Lok Sabha Question No. 5483 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2022-04-05
Subject: Compensation recommended by NHRC
Ministry: HOME AFFAIRS
Asked by: D. Ravikumar

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

## MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS

## LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 5483

TO BE ANSWERED ON THE 05 TH  APRIL, 2022/CHAITRA 15,1944 (SAKA)

COMPENSATION RECOMMENDED BY NHRC

5483.  SHRI RAVIKUMAR D.:

Will the Minister of HOME AFFAIRS be pleased to state:

(a) the number of cases in which National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) recommended monetary compensation for deaths or injuries caused due to police firing-encounter since 2010, State/year-wise;

(b) the amount of monetary compensation recommended by NHRC for deaths or injuries caused due to police firing-encounter since 2010, State/yearwise;

(c)  the  amount  of  monetary  compensation  paid  by  the  State  Governments following the recommendations made by NHRC for deaths or injuries caused due to police firing/encounter since 2010; and

(d) the amount of monetary compensation yet not paid by State Governments following the recommendations made by NHRC for deaths or injuries caused due  to  police  firing/encounter  since  2010,  State/year-wise  and  the  action taken in this regard?

ANSWER

MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS (SHRI NITYANAND RAI)

(a)  &  (b):-    As  per  information  received  from  the  National  Human  Rights Commission  (NHRC),  details  of  cases  (State/UT  and  year-  wise)  of  deaths caused  due  to  police  firing  and  encounter  where  NHRC  recommended monetary compensation are given at Annexure-A and AnnexureB respectively.

(c) & (d) :-  No such data is maintained by the NHRC.

******

STATEMENT SHOWING NUMBER OF CASES OF DEATH IN POLICE FIRING IN WHICH NHRC RECOMMENDED MONETARY COMPENSATION FROM 01.04.2010 TO 28.02.2022

| DURATION - 01/04/2010-31/03/2011   | DURATION - 01/04/2010-31/03/2011   | DURATION - 01/04/2010-31/03/2011   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| BIHAR                              | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 1                                  | 2500000                            |
| TELANGANA                          | 1                                  | 50000                              |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 1                                  | 100000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 4                                  | 2950000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2011-31/03/2012   | DURATION - 01/04/2011-31/03/2012   | DURATION - 01/04/2011-31/03/2012   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 2                                  | 400000                             |
| BIHAR                              | 5                                  | 3000000                            |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| JHARKHAND                          | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 1                                  | 100000                             |
| MIZORAM                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| PUNJAB                             | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 12                                 | 6500000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2012-31/03/2013   | DURATION - 01/04/2012-31/03/2013   | DURATION - 01/04/2012-31/03/2013   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| KARNATAKA                          | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 2                                  | 1500000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2013-31/03/2014   | DURATION - 01/04/2013-31/03/2014   | DURATION - 01/04/2013-31/03/2014   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| JHARKHAND                          | 2                                  | 1400000                            |
| MANIPUR                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 1                                  | 200000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 4                                  | 2100000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2014-31/03/2015   | DURATION - 01/04/2014-31/03/2015   | DURATION - 01/04/2014-31/03/2015   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| DELHI                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |

## L.S.US.Q.NO. 5483 FOR 05.04.2022

| DURATION - 01/04/2015-31/03/2016   | DURATION - 01/04/2015-31/03/2016   | DURATION - 01/04/2015-31/03/2016   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| MADHYA PRADESH                     | 2                                  | 500000                             |
| WEST BENGAL                        | 1                                  | 200000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 3                                  | 700000                             |

| DURATION - 01/04/2016-31/03/2017   | DURATION - 01/04/2016-31/03/2017   | DURATION - 01/04/2016-31/03/2017   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 1                                  | 5500000                            |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| JHARKHAND                          | 2                                  | 825000                             |
| TELANGANA                          | 1                                  | 160000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 6                                  | 7485000                            |
| DURATION - 01/04/2017-31/03/2018   | DURATION - 01/04/2017-31/03/2018   | DURATION - 01/04/2017-31/03/2018   |
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 1                                  | 450000                             |
| DELHI                              | 1                                  | 200000                             |
| JHARKHAND                          | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| RAJASTHAN                          | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 4                                  | 1450000                            |

## 2018-2019 -  IN THIS DURATION NO MONETRAY RELIEF RECOMMENDED

| DURATION - 01/04/2019-31/03/2020   | DURATION - 01/04/2019-31/03/2020   | DURATION - 01/04/2019-31/03/2020   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 1                                  | 3500000                            |
| PUNJAB                             | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 1                                  | 600000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 3                                  | 4400000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2020-31/03/2021   | DURATION - 01/04/2020-31/03/2021   | DURATION - 01/04/2020-31/03/2021   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| BIHAR                              | 2                                  | 550000                             |
| JHARKHAND                          | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| NAGALAND                           | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| SIKKIM                             | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 5                                  | 1650000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2021-28/02/2022   | DURATION - 01/04/2021-28/02/2022   | DURATION - 01/04/2021-28/02/2022   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| HIMACHAL PRADESH                   | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| WEST BENGAL                        | 1                                  | 700000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 2                                  | 1200000                            |

*****

STATEMENT  SHOWING NUMBER  OF  CASES  OF  DEATH  IN  POLICE  ENCOUNTER IN  WHICH NHRC RECOMMENDED MONETARY COMPENSATION FROM 01.04.2010 TO 28.02.2022.

| DURATION - 01/04/2010-31/03/2011   | DURATION - 01/04/2010-31/03/2011   | DURATION - 01/04/2010-31/03/2011   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ANDHRA PRADESH                     | 2                                  | 1000000                            |
| ASSAM                              | 3                                  | 3500000                            |
| HARYANA                            | 2                                  | 2000000                            |
| JHARKHAND                          | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| MADHYA PRADESH                     | 2                                  | 1000000                            |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 26                                 | 16500000                           |
| UTTARAKHAND                        | 3                                  | 2000000                            |
| TOTAL                              | 40                                 | 27500000                           |

| DURATION - 01/04/2011 - 31/03/2012   | DURATION - 01/04/2011 - 31/03/2012   | DURATION - 01/04/2011 - 31/03/2012   |
|--------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                        | No. of Cases                         | Total Amount (in Rs.)                |
| ANDHRA PRADESH                       | 1                                    | 500000                               |
| ASSAM                                | 10                                   | 6000000                              |
| BIHAR                                | 1                                    | 1000000                              |
| DELHI                                | 2                                    | 1000000                              |
| JHARKHAND                            | 3                                    | 1500000                              |
| MADHYA PRADESH                       | 1                                    | 500000                               |
| MAHARASHTRA                          | 4                                    | 2000000                              |
| MANIPUR                              | 1                                    | 600000                               |
| MEGHALAYA                            | 1                                    | 500000                               |
| UTTAR PRADESH                        | 35                                   | 21400000                             |
| UTTARAKHAND                          | 6                                    | 4100000                              |
| TOTAL                                | 65                                   | 39100000                             |

| DURATION - 01/04/2012-31/03/2013   | DURATION - 01/04/2012-31/03/2013   | DURATION - 01/04/2012-31/03/2013   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 10                                 | 6500000                            |
| BIHAR                              | 1                                  | 1500000                            |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 4                                  | 2000000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| ODISHA                             | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TELANGANA                          | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 19                                 | 10200000                           |
| UTTARAKHAND                        | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 39                                 | 22500000                           |

| DURATION - 01/04/2013-31/03/2014   | DURATION - 01/04/2013-31/03/2014   | DURATION - 01/04/2013-31/03/2014   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ARUNACHAL PRADESH                  | 1                                  | 2000000                            |
| ASSAM                              | 19                                 | 12500000                           |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| DELHI                              | 2                                  | 1000000                            |
| HARYANA                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| JHARKHAND                          | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 3                                  | 2000000                            |
| MANIPUR                            | 5                                  | 3000000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| PUNJAB                             | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 35                                 | 21000000                           |
| UTTARAKHAND                        | 1                                  | 2000000                            |
| TOTAL                              | 71                                 | 47500000                           |

## L.S.US.Q.NO. 5483 FOR 05.04.2022

| DURATION - 01/04/2014-31/03/2015   | DURATION - 01/04/2014-31/03/2015   | DURATION - 01/04/2014-31/03/2015   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| DELHI                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| MADHYA PRADESH                     | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 3                                  | 1500000                            |
| TOTAL                              | 6                                  | 3000000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2015-31/03/2016   | DURATION - 01/04/2015-31/03/2016   | DURATION - 01/04/2015-31/03/2016   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| MANIPUR                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 3                                  | 1500000                            |
| TOTAL                              | 5                                  | 2300000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2016-31/03/2017   | DURATION - 01/04/2016-31/03/2017   | DURATION - 01/04/2016-31/03/2017   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 7                                  | 4600000                            |
| DELHI                              | 2                                  | 1500000                            |
| GUJARAT                            | 1                                  | 600000                             |
| HARYANA                            | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| JHARKHAND                          | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 3                                  | 2000000                            |
| MANIPUR                            | 2                                  | 1000000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 1                                  | 2000000                            |
| TRIPURA                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 4                                  | 1900000                            |
| WEST BENGAL                        | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 24                                 | 16100000                           |

| DURATION - 01/04/2017-31/03/2018   | DURATION - 01/04/2017-31/03/2018   | DURATION - 01/04/2017-31/03/2018   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 3                                  | 1800000                            |
| BIHAR                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 3                                  | 1500000                            |
| HARYANA                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 3                                  | 4500000                            |
| MANIPUR                            | 6                                  | 3050000                            |
| PUNJAB                             | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TELANGANA                          | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 7                                  | 4000000                            |
| UTTARAKHAND                        | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 27                                 | 17350000                           |

## L.S.US.Q.NO. 5483 FOR 05.04.2022

| DURATION - 01/04/2018-31/03/2019   | DURATION - 01/04/2018-31/03/2019   | DURATION - 01/04/2018-31/03/2019   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 5                                  | 4500000                            |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 2                                  | 1000000                            |
| JHARKHAND                          | 2                                  | 2000000                            |
| MADHYA PRADESH                     | 2                                  | 2500000                            |
| MANIPUR                            | 2                                  | 1500000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 2                                  | 1500000                            |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 2                                  | 1000000                            |
| TOTAL                              | 17                                 | 14000000                           |

| DURATION - 01/04/2019-31/03/2020   | DURATION - 01/04/2019-31/03/2020   | DURATION - 01/04/2019-31/03/2020   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 5                                  | 3600000                            |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 2                                  | 1700000                            |
| JHARKHAND                          | 2                                  | 1500000                            |
| MADHYA PRADESH                     | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| MAHARASHTRA                        | 1                                  | 1000000                            |
| MANIPUR                            | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 12                                 | 9300000                            |

| DURATION - 01/04/2020-31/03/2021   | DURATION - 01/04/2020-31/03/2021   | DURATION - 01/04/2020-31/03/2021   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 8                                  | 4100000                            |
| BIHAR                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 5                                  | 2600000                            |
| JHARKHAND                          | 2                                  | 600000                             |
| MADHYA PRADESH                     | 1                                  | 1500000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| UTTAR PRADESH                      | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| WEST BENGAL                        | 2                                  | 800000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 21                                 | 10900000                           |

| DURATION - 01/04/2021-28/02/2022   | DURATION - 01/04/2021-28/02/2022   | DURATION - 01/04/2021-28/02/2022   |
|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| State/UT Name                      | No. of Cases                       | Total Amount (in Rs.)              |
| ASSAM                              | 1                                  | 1700000                            |
| BIHAR                              | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| CHHATTISGARH                       | 1                                  | 700000                             |
| DELHI                              | 1                                  | 500000                             |
| HARYANA                            | 2                                  | 1500000                            |
| MEGHALAYA                          | 1                                  | 300000                             |
| TOTAL                              | 7                                  | 5000000                            |

*****