Juanita Broaddrick

**Juanita Broaddrick** (an haife ta a ranar 13 ga Disamba, 1942) tsohuwar mai kula da gidajen kula da tsofaffi ce 'yar Amurka. Ta yi zargin cewa Shugaban Amurka Bill Clinton ya yi mata fyade a ranar 25 ga Afrilu, 1978, lokacin da yake Babban Lauyan Arkansas . Lauyan Clinton, David E. Kendall, ya ce hakan "bai taɓa faruwa ba" a madadin wanda yake karewa, kuma Clinton ta ƙi yin ƙarin bayani game da batun.

An yi rikodin wannan a cikin wata wasiƙa da wani abokin hamayyar Clinton na jam'iyyar Republican ya shirya a kusan 1992, amma Broaddrick ya ƙi yin magana da kafofin watsa labarai har zuwa 1999. A cikin wata sanarwa da aka rantse a 1997 mai suna "Jane Doe #5",  Broaddrick ya shigar da takardar rantsuwa ga lauyoyin Paula Jones yana mai cewa akwai jita-jita da labarai marasa tushe da ke yawo "cewa Mr. Clinton ya yi min lalata da ba a so a ƙarshen shekarun 70. ... Waɗannan zarge-zargen ba gaskiya ba ne".  Daga nan ta karyata wannan bayanin ga masu bincike kan yiwuwar aikata ba daidai ba ta Clinton ƙarƙashin jagorancin Kenneth Starr, yayin da ta dage a lokacin cewa Clinton ba ta matsa mata ko ta ba ta cin hanci ta kowace hanya ba. Starr ta ƙi ƙara bincika batun, kuma ta ambaci hakan ne kawai a cikin ƙaramin bayanin rahotonsa na ƙarshe .

Hasashe ya ci gaba da cewa Broaddrick yana da ƙarin bayani game da lamarin, kuma a cikin wata hira da *Dateline NBC* wanda aka watsa a ranar 24 ga Fabrairu, 1999, Broaddrick ya tattauna batun a bainar jama'a a karon farko, a wannan karon yana cewa Clinton ta yi mata fyade,  wanda lauyan Clinton ya musanta cewa gaskiya ne.  Iƙirarin Broaddrick ya dawo hankalin jama'a dangane da yakin neman zaben shugaban ƙasa na Hillary Clinton na 2016 da kuma ƙungiyar Me Too ta 2017. Ta rubuta wani tarihin rayuwa tana maimaita zargin a 2018.

## Bayani
Broaddrick ta fito ne daga Van Buren, Arkansas, wani gari a arewa maso yammacin jihar.  An haifi ta Juanita Smith ga iyayenta Buster Smith da Mary Elizabeth Smith.  Tana da 'yar'uwa babba.  Mahaifinta ne ke da gidan Smith Cleaners. Iyalin na Cocin Episcopal ne .  A cikin tarihin rayuwarta, ta ce mahaifiyarta ta yi mata cin zarafi ta jiki da ta motsin rai. 

Juanita Smith ta kammala karatunta daga Makarantar Sakandare ta Van Buren a shekarar 1960.  Ta halarci makarantar koyon aikin jinya a Makarantar Koyon Aikin Jinya ta Sparks daga 1960 zuwa 1963.  Daga nan ta yi aiki a matsayin ma'aikaciyar jinya mai rijista a gidajen kula da tsofaffi da dama.  

A shekarar 1974, ta sayi gidan kula da tsofaffi a Van Buren.   An san wurin da Brownwood Manor Nursing Home.  Mahaifiyarta ta kasance mai mallakar wani ɓangare na gidan. 

An fara auren Juanita da Gary Hickey, kuma auren ya faru ne kafin ta bar makarantar koyon aikin jinya.  Sun haifi ɗa, wanda aka haifa a kusa da shekarar 1969.

## Zarge-zargen da ake yi wa Bill Clinton

### 1978: Labarinta
Broaddrick, wanda aka fi sani da Juanita Hickey a lokacin, ya fara haɗuwa da Clinton ne lokacin da ya ziyarci gidan kula da tsofaffi a lokacin yakin neman zaɓensa na gwamna a shekarar 1978. Clinton ita ce Babban Lauyan Arkansas a lokacin. Broaddrick yana son yin aikin sa kai don kamfen ɗin, kuma ya ce Clinton ta gayyace ta ta ziyarci ofishin kamfen ɗin da ke Little Rock .  Ta ce ta tuntuɓi ofishin 'yan makonni bayan haka yayin da take yankin don wani taron gidajen kula da tsofaffi kuma Clinton ya ce ba zai kasance a ofishin kamfen ɗin a wannan ranar ba kuma ta ba da shawarar su haɗu a shagon kofi a Camelot Hotel (wanda yanzu shine otal ɗin DoubleTree ) da ke birnin. Amma bayan isowarsa, ana zargin ya nemi su ci kofi a ɗakinta don guje wa taron 'yan jarida a falon kuma Broaddrick ya amince. 

Broaddrick ta ce su biyun sun yi magana a ɗan lokaci a ɗakinta, inda Clinton ta bayyana shirin da ya kamata ya gyara gidan yari da ke bayyane daga tagarta idan ya zama gwamna. Sai kuma, a cewar Broaddrick, Clinton ta sumbace ta ba zato ba tsammani. Broaddrick ta ce ta tura Clinton ta gaya masa tana da aure kuma ba ta da sha'awar hakan, amma ya dage. Kamar yadda aka ruwaito a hirar NBC: 
 
Da aka tambaye shi ko akwai wata hanya da Clinton zai iya tunanin cewa an amince da shi, Broaddrick ya ce "A'a, ba da abin da na gaya masa ba da kuma yadda na yi ƙoƙarin ture shi. Ba a yarda da shi ba." 

Broaddrick ta raba ɗakin otal ɗin da kawarta kuma ma'aikaciyarta Norma Rogers. Rogers ya halarci wani taron karawa juna sani a safiyar ranar, kuma ta ce ta koma ɗakinsu ta tarar da Broaddrick a kan gado "cikin firgici", da jakar hannunta ta yage a cikin kugunta kuma lebenta ya kumbura kamar an buge shi. Rogers ya ce Broaddrick ya gaya mata cewa Clinton ta "tilasta mata".  Rogers ya taimaka wa Broaddrick ya yi mata kankara, sannan matan suka bar Little Rock. Rogers ya ce Broaddrick ta yi matukar damuwa a kan hanyarta ta komawa gida kuma ta zargi kanta da barin Clinton ta shiga ɗakin.  Broaddrick ta ce ba ta gaya wa mijinta, Gary Hickey, game da lamarin ba, kuma ta gaya masa cewa ta ji wa lebenta rauni ba da gangan ba. Ya shaida wa NBC cewa bai tuna da raunin ko bayaninta ba.   Duk da haka, David Broaddrick ya ce ya lura da leben da ya ji rauni, kuma ta gaya masa cewa Clinton ta yi mata fyade lokacin da ya tambaye shi game da hakan. Wasu abokai uku sun tabbatar da cewa Broaddrick ya gaya musu game da lamarin a lokacin: Susan Lewis; Louis Ma; da kuma Jean Darden, 'yar'uwar Norma Rogers.  Broaddrick bai tuna ranar da aka yi zargin faruwar lamarin ba, amma ya ce bazara ce ta 1978 kuma ta zauna a Otal ɗin Camelot. Bayanai sun nuna cewa Broaddrick ya halarci taron kula da tsofaffi a Otal ɗin Camelot da ke Little Rock a ranar 25 ga Afrilu, 1978.   Fadar White House ta Clinton ba ta amsa buƙatun Clinton na jadawalin ranar ba,  amma rahotannin labarai sun nuna cewa yana Little Rock a wannan ranar, ba tare da wani alƙawarin hukuma ba da safe. 

Makonni uku bayan zargin cin zarafin, Broaddrick ya shiga wani ƙaramin shirin tara kuɗi na Clinton a gidan likitan haƙori na yankin. Broaddrick ta ce ta "ƙaryata" kuma ta ji laifi, tana tunanin cewa ta ba Clinton ra'ayin da bai dace ba ta hanyar barin shi ya shiga ɗakinta.  Lokacin da ta isa wurin taron, ta ce, ƙawarta wacce ta ɗauki Clintons daga filin jirgin sama ta gaya mata cewa Hillary Clinton ta tambaya ko za ta halarci taron. Broaddrick ta ce Bill Clinton bai yi mata magana a wurin taron ba, amma Hillary Clinton ta kusance ta, ta kama hannunta, ta ce "Ina so ki san irin godiyar da Bill da ni ke yi masa." Lokacin da Broaddrick ta motsa hannunta, ta ce, Hillary Clinton ta riƙe ta ta ce, "Kin fahimta? Duk abin da kike yi." Broaddrick ta ce ta ji tashin zuciya kuma ta bar taron. Broaddrick ta ce ta fassara lamarin ne a matsayin Hillary Clinton tana gode mata da ta yi shiru.   

### Abubuwan da suka biyo baya
Juanita Hickey ta saki Gary Hickey a kusa da shekarar 1979 kuma ta auri David Broaddrick a kusa da shekarar 1981. 

Broaddrick ya buɗe wani cibiya ta biyu, don samar da ayyuka ga yara masu nakasa ta hankali a Fort Smith, Arkansas .  

A shekarar 1984, an yi wa cibiyar kula da tsofaffi ta Broaddrick lakabi da mafi kyau a jihar, wanda ya kawo wasiƙar taya murna daga gwamnan. A ƙasa akwai wata takarda da aka rubuta da hannu daga Clinton, tana cewa, "Ina yaba maka sosai." 

Broaddrick ta ce a shekarar 1991, Clinton ta kira ta daga taron ma'aikatan jinya na jihar don neman afuwa: "'Juanita, na yi nadama da abin da na yi. Ba ni ne mutumin da na kasance a da ba, za ki iya yafe min? Me zan iya yi don in gyara miki wannan?' Kuma ina tsaye a wurin cikin firgici. Kuma na gaya masa ya je jahannama, sai na tafi."   Jean Darden, wacce Broaddrick ya bayyana mata lamarin a cikinta, ita ma ta halarci taron kuma ta ce ta ga Broaddrick yana magana da Clinton a cikin zauren.  Clinton ta sanar da yakin neman zaben shugaban kasa na 1992 jim kadan bayan wannan tattaunawar da ake zargin ta yi.

### 1992–1998
Duk da cewa Broaddrick ta ƙi yin magana da manema labarai, jita-jita game da labarinta ta fara yaɗuwa ba da daɗewa ba bayan takarar Clinton a matsayin shugaban ƙasa a 1992. Broaddrick ta ɓoye labarin ga Phillip Yoakum, wanda ta sani daga ƙungiyoyin kasuwanci kuma a lokacin ta ɗauki abokiyar ta a matsayin abokiya. Lokacin da Clinton ta lashe zaɓen 'yan Democrat, Yoakum, wacce aka fi sani da jam'iyyar Republican,  ta tuntuɓi Sheffield Nelson, abokin hamayyar Clinton a takarar gwamna na 1990. Yoakum ta shirya wani taro tsakanin Nelson da Broaddrick, wanda ya ƙi amincewa da buƙatar Yoakum da Nelson na ta bayyana a bainar jama'a.  Yoakum ta yi rikodin tattaunawar a ɓoye kuma ta rubuta wasiƙa da ke taƙaita zarge-zargen, wanda ya fara yaɗuwa a cikin da'irar Republican. Labarin ya isa ga *[[New York Times|jaridar New York Times]]* da *[[Los Angeles Times]]* a watan Oktoban 1992, amma jaridun sun watsar da labarin bayan da Broaddrick ya ƙi yin magana da 'yan jarida kuma Yoakum ya ƙi sakin rikodin. 

A kaka ta 1997, masu binciken sirri na Paula Jones sun yi ƙoƙarin yin magana da Broaddrick a gidanta, sannan suka yi rikodin tattaunawar a ɓoye.  Broaddrick ta ƙi tattauna lamarin, tana cewa "abu ne mai ban tsoro kawai," kuma "ba za ta sake tunawa da shi ba don komai." Masu binciken sun gaya mata cewa za a iya sa mata kira idan ba ta yi magana da su ba. Broaddrick ta ce za ta musanta komai, tana cewa "ba za ka iya zuwa wurinsa ba, kuma ba zan ɓata sunana na ba don yin hakan ... babu wata hanyar da kowa zai iya isa gare shi, kawai mugunta ne."  An sa wa Broaddrick kira a cikin ƙarar Jones jim kaɗan bayan haka kuma ta gabatar da takardar rantsuwa da ke musanta cewa Clinton ta yi "duk wani buƙatar jima'i".   An fallasa rikodin tattaunawar Broaddrick da masu binciken ga manema labarai, amma Broaddrick ya ci gaba da ƙin yin magana da manema labarai. 

Duk da musantawar da Broaddrick ta yi a cikin takardar shaidarta, lauyoyin Jones sun haɗa da wasiƙar Yoakum da sunan Broaddrick a cikin takardar shaidar da aka shigar a shekarar 1998.  Wasiƙar ta nuna cewa Clintons sun sayi shiru na Broaddrick, tana kwatanta kiran waya inda mijin Broaddrick ya nemi Yoakum ya ce lamarin bai taɓa faruwa ba kuma ya ce yana da niyyar neman Clinton "don wasu manyan alheri".  Wannan, tare da rashin jituwa tsakanin wasiƙar da takardar shaidar Broaddrick, ya jawo hankalin lauya mai zaman kansa Kenneth Starr, wanda ke binciken Clinton don hana adalci. Bayan FBI ta tuntube ta, Broaddrick ta tuntuɓi ɗanta, lauya, wanda ya gaya mata cewa ba za ta iya yi wa masu bincike na tarayya ƙarya ba.  Bayan Starr ta ba ta kariya, don haka ta tabbatar da cewa ba za a gurfanar da ita a gaban kuliya ba saboda rantsuwar ƙarya game da takardar shaidarta a shari'ar Jones, Broaddrick ta musanta takardar shaidar.  Duk da haka, ta dage cewa Clinton bai matsa mata ko ya ba ta cin hanci ta kowace hanya ba, don haka Starr ta kammala da cewa labarin bai dace da bincikensa ba kuma rahotonsa ya ambaci sake rubutawa ne kawai a cikin ƙaramin rubutu. 

### 1999
Rumors continued to circulate in tabloids and on talk radio, now with Broaddrick's name attached. Broaddrick was upset by a tabloid report that she had been paid to keep quiet, and decided to agree to an interview with NBC's Lisa Myers. Myers interviewed her on December 20, 1998, the day after Clinton was impeached. The interview only aired on February 24, 1999, 66 days later and after Clinton had been acquitted on February 12. NBC was accused of intentionally sitting on the story and invoking unusually demanding standards of corroboration until the impeachment process ended. Broaddrick and another source said NBC gathered the key corroborating evidence within 10 days of the interview, NBC assistant producer Chris Giglio said it may have taken him 14 days—in either case, while the impeachment process was ongoing. Though the story was unaired, at least one Republican senator reportedly invoked it to convince undecided Republicans to vote for impeachment.

Yayin da NBC ke jiran a watsa hirar, Dorothy Rabinowitz, wacce ta rubuta wa shafin edita na *Wall Street Journal*, ta tuntubi Broaddrick. Cikin takaici da jinkirin da NBC ta yi, Broaddrick ya amince ya yi magana da Rabinowitz, kuma labarin ya fara bayyana a shafin edita *na Wall Street Journal* a ranar 19 ga Fabrairu  NBC ta watsa hirar Myers jim kaɗan bayan haka.

### Martanin Clinton kan zarge-zargen
A daren Juma'a, 19 ga Fabrairu, 1999, lauyan Clinton, David Kendall, ya musanta zargin a madadin Clinton. Kendall ya ce: "Duk wani zargi da ake yi cewa shugaban kasar ya kai wa Mrs. Broaddrick hari fiye da shekaru 20 da suka gabata karya ne. Bayan haka, ba za mu yi magana ba." 

Da aka tambaye shi game da ikirarin Broaddrick a wani taron manema labarai a ranar 24 ga Fabrairu, 1999, Clinton ya ce: "To, lauyana ya yi bayani game da ... batun, kuma babu abin da zan ƙara masa."  Ya zuwa watan Nuwamba na 2020, bai sake yin wani bayani a bainar jama'a kan lamarin ba, kuma ba a gurfanar da shi ko a tuhume shi da wani laifi da ya shafi zargin Broaddrick ba.  

### Martanin jama'a da na manema labarai
Saboda akwai ƙarancin shaidu masu tabbatar da zargin Broaddrick kuma a baya ta shigar da wata sanarwa da ta rantse tana cewa babu wani hari, zarginta ba a yi imani da shi ba.  Kamar yadda *jaridar New York Times* ta taƙaita a 1999, "Babu wata shaida ta zahiri da za ta tabbatar da hakan. Babu wani kuma da ya kasance a wurin a lokacin da ake zargin ganawar a ɗakin otal ɗin Little Rock kusan shekaru 21 da suka gabata. Tun daga lokacin an rufe otal ɗin. Kuma Mrs. Broaddrick ta musanta ganawar a cikin wata takardar rantsuwa a watan Janairun 1998 a shari'ar Paula Jones, wacce aka san ta da 'Jane Doe No. 5' kawai. A duk waɗannan shekarun, ta ƙi fitowa fili. Lokacin da lauyoyin Jones suka matsa mata lamba, ta musanta zargin. Kuma yanzu, ta ƙi amincewa da wannan musantawar." 

A watan Maris na shekarar 1999, mujallar  ta wallafa wani labari da aka ambata a baya.  wani labarin mai suna "Shin Juanita Broaddrick Tana Faɗin Gaskiya?", wanda ya ba da dalilai masu yiwuwa da ya kamata a yarda da Broaddrick, ko kuma kada a yarda da shi, game da kowanne daga cikin muhimman batutuwa. A ɓangaren rashin yarda, an yi nuni da cewa mutane biyar da suka ce Broaddrick ya amince da su jim kaɗan bayan lamarin na iya zama ƙarya. Wannan hujja ta nuna cewa Rogers da Darden sun ƙi amincewa da Clinton; a shekarar 1980 a matsayin gwamna, ya rage hukuncin ɗaurin rai da rai na Guy Lavern Kuehn, mutumin da ya kashe mahaifinsu a shekarar 1971. Masu shakka sun kuma lura cewa ko da waɗannan mutanen suna faɗin gaskiya, Broaddrick zai iya yi musu ƙarya a lokacin da abubuwan da suka faru na asali suka faru. 

Wasu bayanai da ke cikin labarin Broaddrick sun yi daidai da zarge-zargen wasu mata. A wata hira da ta fito bayan zarge-zargen Broaddrick, Elizabeth Gracen ta ce Clinton ta cije lebenta a lokacin wata ganawa da aka yi da ita wadda ta zama mai wahala. 

Broaddrick ya ce bayan harin, Clinton ta gaya mata kada ta damu da daukar ciki domin ciwon mara ya sa shi ba shi da haihuwa.  Da aka tuntube ta game da batun, Gennifer Flowers, wacce Clinton daga baya ta amince da yin jima'i da ita, ta kuma ce Clinton ta yi tunanin ba zai iya haihuwa ba.  Clinton za ta haifi ɗa ɗaya, Chelsea Clinton, wacce aka haifa a shekarar 1980.

A watan Maris na shekarar 1999, jim kaɗan bayan an watsa zarge-zargen a bainar jama'a, kashi 56% na Amurkawa sun yi imanin cewa zarge-zargen ƙarya ne, yayin da kashi na uku ya yi imanin cewa zarge-zargen Broaddrick na fyaɗe aƙalla gaskiya ne. Hakazalika, kashi 66% na jama'a sun ji cewa ya kamata kafofin watsa labarai su daina bin diddigin labarin, yayin da kashi 29% suka ji cewa ya kamata 'yan jarida su ci gaba da binciken zarge-zargen. 

Jama'a da kafofin watsa labarai sun sami "gajiyawar badakala" daga zarge-zargen lalata da ake yi wa Clinton akai-akai, kuma bayan tsige shi da kuma wanke shi daga tuhuma, mutane da yawa sun ji cewa babu inda za su je. 'Yan jarida da yawa sun ci karo da labarin yayin da masu fafutukar Republican ke yada shi kuma sun ji sun riga sun duba shi. Jack Nelson, shugaban ofishin Washington na Los Angeles Times, ya ce "Wannan labari ne da aka rushe shi kuma aka yi watsi da shi sau da yawa ... [Kowa] ya ɗauki ɗan yanki na shi, kuma bayan ya duba shi, kowa ya rushe shi. Matar ta canza labarinta game da ko ya faru. Kawai ba gaskiya ba ne." Julia Malone, 'yar jaridar Cox Communications, ta fusata da abin da ta fahimta a matsayin sakacin kafofin watsa labarai game da labarin kuma ta yi zaman kwamitin National Press Club kan batun mai taken "Zafi sosai ga Sabbin Kafafen Yada Labarai na 'Tsegumi da Bazata' da za a Iya Magance su?" Sam Donaldson na ABC News ya ce ya ji takaicin rashin amincewar abokan aikinsa na 'yan jarida na matsa wa Clinton lamba don ya mayar da martani ga zarge-zargen: Clinton ta ƙi yin tsokaci lokacin da Donaldson ya yi tambaya game da zarge-zargen, kuma babu wanda zai matsa lamba kan batun.

Hukuncin da aka yanke kan batun Broaddrick ya bambanta tsakanin hanyoyin da aka bi wajen magance matsalolin shekarun Bill Clinton. Yayin da littafin Christopher Hitchens na 1999, *No One Left to Lie To*, ya yi jayayya cewa ikirarin Broaddrick abin dogaro ne kuma yana nuna kamanceceniya da zargin cin zarafin mata da Paula Jones ta yi daga baya,  littafin Michael Isikoff, *Uncovering Clinton*, ya ce lauyoyin Clinton sun yi tunanin cewa wataƙila ya yi jima'i da Broaddrick ba tare da aure ba, amma ba su yi imani da cewa zai tilasta mata ba,  da kuma littafin Joe Conason da Gene Lyons na 2004 *, The Hunting of the President,* sun yi jayayya cewa ikirarin Broaddrick ba gaskiya ba ne, suna lura cewa FBI ta sami shaidar zargin da ba ta kammala ba.

## Bayan haka
Broaddrick ta shigar da ƙara a kan Clinton a watan Disamba na 1999 domin samun takardu da Fadar White House ta tattara game da ita, tana mai da'awar kin amincewa da buƙatarta na irin waɗannan takardu ya saɓa wa Dokar Sirri ta 1974.  Lauyanta ɗan ra'ayin mazan jiya ne mai fafutukar kare haƙƙin jama'a Larry Klayman, shugaban ƙungiyar masu fafutukar kare haƙƙin jama'a ta Judicial Watch .  Alkali Henry H. Kennedy Jr. na Kotun Gundumar Amurka ya yi watsi da ƙarar a watan Maris na 2001. Alkalin ya yanke hukuncin cewa Dokar Sirri ba ta yi aiki a wannan shari'ar ba kuma Broaddrick ya gaza nuna shaidar cewa Ma'aikatar Shari'a ta Amurka ta fitar da takardu game da ita ba daidai ba. 

A lokacin, hukumar IRS ta duba harkokin Broaddrick, wanda ta yi iƙirarin cewa ramuwar gayya ce: "Ban yi imani wannan abu ne mai kama da haka ba," in ji Broaddrick, "Ban yi tsammanin adadinmu ya bayyana ba." 

Yayin da yakin neman zaben Hillary Clinton a zaben Majalisar Dattawan Amurka na 2000 a New York ke ci gaba da gudana, Broaddrick ta buga wata buɗaɗɗiyar wasiƙa a gare ta, tana mai Allah wadai da rawar da ta taka wajen kare kanta daga zargin kai hari da mijinta ya yi mata. 

Broaddricks sun rabu a shekara ta 2004. David Broaddrick ya yi adawa da ta bayyana labarin fyaden da ta yi a bainar jama'a a shekara ta 1999. Juanita Broaddrick ta ce ta kuma fara jin tsoron wuraren da aka killace sakamakon abin da ya faru. 

A shekara ta 2008, Broaddrick ta sayar da kasuwancinta na kula da tsofaffi ta kuma yi ritaya,  bayan ta yi aiki mai kyau a matsayin 'yar kasuwa. Ta ci gaba da zama a Van Buren, a wani gona mai fadin eka 23. 

## An sabunta hankali a lokacin yakin neman zaben shugaban Amurka na 2016
Broaddrick ta sake tayar da ikirari na fyaɗe a shafinta na Twitter a lokacin zaɓen shugaban ƙasar Amurka na 2016, yayin da Hillary Clinton ta kasance 'yar takarar jam'iyyar Democrat a matsayin shugabar ƙasa. 

A wannan mahallin, shari'ar Broaddrick sau da yawa ta haifar da rashin jin daɗi daga mutanen da galibi ke goyon bayan Clintons. A cikin wani bita na shari'ar da aka yi a watan Oktoban 2016, Dylan Matthews na Vox ya ce: "Amsar a takaice ita ce wasu daga cikin ikirari [akan Bill Clinton] sun fi sauran inganci. Akwai manyan masu tuhuma guda uku [sauran su ne Jones da Willey], waɗanda da alama sun fi inganci - bisa ga shaidar da jama'a ke da ita - Broaddrick ne." Matthews ya ci gaba da cewa: "Idan aka yi la'akari da ra'ayin da ke tsakanin masu ci gaba da yawa - ciki har da Hillary Clinton - cewa ya kamata mutum ya yarda da masu zargin fyaɗe, zargin Broaddrick yana haifar da matsala."  Michelle Goldberg ta *Slate* ta rubuta a cikin wani rubutu da ta yi a ƙarshen 2015, "ƙa'idojinmu na magana game da cin zarafin mata sun canza tun daga shekarun 1990, lokacin da waɗannan matan suka kasance a cikin labarai na ƙarshe. A yau, masu ra'ayin mata sun yi ta maimaitawa kuma sun tabbatar da cewa lokacin da mata suka ce an yi musu cin zarafin mata, ya kamata mu ɗauka cewa suna faɗin gaskiya ne. Musamman idan ana maganar Broaddrick, ba abu ne mai sauƙi ba a daidaita hujjojin da aka gabatar game da yarda da ita tare da mafi girman ra'ayi kan amincewa da waɗanda abin ya shafa. Wannan tashin hankali ne da mutanen da ke hannun dama ke sha'awar amfani da shi." 

Masu sharhi da yawa waɗanda galibi suna da shakku game da ikirarin cin zarafin mata ba tare da wata hujja mai ƙarfi ba, sun ga zargin Broaddrick abin gaskatawa ne. Kamar yadda Katie JM Baker ta BuzzFeed News ta yi kuka, "A ka'ida, bai kamata siyasa ta jam'iyya ta taka rawa wajen tantance ko wanda ake zargi da fyade ya cancanci a saurare shi ba."  Robby Soave na mujallar *Reason* ya yi irin wannan lura. 

Wakiliyar NBC mai ritaya wadda yanzu ta watsa labarinta, Lisa Myers, ta ce: "Babu wanda zai iya duba labarin Juanita da idon basira ba tare da damuwa ba. Ɗaya daga cikin abubuwan da ke sa ta zama abin dogaro shine ko wacece—a bayyane take, a bayyane take, kuma kamar ba ta da laifi."

A ƙarshen shekarar 2015, a lokacin wani taron jama'a a lokacin yakin neman zabenta na shugaban ƙasa, an tambayi Hillary Clinton game da zargin, sai ta amsa da cewa: "To, zan ce ya kamata a yi imani da kowa da farko har sai an kafirta shi bisa ga shaida." 

A watan Janairun 2016, Broaddrick ta raba a shafin sada zumunta na Twitter, "Ina da shekaru 35 lokacin da Bill Clinton, Babban Lauyan Ark. suka yi min fyade kuma Hillary ta yi kokarin yin shiru da ni. Yanzu ina da shekaru 73. ... ba ta taba shudewa ba." Broaddrick ta ce ba 'yar Democrat ba ce kuma ba 'yar Republican ba ce, amma ta goyi bayan yakin neman zaben Donald Trump na 2016 : "Yana faɗin abubuwan da nake son ji." Ta amince da yadda Trump ya yi amfani da ayyukan lalata da aka amince da su da kuma zargin da ake yi wa Bill Clinton a yakin neman zaben.  Duk da cewa ta zabi George W. Bush a zaben 2000 da 2004, a zaben shugaban kasa na 2008 ta zabi Barack Obama kuma ta ba shi dala $3,000 ga yakin neman zabensa  saboda yana takara da Hillary Clinton . Yayin da zaben ke ci gaba, ta kara daidaita kanta da ayyuka da ra'ayoyi masu ra'ayin mazan jiya . 

A ranar 8 ga Oktoba, 2016, bayan takaddama kan faifan Donald Trump , Trump ya sake wallafa sakonnin Twitter na Broaddrick inda ta kira Bill Clinton "mai fyade" kuma ta kira ayyukan Hillary Clinton "abin ban tsoro".   A ranar 9 ga Oktoba, Broaddrick ya bayyana a wani taro tare da Trump, Paula Jones, da Kathleen Willey (mace ta huɗu a kwamitin, Kathy Shelton, tana da korafi mara alaƙa da Hillary Clinton) awa ɗaya kafin muhawara ta biyu tsakanin Trump da Clinton a ɓangaren zaɓe na gaba ɗaya na muhawarar zaɓen shugaban ƙasa na Amurka, 2016.  Broaddrick da sauran su ma suna cikin masu sauraro yayin muhawarar, haka nan Bill Clinton, kodayake masu shirya muhawarar sun ajiye su a wurare daban-daban.  Kamfen ɗin Trump ya ce ya biya kuɗin tafiyar Broaddrick zuwa muhawarar. 

## #MeToo da ƙarin sharhi a cikin 2017–2018
A shekarar 2017, bayan zarge-zargen cin zarafin mata da Harvey Weinstein ta yi, Broaddrick ta soki tsohuwar budurwar Bill Clinton ta shekarun 1990, Monica Lewinsky, saboda ta haɗa kanta da ƙungiyar #MeToo, tana cewa, "Na daɗe ina baƙin ciki da ke, amma ina kike lokacin da muke buƙatar ki?" Broaddrick ya ƙara da cewa, "Na daɗe ina jin kamar an zalunce ta. Ina fata dai ta yi magana a shekarar 1999 lokacin da nake fuskantar tsanantawa sosai bayan hirar da na yi da ita a NBC Dateline ."

Wasu tattaunawa kan zarge-zargen da ake yi wa Clinton sun bayyana, ciki har da waɗanda suka fito daga Broaddrick.  Matthews ya rubuta cewa "Ci gaba da la'akari da cin zarafin mata da cin zarafin mata da Amurka ke yi a ƙasa da ƙasa daga manyan mutane yanzu ya sa 'yan sassaucin ra'ayi da 'yan Democrat ke sake tunani game da gadon ɗaya daga cikin manyan jiga-jigan jam'iyyar a cikin kwata na ƙarni da ya gabata: Shugaba Bill Clinton." 

Caitlin Flanagan na *jaridar The Atlantic* ta rubuta "Duk da haka kada mu manta da laifukan jima'i da aka zarge Bill Clinton da su a shekarun 1990. Juanita Broaddrick ta ruwaito hakan ..." kafin ta sake duba shari'ar.  A lokacin wata hira da NPR, Flanagan ya ce, "Don haka akwai jerin mata a duk tsawon lokacin shugabancinsa wadanda suka fito da labaran abubuwan da suka ce ya yi musu wanda hakan ya yi daidai da irin abubuwan da muke kallo a yanzu a cikin mafi munin shari'o'in. Juanita Broaddrick, mafi shahara, ta ce ya yi mata fyade da karfi ta hanyar da ta yi kama da zargin Harvey Weinstein dangane da dakin otal da kuma ba zato ba tsammani da kuma mummunan tsoro na duka." 

Michelle Goldberg ta rubuta wani rubutu a *jaridar The New York Times* mai taken "Na Yi Imani da Juanita", inda ta ce, "A wannan lokacin #MeToo, lokacin da muke sake duba shekaru da dama na rashin da'a na maza da kuma mayar da sirrin da ba a bayyana ba zuwa fallasa, ya kamata mu duba a sarari shaidar da ke nuna cewa Juanita Broaddrick ta faɗi gaskiya lokacin da ta zargi Clinton da yi mata fyade. Amma sake duba badakalar Clinton dangane da siyasar yau yana da rikitarwa kuma yana da zafi." 

Bayan zarge-zargen cin zarafin mata da aka yi wa ɗan takarar Majalisar Dattawa na Alabama Roy Moore, Broaddrick ya ce, "Duk waɗanda abin ya shafa suna da muhimmanci. Ko kai ɗan Democrat ne ko ɗan Republican ne ... Duk muna da 'yancin a yarda da mu." 

## Manazarta