Lok Sabha Question No. 313 (STARRED), answered on 2019-12-10
Subject: Panchayati  Raj Institutions
Ministry: PANCHAYATI RAJ
Asked by: Kanakmal Katara

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF PANCHAYATI RAJ

## LOK SABHA

## STARRED QUESTION NO-†*313

ANSWERED ON-10.12.2019

## PANCHAYATI  RAJ INSTITUTIONS

†*313. SHRIKANAKMAL  KATARA:

Will  the  Minister  of  PANCHAYATI  RAJ be pleased to state:

(a)  whetherthe  Government  has  conducted  any  survey  to  assess  the  functioning  of  Panchayati Raj Institutions  in  the country;

(b)if  so, the details  thereof;

(c) whether the Government had prepared a proposal for providing online services and computerization  of all  Panchayats  across the  country;  and

(d)if  so,  the  details  thereof  along  with  the  details  of  the  funds  sanctioned  in  this  regard  during the  last  five  years and  the current  year,  State-wise?

## ANSWER

THE MINISTER  OF PANCHAYATI RAJ (SHRI NARENDRA  SINGH TOMAR)

- (a) to (d) A Statement  is laid  on the  Table  of  the House.

## STATEMENT  REFERRED  TO  IN  REPLY  TO  LOK  SABHA  STARRED  QUESTION NO. 313 ANSWERED ON 10.12.2019 REGARDING PANCHAYATI RAJ INSTITUTIONS

(a)and  (b)  The  Ministry  of  Panchayati  Raj  (MoPR)  has    carried  out    studies  in  the  form  of 'Panchayat Devolution Index' from  year  2006  onwards,  through  independent  institutions,  to assess and rank each State on the parameter of devolution of Funds, Functions and Functionaries working in Panchayats. Twenty six States and six Union Territories (UTs) participated  in  the  Panchayat  Devolution  Index  study  done  by  Tata  Institute  of  Social  Sciences, Mumbai for the year 2015-16. States/UTs ranking provided in the TISS study are at Annexure-I .

(c)and (d)MoPR  has  developed  a  suite  of  core  common  software  applications,  collectively known as Panchayat Enterprise Suite (PES) Applications to aid Panchayats to undertake functions li ke planning, budgeting, implementation, accounting, monitoring and delivery of citizen services. 'Panchayat'  being  a  State  subject, providing  infrastructure facilities including Computers  and  its  peripherals  to  the  Panchayats  is  primarily  the  responsibility  of  the  State  / UTs Governments. This Ministry, under its erstwhile scheme of Rajiv Gandhi Panchayat Sashaktikaran  Abhiyan  (RGPSA)  implemented  during  year  2012-13  to    year  2015-16  had provided support to States/UTs for e-enablement of Panchayats including computers and peripheral for Gram  Panchayats (GPs). Under  the restructured scheme  of  Rashtriya  Gram Swaraj  Abhiyan  (RGSA),  being  implemented  with  effect  from  year  2018-19,  for  developing governance  capabilities of Panchayati  Raj  Institutions, MoPR  has  inter-alia  provided  financial support  to  States/  UTs  for  computers  and  peripherals  on  a  limited  scale.  Fourteenth  Finance Commission  (FFC)  grant  to  GPs  has  also  10%  Operation  and Maintenance provision which can be  utilised  by  the  Gram  Panchayats  also  for  computer  and  peripheral.  The  details  of  GPs  with and without  computers  is at Annexure-II.

BharatNet, a Project of Department of Telecommunication (DOT)  to provide  broadband connectivity to all the GPs  in the country is under implementation by Bharat  Broadband Network  Limited  (BBNL).  As  per  information  available  as  on  date  06.12.2019,  in  1,25,512 GPs are broadband service  ready. The details  of GPs State/UTs  wise  is at Annexure-III .

Common  Service  Centres  (CSC)  to  provide  online  citizen  services  are  set  up  by  the CSC  e-Governance  Services  India  Limited  an  organisation  under  Ministry  of  Electronics  and Information Technology (MEITY). As per information received from MEITY as on 31.10.2019,  2,68,398  Common  Service  Centres  (CSC)  are  functional  at  GP  level  for  delivering online services. The  details  of  GPs  States/UTs  wise  are  at Annexure-IV .  Further  towards colocation  of  CSC  in  Gram  Panchayats  buildings,  the  MoPR  has  entered  into  a  Memorandum of  Understanding  (MoU)  with  CSC  e-Governance  Services  India  Limited  for  providing  online services  in  GPs.

The State-wise details of funds sanctioned for e-enablement under the erstwhile schemes  of  RGPSA  and  Capacity  Building  Panchayat  Sashktikaran  Abhiyan  (CBPSA)  during year  2014-15  to  year  2017-18  and  fund  sanctioned for  computers during the year 2018-19 and year  2019-20  till  date  under  RGSA  is  at Annexure-V .  Finance  Commission  grants  to  States from  year  2014-15 to year 2019-20 till  date are in Annexure-VI .

Annexure  referred  to  in  reply  to  parts  (a)  and  (b)  of  the  Lok  Sabha  Starred  Question  No.  313  answered  on 10.12.2019  regarding 'Panchayati Raj Institutions'

Ranking of States/UTs provided  in the TISS Report

| Name of State/UT          |   Operational Core of Decentralisation |   Support Systems for Devolution |   Aggregate Improved Index-DPI |
|---------------------------|----------------------------------------|----------------------------------|--------------------------------|
| Kerala                    |                                      1 |                                1 |                              1 |
| Tamil Nadu                |                                      2 |                                4 |                              2 |
| Maharashtra               |                                      3 |                                2 |                              2 |
| Karnataka                 |                                      4 |                                3 |                              3 |
| Haryana                   |                                      5 |                                3 |                              4 |
| Gujarat                   |                                      6 |                                8 |                              5 |
| Sikkim                    |                                      7 |                                3 |                              6 |
| Telangana                 |                                      7 |                                5 |                              7 |
| Andhra Pradesh            |                                      8 |                                7 |                              8 |
| Uttarakhand               |                                     10 |                                6 |                              9 |
| West Bengal               |                                     10 |                                9 |                              9 |
| Odisha                    |                                     11 |                                4 |                              9 |
| Madhya Pradesh            |                                      9 |                               12 |                              9 |
| Rajasthan                 |                                     11 |                                3 |                              9 |
| Chhattisgarh              |                                     12 |                                4 |                             10 |
| Himachal Pradesh          |                                     12 |                                9 |                             10 |
| Assam                     |                                     13 |                               10 |                             11 |
| Tripura                   |                                     14 |                                9 |                             12 |
| Bihar                     |                                     15 |                               10 |                             13 |
| Arunachal Pradesh         |                                     15 |                               15 |                             13 |
| Goa                       |                                     14 |                               16 |                             13 |
| Manipur                   |                                     15 |                               14 |                             13 |
| Jharkhand                 |                                     16 |                               11 |                             14 |
| Punjab                    |                                     17 |                                8 |                             14 |
| Uttar Pradesh             |                                     16 |                               13 |                             14 |
| Jammu & Kashmir           |                                     17 |                               17 |                             15 |
| Andaman & Nicobar Islands |                                      1 |                                1 |                              1 |
| Lakshadweep               |                                      2 |                                2 |                              2 |
| Daman and Diu             |                                      2 |                                3 |                              3 |
| Chandigarh                |                                      3 |                                4 |                              3 |
| Puducherry                |                                      4 |                                5 |                              4 |
| Dadra and Nagar Haveli    |                                      5 |                                6 |                              5 |

Source- Devolution Report 2015-16 Study done by TISS Mumbai

Annexure  referred  to  in  reply  to  parts  (c)  and  (d)  of  the  Lok  Sabha  Starred  Question  No.  313 answered on 10.12.2019 regarding  'Panchayati  Raj Institutions'

| Sl. No.   | Name of the State/ Union Territory   |   Total No. of GPs |   GPs without computer |   GPs with computer |
|-----------|--------------------------------------|--------------------|------------------------|---------------------|
| 1         | Andaman &Nicobar Islands             |                 70 |                      0 |                  70 |
| 2         | Andhra Pradesh                       |              13065 |                   8218 |                4847 |
| 3         | Arunachal Pradesh                    |               1794 |                   1652 |                 142 |
| 4         | Assam                                |               2201 |                    767 |                1434 |
| 5         | Bihar                                |               8386 |                   4186 |                4200 |
| 6         | Chhattisgarh                         |              10978 |                   6434 |                4544 |
| 7         | Dadra & Nagar Haveli                 |                 20 |                      0 |                  20 |
| 8         | Daman & Diu                          |                 15 |                      0 |                  15 |
| 9         | Goa                                  |                191 |                      0 |                 191 |
| 10        | Gujarat                              |              14292 |                    267 |               14025 |
| 11        | Haryana                              |               6204 |                   4832 |                1372 |
| 12        | Himachal Pradesh                     |               3226 |                      0 |                3226 |
| 13        | Jammu & Kashmir                      |               4483 |                   3768 |                 715 |
| 14        | Jharkhand                            |               4376 |                    483 |                3893 |
| 15        | Karnataka                            |               6021 |                      0 |                6021 |
| 16        | Kerala                               |                941 |                      0 |                 941 |
| 17        | Lakshadweep                          |                 10 |                      0 |                  10 |
| 18        | Madhya Pradesh                       |              22826 |                   9440 |               13386 |
| 19        | Maharashtra                          |              27869 |                    918 |               26951 |
| 20        | Manipur                              |                161 |                     96 |                  65 |
| 21        | Odisha                               |               6798 |                      0 |                6798 |
| 22        | Pudducherry                          |                 98 |                      0 |                  98 |
| 23        | Punjab                               |              13264 |                  12661 |                 603 |
| 24        | Rajasthan                            |               9892 |                    723 |                9169 |
| 25        | Sikkim                               |                185 |                      0 |                 185 |
| 26        | Tamil Nadu                           |              12524 |                   2509 |               10015 |
| 27        | Telangana                            |              13057 |                   7149 |                5908 |
| 28        | Tripura                              |                591 |                    239 |                 352 |
| 29        | Uttar Pradesh                        |              58791 |                   9542 |               49249 |
| 30        | Uttarakhand                          |               7952 |                   6542 |                1410 |
| 31        | West Bengal                          |               3341 |                      0 |                3341 |
|           | Total                                |             253622 |                  80426 |              173196 |

Annexure referred to in reply to parts (c) and (d) of the Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 313 answered on 10.12.2019  regarding 'Panchayati Raj Institutions'

States/UTs wise Network Service Ready GPs as on date 11/11/2019

| S.No   | State / Union Territories   |          |
|--------|-----------------------------|----------|
| 1      | Andhra Pradesh              | 1573     |
| 2      | Arunachal Pradesh           | 83       |
| 3      | Assam                       | 1622     |
| 4      | Bihar                       | 6975     |
| 5      | Chhattisgarh                | 4395     |
| 6      | Gujarat                     | 7822     |
| 7      | Haryana                     | 6188     |
| 8      | Himachal Pradesh            | 241      |
| 9      | Jharkhand                   | 2422     |
| 10     | Karnataka                   | 6158     |
| 11     | Kerala                      | 1129     |
| 12     | Madhya Pradesh              | 12699    |
| 13     | Maharashtra                 | 15240    |
| 14     | Manipur                     | 325      |
| 15     | Meghalaya                   | 122      |
| 16     | Mizoram                     | 41       |
| 17     | Nagaland                    | 127      |
| 18     | Odisha                      | 3682     |
| 19     | Punjab                      | 10521    |
| 20     | Rajasthan                   | 8680     |
| 21     | Sikkim                      | 16       |
| 22     | Telangana                   | 2047     |
| 23     | Tripura                     | 555      |
| 24     | Uttar Pradesh               | 28630    |
| 25     | Uttarkhand                  | 1525     |
| 26     | West Bengal                 | 2220     |
| 27     | Chandigarh                  | 13       |
| 28     | Dadra &Nagar Haveli         | 21       |
| 29     | Daman& Diu                  | 18       |
| 30     | Jammu &Kashmir              | 322      |
| 31     | Puducherry                  | 100      |
|        | Total                       | 1,25,512 |

* Souce: Bharat Broadband Network Limited (http://bbnl.nic.in/)

Annexure referred to in reply to parts (c) and (d) of the Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 313 answered on 10.12.2019  regarding 'Panchayati Raj Institutions'

## STATEs/UTs-WISE STATUS OF ROLL OUT OF CSCs AS ON 31 OCTOBER, 2019

| S. No.   | State/UT          |   As on 31 Oct'19 |
|----------|-------------------|-------------------|
| 1.       | Uttar Pradesh     |             57752 |
| 2.       | Maharashtra       |             36832 |
| 3.       | Bihar             |             26956 |
| 4.       | Madhya Pradesh    |             21656 |
| 5.       | West Bengal       |             14541 |
| 6.       | Rajasthan         |             11198 |
| 7.       | Chhattisgarh      |             10447 |
| 8.       | Jharkhand         |             11497 |
| 9.       | Odisha            |             11425 |
| 10.      | Haryana           |              8681 |
| 11.      | Gujarat           |              8143 |
| 12.      | Tamil Nadu        |              5876 |
| 13.      | Andhra Pradesh    |              6782 |
| 14.      | Punjab            |              6941 |
| 15.      | Karnataka         |              4827 |
| 16.      | Uttarakhand       |              4971 |
| 17.      | Assam             |              5497 |
| 18.      | Telangana         |              3281 |
| 19.      | Kerala            |              2975 |
| 20.      | Himachal Pradesh  |              3285 |
| 21.      | Tripura           |               783 |
| 22.      | Manipur           |               589 |
| 23.      | Meghalaya         |               507 |
| 24.      | Nagaland          |                45 |
| 25.      | Mizoram           |                56 |
| 26.      | Arunachal Pradesh |               123 |
| 27.      | Goa               |                52 |
| 28.      | Sikkim            |                30 |
|          | States Total      |            265748 |
| 29.      | Jammu& Kashmir    |              2457 |
| 30.      | Delhi             |                 0 |
| 31.      | Puducherry        |               109 |
| 32.      | Chandigarh        |                11 |
| 33.      | Andaman& Nicobar  |                25 |
| 34.      | Dadra & N Haveli  |                24 |
| 35.      | Daman& Diu        |                13 |
| 36.      | Lakshadweep       |                11 |
|          | UTs Total         |              2650 |
|          | GRAND TOTAL       |            268398 |

## Annexure-  V

Annexure referred to in  reply  to  parts  (c)  and  (d)  of  the  Lok  Sabha Starred Question No. 313 answered on 10.12.2019 regarding  'Panchayati  Raj Institutions'

State-wise  amount  approved for e-enablement  under  the scheme  of RGPSA, CBPSA and RGSA during 2014-15 to 2019-20

(Rs. in crore)

| S.      | State             |   2014-15 | 2016-17                | 2017-18                 |   2018-19 |   2019-20 |
|---------|-------------------|-----------|------------------------|-------------------------|-----------|-----------|
| No. 30. | Andhra Pradesh    |      6.53 | provided to computer & |                         |      2.44 |      2.76 |
| 31.     | Arunachal Pradesh |      0    |                        |                         |      0.49 |      0.55 |
| 32.     | Assam             |      4.4  |                        |                         |      0.24 |      0.23 |
| 33.     | Bihar             |      7.32 |                        |                         |      1.24 |      1.4  |
| 34.     | Chhattisgarh      |      8    |                        |                         |      0.4  |      0.4  |
| 35.     | Goa               |      0    |                        |                         |      0    |      0    |
| 36.     | Gujarat           |      4.31 |                        | States/ UTs peripherals |      0    |      0.12 |
| 37.     | Haryana           |      3.68 |                        |                         |      1.44 |      1.62 |
| 38.     | Himachal Pradesh  |      7.64 |                        |                         |      0    |      0    |
| 39.     | Jammu & Kashmir   |      6.19 |                        |                         |      1.26 |      1.4  |
| 40.     | Jharkhand         |      0    |                        |                         |      0.14 |      0.16 |
| 41.     | Karnataka         |      2.52 |                        |                         |      0    |      0    |
| 42.     | Kerala            |      9.78 |                        |                         |      0    |      0.4  |
| 43.     | Maharashtra       |      0    |                        |                         |      0    |      0    |
| 44.     | Madhya Pradesh    |      0    |                        |                         |      0.4  |      0.6  |
| 45.     | Manipur           |      0    |                        |                         |      0.04 |      0.03 |
| 46.     | Meghalaya         |      0    |                        |                         |      0.54 |      0.61 |
| 47.     | Mizoram           |      0.48 |                        |                         |      0.1  |      0.19 |
| 48.     | Nagaland          |      0    |                        |                         |      0.37 |      0.41 |
| 49.     | Odisha            |      5.61 |                        |                         |      0    |      0    |
| 50.     | Punjab            |      0.4  |                        |                         |      3.72 |      4.2  |
| 51.     | Rajasthan         |      0    |                        |                         |      0.21 |      0.21 |
| 52.     | Sikkim            |      0.7  |                        |                         |      0.05 |      0.06 |
| 53.     | Tamil Nadu        |      0    |                        |                         |      0.75 |      0.8  |
| 54.     | Telangana         |      8.22 |                        |                         |      2.13 |      3.2  |
| 55.     | Tripura           |      0.08 |                        |                         |      0.21 |      0.4  |
| 56.     | Uttar Pradesh     |     40    |                        |                         |     16.95 |     19.15 |
| 57.     | Uttarakhand       |      4    |                        |                         |      1.95 |      2.19 |
| 58.     | West Bengal       |      2.03 |                        |                         |      0    |      0    |
|         | Total             |    121.89 |                        |                         |     35.07 |     41.09 |

Fund sanctioned  also includes  computers  & other peripherals

## Annexure-VI

Annexure referred  to  in  reply  to  parts  (c)  and  (d)  of  the Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 313answered on 10.12.2019 regarding  'Panchayati Raj Institutions'

## Allocation and Release of Finance Commissions  grant to the State Governments for Rural Local Bodies (RLBs)  (as on 05.12.2019)

(Rs.  in crore)

| S. No.   | State            | 2014-15    | 2014-15   | 2015-16    | 2015-16   | 2016-17    | 2016-17   | 2017-18    | 2017-18   | 2018-19    | 2018-19   | 2019-20    | 2019-20   |
|----------|------------------|------------|-----------|------------|-----------|------------|-----------|------------|-----------|------------|-----------|------------|-----------|
| S. No.   | State            | Allocation | Release   | Allocation | Release   | Allocation | Release   | Allocation | Release   | Allocation | Release   | Allocation | Release   |
| (1)      | (2)              | (3)        | (4)       | (5)        | (6)       | (7)        | (8)       | (9)        | (10)      | (11)       | (12)      | (13)       | (14)      |
| 1        | Andhra Pradesh   | 828.11     | 1744.40   | 934.34     | 928.41    | 1463.45    | 1454.05   | 1686.85    | 1675.88   | 1947.32    | 858.99    | 2622.13    | 0.00      |
| 2        | ArunachalPradesh | 77.02      | 36.33     | 88.52      | 88.52     | 138.66     | 138.45    | 159.82     | 70.57     | 184.49     | 0.00      | 248.44     | 0.00      |
| 3        | Assam            | 458.07     | 352.76    | 584.80     | 584.80    | 915.98     | 915.98    | 1055.80    | 1055.80   | 1218.82    | 1082.32   | 1641.19    | 0.00      |
| 4        | Bihar            | 1392.65    | 1254.70   | 2269.18    | 2269.18   | 3554.23    | 3142.08   | 4096.80    | 3630.39   | 4729.38    | 4199.71   | 6368.25    | 5674.70   |
| 5        | Chhattisgarh     | 511.83     | 393.28    | 566.18     | 566.18    | 886.82     | 886.82    | 1022.18    | 1022.18   | 1180.02    | 1047.86   | 1588.94    | 707.945   |
| 6        | Goa              | 25.43      | 0.00      | 14.44      | 14.44     | 22.62      | 22.62     | 26.07      | 26.07     | 30.10      | 13.37     | 40.53      | 0.00      |
| 7        | Gujarat          | 684.68     | 527.04    | 932.25     | 932.25    | 1460.18    | 1460.18   | 1683.08    | 1683.08   | 1942.96    | 1725.36   | 2616.26    | 2331.33   |
| 8        | Haryana          | 305.41     | 238.36    | 419.28     | 419.28    | 656.72     | 656.72    | 756.98     | 756.98    | 873.86     | 775.99    | 1176.68    | 1048.53   |
| 9        | Himachal Pradesh | 157.06     | 151.78    | 195.39     | 195.39    | 306.05     | 306.05    | 352.76     | 312.60    | 407.24     | 361.63    | 548.36     | 488.64    |
| 10       | Jammu & Kashmir  | 258.19     | 199.11    | 373.96     | 367.72    | 585.73     | 474.41    | 675.15     | 470.972   | 779.40     | 544.83    | 1049.49    | 0.00      |
| 11       | Jharkhand        | 496.27     | 380.36    | 652.83     | 652.83    | 1022.53    | 1022.53   | 1178.63    | 1044.45   | 1360.62    | 1208.24   | 1832.12    | 1632.59   |
| 12       | Karnataka        | 1266.22    | 976.48    | 1002.85    | 972.36    | 1570.77    | 1547.66   | 1810.55    | 1784.26   | 2090.10    | 1841.54   | 2814.39    | 2504.14   |
| 13       | Kerala           | 548.10     | 527.44    | 433.76     | 433.76    | 679.40     | 679.39    | 783.12     | 773.54    | 904.03     | 802.78    | 1217.30    | 1084.73   |
| 14       | Madhya Pradesh   | 1209.51    | 757.38    | 1463.61    | 1463.61   | 2292.46    | 2292.46   | 2642.40    | 2638.21   | 3050.41    | 2708.78   | 4107.48    | 3660.14   |
| 15       | Maharashtra      | 1561.52    | 1787.82   | 1623.32    | 1623.32   | 2542.61    | 2542.61   | 2930.76    | 2597.10   | 3383.28    | 3004.37   | 4555.70    | 4059.55   |
| 16       | Manipur          | 65.12      | 129.98    | 22.25      | 22.25     | 34.84      | 34.84     | 40.16      | 40.16     | 46.36      | 41.17     | 62.43      | 0.00      |
| 17       | Meghalaya        | 97.12      | 20.73     | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      |
| 18       | Mizoram          | 60.27      | 14.27     | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      |
| 19       | Nagaland         | 93.74      | 17.97     | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      | 0.00       | 0.00      |
| 20       | Odisha           | 771.50     | 454.73    | 955.52     | 955.52    | 1496.64    | 1496.64   | 1725.11    | 1725.11   | 1991.48    | 1768.44   | 2681.59    | 2389.54   |
| 21       | Punjab           | 316.31     | 416.04    | 441.70     | 441.70    | 691.84     | 691.85    | 797.45     | 0.00      | 920.58     | 0.00      | 1239.58    | 0.00      |
| 22       | Rajasthan        | 1114.30    | 872.96    | 1471.95    | 1471.95   | 2305.52    | 2305.52   | 2657.47    | 2657.47   | 3067.80    | 2724.22   | 4130.90    | 3681.01   |
| 23       | Sikkim           | 51.83      | 38.36     | 16.03      | 16.04     | 25.11      | 25.11     | 28.95      | 28.95     | 33.41      | 29.67     | 44.99      | 40.09     |

| 24   | Tamil Nadu    |   866.84 |   668.48 |   947.65 |   947.65 |   1484.31 |   1484.31 |   1710.90 |   1516.12 |   1975.07 |   1753.87 |   2659.50 |     0.00 |
|------|---------------|----------|----------|----------|----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|----------|
| 25   | Telangana     |   652.88 |   895.16 |   580.34 |   580.34 |    908.99 |    908.99 |   1047.75 |   1047.75 |   1209.53 |   1071.59 |   1628.68 |   725.65 |
| 26   | Tripura       |    87.15 |    66.1  |    36.24 |    36.24 |     56.76 |     56.76 |     65.43 |     65.43 |     75.53 |     67.07 |    101.71 |    90.62 |
| 27   | Uttar Pradesh |  2751.4  |  2121.81 |  3862.6  |  3852.6  |   6050.02 |   6034.33 |   6973.57 |   6179.65 |   8050.34 |   7148.74 |  10840    |  9659.47 |
| 28   | Uttarakhand   |   166.15 |    98.81 |   203.26 |   203.26 |    318.37 |    318.37 |    366.97 |    346.77 |    423.64 |    376.19 |    570.44 |   254.15 |
| 29   | West Bengal   |  1168.18 |  1068.32 |  1532.21 |  1470.86 |   2399.91 |   2319.48 |   2766.26 |   2369.18 |   3193.39 |   2740.69 |   4300.01 |  3703.25 |
|      | Total         | 18042.9  | 16211    | 21624.5  | 21510.5  |  33870.5  |  33218.2  |  39041    |  35518.7  |  45069.2  |  37897.4  |  60687.1  | 43736.1  |

Note: Fourteenth  Finance Commission for the period 2015-20,  have  not recommended  any grant to States of Meghalaya, Mizoram and Nagaland.