Sheriff Court Citation and commencement, etc. 1 1 This Act of Sederunt may be cited as the Act of Sederunt (Proceedings for Determination of Compatibility Questions Rules) 2024. 2 It comes into force on 16th July 2024. 3 A certified copy is to be inserted in the Books of Sederunt. Interpretation 2 1 In this Act of Sederunt— “ the 2024 Act ” means the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024; “ compatibility question ” has the meaning given by section 31(1) of the 2024 Act; “ initiating document ” means the initial writ, summons, petition or other document by which the proceedings are initiated; “ relevant authority ” means the Commissioner for Children and Young People in Scotland, the Lord Advocate and the Scottish Commission for Human Rights. 2 Any reference in this Act of Sederunt to a numbered Form is a reference to the Form so numbered in schedule 1 of this Act of Sederunt. Proceedings for determination of a compatibility question 3 Where the initiating document contains an averment or crave which raises a compatibility question, the initiating document must include a crave for warrant to intimate it to the relevant authority, unless it is a party to the action. Time for raising compatibility question 4 It is not competent for a party to any proceedings to raise a compatibility question after proof is commenced, unless the sheriff, on cause shown, otherwise determines. Specification of compatibility question 5 1 Any party raising a compatibility question must specify— a where the party initiates the action, in the initiating document; b in the written defences or answers; or c in any other case, in Form 1, the facts or circumstances and contentions of law on the basis of which it is alleged that the compatibility question arises in sufficient detail to enable the sheriff to determine whether such a question arises in the proceedings. 2 Where a party wishes to raise a compatibility question after lodging any document mentioned in paragraph (1), the party must do so— a by way of adjustment or minute of amendment; or b in proceedings in which there is no procedure for adjustment or amendment, in Form 1, so as to provide specification of the matters mentioned in that paragraph. Intimation of compatibility question 6 1 Intimation of a compatibility question must be given to the relevant authority (unless it is a party to the proceedings) in accordance with this rule. 2 Where the compatibility question is raised in the initiating document, the sheriff is to order intimation of the compatibility question as craved in the warrant for service. 3 In any case other than that described in paragraph (2), the party raising the compatibility question must lodge a motion or incidental application, as the case may be, craving a warrant for intimation of the compatibility question on the relevant authority, and on considering the motion or incidental application, where it appears to the sheriff that a compatibility question arises, the sheriff is to order such intimation of the compatibility question. 4 Where intimation is ordered in accordance with paragraphs (2) or (3), such intimation must be in Form 2 and be made in such manner as the sheriff considers appropriate in the circumstances. 5 The intimation of a compatibility question must specify 14 days, or such other period as the sheriff thinks fit, as the period within which the relevant authority may take part as a party in the proceedings. 6 Where, after determination at first instance of any proceedings in which a compatibility question has been raised under this Act of Sederunt, a party to those proceedings appeals to the Sheriff Appeal Court in accordance with Chapter 6 of the Act of Sederunt (Sheriff Appeal Court Rules) 2021 , that party must, unless the relevant authority is already a party to the proceedings, intimate the note of appeal to the relevant authority, together with a notice in Form 2A. Response to intimation of compatibility question 7 1 This rule applies where the relevant authority receives intimation of a compatibility question. 2 Where the relevant authority intends to take part as a party in the proceedings, it must lodge a minute stating that it intends to do so. 3 Upon receipt of the minute lodged in accordance with paragraph (2), the sheriff is to sist the relevant authority as a party to the action. 4 Upon the relevant authority being sisted as a party in accordance with paragraph (3), the sheriff is to order the relevant authority to lodge a note of its written submissions in respect of the compatibility question specifying those matters mentioned in rule 5(1) within 7 days, or such other period as the sheriff thinks fit. 5 A copy of the minute lodged in accordance with paragraph (2) and a copy of any note lodged in accordance with paragraph (4) must, at the same time as lodging the minute or any note, be intimated by the party lodging such to all other parties in the proceedings. 6 At any time after the note mentioned in paragraph (4) has been lodged, the sheriff may regulate such further procedure in the proceedings as the sheriff thinks fit. 7 Where a relevant authority does not take part as a party in the proceedings at first instance, the court may allow it to take part as a party in any subsequent appeal to the Sheriff Appeal Court. Reference to Inner House or Supreme Court 8 1 This rule applies where— a any reference of a compatibility question is made to the Inner House of the Court of Session under section 35(1) of the 2024 Act; or b the sheriff is required by the Lord Advocate to refer a compatibility question to the Supreme Court under section 36 of the 2024 Act. 2 Where a reference is made in accordance with paragraph (1), the sheriff is to pronounce an interlocutor giving directions about the manner and time in which the reference is to be drafted and adjusted. 3 When the reference has been drafted and adjusted in accordance with paragraph (2), the sheriff is to sign the reference. 4 The reference must— a include such matters as are prescribed in schedule 2 of this Act of Sederunt; b have annexed to it the interlocutor making the reference and any other order of the court in the cause. 5 The sheriff clerk must send a copy of the reference by first class recorded delivery post to— a the parties to the proceedings; b the relevant authority (if it is not already a party), and must certify on the back of the principal reference that a copy has been sent and to whom. 6 In this rule “ first class recorded delivery post ” means a postal service which seeks to deliver documents or other things by post no later than the next working day in all or the majority of cases and which provides for the delivery of the document or other thing by post to be recorded. Sist of cause on reference to Inner House or Supreme Court 9 On a reference being made in accordance with rule 8, the cause must, unless the sheriff when making the reference otherwise orders, be sisted until the compatibility question has been determined. Interim orders 10 1 Notwithstanding the reference of a compatibility question to the Inner House of the Court of Session or to the Supreme Court in accordance with rule 8, the sheriff has power to make any interim order which a due regard to the interests of the parties may require. 2 The sheriff may recall a sist under rule 9 for the purpose of making the interim order mentioned in paragraph (1). Transmission of reference 11 1 The sheriff clerk must forthwith transmit the principal copy of the reference, as the case may be, to— a the Deputy Principal Clerk of the Court of Session; or b together with 7 copies, the Registrar of the Supreme Court. 2 Unless the sheriff otherwise directs, the principal copy of the reference must not be transmitted in accordance with paragraph (1) where an appeal against the making of the reference is pending. 3 For the purpose of paragraph (2), an appeal is to be treated as pending either— a until the expiry of the time for making that appeal; or b where an appeal has been made, until that appeal has been determined. Procedure following determination on reference or appeal 12 1 This rule applies where either the Inner House of the Court of Session or the Supreme Court has determined— a a compatibility question referred to it in accordance with rule 8; or b an appeal made to it. 2 Upon receipt of the determination of the Inner House of the Court of Session or the Supreme Court, as the case may be, the sheriff clerk must immediately place before the sheriff a copy of the determination and the court process. 3 The sheriff— a of the sheriff’s own motion, may; or b upon the lodging of a motion or incidental application by any of the parties to the proceedings, is to, pronounce an interlocutor ordering such further procedure as may be required. 4 Where the sheriff of the sheriff’s own motion pronounces an interlocutor in accordance with paragraph (3), the sheriff clerk must immediately intimate a copy of the interlocutor to all parties in the proceedings. CJM SUTHERLAND Lord President I.P.D. Edinburgh 27th June 2024