Lok Sabha Question No. 4530 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2016-12-14
Subject: Service Level Benchmarking
Ministry: URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Asked by: VIRENDRA  KUMAR

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO 4530 TO BE ANSWERED ON 14 DECEMBER,2016 SERVICE LEV L BEN HMARKING No. 4530                  DR. VIRENDRA KUMAR: Will the Minister of URBAN DEVELOPMENT be pleased to state: (a) the position of implementation of Service Level Benchmarking (SLB) by the Urban Local Bodies (ULB) and the details of pilot cities under the above scheme; (b) the details of cities which have furnished the report of their service level benchmarking indices; (c) the steps taken by the Government to ensure the implementation of SLB by ULB in   other cities; (d)   whether SLB is being implemented in other States and cities; e if so, whether the Government has proposed any mach nery for the inclusion of citizens for the verification of SLB indices; and (f)   if so, the details thereof? ANSWER THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT (RAO INDERJIT SINGH) Cont.. -2(a to d):   Urban Development is a State subject. The Ministry of Urban Development facilitates and handholds States and Urban Local Bodies in improving standard of services with a view to improve the quality of life in cities  and  towns.  To  this  end  the Government had conducted a pilot research study in the year 2012-2013 for establishing Service Level Benchmarks (SLBs) for urban  transport  in  12  cities  of  India  namely,  Delhi,  Jaipur, Jammu & Katra, Nanded, Patna, Vijayawada, Kohima, Bhubaneswar,  Ahmedabad,  Surat,  Mysore,  Hubli  -Dharwad through  CEPT,  Ahmedabad  and  Institute  of  Urban  Transport (India). The report card for all 10 indicators of SLB for 12 cities are given in the Annexure. Establishing SLB is now one of the component of preparation of State Annual Action Plan (SAAP) under the Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation(AMRUT) and Comprehensive   Mobility Plan (CMP) funded by Ministry of Urban Development. These Benchmark indices are prepared based on data collected from cities and the report is placed on website of Ministry of Urban Development. The urban local bodies to be eligible for performance grant in terms of the 14 th     Finance Commission award are inter alia required  to  publish  the  service  level  benchmarks  relating  to basic urban services each year for the period of the award and make it publically available. (e & f)    No, Madam. Government has not proposed any such machinery. The SLBs are required to be published by State Governments and put in public domain. *******

Annexure Annexure referred to in reply to part (a & b) of Lok Sabha Unstarred Question No 4530 for answer on 14.12.2016

| S. N o.                                | Focus Areas      | Delhi         | Jaip ur       | Jammu & Katra   | Jammu & Katra   | Nand ed       | Pat na        | Vijayaw ada   | Ahmeda bad    | Sur at        | Hubli Dharw ad   | Mys ore       | Bhubane swar   | Kohi ma       |
|----------------------------------------|------------------|---------------|---------------|-----------------|-----------------|---------------|---------------|---------------|---------------|---------------|------------------|---------------|----------------|---------------|
|                                        |                  | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a   | Jamm u Katr a   | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a    | Jamm u Katr a | Jamm u Katr a  | Jamm u Katr a |
| 1 Facilities                           | Public Transport | 1             | 3             | 4               | 4               | 2             | 3             | 2             | 2             | 3             | 2                | 2             | 2              | 2             |
| 2 Pedestrian Infrastructure Facilities | 2                | 3             | 4             | 4               | 4               | 4             | 3             | 3             | 3             | 4             |                  | 2             | 2              | 4             |
| 3 Non-Motorized Transport Facilities   | 2                | 4             | 4             | 4               | 1               | 3             | 3             | 4             | 4             | 4             | 4                | 4             |                | 4             |
| 4 Level of Usage of ITS Facilities     | 4                | 4             | 4             | 4               | 4               | 4             | 4             | 2             | 4             | 2             | 3                | 4             | 4              |               |
| 5 Travel Speeds                        | 3                | 2             | 4             | 4               | 2               | 3             | 2             | 2             | 1             | 4             | 1                | 2             |                | 2             |
| 6 Availability Parking                 | of Spaces 4      | 4             | 4             | 4               | 4               | 4             | 4             | 3             | 3             | 4             | 3                | 4             |                | 3             |

| 7                                     | Road Safety   | 4   | 4   | 4   | 3   | 3   | 4   | 3   | 3   | 3   | 2   | 3 3   | 2   |
|---------------------------------------|---------------|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-------|-----|
| 8 Pollution Levels                    | 3             | 3   | 4   | 4   | 2   | 3   | 2   | 1   | 1   | 3   | 2   | 2     | 2   |
| 9 Use Transport System                | 2             | 3   | 3   | 3   | 2   | 3   | 3   | 2   | 3   | 3   | 3   | 3     | 4   |
| 10 Financial Sustainability for Buses | 3             | 3   | 4   | 4   | 4   | 3   | 2   | 4   | 4   |     | 3   | 3     | 3   |
|                                       |               |     |     |     |     |     |     |     |     | 3   |     |       |     |

*The level of service (LoS) is represented by '1', '2', '3', and '4'where '1'represents the highest (Good) LoS and '4'the lowest LoS (Poor).