Lok Sabha Question No. 2031 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2015-12-10
Subject: Gap between Cost of Power Generation and Selling Price
Ministry: POWER
Asked by: HARISH CHANDRA MEENA, PONNUSAMY VENUGOPAL

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF POWER

## LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO.2031 TO BE ANSWERED ON 10.12.2015

## GAP BETWEEN COST OF POWER GENERATION AND SELLING PRICE

2031.  SHRI HARISH MEENA: DR. P. VENUGOPAL:

Will the Minister of POWER be pleased to state:

- (a) whether there is a wide gap between the cost of power generation and the selling price of power to the consumers in the country, if so, the details thereof and the reasons therefor, State-wise;

(b) whether  power  firms  owe  Coal  India  around  Rs.8,000  crore,  if  so,  the details thereof; and

(c) the steps taken by the Government to minimise the gap between per unit cost of power generation and its selling price to the consumers?

## A N S W E R

THE MINISTER OF STATE (INDEPENDENT CHARGE) FOR POWER, COAL AND NEW & RENEWABLE ENERGY

( SHRI  PIYUSH GOYAL )

(a) : Yes,    Madam.    There  exists  a  gap  between  cost  of  generation/ generation tariff and sale price/cost of supply to the end consumer.  This is due the  fact  that  in  addition  to  the  generation  tariff,  the  cost  of  supply  to  the  end consumers includes  the  transmission  charges,  transmission  losses,  distribution network  charges,  distribution  losses  and  commercial  losses  etc.  The  average cost of supply and Average Revenue State-wise for the year 2013-14 is at Annex-I.

- (b) : As per the information provided by Ministry of Coal, as on 30.11.2015,  an amount of ` 8279.19 Crores (provisional) is  outstanding against State  Electricity  Boards  and  Power  Companies,  including  Independent  Power Producers  (IPPs)  to  be  paid  to  Coal  India  Ltd.    The  details  of  the  same  are  at Annex-II.
- (c) : Through appropriate policy framework and programmes, the Government is promoting efficiency in generation, transmission and distribution business and also supporting strengthening of the distribution and transmission infrastructure for reducing technical losses, with a view to reduce the total cost of  supply  of  electricity  to  the  consumer. These measures, along with the policy framework  of  discovery  of  tariff  through  competitive  bidding  will  contribute towards lowering of tariff rates.

**********

ANNEX-I ANNEX  REFERRED  TO  IN  REPLY  TO  PART  (a)  OF  UNSTARRED  QUESTION  NO.  2031  TO  BE

ANSWERED IN THE LOK SABHA ON 10.12.2015. ***********

|                     |                         |               | 2013-14   | 2013-14                          | 2013-14                  |
|---------------------|-------------------------|---------------|-----------|----------------------------------|--------------------------|
| Region              | State                   | Utility       | ACS*      | Avg Revenue (Subsidy Recd basis) | Gap (subsidy recd basis) |
| Eastern             | Bihar                   | BSEB          |           |                                  |                          |
| Eastern             |                         | NBPDCL        | 4.84      | 4.71                             | 0.13                     |
| Eastern             |                         | SBPDCL        | 5.17      | 4.86                             | 0.31                     |
| Eastern             | Bihar Total             |               | 5.04      | 4.80                             | 0.24                     |
| Eastern             | Jharkhand               | JSEB          | 5.52      | 3.79                             | 1.73                     |
| Eastern             | Jharkhand Total         |               | 5.52      | 3.79                             | 1.73                     |
| Eastern             | Sikkim                  | Sikkim PD     | 3.10      | 3.49                             | (0.39)                   |
| Eastern             | Sikkim Total            |               | 3.10      | 3.49                             | (0.39)                   |
| Eastern             | West Bengal             | WBSEDCL       | 4.89      | 4.90                             | (0.01)                   |
| Eastern             | West Bengal Total       |               | 4.89      | 4.90                             | (0.01)                   |
| Eastern             | Odisha                  | NESCO         | 3.93      | 3.84                             | 0.09                     |
| Eastern             |                         | SESCO         | 3.33      | 3.29                             | 0.04                     |
| Eastern             |                         | WESCO         | 3.92      | 3.79                             | 0.13                     |
| Eastern             |                         | CESU          | 3.91      | 3.66                             | 0.25                     |
| Eastern             | Odisha Total            |               | 3.84      | 3.69                             | 0.15                     |
| Eastern Total       |                         |               | 4.68      | 4.42                             | 0.26                     |
| North Eastern       | Arunachal Pradesh       | Arunachal PD  | 8.03      | 1.43                             | 6.59                     |
| North Eastern       | Arunachal Pradesh Total |               | 8.03      | 1.43                             | 6.59                     |
| North Eastern       | Assam                   | APDCL         | 5.16      | 4.15                             | 1.00                     |
| North Eastern       | Assam Total             |               | 5.16      | 4.15                             | 1.00                     |
| North Eastern       | Manipur                 | Manipur PD    | 5.20      | 2.20                             | 3.01                     |
| North Eastern       | Manipur Total           |               | 5.20      | 2.20                             | 3.01                     |
| North Eastern       | Meghalaya               | MeECL         |           |                                  |                          |
| North Eastern       |                         | MePDCL        | 3.39      | 3.21                             | 0.18                     |
| North Eastern       | Meghalaya Total         |               | 3.39      | 3.21                             | 0.18                     |
| North Eastern       | Mizoram                 | Mizoram PD    | 6.35      | 2.34                             | 4.00                     |
| North Eastern       | Mizoram Total           |               | 6.35      | 2.34                             | 4.00                     |
| North Eastern       | Nagaland                | Nagaland PD   | 4.57      | 1.54                             | 3.03                     |
| North Eastern       | Nagaland Total          |               | 4.57      | 1.54                             | 3.03                     |
| North Eastern       | Tripura                 | TSECL         | 3.74      | 3.27                             | 0.47                     |
| North Eastern       | Tripura Total           |               | 3.74      | 3.27                             | 0.47                     |
| North Eastern Total | North Eastern Total     |               | 4.94      | 3.48                             | 1.46                     |
| Northern            | Delhi                   | BSES Rajdhani | 6.10      | 6.11                             | (0.01)                   |
| Northern            |                         | BSES Yamuna   | 6.52      | 6.54                             | (0.02)                   |
| Northern            |                         | TPDDL         | 4.97      | 5.34                             | (0.38)                   |
| Northern            | Delhi Total             |               | 5.83      | 5.96                             | (0.13)                   |
| Northern            | Haryana                 | DHBVNL        | 4.96      | 4.34                             | 0.62                     |
| Northern            |                         | UHBVNL        | 5.55      | 4.86                             | 0.69                     |
| Northern            | Haryana Total           |               | 5.22      | 4.57                             | 0.66                     |
| Northern            | Himachal Pradesh        | HPSEB Ltd.    | 4.83      | 4.77                             | 0.07                     |
| Northern            | Himachal Pradesh Total  |               | 4.83      | 4.77                             | 0.07                     |
| Northern            | Jammu & Kashmir         | J&K PDD       | 3.20      | 1.32                             | 1.88                     |
| Northern            | Jammu & Kashmir Total   |               | 3.20      | 1.32                             | 1.88                     |
|                     | Punjab                  | PSPCL         | 4.71      | 4.77                             | (0.06)                   |
|                     | Punjab Total            |               | 4.71      | 4.77                             | (0.06)                   |
|                     | Rajasthan               | AVVNL         | 7.14      | 4.20                             | 2.94                     |
|                     |                         | JDVVNL        | 6.49      | 3.80                             | 2.69                     |
|                     |                         | JVVNL         | 6.16      | 3.79                             | 2.37                     |
|                     | Rajasthan Total         |               | 6.54      | 3.90                             | 2.64                     |

|                  | Uttar Pradesh        | DVVN                    |   6.18 |   3.19 | 2.99   |
|------------------|----------------------|-------------------------|--------|--------|--------|
|                  | Uttar Pradesh        | KESCO                   |   6.38 |   4.48 | 1.90   |
|                  | Uttar Pradesh        | MVVN                    |   6.18 |   3.89 | 2.29   |
|                  |                      | Pash VVN                |   5.71 |   4.39 | 1.32   |
|                  |                      | Poorv VVN               |   6.53 |   4.11 | 2.42   |
|                  | Uttar Pradesh Total  |                         |   6.12 |   3.96 | 2.16   |
|                  | Uttarakhand          | Ut PCL                  |   3.09 |   3.36 | (0.27) |
|                  | Uttarakhand Total    |                         |   3.09 |   3.36 | (0.27) |
| Northern Total   |                      |                         |   5.53 |   4.29 | 1.24   |
| Southern         | Andhra Pradesh       | APCPDCL                 |   4.9  |   4.65 | 0.25   |
| Southern         |                      | APEPDCL                 |   4.62 |   4.52 | 0.10   |
| Southern         |                      | APNPDCL                 |   4.71 |   4.68 | 0.03   |
| Southern         |                      | APSPDCL                 |   4.94 |   4.74 | 0.20   |
| Southern         | Andhra Pradesh Total |                         |   4.83 |   4.65 | 0.18   |
| Southern Western | Karnataka            | BESCOM                  |   4.4  |   4.43 | (0.03) |
|                  |                      | CHESCOM                 |   3.93 |   3.82 | 0.10   |
|                  |                      | GESCOM                  |   4    |   4.04 | (0.03) |
|                  |                      | HESCOM                  |   4.75 |   4.2  | 0.55   |
|                  |                      | MESCOM                  |   4.81 |   4.81 | (0.00) |
|                  | Karnataka Total      |                         |   4.4  |   4.3  | 0.09   |
|                  | Kerala               | KSEB                    |   4.8  |   4.92 | (0.11) |
|                  |                      | KSEBL                   |   5.41 |   5.38 | 0.03   |
|                  | Kerala Total         |                         |   5.07 |   5.12 | (0.05) |
|                  | Puducherry           | Puducherry PD           |   3.82 |   3.61 | 0.21   |
|                  | Puducherry Total     |                         |   3.82 |   3.61 | 0.21   |
|                  | Tamil Nadu           | TANGEDCO                |   6.52 |   4.71 | 1.81   |
|                  | Tamil Nadu Total     |                         |   6.52 |   4.71 | 1.81   |
| Total            |                      |                         |   5.28 |   4.62 | 0.66   |
|                  | Chhattisgarh         | CSPDCL                  |   3.43 |   3.15 | 0.28   |
|                  | Chhattisgarh Total   |                         |   3.43 |   3.15 | 0.28   |
|                  | Goa                  | Goa PD                  |   3.35 |   3.34 | 0.01   |
|                  | Goa Total            |                         |   3.35 |   3.34 | 0.01   |
|                  | Gujarat              | DGVCL                   |   5.36 |   5.41 | (0.05) |
|                  |                      | MGVCL                   |   4.55 |   4.58 | (0.03) |
|                  |                      | PGVCL                   |   3.71 |   3.72 | (0.01) |
|                  |                      | UGVCL                   |   3.93 |   3.94 | (0.01) |
|                  | Gujarat Total        |                         |   4.21 |   4.23 | (0.02) |
|                  | Madhya Pradesh       | MP Madhya Kshetra VVCL  |   4.89 |   3.33 | 1.56   |
|                  |                      | MP Paschim Kshetra VVCL |   4.89 |   3.89 | 1.00   |
|                  |                      | MP Purv Kshetra VVCL    |   4.94 |   3.73 | 1.21   |
|                  | Madhya Pradesh Total |                         |   4.9  |   3.65 | 1.25   |
|                  | Maharashtra          | MSEDCL                  |   5.34 |   5.22 | 0.12   |
|                  | Maharashtra Total    |                         |   5.34 |   5.22 | 0.12   |
| Western Total    | Western Total        |                         |   4.72 |   4.4  | 0.32   |
| Grand Total      | Grand Total          |                         |   5.15 |   4.41 | 0.73   |

* Average Cost of Supply (ACS) includes cost of power generation, Transmission charges and losses, Distribution Charges and Losses (Source PFC)

************

## ANNEX REFERRED TO IN REPLY TO PART (b) OF UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 2031 TO BE ANSWERED IN THE LOK SABHA ON 10.12.2015.

***********

Details of Outstanding against State Electricity Boards and Power Companies including Independent Power Producers to be paid to Coal India Ltd.

(Provisional)

(Rs. in crores)

| Name of SEB & Power Companies   | Balance as on 01.04.2015   | Balance as on 01.04.2015   | Balance as on 01.04.2015   | During Nov 2015   | During Nov 2015   | During Nov 2015          | During Nov 2015   | Progressive for the year   | Progressive for the year   | Progressive for the year   | Progressive for the year   | Progressive for the year   | As on 30.11.2015   | As on 30.11.2015   | As on 30.11.2015   |
|---------------------------------|----------------------------|----------------------------|----------------------------|-------------------|-------------------|--------------------------|-------------------|----------------------------|----------------------------|----------------------------|----------------------------|----------------------------|--------------------|--------------------|--------------------|
| Name of SEB & Power Companies   | Disputed                   | Undisputed                 | Total                      | Billing           | Actual Realisn    | EB, Royalty, Cess Adjsts | Total Realisn     | Billing                    | Actual Realisn             | EB, Royalty, Cess Adjsts   | Total Realisn              | Other Adjsts               | Disputed           | Undisputed         | Total              |
| NTECL                           |                            |                            |                            | 38.90             | 34.36             |                          | 34.36             | 226.62                     | 212.57                     |                            | 212.57                     | -14.05                     |                    |                    |                    |
| DVC                             | 184.54                     | 1,188.60                   | 1,373.14                   | 348.55            | 285.65            | 30.00                    | 315.65            | 3,199.82                   | 2,722.68                   | 277.19                     | 2,999.87                   | -51.03                     | 226.90             | 1,295.16           | 1,522.06           |
| NTPC                            | 901.42                     | 1,069.84                   | 1,971.26                   | 2,002.57          | 2,075.12          |                          | 2,075.12          | 15,717.69                  | 15,985.38                  |                            | 15,985.38                  | -989.64                    | 174.54             | 539.39             | 713.93             |
| KBUNL                           |                            | 9.03                       | 9.03                       | 9.01              | 11.70             |                          | 11.70             | 141.00                     | 109.70                     |                            | 109.70                     | -40.33                     | 0.02               | -0.02              |                    |
| APCPL (Aravali)                 |                            |                            |                            | 34.49             | 30.00             |                          | 30.00             | 491.47                     | 441.00                     |                            | 441.00                     | -50.47                     |                    | 0.00               | 0.00               |
| DCC                             |                            | 5.35                       | 5.35                       |                   |                   |                          |                   | 6.57                       | 8.23                       |                            | 8.23                       |                            |                    | 3.69               | 3.69               |
| NTPC SAIL                       |                            |                            |                            |                   |                   |                          |                   | 150.02                     | 150.02                     |                            | 150.02                     |                            |                    |                    |                    |
| Total CPU's                     | 1,085.96                   | 2,272.82                   | 3,358.78                   | 2,433.52          | 2,436.83          | 30.00                    | 2,466.83          | 19,933.19                  | 19,629.58                  | 277.19                     | 19,906.77                  | -1,145.52                  | 401.46             | 1,838.22           | 2,239.68           |
| BSEB (BSPHCL)                   | 181.19                     | 22.05                      | 203.24                     |                   |                   |                          |                   | 7.45                       |                            |                            |                            | -7.44                      | 181.48             | 21.77              | 203.25             |
| JSEB                            | 49.96                      | 161.65                     | 211.61                     | 4.19              |                   |                          |                   | 33.73                      | 40.00                      |                            | 40.00                      | -0.33                      | 46.36              | 158.65             | 205.01             |
| UPRVUNL                         | 45.30                      | 578.38                     | 623.68                     | 345.16            | 358.47            |                          | 358.47            | 2,909.13                   | 3,172.01                   | 40.53                      | 3,212.54                   | -27.89                     | 43.52              | 248.86             | 292.38             |
| PSPCL                           | 72.87                      | 59.39                      | 132.26                     | 101.35            | 156.17            |                          | 156.17            | 898.27                     | 937.75                     |                            | 937.75                     | 0.32                       | 74.59              | 18.51              | 93.10              |
| TANGEDCO (TNEB)                 | 78.98                      | 7.68                       | 86.66                      | 200.34            | 169.09            |                          | 169.09            | 1,524.80                   | 1,394.42                   |                            | 1,394.42                   | -47.34                     | 83.21              | 86.49              | 169.70             |
| HPGCL                           | 10.87                      | 90.28                      | 101.15                     | 209.67            | 187.93            |                          | 187.93            | 1,049.49                   | 918.92                     |                            | 918.92                     | -135.85                    | 24.17              | 71.70              | 95.87              |
| RRVUNL                          | 48.39                      | 387.48                     | 435.87                     | 144.00            | 171.35            |                          | 171.35            | 1,362.60                   | 1,142.55                   |                            | 1,142.55                   | 50.54                      | 48.39              | 658.07             | 706.46             |
| MAHAGENCO (MSPGCL)              | 17.53                      | 631.98                     | 649.51                     | 638.66            | 623.48            |                          | 623.48            | 4,596.85                   | 4,742.10                   |                            | 4,742.10                   | -169.31                    | 16.62              | 318.33             | 334.95             |
| MPPGCL                          | 106.37                     | 1,066.83                   | 1,173.20                   | 284.08            | 353.71            |                          | 353.71            | 2,107.07                   | 2,482.17                   |                            | 2,482.17                   | -35.31                     | 106.37             | 656.42             | 762.79             |
| CSPGCL                          | 26.71                      | 460.91                     | 487.62                     | 115.97            | 90.29             |                          | 90.29             | 934.55                     | 949.77                     |                            | 949.77                     | -2.17                      | 26.71              | 443.52             | 470.23             |
| GSECL                           | 3.95                       | 127.77                     | 131.72                     | 201.31            | 170.18            |                          | 170.18            | 1,141.05                   | 1,336.89                   |                            | 1,336.89                   | 89.50                      | 3.95               | 21.43              | 25.38              |
| WBSEB                           | 1.29                       |                            | 1.29                       |                   |                   |                          |                   |                            |                            |                            |                            |                            | 1.29               |                    | 1.29               |
| WBPDCL                          | 209.35                     | 1,316.03                   | 1,525.38                   | 272.69            | 238.00            | 0.50                     | 238.50            | 2,243.27                   | 2,033.00                   | 82.11                      | 2,115.11                   | -23.85                     | 31.79              | 1,597.90           | 1,629.69           |
| APGENCO                         | 0.16                       | 3.50                       | 3.66                       | 60.32             | 49.52             |                          | 49.52             | 500.34                     | 339.47                     |                            | 339.47                     | -133.16                    | 0.16               | 31.21              | 31.37              |
| KPCL                            |                            | 70.40                      | 70.40                      | 57.24             | 38.25             |                          | 38.25             | 591.66                     | 474.29                     |                            | 474.29                     | -8.76                      |                    | 179.01             | 179.01             |
| DPL                             | 22.13                      | 65.24                      | 87.37                      | 42.11             | 43.40             |                          | 43.40             | 235.32                     | 237.05                     |                            | 237.05                     | -10.39                     | 22.89              | 52.36              | 75.25              |
| IPGCL (DVB)                     | 0.15                       | 16.71                      | 16.86                      |                   |                   |                          |                   | 7.29                       | 6.60                       |                            | 6.60                       |                            | 0.15               | 17.40              | 17.55              |
| DPS                             | 2.50                       | -1.42                      | 1.08                       |                   |                   |                          | 0.37              |                            |                            |                            |                            |                            | 2.50               | -1.42              | 1.08               |
| TSGENCO                         |                            |                            |                            |                   | 0.37              |                          |                   | 0.76                       | 8.48                       |                            | 8.48                       | 7.72                       |                    |                    |                    |
| TVNL                            | 18.49                      | 538.77                     | 557.26                     | 30.33             | 19.80             |                          | 19.80             | 269.48                     | 220.80                     |                            | 220.80                     |                            | 20.99              | 584.95             | 605.94             |
| OPGC                            | 2.11                       | 4.07                       | 6.18                       | 19.42             | 29.30             |                          | 29.30             | 191.66                     | 213.00                     |                            | 213.00                     | 17.27                      | 2.11               |                    | 2.11               |
| Total State GenCos              | 898.30                     | 5,607.70                   | 6,506.00                   | 2,726.84          | 2,699.31          | 0.50                     | 2,699.81          | 20,604.77                  | 20,649.27                  | 122.64                     | 20,771.91                  | -436.45                    | 737.25             | 5,165.16           | 5,902.41           |

| VEDANTA (BALCO)                 |          |          |          | 5.91        | 8.82        |       | 8.82        | 2.91   | 38.37         | 49.68         |        | 49.68         | 11.31        |          |          |          |
|---------------------------------|----------|----------|----------|-------------|-------------|-------|-------------|--------|---------------|---------------|--------|---------------|--------------|----------|----------|----------|
| CESC                            | 0.18     | 9.68     | 9.86     | 58.04       | 78.31       |       | 78.31       |        | 511.36        | 499.26        |        | 499.26 -11.16 | 0.26         |          | 10.54    | 10.80    |
| Torrent Power (AEC)             |          | 0.37     | 0.37     | 31.30       | 10.99       |       | 10.99       |        | 151.67        | 135.72        |        | 135.72        | 3.99         |          | 20.31    | 20.31    |
| Reliance (BSES)                 | 0.12     | 3.01     | 3.13     | 19.12       | 24.42       |       | 24.42       | 5.30   | 181.13        | 192.47        |        | 192.47        | 8.21         | 0.12     | -0.12    |          |
| CLP Power (incl. MGTPS/Jhajjar) |          |          |          | 67.43       | 53.00       |       | 53.00       |        | 438.94        | 321.70        |        | 321.70        | -110.98      |          | 6.26     | 6.26     |
| BOKARO PS                       | 0.16     |          | 0.16     | 41.57       | 15.00       |       | 15.00       |        | 323.02        | 245.04        |        | 245.04        | -66.89       | 0.13     | 11.12    | 11.25    |
| Reliance (ROSA PS)              |          |          |          | 84.28       | 80.58       |       | 80.58       |        | 544.90        | 565.90        |        | 565.90        | 21.00        |          |          |          |
| CESC (Haldia E.)                |          |          |          | 19.96       | 17.30       |       | 17.30       |        | 133.14        | 110.89        |        | 110.89        | -13.51       |          | 8.74     | 8.74     |
| Wardha P.                       |          |          |          | 30.40       | 26.63       |       | 26.63       |        | 224.65        | 194.55        |        | 194.55        | -30.10       |          |          |          |
| Bajaj P.                        |          |          |          | 40.68       | 38.63       |       | 38.63       |        | 224.52        | 220.59        |        | 220.59        | -3.93        |          | 0.00     | 0.00     |
| Maithon Power                   | 0.03     |          | 0.03     | 77.38       | 82.89       |       | 82.89       |        | 378.55        | 375.70        |        | 375.70        | 0.12         | 1.88     | 1.12     | 3.00     |
| Adani Power                     |          |          |          | 38.73       | 38.73       |       | 38.73       |        | 403.31        | 403.31        |        | 403.31        |              |          |          |          |
| KSK Mahanadi                    |          |          |          | 27.57       | 27.57       |       | 27.57       |        | 201.69        | 201.69        |        | 201.69        |              |          |          |          |
| DB Power                        |          |          |          | 1.41        | 1.41        |       | 1.41        |        | 9.52          | 9.52          |        | 9.52          |              |          |          |          |
| Ratan India [India bull]        |          |          |          | 20.51       | 20.51       |       | 20.51       |        | 196.98        | 196.98        |        | 196.98        |              |          |          |          |
| M B. Power                      |          |          |          | 10.85       | 10.85       |       | 10.85       |        | 85.64         | 85.64         |        | 85.64         |              |          |          |          |
| EMCO Energy                     |          |          |          | 12.91       | 12.91       |       | 12.91       |        | 150.06        | 150.06        |        | 150.06        |              |          |          |          |
| NAVA Power                      |          |          |          | 19.77       | 19.77       |       | 19.77       |        | 300.71        | 300.71        |        | 300.71        |              |          |          |          |
| LANCO JP Bina                   |          |          |          | 9.31        | 9.31        |       | 9.31 1.32   |        | 90.85 23.40   | 90.85 15.36   |        | 90.85 15.36   |              |          | 8.04     | 8.04     |
| Jindal                          |          |          |          | 9.36        | 1.32        |       |             |        | 28.05         | 28.05         |        | 28.05         |              |          |          |          |
| Power                           |          |          |          |             |             |       |             |        |               |               |        |               |              |          |          |          |
| Maruti Clean Coal               |          |          |          |             |             |       |             |        | 2.41          | 2.41          |        | 2.41          |              |          |          |          |
| Adani Power VEDANTA (SSL)       |          |          |          | 80.96 67.76 | 78.61 61.03 |       | 78.61 61.03 |        | 727.35 285.38 | 692.77 286.12 |        | 692.77 286.12 | -34.58 46.32 |          | 45.58    | 45.58    |
| GMR                             |          | 9.03     | 9.03     | 25.37       | 23.75       |       | 23.75       |        | 157.82        | 164.54        |        | 164.54        | 6.72         |          | 9.03     | 9.03     |
| NTPL                            |          |          |          | 7.01        | 9.16        |       | 9.16        |        | 9.24          | 9.16          |        | 9.16          | -0.08        |          |          |          |
| Hinduja NPL                     |          |          |          | 6.01        | 12.54       |       | 12.54       |        | 6.01          | 12.54         |        | 12.54         | 6.53         |          |          |          |
| THERMAL P-TECH                  |          |          |          | 12.09       | 9.90        |       | 9.90        |        | 72.95         | 55.76         |        | 55.76         | -17.19       |          |          |          |
| TALWANDI SABO                   |          |          |          | 25.77       | 20.00       |       | 20.00       |        | 135.84        | 56.00         |        | 56.00         | -65.75       |          | 14.09    | 14.09    |
| Prayagraj (Jaypee)              |          |          |          | 3.40        |             |       |             |        | 19.35         | 46.03         |        | 46.03         | 26.68        |          |          |          |
| Total Other Power               | 0.49     | 22.09    | 22.58    | 854.86      | 793.94      |       | 793.94      | 8.21   | 6,056.81      | 5,719.00      |        | 5,719.00      | -223.29      | 2.39     | 134.71   | 137.10   |
| TOTAL Power                     | 1,984.75 | 7,902.61 | 9,887.36 | 6,011.82    | 5,930.08    | 30.50 | 5,960.58    | 8.21   | 46,575.42     | 45,951.82     | 399.83 | 46,351.65     | -1,831.94    | 1,141.10 | 7,138.09 | 8,279.19 |

*********