ñóì, ÿê³ áóëè ñïëà÷åí³ ñòîðîíîþ çà îòðèìàííÿ ïîñëóã ñàìå àäâîêàòà (ó ðîçóì³íí³ ïóíêòó 1 ñòàòò³ 1 òà ÷àñòèíè ïåðøî¿ ñòàòò³ 6 Çàêîíó Óêðà¿íè "Ïðî àäâîêàòóðó òà àäâîêàòñüêó ä³ÿëüí³ñòü"), à íå áóäü-ÿêî¿ îñîáè, ÿêà íàäàâàëà ïðàâîâó äîïîìîãó ñòîðîí³ ó ñïðàâ³. Àíàëîã³÷íó ïðàâîâó ïîçèö³þ âèêëàäåíî ó Ð³øåíí³ Êîíñòèòóö³éíîãî Ñóäó Óêðà¿íè â³ä 11.07.2013 N 6-ðï/2013 ó ñïðàâ³ N 1-4/2013.</P>
<P class="ps16">Çã³äíî ç ÷.1 ñò.32 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè äîêàçàìè ó ñïðàâ³ º áóäü-ÿê³ ôàêòè÷í³ äàí³, íà ï³äñòàâ³ ÿêèõ ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ó âèçíà÷åíîìó çàêîíîì ïîðÿäêó âñòàíîâëþº íàÿâí³ñòü ÷è â³äñóòí³ñòü îáñòàâèí, íà ÿêèõ ãðóíòóþòüñÿ âèìîãè ³ çàïåðå÷åííÿ ñòîð³í, à òàêîæ ³íø³ îáñòàâèíè, ÿê³ ìàþòü çíà÷åííÿ äëÿ ïðàâèëüíîãî âèð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñïîðó.</P>
<P class="ps16">Îáñòàâèíè ñïðàâè, ÿê³ â³äïîâ³äíî äî çàêîíîäàâñòâà ïîâèíí³ áóòè ï³äòâåðäæåí³ ïåâíèìè çàñîáàìè äîêàçóâàííÿ, íå ìîæóòü ï³äòâåðäæóâàòèñü ³íøèìè çàñîáàìè äîêàçóâàííÿ (÷.2 ñò.34 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè).</P>
<P class="ps10">Òàêèì ÷èíîì, ñóä àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ ââàæàº, ùî ï³ä ÷àñ ðîçãëÿäó ñïðàâè ¹902/287/14 ôàêòè÷í³ ¿¿ îáñòàâèíè âñòàíîâëåí³ ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ íà ï³äñòàâ³ âñåá³÷íîãî, ïîâíîãî ³ îáºêòèâíîãî äîñë³äæåííÿ ïîäàíèõ äîêàç³â, âèñíîâêè ñóäó â³äïîâ³äàþòü öèì îáñòàâèíàì ³ ¿ì äàíà íàëåæíà þðèäè÷íà îö³íêà ç ïðàâèëüíèì çàñòîñóâàííÿì íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî ³ ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà, îòæå ï³äñòàâè äëÿ ñêàñóâàííÿ ÷è çì³íè îñêàðæåíîãî ð³øåííÿ â³äñóòí³, à òîìó îñòàííº ñë³ä çàëèøèòè áåç çì³í.</P>
<P class="ps15">Êåðóþ÷èñü ñò.ñò. 101, 103, 105 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, Ð³âíåíñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä,  &nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps9"> &nbsp;&nbsp;</P>
<P class="ps7"><FONT class="fs113">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÈÂ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6">1. Ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 10.06.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹902/287/14 çàëèøèòè áåç çì³í, à àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó ÒçÎÂ "Àãðàíà Ôðóò Óêðà¿íà", ì.Â³ííèöÿ - áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ.</P>
<P class="ps6">2. Ñïðàâó ¹902/287/14 ïîâåðíóòè äî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Â³ííèöüêî¿ îáëàñò³.</P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs112">Ãîëîâóþ÷èé ñóääÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ãóëîâà À.Ã. &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs111">Ñóääÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ìàö³ùóê À.Â. &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs107"><BR>
</FONT><FONT class="fs110">Ñóääÿ &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ïåòóõîâ Ì.Ã. &nbsp;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs106"> </FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs74"> </FONT></P>