Lok Sabha Question No. 2038 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2016-03-09
Subject: Swachh Survekshan
Ministry: URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Asked by: MANSHANKAR NINAMA, BOORA NARSAIAH GOUD, GAURAV GOGOI, C.R. CHAUDHARY, PR. SENTHILNATHAN

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT

## LOK SABHA

UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 2038

TO BE ANSWERED ON MARCH 09, 2016

## SWACHH SURVEKSHAN

No. 2038

SHRI MANSHANKAR NINAMA:

DR. BOORA NARSAIAH GOUD:

SHRI GAURAV GOGOI:

SHRI C.R. CHAUDHARY:

SHRI P.R. SENTHIL NATHAN:

Will the Minister of URBAN DEVELOPMENT be pleased to state:

- (a)  whether  the  Government  has  released  the  result  of  the  Swachh Survekshan-2016 and if so, the details of the rankings of cities;
- (b) the criteria for selection of the cities and the details of indicators/parameters  taken  into  consideration  during  the  ranking  and the other findings of the survey;
- (c) whether the Government proposes to provide incentive to the cities which performed well in the said ranking and if so, the details thereof;
- (d) whether the Government proposes to provide assistance to the cities that have failed to figure in the said ranking in the matter of cleanliness and sanitation situation; and
- (e) if so, the details thereof and if not, the reasons therefor along with the  steps  taken/being  taken  to  improve  sanitation  condition  in  the country?

## ANSWER

THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT

(SHRI BABUL SUPRIYO)

Contd…..2

(a):  Yes,  Madam.  The  ranking  of  73  cities  surveyed  under  Swachh Survekshan-2016 was announced on 15th February, 2016. Details of the ranking of the cities are at Annexure-I.

(b): All cities with million plus population and State capitals were part of this  survey.      However,  Kolkata  and  NOIDA,  two  of  the  cities,  did  not participate  in  the  survey.  Following  6  parameters  were  taken  into considerations for determining the rankings of the cities:

|   AREA OF EVALUATION | AREA OF EVALUATION                                                                       | WEIGHTAGE   |
|----------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------|
|                    1 | Strategy for Open Defecation Free town (ODF) and Integrated Solid Waste Management (SWM) | 5%          |
|                    2 | Information, Education and Behavior Change Communication (IEBC) activity                 | 5%          |
|                    3 | Door to door Collection, Sweeping, Collection & Transportation                           | 40%         |
|                    4 | Processing and Disposal of Solid Waste                                                   | 20%         |
|                    5 | Public & Community Toilet Provision                                                      | 15%         |
|                    6 | Individual Toilet                                                                        | 15%         |

(c):  On  15th  February,  2016,  awards  were  given  to  the  cities  in  the following categories:-

|   Rank | City (ULB)      | Key Strengths                                                                                              |
|--------|-----------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|      1 | Mysuru          | Best Overall Performing City                                                                               |
|      2 | Chandigarh      | Best performing city in North Zone and Best in Citizen Feedback Category                                   |
|      3 | Tiruchirappalli | Best Performing city in IEBC activities                                                                    |
|      4 | Delhi-NDMC      | Best Performing city among smart cities and Best in Service Level Status Category                          |
|      5 | Visakhapatnam   | Best Performing city in Independent Observation category                                                   |
|      6 | Surat           | Best Performing city in West Zone                                                                          |
|      7 | Rajkot          | Best Performing city in Cleanliness through Door to Door Collection, Sweeping, Collection & Transportation |

Contd…3

|   8 | Gangtok          | Best Performing city in North East Zone and Best among State Capitals   |
|-----|------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|   9 | Pimpri Chinchwad | Best Performing city among Satellite Towns                              |
|  10 | Greater Mumbai   | Best Performing city among Mega Cities                                  |

|   S. No. | Top Mover   |
|----------|-------------|
|        1 | Allahabad   |

|   S. No. | City (ULB)     | Top Movers Zone Wise   |
|----------|----------------|------------------------|
|        1 | North          | Allahabad              |
|        2 | West & Central | Nagpur                 |
|        3 | South          | Visakhapatnam          |
|        4 | East           | Bhubaneshwar           |
|        5 | North East     | Imphal                 |

(d):  Yes,  Madam.  Government  is  committed  to  mentor  and  handhold cities that have not performed well in the survey 'Swachh Survekshan2016'.

(e):  Based on the gaps identified in the survey, Government of India is planning various capacity building initiatives and peer learning with top performing cities in the survey to address the gaps for these cities in the area  of  sanitation  and  solid  waste  management  to  improve  their scores/ratings in the next survey.

******

ANNEXURE  REFERRED  TO  IN  REPLY  TO  LOK  SABHA  UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 2038 FOR 09.03.2016 REGARDING SWACHH SURVEKSHAN

## ANNEXUFRE-I

|   Rank | City               | State            |   Total Score |   Score obtained |
|--------|--------------------|------------------|---------------|------------------|
|      1 | Mysuru             | Karnataka        |          2000 |             1749 |
|      2 | Chandigarh         | Chandigarh       |          2000 |             1716 |
|      3 | Tiruchirappalli    | Tamil Nadu       |          2000 |             1715 |
|      4 | Delhi-NDMC         | Delhi            |          2000 |             1704 |
|      5 | Visakhapatnam      | Andhra Pradesh   |          2000 |             1643 |
|      6 | Surat              | Gujarat          |          2000 |             1605 |
|      7 | Rajkot             | Gujarat          |          2000 |             1574 |
|      8 | Gangtok            | Sikkim           |          2000 |             1565 |
|      9 | Pimpri Chinchwad   | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1559 |
|     10 | Greater Mumbai     | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1534 |
|     11 | Pune               | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1533 |
|     12 | Navi Mumbai        | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1530 |
|     13 |                    | Gujarat          |          2000 |             1511 |
|     14 | Vadodara Ahmedabad | Gujarat          |          2000 |             1452 |
|     15 | Imphal             | Manipur          |          2000 |             1441 |
|     16 | Panaji             | Goa              |          2000 |             1385 |
|     17 |                    | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1367 |
|     18 | Thane Coimbatore   | Tamil Nadu       |          2000 |             1361 |
|     19 | Hyderabad          | Telangana        |          2000 |             1355 |
|     20 | Nagpur             | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1348 |
|     21 | Bhopal             | Madhya Pradesh   |          2000 |             1336 |
|     22 | Allahabad          | Uttar Pradesh    |          2000 |             1323 |
|     23 | Vijayawada         | Andhra Pradesh   |          2000 |             1284 |
|     24 | Bhubaneshwar       | Odisha           |          2000 |             1279 |
|     25 | Indore             | Madhya Pradesh   |          2000 |             1276 |
|     26 | Madurai            | Tamil Nadu       |          2000 |             1245 |
|     27 | Shimla             | Himachal Pradesh |          2000 |             1244 |
|     28 | Lucknow            | Uttar Pradesh    |          2000 |             1237 |
|     29 | Jaipur             | Rajasthan        |          2000 |             1236 |
|     30 | Gwalior            | Madhya Pradesh   |          2000 |             1235 |
|     31 | Nashik             | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1232 |
|     32 | Warangal           | Telangana        |          2000 |             1226 |
|     33 | Agartala           | Tripura          |          2000 |             1222 |
|     34 | Ludhiana           | Punjab           |          2000 |             1222 |
|     35 | Vasai - Virar      | Maharashtra      |          2000 |             1215 |

| Rank                  | City                  | State             | Total Score   |   Score obtained |
|-----------------------|-----------------------|-------------------|---------------|------------------|
| 36                    | Gurgaon               | Haryana           | 2000          |             1194 |
| 37                    | Chennai               | Tamil Nadu        | 2000          |             1194 |
| 38                    | Bengaluru             | Karnataka         | 2000          |             1182 |
| 39                    | Delhi - SDMC          | DELHI             | 2000          |             1180 |
| 40 Thiruvananthapuram | Kerala                |                   | 2000          |             1167 |
| 41                    | Aizawl                | Mizoram           | 2000          |             1138 |
| 42 Gandhinagar        | Gujarat               |                   | 2000          |             1133 |
| 43 Delhi - North      | DMC DELHI             |                   | 2000          |             1132 |
| 44                    | Kozhikode             | Kerala            | 2000          |             1107 |
| 45 Kanpur             | Uttar Pradesh         | 2000              |               |             1090 |
| 46                    | Durg                  | Chhattisgarh      | 2000          |             1089 |
| 47                    | Agra Uttar            | Pradesh           | 2000          |             1081 |
| 48                    | Srinagar J&K          |                   | 2000          |             1072 |
| 49                    | Amritsar              | Punjab            | 2000          |             1062 |
| 50 Guwahati           | Assam                 |                   | 2000          |             1041 |
| 51                    | Faridabad             | Haryana           | 2000          |             1037 |
| 52                    | DELHI                 |                   | 2000          |             1015 |
| 53                    | Delhi - EDMC Shillong |                   | 2000          |             1012 |
| 54 Hubli and Dharwad  | Meghalaya city        | Karnataka         | 2000          |              992 |
| 55 Kochi              |                       | Kerala            | 2000          |              990 |
| 56                    | Aurangabad            | Maharashtra       | 2000          |              981 |
| 57                    | Jodhpur               | Rajasthan         | 2000          |              971 |
| 58 Kota               |                       | Rajasthan         | 2000          |              954 |
| 59                    | Cuttack Odisha        |                   | 2000          |              925 |
| 60 Kohima             | Nagaland              |                   | 2000          |              893 |
| 61                    | Dehradun              | Uttarakhand       | 2000          |              876 |
| 62                    | Ranchi                | Jharkhand         | 2000          |              874 |
| 63                    | Jabalpur              | Madhya Pradesh    | 2000          |              872 |
| 64 Kalyan             | Dombivli Maharashtra  |                   | 2000          |              858 |
| 65                    | Varanasi              | Uttar Pradesh     | 2000          |              839 |
| 66                    | Jamshedpur            | Jharkhand         | 2000          |              827 |
| 67                    | Ghaziabad             | Uttar Pradesh     | 2000          |              820 |
| 68 Raipur             |                       | Chhattisgarh      | 2000          |              818 |
| 69                    | Meerut Uttar          | Pradesh           | 2000          |              760 |
| 70                    | Patna                 | Bihar             | 2000          |              746 |
| 71                    | Itanagar              | Arunachal Pradesh | 2000          |              639 |
| 72                    | Asansol-Durgapur      | West Bengal       | 2000          |              497 |
| 73                    | Dhanbad               | Jharkhand         | 2000          |              464 |