<TITLE>914/100/15</TITLE>
<!-- BEGIN METADATA -->
<!-- Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ôàéëà ç ð³øåííÿì -->
<META NAME="FILENAME" CONTENT="5036_669754.html">
<!-- 1,2 ID ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCID, DOCORGID) - íóæíî äëÿ ïîëó÷åíèÿ ïîäòâåðæäåíèÿ ðååñòðàöèè -->
<META NAME="DOCID" CONTENT="669754">
<META NAME="DOCORGID" CONTENT="104">
<!-- [3] Íàéìåíóâàííÿ ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(COURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="COURTNAME" CONTENT="Ëüâ³âñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä">
<!-- [4] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5036">
<!-- [4.1] Êîä ñóäó, ÿêèé óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(CAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="974">
<!-- [5] Ñïðàâà íîìåð TAGNAME(CAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="CAUSENUM" CONTENT="914/100/15">
<!-- [6] Äàòà ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="CAUSEDATE" CONTENT="07.04.2015">
<!-- [7] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ ð³øåííÿ TAGNAME(DOCDATE) -->
<META NAME="DOCDATE" CONTENT="07.09.2015">
<!-- [9] Ôîðìà ð³øåííÿ (ID) TAGNAME(DOCTYPE) -->
<!-- ð³øåííÿ = 2 -->
<!-- ïîñòàíîâà = 3 -->
<!-- óõâàëà ñóäó = 4 -->
<!-- ñóäîâèé íàêàç = 5 -->
<!-- îêðåìà óõâàëà = 6 -->
<META NAME="DOCTYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [10] Ôîðìà ñóäî÷èíñòâà (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSETYPE) -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíà = 1 -->
<!-- êðèì³íàëüíà = 2 -->
<!-- ãîñïîäàðñüêà = 3 -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíà = 4 -->
<!-- àäì³í³ñòðàòèâíå ïðàâîïîðóøåííÿ = 5 -->
<META NAME="CAUSETYPE" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [11] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(CAUSECATEGORY) -->
<META NAME="CAUSECATEGORY" CONTENT="4592">
<!-- [12] Ñïðàâà ðîçãëÿäàºòüñÿ ïî ³íñòàíö³¿ (ID) TAGNAME(CAUSELOCATION) -->
<!-- àïåëÿö³éí³é = A -->
<!-- êàñàö³éí³é = C -->
<META NAME="CAUSELOCATION" CONTENT="A">
<!-- [13] Ïîïåðåäí³é íîìåð ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSENUM) -->
<!-- [14] Ïîïåðåäíÿ äàòà ïîòî÷íî¿ ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(REREGCAUSEDATE) -->
<!-- [15] Íîìåð ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSENUM) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSENUM" CONTENT="914/100/15">
<!-- [16] Äàòà ñóäîâî¿ ñïðàâè, ð³øåííÿ â ÿê³é ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="15.01.2015">
<!-- [17] Äàòà óõâàëåííÿ (ïîñòàíîâëåííÿ) ñóäîâîãî ð³øåííÿ, ùî ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVRESCAUSEDATE) -->
<META NAME="PREVRESCAUSEDATE" CONTENT="24.03.2015">
<!-- [18] Ñóä, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCOURTNAME) -->
<META NAME="PREVCOURTNAME" CONTENT="Ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³">
<!-- [19] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT" CONTENT="5015">
<!-- [19.1] Êîä ñóäó, ùî óõâàëèâ (ïîñòàíîâèâ) ñóäîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêå ïåðåãëÿäàºòüñÿ TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECOURT2013) -->
<META NAME="PREVCAUSECOURT2013" CONTENT="914">
<!-- [20] Êîä êàòåãîð³¿ ïîïåðåäíüî¿ ñïðàâè TAGNAME(PREVCAUSECATEGORY) -->
<!-- [21] Ñåêðåòàð ñóäîâîãî çàñ³äàííÿ TAGNAME(SECRETARY) -->
<!-- [22] Çàáîðîíà îïðèëþäíåííÿ TAGNAME(HEARINGCLOSED) -->
<!-- íå çàáîðîíåíî = V -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî = Z -->
<!-- çàáîðîíåíî òèì÷àñîâî = T -->
<META NAME="HEARINGCLOSED" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [23] Ê³ëüê-òü àðêóø³â äîêóìåíòà (ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß) -->
<!-- Ñóää³ â ð³øåíí³: -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME1" CONTENT="Çâàðè÷ Î.Â.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME2" CONTENT="Õàá³á Ì.².">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- [24] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(JUDGEPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="JUDGEPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [25] ÏÐ²ÇÂÈÙÅ, ²Í²Ö²ÀËÈ TAGNAME(JUDGENAME) -->
<META NAME="JUDGENAME3" CONTENT="Þð÷åíêî ß.Î.">
<!-- [26] ÊÎÄ ÑÓÄÄ² TAGNAME(JUDGECODE) -->
<!-- Ñòîðîíè ð³øåííÿ: -->
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION1" CONTENT="1">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE1" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE1" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE1" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME1" CONTENT="ÒçÎÂ &quot;Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ &quot;Øóâàð&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT1" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO1" CONTENT="33711331">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL1" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION2" CONTENT="2">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE2" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE2" CONTENT="">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE2" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE2" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME2" CONTENT="ÒçÎÂ &quot;Ñòàòóñáóä&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT2" CONTENT="Â³äïîâ³äà÷ 1">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO2" CONTENT="34311733">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL2" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION3" CONTENT="3">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE3" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE3" CONTENT="">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE3" CONTENT="V">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE3" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME3" CONTENT="ÒçÎÂ &quot;Ñîëñòðîé&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT3" CONTENT="Â³äïîâ³äà÷ 2">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO3" CONTENT="30210582">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL3" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [27] Ïîðÿäêîâèé íîìåð TAGNAME(MEMBPOSITION) -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOSITION4" CONTENT="4">
<!-- [28] Òèï ñòîðîíè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<META NAME="MEMBTYPE4" CONTENT="P">
<!-- [29] Òèï ïîçèâà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE) -->
<!-- ïîçèâà÷ = P -->
<!-- çàÿâíèê = Z -->
<!-- ñòÿãóâà÷ = S -->
<!-- êðåäèòîð = K -->
<!-- îáâèíóâà÷ = B -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé ïîçèâà÷ = C -->
<!-- çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà = A -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBPOZYVACHTYPE4" CONTENT="Z">
<!-- [30] Òèï â³äïîâ³äà÷à (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE) -->
<!-- â³äïîâ³äà÷ = V -->
<!-- öèâ³ëüíèé â³äïîâ³äà÷ = C -->
<!-- àäì³í.ïðàâîïîðóøíèê = P -->
<!-- áîðæíèê = B -->
<!-- ï³äñóäíèé = D -->
<!-- ³íøà îñîáà = I -->
<META NAME="MEMBVIDPOVIDACHTYPE4" CONTENT="">
<!-- [31] Òèï îñîáè (ID): TAGNAME(MEMBOSOBATYPE) -->
<!-- þðèäè÷íà = U -->
<!-- ô³çè÷íà = F -->
<META NAME="MEMBOSOBATYPE4" CONTENT="U">
<!-- [32] Ïîâíà íàçâà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ïð³çâèùå òà ³í³ö³àëè (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBNAME) -->
<META NAME="MEMBNAME4" CONTENT="ÒçÎÂ &quot;Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ &quot;Øóâàð&quot;">
<!-- [33] Öèôðîâå àáî ë³òåðíå ïîçíà÷åííÿ TAGNAME(MEMBSHORT) -->
<META NAME="MEMBSHORT4" CONTENT="Ïîçèâà÷ 2">
<!-- [34] Êîä ªÄÐÏÎÓ (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBOKPO) -->
<META NAME="MEMBOKPO4" CONTENT="33711331">
<!-- [35] Äàòà íàðîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) - ÍÅ Ï²ÄÒÐÈÌÓªÒÜÑß -->
<!-- [36] Àäðåñà (äëÿ þðèäè÷íèõ) àáî Ì³ñöåçíàõîäæåííÿ (äëÿ ô³çè÷íèõ) TAGNAME(MEMBPOSTADDRESS) -->
<!-- [37] ×àñòêà äåðæâëàñíîñò³ TAGNAME(CHASTDERGVL) ÇÍÀ×ÅÍÈÅ(TRUE|FALSE) -->
<META NAME="CHASTDERGVL4" CONTENT="FALSE">
<!-- [38] Âåðñ³ÿ êë³ºíòà TAGNAME(APPVER) -->
<META NAME="APPVER" CONTENT="1.24.1.200">
<!-- [39] Êîä ïðîâàéäåðà ÅÖÏ TAGNAME(CRYPTPROVIDER) -->
<META NAME="CRYPTPROVIDER" CONTENT="DS13">
<!-- END METADATA -->
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Content-Type" CONTENT="text/html; charset=windows-1251">
<META NAME="Author" CONTENT="">
<META NAME="Description" CONTENT="Document">
<META NAME="Document-state" CONTENT="static">
<META NAME="Updated" CONTENT="10.09.2015 14:37:29">
<META NAME="Robots" CONTENT="All">
<META NAME="Keywords" CONTENT="">
<STYLE TYPE="text/css">
margin-right: 10 mm;
margin-bottom: 10 mm;
mso-paper-source: 0;
@charset "Windows-1251";
font-family: Times New Roman;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Facefont SSH;
font-family: Times New Roman;
margin-bottom: 0 mm;
white-space: normal;
word-spacing: normal;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
margin-right: -1 mm;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
text-align: justify;
<P class="ps13"><FONT class="fs227"> </FONT><FONT class="fs225"><IMG src="herb.gif" height=72 width=54></FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs114">ËÜÂ²ÂÑÜÊÈÉ ÀÏÅËßÖ²ÉÍÈÉ ÃÎÑÏÎÄÀÐÑÜÊÈÉ ÑÓÄ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs223">_________________________________________________________________________________________________________</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs111">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÀ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs110">²ÌÅÍÅÌ ÓÊÐÀ¯ÍÈ</FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs113"> </FONT></P>
<P class="ps10"><FONT class="fs85">"07" âåðåñíÿ 2015 ð.</FONT><FONT class="fs116">                                                   &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ñïðàâà ¹ &nbsp;&nbsp;914/100/15</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs133">Ëüâ³âñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä â ñêëàä³ êîëåã³¿:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs221">ãîëîâóþ÷îãî - ñóää³                                                            Çâàðè÷ Î.Â.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs220">ñóää³â                                                                                Õàá³á Ì.²</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs219">                                                                                Þð÷åíêî ß.Î.,</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs132">ðîçãëÿíóâøè ó â³äêðèòîìó ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ </FONT><FONT class="fs218">àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð (íàäàë³ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð) çà ¹11-04 â³ä 02.04.2015ð. (âõ.¹01-05/1588/15 â³ä 07.04.2015ð.)</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs131">íà ð³øåííÿ </FONT><FONT class="fs217">Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 24.03.2015ð.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs130">ó ñïðàâ³</FONT><FONT class="fs216"> ¹ 914/100/15</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs129">çà ïîçîâîì: </FONT><FONT class="fs215">ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs128">äî â³äïîâ³äà÷à-1: </FONT><FONT class="fs214">Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ Ñòàòóñáóä (íàäàë³ ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä)</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs127">äî â³äïîâ³äà÷à-2: </FONT><FONT class="fs213">Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ Ñîëñòðîé (íàäàë³ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé)</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs126">çà ó÷àñòþ òðåòüî¿ îñîáè, ÿêà íå çàÿâëÿº ñàìîñò³éíèõ âèìîã íà ïðåäìåò ñïîðó íà ñòîðîí³ â³äïîâ³äà÷³â: </FONT><FONT class="fs212">×îâáè Àíàòîë³ÿ Ìèõàéëîâè÷à (íàäàë³ ×îâáà À.Ì.)</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs125">ïðî</FONT><FONT class="fs211"> âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012 ð.,</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs124">çà ó÷àñòþ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs123">â³ä ïîçèâà÷à: </FONT><FONT class="fs210">Ïðîõîðåíêî Î.².  ïðåäñòàâíèê (äîâ³ðåí³ñòü á/í â³ä 20.01.2015ð.);</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs122">â³ä â³äïîâ³äà÷à-1: </FONT><FONT class="fs209">íå çÿâèâñÿ;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps5"><FONT class="fs121">â³ä â³äïîâ³äà÷à-2: </FONT><FONT class="fs208">íå çÿâèâñÿ;</FONT></P>
<P class="ps0"><FONT class="fs120">â³ä òðåòüî¿ îñîáè:</FONT><FONT class="fs207"> Ìóøèíñüêèé Ò.Á.  ïðåäñòàâíèê (äîâ³ðåí³ñòü á/í â³ä 04.11.2014ð.),</FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs119">ÂÑÒÀÍÎÂÈÂ:</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs206">Ð³øåííÿì ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 24.03.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹914/100/15 (ñóääÿ Êèäèñþê Ð.À.) ïîâí³ñòþ â³äìîâëåíî â çàäîâîëåíí³ ïîçîâó. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs205">Ñóä ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ ïðèéøîâ äî âèñíîâêó ïðî òå, ùî ôàêò â³äñóòíîñò³ çãîäè áîðæíèêà íà óêëàäåííÿ êîíòðàãåíòîì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè áåçïîñåðåäíüî íå ïîâ'ÿçàíèé ³ç íåä³éñí³ñòþ ïðàâî÷èíó, ç îãëÿäó íà ùî â³äìîâèâ â çàäîâîëåíí³ ïîçîâó ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ïðî âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs204">Ïîçèâà÷ ïîäàâ àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó, â ÿê³é ââàæàº, ùî ñóä ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ ïîðóøèâ íîðìè ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà. Ñòâåðäæóº ïðî ïîìèëêîâ³ñòü âèñíîâêó ñóäó ùîäî íåïîðóøåííÿ ïðàâà ïîçèâà÷à. Çâåðòàº óâàãó íà òå, ùî â³äïîâ³äíî äî ï. 26.1 äîãîâîðó ï³äðÿäó â³ä 01.09.2010ð. ñòîðîíè çîáîâÿçàëèñü íå ïåðåäàâàòè ñâî¿õ ïðàâ òà îáîâÿçê³â ïî äîãîâîðó òðåò³ì îñîáàì áåç ïèñüìîâî¿ çãîäè íà öå ³íøî¿ ñòîðîíè. Âêàçóº, ùî â³äïîâ³äà÷-2 íå çâåðòàâñÿ äî ïîçèâà÷à ùîäî ïîãîäæåííÿ â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè íà êîðèñòü â³äïîâ³äà÷à-1, ³ â³äïîâ³äíî, ïîçèâà÷ òàêî¿ çãîäè íå íàäàâàâ. Ïðîñèòü ñêàñóâàòè ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 24.03.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹ 914/100/15, ïðèéíÿòè íîâå ð³øåííÿ, ÿêèì ïîçîâ çàäîâîëèòè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs203">Â³äïîâ³äà÷-2 â ïèñüìîâèõ ïîÿñíåííÿõ ïî ñïðàâ³ (âõ. ¹ 01-04/2981/15 â³ä 13.05.2015ð.) íå ïîãîäæóºòüñÿ ç àïåëÿö³éíîþ ñêàðãîþ òà ââàæàº îñêàðæóâàíå ð³øåííÿ ñóäó ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ çàêîííèì ³ îá´ðóíòîâàíèì. Çâåðòàº óâàãó íà òå, ùî ïðîòÿãîì ëèïíÿ-ãðóäíÿ 2012 ðîêó ïîçèâà÷ íåîäíîðàçîâî ïåðåðàõîâóâàâ êîøòè íà ðàõóíîê íîâîãî êðåäèòîðà (â³äïîâ³äà÷à-1) â ÿêîñò³ ÷àñòêîâî¿ îïëàòè çà äîãîâîðîì ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., ùî, íà éîãî äóìêó, ï³äòâåðäæóº ôàêò âèçíàííÿ ïîçèâà÷åì ñï³ðíîãî ïðàâî÷èíó. Ïðîñèòü çàëèøèòè áåç çì³í ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 24.03.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹ 914/100/15, à àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð  áåç çàäîâîëåííÿ.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs202">Â³äïîâ³äà÷-1 òà òðåòÿ îñîáà íå íàäàâàëè ïèñüìîâèõ â³äçèâ³â íà àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs201">Ïðèñóòí³é â ñóäîâîìó çàñ³äàíí³ ïðåäñòàâíèê òðåòüî¿ îñîáè çàïåðå÷èâ ïðîòè âèìîã ³ äîâîä³â àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè, ïðîñèâ çàëèøèòè áåç çì³í îñêàðæóâàíå ð³øåííÿ ñóäó ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs200">Â³äïîâ³äà÷³ íå çàáåçïå÷èëè ÿâêè â ñóäîâå çàñ³äàííÿ óïîâíîâàæåíèõ ïðåäñòàâíèê³â, ïðî ÷àñ, äàòó ³ ì³ñöå ðîçãëÿäó àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè íàëåæíî ïîâ³äîìëåí³, ïðî ùî ñâ³ä÷àòü ïîâ³äîìëåííÿ ïðî âðó÷åííÿ ïîøòîâèõ â³äïðàâëåíü â³ä 05.08.2015ð.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs199">Â òåëåãðàì³ (âõ. ¹ 01-14/316/15 â³ä 04.09.2015ð.) â³äïîâ³äà÷-2 ïðîñèâ ðîçãëÿíóòè ñïðàâó áåç ó÷àñò³ éîãî ïðåäñòàâíèêà.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs198">Àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä, äîñë³äèâøè íàÿâí³ ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè, îáãîâîðèâøè äîâîäè àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè, çàñëóõàâøè ïîÿñíåííÿ ó÷àñíèê³â ñóäîâîãî ïðîöåñó, ïåðåâ³ðèâøè þðèäè÷íó îö³íêó îáñòàâèí ñïðàâè, ïðàâèëüí³ñòü çàñòîñóâàííÿ ñóäîì ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ íîðì ìàòåð³àëüíîãî òà ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî ïðàâà, ä³éøîâ âèñíîâêó ïðî íàÿâí³ñòü ï³äñòàâ äëÿ ñêàñóâàííÿ ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 24.03.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹914/100/15.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs197">ßê âáà÷àºòüñÿ ç ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè, 01.09.2010ð. ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð (çàìîâíèê) òà ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé (ãåíï³äðÿäíèê) óêëàäåíî äîãîâ³ð ï³äðÿäó ¹ 23/09-06, çà óìîâàìè ÿêîãî çàìîâíèê äîðó÷àº ãåíï³äðÿäíèêó çä³éñíèòè áóä³âíèöòâî ïàâ³ëüéîí³â «Îâî÷³. Ôðóêòè» òà òåðì³íàëó «Ðèáà» íà ÷àñòèí³ òåðèòîð³¿ çåìåëüíî¿ ä³ëÿíêè îïòîâîãî ðèíêó ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ ïëîùåþ 3,5ãà (à.ñ.15-26).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs196">Â ïóíêò³ 15.1 äîãîâîðó ï³äðÿäó çàçíà÷åíî, ùî ãåíï³äðÿäíèê îòðèìóº, â ÿêîñò³ îïëàòè çà ðîáîòè, ìàòåð³àëè òà ïîñëóãè ç áóä³âíèöòâà, ùî ìàþòü áóòè âèêîíàí³ â³äïîâ³äíî äî óìîâ öüîãî äîãîâîðó, ñóìó, ùî ñòàíîâèòü 73751852,10 ãðí., êð³ì òîãî ÏÄÂ  14750370,42ãðí. Çàãàëüíà ñóìà äîãîâîðó ñòàíîâèòü: 88502222,52 ãðí.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs195">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ï.26.1 ñòîðîíè çà öèì äîãîâîðîì íå ìàþòü ïðàâà áåç ïîïåðåäíüîãî ïèñüìîâîãî ïîãîäæåííÿ ïåðåäàâàòè ÷è â³äñòóïàòè ñâî¿ îáîâÿçêè ÷è ïðàâà çà öèì äîãîâîðîì áóäü-ÿê³é òðåò³é ñòîðîí³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs194">Ïîçèâà÷ ó ïîçîâí³é çàÿâ³ çàçíà÷èâ, ùî ðîáîòè ïî âëàøòóâàííþ äîðîæíüîãî ïîêðèòòÿ ï³ä ïðî¿çäàìè òà àâòîñòîÿíêîþ íàâêîëî çàêðèòèõ ïàâ³ëüéîí³â Îâî÷³.Ôðóêòè òà Ðèáà âèêîíóâàëèñü âêðàé íåÿê³ñíî. ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð çìóøåíå áóëî çâåðíóòèñÿ â ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä ì. Êèºâà ç ïîçîâíèìè âèìîãàìè ïðî óñóíåííÿ íåäîë³ê³â âèêîíóâàíèõ ðîá³ò äî ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé òà ïðèìóñîâå âèêîíàííÿ îáîâÿçê³â â íàòóð³. Âêàçàâ, ùî íåïðîâåäåííÿ îñòàòî÷íîãî ðîçðàõóíêó ç ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé áóëî äëÿ ïîçèâà÷à ãàðàíò³ºþ òîãî, ùî ãåíï³äðÿäíèê óñóíå íåäîë³êè ðîá³ò, ÿê³ íèì âèêîíóâàëèñÿ çã³äíî äîãîâîðó ï³äðÿäó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs193">Ìàòåð³àëàìè ñïðàâè ï³äòâåðäæåíî, ùî 27.04.2012ð. ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé (ïåðâ³ñíèé êðåäèòîð) òà ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä (íîâèé êðåäèòîð) óêëàäåíî äîãîâ³ð ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè, çã³äíî ÿêîãî ïåðâ³ñíèé êðåäèòîð ïåðåäàº, à íîâèé êðåäèòîð ïðèéìàº íà ñåáå ïðàâî âèìîãè âèêîíàííÿ ãðîøîâèõ çîáîâÿçàíü â ñóì³ 1175000,00 ãðí., ùî íàëåæèòü ïåðâ³ñíîìó êðåäèòîðîâ³ íà ï³äñòàâ³ äîãîâîðó ï³äðÿäó ¹ 23/09-06 â³ä 01.09.2010ð. (îñíîâíèé äîãîâ³ð), ùî óêëàäåíèé ì³æ ïåðâ³ñíèì êðåäèòîðîì òà ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð (áîðæíèê) (à.ñ.210-211).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs192">Çã³äíî ï. 1.2 çà öèì äîãîâîðîì íîâèé êðåäèòîð îäåðæóº ïðàâî (çàì³ñòü ïåðâ³ñíîãî êðåäèòîðà) âèìàãàòè â³ä áîðæíèêà íàëåæíîãî âèêîíàííÿ çîáîâÿçàíü çà îñíîâíèì äîãîâîðîì ùîäî ñïëàòè çàáîðãîâàíîñò³ â ðîçì³ð³ 1175000,00 ãðí.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs191">Çã³äíî ç â³äñòóïëåííÿì ïðàâà âèìîãè çà öèì äîãîâîðîì íîâèé êðåäèòîð ñïëà÷óº ïåðâ³ñíîìó êðåäèòîðó âèíàãîðîäó â ðîçì³ð³ 1175000,00 ãðí. øëÿõîì áåçãîò³âêîâîãî ïåðåðàõóâàííÿ öèõ êîøò³â íà ïîòî÷íèé áàíê³âñüêèé ðàõóíîê ïåðâ³ñíîãî êðåäèòîðà äî 30.12.2012ð. àáî ³íøèì ÷èíîì, íå çàáîðîíåíèì ÷èííèì çàêîíîäàâñòâîì (ï. 2.1 äîãîâîðó).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs190">Ïðàâà òà îáîâÿçêè ñòîð³í äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè, ¿õ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòü, ïåðåäáà÷åí³ ðîçä³ëàìè 3, 4 äàíîãî äîãîâîðó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs189">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ï. 5.1 öåé äîãîâ³ð íàáèðàº ÷èííîñò³ ç ìîìåíòó éîãî ï³äïèñàííÿ ³ ä³º äî ïîâíîãî âèêîíàííÿ ñòîðîíàìè ñâî¿õ çîáîâÿçàíü çà öèì äîãîâîðîì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs188">Äîãîâ³ð ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., óêëàäåíèé ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé òà ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä, ï³äïèñàíèé ³ ñêð³ïëåíèé ïå÷àòêàìè éîãî ñòîð³í.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs187">Ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè íå ì³ñòÿòü ³ ñóäó íå íàäàíî äîêàç³â íà ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ³ñíóâàííÿ ïîïåðåäíüîãî ïèñüìîâîãî ïîãîäæåííÿ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ÿê çàìîâíèêà çà äîãîâîðîì ï³äðÿäó íà óêëàäåííÿ ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé òà ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs186">Ðàçîì ç òèì, âèïèñêàìè ïî ðàõóíêó ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä ï³äòâåðäæóºòüñÿ, ùî â ÷åðâí³, âåðåñí³, æîâòí³ òà ãðóäí³ 2012 ðîêó ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ïåðåðàõîâóâàëî êîøòè íà ðàõóíîê ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä â ÿêîñò³ ñïëàòè áîðãó çã³äíî äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð. (à.ñ.149-152).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs185">Â ïîäàëüøîìó, 15.04.2014ð. ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä (ïåðâ³ñíèé êðåäèòîð) òà ÔÎÏ ×îâáà À.Ì. (íîâèé êðåäèòîð) óêëàäåíî äîãîâ³ð â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè ¹ 01/15-04/2014, çà óìîâàìè ÿêîãî ïåðâ³ñíèé êðåäèòîð ïåðåäàº íîâîìó êðåäèòîðîâ³, à íîâèé êðåäèòîð ïðèéìàº ïðàâî âèìîãè, ùî íàëåæèòü ïåðâ³ñíîìó êðåäèòîðîâ³, ó ðîçì³ð³ 340000,00 ãðí. ³ ñòàº ó ö³é ÷àñòèí³ êðåäèòîðîì çà äîãîâîðîì ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð. (îñíîâíèé äîãîâ³ð), óêëàäåíèì ì³æ ïåðâ³ñíèì êðåäèòîðîì òà ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè ãðîøîâî¿ ñóìè ó ðîçì³ð³ 1175000,00 ãðí. äî ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð (áîðæíèê).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs184">Ï³äñòàâîþ çâåðíåííÿ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð äî ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó ç äàíèì ïîçîâîì ñëóãóâàëî òå, ùî Òîâàðèñòâî íå äàâàëî â³äïîâ³äà÷ó-2 çãîäè íà ïåðåäà÷ó ïðàâ âèìîãè íà âèêîíàííÿ ãðîøîâèõ çîáîâÿçàíü, ïåðåäáà÷åíî¿ äîãîâîðîì ï³äðÿäó. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs182">Ïðè âèíåñåíí³ ïîñòàíîâè, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â êåðóâàëàñÿ íàñòóïíèì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs181">Çã³äíî ÷àñòèíè 2 ñòàòò³ 11 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ï³äñòàâàìè âèíèêíåííÿ öèâ³ëüíèõ ïðàâ òà îáîâÿçê³â, çîêðåìà º äîãîâîðè òà ³íø³ ïðàâî÷èíè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs180">Â ÷àñòèí³ 7 ñòàòò³ 179 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè çàçíà÷åíî, ùî ãîñïîäàðñüê³ äîãîâîðè óêëàäàþòüñÿ çà ïðàâèëàìè, âñòàíîâëåíèìè Öèâ³ëüíèì êîäåêñîì Óêðà¿íè ç óðàõóâàííÿì îñîáëèâîñòåé, ïåðåäáà÷åíèõ öèì Êîäåêñîì, ³íøèìè íîðìàòèâíî-ïðàâîâèìè àêòàìè ùîäî îêðåìèõ âèä³â äîãîâîð³â.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs179">Ñòàòòåþ 627 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè óíîðìîâàíî, ùî ñòîðîíè º â³ëüíèìè â óêëàäåíí³ äîãîâîðó, âèáîð³ êîíòðàãåíòà òà âèçíà÷åíí³ óìîâ äîãîâîðó, ç âðàõóâàííÿì âèìîã öüîãî êîäåêñó, ³íøèõ àêò³â öèâ³ëüíîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà, çâè÷à¿â ä³ëîâîãî îáîðîòó, âèìîã ðîçóìíîñò³ òà ñïðàâåäëèâîñò³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs178">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ìàòåð³àë³â ñïðàâè ïðåäìåòîì ñïîðó â äàí³é ñïðàâ³ º âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., óêëàäåíîãî ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé òà ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs177">Ñòàòòåþ 203 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè âñòàíîâëåíî çàãàëüí³ âèìîãè, äîäåðæàííÿ ÿêèõ º íåîáõ³äíèì äëÿ ÷èííîñò³ ïðàâî÷èíó. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps8"><FONT class="fs176">Òàê, çì³ñò ïðàâî÷èíó íå ìîæå ñóïåðå÷èòè öüîìó Êîäåêñó, ³íøèì àêòàì öèâ³ëüíîãî çàêîíîäàâñòâà, à òàêîæ ³íòåðåñàì äåðæàâè ³ ñóñï³ëüñòâà, éîãî ìîðàëüíèì çàñàäàì. Îñîáà, ÿêà â÷èíÿº ïðàâî÷èí, ïîâèííà ìàòè íåîáõ³äíèé îáñÿã öèâ³ëüíî¿ ä³ºçäàòíîñò³. Âîëåâèÿâëåííÿ ó÷àñíèêà ïðàâî÷èíó ìàº áóòè â³ëüíèì ³ â³äïîâ³äàòè éîãî âíóòð³øí³é âîë³. Ïðàâî÷èí ìàº â÷èíÿòèñÿ ó ôîðì³, âñòàíîâëåí³é çàêîíîì. Ïðàâî÷èí ìàº áóòè ñïðÿìîâàíèé íà ðåàëüíå íàñòàííÿ ïðàâîâèõ íàñë³äê³â, ùî îáóìîâëåí³ íèì.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs175">Â ñèëó ñòàòò³ 215 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè ï³äñòàâîþ íåä³éñíîñò³ ïðàâî÷èíó º íåäîäåðæàííÿ â ìîìåíò â÷èíåííÿ ïðàâî÷èíó ñòîðîíîþ (ñòîðîíàìè) âèìîã, ÿê³ âñòàíîâëåí³ ÷àñòèíàìè ïåðøîþ - òðåòüîþ, ï'ÿòîþ òà øîñòîþ ñòàòò³ 203 öüîãî Êîäåêñó. ßêùî íåä³éñí³ñòü ïðàâî÷èíó ïðÿìî íå âñòàíîâëåíà çàêîíîì, àëå îäíà ³ç ñòîð³í àáî ³íøà çà³íòåðåñîâàíà îñîáà çàïåðå÷óº éîãî ä³éñí³ñòü íà ï³äñòàâàõ, âñòàíîâëåíèõ çàêîíîì, òàêèé ïðàâî÷èí ìîæå áóòè âèçíàíèé ñóäîì íåä³éñíèì (îñïîðþâàíèé ïðàâî÷èí).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs174">Çàÿâëÿþ÷è ïîçîâ ïðî âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó, ïîçèâà÷ ìàº äîâåñòè íàÿâí³ñòü òèõ îáñòàâèí, ç ÿêèìè çàêîí ïîâ'ÿçóº âèçíàííÿ óãîä íåä³éñíèìè ³ íàñòàííÿì â³äïîâ³äíèõ íàñë³äê³â.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs173">Ï³äñòàâîþ âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., óêëàäåíîãî ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé òà ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä, ïîçèâà÷ ââàæàº òå, ùî òàêèé äîãîâ³ð óêëàäåíèé áåç îòðèìàííÿ çãîäè ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ÿê áîðæíèêà çà äîãîâîðîì ï³äðÿäó ¹ 23/09-06 â³ä 01.09.2010ð.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs172">Ñòàòòåþ 512 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè âèçíà÷åíî ï³äñòàâè çàì³íè êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³, çîêðåìà âíàñë³äîê ïåðåäàííÿ íèì ñâî¿õ ïðàâ ³íø³é îñîá³ çà ïðàâî÷èíîì (â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè).</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs171">Çã³äíî ç³ ñòàòòÿìè 514, 516 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè äî íîâîãî êðåäèòîðà ïåðåõîäÿòü ïðàâà ïåðâ³ñíîãî êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³ â îáñÿç³ ³ íà óìîâàõ, ùî ³ñíóâàëè íà ìîìåíò ïåðåõîäó öèõ ïðàâ, ÿêùî ³íøå íå âñòàíîâëåíî äîãîâîðîì àáî çàêîíîì. Çàì³íà êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³ çä³éñíþºòüñÿ áåç çãîäè áîðæíèêà, ÿêùî ³íøå íå âñòàíîâëåíî äîãîâîðîì àáî çàêîíîì. ßêùî áîðæíèê íå áóâ ïèñüìîâî ïîâ³äîìëåíèé ïðî çàì³íó êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³, íîâèé êðåäèòîð íåñå ðèçèê íàñòàííÿ íåñïðèÿòëèâèõ äëÿ íüîãî íàñë³äê³â. Ó öüîìó ðàç³ âèêîíàííÿ áîðæíèêîì ñâîãî îáîâ'ÿçêó ïåðâ³ñíîìó êðåäèòîðîâ³ º íàëåæíèì âèêîíàííÿì. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs170">Ç àíàë³çó íàâåäåíèõ íîðì âáà÷àºòüñÿ, ùî çà çàãàëüíèì ïðàâèëîì çàì³íà êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³ çä³éñíþºòüñÿ áåç çãîäè áîðæíèêà, îñê³ëüêè íå âïëèâàº íà õàðàêòåð, îáñÿã ³ ïîðÿäîê âèêîíàííÿ íèì ñâî¿õ îáîâ'ÿçê³â, íå ïîã³ðøóº ñòàíîâèùå áîðæíèêà òà íå çà÷³ïàº éîãî ³íòåðåñ³â, îäíàê ñòîðîíè ìàþòü ïðàâî äîäàòêîâî âðåãóëþâàòè ïîðÿäîê çàì³íè êðåäèòîðà ó äîãîâîð³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs169">Òîáòî, â³äñóòí³ñòü çãîäè áîðæíèêà íà çàì³íó êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâ'ÿçàíí³, ÿêùî îáîâ'ÿçêîâ³ñòü òàêî¿ çãîäè ïåðåäáà÷åíî äîãîâîðîì, º ï³äñòàâîþ äëÿ âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè íà ï³äñòàâ³ ÷. 1 ñò. 203 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, îñê³ëüêè â³í ñóïåðå÷èòü âèìîãàì ÷. 1 ñò. 516 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs168">Çã³äíî ç ï. 26.1 äîãîâîðó ï³äðÿäó ¹ 23/09-06 â³ä 01.09.2010ð., óêëàäåíîãî ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð òà ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé, ñòîðîíè çà öèì äîãîâîðîì íå ìàþòü ïðàâà áåç ïîïåðåäíüîãî ïèñüìîâîãî ïîãîäæåííÿ ïåðåäàâàòè ÷è â³äñòóïàòè ñâî¿ îáîâÿçêè ÷è ïðàâà çà öèì äîãîâîðîì áóäü-ÿê³é òðåò³é ñòîðîí³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs167">Òîáòî, äîãîâ³ð ï³äðÿäó ïåðåäáà÷àº óìîâó â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâ çà öèì äîãîâîðîì  ïîïåðåäíº ïèñüìîâå ïîãîäæåííÿ ³íøî¿ ñòîðîíè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs166">Ç îãëÿäó íà âèêëàäåíå, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â êîíñòàòóº, ùî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé ïðàâ çà äîãîâîðîì ï³äðÿäó íà êîðèñòü ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä ìîãëî â³äáóâàòèñÿ âèêëþ÷íî çà íàÿâíîñò³ ïîïåðåäíüîãî ïèñüìîâîãî ïîãîäæåííÿ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ÿê áîðæíèêà çà äîãîâîðîì ï³äðÿäó.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs165">Â³äìîâëÿþ÷è â çàäîâîëåíí³ ïîçîâíî¿ âèìîãè ïðî âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., ñóä ïåðøî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ âèõîäèâ ç òîãî, ùî êîï³¿ âèïèñîê ïî ðàõóíêó ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä, ç ÿêèõ âáà÷àºòüñÿ, ùî ïðîòÿãîì ëèïíÿ-ãðóäíÿ 2012 ðîêó ÒçÎÂ ÐÑÏ Øóâàð íåîäíîðàçîâî ïåðåðàõîâóâàëî êîøòè íà ðàõóíîê ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä â ÿêîñò³ ÷àñòêîâî¿ îïëàòè çà îñïîðþâàíèì äîãîâîðîì ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., ï³äòâåðäæóþòü ôàêò âèçíàííÿ ïîçèâà÷åì ÒçÎÂ ÐÑÏ Øóâàð ñï³ðíîãî ïðàâî÷èíó  äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs164">Ïðîòå, êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ââàæàº ïîìèëêîâèì âêàçàíèé âèñíîâîê ì³ñöåâîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó, âðàõîâóþ÷è òå, ùî ìàòåð³àëè ñïðàâè íå ì³ñòÿòü íàëåæíèõ òà äîïóñòèìèõ â ðîçóì³íí³ ïðèïèñ³â ñò.ñò. 32, 33 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè äîêàç³â íà ï³äòâåðäæåííÿ ³ñíóâàííÿ ïîïåðåäíüîãî ïèñüìîâîãî ïîãîäæåííÿ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ÿê áîðæíèêà çà äîãîâîðîì ï³äðÿäó íà óêëàäåííÿ ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé òà ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä ñï³ðíîãî äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs163">Çà òàêèõ îáñòàâèí êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â ïðèõîäèòü äî âèñíîâêó, ùî äîãîâ³ð ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð. áóëî óêëàäåíî ì³æ ÒçÎÂ Ñòàòóñáóä òà ÒçÎÂ Ñîëñòðîé áåç îòðèìàííÿ ïîïåðåäíüîãî ïèñüìîâîãî ïîãîäæåííÿ ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð, ùî ñâ³ä÷èòü ïðî ïîðóøåííÿ ñòîðîíàìè ï³ä ÷àñ óêëàäåííÿ òàêîãî ñï³ðíîãî äîãîâîðó ïðèïèñ³â ï. 26.1 äîãîâîðó ï³äðÿäó ¹ 23/09-06 â³ä 01.09.2010ð. òà ÷àñòèíè 1 ñòàòò³ 516 Öèâ³ëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs162">Â³äñóòí³ñòü çãîäè áîðæíèêà íà çàì³íó êðåäèòîðà ó çîáîâÿçàíí³, ÿêùî îáîâÿçêîâ³ñòü òàêî¿ çãîäè ïåðåäáà÷åíî äîãîâîðîì, º ï³äñòàâîþ äëÿ âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì íà ï³äñòàâ³ ÷.1 ñò.203 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè, îñê³ëüêè â³í ñóïåðå÷èòü âèìîãàì ÷.1 ñò.516 ÖÊ Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs161">Àíàëîã³÷í³ âèñíîâêè ì³ñòÿòüñÿ â ïîñòàíîâ³ Âåðõîâíîãî Ñóäó Óêðà¿íè â³ä 15.04.2015ð. ïðî ïåðåãëÿä ïîñòàíîâè Âèùîãî ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Óêðà¿íè â³ä 18 ãðóäíÿ 2014 ðîêó ó ñïðàâ³ ¹ 910/6098/14. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps9"><FONT class="fs160">Âðàõîâóþ÷è âèùåâêàçàíå, ñóä àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ³íñòàíö³¿ â³äçíà÷àº, ùî ïîçîâí³ âèìîãè ÒçÎÂ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð ïðî âèçíàííÿ íåä³éñíèì äîãîâîðó ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð. º ïðàâîì³ðíèìè òà îá´ðóíòîâàíèìè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs159">Ùîäî âèìîãè ïðî â³äøêîäóâàííÿ âèòðàò íà ïðàâîâó äîïîìîãó êîëåã³ÿ ñóää³â çàçíà÷àº òàêå.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs158">Â³äïîâ³äíî äî ñò. 44 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè ñóäîâ³ âèòðàòè ñêëàäàþòüñÿ ç ñóäîâîãî çáîðó, ñóì, ùî ï³äëÿãàþòü ñïëàò³ çà ïðîâåäåííÿ ñóäîâî¿ åêñïåðòèçè, ïðèçíà÷åíî¿ ãîñïîäàðñüêèì ñóäîì, âèòðàò, ïîâ'ÿçàíèõ ç îãëÿäîì òà äîñë³äæåííÿì ðå÷îâèõ äîêàç³â ó ì³ñö³ ¿õ çíàõîäæåííÿ, îïëàòè ïîñëóã ïåðåêëàäà÷à, àäâîêàòà òà ³íøèõ âèòðàò, ïîâ'ÿçàíèõ ç ðîçãëÿäîì ñïðàâè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs157">Çã³äíî ñò. 48 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè âèòðàòè, ùî ï³äëÿãàþòü ñïëàò³ çà ïîñëóãè àäâîêàòà, âèçíà÷àþòüñÿ ó ïîðÿäêó, âñòàíîâëåíîìó Çàêîíîì Óêðà¿íè Ïðî àäâîêàòóðó. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs156">Â ÷àñòèí³ 1 ñòàòò³ 26 Çàêîíó Óêðà¿íè Ïðî àäâîêàòóðó òà àäâîêàòñüêó ä³ÿëüí³ñòü çàçíà÷åíî, ùî àäâîêàòñüêà ä³ÿëüí³ñòü çä³éñíþºòüñÿ íà ï³äñòàâ³ äîãîâîðó ïðî íàäàííÿ ïðàâîâî¿ äîïîìîãè. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs155">Ïîðÿäîê îá÷èñëåííÿ ãîíîðàðó (ô³êñîâàíèé ðîçì³ð, ïîãîäèííà îïëàòà), ï³äñòàâè äëÿ çì³íè ðîçì³ðó ãîíîðàðó, ïîðÿäîê éîãî ñïëàòè, óìîâè ïîâåðíåííÿ òîùî âèçíà÷àþòüñÿ â äîãîâîð³ ïðî íàäàííÿ ïðàâîâî¿ äîïîìîãè. Ïðè âñòàíîâëåíí³ ðîçì³ðó ãîíîðàðó âðàõîâóþòüñÿ ñêëàäí³ñòü ñïðàâè, êâàë³ô³êàö³ÿ ³ äîñâ³ä àäâîêàòà, ô³íàíñîâèé ñòàí êë³ºíòà òà ³íø³ ³ñòîòí³ îáñòàâèíè. Ãîíîðàð ìàº áóòè ðîçóìíèì òà âðàõîâóâàòè âèòðà÷åíèé àäâîêàòîì ÷àñ (÷.2,3 ñò.30 Çàêîíó Óêðà¿íè Ïðî àäâîêàòóðó òà àäâîêàòñüêó ä³ÿëüí³ñòü). Çàêîí íå ì³ñòèòü ³íøîãî ïîðÿäêó âèçíà÷åííÿ ðîçì³ðó êîøò³â çà ïîñëóãè àäâîêàòà. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps1"><FONT class="fs151">Âèòðàòè ïî îïëàò³ ñóäîâîãî çáîðó çà ðîçãëÿä àïåëÿö³éíî¿ ñêàðãè òà ïîçîâíî¿ çàÿâè íåîáõ³äíî ïîêëàñòè íà â³äïîâ³äà÷³â ïîð³âíó çã³äíî ïîëîæåíü ñò.49 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps3"><FONT class="fs150">Êåðóþ÷èñü, ñò. ñò. 43, 99, 101, 103, 104, 105 Ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ïðîöåñóàëüíîãî êîäåêñó Óêðà¿íè, Ëüâ³âñüêèé àïåëÿö³éíèé ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä - </FONT></P>
<P class="ps11"><FONT class="fs118">ÏÎÑÒÀÍÎÂÈÂ</FONT><FONT class="fs149"> :</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs148">Àïåëÿö³éíó ñêàðãó Òîâàðèñòâà ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ Ðèíîê ñ³ëüñüêîãîñïîäàðñüêî¿ ïðîäóêö³¿ Øóâàð çàäîâîëèòè ÷àñòêîâî.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs147">Ð³øåííÿ ãîñïîäàðñüêîãî ñóäó Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³ â³ä 24.03.2015ð. ó ñïðàâ³ ¹914/100/15 ñêàñóâàòè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs146">Ïðèéíÿòè íîâå ð³øåííÿ. Ïîçîâ çàäîâîëèòè ÷àñòêîâî. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs145">Âèçíàòè íåä³éñíèì äîãîâ³ð ïðî â³äñòóïëåííÿ ïðàâà âèìîãè â³ä 27.04.2012ð., óêëàäåíèé ì³æ Òîâàðèñòâîì ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ Ñîëñòðîé òà Òîâàðèñòâîì ç îáìåæåíîþ â³äïîâ³äàëüí³ñòþ Ñòàòóñáóä. </FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs141">Ì³ñöåâîìó ãîñïîäàðñüêîìó ñóäó âèäàòè â³äïîâ³äí³ íàêàçè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps3"><FONT class="fs140">Ñïðàâó ïîâåðíóòè â ãîñïîäàðñüêèé ñóä Ëüâ³âñüêî¿ îáëàñò³.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps6"><FONT class="fs139">Ïîñòàíîâà íàáèðàº çàêîííî¿ ñèëè ç äíÿ ¿¿ ïðèéíÿòòÿ ³ ìîæå áóòè îñêàðæåíà â êàñàö³éíîìó ïîðÿäêó çã³äíî ç Ðîçä³ëîì Õ²²-1 ÃÏÊ Óêðà¿íè.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps7"><FONT class="fs138">Ãîëîâóþ÷èé ñóääÿ                                                                       &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Çâàðè÷ Î.Â.</FONT></P>
<P class="ps4"><FONT class="fs137">ñóää³                                                                                           &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Õàá³á Ì.².</FONT></P>
<P><FONT class="fs136">                                                                                                     &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Þð÷åíêî ß.Î. </FONT></P>