Lok Sabha Question No. 199 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2016-11-16
Subject: Smart Cities
Ministry: URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Asked by: BIDYUT BARAN MAHATO, SUDHEER GUPTA, YOGI ADITYANATH, SUNIL BALIRAM GAIKWAD, JAYAKUMAR JAYAVARDHAN, PARASURAMAN K., T. RADHAKRISHNAN, GAJANAN CHANDRAKANT KIRTIKAR, KUNWAR PUSHPENDRA SINGH CHANDEL, SHRIKANT EKNATH SHINDE, RAVINDRA VISHWANATH GAIKWAD, DHANANJAY BHIMRAO MAHADIK, VINAYAK BHAURAO RAUT, Shrirang Appa Barne, VIJAYSINH MOHITE PATIL, RAJEEV SHANKARRAO SATAV, SAUGATA ROY, MALLIKARJUN  KHARGE, ANIRUDHAN SAMPATH, SUPRIYA SADANAND SULE, C. N. JAYADEVAN, VIJAY KUMAR S.R., PRALHAD VENKATESH JOSHI, ANANDRAO  ADSUL, BHARATENDRA SINGH, ASHOK SHANKARRAO CHAVAN, George Baker, RAMESH POKHRIYAL NISHANK, KUNWAR HARIBANSH SINGH

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT LOK SABHA

UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 199

## TO BE ANSWERED ON NOVEMBER 16, 2016 SMART CITIES

No. 199

SHRI BIDYUT BARAN MAHATO:

SHRI YOGI ADITYA NATH:

SHRI K. PARASURAMAN:

SHRI SUDHEER GUPTA:

SHRI DHANANJAY MAHADIK:

SHRI GAJANAN KUMAR:

SHRI SUNIL BALIRAM GAIKWAD:

SHRIMATI SUPRIYA SULE:

KUNWAR BHARATENDRA:

SHRI ANANDRAO ADSUL:

SHRI SHRIRANG APPA BARNE:

SHRI MALLIKARJUN KHARGE:

SHRI VINAYAK BHAURAO RAUT:

SHRI MOHITE PATIL VIJAYSINH SHANKARRAO:

SHRI SATAV RAJEEV:

SHRI S. R. VIJAYAKUMAR:

SHRI ASHOK SHANKARRAO CHAVAN:

SHRI T. RADHAKRISHNAN:

KUNWAR HARIBANSH SINGH:

SHRI SAUGATA ROY:

SHRI GEORGE BAKER:

SHRI SHRIKANT EKNATH SHINDE:

PROF. RAVINDRA VISHWANATH GAIKWAD:

DR. A. SAMPATH:

SHRI PRALHAD :

SHRI C.N. JAYADEVAN:

DR. J. JAYAVARDHAN:

Will the Minister of URBAN DEVELOPMENT be pleased to state:

- (a) the details of the norms formulated for certifying a city as
- smart  city  and  the  details  of  proposals  received  by  the Government from various States for selection of cities to be developed as Smart Cites, State-wise;
- (b) the  details  of  cities  selected  so  far,  State-wise  and  the criteria  for  selection  along  with  the  time  by  which  other cities are likely to be selected;
- (c) the  details  of  funds  sanctioned,  released  and  utilized  for
- smart city Projects so far, city-wise and the funding pattern thereof;
- (d) the  details  of  projects  taken  up/likely  to  be  taken  up  in selected cities, city-wise;
- (e) the names of foreign countries which have shown interest in  smart  city  projects  along  with  the  names  of  cities  to which  foreign  assistance,  is  provided  and  the  challenges being faced in the implementation of the projects and the steps  taken/being  taken  to  develop  the  smart  cities  in  a time bound manner along with the time period for development of selected Smart Cities?

## ANSWER

## THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT (RAO INDERJIT SINGH)

- (a) :The objective of Smart Cities Mission is to promote cities that provide core infrastructure and give a decent quality of  life  to  its  citizens  by  application  of  'Smart'  Solutions. The  core  infrastructure  elements  in  a  Smart  City  would include: adequate water supply, assured electricity supply, sanitation (including solid waste management), affordable housing,  especially  for  the  poor,  etc.    The  focus  is  on sustainable and inclusive development and the idea is to look  at  compact  areas,  create  a  replicable  model  which will  act  like  a  light  house  to  other  aspiring  cities.  It  is meant to set examples that can be replicated both within and outside the Smart City.

In Stage 1, all States/UTs shortlisted potential Smart Cities as per the allocation and criteria given in the Smart Cities Mission Statement and Guidelines. On the basis of that, 98 potential Smart Cities were announced in August, 2015 to participate  in  Stage  II.  Further,  on  the  basis  of  requests received from States, 11 new potential Smart Cities have also been included in May, 2016 to participate in All India Competition (Stage 2) of the Smart City Challenge Process.

In Round 1, 97 potential Smart Cities, in fast track round, 23  potential  Smart  Cities  and  in  Round  2,  63  potential Smart Cities participated through their respective State/UT Governments.  The  details  are  enclosed  at  Annexure-I,  II and III.

- (b):  So far 60 Smart Cities have been selected in Round 1, Fast-
- track Round and main Round 2 of Smart Cities Mission on the  basis  of  evaluation  done  by  a  panel  of  national  and international experts on the basis of two criteria i.e. (i) City Level Criteria, and (ii) Proposal Level Criteria. The list of 60 cities selected so far are enclosed at Annexure-IV, V & VI. The remaining cities will participate in Round 3 with their upgraded Smart City Proposals. Round 3 will start from 1 st January 2017 and will end on 31 st  March 2017.
- (c):  The  Mission  is  being    operated  as  a  Centrally  Sponsored Scheme (CSS) and the Central Government proposes to give financial support to the Mission  to the extent of Rs. 48,000 crore  over  five  years  i.e.  on  an  average  Rs.  100  crore  per city  per  year.  An  equal  amount,  on  a  matching  basis,  will have  to  be  contributed  by  the  State  /  Urban  Local  Body (ULB).  In  the  first  year,  Government  of  India  will  provide grant of Rs. 194 crore followed by Rs. 98 crore every year for the next three years. So far, total Rs. 4572.20 crore have been  released  to  these  Cities  for  development  as  Smart Cities  under  Smart  Cities  Mission  during  Financial  Year 2015-16 and 2016-17. The city wise details are enclosed at Annexure-VII.
- (d): The details of projects for the selected 60 smart cities are
- given in their Smart City Proposals (SCPs). These SCPs have

been uploaded on the Mission's website (www.smartcities.gov.in).

- (e):  In  terms  of  mutual  understanding  between  the  Ministry, States/UTs and Foreign Agencies, this Ministry is facilitating execution of Memoranda of Understanding (MoUs)/Agreements between Foreign Agencies and States/UTs for assistance under Smart Cities Mission.Presently,  following  MoUs/Agreements  have  been executed between foreign agencies and States/UTs :-

|   S.N. | Name of Foreign Agency                | State/UT                               | City                          | Date of MoU/ Agreement   |
|--------|---------------------------------------|----------------------------------------|-------------------------------|--------------------------|
|      1 | US Trade & Development Agency (USTDA) | Andhra Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Rajasthan | Visakhapatnam Allahabad Ajmer | 25.01.2015               |
|      2 | French Agency for Development (AFD)   | Maharashtra Chandigarh Puducherry      | Nagpur Chandigarh Oulgaret    | 24.01.2016               |

Moreover, various countries namely, Spain, Canada, Germany,  China,  Singapore,  UK,  South  Korea  and  Japan have also shown interest to participate in the development of Smart Cities.

The objective of the Smart City Mission is to promote cities that provide core infrastructure and give a decent quality of life to its citizens, a clean and sustainable environment and application of 'Smart' Solutions. The focus is on sustainable and  inclusive  development  and  the  idea  is  to  look  at compact  areas,  create  a  replicable  model  which  will  act like a light house to other aspiring cities.

The  focus  is  also  on  creating  the  institutional  framework, and building capacity of municipal functionaries for implementation. Government  is making  all efforts to develop the Smart Cities in a time-bound manner within the Mission period.

***

Annexure-I List of 97 Cities which participated in Round 1 of Smart Cities Mission

|   Sl. No. | Name of State/UT          | Names of Potential shortlisted                                     | Cities   |
|-----------|---------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------|----------|
|         1 | Andaman & Nicobar Islands | Port Blair                                                         |          |
|         2 | Andhra Pradesh            | Vishakhapatnam Tirupati Kakinada                                   |          |
|         3 | Arunachal Pradesh         | Pasighat                                                           |          |
|         4 | Assam                     | Guwahati                                                           |          |
|         5 | Bihar                     | Muzaffarpur Bhagalpur Biharsharif                                  |          |
|         6 | Chandigarh                | Chandigarh                                                         |          |
|         7 | Chhatisgarh               | Raipur Bilaspur                                                    |          |
|         8 | Daman & Diu               | Diu                                                                |          |
|         9 | Dadra & Nagar Haveli      | Silvassa                                                           |          |
|        10 | Delhi                     | New Delhi Municipal Council                                        |          |
|        11 | Goa                       | Panaji                                                             |          |
|        12 | Gujarat                   | Gandhinagar Ahmedabad Surat Vadodara Rajkot Dahod                  |          |
|        13 | Haryana                   | Karnal Faridabad                                                   |          |
|        14 | Himachal Pradesh          | Dharamshala                                                        |          |
|        15 | Jharkhand                 | Ranchi                                                             |          |
|        16 | Karnataka                 | Mangaluru Belagavi Shivamogga Hubballi-Dharwad Tumakuru Davanegere |          |
|        17 | Kerala                    | Kochi                                                              |          |
|        18 | Lakshadweep               | Kavaratti                                                          |          |
|        19 | Madhya Pradesh            | Bhopal Indore Jabalpur Gwalior Sagar Satna Ujjain                  |          |
|        20 | Maharashtra               | Navi Mumbai Nashik Thane Greater Mumbai Amravati                   |          |

|    |               | Solapur Nagpur Kalyan-Dombivali Aurangabad Pune                                                                   |
|----|---------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 21 | Manipur       | Imphal                                                                                                            |
| 22 | Meghalaya     | Shillong                                                                                                          |
| 23 | Mizoram       | Aizawl                                                                                                            |
| 24 | Nagaland      | Kohima                                                                                                            |
| 25 | Odisha        | Bhubaneshwar Raurkela                                                                                             |
| 26 | Puducherry    | Oulgaret                                                                                                          |
| 27 | Punjab        | Ludhiana Jalandhar Amritsar                                                                                       |
| 28 | Rajasthan     | Jaipur Udaipur Kota Ajmer                                                                                         |
| 29 | Sikkim        | Namchi                                                                                                            |
| 30 | Tamil Nadu    | Tiruchirapalli Tirunelveli Dindigul Thanjavur Tiruppur Salem Vellore Coimbatore Madurai Erode Thoothukudi Chennai |
| 31 | Telangana     | Greater Warangal                                                                                                  |
| 32 | Tripura       | Agartala                                                                                                          |
| 33 | Uttar Pradesh | Moradabad Aligarh Saharanpur Bareilly Jhansi Kanpur Allahabad Lucknow Varanasi Ghaziabad Agra Rampur              |
| 34 | Uttarakhand   | Dehradun                                                                                                          |
| 35 | West Bengal   | New Town Kolkata Bidhannagar Durgapur Haldia                                                                      |

## Annexure-II

## List of 23 Cities which participated in fast track round of Smart Cities Mission

|   S.N. | Name of State/UT    | Name of City    |
|--------|---------------------|-----------------|
|      1 | Uttar Pradesh       | Lucknow         |
|      2 | Telangana           | Warangal        |
|      3 | Himachal Pradesh    | Dharamshala     |
|      4 | Chandigarh          | Chandigarh      |
|      5 | Chhattisgarh        | Raipur          |
|      6 | West Bengal         | Newtown Kolkata |
|      7 | Bihar               | Bhagalpur       |
|      8 | Goa                 | Panaji          |
|      9 | A & N Islands       | Port Blair      |
|     10 | Manipur             | Imphal          |
|     11 | Jharkhand           | Ranchi          |
|     12 | Tripura             | Agartala        |
|     13 | Haryana             | Faridabad       |
|     14 | Sikkim              | Namchi          |
|     15 | Mizoram             | Aizawl          |
|     16 | Arunachal Pradesh   | Pasighat        |
|     17 | Uttarakhand         | Dehradun        |
|     18 | Nagaland            | Kohima          |
|     19 | Puducherry          | Oulgaret        |
|     20 | Dadar& Nagar Haveli | Silvassa        |
|     21 | Lakshadweep         | Kavaratti       |
|     22 | Daman & Diu         | Diu             |
|     23 | Meghalaya           | Shillong        |

## Annexure-III

## List of 63 Cities which participated in main Round 2 of Smart Cities Mission

|   Sl. No. | Name of State/UT     | Names of Potential Cities shortlisted                                                          |
|-----------|----------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|         1 | Andhra Pradesh       | Tirupati Amaravati                                                                             |
|         2 | Arunachal Pradesh    | Pasighat                                                                                       |
|         3 | Bihar                | Muzaffarpur Biharsharif                                                                        |
|         4 | Chhatisgarh          | Bilaspur                                                                                       |
|         5 | Daman & Diu          | Diu                                                                                            |
|         6 | Dadra & Nagar Haveli | Silvassa                                                                                       |
|         7 | Gujarat              | Gandhinagar Vadodara Rajkot Dahod                                                              |
|         8 | Haryana              | Karnal                                                                                         |
|         9 | Karnataka            | Mangaluru Shivamogga Hubballi-Dharwad Tumakuru Bengaluru                                       |
|        10 | Lakshadweep          | Kavaratti                                                                                      |
|        11 | Madhya Pradesh       | Gwalior Sagar Satna Ujjain                                                                     |
|        12 | Maharashtra          | Navi Mumbai Nashik Thane Greater Mumbai Amravati Nagpur Kalyan-Dombivali                       |
|        13 | Meghalaya            | Aurangabad Shillong                                                                            |
|        14 | Mizoram              | Aizawl                                                                                         |
|        15 | Nagaland             | Kohima                                                                                         |
|        16 | Odisha               | Raurkela                                                                                       |
|        17 | Punjab               | Jalandhar Amritsar                                                                             |
|        18 | Rajasthan            | Kota Ajmer                                                                                     |
|        19 | Sikkim               | Namchi                                                                                         |
|        20 | Tamil Nadu           | Tiruchirapalli Tirunelveli Dindigul Thanjavur Tiruppur Salem Vellore Madurai Erode Thoothukudi |

|   21. | Uttar Pradesh   | Moradabad Aligarh Saharanpur Bareilly Jhansi Kanpur Allahabad Varanasi Ghaziabad Agra Rampur Meerut   |
|-------|-----------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
|    22 | Uttarakhand     | Dehradun                                                                                              |

## Winning Cities in Round 1

|   Rank No. | Name of State/UT   | Name of City   |
|------------|--------------------|----------------|
|          1 | Odisha             | Bhubaneswar    |
|          2 | Maharashtra        | Pune           |
|          3 | Rajasthan          | Jaipur         |
|          4 | Gujarat            | Surat          |
|          5 | Kerala             | Kochi          |
|          6 | Gujarat            | Ahmadabad      |
|          7 | Madhya Pradesh     | Jabalpur       |
|          8 | Andhra Pradesh     | Visakhapatnam  |
|          9 | Maharashtra        | Solapur        |
|         10 | Karnataka          | Davanagere     |
|         11 | Madhya Pradesh     | Indore         |
|         12 | Delhi              | NDMC           |
|         13 | Tamil Nadu         | Coimbatore     |
|         14 | Andhra Pradesh     | Kakinada       |
|         15 | Karnataka          | Belagavi       |
|         16 | Rajasthan          | Udaipur        |
|         17 | Assam              | Guwahati       |
|         18 | Tamil Nadu         | Chennai        |
|         19 | Punjab             | Ludhiana       |
|         20 | Madhya Pradesh     | Bhopal         |

## Annexure-IV

Winning Cities in fast track round

<!-- image -->

|   S.N. | Name of State/UT   | Name of City    |
|--------|--------------------|-----------------|
|      1 | Uttar Pradesh      | Lucknow         |
|      2 | Telangana          | Warangal        |
|      3 | Himachal Pradesh   | Dharamshala     |
|      4 | Chandigarh         | Chandigarh      |
|      5 | Chhattisgarh       | Raipur          |
|      6 | West Bengal        | Newtown Kolkata |
|      7 | Bihar              | Bhagalpur       |
|      8 | Goa                | Panaji          |
|      9 | A & N Islands      | Port Blair      |
|     10 | Manipur            | Imphal          |
|     11 | Jharkhand          | Ranchi          |
|     12 | Tripura            | Agartala        |
|     13 | Haryana            | Faridabad       |

## Annexure-V

Annexure-VI

Winning cities in main Round 2

|   S.no | Name of State/UT   | Name of City     |
|--------|--------------------|------------------|
|      1 | Punjab             | Amritsar         |
|      2 | Maharashtra        | Kalyan-Dombivali |
|      3 | Madhya Pradesh     | Ujjain           |
|      4 | Andhra Pradesh     | Tirupati         |
|      5 | Maharashtra        | Nagpur           |
|      6 | Karnataka          | Mangaluru        |
|      7 | Tamil Nadu         | Vellore          |
|      8 | Maharashtra        | Thane            |
|      9 | Madhya Pradesh     | Gwalior          |
|     10 | Uttar Pradesh      | Agra             |
|     11 | Maharashtra        | Nashik           |
|     12 | Odisha             | Rourkela         |
|     13 | Uttar Pradesh      | Kanpur           |
|     14 | Tamil Nadu         | Madurai          |
|     15 | Karnataka          | Tumakuru         |
|     16 | Rajasthan          | Kota             |
|     17 | Tamil Nadu         | Thanjavur        |
|     18 | Sikkim             | Namchi           |
|     19 | Punjab             | Jalandhar        |
|     20 | Karnataka          | Shivamogga       |
|     21 | Tamil Nadu         | Salem            |
|     22 | Rajasthan          | Ajmer            |
|     23 | Uttar Pradesh      | Varanasi         |
|     24 | Nagaland           | Kohima           |
|     25 | Karnataka          | Hubballi-Dharwad |
|     26 | Maharashtra        | Aurangabad       |
|     27 | Gujarat            | Vadodara         |

## Annexure-VII

## Release of funds under Smart City Mission city-wise for the year 2015-16 and 2016-17

Amount Rs. in crores

|   S.N. | State                    | Name of cities                                                                                           | Released            |
|--------|--------------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------|
|      1 | Andaman &Nikobar Islands | 1. Port Blair                                                                                            | 196                 |
|      2 | Andhra Pradesh           | 1. Vishakhapatnam 2. Tirupati 3. Kakinada                                                                | 196 2 196           |
|      3 | Arunachal Pradesh        | 1. Pasighat                                                                                              | 2                   |
|      4 | Assam                    | 1. Guwahati                                                                                              | 191                 |
|      5 | Bihar                    | 1. Muzaffarpur 2. Bhagalpur 3. Biharsharif                                                               | 2 2 2               |
|      6 | Chandigarh               | 1. Chandigarh                                                                                            | 73                  |
|      7 | Chattisgarh              | 1. Raipur 2. Bilaspur                                                                                    | 2 2                 |
|      8 | Daman & Diu              | 1. Diu                                                                                                   | 2                   |
|      9 | Dadra & Nagar Haveli     | 1. Silvassa                                                                                              | 2                   |
|     10 | Delhi                    | 1. New Delhi Municipal Council                                                                           | 196                 |
|     11 | Goa                      | 1. Panaji                                                                                                | 2                   |
|     12 | Gujarat                  | 1. Gandhinagar 2. Ahmedabad 3. Surat 4. Vadodara 5. Rajkot 6. Dahod                                      | 2 196 196 2 2 2     |
|     13 | Haryana                  | 1. Karnal 2. Faridabad                                                                                   | 2 2                 |
|     14 | Himachal Pradesh         | 1. Dharamshala                                                                                           | 188                 |
|     15 | Jharkhand                | 1. Ranchi                                                                                                | 2                   |
|     16 | Karnataka                | 1. Mangaluru 2. Belagavi 3. Shivamogga 4. Hubballi-Dharwad 5. Tumakuru 6. Davanegere                     | 2 196 2 2 2 196     |
|     17 | Kerala                   | 1. Kochi                                                                                                 | 196                 |
|     18 | Lakshadweep              | 1. Kavaratti                                                                                             | 2                   |
|     19 | Madhya Pradesh           | 1. Bhopal 2. Indore 3. Jabalpur 4. Gwalior 5. Sagar 6. Satna 7. Ujjain                                   | 196 196 196 2 2 2 2 |
|     20 | Maharashtra              | 1. Navi Mumbai 2. Nashik 3. Thane 4. Greater Mumbai 5. Amravati 6. Solapur 7. Nagpur 8. Kalyan-Dombivali | 2 2 2 2 2 196 2 2   |

|    |               | 9. Aurangabad 10.Pune                                                                                                                                            | 2 196                       |
|----|---------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------|
| 21 | Manipur       | 1. Imphal                                                                                                                                                        | 2                           |
| 22 | Meghalaya     | 1. Shillong                                                                                                                                                      | 2                           |
| 23 | Mizoram       | 1. Aizawl                                                                                                                                                        | 2                           |
| 24 | Nagaland      | 1. Kohima                                                                                                                                                        | 2                           |
| 25 | Odisha        | 1. Bhubaneshwar 2. Raurkela                                                                                                                                      | 196 2                       |
| 26 | Puducherry    | 1. Oulgaret                                                                                                                                                      | 2                           |
| 27 | Punjab        | 1. Ludhiana 2. Jalandhar 3. Amritsar                                                                                                                             | 196 2 2                     |
| 28 | Rajasthan     | 1. Jaipur 2. Udaipur 3. Kota 4. Ajmer                                                                                                                            | 196 196 2 2                 |
| 29 | Sikkim        | 1. Namchi                                                                                                                                                        | 2                           |
| 30 | Tamil Nadu    | 1. Tiruchirapalli 2. Tirunelveli 3. Dindigul, 4. Thanjavur, 5. Tiruppur, 6. Salem, 7. Vellore, 8. Coimbatore, 9. Madurai, 10. Erode, 11. Thoothukudi 12. Chennai | 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 188 2 2 2 188 |
| 31 | Telangana     | 1. Greater Hyderabad 2. Greater Warangal                                                                                                                         | 2 2                         |
| 32 | Tripura       | 1. Agartala                                                                                                                                                      | 2                           |
| 33 | Uttar Pradesh | 1. Moradabad 2. Aligarh 3. Saharanpur 4. Bareilly 5. Jhansi 6. Kanpur 7. Allahabad 8. Lucknow 9. Varanasi 10. Ghaziabad 11. Agra 12. Rampur                      | 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 68.20 2 2 2 2 |
| 34 | Uttarakhand   | 1. Dehradun                                                                                                                                                      | 2                           |
| 35 | West Bengal   | 1. New Town Kolkata 2. Bidhannagar 3. Durgapur 4. Haldia                                                                                                         | 2 2 2 2                     |
|    | Total         |                                                                                                                                                                  | 4572.2                      |