Lok Sabha Question No. 2520 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2018-03-09
Subject: Conduct and Ethics for Doctors
Ministry: HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE
Asked by: CHANDU LAL SAHU, RAJESH KUMAR DIWAKAR, SANTOSH AHLAWAT

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE

LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 2520 TO BE ANSWERED ON 9 TH MARCH, 2018

## CONDUCT AND ETHICS F OR DOCTORS

## 2520. SHRI CHANDU LAL SAHU: SHRI RAJESH KUMAR DIWAKER: SHRIMATI SANTOSH AHLAWAT:

Will the Minister of HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE be pleased to state:

- (a)  whether  the  Medical  Council  of India  sets  any  norms  regarding  professional conduct, ethics and policy for registered doctors which take care of the interests of the doctors as well as the community in a comprehensive manner;
- (b) if so, the details thereof along with the total number of complaints received by the council during the last three  years and the total number of complaints settled and pending out of them, State/UT - wise; and
- (c) the total number of doctors found guilty of professional misconduct during the last ten years along with the action take  in this regard, State/UT - wise?

## ANSWER THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF HEALTH AN D FAMILY WELFARE (SHRI ASHWINI KUMAR CHOUBEY)

- (a): Medical Council of India with the previous approval of the Central Government h notified Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette And Ethics) Regulati 2002  to  prescribe  standards  of  p rofessional  conduct  and  etiquette  and  code  of  ethics  for medical  practitioners.  The  MCI  or  the  appropriate  State  Medical  Councils  have  b empowered to take disciplinary action against a doctor for violation of the provision aforesaid Regulations. As and when complaints are received against the violation of code o ethics  for  doctors,  such  complaints  are  referred  by  MCI  to  the  concerned  State  Me Councils  where  the  doctors/medical  practitioners  are  registered.  The  MCI  is  an  Appe Authority.
- (b): MCI informed that during the last three years, the complaint received are as unde
- (c): The details of action taken by the MCI against the doctors found guilty of profes misconduct are at Annexure.

|                                                   | 2015    |   2016 |   2017 |
|---------------------------------------------------|---------|--------|--------|
| Total complaints received in the year             | 154     |    164 |     67 |
| Complaints refer to State Medical Councils in the | year 83 |     98 |     50 |

Annexure Action taken by the MCI against the doctors found guilty of professional misconduct 2014

|   S.NO. | Date of Ethic Meeting   | Name of Doctor                 | Punishment                                                    |
|---------|-------------------------|--------------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------|
|       1 | 21.02.2014              | Dr.Narendra Vikramaditya Yadav | 5 years (IMR)                                                 |
|       2 | 21.02.2014              | Dr. Vineet Garg                | 1 Year (IMR)                                                  |
|       3 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Kapoor Choudhary, Jalore   | 6 months under 8.5                                            |
|       4 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Pramod Sharma              | 6 months under 8.5                                            |
|       5 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. B.R. Rao                   | Warning                                                       |
|       6 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Mrs. Alka Rao              | Warning                                                       |
|       7 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Ketan Bhatt                | Warning                                                       |
|       8 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. P.K. Pujari                | 6 months under 8.5                                            |
|       9 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Ranjan Bhattacharjeet      | 6 months under 8.5                                            |
|      10 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Asis Kumar Patra           | 6 months under 8.5                                            |
|      11 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Bindu Kedia                | Warning                                                       |
|      12 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Deepa Singh                | 3 months (IMR) + refund money charged for i.e. 22000/ -       |
|      13 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Alok Singh                 | Warning                                                       |
|      14 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. V.P. Sinha                 | 3 months (IMR)                                                |
|      15 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Pradeep                    | 2 years (IMR)                                                 |
|      16 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Naresh Johri               | 6 months (IMR)                                                |
|      17 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Rajesh Gupta               | 6 months (IMR)                                                |
|      18 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Bhatnagar                  | 3 months (IMR)                                                |
|      19 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Vinay Surain               | Warning                                                       |
|      20 | 24.04.2014              | Dr. Rama Rathi Saboo           | Warning                                                       |
|      21 | 22.05.2014              | Dr. Harish Kumar               | 1 months (SMR) - Uphold DMC decision.                         |
|      22 | 22.05.2014              | Dr. Shrihari Abhaji Dhore      | 3 months (SMR) - Uphold Maharashtra Medical Council decision. |
|      23 | 22.05.2014              | Dr. Anand Prakash Sharma       | 5 year (SMR/IMR) - Uphold UPMC decision                       |
|      24 | 22.05.2014              | Dr. Prafulla MIsra             | Warning - Uphold DMC decision.                                |
|      25 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. B.K. Mahato                | 6 months (IMR)                                                |
|      26 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Liyakat Ali                | 1 Year (IMR)                                                  |
|      27 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Nirmala Aggarwal           | 1 Year (IMR)                                                  |
|      28 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Srinivas Rao               | Warning                                                       |
|      29 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Hari Krishan P             | Warning                                                       |
|      30 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Vivek Nigam                | Suspended under                                               |
|      31 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Rohit R. Kulkarni          | 8.5 Suspended under 8.5                                       |
|      32 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Ashok Kumar Ghosh          | Warning                                                       |
|      33 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Sujit Sarkar               | Warning                                                       |
|      34 | 13.08.2014              | Dr.Arvind Das                  | Warning                                                       |
|      35 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Mohit Mathur               | Warning                                                       |
|      36 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Naveen Kishore             | Warning                                                       |
|      37 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Ashok Kumar Bajpai         | 5 Years debarred from taking any post of teacher              |
|      38 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. R. Vedamanikam             | 1 year (IMR)                                                  |
|      39 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Sushil Jain                | Warning                                                       |

|   S.NO. | Date of Ethic Meeting   | Name of Doctor                                                 | Punishment                           |
|---------|-------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|
|      40 | 13.08.2014              | Dr. Ranjit Kumar                                               | Suspended under 8.5                  |
|      41 | 30.09.2014              | Dr. Ramcharan Thiagarajan                                      | 1 year (IMR/SMR)                     |
|      42 | 09.10.2014              | Dr. lallan Prasad                                              | 1 year (IMR)                         |
|      43 | 09.10.2014              | Dr. Sudhir Kumar                                               | 1 month IMR - uphold decision of DMC |
|      44 | 09.10.2014              | Dr. Sunil Kumar Bakshi                                         | 1 month IMR - uphold decision of DMC |
|      45 | 09.10.2014              | Dr. Devika Bhatt                                               | Suspended under 8.5                  |
|      46 | 09.10.2014              | Dr. Rishiraj Bhatt                                             | Suspended under 8.5                  |
|      47 | 17.11.2014              | Dr. Jayaprakash, Principal, MullerInstt. Of Med. Sc. Mangalore | Fr. Warning                          |
|      48 | 17.11.2014              | Dr. H.Basavanagowdappa, Principal JSS Med.College.             | Permanently Debarred                 |
|      49 | 17.11.2014              | Dr. H. Rangappa, Dean, Rajarajeshwari                          | 5years debarred from taking any post |
|      50 | 17.11.2014              | Dr. Bala Krishnan                                              | Permanently debarred.                |

|   S. No. | Ethics Committee Meeting dated   | Doctor's Name                                                                                                                                                                 | Period of punishment awarded                                                                                                             |
|----------|----------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|        1 | 15- 16.01.2015                   | Dr. Sukhchain Singh Bhullar Dr. B. K. Sanjay                                                                                                                                  | and any teaching post/administrative in any medical college for a 5 (five Years)                                                         |
|        2 | 04- 05.11.2015                   | Dr. Basudeb Tewari                                                                                                                                                            | Warning                                                                                                                                  |
|        3 | 28.01.2015                       | Dr.(Mrs.) Meenakshi Chaki                                                                                                                                                     | Warning                                                                                                                                  |
|        4 | 28.01.2015                       | Dr. Manoj Dhingra                                                                                                                                                             | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                                                  |
|        5 | 05- 06.02.2015                   | Dr. Goli Venkateshwar Rao                                                                                                                                                     | Remove for 3 (Three) Months                                                                                                              |
|        6 | 19- 20.02.2015                   | Dr. A. Goenkaand Dr. Abhay Tyagi                                                                                                                                              | Warning                                                                                                                                  |
|        7 | 19- 20.02.2015                   | Dr. M. L. Sharma                                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                                                  |
|        8 | 19- 20.02.2015                   | Dr. Gaurav Bansal and Dr. Kohli Dr. Alka Goel and Dr. Renu Agarwal Dr. Anu Nayar                                                                                              | V.K. Remove for 1 (One) Year Remove for 3 (Three) Months Warning                                                                         |
|        9 | 17- 18.03.2015                   | Dr. Jatinder Sharma                                                                                                                                                           | Warning                                                                                                                                  |
|       10 | 17- 18.03.2015                   | Dr. Praveen Rathi                                                                                                                                                             | Warning                                                                                                                                  |
|       11 | 06- 07.04.2015                   | Dr. S.B. Dabral                                                                                                                                                               | permanently debar from taking post of Principal/Dean/Administrative any teaching post of similar nature                                  |
|       12 | 06- 07.04.2015                   | Dr. Rajender Singh Dr. Prafull Kumar Arya                                                                                                                                     | Remove for 5 (Five) Years from undertaking any post of teacher, administrative capacity post of similar nature Remove for 5 (Five) Years |
|       13 | 06- 07.4.2015                    | Dr. H. Basavanagowdappa                                                                                                                                                       | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                                                               |
|       14 | 29 th & 30 th April, 2015        | Dr. Parveen Doddamani                                                                                                                                                         | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                                                               |
|       14 | 26- 27.05.2015                   | Dr. Narain Harsinghani                                                                                                                                                        | Remove for 3 (Three) Months                                                                                                              |
|       15 | 16- 17.06.2015                   | Dr. T. Gunasagaran, Dr. Bavanisankar T., Dr. Dipti Shah, Dr. M. P. Sasi, Dr. A. H. Nagarajappa and Dr. Vidya Modgaonkar                                                       | permanently debarred from the Assessors                                                                                                  |
|       16 | 16- 17.06.2015                   | Dr. K. Ravi, Dr. Shilpa Rao, Dr. Dubey, Dr. Yamini Nilesh Trivedi and Dr. Srikumari Damodaran                                                                                 | Kirti permanently debarred from the the MCI Assessment                                                                                   |
|       17 | 16- 17.06.2015                   | Dr. Atul Chhabra                                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 6 (Six) Months                                                                                                                |
|       18 | 16- 17.06.2015                   | Dr.Basudev Tewari                                                                                                                                                             | Warning                                                                                                                                  |
|       19 | 16- 17.06.2015                   | 1. Dr. SubodhBanzal, Professor of Medicine 2. Dr. MahendraTilkar, Assistant Professor of Medicine 3. Dr. Kailash Bhatia, Professor of Dermatology 4. Dr. ManojKela, Associate | Remove for 3 (Three) Years from teaching post                                                                                            |

Administrative

|    |                | Professor of Surgery 5. Dr. Rajiv Jain, Professor of Surgery. 6. Dr. SaketJati, Associate                                                                                                                                                                                                       | Associate                                                                                                      |
|----|----------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 20 | 25- 26.06.2015 | Dr. Neetu Ras togi                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                        |
| 21 | 10- 11.08.2015 | 1. Dr. A. K. Bhargava, Professor of Pathology 2. Dr. RakeshLal, Associate Professor of Radiology 3. Dr. Ramesh M. Vanjani, Professor of Pathology 4. Dr. N. K. Malpani, Professor of General Surgery 5. Dr. ShailjaRatanShukla, Professor of DVL 6. Dr. PawanShorey, Professor of Ophthalmology | Remove for 5 (Five) from undertaking any post of nature/teaching post of similar any university and/or medical |
| 22 | 10- 11.08.2015 | Dr. H Ran gappa                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | Remove for 5 (Five)                                                                                            |
| 23 | 27- 28.08.2015 | Dr. Ravi Prakash Agarwal                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        | Years Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                               |
| 24 | 27- 28.08.2015 | Dr. Nandeesh                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                                     |
| 25 | 27- 28.08.2015 | Dr. T.K. Aneetha                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                                     |
| 26 | 27- 28.08.2015 | Dr.Mohammed Shahid                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                                     |
| 27 | 29- 30.09.2015 | Dr. Ashok Kumar Ghosh                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                        |
| 28 | 29- 30.09.2015 | Dr. Sujit Sarkar                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                        |
| 29 | 15- 16.10.2015 | Dr. N. S. Kothari                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               | Permanently debar fro m undertaking any post of Principal/Dean or Administrative post of similar               |
| 30 | 4- 5.11.2015   | of Ophthalmology Dr. Ashalata Shankararao                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       | Jagtap In terms of clause 8.5. of I ndian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations,     |
| 31 | 4- 5.11.2015   | Dr. Kailash ChandraManchanda                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    | In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional                                                |
| 32 | 4- 5.11.2015   | Dr. Shri Ram Bharadwaj                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          | Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional             |
| 33 | 4- 5.11.2015   | Dr. Kanwardeep Randhawa                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         | Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations,                                                                             |
| 34 | 02-            | The Dean Dr. Ashok Kumar                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        | Remove for 180 Debar for 1 (One)                                                                               |
|    | 03.12.2015     |                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | days year from                                                                                                 |

|    |                | Dhanvijay                                                          | undertaking any post of or any Administrative post                                                                                                                                                       |
|----|----------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 35 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr. Aswani Patchala                                                | Remove for 6 (Six) months                                                                                                                                                                                |
| 36 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr.Sadanand Govindrao Kulkarni                                     | In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) 2002. Remove for 5 (Year) Years any post Administrative nature/teaching similar nature. ( Decision sent on dated ) |
| 37 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr. Sabha Shankar Tiwari                                           | In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) 2002.                                                                                                              |
| 38 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr. Rupendra Singh                                                 | In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) Re gulations, 2002.                                                                                                |
| 39 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr. Amit Panwar                                                    | In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) 2002.                                                                                                              |
| 40 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dean/Principal of Chintpurni College & Hospital, Pathankot, Punjab | Medical In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) 2002.                                                                                                      |
| 41 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr. Manish Kumar                                                   | In terms of clause 8.5. of Indian Medical Council (Professional Etiquette and Ethics) Regul ations,                                                                                                      |
| 42 | 22- 23.12.2015 | Dr. Paresh Ruparel Dr. U.B. Shah                                   | Remove for 5 (Year) Yeas any post Administrative nature/teaching                                                                                                                                         |

| 1.      | 05- 06.01.2016   | Dr. V. S. Solanki Dr. Madhu Chadha                                            | More Careful                                                                                                  |
|---------|------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 2.      | 19- 20.01.2016   | Dr. Y. P. Bhattacharya Dr. S. K. Sinha                                        | In terms of clause 8.5. Indian Medical Council (Professional conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 |
| 3.      | 19- 20.01.2016   | Dr. K. Koteshwer Rao Prof. J. Sasi Kumar and Dr.Gurunadha Rao Dr. Anil Grover | Debarred permanently warning Five Years                                                                       |
| 4.      | 19- 20.01.2016   | Dr. R.P. Singh                                                                | Remove for 6 (six) Months                                                                                     |
| 5.      | 17- 18.02.2016   | Dr. Arvind Kumar                                                              | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
| 6.      | 17- 18.02.2016   | Dr. Ashok Kumar Ghosh                                                         | Remove for 1 (One) Year Remove for 6 (six) Months                                                             |
| 7.      | 17- 18.02.2016   | Dr. Sujit Sarkar Dean Dr. Anil Agarwal                                        | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
| 8.      | 17- 18.02.2016   | Dr. Shirish B. Patil                                                          | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
| 9.      | 17- 18.02.2016   | Dr. Mihir Choudhary Dr. Swapnil Thorat                                        | warning '                                                                                                     |
| 10.     | 17- 18.03.2016   | Dr. Alok Madan Dr. Mahesh Gupta                                               | Warning '                                                                                                     |
| 11.     | 17- 18.03.2016   | Dean/Principal                                                                | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
| 12.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Talisetti Bharti                                                          | warning                                                                                                       |
| 13.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Vijay Kumar Sharda                                                        | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 14.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. E. Sudhakar Reddy                                                         | warning                                                                                                       |
| 15.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Arunachalam Kumar                                                         | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 16.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. H. P. Shanta                                                              | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 17.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Bolar Ram Prasad                                                          | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 19.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Mohammad Shuaib                                                           | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 20.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Smita Singh Banerjee                                                      | Remove for 3 (Three)                                                                                          |
| 21.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Shilpa S. Naik                                                            | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 22.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Harshida Sukhalagir Gosai                                                 | Remove for 3 (Three)                                                                                          |
| 23.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Muddu Surendra Nehru                                                      | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 24.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. NemadePankaj Ramesh                                                       | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 25.     | 18.04.20146      | Dr. Narendrula Sunitha                                                        | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 26.     | 18.04.2016       | Dr. Rajnish Chandran                                                          | Remove for 3 (Three)                                                                                          |
| 27.     | 18.06.2016       | Dr. Bhagat Haridas                                                            | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 28.     | 18.06.2016       | Dr.Pradhya P. Kulkarni                                                        | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 29.     | 18.06.2016       | Dr. Sagar Sunka                                                               | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 31.     | 18.06.2016       | Dr. Ved Prakash Gupta                                                         |                                                                                                               |
| 30.     | 18.06.2016       | Dr. B. Venugopal Rao                                                          | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                           |
| 32.     | 18.06.2016       | Dr. Vijay Kumar Chaudhary                                                     | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
| 33. 34. | 18.06.2016       | Dr. Basavaraj M. Tinginkai Dr. Hemant Kumar                                   | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months Remove for 3 (Three)                                                                |
|         | 18.06.2016       |                                                                               |                                                                                                               |

|   35. | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Muthu Kumar R.                                                                                                    | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|-------|----------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|    36 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Abhay Kumar                                                                                                       | Remove for 3 (Three)                                                                                          |
|    37 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Ishan Hemant Kumar Shah                                                                                           | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    38 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Ruchi Garg                                                                                                        | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    39 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Sonawane Yashdeep Liladhar                                                                                        | Remove for 3 (Three)                                                                                          |
|    40 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. M. Chitra                                                                                                         | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    41 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Amit Srivastava                                                                                                   | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    42 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. P. Madanika                                                                                                       | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    43 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Sachin S Shabadi                                                                                                  | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    45 | 18.06.2016     | Dr. Vishal K. Kadeli                                                                                                  | Remove for 6 (SIx) Months                                                                                     |
|    46 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. S. Swarupa Rani                                                                                                   | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
|    47 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. N.S. Sharma of the then Dean Chintpurni Medical College & Hospital, Bungal, Pathankot, Punjab.                    | of Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                                                 |
|    48 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Ardaman Singh                                                                                                     | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
|    49 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. N.S. Sharma of the then Dean Chintpurni Medical College & Hospital, Bungal, Pathankot, Punjab.                    | of Remove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                                |
|    50 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Ravdeep Singh                                                                                                     | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
|    51 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Mrinalini, Dean ofMelmaruvathur Adhiparasakthi Institute of Medical Sciences & Research, Melmaruvathur, Tamilnadu | Remove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                                   |
|    52 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Dipti Basu the then Dean of Hi - Tech Medical College, Rourkela                                                   | Remove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                                   |
|    53 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Om Prakash Pandey                                                                                                 | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
|    54 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Tushar R. Patil                                                                                                   | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
|    55 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Mrinalini, Dean ofMelmaruvathur Adhiparasakthi Institute of Medical Sciences & Research, Melmaruvathur, Tamilnadu | Remove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                                   |
|    56 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. M. Rama Rao                                                                                                       | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                                                       |
|    57 | 03- 04.05.2016 | Dr. Rama Kant                                                                                                         | Remove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                                   |
|    58 | 24- 25.05.2016 | Dr. Amit Jagtap                                                                                                       | Warning                                                                                                       |
|    59 | 24- 25.05.2016 | Dr. Nirmala Jaiswal Dr. Pritha Datta                                                                                  | In terms of clause 8.5. Indian Medical Council (Professional conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 |
|    60 | 23- 24.06.2016 | Dr. Muktanjali Arya, Dr. A. S. Sekhon Dr. V. Mohan Dr. P.K. Arya                                                      | Remove for 3 (Three) Year s ' '                                                                               |
|    61 | 23- 24.06.2016 | Dr. N. K. Das, Dr. SP Choudhary, Dr. R. K. Mishra, Dr. J.K. Prasad Dr. P. K. Moonka                                   | Remove for 1 (One) Month ' ' '                                                                                |
|    62 | 30.06.2016     | Dr. Neetu Rastogi                                                                                                     | Remove for 1 (One) Month                                                                                      |
|    63 | 4- 5.08.2016   | Dr. Keerti Mundey                                                                                                     | Remove for 6 (Six) Month                                                                                      |
|    64 | 19- 20.08.2016 | Dr. Surendra Bhandari the then Maheshwara Medical College, Medak                                                      | Dean, Remove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                             |
|    65 | 19- 20.08.2016 | District Dr. Kailash Chandra Manchanda,                                                                               | DeanRemove for 3 (Three) Year s                                                                               |

|    |              | of Chintpurni Medical College & Hospital, Pathankot, Punjab   |                                              |
|----|--------------|---------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------|
| 66 | 7- 8.09.2016 | Dr. Manoj Kumar Rai                                           | Remove for 1 (One) Year                      |
| 67 | 5/6.10.2016  | Dr. H. S. Somasekhar Dr.B. Vijay Kumar                        | Warning Warning & Remove for 3 (Three) Years |
| 68 | 5/6.10.2016  | Dr. S. B. Ongale                                              | Warning                                      |
| 69 | 5/6.10.2016  | Dr. Sharad Gupta The Dean Dr. Mahendra Raj Waghray            | Debarred for 5 (Five) Remove for 3 (Three)   |
| 70 | 5/6.10.2016  | The Principal Dr. S. Balakrishanan                            | Debarred for 1(One) Year                     |
| 71 | 5/6.10.2016  | The Principal Dr.Jayapakash                                   | Debarred for 1(One) Year                     |
| 72 | 5/6.10.2016  | The Dean Dr. H. Rangappa                                      | Debarred for 1(One) Year                     |
| 73 | 09.11.2016   | Dr. Gunjan Singh                                              | Remove for 6 (Six) Months                    |

|   S. No. | Ethics Committee Meeting dated   | Doctor's Name                                                                                                                                                     | Period of punishment awarded                                                     |
|----------|----------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|        1 | 14.12.2016                       | Dr. Manish Kumar Singh                                                                                                                                            | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                          |
|        2 | 29/30.11.2016                    | The Principal Dr.(Lt.Col.) K. S. N. & Dr. Gudurusree Latha Dr. C. Madhav Rao Dr. Pradeep Vundavalli Dr. Pandula Revathi Dr. D.K. Chedrolu Dr. Y. Nagatalupula Rao | Rao Remove for 1 (One) Year Remove for 3 (Three) Years ' ' ' ' '                 |
|        3 | 29/30.11.2016                    | Dr. Pratibha D. Athavia                                                                                                                                           | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                          |
|        4 | 29/30.11.2016                    | Dr. Parul Verma                                                                                                                                                   | Remove for 6 (Six) Months                                                        |
|        5 | 29/30.11.2016                    | Dr. Shiuli                                                                                                                                                        | Remove for 6 (Six) Months                                                        |
|        6 | 29/30.11.2016                    | Dr. Sanjeev Kumar                                                                                                                                                 | Remove for 6 (Six) Months                                                        |
|        7 | 30.12.2016                       | Dr. Kaushik Samajdar                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 3 (Three) Months                                                      |
|        8 | 09.01.2017                       | Dr. Bhawani Shankar                                                                                                                                               | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                       |
|        9 | 09.01.2017                       | The then Dean, Dr. Deepti Basu The then Dean, Dr. Ch. Lakshmi Kumar &                                                                                             | Remove for 3 (Three) Years '                                                     |
|       10 | 24/25.01.2017                    | The then Dean Dr. U. B. Shah                                                                                                                                      | Remove for 1 (One) Year Remove for 3 (Three) Years                               |
|       11 | 24/25.01.2017                    | Dr. Umesh Gupta                                                                                                                                                   | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                                       |
|       12 | 24/25.01.2017                    | Dr. Deepak Kumar Dr. Prabhat Sinha                                                                                                                                | Warning '                                                                        |
|       13 | 24/25.01.2017                    | The Ex- Principal Dr. Chandrakant Shirohi                                                                                                                         | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                          |
|       14 | 24/25.01.2017                    | Dr. Shailendra Singh                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                          |
|       15 | 06.04.2017                       | Dr.(Prof.) Kedar Bandhopadhyay                                                                                                                                    | Remove for3(Three) Months                                                        |
|       16 | 27/28.04.2017                    | Dr. Aashish N. Tripathi                                                                                                                                           | Remove for 3(Three) Months                                                       |
|       17 | 27/28.04.2017                    | Dr. Gour Chandra Naskar & Dr. Charan Roy & Dr. Ashok Kumar Biswas & Dr. R. Basu                                                                                   | Chandi Remove for 3 (Three) Years Warning                                        |
|       18 | 27/28.04.2017                    | Dr. Jose Chellan                                                                                                                                                  | Remove 2 (Two) Years                                                             |
|       19 | 27/28.04.2017                    | Dr. Rajeev Kumar Aggarwal, Dr. Chandra Prakash Singh, Dr. P.K. Vashist & The then Dean Dr. M. D. Tripathi                                                         | Remove for 3 (Three) Years Remove for 3 (Three) Years Remove for 3 (Three) Years |
|       20 | 27/28.04.2017                    | Dr. Nikhil Raheja                                                                                                                                                 | Remove for 3 (Three) Years Remove for 1 (One) Year                               |
|       21 | 27/28.04.2017                    | Dr. Purnendu Roy                                                                                                                                                  | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                                          |

|   22. | 27/28.04.2017             | The then Dean Dr. Rajiv Kumar Gupta                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                |
|-------|---------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------|
|    23 | 27/28.04.2017             | Dr. Anil Bharani, Dr. Ujwal Sardesai, Dr.V. S. Pal, Dr. Abhay Paliwal, Pali Rastogi, Dr. Hemant Jain, Ashish Patel, Dr. Raghulam Razdan                                                                                                                                                                                                                       | Dr. Dr. Remove for 3(Three) Months ' ' '                  |
|    24 | 27/28.04.2017             | Dr. Murarilal Nagarmal Saraf                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  | ' Remove for 5 (Five) Years                               |
|    25 | 18/19.05.2017             | Dr. Yatish Sharma Dr. Pawan Khurana                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           | Warning '                                                 |
|    26 | 06/07.06.2017             | the then Dean, SMBT Institute Medical Sciences & Research Centre & Dr. Pankajrao Himmatrao Patil, Dr. Nukte Muktanand Ratilal, Dr. Sawant Rujuta Rajesh, Dr. Mahajan Pratik shit Madhav, Dr. Amit Ramnath Kakad , Dr. Sakharam Tulshiram Ghankute, Nikam Maheshkumar Prabhakarand Dr.Khadose Gopal Jagannath Dr.Tharat Sukhdeo Lingaji Dr.Jayant R Maheshwari | of Dr. Remove for 3 (Three) Years Remove for 1 (One) Year |
|    27 | 06/07.06.2017             | The then Dean, Dr. R. Gopinathan                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                |
|    28 | 30th June & 1st July 2017 | Dr. Parveen Choudhary                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                   |
|    29 | 30th June & 1st July 2017 | Dr. Seema Shivhare                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            | Remove for 1 (One) Month                                  |
|    30 | 0                         | 0                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             | 0                                                         |
|    31 | 22 nd September, 2017     | Dr.G.P.I Singh                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                |
|    32 | 22 nd September, 2017     | Dr. Darshan M.S                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                   |
|    33 | 16 th October, 2017       | Dr. Rajammal Bhagirathy Ammal                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                   |
|    34 | 22 nd September, 2017     | Dr. Dinesh Chandra Gupta                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      | Remove for 1 (One) Year                                   |
|    35 | 30 th October, 2017       | Dr. Meena Taneja                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              | Remove for 5 (Five) Years                                 |
|    36 | 21 st September, 2017     | Dr. Surender Bhandari                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         | Remove for 3 (Three) Years                                |

|   S. No. | Ethics Committee Meeting dated   | Doctor's Name                          | Period of punishment awarded   |
|----------|----------------------------------|----------------------------------------|--------------------------------|
|        1 | 20 th & 21 st November, 2017     | Dr. Kanu Verma Dr. Kishan Kumar Sharma | Remove for 3 (Three) Years     |
|        2 | 28 th November, 2017             | Dr. Narendra Kumar Gupta               | Permanently erase from IMR/SMR |