Lok Sabha Question No. 1545 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2019-02-12
Subject: Expenditure on Smart Cities
Ministry: HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
Asked by: RAJIV PRATAP RUDY

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HOUSING & URBAN AFFAIRS

## LOK SABHA

## UNSTARRED QUESTION NO.1545

## TO BE ANSWERED ON FEBRUARY 12, 2019

## EXPENDITURE ON SMART CITIES

No. 1545.  SHRI RAJIV PRATAP RUDY:

Will the Minister of HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS be pleased to state:

- the details of the expenditure incurred by the Government for establishing smart cities in the country including Bihar along with the progress made in the development of each smart city
- (a) and the expected time frame for completion;
- (b) whether  the  funds  provided  /being  provided  is  sufficient  to convert  the  existing  cities  into  smart  cities  and  if  not,  the steps taken/being taken in this regard;
- (c) the  name  of  private  companies  and  foreign  companies  which have  shown  interest  in  smart  cities  project  and  the  name  of the cities to which foreign assistance is likely to be provided; and
- (d) whether the Government has received any additional proposal from  the  State  of  Bihar  to  be  included  under  the  Smart  City Mission and if so, the details thereof?

## ANSWER

## THE MINISTER OF STATE (INDEPENDENT CHARGE) OF THE MINISTRY OF HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS (SHRI HARDEEP SINGH PURI)

- (a) & (b) 100 smart cities have been selected for development as
- Smart cities in four rounds as follows:
- 20 Smart Cities in Round 1 in January 2016
- 13 Smart Cities in Fast Track Round 2 in May 2016
- ·
- 27 Smart Cities in Round 2 in September 2016.
- ·
- 30 Smart Cities in Round 3 in June 2017 and
- 10 Smart Cities in Round 4 (9 in January 2018 and 1 in June 2018).

A  total  of  5,151  projects  at  an  estimated  cost  of  Rs. 2,05,018 crores have been included by the 100 cities in their Smart City Proposals. As per Smart Cities Mission Statement and  Guidelines,  the  Central  Government  proposes  to  give financial  support  to  the  extent  of  Rs.  48,000  crores  over  the Mission  period  or  23%  of  the  estimated  cost  of  projects.    An equal  amount,  on  a  matching  basis,  is  to  be  provided  by  the State/Urban  Local  Body  (ULB).  Apart  from  these,  around  Rs. 42,028 crores (21%) is expected from convergence with other Private Partnerships (PPPs), around Rs. 9,843 crores (5%) from loans,

Missions, Rs. 41,022 crores (20%) from Public and remaining from other sources.

Against  Rs.  16,604.20  crore  allocated  in  the  budget  for Smart Cities  Mission  since  2015-16,  an  amount  of  Rs.  15,536 crore  has  so  far  been  released  by  Government  of  India  to States for Smart Cities.

The implementation of the Smart Cities Mission is being done  by  a  city-level  Special  Purpose  Vehicle  (SPV).  All  100 cities have incorporated Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) and appointed  Project  Management  Consultants  (PMCs).  As  on January  25,  2019,    2,748  projects  worth  Rs.  1,04,964  crore have been tendered, of which 2,032 projects worth Rs. 62,295 crore are under implementation/have been completed.

The  timeline  for  completion  of  projects  by  cities  is  five years from the date of their selection as Smart cities.

City-wise details of funds released and  progress of projects in Smart cities is at Annexure.

- (c) At  the  National  level,  Memorada  of  Understanding  (MoUs)  / Agreements for Technical Assistance have been executed with Department for International Development (DFID), United Kingdom  and  GIZ,  Germany  separately.  Under  the  Climate Smart Cities project, GIZ shall be assisting the cities of Kochi

Coimbatore and Bhubaneshwar.  An MoU has also been signed with Netherlands for Technical Assistance to the Smart cities of  Agra,  Dharamshala  and  Karnal.  At  the  State  level,  MoUs/ Agreements  for  Technical  Assistance  have  been  executed between United States Trade and Development Agency (USTDA)  &  State Governments  of  Andhra  Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh  and  Rajasthan  and  between  French  Development Agency (AFD) and Union Territories of Chandigarh, Puducherry and  State  Government  of  Maharashtra.    A  Credit  Facility Agreement  for  loan  of  EUR  100  million  and  Grant  Financing Agreement of EUR 6 million has been executed with AFD for funding  of  upto  15  innovative  Smart  City  Projects  selected through a Challenge Process from across the country. There is a  provision  for  global  expertise  to  be  provided  during  the design and implementation phases of these Projects.

In addition, various other countries, namely, Spain, Canada,  Germany,  Singapore,  South  Korea  and  Japan  have also  shown  interest  in  participating  in  the  development  of Smart Cities.

The implementation of the Smart Cities Mission is being done  by  a  city-level  Special  Purpose  Vehicle  (SPV).  Several private  companies  like  Eptisa,  Price  Water  house  Coopers, Grant  Thornton,  Ernst  and  Young,  KPMG  etc.  have  been appointed  as  Project  Management  Consultants  (PMCs)  by SPVs. Private companies  are  also expressing interest in various  projects  tendered  by  SPVs  and  executing  them  on award of work.

- (d) No, Madam.

*****

## Annexure referred to in reply to part (a) & (b) of Lok Sabha Unstarred

## Question No.1545 for 12.02.2019 regarding Expenditure on Smart Cities

State-wise/City-wise details of funds released and progress of projects under Smart Cities

Mission (in Rs. crores) - based on MIS data of Jan 25, 2019

| S.N.   | State               | Name of City    | Total funds released under SCM   | Total Value of Projects Tendered/under Tendering through all sources   | Total Value of Projects Grounded/Compl eted through all sources   |
|--------|---------------------|-----------------|----------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 1      | Andhra Pradesh      | Vishakhapatnam  | 294                              | 2247.49                                                                | 1451.22                                                           |
| 1      | Andhra Pradesh      | Tirupati        | 196                              | 1528.81                                                                | 184.86                                                            |
| 1      | Andhra Pradesh      | Kakinada        | 289                              | 1613.11                                                                | 967.36                                                            |
| 1      | Andhra Pradesh      | Amaravati       | 385                              | 1792.46                                                                | 1591.45                                                           |
| 2      | Andaman& Nicobar    |                 |                                  | 14.33                                                                  | 14.33                                                             |
| 2      | Islands             | Port Blair      | 196                              |                                                                        |                                                                   |
| 3      | Arunachal Pradesh   | Pasighat        | 60                               | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| 3      | Arunachal Pradesh   | Itanagar        | 58                               | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| 4      | Assam               | Guwahati        | 196                              | 538.25                                                                 | 25.03                                                             |
| 5      | Bihar               | Muzaffarpur     | 60                               | 180.41                                                                 | 21.99                                                             |
| 5      | Bihar               | Bhagalpur       | 196                              | 1046.38                                                                | 511.14                                                            |
| 5      | Bihar               | Bihar Sharif    | 60                               | 384.1                                                                  | 224.02                                                            |
| 5      | Bihar               | Patna           | 108                              | 1760.92                                                                | 663.32                                                            |
| 6      | Chandigarh          | Chandigarh      | 196                              | 1271.55                                                                | 238.09                                                            |
| 7      | Chhattisgarh        | Raipur          | 196                              | 986.26                                                                 | 471.73                                                            |
| 7      | Chhattisgarh        | Bilaspur        | 58                               | 100                                                                    | -                                                                 |
| 7      | Chhattisgarh        | Naya Raipur     | 122                              | 176                                                                    | 168                                                               |
| 8      | Daman& Diu          | Diu             | 104                              | 97.03                                                                  | 9.49                                                              |
| 9      | Dadra& Nagar Haveli | Silvassa        | 54                               |                                                                        | - -                                                               |
| 10     | Delhi               | NDMC            | 196 1244.6                       | 1134.6                                                                 |                                                                   |
| 11     | Goa                 | Panaji          | 196                              | 392.71                                                                 | 335.47                                                            |
| 12     | Gujarat             | Gandhinagar     | 110                              | 421.02                                                                 | 142.68                                                            |
|        | Gujarat             | Ahmedabad       | 196                              | 2782.29                                                                | 2581.43                                                           |
|        | Gujarat             | Surat           | 294                              | 3684.76                                                                | 2981.05                                                           |
|        | Gujarat             | Vadodara        | 196                              | 2454.14                                                                | 2063.27                                                           |
|        | Gujarat             | Rajkot          | 160                              | 2605.86                                                                | 117.3                                                             |
|        | Gujarat             | Dahod           | 109                              | 647.4                                                                  | 168.89                                                            |
| 13     | Haryana             | Karnal          | 60                               | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| 13     | Haryana             | Faridabad       | 196                              | 532.78                                                                 | 227.18                                                            |
| 14     | Himachal            | Dharamshala     | 196                              | 77.73                                                                  | 75.3                                                              |
|        | Pradesh             | Shimla          | 58                               | 138.19                                                                 | 138.19                                                            |
| 15     | Jharkhand           | Ranchi          | 196                              | 3296.6                                                                 | 1726.34                                                           |
| 16     | Jammu&              | Jammu/ Srinagar | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| 16     | Kashmir             | Srinagar        | 58                               | 8.88                                                                   | 8.88                                                              |
| 16     | Jammu&              | Jammu           | 58                               | 232.86                                                                 | 215.86                                                            |
| 17     | Karnataka           | Mangaluru       | 117                              | 847.21                                                                 | 397.16                                                            |
| 17     | Karnataka           | Belagavi        | 196                              | 1383.45                                                                | 1240.32                                                           |
| 17     | Karnataka           | Shivamogga      | 132                              | 892.68                                                                 | 635.23                                                            |
| 17     | Karnataka           | Hubli-Dharwad   | 196                              | 903.89                                                                 | 534.9                                                             |

| S.N.   | State            | Name of City      | Total funds released under SCM   | Total Value of Projects Tendered/under Tendering through all sources   | Total Value of Projects Grounded/Compl eted through all sources   |
|--------|------------------|-------------------|----------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|        |                  | Tumakuru          | 196                              | 1688.31                                                                | 1299.33                                                           |
|        |                  | Davanagere        | 196                              | 1647.13                                                                | 1134.75                                                           |
|        |                  | Bengaluru         | 58                               | 957.98                                                                 | 65.29                                                             |
| 18     | Kerala           | Kochi             | 196                              | 536.07                                                                 | 136.67                                                            |
|        |                  | Tiruvananthapuram | 194                              | 281.21                                                                 | 191.19                                                            |
| 19     | Lakshadweep      | Kavarati          | 52                               | 7.7                                                                    | 7.7                                                               |
| 20     | Madhya           | Bhopal            | 294                              | 6099.84                                                                | 3026.84                                                           |
|        | Pradesh          | Indore            | 196                              | 6273.38                                                                | 3231                                                              |
|        |                  | Jabalpur          | 196                              | 1065.89                                                                | 883.67                                                            |
|        |                  | Gwalior           | 196                              | 1569.55                                                                | 1055.77                                                           |
|        |                  | Sagar             | 85                               | 1037.88                                                                | 1037.88                                                           |
|        |                  | Satna             | 196                              | 531.59                                                                 | 327.46                                                            |
|        |                  | Ujjain            | 196                              | 1885.77                                                                | 1706.49                                                           |
| 21     |                  | Pimpri-Chinchwad  | 196                              | 1140.85                                                                | 315.91                                                            |
|        | Maharashtra      | Nashik            | 196                              | 1587.57                                                                | 893.09                                                            |
|        |                  | Thane             | 196                              | 1510.83                                                                | 634.33                                                            |
|        |                  | Greater Mumbai#   | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |                  | Amravati#         | 2                                | - 1881.29                                                              | - 346.03                                                          |
|        |                  | Solapur Nagpur    | 196 196                          | 1894.34                                                                | 1656.94                                                           |
|        |                  | Kalyan-Dombivali  | 196                              | 940.48                                                                 | 228.48                                                            |
|        |                  | Aurangabad        | 196                              | 357.02                                                                 | 237.02                                                            |
|        |                  | Pune              | 196                              | 3975.82                                                                | 1594.7                                                            |
| 22     | Manipur          | Imphal            | 117                              | 275.16                                                                 | 275.16                                                            |
| 23     | Meghalaya        | Shillong          | 52                               | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| 24 25  | Mizoram Nagaland | Aizawl Kohima     | 60 117                           | 212.02 135.69                                                          | 212.02 76.41                                                      |
| 26     | Odisha           | Bhubaneswar       | 196                              | 4082.83                                                                | 2823.72                                                           |
|        |                  | Rourkela          | 196                              | 871.45                                                                 | 374.17                                                            |
| 27     | Puducherry       | Puducherry        | 102                              | 62.43                                                                  | 62.43                                                             |
| 28     | Punjab           | Ludhiana          | 196                              | 609.57                                                                 | 418.93                                                            |
|        |                  | Jalandhar         | 60                               | 254.86                                                                 | 98.41                                                             |
|        |                  | Amritsar          | 60                               | 383.15                                                                 | 101.33                                                            |
| 29     | Rajasthan        | Jaipur            | 196                              | 1459.42                                                                | 1076.62                                                           |
|        |                  | Udaipur           | 196                              | 1309.49                                                                | 996.42                                                            |
|        |                  | Kota              | 196                              | 1499.61                                                                | 710.58                                                            |
| 30     | Sikkim           | Namchi            | 196                              | 338.41                                                                 | 301.5                                                             |
|        |                  | Gangtok           | 58                               | 131.95                                                                 | 22.61                                                             |
|        |                  |                   | 125                              |                                                                        |                                                                   |
|        |                  |                   |                                  |                                                                        | 347.49                                                            |
| 31     | Tamil Nadu       | Tiruchirappalli   |                                  | 244.87                                                                 | 195.04                                                            |
|        |                  | Tirunelveli       | 196                              | 347.49                                                                 |                                                                   |
|        |                  | Dindigul#         | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |                  | Tiruppur          | 196 196                          | 611.99                                                                 | 211.41 786.14                                                     |
|        |                  | Salem             |                                  | 791.02                                                                 |                                                                   |
|        |                  | Vellore           | 196                              | 688.47                                                                 | 504.56                                                            |
|        |                  | Coimbatore        | 196                              | 1210.43                                                                | 986.79                                                            |
|        |                  | Madurai Erode     | 196 196                          | 363.28 326.24                                                          | 323.09 311.24                                                     |

| S.N.   | State       | Name of City      | Total funds released under SCM   | Total Value of Projects Tendered/under Tendering through all sources   | Total Value of Projects Grounded/Compl eted through all sources   |
|--------|-------------|-------------------|----------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|        |             | Thoothukudi       | 60                               | 49.52                                                                  | 49.52                                                             |
|        |             | Chennai           | 196                              | 880.38                                                                 | 360.36                                                            |
| 32     | Telangana   | Karimnagar        | 60                               | 231.7                                                                  | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Warangal          | 100                              | 901.52                                                                 | 616.6                                                             |
| 33     | Tripura     | Agartala          | 196                              | 329.02                                                                 | 152.59                                                            |
| 34     | Uttar       | Moradabad         | 60                               | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        | Pradesh     | Aligarh           | 110                              | 610.68 38.33                                                           |                                                                   |
|        |             | Saharanpur        | 60                               | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Bareilly          | 60                               | 88.09                                                                  | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Jhansi            | 60                               | 2668.6                                                                 | 908.3                                                             |
|        |             | Kanpur            | 196                              | 2504.42                                                                | 1834.56                                                           |
|        |             | Allahabad         | 196                              | 952.06                                                                 | 881.58                                                            |
|        |             | Lucknow           | 196                              | 987.73                                                                 | 794.76                                                            |
|        |             | Varanasi          | 196                              | 1838.49                                                                | 1761.56                                                           |
|        |             | Ghaziabad#        | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Agra              | 196                              | 1975.4                                                                 | 1298.01                                                           |
|        |             | Rampur#           | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Meerut/Raebareli# | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| 35     | Uttarakhand | Dehradun          | 60                               | 244.07                                                                 | -                                                                 |
| 36     | West Bengal | New Town Kolkata  | 60                               | 10                                                                     | 10                                                                |
|        |             | Bidhannagar#      | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Durgapur#         | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
|        |             | Haldia#           | 2                                | -                                                                      | -                                                                 |
| Total  | Total       | Total             | 15,536                           | 1,04,964                                                               | 62,295                                                            |

# Cities which did not get selected as Smart Cities