A nan ba tare da kai ba (Waƙar Byrds)

Here Without You" waka ce da Gene Clark ya rubuta wacce aka fara yi a kan kundin farko na Byrds na 1965 Mr. Tambourine Man. Daga baya wasu masu fasaha suka rufe ta, gami da Reigning Sound da Richard Thompson. .

## Rayra da kiɗa
"Here Without You" yana daya daga cikin waƙoƙin sa na asali da ɗayan Byrds ya rubuta, wanda ya samo asali ne daga 1964 lokacin da aka san ƙungiyar da Jet Set .  An rubuta shi a Columbia Studios a Hollywood, CA a ranar 22 ga Afrilu, 1965, a cikin zaman rikodin karshe na kundin Mr. Tambourine Man .  Yana da wani mid-tempo ballad wanda ke amfani da kananan key harmonies don ƙirƙirar wani melancholy yanayi. AllMusic mai sukar Matthew Greenwald ya ba da shawarar cewa Beatles ne ya yi wahayi zuwa ga waƙar. Marubucin James Perone ya lura da kamanceceniya tsakanin jituwa na murya na "Here Without You" da na wasu waƙoƙin Chadi da Jeremy da Masu Bincike. Kalmomin suna nuna kaɗaici na mawaƙin. Mai sukar kiɗa Johnny Rogan ya ga kamanceceniya tsakanin taken "Here Without You" da na Hal David's " (Akwai) Kullum Wani abu da za a Tunatar da Ni", a cikin wannan waƙoƙin biyu suna kwatanta mawaƙin da ke wucewa ta cikin birni inda komai ya tunatar da shi game da dangantakar da ta ƙare. A cikin layi kamar "Hanya da nake tafiya a kan su ya kunyata ni / Wadanda suka yi farin ciki lokacin da nake tare da ku", Clark yana amfani da hotuna don bayyana abubuwan da ya samu na Los Angeles a tsakiyar shekarun 1960. Waƙar tana ba da ɗan bege ga mawaƙin a cikin layin "Na san ba zai daɗe ba / Zan gan ka wata rana. "  Will Levith na Ultimate Classic Rock ya lura cewa waƙar ta haɗu da manyan da ƙananan maɓalli kuma kalmomin suna da "duhu da rikitarwa. "

## Karɓar karɓa mai mahimmanci
Greenwald ya kira "A nan Ba ​​tare da ku" wani "haske" na Mista Tambourine Man da misali na "babban damar rubuta waƙa" na Gene Clark.  Rogan ya ɗauki waƙar ta zama mai ban sha'awa "don tsayawa tare da wasu daga cikin mafi kyawun kayan Lennon / McCartney na lokacin.  A cewar Rogan, "an dauke shi daga cikin manyan abubuwan aikin farko na ƙungiyar" kuma a matsayin "wani muhimmin ɓangare na tarihin ƙungiyar da ci gaba."  A cikin 4th edition na The Rolling Stone High Album Guide, Rob Sheffield ya kira shi daya daga cikin "mafi mahimmancin waƙoƙi" a kan Mr. Tambourine Man.  Mai sukar AllMusic Richie Unterberger ya ɗauki shi "mai ƙalubale, amma daidai da iko a cikin kiɗa" idan aka kwatanta da Bob Dylan, Pete Seeger, da Jackie DeShannon-rubuce ya rubuta waƙoƙin da aka yi a matsayin mafi kyawun waƙar Clark, wanda ya kuma yabon cewa daga baya ya fi dacewa da waƙar Per Per Per Per, ya sananne, ya sanannun sautin da shi a kan waƙar nan kuma ya zama "Mill ya zama mafi kyau"

## Sauran bayyanar
"Here Without You" an haɗa shi a cikin kundin tarin Byrds da yawa. An haɗa shi a cikin akwatin da aka saita a shekara ta 2006 *Akwai Lokaci*. An haɗa wani nau'i *A farkon*, a cikin kundin *Preflyte* na 1969 da kuma kundin In the Beginning na 1988. An kuma haɗa shi a cikin kundin haraji na Byrds ga Gene Clark, Set You Free: Gene Clark a cikin Byrds 1964-1973. 

Richard Thompson, Clive Gregson, da Christine Collister sun rufe "A nan Ba ​​tare da ku" a kan kundin harajin Byrds na 1989 Time Tsakanin - Tarar Ga Byrds Thompson ya kuma haɗa waƙar a cikin kundi na 2003 More Guitar .  Reigning Sound ya fitar da wani nau'in waƙar a kan guda 2001.

An rufe waƙar a cikin fitowar *[[Peter Holsapple]] and Chris Stamey album)">Mavericks* ta 1991, aikin da shugabannin dB Peter Holsapple da Chris Stamey suka yi.

An gama waƙar a ka saki 2000 na Sui Generis, don kundi na haduwa Sinfonías para Adolescentes da ke fitowa a matsayin "Aqui sin tu amor".  Charly Garcia ce ta fassara waƙoƙin tana kiyaye ma'anar waƙar amma ta canza ainihin fassarar.

## Manazarta