Lok Sabha Question No. 1979 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2016-05-05
Subject: Disputes between Coal Management and Consumers
Ministry: COAL
Asked by: SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH

## GOVERNEMNT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF COAL UNSTARRED QUESTION NO 1979 TO BE ANSWERED ON 05.05.2016

'Disputes between Coal Management and Consumers'

## 1979.  SHRI SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH:

Will the Minister of Coal be pleased to state:

- a. whether the number of cases in various courts is increasing due to the disputes between the coal management and coal consumers, workers and others in Coal India Limited (CIL) and each of its ancillaries;
- b. if so, the details of the current/ pending cases in the CIL and each of its ancillaries during the last three years, year and company -wise;
- c. the amount spent on advocates and other legal issues by the CIL and each of its ancillaries during the said period, year-wise;
- d. the winning percentage of these cases by the CIL and each of its ancillaries;
- e. whether  several  such  minor  cases  are  lying  pending  in  the  courts  in  which  the  CIL  and  its ancillaries have spent much more than the demand of the petitioners; and
- f. if so, the details thereof and the effective steps taken to reduce the amount of money being spent by the said companies on litigation?

## ANSWER

## MINISTER  OF  STATE  (I/C)  IN  THE  MINISTRY  OF  COAL,  POWER  NEW  & RENEWABLE ENERGY

## (SHRI PIYUSH GOYAL)

- (a) & (b) As per the information received from Coal India Limited(CIL),the number of court cases  pending  in  Coal  India  Limited  including  the  disputes  between  management  and coal companies, workers, etc. for the last three years and current year are given as under :

|   S.No |   Year |   No. of cases pending |
|--------|--------|------------------------|
|      1 |   2013 |                     38 |
|      2 |   2014 |                     37 |
|      3 |   2015 |                     40 |
|      6 |   2016 |                     09 |

Details of pending court cases in CIL is given at Annexure .

- (c) The amount spent by the Coal India Limited (CIL) on advocates and other legal issues,year-wise, is given below:
- (d) to (f) Out of a total of 85 cases disposed of during the last three years, the outcome was not adverse  in  67  cases.  Court  cases  arenot  distinguished  as  minor  or  major  cases,  and  all cases are treated /contested with importance.Further, to resolve the disputes between the coal companies and consumers,an Alternate Dispute Resolution Mechanism (ADRM) has been introduced in the Ministry of Coal for out of court settlement.

|   S.No | Year    | Legal expenses (rupees in crore)                                                                     |
|--------|---------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|      1 | 2013-14 | 4.75                                                                                                 |
|      2 | 2014-15 | 4.66                                                                                                 |
|      3 | 2015-16 | 9.00 (subject to reconciliation since accounts in the process of finalization for this fiscal year.) |

|   S.No |   Year | CAUSE-TITLE                                                                                           | SUBJECT MATTER      | FORUM/COURT                | STATUS   |
|--------|--------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------|----------------------------|----------|
|      1 |   2013 | Reference Case No. 52 of 2013- Coal India Limited& Third Workmen                                      | IR matter           | Tribunal Calcutta          | PENDING  |
|      2 |   2013 | W.P No. 6237 of 2013 India Power Corporation Ltd V. UoI                                               | S & Mmatter.        | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      3 |   2013 | GA No. Of 2013 ; C S No. 392 of 2013 Videocon Industries Ltd. V.CIL                                   | S & Mmatter.        | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      4 |   2013 | Case No. 5&6 of 2013 Paul Buiders V.CIL                                                               | Civil               | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      5 |   2013 | W.P No. 32863 (W) of 2013 - Awadh Kishore Pandey& others V.CIL & others -                             | SERVICE MATTER      | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      6 |   2013 | WPNo. 1017 of 2013- Girindra Soft Coke Enterprises &anothers V. CIL & others                          | S & Mmatter.        | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      7 |   2013 | W.P No. 905 of 2013- Continental Coke& Minerals V. CIl& others                                        | S & Mmatter.        | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      8 |   2013 | W.P No. 1064 of 2013- Sudhir Prasad SIngh V. CIL & others                                             | SERVICE MATTER      | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|      9 |   2013 | SLP ©No. 24908 of 2013-Shree Enterprises Coal Sales Pvt. Ltd V. UoI& others                           | S & Mmatter.        | Supreme Court of India     | PENDING  |
|     10 |   2013 | EC No. 281 of 2013- Canadian Commercial Corporation V. CIL                                            | Misc                | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|     11 |   2013 | CAN no. 7424 of 2013;MAT no. 1085 /2013-Mithlesh Kr.SinghV.UoI& others                                | SERVICE MATTER      | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|     12 |   2013 | W.P No.21746 (W) of 2013-Pankaj Kr. Sinha V. CIL& others                                              | SERVICE MATTER      | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|     13 |   2013 | W.P No. 667 of 2013- Vineet Singh V. CIl& others                                                      | VIG/SERVICE MATTER. | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|     14 |   2013 | BIFR case No. 28 of 2000 & MAno. 256 of 2013 - Bagalkot Cement& Industries ltd                        | BIFR                | BIFR , New Delhi           | PENDING  |
|     15 |   2013 | LPA NO. 640 of 2013- CIL V.RK gupta& others                                                           | SERVICE MATTER      | Delhi H/c                  | PENDING  |
|     16 |   2013 | CA No. 4281 of 2013- Gulf Oil Corporation Ltd. V. UoI& others                                         | MM                  | Supreme Court of India     | PENDING  |
|     17 |   2013 | CS No. Of 2013'; T No. 180 of 2013;TA No. 68 of 2013 - ShyamMetalics& Engineering ltd. V. CIl& others | S & Mmatter.        | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|     18 |   2013 | Reference No.18 of 2013- CIL V. Their Workmen                                                         | Misc                | Tribunal, calcutta         | PENDING  |
|     19 |   2013 | Reference No.21 of 2013- CIL V. Their Workmen                                                         | Misc                | Tribunal, calcutta         | PENDING  |
|     20 |   2013 | Money suit no.285 of 2013- Ratna Mukherjee V. CIl& Others                                             | SERVICE MATTER      | City Civil Court, Calcutta | PENDING  |
|     21 |   2013 | W.P No.15485 (W) of 2013 - Smt. Reena Das V.CIL & others                                              | Misc                | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |
|     22 |   2013 | W.P No.15603of 2013 - Roshan Kr. CIL & others                                                         | SERVICE MATTER      | Calcutta H/C               | PENDING  |

|   23 |   2013 | W.P No. 470 of 2013-S.K.J Coke Industries Ltd V. CIL & others                                              | S & Mmatter.   | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|------|--------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------|------------------------|-----------|
|   24 |   2013 | W.P No. 12024 (W) of 2013- K.S Natrajan& others V. CIL & others                                            | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   25 |   2013 | W.A No. 84 of 2013- Anil Kr.Srivastava& others V. CIL & others                                             | SERVICE MATTER | Jabalpur H/C           | PENDING   |
|   26 |   2013 | W.P No.9647 of 2013- Rashmi cement ltd. V. UoI& others                                                     | S & Mmatter.   | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   27 |   2013 | W.P (S) No. 1051 of 2013- Sanjay Kr. Guta&other sV.CIl& Others                                             | SERVICE MATTER | Bilaspur H/C           | PENDING   |
|   28 |   2013 | WP©No. 47 of 2013- Cement Manufacturing Com. Ltd V. UoI& others                                            | S & Mmatter.   | Guahati H/c            | PENDING   |
|   29 |   2013 | SLP ©No. Of 2013- CIL V. MainakDutta                                                                       | SERVICE MATTER | Supreme Court of India | PENDING   |
|   30 |   2013 | WPNo. 254 of 2013- Kumar Rahul V. CIL & others                                                             | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   31 |   2013 | W.P No. 7916 (W) of 2013-Dhiresh Kumar V.CIL & others                                                      | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   32 |   2013 | CC no. 118 of 2013; GA No. 143 of 2013- Indigo Smokeless Fuels India V. S. Narsingrao, Chaiman CIL& others | S & Mmatter.   | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   33 |   2013 | W.P No. 3097 (W0 of 2013- Somnath Bag V. CIL                                                               | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   34 |   2013 | W.P No. 2338 (W) of 2013- Godavari Power Ispat Limited& others V. CIL                                      | S & Mmatter.   | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   35 |   2013 | W.P No. 69 of 2013- Siba Prasad DuttaMazumderV.CIl& others                                                 | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   36 |   2013 | W.P No. 709 (W) of 2013- Maj.Sandeep Kr. Deb v. UoI& others                                                | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | PENDING   |
|   37 |   2013 | W/P ©No. 6129 of 2013- Anmol (india) Ltd & others V. NEC & others                                          | TAX            | Gauhati H/C            | PENDING   |
|   38 |   2014 | C.C.No. 134 of 2013, W.P.No. 110 of 2010, Dipak Kr. Mukherjee Vs S. NarsinghRao                            | SERVICE MATTER | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   39 |   2014 | Application No.50 of 2014, M/S L&T Finance Ltd. VsVinirrama Project P. Ltd                                 | Misc           | Madras                 | Pending   |
|   40 |   2014 | Civil Appeal No. 9173-9181 of 2013, CCI Vs GOCL                                                            | MM             | Supreme Court of India | PENDING   |
|   41 |   2014 | Appeal No. 1 of 2014 CIL Vs CCI Mahagenco                                                                  | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |
|   42 |   2014 | AppealNo. 44-47 of 2014- CIL and Subsidiaries v. MPPGCL, WBPDCL and SIMA                                   | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |
|   43 |   2014 | Appeal No.49 of 2014- MPPGCL V. CIL                                                                        | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |
|   44 |   2014 | Appeal No. 70 of 2014- Sponge Iron Manufacture Association V. CCI,CIL                                      | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |
|   45 |   2014 | Appeal no.80 of 2014- SaiWardha Power Limited V. CIL/WCL                                                   | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |
|   46 |   2014 | Appeal No.81 of 2014- BijayPoddar V. CIL &itssubidiaries                                                   | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |
|   47 |   2015 | Appeal No.. Of 2015 - CIL V. GHCL                                                                          | S & MMatter    | COMPAT, New Delhi      | Pending   |

|   48 |   2014 | WPNo. 4222 (W)of 2014, Integrated Coal Mining Vs UOI &Ors                                                | S&M          | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|------|--------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------|-------------------------|-----------|
|   49 |   2014 | Application No.19 of 2014, Dr.KashmireKakatiVs UOI &Ors                                                  | Misc. matter | Green Tribunal Of India | Pending   |
|   50 |   2014 | C.A.N. No. 2822 of 2015, WPNo. 5814 (w) of 2014, Md. ArifAkhtarVs State of West Bengal &Ors              | Service      | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|   51 |   2014 | WpNo.13608 (W) of 2014- IOL Explosives Ltd. V. Uoi& others                                               | MM           | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|   52 |   2014 | CAN NO, 6299 of 2014- WPNo. 13699 (W) of 2014- Solar industries Ltd. &anothers V. Cil& others            | MM           | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   53 |   2014 | AP No. ___ of 2014- Sendoz Commercial Pvt. Ltd. V. Cil& others                                           | S&M          | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   54 |   2014 | Appeal No._____ of 2014 - Cil V. Commissioner of Customs& others                                         | C & F        | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   55 |   2014 | WP©No. 639 of 2014-Banur Cement Store V. NEC, CIL & others                                               | S&M          | Guahati H/c             | PENDING   |
|   56 |   2014 | GA No.632 of 2014; APOT No.96/2014 WPNo.232 of 2013- CIL V. Anari Devi& others                           | Service      | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   57 |   2014 | Arbitration between R.S. Fuels P Ltd. V. ECL& others                                                     | Arbitration  | at Kolkata              | Pending   |
|   58 |   2014 | GA No.260 of 2014-APOT No.1588 of 2014-WP No.600 of 2005-Indian Explosives V. Uoi& others                | MM           | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   59 |   2014 | MANo. 82 of 2014; Appeal No.89 of 2014- BagalkotUdyog limited V. BIFR & others                           | S&M          | BIFR                    | Pending   |
|   60 |   2014 | WPNO. 20259 (W) of 2014- Dibyajyoti Ghosh V. Cil& others                                                 | Service      | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   61 |   2014 | MAT no.1071 of 2014 ; CAN No. 6453 of 2014; Major sandeep Kumar de V. UoI& others                        | Service      | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   62 |   2014 | Application No.127 of 2014-Ajay dubey V. CIL& others                                                     | NGT          | NGT Bhopal              | Pending   |
|   63 |   2014 | WP(C ) No.4653 of 2014;CMA 9280 of 2014;CMA 9281 of 2014-Shyam Metallics& Energy Limited V. CIL & others | S&M          | Delhi HC                | Pending   |
|   64 |   2014 | WPNo.740 of 2014-Mjunction Services Ltd. & another V. Cil& others                                        | S&M          | Calcutta                | Pending   |
|   65 |   2014 | Contmpt case No.1966 of 2014- Manoranjan DeyKirty V. S. NarsingRao& others                               | Service      | Jabalpur H/C            | Pending   |
|   66 |   2014 | WPNo.25423(W) of 2014- Mahalaxmi Intra Contract P. Ltd. V. CIL & others                                  | S&M          | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|   67 |   2014 | WPNo. ___ of 2014 - NabagopalBanejeeV.Cil& other s                                                       | Service      | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|   68 |   2014 | WpNo. 26993(W) of 2014 - Concastbengal Industries ltd& another v. Ecl& others                            | S&M          | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|   69 |   2014 | WPNo.27759 (W) of 2014-K.Sunil Kumar& OTHERS V.CIL& others                                               | Service      | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |
|   70 |   2014 | Can No. __ of 2014;ASTA No.__ of 2014; MAT 885 of 2014-R.S.Fuel Pvt. Ltd. & others V. Cil& others        | Tax          | Calcutta H/C            | Pending   |

|   71 |   2014 | WPNo. 30032 (W) of 2014- CIL ContractorWorkers' Union& another V. C.A.C.L Board& others      | IR matter             | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|------|--------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------|------------------------|-----------|
|   72 |   2014 | CAN No.11419 of 2014;MAT No. 1964 of 2014 ;FMA No.---of 2014;CIL V.Anil Kumara Joshi& others | SERVICE MATTER        | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   73 |   2014 | CAN No. __ 2014;MAT No 1088 of 2014-Arpa Fuels limited& others V. CIL & others               | Tax                   | Calcutta               | Pending   |
|   74 |   2014 | WP©No.6155 0f 2013-Shiv Shakti Coal Traders V. NEC & others                                  | Tax                   | Guahati H/c            | PENDING   |
|   75 |   2013 | WP©No. 6150 of 213-Pankaj Coal Enterprises V.NEC o& others                                   | Tax                   | Guahati H/c            | PENDING   |
|   76 |   2015 | W.P No.2535 (W) of 2015- Solar Industries India Ltd. V. Cil& others                          | MM                    | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   77 |   2015 | WP. No. 2184 (W) of 2015 IDL Explosives Ltd. -VS- UOI &Ors.                                  | M.M                   | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   78 |   2015 | WP. No. 34385 (W) of 2014 E- Procurement Technologies &Anr. - VS- CIL &Ors.                  | S&M                   | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   79 |   2015 | WP. No. 2211 (W) of 2015 DhaneswarPandey&Ors. -VS- CIL &Ors.                                 | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   80 |   2015 | WP. No. 1641 (W) of 2015 ManoranjanSen Gupta -VS- CIL &Ors.                                  | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   81 |   2015 | MAT. No. 167 of 2015 and WP. No. 10654 (W) of 2013 ChanderBhusanSood -VS- CIL &Ors.          | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   82 |   2015 | WP. No. 33487 (W) of 2014 Gopal Chandra Pandey -VS- CIL &Ors.                                | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   83 |   2015 | MAT. No. 398 of 2015 and FMAT. No…..of 2015 CIL -VS- Ram Chandra Rawagiwala&Ors.             | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   84 |   2015 | WP. No. 6478 (W) of 2015 Smt. SovonaBhattacharjee -VS- CIL &Ors.                             | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   85 |   2015 | Civil Appeal No. 6137 of 2013 Ideal Industries Explosive Ltd. -VS- CIL &Ors.                 | MM                    | Supreme Court of India | PENDING   |
|   86 |   2015 | Civil Appeal No. 6091 of 2013 KeltechEngrgies Ltd. -VS- CIL &Ors.                            | MM                    | Supreme Court of India | PENDING   |
|   87 |   2015 | Civil Appeal No. 4836 of 2013 Solar Industries India Ltd -VS- CC of India &Ors.              | MM                    | Supreme Court of India | PENDING   |
|   88 |   2015 | WP. ©No. 3001 of 2015 Jindal Power Ltd. &Anr. -VS- UOI &Ors.                                 | Auction of Coal Mines | Delhi H/C              | PENDING   |
|   89 |   2015 | MAT. No. 2072 of 2014 and FMA. No……of 2014 CIL -VS- C. Raja Seelan&Ors.                      | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   90 |   2015 | MAT. No. 2071 of 2014 and FMA. No……of 2014 CIL -VS- Dr. Ashok Kr. Singh &Ors.                | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   91 |   2015 | MAT. No. 2073 of 2014 and FMA. No…..of 2014 CIL &Ors. -VS- R. P. Singh &Ors.                 | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   92 |   2015 | MAT. No. 2074 of 2014 and FMA. No……of 2014 CIL &Ors. -VS- N. K. Shresh&Ors.                  | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |
|   93 |   2015 | MAT. No. 2075 of 2014 and FMA. No……of 2014 CIL &Ors. -VS- Asit                               | Service               | Calcutta H/C           | Pending   |

|     |      | Kumar Das &Ors.                                                                                                               |                         |                          |         |
|-----|------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------|--------------------------|---------|
|  94 | 2015 | MAT. No. 2076 of 2014 and FMA. No…….of 2014 CIL &Ors. -VS- K. S. Natrajan&Ors.                                                | Service                 | Calcutta H/C             | Pending |
|  95 | 2015 | MAT. No. 2077 of 2014 and FMA. No……of 2014 CIL &Ors. -VS- C. B. Singh &Ors.                                                   | Service                 | Calcutta H/C             | Pending |
|  96 | 2015 | SLP. ©No. 12532 of 2015 Vulcan Industrial Engneering Co. Ltd. -VS- CIL &Ors.                                                  | M.M                     | Supreme Court of India   | PENDING |
|  97 | 2015 | SLP. ©No.7927 of 2015 CIL V. Anand Vijay Pawar&Anr.                                                                           | SERVICE MATTER          | Supreme Court of India   | PENDING |
|  98 | 2015 | WP. No. 9996 (W) of 2015 Solar Industries Ltd. &Anr. -VS- CIL &Ors.                                                           | M.M                     | Calcutta H/C             | Pending |
|  99 | 2015 | O.A. No. 319 of 2014 ( Z) Dukalu Ram &Ors. -VS- UOI &Ors.                                                                     | S&M                     | Green Tribunal at Bhopal | Pending |
| 100 | 2015 | T.P ©No. 489-490 of 2015-CIL & others V .R.S.Fuels (P) Ltd& others                                                            | Tax                     | Supreme Court of India   | Pending |
| 101 | 2015 | W.P. No. 1565 of 2015 Electrosteel Castings Ltd. &Anr. -VS- UOI &Ors.                                                         | Auction of Coal Mines   | Delhi H/C                | PENDING |
| 102 | 2015 | W.P. ©No. 3398 of 2015 Jindal Steel & Power Ltd. &Anr. -VS- UOI &Ors.                                                         | Auction of Coal Mines   | Delhi H/C                | PENDING |
| 103 | 2015 | C.M. No. 7704 of 2015 and W.P.(C) No. 23118 of 2015 Federation of Coal Industries Retired Employees Asso. Ors. -VS- UOI &Ors. | Service (Pension Matter | Delhi H/C                | Pending |
| 104 | 2014 | W.P No ©235 of 2014 Keltech engineering Limited V. UoI& others                                                                | MM                      | Supreme Court of India   | PENDING |
| 105 | 2015 | W.P No. 16919 of 2015 - awadhKishor V. UoI& others                                                                            | SERVICE MATTER          | Bombay H/c               | PENDING |
| 106 | 2015 | Case No. 641 of 2015 &CS No. 5270 of 2013- Jasbirsingh V. CIL & others                                                        | SERVICE MATTER          | Civil Judge at Bhatinda  | PENDING |
| 107 | 2015 | WP©No. 6988 of 2015& CM No.12814 of 2015- KoylaUdyogKamgarSangathanV.UoI& others                                              | IR matter               | Delhi H/c                | PENDING |
| 108 | 2015 | WPNo. 23462 (W) of 2015- SubratoChakravarty V. UoI& others                                                                    | SERVICE MATTER          | Calcutta H/C             | PENDING |
| 109 | 2015 | WPNo. 23552 (W) of 2015- KetakiGantait V. UoI& others                                                                         | SERVICE                 | Calcutta H/C             | PENDING |
| 110 | 2015 | CWP NO. Of 2015- ravindraKishor Prasad V. S. Bhattacharya& others                                                             | SERVICE MATTER          | Delhi H/C                | PENDING |
| 111 | 2015 | SLP ©No. 24574 of 2015- ShivpurariKishan Singh V. CIL& others                                                                 | SERVICE MATTER          | Delhi H/C                | PENDING |
| 112 | 2015 | CG No. 111 of 2015- RakeshChaturvedi V. State ofMP & others                                                                   | Environment             | Green Tribunal, Bhopal   | PENDING |
| 113 | 2015 | W.P No.18735 of 2015-Kailash Kr.Kedia, MaendragarhKoriya V. State ofmP& others                                                | Sales Tax               | Jabalpur H/C             | Pending |
| 114 | 2015 | W.P No.30432 (W) of 2015-Smt.Raj Kumari Devi V.CIL & others                                                                   | Service matter          | Calcutta H/c             | Pending |
| 115 | 2016 | W.P (C ) No.18254 of 2015- Santosh Kr. Pradhan V. Cil& others                                                                 | Service matter          | Cuttack H/C              | Pending |

| 116   | 2016                                                                                                                       | W.P©No451 of 2016; C.M No. 1798 of 2016- MuziburRehman V. UoI& others                            | PIL            | Delhi H/c              | Pending   |
|-------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------|------------------------|-----------|
| 117   | 2016 APOT No….. Of 2015;GA. No. …of 2016; G.A No. 3814 of 2015;GA No.2093 /2008-NEC& another V. SomalPipes (P) Ltd& others | S&M                                                                                              | Calcutta       | H/c Pending            |           |
| 118   | 2016                                                                                                                       | W.P(S) No.331 of 2016- DevendraKr.Srivastava& Another V. CIL & others                            | Service matter | Bilaspur H/C           | Pending   |
| 119   | 2016                                                                                                                       | W.P ©No. 6143 of 2015-Shyam Sel& Power Ltd. V. UoI& others                                       | S&M            | Ranchi H/C             | Pending   |
| 120   | 2016                                                                                                                       | W.P No. 1665 of 2016: C.S. Singh V. CMD&others                                                   | Service matter | Jabalpur H/C           | Pending   |
| 121   | 2015                                                                                                                       | W.A No.502 of 2015: Ritesh Kumar Behra V. UoI&ors                                                | Service matter | Bilaspur H/C           | Pending   |
| 122   | 2016                                                                                                                       | GA No of 2016;APOT No. Of 2016: NEC & another V Oriental Ceramics& refractories Pvt. Ltd& others | S&M            | Calcutta H/c           | Pending   |
| 123   | 2016 W.P No.2936 of RajnishChaturvedi                                                                                      | 2016 : V. SECL& others                                                                           | PIL            | Bilaspur H/C           | Pending   |
|       | 2016 SLP(                                                                                                                  | c) No. 6177 of 2016- CIL                                                                         | Misc           | Supreme Court of India | Pending   |