Lok Sabha Question No. 2946 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2018-03-13
Subject: Evaluation of CPSUs
Ministry: HEAVY INDUSTRIES AND PUBLIC ENTERPRISES
Asked by: VISHNU DAYAL RAM

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HEAVY INDUSTRIES & PUBLIC ENTERPRISES DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC ENTERPRISES

## LOK SABHA

## UNSTARRED QUESTION No. 2946

## TO BE ANSWERED ON 13.03.2018 Evaluation of CPSUs

## 2946.   SHRI VISHNU DAYAL RAM:

Will  the  Minister  of  HEAVY  INDUSTRIES AND  PUBLIC ENTERPRISES be pleased to state:

- (a)  whether the performance/functioning of Central Public Sector Undertakings (CPSUs) is being evaluated regularly;
- (b)  if so, the details of the grading of CPSUs during each of the last three years; and
- (c)  the details of the assistance being provided to loss making CPSUs by the Government, CPSU-wise?

## A N S W E R

## THE MINISTER OF STATE OF HEAVY INDUSTRIES AND PUBLIC ENTERPRISES

## (Shri Babul Supriyo)

- (a) Evaluation of the performance of Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) is done after the end of the financial year against the targets fixed in respect of MoU signing CPSEs.
- (b)  The details of the grading of performance of MoU signing CPSEs during each of the last three year is enclosed as Annex.
- (c)  Central  Public  Sector  Enterprises  (CPSEs) function under the administrative control of various  Ministries/Departments.  As  per  the  guidelines  issued  by  Department  of  Public Enterprises  (DPE)  on  29.10.2015  for  'Streamlining  the  mechanism  for  revival  and restructuring  of  sick/incipient  sick  and  weak  CPSEs',  the  responsibility  for  addressing the sickness of Central CPSEs lies with the concerned administrative Ministries/Departments. The administrative Ministries/Departments monitor the sickness of CPSEs and identify the sick/incipient sick/weak CPSEs functioning under their control based  on  the  performance  and  take  timely  redressal  measures.  The  concerned administrative Ministries/ Departments formulate revival/ restructuring/ closure plans for CPSEs functioning under them on a case-to-case basis and after obtaining the approval of competent authority implement the plan.

## GRADING FOR LAST THREE YEARS

## (LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 2946)

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                                | 2014-15   | 2015-16                              | 2016-17                              |
|-----------|-------------------------------------------------------------|-----------|--------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|
|         1 | Air India Air Transport Services Ltd.                       | -         | Very Good                            | NS/NE                                |
|         2 | Air India Charters Ltd.                                     | Very Good | Very Good                            | Fair                                 |
|         3 | Air India Engineering Services Ltd.                         | -         | Poor                                 | NS/NE                                |
|         4 | Air India Ltd.                                              | Good      | Very Good                            | NS/NE                                |
|         5 | Airline Alied Services Ltd.                                 | -         | Fair                                 | Poor                                 |
|         6 | Airports Authority of India                                 | Very Good | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|         7 | Andrew Yule & Co Ltd                                        | Very Good | Good                                 | Very Good                            |
|         8 | Antrix Corporation Ltd                                      | Very Good | Very Good                            | Good                                 |
|         9 | Artificial Limbs Manufacturing Corpn of India Limited       | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        10 | Assam Ashok Hotel Corporation Ltd.                          | Poor      | -                                    | NS/NE                                |
|        11 | Balmer Lawrie & Co. Ltd.                                    | Very Good | Very Good                            | Excellent                            |
|        12 | BEL Optronic Devices Ltd.                                   | Good      | Very Good                            | Very Good                            |
|        13 | BEL Thales System Ltd.                                      | -         | -                                    | Excellent                            |
|        14 | Bengal Chemical & Pharma Ltd.                               | Good      | Excellent                            | Very Good                            |
|        15 | Bharat BhariUdyog Nigam Ltd.                                | Good      | Merged with BBJ Construction Co.Ltd. | Merged with BBJ Construction Co.Ltd. |
|        16 | Bharat Broadband Nigam Ltd.                                 | Good      | Good                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        17 | Bharat Coking Coal Limited                                  | Very Good | Very Good                            | #                                    |
|        18 | Bharat Dynamics Ltd.                                        | Excellent | Excellent                            | Very Good                            |
|        19 | Bharat Earth Movers Limited(BEML)                           | Good      | Good                                 | Very Good                            |
|        20 | Bharat Electronics Limited                                  | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        21 | Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd.                               | Good      | Good                                 | Excellent                            |
|        22 | Bharat Immunological & Biological Ltd                       | Fair      | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        23 | Bharat Petro Resources Ltd.                                 | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        24 | Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.                           | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        25 | Bharat Pumps & Compressors Ltd.                             | -         | Fair                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        26 | Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd                                    | Fair      | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        27 | Bharat Wagon & Engineering Co. Ltd.                         | Poor      | Fair                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        28 | Bharitya Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam Ltd                         | Very Good | Good                                 | Fair                                 |
|        29 | Bhartiya Rail Bijlee Company Ltd.                           | Good      | Good                                 | Fair                                 |
|        30 | BHEL -EML                                                   | Fair      | Fair                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        31 | Biotechnology Industry Research Assis. Council              | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        32 | Brahmaputra Valley Fertilizers Corp Ltd,                    | Poor      | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        33 | Brahmputra Crackers and Polymers Ltd.                       | Very Good | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        34 | Braithwaite & Co Ltd.                                       | Fair      | Good                                 | Poor                                 |
|        35 | Braithwaite Burn and Jessop Construction Company (BBJ) Ltd. | Good      | Good                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        36 | Bridge & Roof Co. (I) Ltd.                                  | Good      | Very Good                            | Very Good                            |
|        37 | Broadcast Engineering Consultants India Limited(BECIL)      | -         | Fair                                 | Good                                 |

## Annexure

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                            | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|---------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|        38 | Burn Standard Co.                                       | Fair      | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|        39 | Cement Corporation of India                             | Very Good | Good      | Poor      |
|        40 | Central Coalfields Ltd                                  | Excellent | Excellent | #         |
|        41 | Central Cottage Industries Corp. of India Ltd           | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        42 | Central Electronics Limited                             | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        43 | Central Mine Planning & Design Institute                | Excellent | Excellent | #         |
|        44 | Central Railside Warehousing Compny Ltd.                | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|        45 | Central Warehousing Corporation Ltd                     | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|        46 | Certification Engineers |India Ltd.                | Excellent | Excellent | Very good |
|        47 | Chandigarh International Airport Ltd.                   | -         | -         | Excellent |
|        48 | Chennai Petroleum Corporation Ltd.                      | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|        49 | Coal India Limited                                      | Excellent | Very Good | Fair      |
|        50 | Cochin Shipyard Limited                                 | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|        51 | Concor Air Ltd.                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Good      |
|        52 | Container Corporation of India Ltd (CONCOR)             | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|        53 | Cotton Corporation of India Ltd.                        | Very Good | Very Good | Fair      |
|        54 | CREDA-HPCL Biofuels Ltd.                                | Good      | -         | Excellent |
|        55 | Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation of India         | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|        56 | Donyi Polo Ashok Hotel Ltd.                             | Fair      | Poor      | Poor      |
|        57 | Dredging Corporation of India Ltd.                      | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        58 | Eastern Coal field Ltd.                                 | Excellent | Very Good | #         |
|        59 | Educational Consultants India Ltd.(EdCIL)               | Good      | Excellent | Good      |
|        60 | Electronics Corp. Of India Ltd.                         | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|        61 | Engineering Projects (India) Ltd.                       | Very Good | Very Good | Good      |
|        62 | Engineers India Ltd,                                    | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        63 | Kamarajar Port Ltd. (Earlier known as Ennore Port Ltd.) | Excellent | Excellent | Good      |
|        64 | Export Credit Guarantee Corp. Ltd                       | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        65 | FCIAravali Gypsum & Minerals (I) Ltd                    | Excellent | Good      | Fair      |
|        66 | Fertilizers and Chemicals (T) Ltd.                      | Poor      | Fair      | Poor      |
|        67 | Food Corporation of India                               | Very Good | Very Good | NS/NE     |
|        68 | Fresh & Healthy Enterprises Ltd.                        | Good      | Good      | Exempted  |
|        69 | FSNL                                                    | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|        70 | GAIL (I) Limited                                        | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|        71 | Gail Gas Ltd.                                           | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        72 | Garden Reach Shipbuilders &Eng. Ltd.                    | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        73 | Goa Antibiotics & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.                  | -         | -         | Good      |
|        74 | Goa Shipyard Ltd.                                       | Very Good | Excellent | Excellent |
|        75 | Handicrafts & Handlooms Export Corpn.                   | Very Good | Good      | NS/NE     |
|        76 | Heavy Engineering Corporation Ltd.                      | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|        77 | High Speed Rail Corp. of India Ltd.                     | Excellent | Good      | Exempted  |
|        78 | Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd.                              | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|        79 | Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd.                              | Fair      | Poor      | Good      |
|        80 | Hindustan Cables Ltd                                    | Poor      | -         | NS/NE     |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                                                       | 2014-15             | 2015-16        | 2016-17        |
|-----------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------|----------------|----------------|
|        81 | Hindustan Copper Ltd.                                                              | Good                | Very Good      | Good           |
|        82 | Hindustan Fluorocarbons Ltd.                                                       | Fair                | Good           | Good           |
|        83 | Hindustan Insecticides Ltd.                                                        | Good                | Good           | Fair           |
|        84 | Hindustan Newsprint Limited                                                        | Fair                | Poor           | NS/NE          |
|        85 | Hindustan Organic Chemicals Ltd.                                                   | Poor                | Fair           | Fair           |
|        86 | Hindustan Paper Corporation Ltd                                                    | -                   | Poor           | NS/NE          |
|        87 | Hindustan Petroleum Corp. Ltd.                                                     | Excellent           | Excellent      | Excellent      |
|        88 | Hindustan Prefab Ltd.                                                              | Excellent           | Very Good      | NS/NE          |
|        89 | Hindustan Salts Ltd.                                                               | Fair                | Fair           | Fair           |
|        90 | Hindustan Shipyard Limited                                                         | Good                | Good           | Good           |
|        91 | Hindustan Steelworks Construction Ltd.                                             | Excellent           | Very Good      | Fair           |
|        92 | HLL Biotech Ltd.                                                                   | Very Good           | Very Good      | Excellent      |
|        93 | HLL Infra Tech Services Ltd.                                                       | -                   | -              | Excellent      |
|        94 | HLL Lifecare Ltd.                                                                  | Excellent           | Very Good      | Fair           |
|        95 | HMT Bearing Ltd.                                                                   | Good                | -              | NS/NE          |
|        96 | HMT International Ltd.                                                             | Good                | Good           | Poor           |
|        97 | HMT Ltd.                                                                           | Fair                | Fair           | Good           |
|        98 | HMT Machine Tools Ltd.                                                             | Fair                | Fair           | Poor           |
|        99 | Hoogly Printing Co. Ltd.                                                           | Good                | Good           | Fair           |
|       100 | Hotel Corp. of India Ltd                                                           | -                   | Good           | Poor           |
|       101 | Housing & Urban Development Corporation Ltd (HUDCO)                                | Excellent           | Excellent      | Excellent      |
|       102 | HPCL Biofuel Ltd.                                                                  | Good                | Good           | Fair           |
|       103 | HSCC (India) Ltd                                                                   | Very Good           | Excellent      | Very Good      |
|       104 | India Trade Promotion Organization (ITPO)                                          | Excellent           | Very Good      | Very Good      |
|       105 | Indian Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.                                                | -                   | Poor           | NS/NE          |
|       106 | Indian Medicines Pharmaceuticals Corporation Ltd,                                  | -                   | Fair           | NS/NE          |
|       107 | Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.                                                        | Excellent           | Excellent      | Very Good      |
|       108 | Indian Railway Catering & Tourism Corpn Ltd                                        | Excellent           | Excellent      | Good           |
|       109 | Indian Railway Finance Corporation Ltd,                                            | Excellent           | Excellent      | Excellent      |
|       110 | Indian Railway Station Dev. Corp. Ltd.                                             | Fair                | Good           | Fair           |
|       111 | Indian Rare Earth Ltd.                                                             | Good                | Good           | Very Good      |
|       112 | Indian Renewable Energy Dev. Agency (IREDA)                                        | Excellent           | Very Good      | Excellent      |
|       113 | Indian Tourism Development Corp. (ITDC)                                            | Good                | Good           | Good           |
|       114 | Instrumentation Ltd.                                                               | Fair                | Fair           | Good           |
|       115 | Ircon Infrastructure & Services Ltd.                                               | Very Good           | Excellent      | Good           |
|       116 | IRCON International Ltd.                                                           | Very Good           | Very Good      | Very Good      |
|       117 | IRCON Pb Tollways Limited                                                          | -                   | -              | Very Good      |
|       118 | IRCON Shivpuri Guna Tollway Ltd.                                                   | -                   | -              | Excellent      |
|       119 | ITI Ltd.                                                                           | Very Good           | Good           | Good           |
|       120 | Jute Corporation of India Ltd.                                                     | Very Good           | Very Good      | Fair           |
|       121 | Kanti Bijlee Utpadan Nigam Ltd.                                                    | Excellent           | Good           | Good           |
|       122 | Karnataka Antibiotics & Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Karnatka Trade Promotion Organisation | Very Good Excellent | Very Good Very | Very Good Poor |
|       123 |                                                                                    |                     | Good           |                |
|       124 | KIOCL Ltd.                                                                         | Fair                | Fair           | Good           |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                              | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|-----------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|       125 | Konkan Railway Corporation Ltd.                           | Very Good | Excellent | Good      |
|       126 | Kumararupa Frountier Hotel Ltd                            | -         | -         | Very Good |
|       127 | Madhya Pradesh Ashok Hotel Ltd.                           | Fair      | -         | NS/NE     |
|       128 | Madras Fertilizers Ltd.                                   | Fair      | Fair      | Fair      |
|       129 | Mahanadi Coalfield Ltd.                                   | Excellent | Very Good | #         |
|       130 | Mahanagar Telephone Mauritius Ltd.(MTML)                  | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|       131 | Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. (MTNL)                     | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|       132 | Mangalore Refinery & Petrochemicals Ltd.                  | Very Good | Excellent | Excellent |
|       133 | Manganese Ore (I) Ltd. (MOIL)                             | Excellent | Good      | Very Good |
|       134 | Mazagoan Dock Ltd.                                        | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       135 | MECON Ltd.                                                | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|       136 | Millennium Telecom Limited                                | -         | -         | Excellent |
|       137 | Mineral Exploration Corporation Ltd.                      | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|       138 | Mishra Dhatu Nigam Ltd.                                   | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       139 | MMTC Ltd.                                                 | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       140 | MSTC Ltd.                                                 | Excellent | Very Good | Good      |
|       141 | Mumbai Rail Vikas Nigam                                   | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       142 | Nagaland Pulp & Paper Company Ltd.                        | -         | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       143 | National Aluminium Co. Limited                            | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       144 | National BC Fin. & Development Corpn.                     | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       145 | National Building Construction Corpn Ltd,                 | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       146 | National Fertilizers Ltd.                                 | Very Good | Very Good | Good      |
|       147 | National Film Development Corp. Ltd                       | Good      | Excellent | Poor      |
|       148 | National Handicapped Finance & Development Corporation    | Excellent | Excellent | Fair      |
|       149 | National Handloom Dev. Corp.                              | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|       150 | National Informatics Centre Services Incorporated (NICSI) | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       151 | National Jute Manufacturing Corporation Ltd.              | Fair      | Good      | NS/NE     |
|       152 | National Mineral Dev. Corp. (NMDC)                        | Very Good | Good      | Very Good |
|       153 | National Minorities Finance Development Corpn             | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       154 | National Projects Construction Corpn. Ltd.                | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|       155 | National Research Dev. Corpn.                             | Good      | Very Good | Fair      |
|       156 | National Safai Karamchari's Fin. & Dev. Corpn.            | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       157 | National Schedule Caste Finance Development Corpn         | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       158 | National Schedule Tribes Finance Development Corpn.       | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|       159 | National Seeds.Corpn. Ltd                                 | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|       160 | National Small Industries Corpn. Ltd                      | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       161 | National Textile Corporation Ltd.                         | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|       162 | NBCC Services Limited                                     | -         | -         | Excellent |
|       163 | NEPA Ltd.                                                 | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|       164 | Neyveli Lignite Corporation Limited                       | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       165 | Neyveli Uttar Pradesh Power Ltd                           | -         | -         | Excellent |
|       166 | NHDC Ltd.                                                 | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       167 | NHPC Ltd.                                                 | Very Good | Very Good | Good      |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                                      | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|-------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|       168 | NLC TAMILNADU POWER LTD                                           | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|       169 | NMDC-CMDC Limited                                                 | -         | -         | Poor      |
|       170 | North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Ltd. (NEEPCO)            | Very Good | Good      | Good      |
|       171 | North Eastern Handicraft & Handlooms Development Corporation Ltd. | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|       172 | North Eastern Reg. Agri. Marketing Corpn. (NERAMAC)               | NS/NE     | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       173 | Northern Coalfield Ltd.                                           | Very Good | Excellent | #         |
|       174 | NTPC Electric Supply Co. Ltd.                                     | Good      | -         | Exempted  |
|       175 | NTPC Ltd.                                                         | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       176 | NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Ltd.                                     | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       177 | Nuclear Power Corpn. Ltd.                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|       178 | Numaligarh Refinery Ltd.                                          | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       179 | Oil & Natural Gas Co. Ltd. (ONGC)                                 | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       180 | Oil India Limited                                                 | Very Good | Good      | Very Good |
|       181 | ONGC Videsh Ltd.                                                  | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       182 | Pawan Hans Helicopters Ltd.                                       | Very Good | Good      | NS/NE     |
|       183 | PEC Limited                                                       | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|       184 | PFC CAPITAL ADVISORY SERVICES LTD.                                | Excellent | Good      | Exempted  |
|       185 | PFC CONSULTING LTD.                                               | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       186 | PFC GREEN ENERGY LTD.                                             | Very Good | Excellent | NS/NE     |
|       187 | Pondicherry Ashok Hotel Corporation Ltd.                          | Good      | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       188 | Power Finance Corporation Ltd                                     | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       189 | Power Grid Corpn. Of India Ltd.                                   | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       190 | Power Grid NM Transmission Ltd.                                   | -         | Very Good | Exempted  |
|       191 | Power System Operation Corporation Limited                        | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       192 | PRIZE PETROLIUM CO. LTD                                           | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       193 | Projects & Development India Ltd.                                 | Fair      | Good      | Fair      |
|       194 | Punjab Logistics Infrastructure Ltd.                              | -         | Good      | Fair      |
|       195 | Rail Vikas Nigam Ltd.                                             | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       196 | Railtel Corporation of India Ltd                                  | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       197 | Railtel Enterprises Ltd.                                          | -         | -         | Fair      |
|       198 | RAILWAY ENERGY MANAGEMENT COMPONY LTD.                            | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|       199 | Rajasthan Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.                            | Poor      | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       200 | Rajasthan Electronics & Instrumentation Ltd.                      | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|       201 | Ranchi Ashok Bihar Hotel Corporation Ltd.                         | NS/NE     | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       202 | Rashtirya Ispat Nagam Ltd.                                        | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|       203 | Rashtriya Chemicals & Fertilizers Ltd,                            | Excellent | Very Good | Good      |
|       204 | REC Power Distribution Co. Ltd.                                   | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       205 | REC Transmission Projects Co. Ltd.                                | -         | -         | Excellent |
|       206 | Richardson & Cruddas Ltd.                                         | Very Good | Good      | NS/NE     |
|       207 | RITES Afrika Limited                                              | Very Good | Excellent | Poor      |
|       208 | RITES INFRASTUCTURE SERVISES LTD.                                 | Excellent | Excellent | Exempted  |
|       209 | RITES Limited                                                     | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                            | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|---------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|       210 | Rural Electrification Corpn. Ltd                        | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       211 | SAIL REFRACTORY CO. LTD.(SRCL)                          | Good      | Good      | Very Good |
|       212 | Sambar Salt Ltd.                                        | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|       213 | SJVN Ltd.                                               | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       214 | Scooters India Ltd                                      | Fair      | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       215 | Security Printing and Minting Corporation of India Ltd. | Excellent | Very Good | Good      |
|       216 | Shipping Corpn. Of India Ltd.                           | Very Good | Very Good | Poor      |
|       217 | SIDCUL CONCOR INFRA COMPANY LTD.                        | Very Good | Good      | Fair      |
|       218 | SJVN Arun-3 Power Development Co.Ltd.                   | -         | -         | Very Good |
|       219 | SJVN Thermal Pvt. Ltd.                                  | -         | -         | Very Good |
|       220 | Solar Energy Corporation of India Ltd.                  | -         | Very Good | Very Good |
|       221 | South Eastern Coalfield Ltd.                            | Excellent | Very Good | #         |
|       222 | State Trading Corporation Ltd                           | Good      | Good      | Poor      |
|       223 | Steel Authority of India Ltd.                           | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       224 | TAMILNADU TELECOMMUNICATION CO. LTD.                    | Fair      | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       225 | Tamilnadu Trade Promotion Organisation                  | Very Good | Good      | Poor      |
|       226 | TCIL BINA ROAD                                          | Excellent | Very Good | NS/NE     |
|       227 | THDC Ltd. (Tehri Hydro Development Corpn. Ltd.)         | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|       228 | Telecommunications Consultants India Ltd                | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|       229 | Uranium Corporation of India Ltd.                       | Good      | Good      | Very Good |
|       230 | Vignyan Industries Ltd.                                 | Fair      | Fair      | Fair      |
|       231 | Powergrid Vizag Transmission Ltd. (VTL)                 | -         | Excellent | NS/NE     |
|       232 | WAPCOS Ltd.                                             | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       233 | Western Coalfield Ltd.                                  | Very Good | Very Good | #         |

NS/NE: Not Submitted/Not Evaluated

#: MoU signed on consolidated basis with Holding Company (CIL).