ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION, WALES PART 1 General Title, application and commencement 1 The title of these Regulations is the Recycling, Preparation for Re-use and Composting Targets (Monitoring and Penalties) (Wales) Regulations 2011; they apply in relation to Wales and come into force on 30 March 2011. Interpretation 2 1 In these Regulations— “the Measure” (“ y Mesur ”) means the Waste (Wales) Measure 2010; “the targets” (“ y targedau ”) means the recycling, preparation for re-use and composting targets specified in section 3(3) of the Measure; “the Waste Framework Directive” (“ y Gyfarwyddeb Fframwaith Gwastraff ”) means Directive 2008/98/ EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives as last amended by Directive (EU) 2018/851 and read in accordance with paragraphs (3) to (8) ; “the WasteDataFlow system” (“ y system WasteDataFlow ”) means the web-based system for the reporting of municipal waste maintained and operated in Wales by the Natural Resources Body for Wales ; and “waste facility” (“ cyfleuster gwastraff ”) means a facility for the disposal or recovery of waste. For the purposes of this definition, “disposal” and “recovery” have the same meaning as in Article 3(15) and (19) of the Waste Framework Directive. 2 In these Regulations— a references to an amount of a local authority’s municipal waste are references to an amount of waste by tonnage; and b references to waste being sent by a local authority to a waste facility are to include references to waste being sent to such a facility in pursuance of arrangements made by the local authority. 3 A reference to one or more member States in a provision imposing an obligation or conferring a discretion on a member State or member States is to be read as a reference to the Welsh Ministers, the Natural Resources Body for Wales or local authority which, immediately before IP completion day (within the meaning given to that expression in the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020), was responsible for the United Kingdom's compliance with that obligation or able to exercise that discretion in respect of Wales. 4 Article 2 is to be read as if— a in paragraph 2— i in the words before point (a), for “other Community legislation” there were substituted “ assimilated law ” ; ii in points (b) and (c), for “Regulation (EC) No 1774/2002 ” there were substituted “ Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 ” ; iii in point (d), for the words from “Directive 2006/21/EC ” to the end there substituted “ the Mining Waste Directive (see regulation 2A) ” ; b in paragraph 3, the words from “Without prejudice” to “Community legislation,” were omitted; c paragraph 4 were omitted.(5) Article 5 is to be read as if paragraph 2 were omitted. 5 Article 5 is to be read as if— a in paragraph 1, for “Member States shall take appropriate measures to ensure that a” there were substituted “A”; b after paragraph 1 there were inserted— 1A Any decision as to whether a substance or object is a by-product must be made— a in accordance with any regulations setting out detailed criteria on the application of the conditions in paragraph 1 to specific substances or objects; and b having regard to any guidance published by the Welsh Ministers or the Natural Resources Body for Wales for the purposes of this Article. ; c paragraphs 2 and 3 were omitted. 6 Article 6 is to be read as if— a in paragraph 1, for “Member States shall take appropriate measures to ensure that waste” there were substituted “Waste”; b after paragraph 1 there were inserted— 1A Any decision as to whether a substance or object has ceased to be waste must be made— a in accordance with any regulations or assimilated direct legislation (within the meaning given to that expression in the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 setting out detailed criteria on the application of the conditions in paragraph 1 to specific types of waste; and b having regard to any guidance published by the Welsh Ministers or the Natural resources Body for Wales for the purposes of this Article. ; c in paragraph 2— i the first sub-paragraph were omitted; ii in the second sub-paragraph, for “Those detailed criteria” there were substituted “Any detailed criteria set out in guidance as referred to in paragraph 1A”; iii the third and fourth sub-paragraphs were omitted; d paragraph 3 were omitted; e in paragraph 4— i in the first sub-paragraph— aa in the first sentence, for the words from the beginning to “Member State”, there were substituted “Where criteria have not been set out as referred to in paragraph 1A(a), the Natural Resources Body for Wales”; bb the second sentence were omitted; ii in the second sub-paragraph— aa for “Member States” there were substituted “The Natural Resources Body for Wales”; bb “by competent authorities” were omitted. 7 Article 7 is to be read as if— a before paragraph 1 there were inserted— A1 In this Article, the “list of waste” means the list contained in the Annex to Commission Decision 2000/532/EC , as that list has effect in Wales. ; b in paragraph 1— i the first and second sentences were omitted; ii for the third sentence there were substituted “The list of waste shall, except as provided in Commission Decision 2000/532/EC , be binding as regards determination of the waste which is to be considered as hazardous waste or as non-hazardous waste.”; c paragraphs 2, 3, 6 and 7 were omitted. 8 Annex 3 is to be read as if, in entry HP 9, in the second sentence, “in the Member States” were omitted. Meaning of “the Mining Waste Directive” in regulation 2 2A 1 In regulation 2(4)(a)(iii), “ the Mining Waste Directive ” means Directive 2006/21/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the management of waste from extractive industries, read in accordance with subsections (2) to (4). 2 Article 2 is to be read as if— a in paragraph 2(c), the reference to Article 11(3)(j) of Directive 2000/60/EC were a reference to that Article read in accordance with subsection (4); b paragraphs 3 and 4 were omitted. 3 Article 3(1) is to be read as if, for “Article 1(a) of Directive 75/442/EC ” there were substituted “ Article 3(1) of the Waste Framework Directive, as read with Articles 5 and 6 of that Directive ” . 4 For the purposes of paragraph (2)(a), Article 11(3)(j) of Directive 2000/60/EC is to be read as if— a the first reference to “Member States” were a reference to the Welsh Ministers or the Natural Resources Body for Wales; b at the end, there were inserted— and “ environmental objectives ”, in relation to a river basin district within the meaning of the Water Environment (Water Framework Directive) (England and Wales) Regulations 2017 has the same meaning as in those Regulations. . PART 2 Monitoring Monitoring authority 3 1 The Natural Resources Body for Wales is the monitoring authority for the purposes of the targets. 2 The monitoring authority must— a monitor the performance of local authorities with respect to the targets: b monitor the performance of local authorities in complying with their obligations under these Regulations; c in accordance with regulation 7, validate the information that is entered by local authorities on the WasteDataFlow system; and d without delay notify the Welsh Ministers, in writing, of any case where it appears to the monitoring authority that a local authority is or may be liable to a penalty under section 3(7) of the Measure or under these Regulations. Obligation for local authorities to collect information and maintain records 4 1 A local authority must make arrangements for the collection of information that will allow the authority to comply with its requirements to maintain records under this regulation. 2 A local authority must maintain records containing the following information for each target financial year and each subsequent financial year until the next target financial year — a the total amount of its municipal waste ; b the total amount of municipal waste sent to each and every waste facility by the local authority; c the amount of material rejected at each successive stage of sorting of the municipal waste, at any and all waste facilities; and d the amount of material rejected under paragraph (c) that is disposed of by the local authority, or by a waste facility. 3 The record must contain details of— a the description of the waste in terms of its material type; b how each material type was collected; and c if an agent of the local authority collected the waste, the name of that agent. 4 The records must be kept for a period of three years beginning on the day they are first submitted using the WasteDataFlow system in accordance with regulation 5(2). 5 A local authority may maintain the records required by paragraph (2) in electronic form if the text is capable of being produced by the local authority in a visible and legible documentary form. 6 A local authority that fails to maintain the records required by paragraph (2) is liable to a penalty. 7 In this regulation, “sorting” means the act of separating individual recyclable materials from an amount of mixed waste or mixed materials. 8 In this regulation, municipal waste is “disposed of” when it undergoes a disposal operation of a type that is identified in Annex I of the Waste Framework Directive. Obligation for local authorities to provide information 5 1 During each target financial year and each subsequent financial year until the next target financial year, a local authority must submit to the monitoring authority returns containing all the information listed in regulations 4(2) and (3) (“the information”). 2 Each return must— a contain the information for the relevant 3 month period; b be made within one calendar month of the end of the relevant 3 month period; and c be submitted using the WasteDataFlow system. 3 The relevant 3 months periods are— a 1 April to 30 June; b 1 July to 30 September; c 1 October to 31 December; d 1 January to 31 March. 4 A local authority that fails to submit a return in accordance with this regulation is liable to a penalty. Power to require information 6 1 The Welsh Ministers, or the monitoring authority, may by notice served on a local authority, require that authority to— a produce for inspection, or for the removal for inspection elsewhere, any of the records that are required to be maintained under regulation 4; b supply information about or evidence as to matters connected with the local authority’s obligation to meet the targets and its obligations under these Regulations; 2 A local authority must comply with a notice served under paragraph (1) in the form and within such reasonable time as is specified in the notice. 3 Any notice served under this regulation must be in writing. 4 A local authority that fails to comply with the requirements of a notice is liable to a penalty. Validation by the monitoring authority 7 1 Within three months of the date required of a local authority to have submitted a return under regulation 5(2)(b), the monitoring authority must complete a validation of the information submitted by the local authority on the WasteDataFlow system. 2 If a local authority fails to submit a return in accordance with the timescale specified in regulation 5(2)(b), the monitoring authority must complete a validation of the information submitted by the local authority on the WasteDataFlow system within three months of the date on which the return is submitted. 3 In this regulation “validation” means— a a check that all local authorities have submitted data in accordance with their obligation to provide information under regulation 5; and b a reconciliation of any inaccurate or inconsistent data that has been submitted. Assessment of compliance with the targets 8 1 Within five calendar months of the end of each target financial year, and each subsequent financial year until the next target financial year, the monitoring authority must provide to the Welsh Ministers— a its monitoring information; and b a report containing the information set out in paragraph (3). 2 The monitoring information and the report must contain information covering the last financial year. 3 The report must contain the following information— a the total amount of municipal waste arising for each local authority; b the total amount of municipal waste validated by the monitoring authority that has been recycled, prepared for re-use, and composted; c the recycling, preparation for re-use and composting rates for each local authority; d the difference between the target amount for recycling, preparation for re-use and composting rates and the actual rate achieved by each local authority; and e the difference between the target amount for recycling, preparation for re-use and composting rates and the actual rate achieved by all the local authorities, taken as a whole. 4 In this regulation “monitoring information” means the information or evidence acquired by the monitoring authority in carrying out its functions under regulation 3(2). PART 3 Penalties Penalties: waiver 9 Where a local authority is liable to a penalty under section 3(7) of the Measure or under these Regulations, the Welsh Ministers may either waive the penalty, or assess the amount due by way of penalty and notify the local authority accordingly. Penalties: failure to meet a target 10 The amount of financial penalty to which a local authority is liable under section 3(7) of the Measure is £200 per tonne by which a local authority falls short of the target amount. Penalties: failure to comply with requirements of Part 2 11 A local authority is liable to a penalty of £1000 when it— a fails to maintain records in accordance with regulation 4; b fails to submit a return in accordance with regulation 5; c fails to comply with the requirements of a notice served under regulation 6. Penalties: general 12 1 Any penalty imposed by the Welsh Ministers is due one month after the date on which the local authority is notified by the Welsh Ministers of the amount of the penalty. 2 Where a local authority is liable to a penalty and does not pay the penalty by the date upon which it is due under paragraph (1), the local authority is liable to pay interest on the penalty for the period which— a begins on the date under paragraph (1); and b ends on the day before the date on which a penalty assessed is paid. 3 Interest under this regulation is payable at a rate of one percentage point above the LIBOR on a day to day basis. 4 For the purposes of paragraph (3), “LIBOR” means the sterling three month London interbank offered rate in force during the period between the date on which the penalty becomes due and the day before the date on which the penalty is paid to the Welsh Ministers. 5 Where a penalty has been assessed and notified to a local authority, the penalty and any interest incurred is recoverable as a civil debt. 6 For the purposes of this regulation, references to penalties include references to interest when payable. Jane Davidson Minister for Environment, Sustainability and Housing, one of the Welsh Ministers