Lok Sabha Question No. 673 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2015-12-02
Subject: Cancellation of Land allotments to Hospitals
Ministry: URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Asked by: SAUGATA ROY

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

## MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT LOK SABHA

## UNSTARRED QUESTION NO.673

## TO BE ANSWERED ON DECMEBER 02, 2015 CANCELLATION OF LAND ALLOTMENTS TO HOSPITALS

No.673

PROF. SAUGATA ROY:

Will the Minister of URBAN DEVELOPMENT be pleased to state:

- a) the names of the allottees, who got land on subsidized rates for construction of hospitals in Delhi;
- b) whether there is mechanism to verify the functioning of hospitals as per the lease deed; and
- c) the  details  of  action  taken  so  far  to  cancel  the  land allotments to various hospitals on failing to comply with the  Supreme  Court's  order  to  provide  free  treatment  to the  eligible  category  of  economically  weaker  section patients?

## ANSWER

## THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT

## (SHRI BABUL SUPRIYO)

- a) :The names of the allottees, who got land on concessional rates  for  construction  of  hospitals  in  Delhi  from  Land  and Development Office are enclosed at Annexure-A.

As per DDA, no allotment has been made on subsidized rates  to  hospitals.  However,  before  2006,  DDA  used  to make allotment on Current Zonal Variant Rates which is above the concessional rates and below to market rate. The list  of  allotments  made  to  the  Private  Societies  for construction of hospitals by DDA is enclosed as Annexure-B.

Cont.p/2…

- b) The  functioning  of  hospitals  is  examined  as  per  the  lease terms and conditions through inspection from time to time.
- c) While land is allotted to private hospitals in Delhi by Land & Development Office and DDA, the monitoring regarding free treatment  to  the  patients  belonging  to  EWS  category  is within  the  jurisdiction  of  Govt.  of  NCT  of  Delhi.  The  State Government  has  constituted  Monitoring  Committee  as  per the directions of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi & the Supreme Court of India in this regard.

In case of both Land & Development Office and DDA, for those hospitals who have agreed to comply the Hon'ble Supreme  Court's  order  to  provide  free  treatment  to  the eligible category of EWS patients, no such report from the State Government has been reported in recent past.

However,  out  of  6  hospitals  to  whom  land  has  been allotted  by  Land  &  Development  Office  on  subsidized rates,  two  hospitals,  namely,  St.  Stephen  Hospital  and Moolchand Kharaiti Ram Hospital have ab-initio failed to comply with the order citing that this was not mentioned in  their  lease  deed.  These  hospitals  filed  Writ  Petition before  the  Hon'ble  High  Court.  The  Hon'ble  High  Court passed  the  order  dated  28.4.2014  ordering  that,  such objective has to be achieved within the framework of the Constitution through the route of   legislation, the route taken by the respondent doesn't accord with the Constitution. Therefore, against this order the Department has filed SLPs in the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in this regard.

………

Annexure A - referred to in reply to Lok Sabha Un-starred Question No. 673 for 02.12.2015 regarding Cancellation of Land Allotments to Hospitals.

|   Sl. No. | Name of the Hospital and Location                                                      |
|-----------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|         1 | Sir Ganga Ram Hospital at Rajinder Nagar                                               |
|         2 | Veerawali International Hospital (Delhi Hospital Society/ PRIMUS-ORTHO at Chanakyapuri |
|         3 | Dr. Vidyasagar Kaushalaya Devi Memorial Trust (VIMHANS) at Nehru Nagar                 |
|         4 | Moolchand Kharaiti Ram Hospitali at Lajpat Nagar                                       |
|         5 | St. Stephen's Hospital near Tis Hazari                                                 |
|         6 | A strip of land to R.B Seth Jessa Ram Hospital at Karol Bagh                           |

Annexure B -referred to in reply to Lok Sabha Question No. 673 for

## 02.12.2015 regarding Cancellation of Land Allotments to Hospitals

|   Sl.No | NAME OF SOCIETY/HOSPITALS                                           | LOCATION               |
|---------|---------------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------|
|       1 | B. R. Jesa Ram Hospital                                             | Karol Bagh             |
|       2 | Dr. B.L Kapoor Memorial Hospital                                    | Pusa Road              |
|       3 | Delhi Cheshire Home (Hospital for Disabled Person)                  | Okhla                  |
|       4 | Sunder Lal Jain Charitable Trust                                    | Ashok Vihar            |
|       5 | Asthma & Bronchitis Foundation ( Delhi University)                  | Gautam Nagar           |
|       6 | Aishi Ram Batra Public Charitable Trust                             | Tughalakabad           |
|       7 | Gujarmal Modi Hospital & Research Centre                            | Saket                  |
|       8 | Mata Chanan Devi Eye Hospital                                       | Jankapuri              |
|       9 | Amar Jyoti Charitable Trust                                         | Karkardooma            |
|      10 | Flt. Lt. Rajan Dhall Charitable Trust                               | Masood Pur             |
|      11 | Mahasati Mohan Devi Jain Shikshan Samiti (Bhagwan Mahavir Hospital) | Sector - IX, Rohini    |
|      12 | Khosla Medical Institute & Research Centre                          | Shalimar Bagh          |
|      13 | Birla Centre for Medical Research                                   | Vasant Vihar           |
|      14 | Jaipur Golden Charitable Trust                                      | Sector - III, Rohini   |
|      15 | Deepak Gupta Memorial Charitable Foundation                         | Karkardooma            |
|      16 | All India Society for Health And Education Research                 | Mayur Vihar Phase - II |
|      17 | Ganesh Das Chawala Charitable Trust                                 | Rohini                 |
|      18 | Mai Kamali Wali Jan Kalyan Charitable Trust                         | Rajouri Garden         |
|      19 | Parmarath Mission Hospital                                          | Pitampura              |
|      20 | Mukand Lal Memorial Foundation                                      | Karkardooma            |
|      21 | Lala Gela Ram Memorial Medical Research Centre (Dental Hospital)    | Pitampura              |
|      22 | V.N. Gupta Charitable Trust                                         | Pitampura              |
|      23 | Indian Spinal Injuries Centre                                       | Vasant Kunj            |
|      24 | Foundation of Applied Research in Cancer                            | South of I.I.T Delhi   |
|      25 | Dharamshila Cancer Foundation & Research Centre                     | Dallupura              |
|      26 | National Society for Prevention of Blindness (Small Hospital)       | Karkardooma            |

|   27 | Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute and Research Centre                      | Sector - V, Rohini               |
|------|------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------|
|   28 | Escort Heart Institute & Research Centre                               | Okhla                            |
|   29 | Laxmipat Sighnamia Medical Foundation                                  | Saket                            |
|   30 | Venu Charitable Society (Eye Hospital)                                 | Saket                            |
|   31 | Sondhi Charitable Trust                                                | Okhla                            |
|   32 | Vivekanand Pratishthanam                                               | Khureji                          |
|   33 | Manav Sewarath Trust                                                   | Paschim Puri                     |
|   34 | Araya Vaidyasala Kottakali                                             | Karkardooma                      |
|   35 | Human Care Medical Trust                                               | Dwarka                           |
|   36 | Devki Devi Foundation                                                  | Saket                            |
|   37 | Dr. Narain Dutt Shrimali Foundation                                    | Pitampura                        |
|   38 | Vikrant Children Medical Foundation                                    | Saket                            |
|   39 | Balaji Medical & Research Centre                                       | Manadawali                       |
|   40 | B.R. Dhawan Medical Charitable Trust                                   | Dwarka                           |
|   41 | Nirogi Charitable Medical Charitable Trust                             | Mandawali Fazalpur               |
|   42 | Lala Munni Lal Mange Ram Charitable Trust                              | Paschim Vihar                    |
|   43 | Multan Sewa Samiti                                                     | Pritampura                       |
|   44 | Walia Charitable Trust                                                 | Mayur Vihar Phase III            |
|   45 | Param Shakti Peeth                                                     | Mandawali                        |
|   46 | Unique Hospital & Research Institute                                   | Dwarka                           |
|   47 | Sarvodaya Health Foundation                                            | Rohini                           |
|   48 | Shanti Memorial Society                                                | Lado Sarai                       |
|   49 | Delhi ENT Hospital & Research Centre ( ENT Hospital & Research Centre) | FC - 33, Jasola                  |
|   50 | Sant Nirankari Mandal                                                  | Dheer Pur                        |
|   51 | Madhukar Multi Speciality Hospital                                     | Geetanjali                       |
|   52 | National Heart Institute                                               | East of Kailash                  |
|   53 | Sita Ram Bhartiya Institute                                            | B - 16, Qutub Institutional Area |
|   54 | Bala Sahib Gurudwara ( Delhi Sikh Gurudwara Management Committee)      | Kilokari                         |
|   55 | Maha Durga Charitable Trust                                            | Model Town                       |
|   56 | Jivodaya Hospital                                                      | Ashok Vihar                      |