Lok Sabha Question No. 2501 (UNSTARRED), answered on 2018-01-02
Subject: Evaluation of CPSUs
Ministry: HEAVY INDUSTRIES AND PUBLIC ENTERPRISES
Asked by: VISHNU DAYAL RAM, JANAK RAM

## GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HEAVY INDUSTRIES & PUBLIC ENTERPRISES DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC ENTERPRISES

## LOK SABHA

## UNSTARRED QUESTION No. 2501

## TO BE ANSWERED ON 02.01.2018

## Evaluation of CPSUs

## 2501.   SHRI VISHNU DAYAL RAM:

## SHRI JANAK RAM:

Will  the  Minister  of  HEAVY  INDUSTRIES  AND  PUBLIC  ENTERPRISES  be pleased to state:

- (a)  whether  the  performance/functioning  of  Central  Public  Sector  Undertakings (CPSUs) is evaluated regularly;
- (b)  if so, the details of the categorisation of the performance of CPSUs during each of the last three years; and
- (c)  the details of the CPSUs being currently rejuvenated along with the assistance being provided to the loss making CPSUs by the Government?

## A N S W E R

## THE MINISTER OF STATE OF HEAVY INDUSTRIES AND PUBLIC ENTERPRISES (SHRI BABUL SUPRIYO)

- (a)  Evaluation of the performance of Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) is done  after  the  end  of  the  financial  year  against  the  targets  fixed  in  respect  of MoU signing CPSEs.
- (b)  The details of the categorization of performance of MoU signing CPSEs during each of the last three year is enclosed as Annex.
- (c)  Central  Public  Sector  Enterprises  (CPSEs)  function  under  the  administrative control  of  various  Ministries/Departments  and  all  matters  relating  to  revival/ restructuring of sick/loss making CPSEs are dealt by the concerned administrative Ministries/ Departments on a case to case basis.  Department of Public  Enterprises  (DPE),  as  a  nodal  department,  has  issued  guidelines  on 29.10.2015 for 'Streamlining the mechanism for revival and restructuring of sick/ incipient sick and weak Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs)'. As per the guidelines, the responsibility for addressing the sickness of Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) lies with the concerned administrative Ministries/Departments.   The  concerned  administrative  Ministries/  Departments formulate revival/ restructuring/ closure plans for CPSEs functioning under them on a case-to-case basis and after obtaining the approval of competent authority implement the plan.

## CATEGORISATION FOR LAST THREE YEARS

## (LOK SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 2501)

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                                | 2014-15   | 2015-16                              | 2016-17                              |
|-----------|-------------------------------------------------------------|-----------|--------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|
|         1 | Air India Air Transport Services Ltd.                       | -         | Very Good                            | NS/NE                                |
|         2 | Air India Charters Ltd.                                     | Very Good | Very Good                            | Fair                                 |
|         3 | Air India Engineering Services Ltd.                         | -         | Poor                                 | NS/NE                                |
|         4 | Air India Ltd.                                              | Good      | Very Good                            | NS/NE                                |
|         5 | Airline Alied Services Ltd.                                 | -         | Fair                                 | Poor                                 |
|         6 | Airports Authority of India                                 | Very Good | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|         7 | Andrew Yule & Co Ltd                                        | Very Good | Good                                 | Very Good                            |
|         8 | Antrix Corporation Ltd                                      | Very Good | Very Good                            | Good                                 |
|         9 | Artificial Limbs Manufacturing Corpn of India Limited       | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        10 | Assam Ashok Hotel Corporation Ltd.                          | Poor      | -                                    | NS/NE                                |
|        11 | Balmer Lawrie & Co. Ltd.                                    | Very Good | Very Good                            | Excellent                            |
|        12 | BEL Optronic Devices Ltd.                                   | Good      | Very Good                            | Very Good                            |
|        13 | BEL Thales System Ltd.                                      | -         | -                                    | Excellent                            |
|        14 | Bengal Chemical & Pharma Ltd.                               | Good      | Excellent                            | Very Good                            |
|        15 | Bharat BhariUdyog Nigam Ltd.                                | Good      | Merged with BBJ Construction Co.Ltd. | Merged with BBJ Construction Co.Ltd. |
|        16 | Bharat Broadband Nigam Ltd.                                 | Good      | Good                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        17 | Bharat Coking Coal Limited                                  | Very Good | Very Good                            | #                                    |
|        18 | Bharat Dynamics Ltd.                                        | Excellent | Excellent                            | Very Good                            |
|        19 | Bharat Earth Movers Limited(BEML)                           | Good      | Good                                 | Very Good                            |
|        20 | Bharat Electronics Limited                                  | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        21 | Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd.                               | Good      | Good                                 | Excellent                            |
|        22 | Bharat Immunological & Biological Ltd                       | Fair      | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        23 | Bharat Petro Resources Ltd.                                 | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        24 | Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.                           | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        25 | Bharat Pumps & Compressors Ltd.                             | -         | Fair                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        26 | Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd                                    | Fair      | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        27 | Bharat Wagon & Engineering Co. Ltd.                         | Poor      | Fair                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        28 | Bharitya Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam Ltd                         | Very Good | Good                                 | Fair                                 |
|        29 | Bhartiya Rail Bijlee Company Ltd.                           | Good      | Good                                 | Fair                                 |
|        30 | BHEL -EML                                                   | Fair      | Fair                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        31 | Biotechnology Industry Research Assis. Council              | Excellent | Excellent                            | Excellent                            |
|        32 | Brahmaputra Valley Fertilizers Corp Ltd,                    | Poor      | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        33 | Brahmputra Crackers and Polymers Ltd.                       | Very Good | Good                                 | Good                                 |
|        34 | Braithwaite & Co Ltd.                                       | Fair      | Good                                 | Poor                                 |
|        35 | Braithwaite Burn and Jessop Construction Company (BBJ) Ltd. | Good      | Good                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        36 | Bridge & Roof Co. (I) Ltd.                                  | Good      | Very Good                            | Very Good                            |
|        37 | Broadcast Engineering Consultants India Limited(BECIL)      | -         | Fair                                 | Good                                 |
|        38 | Burn Standard Co.                                           | Fair      | Poor                                 | NS/NE                                |
|        39 | Cement Corporation of India                                 | Very Good | Good                                 | Poor                                 |

## Annex.

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                            | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|---------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|        40 | Central Coalfields Ltd                                  | Excellent | Excellent | #         |
|        41 | Central Cottage Industries Corp. of India Ltd           | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        42 | Central Electronics Limited                             | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        43 | Central Mine Planning & Design Institute                | Excellent | Excellent | #         |
|        44 | Central Railside Warehousing Compny Ltd.                | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|        45 | Central Warehousing Corporation Ltd                     | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|        46 | Certification Engineers |India Ltd.                | Excellent | Excellent | Very good |
|        47 | Chandigarh International Airport Ltd.                   | -         | -         | Excellent |
|        48 | Chennai Petroleum Corporation Ltd.                      | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|        49 | Coal India Limited                                      | Excellent | Very Good | Fair      |
|        50 | Cochin Shipyard Limited                                 | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|        51 | Concor Air Ltd.                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Good      |
|        52 | Container Corporation of India Ltd (CONCOR)             | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|        53 | Cotton Corporation of India Ltd.                        | Very Good | Very Good | Fair      |
|        54 | CREDA-HPCL Biofuels Ltd.                                | Good      | -         | Excellent |
|        55 | Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation of India         | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|        56 | Donyi Polo Ashok Hotel Ltd.                             | Fair      | Poor      | Poor      |
|        57 | Dredging Corporation of India Ltd.                      | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        58 | Eastern Coal field Ltd.                                 | Excellent | Very Good | #         |
|        59 | Educational Consultants India Ltd.(EdCIL)               | Good      | Excellent | Good      |
|        60 | Electronics Corp. Of India Ltd.                         | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|        61 | Engineering Projects (India) Ltd.                       | Very Good | Very Good | Good      |
|        62 | Engineers India Ltd,                                    | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        63 | Kamarajar Port Ltd. (Earlier known as Ennore Port Ltd.) | Excellent | Excellent | Good      |
|        64 | Export Credit Guarantee Corp. Ltd                       | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        65 | FCIAravali Gypsum & Minerals (I) Ltd                    | Excellent | Good      | Fair      |
|        66 | Fertilizers and Chemicals (T) Ltd.                      | Poor      | Fair      | Poor      |
|        67 | Food Corporation of India                               | Very Good | Very Good | NS/NE     |
|        68 | Fresh & Healthy Enterprises Ltd.                        | Good      | Good      | Exempted  |
|        69 | FSNL                                                    | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|        70 | GAIL (I) Limited                                        | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|        71 | Gail Gas Ltd.                                           | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|        72 | Garden Reach Shipbuilders &Eng. Ltd.                    | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        73 | Goa Antibiotics & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.                  | -         | -         | Good      |
|        74 | Goa Shipyard Ltd.                                       | Very Good | Excellent | Excellent |
|        75 | Handicrafts & Handlooms Export Corpn.                   | Very Good | Good      | NS/NE     |
|        76 | Heavy Engineering Corporation Ltd.                      | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|        77 | High Speed Rail Corp. of India Ltd.                     | Excellent | Good      | Exempted  |
|        78 | Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd.                              | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|        79 | Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd.                              | Fair      | Poor      | Good      |
|        80 | Hindustan Cables Ltd                                    | Poor      | -         | NS/NE     |
|        81 | Hindustan Copper Ltd.                                   | Good      | Very Good | Good      |
|        82 | Hindustan Fluorocarbons Ltd.                            | Fair      | Good      | Good      |
|        83 | Hindustan Insecticides Ltd.                             | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|        84 | Hindustan Newsprint Limited                             | Fair      | Poor      | NS/NE     |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                        | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|-----------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|        85 | Hindustan Organic Chemicals Ltd.                    | Poor      | Fair      | Fair      |
|        86 | Hindustan Paper Corporation Ltd                     | -         | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|        87 | Hindustan Petroleum Corp. Ltd.                      | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|        88 | Hindustan Prefab Ltd.                               | Excellent | Very Good | NS/NE     |
|        89 | Hindustan Salts Ltd.                                | Fair      | Fair      | Fair      |
|        90 | Hindustan Shipyard Limited                          | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|        91 | Hindustan Steelworks Construction Ltd.              | Excellent | Very Good | Fair      |
|        92 | HLL Biotech Ltd.                                    | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|        93 | HLL Infra Tech Services Ltd.                        | -         | -         | Excellent |
|        94 | HLL Lifecare Ltd.                                   | Excellent | Very Good | Fair      |
|        95 | HMT Bearing Ltd.                                    | Good      | -         | NS/NE     |
|        96 | HMT International Ltd.                              | Good      | Good      | Poor      |
|        97 | HMT Ltd.                                            | Fair      | Fair      | Good      |
|        98 | HMT Machine Tools Ltd.                              | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|        99 | Hoogly Printing Co. Ltd.                            | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|       100 | Hotel Corp. of India Ltd                            | -         | Good      | Poor      |
|       101 | Housing & Urban Development Corporation Ltd (HUDCO) | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       102 | HPCL Biofuel Ltd.                                   | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|       103 | HSCC (India) Ltd                                    | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|       104 | India Trade Promotion Organization (ITPO)           | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|       105 | Indian Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.                 | -         | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       106 | Indian Medicines Pharmaceuticals Corporation Ltd,   | -         | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       107 | Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.                         | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       108 | Indian Railway Catering & Tourism Corpn Ltd         | Excellent | Excellent | Good      |
|       109 | Indian Railway Finance Corporation Ltd,             | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       110 | Indian Railway Station Dev. Corp. Ltd.              | Fair      | Good      | Fair      |
|       111 | Indian Rare Earth Ltd.                              | Good      | Good      | Very Good |
|       112 | Indian Renewable Energy Dev. Agency (IREDA)         | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|       113 | Indian Tourism Development Corp. (ITDC)             | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|       114 | Instrumentation Ltd.                                | Fair      | Fair      | Good      |
|       115 | Ircon Infrastructure & Services Ltd.                | Very Good | Excellent | Good      |
|       116 | IRCON International Ltd.                            | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       117 | IRCON Pb Tollways Limited                           | -         | -         | Very Good |
|       118 | IRCON Shivpuri Guna Tollway Ltd.                    | -         | -         | Excellent |
|       119 | ITI Ltd.                                            | Very Good | Good      | Good      |
|       120 | Jute Corporation of India Ltd.                      | Very Good | Very Good | Fair      |
|       121 | Kanti Bijlee Utpadan Nigam Ltd.                     | Excellent | Good      | Good      |
|       122 | Karnataka Antibiotics & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.        | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       123 | Karnatka Trade Promotion Organisation               | Excellent | Very Good | Poor      |
|       124 | KIOCL Ltd.                                          | Fair      | Fair      | Good      |
|       125 | Konkan Railway Corporation Ltd.                     | Very Good | Excellent | Good      |
|       126 | Kumararupa Frountier Hotel Ltd                      | -         | -         | Very Good |
|       127 | Madhya Pradesh Ashok Hotel Ltd.                     | Fair      | -         | NS/NE     |
|       128 | Madras Fertilizers Ltd.                             | Fair      | Fair      | Fair      |
|       129 | Mahanadi Coalfield Ltd.                             | Excellent | Very Good | #         |
|       130 | Mahanagar Telephone Mauritius Ltd.(MTML)            | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                                      | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17          |
|-----------|-------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|------------------|
|       131 | Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. (MTNL)                             | Good      | Good      | Fair             |
|       132 | Mangalore Refinery & Petrochemicals Ltd.                          | Very Good | Excellent | Excellent        |
|       133 | Manganese Ore (I) Ltd. (MOIL)                                     | Excellent | Good      | Very Good        |
|       134 | Mazagoan Dock Ltd.                                                | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good        |
|       135 | MECON Ltd.                                                        | Good      | Good      | Good             |
|       136 | Millennium Telecom Limited                                        | -         | -         | Excellent        |
|       137 | Mineral Exploration Corporation Ltd.                              | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good        |
|       138 | Mishra Dhatu Nigam Ltd.                                           | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent        |
|       139 | MMTC Ltd.                                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good        |
|       140 | MSTC Ltd.                                                         | Excellent | Very Good | Good             |
|       141 | Mumbai Rail Vikas Nigam                                           | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good        |
|       142 | Nagaland Pulp & Paper Company Ltd.                                | -         | Poor      | NS/NE            |
|       143 | National Aluminium Co. Limited                                    | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good        |
|       144 | National BC Fin. & Development Corpn.                             | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent        |
|       145 | National Building Construction Corpn Ltd,                         | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent        |
|       146 | National Fertilizers Ltd.                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Good             |
|       147 | National Film Development Corp. Ltd                               | Good      | Excellent | Poor             |
|       148 | National Handicapped Finance & Development Corporation            | Excellent | Excellent | Fair             |
|       149 | National Handloom Dev. Corp.                                      | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good        |
|       150 | National Informatics Centre Services Incorporated (NICSI)         | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent        |
|       151 | National Jute Manufacturing Corporation Ltd.                      | Fair      | Good      | NS/NE            |
|       152 | National Mineral Dev. Corp. (NMDC)                                | Very Good | Good      | Very Good        |
|       153 | National Minorities Finance Development Corpn                     | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good        |
|       154 | National Projects Construction Corpn. Ltd.                        | Good      | Good      | Good             |
|       155 | National Research Dev. Corpn.                                     | Good      | Very Good | Under Evaluation |
|       156 | National Safai Karamchari's Fin. & Dev. Corpn.                    | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good        |
|       157 | National Schedule Caste Finance Development Corpn                 | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent        |
|       158 | National Schedule Tribes Finance Development Corpn.               | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent        |
|       159 | National Seeds.Corpn. Ltd                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent        |
|       160 | National Small Industries Corpn. Ltd                              | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good        |
|       161 | National Textile Corporation Ltd.                                 | Good      | Good      | Fair             |
|       162 | NBCC Services Limited                                             | -         | -         | Excellent        |
|       163 | NEPA Ltd.                                                         | Fair      | Fair      | Poor             |
|       164 | Neyveli Lignite Corporation Limited                               | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good        |
|       165 | Neyveli Uttar Pradesh Power Ltd                                   | -         | -         | Excellent        |
|       166 | NHDC Ltd.                                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good        |
|       167 | NHPC Ltd.                                                         | Very Good | Very Good | Good             |
|       168 | NLC TAMILNADU POWER LTD                                           | Fair      | Fair      | Poor             |
|       169 | NMDC-CMDC Limited                                                 | -         | -         | Poor             |
|       170 | North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Ltd. (NEEPCO)            | Very Good | Good      | Good             |
|       171 | North Eastern Handicraft & Handlooms Development Corporation Ltd. | Good      | Good      | Good             |
|       172 | North Eastern Reg. Agri. Marketing Corpn. (NERAMAC)               | NS/NE     | Poor      | NS/NE            |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                            | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|---------------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|       173 | Northern Coalfield Ltd.                                 | Very Good | Excellent | #         |
|       174 | NTPC Electric Supply Co. Ltd.                           | Good      | -         | Exempted  |
|       175 | NTPC Ltd.                                               | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       176 | NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Ltd.                           | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       177 | Nuclear Power Corpn. Ltd.                               | Very Good | Very Good | Excellent |
|       178 | Numaligarh Refinery Ltd.                                | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       179 | Oil & Natural Gas Co. Ltd. (ONGC)                       | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       180 | Oil India Limited                                       | Very Good | Good      | Very Good |
|       181 | ONGC Videsh Ltd.                                        | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       182 | Pawan Hans Helicopters Ltd.                             | Very Good | Good      | NS/NE     |
|       183 | PEC Limited                                             | Good      | Good      | Fair      |
|       184 | PFC CAPITAL ADVISORY SERVICES LTD.                      | Excellent | Good      | Exempted  |
|       185 | PFC CONSULTING LTD.                                     | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       186 | PFC GREEN ENERGY LTD.                                   | Very Good | Excellent | NS/NE     |
|       187 | Pondicherry Ashok Hotel Corporation Ltd.                | Good      | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       188 | Power Finance Corporation Ltd                           | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       189 | Power Grid Corpn. Of India Ltd.                         | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       190 | Power Grid NM Transmission Ltd.                         | -         | Very Good | Exempted  |
|       191 | Power System Operation Corporation Limited              | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       192 | PRIZE PETROLIUM CO. LTD                                 | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       193 | Projects & Development India Ltd.                       | Fair      | Good      | Fair      |
|       194 | Punjab Logistics Infrastructure Ltd.                    | -         | Good      | Fair      |
|       195 | Rail Vikas Nigam Ltd.                                   | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       196 | Railtel Corporation of India Ltd                        | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       197 | Railtel Enterprises Ltd.                                | -         | -         | Fair      |
|       198 | RAILWAY ENERGY MANAGEMENT COMPONY LTD.                  | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|       199 | Rajasthan Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Ltd.                  | Poor      | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       200 | Rajasthan Electronics & Instrumentation Ltd.            | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
|       201 | Ranchi Ashok Bihar Hotel Corporation Ltd.               | NS/NE     | Poor      | NS/NE     |
|       202 | Rashtirya Ispat Nagam Ltd.                              | Good      | Good      | Good      |
|       203 | Rashtriya Chemicals & Fertilizers Ltd,                  | Excellent | Very Good | Good      |
|       204 | REC Power Distribution Co. Ltd.                         | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       205 | REC Transmission Projects Co. Ltd.                      | -         | -         | Excellent |
|       206 | Richardson & Cruddas Ltd.                               | Very Good | Good      | NS/NE     |
|       207 | RITES Afrika Limited                                    | Very Good | Excellent | Poor      |
|       208 | RITES INFRASTUCTURE SERVISES LTD.                       | Excellent | Excellent | Exempted  |
|       209 | RITES Limited                                           | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       210 | Rural Electrification Corpn. Ltd                        | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       211 | SAIL REFRACTORY CO. LTD.(SRCL)                          | Good      | Good      | Very Good |
|       212 | Sambar Salt Ltd.                                        | Fair      | Fair      | Poor      |
|       213 | SJVN Ltd.                                               | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good |
|       214 | Scooters India Ltd                                      | Fair      | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       215 | Security Printing and Minting Corporation of India Ltd. | Excellent | Very Good | Good      |
|       216 | Shipping Corpn. Of India Ltd.                           | Very Good | Very Good | Poor      |
|       217 | SIDCUL CONCOR INFRA COMPANY LTD.                        | Very Good | Good -    | Fair      |
|       218 | SJVN Arun-3 Power Development Co.Ltd.                   | -         |           | Very Good |

|   Sl. No. | Name of CPSE                                    | 2014-15   | 2015-16   | 2016-17   |
|-----------|-------------------------------------------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
|       219 | SJVN Thermal Pvt. Ltd.                          | -         | -         | Very Good |
|       220 | Solar Energy Corporation of India Ltd.          | -         | Very Good | Very Good |
|       221 | South Eastern Coalfield Ltd.                    | Excellent | Very Good | #         |
|       222 | State Trading Corporation Ltd                   | Good      | Good      | Poor      |
|       223 | Steel Authority of India Ltd.                   | Very Good | Very Good | Very Good |
|       224 | TAMILNADU TELECOMMUNICATION CO. LTD.            | Fair      | Fair      | NS/NE     |
|       225 | Tamilnadu Trade Promotion Organisation          | Very Good | Good      | Poor      |
|       226 | TCIL BINA ROAD                                  | Excellent | Very Good | NS/NE     |
|       227 | THDC Ltd. (Tehri Hydro Development Corpn. Ltd.) | Excellent | Very Good | Very Good |
|       228 | Telecommunications Consultants India Ltd        | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
|       229 | Uranium Corporation of India Ltd.               | Good      | Good      | Very Good |
|       230 | Vignyan Industries Ltd.                         | Fair      | Fair      | Fair      |
|       231 | Powergrid Vizag Transmission Ltd. (VTL)         | -         | Excellent | NS/NE     |
|       232 | WAPCOS Ltd.                                     | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
|       233 | Western Coalfield Ltd.                          | Very Good | Very Good | #         |

NS/NE: Not Submitted/Not Evaluated

#: MoU signed on consolidated basis with Holding Company (CIL).