corporation tax Introduction Citation, commencement and effect 1 1 These Regulations may be cited as the Oil Taxation (Market Value of Oil) Regulations 2006, and shall come into force on the day after that on which they are made. 2 These Regulations have effect in relation to the first new period, within the meaning of section 147(4)(b) of FA 2006 (commencement and transitional provisions for amendments to Schedule 3 to OTA by section 146 of, and Schedule 18 to, FA 2006) and subsequent periods. Interpretation 2 1 This paragraph gives the meaning of the abbreviated references used in these Regulations— “FA 2006” means the Finance Act 2006; “ ICTA ” means the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 ; and “OTA” means the Oil Taxation Act 1975. 2 This paragraph gives the meaning of other terms used in these Regulations— “bank holiday” means a day which is a bank holiday in England and Wales under the Banking and Financial Dealings Act 1971 ; “Category 1 oil” is oil of any of the kinds specified in regulation 3 ; “relevantly appropriated” has the meaning given by section 12(1) of OTA . 3 A sale of oil is at arm’s length if (but only if) it satisfies paragraph 1 of Schedule 3 to OTA . Category 1 oil 3 1 Category 1 oil is oil of any of the following kinds— a Brent blend; b Ekofisk blend; c Flotta blend; d Forties blend; e Statfjord oil. 2 In these Regulations— “Brent blend” means the blend of crude oils landed at Sullom Voe in Shetland via either the Brent or Ninian pipeline systems; “Ekofisk blend” means the blend of crude oils landed at the Teesside Oil Terminal at Seal Sands via the Norpipe pipeline; “Flotta blend” means the blend of crude oils landed at the Flotta Oil Terminal in Orkney and originating from the Flotta catchment area; “Forties blend” means the blend of crude oils landed at Cruden Bay, Aberdeenshire via the Forties pipeline system; “Statfjord oil” means oil to which article 23 of the Agreement between Her Majesty’s Government of the United Kingdom and Northern Ireland and the Government of the Kingdom of Norway relating to the exploitation of the Statfjord Field Reservoirs signed at Oslo on 16th October 1979 applies. Interpretation – reports and factors used in calculations 4 1 In these Regulations the terms defined in the following paragraphs, which relate to the way in which the market value of a Category 1 oil is determined, have the meanings given there. 2 “The relevant reports” means— a Argus Crude published by Argus Media Limited, whose registered office is Argus House, St. John Street London EC1V 4LW; b ICIS (the Independent Chemical Information Services’ World Crude Report), published by Reed Elsevier Group plc whose registered office is Quadrant House, The Quadrant, Sutton, Surrey, SM2 5AS; and c Platts Oilgram published by Platts, a division of the McGraw-Hill Companies, whose registered office is Two Penn Plaza, 25 th Floor, New York, N.Y. 10121-2298. 3 “The reference value” is the value quoted— a in the case of Argus Crude as “Dated BFO” in the section of the report entitled “Atlantic Basin Crudes, London 16.30 hours, North Sea”; b in the case of ICIS, as “Dated BFO” in the North Sea 3 rd Update; and c in the case of Platts Oilgram, as “Brent (DTD)” in the International section of the report. 4 “Adjustment factor” means the differential, upon the day in question, from the reference value— a found, in the case of Brent blend, in accordance with regulation 14 ; b for any other Category 1 oil, shown— i in the case of Argus Crude, in the report under “Atlantic Basin Crudes, London 16.30 hours North Sea”; ii in the case of ICIS, in North Sea 3 rd Update; and iii in the case of Platts Oilgram, as the assessment of the spread against forward dated Brent blend (described in the report as “spread vs fwd DTD Brent”). Scope General scope of these Regulations 5 These Regulations apply for the purpose of determining the market value of oil won from a field to which section 2(5)(b) or (c) of OTA applies and which is— a delivered, or relevantly appropriated, on or after 1st July 2006; or b held by a participator and not delivered at the end of a chargeable period. Valuing Category 1 oil General 6 The method of determining the market value of Category 1 oil to which these Regulations apply is as follows— a find the notional delivery day (see regulations 7 and 8); b find the average reference value for that day (see regulations 9 to 12); c add the adjustment factor (see regulations 13 to 15); and d find the total market value of the oil (see regulation 16). The notional delivery day: the general rule 7 1 The general rule is that the notional delivery day is found in accordance with paragraph 1A of Schedule 3 to OTA (determination of market value: notional delivery day for a quantity of oil). 2 The general rule is subject to regulation 8. The notional delivery day: additional rule 8 1 Paragraph (2) applies to a delivery of Category 1 oil by way of a sale otherwise than at arm’s length if— a during any period of 24 months, beginning on or after 1st July 2006, the total quantity of equity oil of that type disposed of by a participator and persons connected with him is not less than 4,000,000 barrels; b a lower price would fall to be taken into account in determining the participator’s gross profit under section 2(1) of OTA for the delivery from that which would have applied if it had been by way of a sale at arm’s length; c the reason for that lower price is because the notional delivery day is a day other than that on which the actual delivery takes place; d the whole or main benefit which might reasonably be expected to be obtained from a sale otherwise than at arm’s length, when compared with a sale at arm’s length, is a tax advantage within the meaning of section 709 of ICTA . 2 The notional delivery day is the day specified in paragraph (a) or (b) (as the case requires) of paragraph 1A(7) of Schedule 3 to OTA. 3 In this regulation— “barrel” means a volume of 0.158987 cubic metres of oil; and “equity oil” means oil forming part of the trading stock of a participator or a person connected with him which has been won by that participator or a person connected with him from a field in the United Kingdom sector of the North Sea. 4 Section 839 of ICTA (connected persons) applies for determining whether persons are connected for the purposes of this regulation. The average reference value: notional delivery day one for which reference values available 9 1 If the notional delivery day is a day for which reference values are available find the daily average of the reference values from each of the three relevant reports for— a each of the two dates immediately preceding the notional delivery day; b the notional delivery day; and c each of the two dates immediately following notional delivery day. 2 If any of the relevant reports contains more than one reference value for any of these dates, the result for that report for that date is the arithmetical mean of those values. 3 Find the average of the daily averages found for each of the five days referred to in paragraph (1). 4 The result is the average reference value for the notional delivery day. The average reference value: notional delivery day a Saturday, or a Bank Holiday which is not a Monday, and for which reference values not available 10 1 If the notional delivery day is not a day for which reference values are available but is a Saturday, or a bank holiday which is not a Monday, find the daily average of the reference values from each of the three relevant reports for— a each of the three business days immediately preceding the notional delivery day; and b each of the two business days immediately following the notional delivery day. 2 If any of the relevant reports contains more than one reference value for any of these dates, the result for that report for that date is the arithmetical mean of those values. 3 Find the average of the daily averages found for each of the five days referred to in paragraph (1). 4 The result is the average reference value for the notional delivery day. The average reference value: notional delivery day a Sunday, or a Bank Holiday which is a Monday 11 1 If the notional delivery day is not a day for which reference values are available but is a Sunday, or a bank holiday which is a Monday, find the daily average of the reference values from each of the three relevant reports for— a each of the two business days immediately preceding the notional delivery day; and b each of the three business days immediately following the notional delivery day. 2 If any of the relevant reports contains more than one reference value for any of these dates, the result for that report for that date is the arithmetical mean of those values. 3 Find the average of the daily averages found for each of the five days referred to in paragraph (1). 4 The result is the average reference value for the notional delivery day. The average reference value: additional provisions 12 1 If in respect of any of the days specified in a provision of regulation 9, 10 or 11 one or two of the relevant reports is not published, that provision has effect as if references to the relevant reports were to such of the relevant reports as are actually published in respect of that day. 2 If in respect of any of the days specified in a provision of regulation 9, 10 or 11 other than the notional delivery day, none of the relevant reports is published (“a non-publication day”), that provision has effect as if— a references to a day which is a non-publication day falling before the notional delivery day were to the day falling next before that day on which at least one of the relevant reports is published; and b references to a day which is a non-publication day falling after the notional delivery day were to the day falling next after that day on which at least one of the relevant reports is published. 3 If the application of the rule in paragraph (2) would lead to the reports for a day being taken into account more than once, a reference to the day falling next before, or after, the non-publication day shall be read as a reference to the first day falling next before or after (as the case may be) the non-publication day which would not otherwise be taken into account for the purposes of this regulation. 4 In cases where the date of completion of load or the date of the bill of lading is substituted for the notional delivery day under regulation 8 , references in this regulation to the notional delivery day are to be read as references to the day substituted under that regulation. The adjustment factors — general 13 1 The adjustment factor applicable to the Category 1 oil in question must be added to the average reference value. 2 The adjustment factor is found— a in accordance with regulation 14 in the case of Brent blend; and b in accordance with regulation 15 in the case of other Category 1 oil. Adjustment factor — Brent blend 14 1 The adjustment factor for Brent blend is found as follows. 2 Find the daily average of the differentials from the reference value quoted in the relevant reports for each of the days— a during the period which begins 21 days, and ends 14 days before the notional delivery day, and b in respect of which at least one such report is produced, as follows. 3 Find the Argus Crude differential for a particular day by taking the value shown as the “Brent” assessment and subtracting from it the value shown as “Dated BFO” in that report. 4 Find the ICIS differential for a particular day by taking the value shown as the “Brent” assessment and subtracting from it the value shown as “Dated BFO” in that report. 5 Find the Platts differential for a particular day by taking the value for “Brent Assessment 10 — 21 days out” in Platts Crude Oil Marketwire and subtracting from it the value for “North Sea Dated Strip” in that report. 6 In this regulation “Platts Crude Oil Marketwire” means the report of that name published by Platts, a division of the McGraw-Hill Companies, whose registered office is Two Penn Plaza, 25 th Floor, New York, N.Y. 10121-2298. 7 If any of the reports referred to in this regulation contains more than one value for the relevant quote for any of these days, the result for that report for that day is the arithmetical mean of those values. 8 Find the average of the daily averages found in accordance with this regulation for each of the days specified in paragraph (2). 9 The result is the adjustment factor for Brent blend. Adjustment factor — other Category 1 oil 15 1 The adjustment factor for a Category 1 oil other than Brent blend is found as follows. 2 Find the daily average of the differentials, from reference value, for the Category 1 oil in question quoted in the three relevant reports for each of the days— a during the period which begins 21 days, and ends 14 days before the notional delivery day, and b in respect of which at least one such report is produced. 3 If any of the relevant reports contains more than one value for the Category 1 oil in question for any of these days, the result for that report for that day is the arithmetical mean of those values. 4 Find the average of the daily averages found by paragraphs (2) and (3) for each of the days specified in paragraph (2). 5 The result is the adjustment factor for the relevant Category 1 oil. The total market value of the oil 16 1 The total market value of a volume of Category 1 oil to which these Regulations apply is found as follows— a take the average reference value for the notional delivery day (see regulations 9 to 12); b add the adjustment factor applicable to the Category 1 oil in question (see regulations 13 to 15); and c multiply the sum found by sub-paragraph (b) by the volume of Category 1 oil in question. 2 The result is the total market value of the oil. Valuing Category 2 oils Market value: Category 2 oils 17 The market value of a quantity of Category 2 oil to which these Regulations apply is found by whichever of the methods in regulation 18 (method 1) or regulations 19 to 23 (method 2) would produce a sum which more closely reflects the price which would normally apply in a sale at arm’s length for a similar quantity of that oil on the notional delivery day (found in accordance with paragraph 1A of Schedule 3 to OTA), but subject to the special rules in regulation 24. Method 1 18 The first method is to find the average unit price for actual sales at arm’s length of the relevant Category 2 oil under contracts meeting the conditions set out in paragraphs (a) to (e) of paragraph 2(2AA) of Schedule 3 to OTA . Method 2: general 19 The second method is as follows— a find the relevant reference oils (“the marker crudes”) for the relevant Category 2 oil (see regulation 20); b find the average marker crude price quoted in respect of the relevant Category 2 oil (see regulation 21); c adjust the average marker crude price (see regulation 22); d find the total market value of the oil (see regulation 23). Finding the relevant reference oils for the Category 2 oil in question 20 Ascertain which crude oils are normally used as marker crudes for the purposes of determining the market value of the relevant Category 2 oil under contracts at arm’s length. Finding the average marker crude price 21 1 Find the average of the prices quoted by the relevant reports for the sale of the marker crudes in respect of trades during the reference period in contracts for the sale at arm’s length of the relevant Category 2 oil. 2 In paragraph (1) “the reference period” means the period ordinarily used to find the market value of oils, by reference to which the price of the oil in question is determined, in a contract for the sale of that oil at arm’s length. Adjusting the average marker crude price 22 Add to the result of regulation 21 differential or combination of differentials normally applied in a contract for the sale at arm’s length of the relevant Category 2 oil. Total value of the Category 2 oil sold or relevantly appropriated 23 1 Multiply the result of regulation 22 by the volume of Category 2 oil to which these Regulations apply in the particular case. 2 The product so found is the market value of the Category 2 oil in question. 3 This is subject to regulation 24. Special rules 24 1 If a participator’s contracts for the sale of Category 2 oil in sales at arm’s length normally provide for the price to be determined— a in the case of oil transported by ship from the place of extraction to a place in the United Kingdom or elsewhere, by reference to the actual date of the completion of the load, or completion of the discharge, of the cargo; or b in the case of oil transported by pipeline to a place in the United Kingdom and loaded on to a ship there, by reference to the date of the bill of lading; references to the notional delivery day in regulation 17 are to be construed, in relation to that participator as references to the day mentioned in sub-paragraph (a) or (b) (as the case requires). 2 The modification in paragraph (1) also applies where Category 2 oil is loaded onto a ship at least 7 days later than the date provided for by the contract for sale by reason of circumstances wholly beyond the control of the parties. Paul Gray Mike Eland Two of the Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs 13th December 2006