Lok Sabha Question No. 4627 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2016-12-15
Subject: Audit of Irrigation Projects/Dams
Ministry: WATER RESOURCES, RIVER DEVELOPMENT AND GANAGA REJUVENATION
Asked by: RAKSHA NIKHIL KHADSE

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF WATER RESOURCES, RIVER DEVELOPMENT & GANGA REJUVENATION

## LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 4627

ANSWERED ON 15.12.2016

## AUDIT OF IRRIGATION PROJECTS/DAMS

## 4627.        SHRIMATI RAKSHATAI KHADSE

Will the Minister of WATER RESOURCES, RIVER DEVELOPMENT AND GANGA REJUVENATION be pleased to state:

- (a)  whether  the  Government  proposes  to  bring  irrigation  projects/dams  older  than  20  years  under social and economic audit, it so, the details and the purpose thereof;
- (b) whether the Government has prepared a list in this regard, if so, the Statewise details thereof along with the time schedule fixed for their audit;
- (c) whether the drought prone areas are to be prioritized for the purpose; and

(d) if so, the details thereof?

## ANSWER

## THE MINISTER OF STATE FOR WATER RESOURCES, RIVER DEVELOPMENT & GANGA REJUVENATION

(DR. SANJEEV KUMAR BALYAN)

(a) to (d) Central Water Commission (CWC) carries out Post Project Performance Evaluation Studies and  Water  Use  Efficiency  Studies  of  completed  major  /  medium  irrigation  projects  to  identify deficiencies  and  recommend  measures  for  improving  the  performance  of  the  projects  to  achieve envisaged objectives and targeted benefits. The scope of the studies, inter-alia, includes evaluation of system  performance,  agro-economic,  socio-economic  and  economic  analysis  of  the  project.    The projects which have completed at least 5 years of operation are selected for the study based on gap between Irrigation Potential Created & Utilization as well as the potential for drought proofing. CWC has completed Performance Evaluation Studies of 131 projects as listed at Annexure-1. Post Projects Performance  Evaluation  Studies  of  6  projects  are  at  various  stages  of  study  and  the  details  are  at Annexure-2 . In addition, Water Use Efficiency Studies have been completed for 35 projects( Annexure-3) .

*****

## Annexure referred to in reply to parts (a) to (d) of LokSabha Un-starred Question No 4627 on Audit of Irrigation Projects/Dams for answer on 15.12.2016

## List of completed Post Project Performance Evaluation Studies

|   S. No. | Project                                                                                                       | State             |
|----------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------|
|        1 | Gajuladinne Medium Project                                                                                    | Andhra Pradesh    |
|        2 | Gandipalem Project                                                                                            | Andhra Pradesh    |
|        3 | Godavari Delta                                                                                                | Andhra Pradesh    |
|        4 | Godavari Delta Region - Socio-economic and agro-economic survey                                               | Andhra Pradesh    |
|        5 | NagarjunaSagar Project                                                                                        | Andhra Pradesh    |
|        6 | Sriramsagar                                                                                                   | Andhra Pradesh    |
|        7 | Dihand dam project - Evaluation of the role of on social and economic conditions in Arunachal Pradesh         | Arunachal Pradesh |
|        8 | Bordikarai irrigation - Report on post-facto evaluation scheme                                                | Assam             |
|        9 | Jamuna Project                                                                                                | Assam             |
|       10 | Kaldiya Project                                                                                               | Assam             |
|       11 | Kaliabor Project                                                                                              | Assam             |
|       12 | Sukla Irrigation Project                                                                                      | Assam             |
|       13 | Badua Reservoir project - Post facto study                                                                    | Bihar             |
|       14 | Chandan reservoir project - Post facto study                                                                  | Bihar             |
|       15 | Durgawati irrigation project (OLD) - Post facto study                                                         | Bihar             |
|       16 | Eastern Kosi Canal Project                                                                                    | Bihar             |
|       17 | Gobai irrigation project - Post facto evaluation study                                                        | Bihar             |
|       18 | Kamla irrigation project - Post facto study                                                                   | Bihar             |
|       19 | Kiul irrigation project - Post facto study of lower                                                           | Bihar             |
|       20 | Kohira Project                                                                                                | Bihar             |
|       21 | Kohira reservoir project - Post facto study                                                                   | Bihar             |
|       22 | Kosi CAD programme - Evaluation study                                                                         | Bihar             |
|       23 | Kosi Project                                                                                                  | Bihar             |
|       24 | Lower Morhar irrigation project - Post facto study                                                            | Bihar             |
|       25 | Mayurakshi irrigation project - Post facto study                                                              | Bihar             |
|       26 | Musakhand (Karmnasa) Irrigation project - Post facto study                                                    | Bihar             |
|       27 | Oria-Danro reservoir project - Post facto study                                                               | Bihar             |
|       28 | Palna reservoir - Post facto evaluation study                                                                 | Bihar             |
|       29 | Paras irrigation project - Post facto study                                                                   | Bihar             |
|       30 | Sakri irrigation project - Post facto study                                                                   | Bihar             |
|       31 | Upper Morhar irrigation project - Post facto study                                                            | Bihar             |
|       32 | Chandan Reservoir Project - PES                                                                               | Bihar             |
|       33 | Aji-II irrigation project socio-economic survey of command area Rajkot Distrct                                | Gujarat           |
|       34 | Bhadar - Modernisation of Medium irrigation project study of socio-economic aspects and irrigation management | Gujarat           |
|       35 | Bhadar irrigation project panchmahal and KhedaDistt.                                                          | Gujarat           |
|       36 | Bhadar(P), Gujarat                                                                                            | Gujarat           |
|       37 | Damanganga                                                                                                    | Gujarat           |
|       38 | Damanganga irrigation project socio-economic study of command area                                            | Gujarat           |
|       39 | Dantiwada                                                                                                     | Gujarat           |

|   S. No. | Project                                                                                                 | State   |
|----------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------|
|       40 | Dantiwada project - A case study towards evolving criteria for planning and design of irrigation system | Gujarat |
|       41 | Demi-II irrigation project, socio-economic survey of command area Rajkot district                       | Gujarat |
|       42 | Deo Irrigation Project                                                                                  | Gujarat |
|       43 | Dharoi project - Evaluation studies for command area development programme, Gujarat                     | Gujarat |
|       44 | Dharvi Project                                                                                          | Gujarat |
|       45 | Hadaf Irrigation project, socio-economic survey of command area Panchmahals                             | Gujarat |
|       46 | Jhuj irrigation project socio-economic survey of command area Valsad&Surat                              | Gujarat |
|       47 | Kalubhar irrigation project, Bhavnagar Distt.                                                           | Gujarat |
|       48 | Karjan command area - A socio-economic study                                                            | Gujarat |
|       49 | Kelia Irrigation project, socio-economic survey of command area Valsad                                  | Gujarat |
|       50 | Kharicut                                                                                                | Gujarat |
|       51 | Kharicut medium irrigation project - An impact evaluation of within the perspective of modernisation    | Gujarat |
|       52 | Machhu-I                                                                                                | Gujarat |
|       53 | Machhu-I irrigation project socio-economic cum efficiency study                                         | Gujarat |
|       54 | Machhu-II                                                                                               | Gujarat |
|       55 | Madhavpur and UNA - Socio-economic survey in south coast of saurashtra affected by ingress of salinity  | Gujarat |
|       56 | Mazam irrigation project, Sabarkantha district                                                          | Gujarat |
|       57 | ModernisationBhadar                                                                                     | Gujarat |
|       58 | Shetrunji - Modernisation of Medium Irrigation Project,                                                 | Gujarat |
|       59 | Sipu irrigation project socio-economic survey of command area Banaskantha District                      | Gujarat |
|       60 | Sukhbhadar irrigation project socio-economic survey of command area, Bhavnagar                          | Gujarat |
|       61 | Sukhi irrigation project, socio-economic survey of command area Vadodara                                | Gujarat |
|       62 | Uben&Machhundri                                                                                         | Gujarat |
|       63 | Uren irrigation project, Socio-economic survey of command area, Junagadh& Rajkot                        | Gujarat |
|       64 | Zankhari Irrigation project socio-economic survey of command area Surat                                 | Gujarat |
|       65 | UkaiKakrapar                                                                                            | Gujarat |
|       66 | Evaluation report on the effect of augmentation tubewells on private tubewells in district Karnal       | Haryana |
|       67 | Evaluation report on the working of augmentation tubwells installed along the augmentation canal        | Haryana |
|       68 | Evaluation study of lining of water courses in Haryana                                                  | Haryana |
|       69 | Evaluation study of the working of direct irrigation tubewells in Haryana                               | Haryana |
|       70 | Gurgaon canal system - A performance evaluation                                                         | Haryana |
|       71 | JLN - Evaluation studies for command area development programme                                         | Haryana |
|       72 | Jui canal command area - Evaluation study of command area development programme                         | Haryana |
|       73 | Siwani lift irrigation project - Evaluation study, Haryana                                              | Haryana |

|   S. No. | Project                                                                      | State            |
|----------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------|------------------|
|       74 | Balh valley                                                                  | Himachal Pradesh |
|       75 | Girni                                                                        | Himachal Pradesh |
|       76 | Kanchi weir Irrigation Project                                               | Jharkhand        |
|       77 | Malaprabha project - Evaluation study for command area development programme | Karnataka        |
|       78 | Upper Mullamari Project                                                      | Karnataka        |
|       79 | Cheerakuzhi Project                                                          | Kerala           |
|       80 | Neyyar and Malampuzha irrigation project - Evaluation of the impact of CADA  | Kerala           |
|       81 | Pazhassi Project                                                             | Kerala           |
|       82 | Barna Project                                                                | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       83 | Barnai - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project        | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       84 | Bundala - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project       | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       85 | Chandora - Report on socio-economic of medium irrigation project             | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       86 | Chhirpani - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project     | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       87 | Choral - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project        | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       88 | Ghunghutta - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project    | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       89 | Gomukh - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project        | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       90 | HasdeoBango Project                                                          | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       91 | Kanhargaon - Report on socio-economic survey of medium irrigation project    | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       92 | Tawa Irrigation Project                                                      | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       93 | Samrat Ashok Sagar Irrigation Project                                        | Madhya Pradesh   |
|       94 | BOR irrigation project - Performance evaluation report                       | Maharashtra      |
|       95 | Kukadi Project                                                               | Maharashtra      |
|       96 | Mula irrigation project - Evaluation studies                                 | Maharashtra      |
|       97 | NeeraPraveera                                                                | Maharashtra      |
|       98 | Nirgudi irrigation scheme - Diagnostic analysis                              | Maharashtra      |
|       99 | Ozarked project - Report on Bench Mark socio-economic survey                 | Maharashtra      |
|      100 | Palkhed command area - Socio-economic changes                                | Maharashtra      |
|      101 | Pench Project                                                                | Maharashtra      |
|      102 | Shahnoor Project                                                             | Maharashtra      |
|      103 | Surya Project                                                                | Maharashtra      |
|      104 | Waghad project - Report on bench mark socio-economic survey                  | Maharashtra      |
|      105 | Itiadoh Irrigation Project,                                                  | Maharashtra      |
|      106 | Loktak Lift Irrigation Project                                               | Manipur          |
|      107 | Salia Project                                                                | Orissa           |
|      108 | Sunei Project                                                                | Orissa           |
|      109 | Salki Irrigation Project                                                     | Orissa           |
|      110 | Sidhwan Branch Irrigation System                                             | Punjab           |
|      111 | Sirhind Feeder canal                                                         | Punjab           |
|      112 | Chambal - Evaluation study for command area development programme            | Rajasthan        |
|      113 | Harish Chandra Sagar Project                                                 | Rajasthan        |

|   S. No. | Project                                                                     | State         |
|----------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------|
|      114 | Rajasthan canal (Indira Gandhi Nahar Project)                               | Rajasthan     |
|      115 | Surwal Project                                                              | Rajasthan     |
|      116 | Indira Gandhi Nahar Canal                                                   | Rajasthan     |
|      117 | Kota Barrage                                                                | Rajasthan     |
|      118 | Lower Bhawani project - Performance evaluation                              | Tamil Nadu    |
|      119 | ParambikulamAliyar Project - Evaluation Study on the Irrigation Development | Tamil Nadu    |
|      120 | PariyarVaigai Project                                                       | Tamil Nadu    |
|      121 | Kodayar Irrigation Project                                                  | Tamil Nadu    |
|      122 | Augasi Canal Project                                                        | Uttar Pradesh |
|      123 | Kanpur Branch Canal                                                         | Uttar Pradesh |
|      124 | Saryu Pump Canal Project                                                    | Uttar Pradesh |
|      125 | Shahzad Dam project                                                         | Uttar Pradesh |
|      126 | Sharda canal project-Evaluation of command area development                 | Uttar Pradesh |
|      127 | Study of water rates for irrigation Ramganga, ShardaSahayak, Gandak         | Uttar Pradesh |
|      128 | Nanak Sagar Irrigation Project                                              | Uttar Pradesh |
|      129 | Kangsabati Project                                                          | West Bengal   |
|      130 | Karotowa Project                                                            | West Bengal   |
|      131 | Mayurakshi - Evaluation study for CAD programme                             | West Bengal   |

## Annexure referred to in reply to parts (a) to (d) of LokSabha Un-starred Question No 4627 on Audit of Irrigation Projects/Dams for answer on 15.12.2016

## List of ongoing Post Project Performance Evaluation Studies

|   S. No. | Project                                   | State            |
|----------|-------------------------------------------|------------------|
|        1 | Bhimsagar Irrigation Project              | Rajasthan        |
|        2 | SomKamlaAmba Irrigation Project           | Rajasthan        |
|        3 | Salandi Irrigation Project                | Odisha           |
|        4 | Jayakwadi Stage-I Irrigation Project      | Maharashtra      |
|        5 | Krinshnagiri reservoir Irrigation Project | Tamil Nadu       |
|        6 | Giri Irrigation Project                   | Himachal Pradesh |

## Annexure referred to in reply to parts (a) to (d) of LokSabha Un-starred Question No 4627 on Audit of Irrigation Projects/Dams for answer on 15.12.2016

## List of completed Water Use Efficiency Studies

|   Sl No | Name of Project                                   | State          |
|---------|---------------------------------------------------|----------------|
|       1 | KoilSagar Project                                 | Andhra Pradesh |
|       2 | Bhairavanithippa Project                          | Andhra Pradesh |
|       3 | Augmentation Canal Project                        | Haryana        |
|       4 | Matatila Dam Project                              | Uttar Pradesh  |
|       5 | Eastern sone canal                                | Bihar          |
|       6 | Vamsadhara Project                                | Andhra Pradesh |
|       7 | Durgawathi Irrigation Project                     | Bihar          |
|       8 | Dholabaha Dam Project                             | Punjab         |
|       9 | Kamla Irrigation Project                          | Bihar          |
|      10 | Naugarh Dam Irrigation Project                    | Uttar Pradesh  |
|      11 | Ahraura Dam Irrigation Project                    | Uttar Pradesh  |
|      12 | Tungabhadra High Level Canal                      | Andhra Pradesh |
|      13 | Godavari Delta System (Sir Arthur Cotton Barrage) | Andhra Pradesh |
|      14 | Sri Ram Sagar Project                             | Andhra Pradesh |
|      15 | Rajolibanda Diversion Scheme                      | Andhra Pradesh |
|      16 | East Baigul Reservoir Project                     | Uttar Pradesh  |
|      17 | Krishna Delta System (Prakasam Barrage)           | Andhra Pradesh |
|      18 | Nizamsagar Project                                | Andhra Pradesh |
|      19 | WalmikiSarovar Project                            | Uttar Pradesh  |
|      20 | Pili Dam Project                                  | Uttar Pradesh  |
|      21 | RanjitSagar Dam Project                           | Punjab         |
|      22 | Tungabhadra Low Level Canal                       | Andhra Pradesh |
|      23 | Saran Canal Irrigation Project                    | Bihar          |
|      24 | Upper Morhar                                      | Bihar          |
|      25 | Kurnool -Cuddapah Canal System                    | Andhra Pradesh |
|      26 | Gandipalem Project                                | Andhra Pradesh |
|      27 | Gajuladinne (SanjeevaiahSagar Project)            | Andhra Pradesh |
|      28 | NagarjunaSagar Project                            | Andhra Pradesh |
|      29 | Somasila Project                                  | Andhra Pradesh |
|      30 | Kaddam Project                                    | Andhra Pradesh |
|      31 | Srisailam Project                                 | Andhra Pradesh |
|      32 | Narayanapuram Project                             | Andhra Pradesh |
|      33 | Yeleru Project                                    | Andhra Pradesh |
|      34 | Nagal Lift Project                                | Haryana        |
|      35 | Upper Manair Project                              | Andhra Pradesh |