Mutuwar Jean Perera Sinnappa

A ranar 6 ga Afrilu 1979, a wani shinge mai zurfi kusa da Filin jirgin saman Subang, **Jean Perera Sinnappa** mai shekaru 31 (26 ga Oktoba 1947 - 6 ga Afrilun 1979), tsohuwar sarauniya mai kyau kuma malami, an same ta da mummunan rauni tare da raunuka masu yawa a kirji kuma har yanzu an ɗaure ta a cikin kujerar motar surukarta. An sami surukin Jean Perera kuma mai sonsa, **Karthigesu Sivapakiam** (ko S. Karthigesu; 23 Maris 1942 - 27 Agusta 2023), yana kwance ba tare da sanin komai ba kusa da wurin aikata laifuka, kuma an kai shi asibiti, inda ya gaya wa 'yan sanda cewa wani ba a san shi ba ne ya buge shi yayin da ya fita daga motar don ya sauƙa kansa, yana mai kisan kai shi ga mutumin da ya kori Karthigesu.

Koyaya, bayan ƙarin bincike, an kama Karthigesu a matsayin wanda ake zargi kuma daga baya aka gurfanar da shi don kisan kai, bisa la'akari da cewa Karthigesu ya kashe Jean Perera saboda kishi game da kasancewar wani masoyi a rayuwar Jean Perera. An sami Karthigesu da laifin kisan kai kuma An yanke masa hukuncin kisa a shekarar 1980, amma bayan wani babban mai gabatar da kara ya yi ikirarin yin ƙarya game da barazanar Karthigesu na kashe Jean Perera, an wanke Karthigesu bayan Kotun Tarayya ta Malaysia ta ba da izinin daukaka kara, kuma daga baya aka daure shaidar saboda rantsuwa. Kisan Jean Perera Sinnappa ya kasance ba a warware shi ba har zuwa yau.

## Binciken kisan kai
A ranar 6 ga Afrilu 1979, injiniyoyin jirgin sama biyu na Malaysia Airlines Teng Hua Kiet da Tan Tiong Keng suna komawa gida bayan sun kammala aikin su a Filin jirgin saman Subang, lokacin da suka yi wani abu mai ban tsoro a kan wani rami mai zurfi wanda ke da nisan kilomita 5 daga filin jirgin sama.&nbsp;

Dukansu Teng da Tan sun gano motar da aka ajiye a kusa da hanya kuma sun ga wani dan Indiya yana kwance ba tare da sanin komai ba (amma har yanzu yana da rai) a kan hanya. Yayin da su biyun suka ci gaba kuma suka kusanci motar, sai suka gano jikin wata mace 'yar Indiya da ke da raunuka da yawa a jikinta kuma har yanzu an ɗaure ta da bel a cikin motar kanta. Matar, mai shekaru 31 mai suna Jean Perera Sinnappa, an sanar da mutuwarta yayin da aka kai mutumin, mai shekaru 36 mai suna Karthigesu Sivapakiam, asibiti. Dukansu Tan da Teng ba su kadai ba ne wadanda suka gano. Sauran shaidu biyu - injiniyan gyare-gyare Cheah Wei Keong da masanin jirgin sama Abdul Wahab Anu Amin - suma sun ga jikin Karthigesu da / ko motar lokacin da suka koma gida daga filin jirgin sama.[1]￼

Binciken gawawwakin da Dr. R. Krishnan (Krishnan Ramanathan) ya yi ya tabbatar da cewa akwai raunuka da yawa a jikin Jean Perera, kuma daga cikin waɗannan raunuka daban-daban, biyu sun isa a cikin al'ada don haifar da mutuwa, yayin da aka kawo ɗaya daga cikinsu a kirji kuma wani ya buga ciki, wanda ya shiga cikin huhu na dama da hanta bi da bi.

Yayinda yake asibiti, Karthigesu, surukin Jean Perera wanda ke da dangantaka ta soyayya da wanda aka azabtar, wanda mijinta ya mutu a shekara ta 1978, ya gaya wa 'yan sanda cewa bayan fita da dare, ya tuka tare da surukinsa har sai da ya tsaya a kan babbar hanyar don ya sauƙaƙe kansa, amma wani ya kori Karthigesu. Koyaya, ba a sami alamun rauni a kai a kan Karthigesu ba yayin kowane gwajin likita. Bayan ci gaba da bincike na wasu kwanaki 20, an kama Karthigesu a matsayin wanda ake zargi, kuma an tuhume shi da kisan kai a ranar 9 ga Mayu 1979. 

Bayanan baya sun nuna cewa Jean Perera, dan asalin Indiya wanda aka haifa a Negeri Sembilan wanda ya yi gasa a gasa da yawa na kyawawan jihohi da na kasa (ciki har da Miss World Malaysia), ya auri Sinnappa Sivapakiam, masanin sunadarai wanda ɗan'uwan Karthigesu ne. Sinnappa ya mutu daga hatsarin mota a ranar Sabuwar Shekara a shekara ta 1978; wurin hatsarin mota ya kasance kusa da inda aka kashe Jean Perera. Jean Perera, wacce ta zama gwauruwa kuma dole ne ta kula da 'ya'yanta uku (waɗanda ta haifa tare da Sinnappa), ta zauna tare da surukarta da Karthigesu, wacce ta kasance malami a ilimin halayyar dan adam a Cibiyar Horar da Malamai ta Musamman a Cheras. Dangantakar soyayya ta bunƙasa tsakanin Karthigesu da Jean Perera bayan wannan ya koma tare da shi da mahaifiyarsa, kuma a lokacin da aka kashe Jean Perera, dukansu sun amince da yin aure. Karthigesu kuma yana son 'ya'yan surukinsa, wadanda dukansu suna kallon shi a matsayin mahaifin maye gurbinsa,  kuma kafin kama shi, Karthigesu ya yi alkawarin kula da' ya'yan Jean Perera. 

## Shari'ar Karthigesu Sivapakiam
A watan Yunin 1980, Karthigesu Sivapakiam mai shekaru 37 ya tsaya a gaban shari'a don kisan Jean Perera Sinnappa . Mataimakin mai gabatar da kara (DPP) T. S. Sambanthamurthi ne ya jagoranci karar, yayin da lauyan tsaro R. Ponnudurai ya wakilci Karthigesu. Wani juriya na maza bakwai da Mai Shari'a Mohamed Azmi na Babban Kotun Kuala Lumpur ne suka jagoranci shari'ar.

A cikin shari'ar kwanaki 38, inda aka kira shaidu 58, shari'ar mai gabatar da kara ita ce Karthigesu ta kashe Jean Perera saboda fushi da kishi bayan ta sami labarin wata dangantakar soyayya da likitan Sri Lanka Narada Warnasurya. Shari'ar ta ba da shaidar wasikun soyayya da yawa da aka musayar tsakanin Dr Narada da Jean Perera a matsayin tabbacin dangantakar sirri tsakanin su biyu. Akwai ƙarin wasika daga Jean Perera zuwa ga likita, wanda ba a taɓa aikawa ba, kuma a cikin wasikar, Jean Perera ya rubuta wa Dokta Narada cewa ta zaɓi ta zauna tare da Karthigesu kuma ba za ta auri Dokta Narana ba, saboda ƙaunar da take yi wa Karthigesu ta fi karfi kuma tana tsammanin sabon makoma tare da Karthiguesu da 'ya'yanta uku (wa waɗanda Karthigesu ya bi da su da kyau).  Daga cikin shaidun masu gabatar da kara, Bandhulanda Jayathilake, dangi na Jean Perera kuma aboki na Karthigesu, ya shaida cewa Karthigesu ya gaya masa cewa Jean Perera ya cancanci ya mutu saboda dangantakar da Jean Perera ta raba da Dokta Narada, wanda ya ki zuwa kotu a matsayin shaida. Adrian De Silva, aboki na wanda aka azabtar, ya shaida cewa ya ga Jean Perera da Karthigesu tare a cikin motansu yayin da yake tuki ya wuce su a kan hanya, jim kadan kafin kisan ya faru.

A cikin karewarsa, Karthigesu ya bayyana cewa bai san da dangantakar soyayya tsakanin Dr Narada da Jean Perera ba har sai an nuna masa wasikun da aka musayar tsakanin su biyu. Ya kuma bayyana cewa a wannan dare kanta, lokacin da ya ajiye motar don ya sauƙaƙe kansa, wani rukuni na maza huɗu ne suka kai masa hari wanda suka tilasta masa ya kalli Jean Perera ana soke shi har ya mutu kuma suka yi masa barazanar kada ya gaya wa 'yan sanda game da su ko kuma za su bi iyalinsa. Har ila yau, masu kare sun yi jayayya cewa Karthigesu bai kashe Jean Perera ba, saboda babu wani jini ko ma wani DNA ko tabo da aka samu a kan tufafin Karthigesu lokacin da aka same shi, kuma motar kanta tana cike da jini da kuma tabo, wanda ba zai yiwu tufafinsa su kasance masu tsabta ba, kuma ba zai yiwu ba Karthigesu ya kashe surukinsa kuma ya tsabtace kansa a cikin gajeren minti 17 kafin a gano jikin wanda aka azabtar. Ng Kwai Yew, wani mai shaida don karewa, ya bayyana cewa yana tuki a kan hanya kuma ya ga motoci biyu da aka ajiye a gefen hanya inda aka sami Jean Perera an kashe shi, jim kadan kafin a gano jikinta.

A ranar 1 ga watan Agustan shekara ta 1980, bayan sa'o'i hudu da minti goma na tattaunawa, juriya ta dawo tare da hukuncin su. Ta hanyar yanke shawara mafi rinjaye na biyar zuwa biyu, juriya ta sami Karthigesu da laifin kisan Jean Perera kuma ta ba da shawarar hukuncin kisa. Mai shari'a Mohamed Azmi ya yarda da hukuncin juriya kuma ya yanke masa hukuncin kisa, kuma ya yanke shi hukuncin kisa ta hanyar ratayewa.

## Cutar da aka yi wa Karthigesu
Yayinda yake kan layin mutuwa a gidan yarin Pudu, Karthigesu ya daukaka kara game da hukuncin da aka yanke masa. Yayinda ake jiran roko na Karthigesu a gaban Kotun Tarayya ta Malaysia, a cikin wani gagarumin canji na abubuwan da suka faru, Bandhulanda Jayathilake, mai gabatar da kara wanda ya ba da muhimmiyar shaidar da ta tura Karthigesu zuwa layin mutuwa, ya furta cewa ya yi ƙarya a ƙarƙashin rantsuwa game da Karthigesu yana barazanar kashe Jean Perera kuma ya yi ƙarya game da Karthigesu don aikata laifin. An ba da izini ga kotun don gabatar da ƙarin shaida daga Jayathilake, wanda ya sake ba da shaida cewa ya yi ƙarya ga kotun shari'a game da sa hannun Karthigesu a cikin laifin, kuma ya nuna yatsunsu ga dangin Jean Perera da suka mutu a matsayin waɗanda suka sa ya yi ƙarya.

Kodayake mai gabatar da kara ya bayyana cewa alƙalin bai yi kuskuren juriya ba kuma ya nemi Kotun Tarayya ta tabbatar da hukuncin ko kuma ta ba da umarnin sabon shari'a, mai kare ya yi jayayya cewa tare da shaidar da Jayathilake ya bayar da aka ɗauka ba daidai ba, juriya ba za ta sami isasshen shaidar da za ta yi la'akari da hukuncin laifi ga Karthigesu ba, kuma kara da cewa sake shari'a zai haifar da ba lallai ba don ci gaba da sake shari'ar yayin da sake shariʼa ba a sake tabbatar da ita ba tare da ita ba, shaidar da ita ba ta kasance mai ƙarfi, shaidar Jayatke.

A ranar 31 ga Mayu 1981, Kotun Tarayya ta ba da izinin daukaka kara ta Karthigesu kuma ta ba shi cikakken wankewa daga zargin kisan kai. Alƙalai uku na daukaka kara - Hashim Yeop Sani, Wan Suleiman da Abdul Hamid - sun gano cewa babu isasshen shaida don haɗa Karthigesu a matsayin mai kisan shari'ar, musamman tun lokacin da aka janye shaidar Jayathilake a shari'ar kuma an gano cewa an yi ta ƙarya a ƙarƙashin rantsuwa. An ruwaito cewa Karthigesu ya sami sauki a lokacin da aka wanke shi, wanda aka yaba da shi a cikin kotun da ke cike da mutane, kuma ya rungumi lauyansa R. R. Chelliah (wanda ya wakilce shi a cikin roko) kuma ya mika hannu tare da mai gabatar da kara T. S. Sambanthamurthi .   Ya kuma bayyana cewa yana da kyau ya kasance a gida bayan danginsa da abokansa sun maraba da shi.

An ruwaito cewa, lokacin da mahaifiyar Jean Perera ta ji cewa Jayathilake tana sanya wa iyalinta yatsan hannu a matsayin wanda ya sanya shi a cikin yin ƙarya, ta firgita kuma ta bayyana cewa ba ita ko 'yan iyalinta ba su umarci Jayathilaque da ta gabatar da shaidar ƙarya a cikin tsara Karthigesu don kisan, kuma ta bayyana a matsayin cewa ba su da wani abu game da Karthigesu, saboda ba su so wani mutum marar laifi ya mutu kuma su bar shi ga kotuna don yanke shawara kan ko Karthigesu yana da laifi ko a gaskiya ko a'a.

## Tabbacin ƙarya na Bandhulanda Jayathilake
Wani lokaci bayan da aka wankewa Karthigesu, a ranar 17 ga Yulin 1981, an same Bandhulanda Jayathilake mai shekaru 35 da laifin yin rantsuwa kuma Kotun Koli ta Kuala Lumpur ta yanke masa hukuncin shekaru goma a kurkuku, saboda haka ya zama mutum na farko a duk Malaysia da za a yanke masa hukunci saboda yin rantsuwa a cikin shari'ar kisan kai. 

An ruwaito cewa Jayathilake ya gabatar da dogon roƙo na ragewa, kuma an gabatar da wasika da aka ruwaito ta Karthigesu a kotu, tare da lauyan Jayathilaque yana karanta shi kuma yana bayyana cewa marubucin bai dauki wani mummunan niyya a kan Jayathilahe ba duk da abin da ya faru. Koyaya, Mai Shari'a Ajaib Singh ya bayyana cewa Jayathilake dole ne ya faɗi gaskiya a ƙarƙashin rantsuwa yayin da yake tsaye, amma ayyukansa sun kasance rashin girmama rantsuwar da kuma cin mutunci ga gudanar da adalci, kuma da gangan ya yaudari juri da alƙali don yanke hukunci ga mutum marar laifi na kisan kai, kuma ya haifar da mummunar lalacewa ga hanyar adalci da tsarin shari'a. Da yake nuna yarda da Jayathilake na samun ƙarfin hali don faɗin gaskiya daga lamiri, Mai Shari'a Singh ya bayyana cewa Jayathilaque ya kamata ya yi amfani da irin wannan ƙarfin hali don fuskantar da ɗaukar sakamakon ayyukansa.[undefined][1]￼

An yi watsi da roko na Jayathilake a ranar 23 ga Satumba 1981, bayan Kotun Tarayya ta Malaysia ta bayyana cewa Jayathilaque ya nuna rashin kula da gaskiya kuma ya gargadi shi don yin aiki da mugunta da karkatar da hanyar adalci ta hanyar ba da shaidar ƙarya a cikin shari'ar da za a rataye wani mutum marar laifi kamar Karthigesu saboda babban zargi kamar kisan kai. Koyaya, Jayathilake ya mutu a 1983 yayin da yake yin hukuncin shekaru goma. 

## Manazarta