Lok Sabha Question No. 102 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2023-07-20
Subject: Implementation Status of Smart Cities Mission
Ministry: HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
Asked by: Gajanan Chandrakant Kirtikar, Kalaben Mohanbhai Delkar, Hemant Tukaram Godse

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

## MINISTRY OF HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS LOK SABHA

## UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 102 TO BE ANSWERED ON JULY 20, 2023

## IMPLEMENTATION STATUS OF SMART CITIES MISSION

NO. 102. SHRI GAJANAN KIRTIKAR: SHRIMATI DELKAR KALABEN MOHANBHAI: SHRI HEMANT TUKARAM GODSE:

Will  the  Minister  of  HOUSING  AND  URBAN  AFFAIRS  be  pleased  to state:

- (a) whether the Smart Cities Mission (SCM) is lagging behind with respect to the implementation of projects in various parts of the country;
- (b) if  so,  the  details  thereof,  State-wise,  especially  of  Dadra  and  Nagar
- Haveli, Daman & Diu and Maharashtra;
- (c) whether the Government proposes to develop any model to improve the performance of cities lagging behind and if so, the details thereof; and
- (d) the  list  showing  outstanding  performance  of  cities  and  the  cities performing  poorly  under  the  SCM,  State/UT-wise  including  Dadra  and Nagar Haveli, Daman and Diu and Maharashtra?

ANSWER THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS (SHRI KAUSHAL KISHORE)

(a) to (d) : Government of India launched Smart Cities Mission (SCM) on 25 June  2015.    100  Smart  Cities  have  been  selected  through  4  rounds  of competition from January 2016 to June 2018.

As  on  7  July  2023,  work  orders  have  been  issued  by  100  Smart  Cities  in 7,978 projects; of which 5,909 projects (74%) have been completed. As on 7 July  2023,  ₹  73,454  crore  has  been  released  for  Smart  Cities  of  which  ₹ 66,023 crore (90%) has been utilized. State/Union Territory(UT)/Smart Citywise progress, including those in Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Daman & Diu and Maharashtra is given in Annexure-I.

The implementation of SCM at the City level is done by SPV created for the purpose. At State level, Mission implementation is coordinated by the State Level  High  Powered  Steering  Committee  (HPSC).      At  the  National  level, implementation  of  SCM  is  monitored  by  an  Apex  Committee  headed  by Secretary,  Ministry  of  Housing  and  Urban  Affairs  (MoHUA).    Nominee Directors of MoHUA on the Boards of SPVs monitor progress in respective cities on a regular basis.  MoHUA regularly interacts with the States/Smart Cities  through  video  conferences,  review  meetings,  field  visits,  regional workshops etc. Smart Cities are assessed on various parameters including, but  not  limited  to,  project  implementation  and  utilization  of  funds  through the Real Time Online Geospatial Management Information System (GMIS).  In addition, SCM had launched a concept of Sister Cities for 20 leading cities to support the laggard 20 cities.

So as to assess the performance of Smart Cities and inculcate the spirit of healthy  competition,  a  dynamic  system  of  ranking  has  been  introduced which  considers  various  quantitative  and  qualitative  parameters.    The rankings, as on 7 July 2023, are given in Annexure-I.

The period of implementation of SCM has been extended upto June 2024, and  all  Smart  Cities  are  expected  to  complete  their  projects  within  the stipulated time.

*****

## State/UT/Smart City-wise ranking and progress of projects of Smart Cities

(Amount in ₹ Crore)

| State/UT/City           | Rank   | Ongoing         | Ongoing   | Completed       | Completed   | Total           | Total    |
|-------------------------|--------|-----------------|-----------|-----------------|-------------|-----------------|----------|
| State/UT/City           | Rank   | No. of Projects | Amount    | No. of Projects | Amount      | No. of Projects | Amount   |
| Andaman Nicobar Islands | 33     | 12              | 683.32    | 7               | 39.65       | 19              | 722.97   |
| Port Blair              | 97     | 12              | 683.32    | 7               | 39.65       | 19              | 722.97   |
| Andhra Pradesh          | 14     | 76              | 3768.92   | 203             | 3083.39     | 279             | 6852.31  |
| Amaravati               | 59     | 7               | 302.86    | 12              | 627.15      | 19              | 930.01   |
| Kakinada                | 34     | 22              | 787.11    | 72              | 1123.13     | 94              | 1910.24  |
| Tirupati                | 83     | 42              | 1562.56   | 63              | 424.27      | 105             | 1986.83  |
| Visakhapatnam           | 51     | 5               | 1116.39   | 56              | 908.84      | 61              | 2025.23  |
| Arunachal Pradesh       | 28     | 51              | 768.19    | 24              | 263.92      | 75              | 1032.11  |
| Itanagar                | 88     | 25              | 369.55    | 7               | 151.06      | 32              | 520.61   |
| Pasighat                | 93     | 26              | 398.64    | 17              | 112.86      | 43              | 511.50   |
| Assam                   | 30     | 12              | 851.31    | 10              | 93.86       | 22              | 945.17   |
| Guwahati                | 94     | 12              | 851.31    | 10              | 93.86       | 22              | 945.17   |
| Bihar                   | 23     | 51              | 3028.94   | 92              | 2789.35     | 143             | 5818.29  |
| Bhagalpur               | 60     | 11              | 687.16    | 14              | 842.32      | 25              | 1529.48  |
| Biharsharif             | 79     | 10              | 718.44    | 41              | 705.80      | 51              | 1424.24  |
| Muzaffarpur             | 89     | 16              | 964.31    | 12              | 220.78      | 28              | 1185.09  |
| Patna                   | 77     | 14              | 659.03    | 25              | 1020.45     | 39              | 1679.48  |
| Chandigarh              | 9      | 13              | 1479.42   | 85              | 1729.20     | 98              | 3208.62  |
| Chandigarh              | 37     | 13              | 1479.42   | 85              | 1729.20     | 98              | 3208.62  |
| Chhattisgarh            | 21     | 151             | 2929.76   | 379             | 2407.47     | 530             | 5337.23  |
| Atal Nagar              | 90     | 42              | 737.40    | 11              | 206.36      | 53              | 943.76   |
| Bilaspur                | 75     | 70              | 1539.26   | 67              | 1081.12     | 137             | 2620.38  |
| Raipur                  | 54     | 39              | 653.10    | 301             | 1119.99     | 340             | 1773.09  |
| Dadra and Nagar Haveli  | 22     | 36              | 833.99    | 8               | 270.64      | 44              | 1104.63  |
| Silvassa                | 76     | 36              | 833.99    | 8               | 270.64      | 44              | 1104.63  |
| Daman and Diu           | 31     | 33              | 859.42    | 22              | 251.09      | 55              | 1110.51  |
| Diu                     | 95     | 33              | 859.42    | 22              | 251.09      | 55              | 1110.51  |
| Delhi                   | 17     | 32              | 578.16    | 106             | 709.49      | 138             | 1287.65  |
| NDMC                    | 67     | 32              | 578.16    | 106             | 709.49      | 138             | 1287.65  |
| Goa                     | 16     | 23              | 669.88    | 26              | 383.89      | 49              | 1053.77  |
| Panaji                  | 62     | 23              | 669.88    | 26              | 383.89      | 49              | 1053.77  |
| Gujarat                 | 5      | 59              | 3384.95   | 285             | 9087.17     | 344             | 12472.12 |
| Ahmedabad               | 3      | 3               | 792.59    | 67              | 2511.30     | 70              | 3303.89  |
| Dahod                   | 44     | 12              | 325.75    | 25              | 672.99      | 37              | 998.74   |
| Gandhinagar             | 71     | 8               | 506.00    | 26              | 500.86      | 34              | 1006.86  |
| Rajkot                  | 50     | 29              | 1167.63   | 42              | 993.84      | 71              | 2161.47  |
| Surat                   | 1      | 3               | 245.88    | 79              | 2811.88     | 82              | 3057.76  |
| Vadodara                | 28     | 4               | 347.10    | 46              | 1596.30     | 50              | 1943.40  |
| Haryana                 | 13     | 59              | 823.22    | 105             | 1340.07     | 164             | 2163.29  |
| Faridabad               | 57     | 20              | 309.60    | 25              | 621.44      | 45              | 931.04   |
| Karnal                  | 52     | 39              | 513.62    | 80              | 718.63      | 119             | 1232.25  |
| Himachal Pradesh        | 25     | 138             | 899.59    | 163             | 719.20      | 301             | 1618.79  |

| State/UT/City      | Rank   | Ongoing         | Ongoing       | Completed       | Completed       | Total           | Total    |
|--------------------|--------|-----------------|---------------|-----------------|-----------------|-----------------|----------|
| State/UT/City      | Rank   | No. of Projects | Amount        | No. of Projects | Amount          | No. of Projects | Amount   |
| Dharamshala        | 74     | 39              | 342.19        | 42              | 315.95          | 81              | 658.14   |
| Shimla             | 86     | 99              | 557.40        | 121             | 403.25          | 220             | 960.65   |
| Jammu and Kashmir  | 18     | 122             | 3681.53       | 187             | 4055.30         | 309             | 7736.83  |
| Jammu              | 66     | 40              | 2102.52       | 84              | 1479.35         | 124             | 3581.87  |
| Srinagar           | 69     | 82              | 1579.01       | 103             | 2575.95         | 185             | 4154.96  |
| Jharkhand          | 1      | 9               | 1345.22       | 18              | 1281.64         | 27              | 2626.86  |
| Ranchi             | 14     | 9               | 1345.22       | 18              | 1281.64         | 27              | 2626.86  |
| Karnataka          | 3      | 86              | 3971.92       | 828             | 11836.62        | 914             | 15808.54 |
| Belagavi           | 20     | 16              | 1308.33       | 203             | 2205.89         | 219             | 3514.22  |
| Bengaluru          | 29     | 8               | 159.08        | 42              | 916.82          | 50              | 1075.90  |
| Davanagere         | 16     | 15              | 472.41        | 112             | 1542.30         | 127             | 2014.71  |
| Hubballi - Dharwad | 27     | 6               | 969.39        | 72              | 1887.95         | 78              | 2857.34  |
| Mangaluru          | 38     | 23              | 667.73        | 80              | 1998.88         | 103             | 2666.61  |
| Shivamogga         | 8      | 6               | 86.32         | 103             | 1292.93         | 109             | 1379.25  |
| Tumakuru           | 6      | 12              | 308.66        | 216             | 1991.85         | 228             | 2300.51  |
| Kerala             | 20     | 58              | 1698.60       | 80              | 1224.80         | 138             | 2923.40  |
| Kochi              | 68     | 23              | 832.98        | 41              | 847.95          | 64              | 1680.93  |
| Thiruvananthapuram | 80     | 35              | 865.62        | 39              | 376.85          | 74              | 1242.47  |
| Lakshadweep        | 36     | 4               | 108.87        | 5               | 4.76            | 9               | 113.63   |
| Kavaratti          | 100    | 4               | 108.87        | 5               | 4.76            | 9               | 113.63   |
| Madhya Pradesh     | 8      | 184             | 9703.16       | 619             | 9668.01         | 803             | 19371.17 |
| Bhopal             | 4      | 12              | 698.40        | 78              | 2737.09         | 90              | 3435.49  |
| Gwalior            | 64     | 14              | 452.08        | 54              | 1019.80         | 68              | 1471.88  |
| Indore             | 13     | 25              | 3509.91       | 221             | 2797.64         | 246             | 6307.55  |
| Jabalpur           | 36     | 35              | 2321.55       | 102             | 933.55          | 137             | 3255.10  |
| Sagar              | 48     | 18              | 989.71        | 62              | 819.66          | 80              | 1809.37  |
| Satna              | 78     | 43              | 981.11        | 38              | 408.97          | 81              | 1390.08  |
| Ujjain             | 40     | 37              | 750.40        | 64              | 951.30          | 101             | 1701.70  |
| Maharashtra        | 10     | 73              | 6904.78       | 245             | 9511.80         | 318             | 16416.58 |
| Aurangabad         | 35     | 10              | 2263.97       | 36              | 1282.90         | 46              | 3546.87  |
| Kalyan - Dombivali | 81     | 6               | 862.90        | 11              | 498.96          | 17              | 1361.86  |
| Nagpur             | 65     | 20              | 933.82        | 10              | 1035.19         | 30              | 1969.01  |
| Nashik             | 49     | 12              | 718.73        | 40              | 2558.83         | 52              | 3277.56  |
| Pimpri - Chinchwad | 22     | 6               | 394.43        | 19              | 942.13          | 25              | 1336.56  |
| Pune               | 18     | 3               | 233.08        | 45              | 1589.62         | 48              | 1822.70  |
| Solapur            | 43     | 5               | 629.08        | 43              | 627.48          | 48              | 1256.56  |
| Thane              | 82     | 11              | 868.77        | 41              | 976.69          | 52              | 1845.46  |
| Manipur            | 32     | 13              | 457.62        | 12              | 55.40           | 25              | 513.02   |
| Imphal             | 96     | 13              | 457.62        | 12              | 55.40           | 25              | 513.02   |
| Meghalaya          | 34     | 15              | 745.30        | 2               | 20.14           | 17              | 765.44   |
| Shillong           | 98     | 15              | 745.30        | 2               | 20.14           | 17              | 765.44   |
| Mizoram            | 29     | 36              | 389.81        | 7               | 123.49          | 43              | 513.30   |
| Nagaland           | 15     | 9               | 258.97        | 31              | 430.33          | 40              | 689.30   |
|                    | 56     | 9               |               |                 |                 | 40              | 689.30   |
| Kohima             | 7      | 14              | 258.97 965.33 | 31              | 430.33          | 99              | 3672.63  |
| Odisha Bhubaneswar | 24     | 9               | 607.71        | 85 26           | 2707.30 1552.06 | 35              | 2159.77  |
| Rourkela           | 47     | 5               | 357.62        | 59              | 1155.24         | 64              | 1512.86  |

| State/UT/City    | Rank   | Ongoing         | Ongoing   | Completed       | Completed   | Total           | Total      |
|------------------|--------|-----------------|-----------|-----------------|-------------|-----------------|------------|
| State/UT/City    | Rank   | No. of Projects | Amount    | No. of Projects | Amount      | No. of Projects | Amount     |
| Puducherry       | 35     | 70              | 930.80    | 23              | 17.18       | 93              | 947.98     |
| Puducherry       | 99     | 70              | 930.80    | 23              | 17.18       | 93              | 947.98     |
| Punjab           | 19     | 53              | 3494.03   | 146             | 2278.90     | 199             | 5772.93    |
| Amritsar         | 73     | 8               | 1467.91   | 34              | 1188.36     | 42              | 2656.27    |
| Jalandhar        | 84     | 20              | 1301.09   | 58              | 290.02      | 78              | 1591.11    |
| Ludhiana         | 45     | 25              | 725.03    | 54              | 800.52      | 79              | 1525.55    |
| Rajasthan        | 2      | 59              | 1681.92   | 522             | 7384.85     | 581             | 9066.77    |
| Ajmer            | 23     | 19              | 477.54    | 159             | 1746.04     | 178             | 2223.58    |
| Jaipur           | 11     | 25              | 725.48    | 151             | 2263.46     | 176             | 2988.94    |
| Kota             | 15     | 11              | 343.34    | 75              | 1791.20     | 86              | 2134.54    |
| Udaipur          | 10     | 4               | 135.56    | 137             | 1584.15     | 141             | 1719.71    |
| Sikkim           | 24     | 45              | 1753.07   | 18              | 718.66      | 63              | 2471.73    |
| Gangtok          | 91     | 32              | 1022.82   | 6               | 193.67      | 38              | 1216.49    |
| Namchi           | 61     | 13              | 730.25    | 12              | 524.99      | 25              | 1255.24    |
| Tamil Nadu       | 4      | 122             | 3110.58   | 588             | 14077.59    | 710             | 17188.17   |
| Chennai          | 31     | 5               | 272.59    | 43              | 824.29      | 48              | 1096.88    |
| Coimbatore       | 32     | 11              | 678.68    | 61              | 776.14      | 72              | 1454.82    |
| Erode            | 25     | 11              | 224.45    | 43              | 1079.67     | 54              | 1304.12    |
| Madurai          | 7      | 0               | 0.00      | 16              | 1899.66     | 16              | 1899.66    |
| Salem            | 41     | 16              | 348.73    | 80              | 661.43      | 96              | 1010.16    |
| Thanjavur        | 30     | 11              | 175.56    | 94              | 827.77      | 105             | 1003.33    |
| Thoothukudi      | 39     | 12              | 352.38    | 59              | 708.74      | 71              | 1061.12    |
| Tiruchirappalli  | 26     | 18              | 396.36    | 65              | 1151.32     | 83              | 1547.68    |
| Tirunelveli      | 19     | 25              | 257.90    | 59              | 1586.27     | 84              | 1844.17    |
| Tiruppur         | 17     | 4               | 269.21    | 24              | 2601.19     | 28              | 2870.40    |
| Vellore          | 9      | 9               | 134.72    | 44              | 1961.11     | 53              | 2095.83    |
| Telangana        | 26     | 71              | 1582.97   | 59              | 1233.97     | 130             | 2816.94    |
| Greater Warangal | 87     | 41              | 807.98    | 38              | 815.81      | 79              | 1623.79    |
| Karimnagar       | 72     | 30              | 774.99    | 21              | 418.16      | 51              | 1193.15    |
| Tripura          | 27     | 12              | 908.10    | 65              | 543.50      | 77              | 1451.60    |
| Agartala         | 85     | 12              | 908.10    | 65              | 543.50      | 77              | 1451.60    |
| Uttar Pradesh    | 6      | 236             | 3971.81   | 640             | 16613.00    | 876             | 20584.81   |
| Agra             | 2      | 1               | 1.88      | 61              | 2366.92     | 62              | 2368.80    |
| Aligarh          | 58     | 18              | 562.36    | 34              | 1278.12     | 52              | 1840.48    |
| Bareilly         | 46     | 12              | 418.55    | 77              | 1058.42     | 89              | 1476.97    |
| Jhansi           | 21     | 19              | 331.30    | 60              | 1538.69     | 79              | 1869.99    |
| Kanpur           | 12     | 14              | 324.82    | 78              | 2871.15     | 92              | 3195.97    |
| Lucknow          | 42     | 32              | 562.93    | 71              | 1563.48     | 103             | 2126.41    |
| Moradabad        | 63     | 15              | 593.93    | 24              | 906.74      | 39              | 1500.67    |
| Prayagraj        | 33     | 37              | 290.44    | 92              | 1231.14     | 129             | 1521.58    |
| Saharanpur       | 70     | 81              | 761.49    | 33              | 525.37      | 114             | 1286.86    |
| Varanasi         | 5 11   | 7               | 124.11    | 110             | 3272.97     | 117             | 3397.08    |
| Uttarakhand      |        | 13              | 740.61    | 29              | 695.60      | 42              | 1436.21    |
| Dehradun         | 53     | 13              | 740.61    | 29              | 695.60      | 42              | 1436.21    |
| New Town Kolkata | 55     | 19              | 847.09    |                 | 766.60      | 204             | 1613.69    |
|                  |        |                 |           | 185             |             |                 |            |
| Grand Total      |        | 2069            | 70,811.16 | 5909            | 108,417.83  | 7978            | 179,228.99 |

Source: SCM Geospatial Management Information System (GMIS) as on 7 July 2023