Tribunals And Inquiries Citation, commencement and application 1 1 These Rules may be cited as the Infrastructure Planning (Examination Procedure) Rules 2010 and shall come into force on 1st March 2010. 2 Subject to paragraphs (3) to (5), these Rules apply to the examination of an application and specified matters by an Examining authority. 3 These Rules do not apply if the development to which the application relates (or part of the development) is the construction (other than by a gas transporter) of an oil or gas cross-country pipe-line— a one end of which is in England or Wales, and b the other end of which is in Scotland. 4 Parts 1 and 2 of the Schedule to these Rules apply where the Secretary of State has received a request for a direction to be given. 5 Parts 1 and 3 of the Schedule to these Rules apply instead of rules 3 to 23 to the examination of closed evidence where the Secretary of State has made a direction. Interpretation 2 1 In these Rules, unless otherwise defined in Part 1 of the Schedule to these Rules— “the 2008 Act ” means the Planning Act 2008; “accepted application” means an application that has been accepted under section 55 (acceptance of applications); “address” includes any number or address used for the purposes of electronic transmission; “affected person” means a person whose name has been given to the Commission in a notice under section 59 (notice of persons interested in land to which compulsory acquisition request relates); “application” means an application for development consent under section 37 (application for orders granting development consent) and includes— part of an application; any accompanying documents and further representations made by the applicant; and any amendments made to the application; “assessor” means a person appointed by the chair to the Commission to assist and advise the Examining authority in its examination of an application; “closed evidence” means any representation which is subject to a direction; “Commissioner” means a person appointed by the Secretary of State as a Commissioner ; “compulsory acquisition hearing” means a hearing held in accordance with section 92(3) (compulsory acquisition hearings); “compulsory acquisition request” means a request for an order granting development consent to authorise compulsory acquisition of land or of an interest in or right over land; “decision-maker”, in relation to an application for an order granting development consent— where the Council or the Secretary of State has the function of deciding the application, means the Council or (as the case may be) the Secretary of State; in any other case, means the Panel that has the function of deciding the application; “direction” means a direction given by the Secretary of State under paragraph 2(6) of Schedule 3; “electronic transmission” means a communication transmitted— by means of an electronic communications network; or by other means but in electronic form; “Examining authority” means— the Panel or single Commissioner appointed under section 65 (appointment of members, and lead member, of Panel) or section 79 (appointment of single Commissioner), and may include one or more members of the Panel allocated a function of the Panel in accordance with section 76 (allocation within Panel of Panel’s functions); or the Secretary of State, where the Secretary of State has the function of examining an application following a direction under section 112(1) (power of Secretary of State to intervene), and may include any person appointed by the Secretary of State to act on the Secretary of State’s behalf; “hearing” means an open-floor hearing, issue-specific hearing or compulsory acquisition hearing; “interested party”, in relation to an application, means a person who is an interested party for the purposes of Chapter 4 of Part 6 ; “issue-specific hearing” means a hearing held in accordance with section 91 (hearings about specific issues); “national policy statement” means a statement designated under section 5(1) (national policy statements); “open-floor hearing” means a hearing held in accordance with section 93 (open-floor hearings); “Panel” means the Panel appointed under section 65 (appointment of members, and lead member, of Panel) to handle the application; “preliminary meeting” means the meeting which the Examining authority is required to hold under section 88 (initial assessment of issues, and preliminary meeting); “procedural decision”, in relation to an application, means a decision about how the application is to be examined; “representation” includes evidence and references to the making of a representation include the giving of evidence; “single Commissioner” means the Commissioner appointed under section 79 (appointment of single Commissioner) to handle the application; “specified matters”, in relation to the application, means the matters specified in relation to that application in the Secretary of State’s direction under section 113(3)(a) (effect of intervention); “statement of common ground” means a written statement prepared jointly by the applicant and any interested party, which contains agreed factual information about the application; and “written representation” means the full particulars of the case which a person puts forward in respect of an application and includes any supporting evidence or documents. 2 Any reference in these Rules to a section, Part or Schedule by number is a reference to a section or Part of, or a Schedule to, so numbered in the 2008 Act. Relevant representations, etc. 3 1 An interested party must ensure that their relevant representation is received by the Commission by whichever is the later of— a the deadline notified under section 56(4) (notifying persons of accepted applications) or b the deadline for receipt of representations included in the notice published in accordance with section 56(8). 2 Any interested party who submits a written comment on any relevant representation must ensure that it is received by the Commission by whichever is the later of— a the date on which the preliminary meeting is held; or b the date specified in the timetable referred to in rule 8. 3 The Commission may require in writing any person who has submitted a relevant representation or written comment to provide— a a specified number of additional copies of the representation or comment; and b such further information about the matters contained in the representation or comment as the Commission may specify, and may specify the date by which the copies or information must be received by it. 4 Any person required to provide additional copies or further information must ensure that the additional copies or further information have been received by the Commission by the date specified. 5 As soon as practicable after receipt of any relevant representations, written comments on relevant representations or further information requested under paragraph (4)(b) the Commission must make the representations, comments or information available in accordance with rule 21. Notice of appointment of a Panel or a single Commissioner 4 1 Where the Examining authority is a Panel or a single Commissioner, the chair must, before the preliminary meeting, notify all those who in accordance with section 56(2) (notifying persons of accepted applications) have been notified of an accepted application, that the Examining authority has been appointed and give details of who has been appointed. 2 Where— a a single Commissioner has been appointed as the Examining authority in relation to an application; and b the chair subsequently decides that the Examining authority should be a Panel, the chair must notify all those who were notified in accordance with paragraph (1), and any other interested party, of the chair’s decision. 3 The chair must notify all those who were notified in accordance with paragraph (1), and any other interested party, of— a any change in the membership of the Panel or appointment of any replacement single Commissioner in accordance with section 82 (appointment of replacement single Commissioner); and b any direction given by the Secretary of State under section 112(1). Initial assessment of issues 5 The Examining authority shall make its initial assessment under section 88(1) (initial assessment of issues, and preliminary meeting) within the period of 21 days that begins with the day after the day notified under section 56 (notifying persons of accepted application) as the deadline for the receipt of representations. Notice of preliminary and other meetings 6 1 The Examining authority must give at least 21 days’ notice of the date, time and place of the meeting required by section 88(2) (in these Rules, “the preliminary meeting”), to all those whom it is required by section 88(3) to invite to the preliminary meeting, and to any other person it chooses to invite. 2 The Examining authority must, at the same time as giving notice of the preliminary meeting, notify all those invited to it of the matters to be discussed at the preliminary meeting. 3 Where the Examining authority holds any other meeting for the purposes of the examination to which these Rules apply, it shall arrange for such notice to be given of that meeting as appears to the authority to be necessary. Preliminary meeting 7 1 The Examining authority shall preside at the preliminary meeting and shall determine— a the procedure at the preliminary meeting; b the matters to be discussed; c the amount of time to be allocated— i to each matter; and ii allowed for making any oral representations. 2 As soon as practicable after the end of the preliminary meeting, the Examining authority must prepare a note of the proceedings, and make the note available in accordance with rule 21 to all interested parties and anyone who attended the preliminary meeting. Timetable 8 1 At the preliminary meeting, or as soon as practicable after the end of that meeting, the Examining authority must set the timetable for its examination of the application or specified matters, specifying in the timetable— a the date by which written representations must be received by the Examining authority; b the period within which the Examining authority will ask questions in writing and seek further written information about— i any matter contained in the application, specified matters or a relevant representation; ii any written representation; and iii any other matter it considers relevant to its examination of the application or specified matters; c the period within which the applicant will have the opportunity to comment in writing on— i any relevant or written representations; and ii any responses to written questions received from an interested party or others; d the period within which any interested party will have the opportunity to comment in writing on— i any relevant and written representations; and ii any responses to written questions received from an interested party or others; e the period within which the applicant and any interested party must agree a statement of common ground; f the date by which any interested party must notify the Examining authority of their wish to be heard at an open-floor hearing; g the date by which any affected person must notify the Examining authority of their wish to be heard at a compulsory acquisition hearing; h the date of any issue-specific hearing; i the date by which any summaries of relevant and written representations must be received by the Examining authority; j the date by which any local impact report must be received by the Commission and the period within which an interested party will have the opportunity to make written comments on that report; and k such other deadlines as the Examining authority considers necessary. 2 The Examining authority must send the timetable to all interested parties and any other person it has invited to the preliminary meeting. 3 The Examining authority may subsequently vary the timetable; and as soon as practicable after doing so it must notify the variation to all interested parties and any other person it has invited to the preliminary meeting. Notice of procedural decisions 9 As soon as practicable after making any procedural decision, the Examining authority must notify all interested parties of the decision. Written representations 10 1 An interested party must ensure that any written representation that party may wish to make is received by the Examining authority by the date specified in the timetable set under rule 8, or otherwise under this rule, by the Examining authority. 2 The Examining authority may at any time specify the date (being a date not earlier than the end of a period of 21 days) by which a written representation to be submitted from an interested party must be received by the Examining authority. 3 The Examining authority may permit a written representation to be made by any person who is not an interested party. 4 Any person, other than the applicant, who submits a written representation, must identify in their written representation those parts of the application or specified matters with which they agree and those parts with which they do not agree, and must state the reasons for such disagreement. 5 The Examining authority must provide all interested parties with the opportunity to comment in writing on any written representation relevant to the examination of the application or specified matters. 6 The Examining authority may in writing request— a a specified number of additional copies of any representation; b responses to questions posed by the Examining authority about the matters contained in any representation; and c such further information about the matters contained in any representation as the Examining authority may specify; and shall specify the date by which these must be received by it. 7 Any person who receives a request in accordance with paragraph (6) above must ensure that the additional copies, responses to written questions or further information are received by the Examining authority by the date specified. 8 The Examining authority may disregard any written representations, responses to questions or further information received after the date, or the expiry of the period, specified for their receipt. 9 The Examining authority must make all written representations, responses to written questions and further information received by it available in accordance with rule 21 as soon as is practicable . Appointment of assessor 11 The Examining authority must notify all interested parties of the name of any assessor, appointed under section 100 (assessors), and of the particular matters on which the assessor is to assist the Examining authority. Appointment of barrister, solicitor or advocate 12 The Examining authority must notify all interested parties if a barrister, solicitor or advocate is appointed under section 101 (legal advice and assistance) give details of who has been appointed. Notification of hearings 13 1 In fixing, and causing persons to be informed of, a deadline under section 92(2) (compulsory acquisition hearing) or 93(1) (open-floor hearing), the Examining authority must ensure that the deadline is at least 21 days after the date on which notice of the deadline is given. 2 The Examining authority may disregard any request for an open-floor hearing or for a compulsory acquisition hearing to be held which is received after the deadline. 3 As soon as practicable after the expiry of the deadline the Examining authority must notify— a all interested parties of the date, time and place fixed for any open-floor hearing or issue-specific hearing; and b affected persons of the date, time and place fixed for a compulsory acquisition hearing, and ensure that at least 21 days’ notice is given of any hearing. 4 The Examining authority may vary the date, time and place fixed for any hearing and must give such notice of any variation as appears to it to be reasonable. 5 The place at which a hearing is to be held shall be determined by the Examining authority in consultation with the applicant and, where the Examining authority is satisfied, having regard to the nature of the application, that it is reasonable to do so, the Examining authority may direct that different parts of a hearing shall be held at different locations. 6 Unless the Examining authority otherwise directs, the applicant must not later than 21 days before the date fixed for the commencement of a hearing— a post and maintain a notice of the hearing in a conspicuous place or (in the case of an application for an order making provision for land-based linear works more than 5 kilometres in length) at intervals of not more than 5 kilometres on, or as close as is reasonably practicable to, the land to which the application relates; b post and maintain a notice of the hearing in one or more places where public notices are usually posted in the area to which the proposals contained in the application relate; and c publish a notice of the hearing by local advertisement in the area in which the proposals contained in the application are to have effect. 7 In this rule “by local advertisement” means— a by publication of the notice in a newspaper circulating in the locality in which the land to which the application relates is situated; and b where the Examining authority maintains a website for the purpose of advertisement of applications, by publication of the notice on the website. 8 Where a direction has been given under paragraph (5), paragraph (6) shall have effect with the substitution— a for references to the hearing, of references to the part of the hearing which is to be held at a place specified in the direction; and b for references to the application, of references to that part of the application which is to be the subject of that part of the hearing. 9 Any notice posted pursuant to paragraph (6)(a) or (b) must be readily visible to and legible by members of the public; but where, without any fault or intention of the applicant, the notice is removed, obscured or defaced before the commencement of the hearing, the applicant shall be treated as having complied with the requirements of those sub-paragraphs if the applicant has taken reasonable steps for the protection of the notice and, if need be, its replacement. 10 A notice of a hearing posted or published pursuant to paragraph (6) must contain a statement of the date, time and place of the hearing, and of the section of the 2008 Act under which the application has been made, together with a description of the proposals contained in the application sufficient to identify the location of the proposed development with or without reference to a specified map, and details of a place where a copy of the application can be inspected. Procedure at hearings 14 1 The Examining authority shall preside at any hearing and shall determine the procedure at the hearing. 2 At the start of the hearing the Examining authority shall identify the matters to be considered at the hearing, and any matters on which the Examining authority requires further explanation from— a the persons entitled under section 91(3), 92(4) or 93(3) to make oral representations; or b the persons permitted under rule 14(10) to make oral representations. 3 Any oral representations must be based on either the relevant or written representations made by the person by whom or on whose behalf the oral representations are made; and where those relevant or written representations exceed 1500 words the person by whom they were made must prepare a summary. 4 Without prejudice to the Examining authority’s discretion as to the conduct of the hearing, nothing in paragraph (2) or (3) precludes a person from referring to issues which they consider relevant to the examination of an application or specified matters but which are not issues identified by the Examining authority pursuant to paragraph (2) or included in their relevant or written representations. 5 The Examining authority shall be responsible for the oral questioning of a person giving evidence (“A”) except where, in the view of the Examining authority, oral questioning of A by another person (“B”) is necessary in order to ensure— a adequate testing of any representation; or b that B has a fair chance to put B’s case. 6 The Examining authority may refuse to permit the oral questioning of persons giving evidence, or may require such questioning to cease, if it appears to the Examining authority that permitting such questioning or allowing it to continue (as the case may be) would have the effect that the timetable referred to in rule 8 could not be met. 7 The Examining authority may proceed with a hearing in the absence of a person entitled to appear at it. 8 The Examining authority may from time to time adjourn a hearing and, if the date, time and place of the adjourned hearing are announced at the hearing before the adjournment, no further notice shall be required. 9 Any person entitled or permitted to make oral representations at a hearing may do so on that person’s own behalf or be represented by any other person. 10 The Examining authority may permit any person, in addition to those who are entitled under section 91(3), 92(4) or 93(3), to make oral representations at a hearing. Hearings 15 1 Where the Examining authority is a Panel, it may hold any two or more hearings relating to the same application concurrently; and where it does so and decides to allocate functions under section 76 (allocation within the Panel of the Panel’s functions), it must notify all interested parties of the details of the allocation. 2 The Examining authority may consider all compulsory acquisition requests relating to the same application at the same compulsory acquisition hearing or at separate compulsory acquisition hearings. Site inspections 16 1 The Examining authority may make an unaccompanied inspection of any site to which the application or specified matters relate before or during its examination of the application or specified matters without giving notice of its intention. 2 The Examining authority may, before the completion of its examination of the application or specified matters, inspect any site to which the application or specified matters relate in the company of any interested party or their representative. 3 Where the Examining authority intends to make an inspection of the kind referred to in paragraph (2), it must notify all interested parties of the date, time and place at which it proposes to make the inspection. 4 The Examining authority shall not be bound to defer an inspection of the kind referred to in paragraph (2) where an interested party is neither present nor represented at the time appointed. Further information 17 1 The Examining authority may at any time before the completion of its examination of an application or specified matters request further information or written comments from an interested party, who must supply such information by the date and in the manner specified by the Examining authority. 2 The Examining authority shall on receiving any further information or written comments within the specified period, consider whether or not a further opportunity to comment in writing should be given to all interested parties and, if so, the Examining authority shall specify a period for making any further written comments. 3 The Examining authority and the decision-maker may disregard any information or written comments received after the date specified or in a manner other than that specified. Additional copies 18 1 The Examining authority may at any time before the completion of its examination of an application request from any interested party additional copies of any document sent to the Examining authority during the examination and specify the period within which and the manner in which the copies are to be supplied. 2 The interested party must supply the copies within the period and in the manner specified by the Examining authority. Procedure after completion of examination 19 1 Where the Examining authority does not have the function of deciding an application, after the completion of its examination it must make a written report to the decision-maker. 2 The report must include the Examining authority’s— a findings and conclusions in respect of the application and any specified matters; and b recommendation as to the decision to be made on the application. 3 If after the completion of the Examining authority’s examination, the decision-maker— a differs from the Examining authority on any matter of fact mentioned in, or appearing to the decision-maker to be material to, a conclusion reached by the Examining authority; or b takes into consideration any new evidence or new matter of fact, and is for that reason disposed to disagree with a recommendation made by the Examining authority, the decision-maker shall not come to a decision which is at variance with that recommendation without— i notifying all interested parties of the decision-maker’s disagreement and the reasons for it; and ii giving them an opportunity of making representations in writing to the decision-maker in respect of any new evidence or new matter of fact. 4 Rule 10 shall apply to any representation in writing made in response to the opportunity given under paragraph (3) subject to the following modifications— a for “Examining authority” there shall be substituted “decision-maker”; b for “written representation” there shall be substituted “representation in writing”; and c paragraphs (2) and (4) shall not apply . Procedure following quashing of decision 20 1 Where a decision of the Council or a Panel in respect of an application is quashed in proceedings before any court, the chair of the Commission— a shall send to all interested parties a written statement of the matters with respect to which further representations in writing are invited for the purposes of the decision-maker’s further consideration of the application; b shall give all interested parties the opportunity of making representations in writing to the decision-maker in respect of those matters or of requesting a hearing, or if a hearing has been held, of requesting it to be re-opened. 2 Where a decision of the Secretary of State in respect of an application is quashed in proceedings before any court, the Secretary of State— a shall send to all interested parties a written statement of the matters with respect to which further representations in writing are invited for the purposes of the Secretary of State’s further consideration of the application; b shall give all interested parties the opportunity of making representations in writing to the Secretary of State in respect of those matters. Availability and inspection of representations and documents 21 1 Relevant representations, written representations or documents must be made available by the Commission to all interested parties and to anyone who requests an opportunity to inspect and take copies of them. 2 A relevant representation, written representation or document shall be taken to be available where all interested parties are notified of— a publication of the relevant document on a website; b the address of the website; c the place on the website where the representation or document may be accessed, and how it may be accessed; d details of where and when copies of representations and documents may be inspected; e details of where and when representations and documents may be copied; and f whether a charge will be made for copies of any representation or document available for inspection and if so the amount of any charge. 3 Where the applicant or an interested party is under an obligation to give to any person who so requests an opportunity to inspect and take copies of any representation or document, the opportunity shall be taken to have been given where that person is notified of— a publication of the relevant representation or document on a website; b the address of the website; c the place on the website where the representation or document may be accessed, and how it may be accessed; d details of where and when copies of the representation or document may be inspected; e details of where and when any representation or document may be copied; f whether a charge will be made for copies of any representation or document available for inspection and if so the amount of any charge. 4 In this rule “document” means any notice, report or other document required or authorised to be sent or prepared under these Rules or under the 2008 Act Form and service of notices etc. 22 1 Where under any provision of these Rules a person is required to notify another person or body of something, that notification must be in writing. 2 Any representation, notice or other document required or authorised to be sent under any provision of these Rules may be sent— a by sending it by post, addressed to that person at that person’s usual or last known place of abode, or in a case where an address for service has been given by that person, at that address; b by sending it in a prepaid registered letter, or by recorded delivery service addressed to that person at that person’s usual or last known place of residence, or in a case where an address for service has been give by that person, at that address; or c subject to paragraphs (3) to (6), by electronic transmission to such address as may for the time being be specified by the person for that purpose. 3 Where a representation, notice or other document required to be sent for any purpose of these Rules is sent by electronic transmission, the requirement shall be taken to be fulfilled where the recipient of the representation, notice or other document has consented, either in writing or by electronic transmission, to the use of electronic transmission. 4 Where the recipient of a representation, notice or other document served or sent by electronic transmission notifies the sender within 7 days of receipt that the recipient requires a paper copy of all or any part of that representation, notice or other document, the sender must provide such a copy as soon as is reasonably practicable. 5 A person may revoke their consent to the use of electronic transmission for any purpose of these Rules by giving notice to that effect in writing or by electronic transmission, specifying the purpose for which electronic transmission may not be used and the date on which revocation is to take effect, being not less that 7 days after the date on which the notice is given. 6 A revocation under paragraph (5) shall take effect on the date specified in the notice. Allowing further time 23 The Commission or the Examining authority may at any time and in any particular case allow further time for the taking of any step which must or may be taken by virtue of these Rules. Closed evidence not to be disclosed 24 Nothing in these Rules shall be taken to require or permit closed evidence to be disclosed to a person other than— a the Secretary of State; b the parties; or c a person of any description specified in a direction. Signed by authority of the Lord Chancellor Bridget Prentice Parliamentary Under Secretary of State Department for Justice 21st January 2010