Lok Sabha Question No. 262 (STARRED), answered on 2017-08-03
Subject: Bribe to bag Contracts
Ministry: ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS
Asked by: DHARMENDRA YADAV, ANWHAR RAAJHAA

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS

## LOK SABHA STARRED QUESTION NO. 262

ANSWERED ON 03 rd  AUGUST, 2017

## BRIBE TO BAG CONTRACTS

## *262   SHRI DHARMENDRA YADAV: SHRI A. ANWHAR RAAJHAA:

## Will the Minister of ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS

## सड़क परिवहन औि िाजमार्ग मंत्री

be pleased to state:

- (a) whether officials of the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) have allegedly been bribed by the US based firms to bag contracts during 2011-15;
- (b) if so, the details thereof along with the reaction of the Government thereto;
- (c) whether the Government has conducted any inquiry in this regard;
- (d) if  so,  the  outcome  thereof  along  with  the  action  taken/proposed  to  be  taken  by  the Government in this regard; and
- (e) the names of the National Highways allocated to the said firms along with the present status thereof, State-wise?

## ANSWER

## THE MINISTER OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS

(SHRI NITIN JAIRAM GADKARI)

- (a) to (e) The statement is laid on the Table of the House.

STATEMENT REFERRED TO IN REPLY TO PARTS (a) TO (e)  OF  LOK  SABHA STARRED  QUESTION  NO.  262  ANSWERED  ON  3 RD AUGUST,  2017  ASKED  BY SHRI  DHARMENDRA YADAV AND SHRI A. ANWHAR RAAJHAA REGARDING 'BRIBES TO BAG CONTRACTS'

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(a) & (b) It  was  reported  in  media  that  M/s  CDM Smith, through its employees and agents, and those of its wholly owned subsidiary in India (CDM India), paid approximately $1.18  million  in  bribes  to  government  officials  in  India  in  exchange  for  highway construction supervision and design contracts.  This media report emanates from the U.S. Department  of  Justice,  Criminal  Division  letter  dated  June  21,  2017  available  on  their official website. The relevant part of the aforesaid letter is extracted below:

'From approximately 2011 until approximately 2015, employees of CDM Smith's division  responsible  for  India  operations  and  CDM  India  illegally  paid  bribes  to officials  in  the  National  Highways  Authority  of  India  ('NHAI'),  India's  stateowned highway management agency and an 'instrumentality' under the FCPA, in order  to  receive  contracts  from  NHAI.  The  bribes  generally  were  2-4%  of  the contract price and paid through fraudulent subcontractors, who provided no actual services and understood that payments were meant to solely benefit the officials.'

The  National  Highways  Authority  of  India  has  compiled  the  list  of  all  the  consultancy assignments awarded to the said firm and its associates. The Ministry of Road Transport & Highways (MoRTH) and the National Highways Authority of India have initiated steps to obtain the supporting documents so as to take the matter to logical conclusion. MoRTH has taken up the matter with the Ministry of External Affairs as well as the Indian Embassy in USA  to  liaise  with  U.S.  Department  of  Justice  to  obtain  the  information  and  records gathered by them during their inquiry.

Incidentally, it may be mentioned that the NHAI had debarred the said firm for a period of 3  (three)  months  in  2015  from  participating/  engagement  in  future  bidding  of  NHAI projects  because  of  deficiency  in  services  in  one  of  the  projects,  i.e.  Dholpur-  Morena Section of NH-3. Similarly, in a lone assignment awarded to the said firm, the NHIDCL has debarred the said firm this year for a period of two years.

(c)& (d) The  Central  Vigilance  Commission  of  India  has  constituted  a  Special InvestigationTeam of three officers to investigate the matter and report to Commission.

(e) Details  of  projects  wherein  CDM  Smith  was  engaged  by  NHAI  for  Engineering Consultancy  Services  so  for  along  with  the  status  of  their  completion  is  attached  at Annexure-1.

## Annexure-1

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                              | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates          | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                               | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                  |
| 1                                                                        | Independent Consultancy Services for 4-laning of Armur- Adloor-Yellareddy Section | Telangana                                                                | 7                                                                        | 4,76,29,091 (LC) + US$ 6,79,320 (FC)                                     | 4,67,74,668 (LC) + US$ 2,83,255 (FC)                                     | 13.12.2010                                                               | 22.12.2015                                                               |                                                                          |
| 2                                                                        | IE Services for 6-laning of Vijayawada-Gundugolanu Section                        | Andhra Pradesh                                                           | 5                                                                        | 8,36,88,800                                                              | 4,55,43,538                                                              | 11.02.2013                                                               | 12.07.2016                                                               |                                                                          |
| 3                                                                        | IE Services for 4-laning of Vijayawada-Machilipatnam Section                      | Andhra Pradesh                                                           | 9                                                                        | 7,76,23,500                                                              | 1,96,72,753                                                              | 18.10.2012                                                               | 12.09.2014                                                               |                                                                          |
| 4                                                                        | Consultancy Services for Packages EW (RJ-9)                                       | Rajasthan                                                                | 76                                                                       | 11,09,63,711 (LC) + US$ 28,62,600 (FC)                                   | 16,21,99,256                                                             | 14.02.2006                                                               | July, 2010                                                               |                                                                          |
| 5                                                                        | Consultancy Services for Packages EW (RJ-10)                                      | Rajasthan                                                                | 76                                                                       | 11,09,63,711 (LC) + US$ 28,62,600 (FC)                                   | 16,21,99,256                                                             | 14.02.2006                                                               | July, 2010                                                               |                                                                          |
| 6                                                                        | Consultancy Services for                                                          | Rajasthan                                                                | 76                                                                       | 11,09,63,711 (LC) + US$ 28,62,600 (FC)                                   | 16,21,99,256                                                             | 14.02.2006                                                               | July, 2010                                                               |                                                                          |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                      | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                  |
|                                                                          | Packages EW (RJ-11)                                                      |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |
| 7                                                                        | 4-laning of Dholpur-Morena Section                                       | Rajasthan                                                                | 3                                                                        | 5,27,35,600                                                              | 8,72,60,302                                                              | 11.03.2008                                                               | 15.07.2017                                                               |                                                                          |
| 8                                                                        | Consultancy Services for 4- laning of Lucknow-Sitapur Section            | Uttar Pradesh                                                            | 24                                                                       | 3,73,25,800 (LC) + US$ 7,03,060 (FC)                                     | 4,93,93,346 (LC) + US$ 8,58,404 (FC)                                     | 02.06.2006                                                               | 01.06.2010                                                               |                                                                          |
| 9                                                                        | Consultancy Services for Dhule-Pimpalgaon Section                        | Maharashtra                                                              | 3                                                                        | 4,05,98,250 (LC) + US$ 6,57,970 (FC)                                     | 4,57,07,664 (LC) + US$ 4,54,988 (FC)                                     | 01.04.2006                                                               | 30.06.2014                                                               |                                                                          |
| 10                                                                       | 4-laning of MP/Maharashtra Border - Dhule Section                        | Maharashtra                                                              | 3                                                                        | 6,60,26,840 (LC) + US$ 6,89,349 (FC)                                     | 2,84,33,761 + 79,85,459                                                  | 21.04.2010                                                               | 30.09.2016                                                               |                                                                          |
| 11                                                                       | 4-laning of Talegaon-Amravati Section                                    | Maharashtra                                                              | 6                                                                        | 6,41,53,040 (LC) + US$ 8,41,439 (FC)                                     | 6,46,88,316 (LC) + US$9,58,341 (FC)                                      | 28.10.2010                                                               | 15.04.2015                                                               |                                                                          |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                                                                                                                                                                               | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                  |
| 12                                                                       | Four Laning of Maharashtra / Karnataka border - Sangareddy Section from Km 348.800 to Km 493.000 in the state of Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh on DBFOT Basis under NHDP III (Package No. : Kar/Phase-III/IC-3/2011-12)                                                 | Karnataka                                                                | 9                                                                        | 13,22,86,143                                                             | 9,58,81,027                                                              | 11.02.2013                                                               | 30.09.2016                                                               |                                                                          |
| 13                                                                       | Operation and Maintenance and fee collection of Elevated highway project from silk board junction to Attibele from Km.8.765 to Km.33.130 on Bangalore-Hosure Section of NH-7 constructed under BOT toll basis through a concessionaire (Package No. Kar/O&M/IC-2/2011) | Karnataka                                                                | 7                                                                        | 3,05,86,190 (including Taxes)                                            | 3,74,76,672 (including Taxes)                                            | 15.03.2012                                                               | 31.12.2015                                                               |                                                                          |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                                                                                                                                   | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                        |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                                                                                                                                               | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                                    |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                                                                                                                                                                                    | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                                                                     |
| 14                                                                       | Independent Engineer Services for 4 laning of Gwalior-Shivpuri section of NH-3 from km 15.600 of NH- 75 (End of Gwalior bypass) to km 236.00 of NH-3 in the state of Madhya Pradesh on BOT (Toll) on DBFOT Pattern under NHDP Phase-IV | Madhya Pradesh                                                           | 3                                                                        | 11,79,89,528                                                             | 7,83,48,248                                                              | 20.11.2013                                                               | 02.12.2016                                                               |                                                                                                                             |
| 15                                                                       | Consulatancy Services for 4/6 laning of Shillong - Jowai Section including Shillong Bypass & Jowai Bypass                                                                                                                              | Meghalaya                                                                | 40 & 44                                                                  | 1,70,80,900                                                              | 1,12,03,166                                                              | 28.03.2005                                                               | 06.02.2007                                                               |                                                                                                                             |
| 16                                                                       | Operation and Maintenance of Orai - Bhognipur Section (Km.220.000 to Km.255.100) and Bhognipur-Barah Section (Km.421.000 to Km.449.000) in the State of U.P.                                                                           | Uttar Pradesh                                                            | 2 & 25                                                                   | 3,57,84,997 (LC) + US$ 6,16,920 (FC)                                     | 5,42,13,573 (LC) + US$ 7,76,532 (FC)                                     | 12.09.2006                                                               | 26.04.2014                                                               | The Consultant, M/s. Wilbur Smith Associates Inc.- M/s. Wilbur Smith Associates Pvt. Ltd (JV) demobilized from the project. |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                   |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                            | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                               |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                                                                 | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                                                                |
| 17                                                                       | Operation and Maintenance of four laning of Karnataka/ Kerala Border to Kannur Section from Km.17.200 to Km.143.823 | Kerala                                                                   | 17                                                                       | 13,05,85,740                                                             | -                                                                        | -                                                                        | -                                                                        | NHAI issued letter dated 15.10.2014 to the Concessionaire intimating Termination/ Foreclosure of Concession Agreement. |
| 18                                                                       | IE services for 4-laning of Tirupati -Tiruthani - Chennai section in the States of Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu    | Tamil Nadu & Andhra Pradesh                                              | 205                                                                      | 14,94,65,040 (LC)                                                        | 17,58,49,740                                                             | 01.01.2012                                                               | 05.05.2016                                                               |                                                                                                                        |
| 18                                                                       | IE services for 4-laning of Tirupati -Tiruthani - Chennai section in the States of Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu    | Tamil Nadu & Andhra Pradesh                                              | 205                                                                      | US$ 1,77,103 (FC)                                                        | 44,44,812                                                                | 01.01.2012                                                               | 05.05.2016                                                               |                                                                                                                        |
| 19                                                                       | IE services for OMT Package of Chennai Bypass                                                                       | Tamil Nadu                                                               | Chennai Bypass                                                           | 2,78,82,000                                                              | 2,23,41,748                                                              | 08.09.2014                                                               | 11.01.2017                                                               |                                                                                                                        |
| 20                                                                       | IE services for O&M of Tambaram - Tindivanam section                                                                | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 45                                                                       | 1,12,73,892                                                              | 1,17,88,819                                                              | 05.04.2013                                                               | 30.09.2016                                                               |                                                                                                                        |
| 21                                                                       | IE Services for 2/4-laning of Trichy - Karur section                                                                | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 67                                                                       | 12,70,75,878 (LC) + US$15,31,000 (FC)                                    | 10,61,08,825 + 4,59,76,729                                               | 23.05.2008                                                               | 31.05.2017                                                               |                                                                                                                        |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                             | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                        |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates         | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                    |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                              | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                                                     |
| 22                                                                       | Preparation of fresh DPR for Trichy Bypass section                               | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 67                                                                       | 40,90,000                                                                | 11,69,026                                                                | 28.11.2011                                                               | Not yet completed                                                        | Draft DPR submitted. Extention of time upto 31.12.2017 sought for by consultant for submission of final DPR |
| 23                                                                       | IE services for OMT Package of Trichy - Madurai section                          | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 45B                                                                      | 3,05,97,000                                                              | 2,48,84,521                                                              | 11.06.2014                                                               | 10.06.2017                                                               |                                                                                                             |
| 24                                                                       | IE services for Six Laning of Hosur - Krishnagiri section                        | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 7                                                                        | 8,27,34,720                                                              | 7,66,44,151                                                              | 16.08.2012                                                               | 27.08.2016                                                               |                                                                                                             |
| 25                                                                       | O&M of Tindivanam - Ulundurpet section                                           | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 45                                                                       | 3,60,03,720                                                              | 76,71,432                                                                | 05.04.2013                                                               | 30.09.2016                                                               |                                                                                                             |
| 26                                                                       | IE services for O&M of Ulundurpet - Padalur - Trichy section                     | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 45                                                                       | 3,60,03,720                                                              | 1,54,46,283                                                              | 05.04.2013                                                               | 30.09.2016                                                               |                                                                                                             |
| 27                                                                       | Supervision Consultancy Services for Annual / Ordinary works on NH 45C, 66, 68 & | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 45C, 66, 68 and 205                                                      | 51,89,347                                                                | 48,93,203                                                                | 06.02.2008                                                               | Sept. 2008                                                               |                                                                                                             |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                             | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                                         | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                                                                              | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                  |
|                                                                          | 205                                                                                                                              |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |                                                                          |
| 28                                                                       | IE services for OMT Package of Madurai - Kanniyakumari section                                                                   | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 7                                                                        | 3,19,29,000                                                              | 2,15,22,879                                                              | 25.06.2014                                                               | 24.06.2017                                                               |                                                                          |
| 29                                                                       | IE services for O&M of Madurai - Aruppukottai - Tuticorin section, Dindigul - Samayanallur section and Karur to Dindigul Section | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 45B & 7                                                                  | 3,71,49,816                                                              | 2,82,07,463                                                              | 11.04.2013                                                               | 30.04.2016                                                               |                                                                          |
| 30                                                                       | Supervision Consultancy for Four laning of Panagudi - Kanniyakumari section                                                      | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 7                                                                        | 3,07,35,900                                                              | 3,05,68,562                                                              | 28.05.2008                                                               | 30.06.2012                                                               |                                                                          |
| 31                                                                       | SC Services for Permanent Restoration Works on Mettupalayam-Ooty-Tamil Nadu / Karnataka Border from Km.384 to Km.450             | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 67 Extn.                                                                 | 91,17,817                                                                | 6752496.00                                                               | 28.02.2008                                                               | 31.08.2009                                                               |                                                                          |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                                                                                                                       | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates                                                                                                   | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                                                                                                                        | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                  |
| 32                                                                       | SC Services for Permanent Restoration Works on Mettupalayam-Ooty-Tamil Nadu / Karnataka Border from Km.450 to Km.504                                                       | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 67 Extn.                                                                 | 88,16,047                                                                | 83,79,694                                                                | 25.01.2008                                                               | 31.08.2009                                                               |                                                                          |
| 33                                                                       | Preparation of Fresh DPR for 4/6 laning from Km.100 (Chengapalli) to Km.182 (Walayar)                                                                                      | Tamil Nadu                                                               | 47                                                                       | 97,16,600                                                                | 28,22,243                                                                | 10.09.2007                                                               | 09.12.2008                                                               |                                                                          |
| 34                                                                       | Supervision Consultancy of Civil Projects of 4-laning of 2 Packages No. C-II/BR-4 & BR- 6 - Simrahi to Ring Road (Missing Link) (BR-4) and Ring Bund to Jhanjharpur (BR-6) | Bihar                                                                    | 57                                                                       | 5,92,99,400 (LC) + US$ 1,83,000 (FC)                                     | 7,17,13,743 + 5,44,13,713                                                | 21.04.2006                                                               | 30.04.2013                                                               |                                                                          |
| 35                                                                       | Kosi Bridge including approaches and Guide Bund & Afflux Bund (BR-5)                                                                                                       | Bihar                                                                    | 57                                                                       | 5,04,63,000                                                              | 5,57,93,114                                                              | 01.05.2007                                                               | 31.01.2012                                                               |                                                                          |

| National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     | National Highways Authority of India                                     |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates | Consultancy Services awarded to M/s. CDM Smith & Wilbur Smith Associates |
| Sr. No.                                                                  | Name of the Project                                                      | State                                                                    | NH No.                                                                   | Consultancy Awarded Amount (Rs.)                                         | Actual Payments Made (Rs.)                                               | Start Date of Consultancy Services                                       | Completion Date of Consultancy Services                                  | Remarks                                                                  |
| 36                                                                       | 6-laning of Vadodara - Bharuch Section from Km.108.700 to Km.192.000     | Gujarat                                                                  | 8                                                                        | 4,54,00,000                                                              | 2,73,00,000                                                              | 17.03.2015                                                               | Not yet completed                                                        | Completion date 16.03.2018                                               |
| 37                                                                       | IE Services for Palanpur - Ratanpur - Samakhiyali on OMT Basis Package-I | Gujarat                                                                  | 14 & 15                                                                  | 3,73,01,268                                                              | 2,99,02,631                                                              | 16.05.2014                                                               | 15.05.2017                                                               |                                                                          |

*****