Lok Sabha Question No. 4688 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2022-03-31
Subject: Group Housing Societies
Ministry: HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
Asked by: Bhartruhari Mahtab, Pallab Lochan Das

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

## MINISTRY OF HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 4688

## TO BE ANSWERED ON MARCH 31, 2022 GROUP HOUSING SOCIETIES

NO. 4688.

SHRI BHARTRUHARI MAHTAB: SHRI PALLAB LOCHAN DAS:

Will the Minister of HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS be pleased to state:

- (a) the details of Cooperative Group  Housing Societies in Delhi including Dwarka permitted by Delhi Development Authority (DDA) to increase their Floor Area Ratio (FAR), with date(s) of permission, during the last five years;
- (b) the details of Societies whose requests have been rejectedlpending by DDA for increase FAR and the reasons for the same;
- (c) Whether DDA has been giving permission to Societies for utilization of additional FAR on existing structures, compromising the structural safety of existing buildings and risk to living inhabitants; and
- (d) If so, whether the permission so granted have not been in contravention of revised guidelines being followed 23.04.2012 for utilization of additional FAR permissible as per Master Plan for Delhi-2021 and if So, the details thereof?

## MINISTRY OF HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS

## ANSWER THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE (SHRI KAUSHAL KISHORE)

(a): Delhi Development Authority (DDA) has informed that total 37 Cooperatives Group Housing Societies (CGHS) in Delhi including 34 CGHS in Dwarka have been   granted sanction of building  plans by DDA for utilization of additional Floor Area Ratio (FAR) as per Master Plan for Delhi (MPD) 2021 and Unified Building Bye Laws (UBBL) for Delhi -2016 since last five yearsThe details are enclosed as Annexure 'A'

(b): DDA has informed that the requestslbuilding permits of total 16 CGHS in Delhi  including 13 CGHS in Dwarka have been rejected by DDA for utilization of additional FAR since last five yearsThe reasons rejection of such requests were non compliance of parameters of UBBL for Delhi 2016 and MPD 2021. The details are enclosed as Annexure 'B'. DDA has further informed that requestslbuilding permits of total 07 CGHS in Delhi (all are in Dwarka) are pending with DDA for utilization of additional FAR The reasons for pending of such requests are non compliance of shortfalls given as per the provisions of UBBL for Delhi2016 and MPD-2021. The details are enclosed as Annexure 'C' . for

(c) & (d): DDA has informed that it has been sanctioning the building plans for utilization of additional FAR on existing structures as per the provisions of MPD-2021 and UBBL for Delhi-2016 wherein certificate of structural safety is a mandatory document to be submitted by the qualified Structural Engineer while applying the building permit:

DDA has further informed that the permission for utilization of additional FAR for group housing societies is being granted as per the Gazette Notification vide S.O. 2690(E) dated 11.08.2016. This supersedes DDA office order dated 16.04.2012, which was applicable with effect from 23.04.2012.

******

## ANNEXURE 'A'

|     | FILE NO.                         | PROJECT                                 | APPROVED DATE     |
|-----|----------------------------------|-----------------------------------------|-------------------|
| 1   | CGHS/0133/19-20 KUMUDI CGHS LTD. |                                         | 27 December, 2021 |
| 2   | Dw22/0070/2021                   | HIMALAYAN CGHS LTD.                     | 15 November, 2021 |
| 3.  | DW11/0047/2021                   | CHINIOT CGHS LTD.                       | 14 October 2021   |
| 4.  | DW4/0079/20-21                   | SHREE NEW ANAMIKA CGHS                  | 23 December, 2020 |
| 5   | Dw22/0221/19-20                  | MAHAVIR CGHS LTD.                       | 10 December, 2020 |
| 6.  | DW22/0209/19-20                  | NAV SANSAD VIHAR CGHS LTD.              | 10 December, 2020 |
|     | DW7/0588/18-19                   | SARGODHA VIHAR CGHS LTD.                | 13 November, 2020 |
| 8.  | DW22/0014/20-21                  | GREEN VALLEY CGHS LTD.                  | 13 November, 2020 |
| 9   |                                  | ST. COLUMBAS CGHS LTD.                  | 13 November, 2020 |
| 10. | DW12/0208/19-20                  | MIS ABHIYAN CGHS LTD.                   | 23 September 2020 |
| 11. | DW5/0038/19-20                   | NAVIN CGHS LTD.                         | 31 October, 2019  |
| 12  | PV/0103/19-20                    | GASTA CGHS LTD_                         | 13 November, 2020 |
| 13. | DW10/0062/19-20                  | RASHTRAPATI BHAWAN CABINET AFFAIRS CGHS | 02 January, 2020  |
| 14. | DW4/0126/17-18                   | ECIL CGHS LTD.                          | 23 August, 2019   |
| 15. | DW6/0749/18-19                   | SHIVLOK CGHS LTD.                       | 23 August, 2019   |
| 16. | DW12/0575/18-19                  | DEFENCE LAND AND CANT.                  | 24 June, 2019     |
| 17. | DW12/0767/18-19                  | VIKRAM NAGAR CGHS LTD.                  | 24 June, 2019     |
| 18. | DW23P/0686/18-19                 | DABAS CGHS LTD-                         | 09 April, 2019    |
| 19  | DW2/0698/18-19                   | MANDAKINI CGHS LTD.                     | 09 April, 2019    |
| 20. | Dw3/0559/18-19                   | BALAJI CGHS LTD-                        | 23 February, 2019 |
| 21_ | DW5/0558/18-19                   | SHAHDARA CGHS LTD.                      | 22 February, 2019 |
| 22. | DW5/0595/18-19                   | SHRI GHANINATH CGHS LTD.                | 22 February, 2019 |
| 23. | DW5/0663/18-19                   | NEW PRIYADARSHANI CGHS                  | 23 February, 2019 |
| 24. | DW11/0021/19-20                  | THE SRI DURGA CGHS LTD                  | 18 November, 2019 |

| 25.   | DW10/0521/18-19   | CHANDANWARI CGHS LTD_                     | 23 August, 2019   |
|-------|-------------------|-------------------------------------------|-------------------|
| 26_   | DW11/0720/18-19   | SEEMA CGHS LTD.                           | 23 August, 2019   |
| 27_   | DW5/0435/18-19    | JAWAHARLAL CGHS LTD.                      | 17 December, 2018 |
|       | DHP/0529/18-19    | ISI CGHS LTD.                             | 17 December_ 2018 |
| 29.   | DW22/0546/18-19   | DELHI APPARTMENTS CGHS                    | 20 November, 2018 |
| 30.   | DW6/0055/18-19    | YOUNGSTER CGHS LTD.                       | 26 November, 2018 |
| 31_   | DW4/0109/17-18    | DPS CGHS LTD:                             | 14 August, 2018   |
| 32.   | DW4/0045/17-18    | RATNAKAR CGHS LTD:                        | 14 July, 2018     |
| 33_   | DW6/0044/17-18    | DIAMOND SQUARE CGHS LTD_                  | 03 July, 2018     |
| 34.   | DW6/0059/17-18    | SABKA GHAR CGHS LTD.                      | 03 July, 2018     |
|       | DW11/0161/18-19   | YOUNG ROFESSIONAL CGHS LTD.               | 03 December, 2018 |
| 36.   | DW1 1/0144/17-18  | SADBHAWNA CGHS LTD.                       | 19 November, 2018 |
| 37 .  | VP/0113/17-18     | E.LL EMPLOYEES CGHS ANAND KUNJ VIKAS PURI | 09 July, 2018     |

## ANNEXURE 'B'

| SNo.   | FILE NO.         | PROJECT                                      | Rejection Date     | Reasons for rejection as mentioned by DDA                                                                                                                                                |
|--------|------------------|----------------------------------------------|--------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|        | DW22/078 0/18-19 | HIMALAYAN                                    | 13 July, 2021      | On the request of the society, due to change the Architect, the proposal was rejected:                                                                                                   |
| 2.     | 20-21            | RUDRA CGH.S LTD.                             | 18 February, 2021  | Non submission 0 environment clearance.                                                                                                                                                  |
| 3.     | 7/20-21          | UNIVERSAL BROTHERHOO D CO_ OP . GR HSG. SOC. | 12 November, 2020  | On the request of the society, due to demise of the Architect, the proposal was rejected:                                                                                                |
| 4      | DW4/0144/ 19-20  | SHREE NEW ANAMIKA CGHS LTD:                  | 10 September, 2020 | Due to non-submission corrected drawings as per UBBL for Delhi-2016 norms-                                                                                                               |
| 5.     | DW22/017 8/19-20 | GREEN VALLEY CGHS                            | 11 April, 2020     | Non submission of environment clearance-                                                                                                                                                 |
|        | DW22/006 6/19-20 | THE BHAGWATI CGHS LTD-                       | 05 February, 2021  | Non compliance 0 instruction of AAI and submission of up-to-date Extension of Time (EOT):                                                                                                |
|        | DW12/011 5/19-20 | ABHIYAN CGHS LTD.                            | 10 January, 2020   | Non-submission of the                                                                                                                                                                    |
| 8.     | DW12/082 2/18-19 | NAVSANJIVAN CGHS LTD-                        | 02 December, 2019  | Non-submission revised drawing and documents as per UBBL for Delhi-2016/MPD- 21 such as (1) dimensions and details missing (2) incomplete parking   plan (3) incorrect area calculation_ |
| 9      | DW7/0589/ 18-19  | NEHRU CGHS LTD.                              | 04 January, 2020   | Due to rejection by Delhi Urban Art Commission (DUAC) and Delhi Fire Services (DFS) and further non submission of the revised proposal:                                                  |
| 10.    | DW22/007 2/17-18 | UDYOGVIHAR CGHS                              | 29 2018 July,      | Non-submission of revised drawing and documents as per UBBL for Delhi-2016/MPD- 2021 such as (1) soil testing report (2) degreellicense of structural engineer:                          |
| 11.    | DW2/0094/ 17-18  | AARTI CGHS                                   | 30 December, p2018 | Non-compliance of DFS condition, non submission of (1) structural safety                                                                                                                 |

|    |                   |                                            |                   | certificate and (2) Form A-2 certificate of appointment professionals:                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
|----|-------------------|--------------------------------------------|-------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 12 | PV/0094/2 0-21    | RAKSHAKARA MCHARI CGHS LTD:                | 18 2022           | February, Non-submission documents like Common Occupancy-cum-Completion Certificate Request Form (COCCRF), lift manufacture certificate, up-to-date EOT, digitally signed forms, indemnity bond for basement, labour cess, DUAC proforma, incomplete layout, parking and landscape plans: |
| 13 | VP/0831/1 8-19    | AIRPORT CGHS VIKASPURI                     | 05 2021           | February, Non-submission Of revised drawing and documents as per UBBL for Delhi-2016/MPD- 2021 such as (1) incomplete layout plans (2) documents not as per prescribed format (3) incorrect area calculations-                                                                            |
| 14 | VP/0526/1 8-19    | SBI COOPERATIVE GROUP HOUSING SOCIETY LTD. | 22 2020           | February Due to non-compliance of observations of DUAC and DFS_                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| 15 | DW10/079 1/18-19  | SARAL CGHS LTD.                            | 05 December, 2019 | Non-submission Development Control Rules (PreDCR) drawing file:                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| 16 | DW1 1/074 7/18-19 | MODEST KETKI CGHS LTD.                     | 01 August, 2019   | Non submission Of environment clearance.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |

## ANNEXURE 'C'

| SNo:   | FILE NO.        | PROJECT               | Reasons for pendency as mentioned by DDA                                                                                                                                                                                                                 |
|--------|-----------------|-----------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|        | DW12/0244/20-21 | NAVSANJIVAN CGHS LTD. | Shortfalls have been given for submission of digitally signed documents, corrected layout plan, area statement & parking plans. The same is to be submitted by the Architect: yet                                                                        |
| 2.     | DW12/0233/19-20 | VIKRAM NAGAR CGHS     | Proposal is to be resubmitted by the Architect incorporating the recommendations of DUAC and DFS. yet                                                                                                                                                    |
| 3.     | DW2/0048/2021   | AARTI CGHS LTD.       | The file is sent for legal opinion as a court case related to the premise is pendin gin the Court:                                                                                                                                                       |
| 4.     | DW7/0243/20-21  | KAMAL VIHAR CGHS LTD. | Shortfalls have been given for submission of corrected Common Application Form [CAF], qualified professional and corrected drawings as per UBBL for Delhi-2016.                                                                                          |
| 5.     | DW7/0022/2021   | NEHRU CGHS LTD:       | Proposal is pending on DUAc portal for their approvalINo Objection Certificate (NOC)                                                                                                                                                                     |
| 6      | DW10/0243/2021  |                       | Shortfalls have been given for submission Of mandatory documents i.e_ Proof of educational qualification of Architect and Supervisor, copy of Authority letter and corrected drawing as per UBBL-2016. The same is yet to be submitted by the Architect- |
| 7      | DW10/0160/19-20 | PRABHAVI CGHS LTD.    | Shortfalls have been given for submission of corrected layout plan, area statement & parking plans: The same is to be submitted by the Architect: yet                                                                                                    |

******