Kisan Elaine O'Hara

**Elaine O'Hara** (17 Maris 1976 -  22 Agusta 2012) ma'aikaciyar kula da yara ce ta Irish wacce masanin gine-gine Graham Dwyer ya kashe ta a watan Agustan 2012. An gan ta na karshe da rai a wani wurin shakatawa na jama'a a Shanganagh, Dublin, Ireland, a ranar 22 ga watan Agusta. An gano ragowar jikinta a Dutsen Killakee, kudu da Dublin, a watan Satumbar 2013. Binciken bacewarta da kuma daga baya mutuwar ta an bayar da rahoton ko'ina. 

Shari'ar 2015 da kuma yanke hukunci na Dwyer ya haifar da yaduwar shaidu game da sa hannun O'Hara da Dwyer a cikin al'adun jima'i na BDSM. Shaidar ayyukan jima'i na Dwyer ya haifar da kisan da ake kira daya daga cikin manyan laifuka a tarihin Irish.

Wani roko da Dwyer ya yi, wanda ya yi tambaya game da tushen doka don riƙe bayanan wayar hannu (wanda aka yi amfani da shi a cikin shari'ar da aka yi masa), Kotun Shari'a ta Tarayyar Turai (CJEU) ta amince da shi. Sakamakon wannan yanke shawara an bayyana shi kamar yadda yake da yiwuwar "matsananciyar tasiri ga binciken manyan laifuka a duk faɗin Turai",  kuma ya ba da tushe don ƙarin roko daga Dwyer.  Dwyer ya rasa roko da yawa, a duka Kotun daukaka kara da kuma Kotun Koli, tare da yanke hukunci tare da cewa shaidar da aka samo daga bayanan wayar hannu ta dace a shari'arsa ta asali.

## Tarihi
An haifi Elaine O'Hara a Dublin a ranar 17 ga Maris 1976 kuma ta yi karatu a makarantar sakandare ta St. Joseph na Cluny .  An zalunta ta a makaranta. Tana da matsalolin lafiyar kwakwalwa da yawa tun tana matashiya, kuma ana kwantar da ita a asibiti akai-akai don kula da lafiyar kwakwalwa. Farfesa Anthony Clare ne ya kula da ita, wanda ya gano baƙin ciki da rikicewar halin mutum. Ta kuma sami asma, Ciwon sukari, da dyslexia. Mutuwar mahaifiyarta a shekara ta 2002 babbar matsala ce a gare ta, kamar yadda mutuwar kwatsam ta Farfesa Clare a shekara ta 2007.

A shekara ta 2005, ta ƙaura daga gidan iyalinta a Killiney zuwa wani gida a Blackrock .  A shekara ta 2008, ta koma wani gida a Blackrock, kafin ta sami gidaje masu araha a Belarmine Plaza, Stepaside .  O'Hara ta yi aiki a matsayin mataimakiyar kula da yara a Ballybrack kuma na ɗan lokaci a cikin kantin labarai a Blackrock .  Tana karatun dare a garin Dún Laoghaire  tare da fatan zama malamin Montessori. 

### Bacewa
O'Hara ta ɓace daga gidanta a ranar 22 ga watan Agusta 2012,  kuma da farko an ɗauka cewa ta ɓace yayin da take ba da gudummawa a 2012 Tall Ships' Races . A cikin gidanta, duk da haka, ta bar jakarta, jaka, da wayar hannu, kuma hotunan tsaro sun nuna ta barin gidanta da wayar daban. Wani mai tsere ne ya gan ta na karshe a Shanganagh Park a cikin gundumar Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown kawai a kudancin Shankill .  Daga baya aka tabbatar da cewa ta tafi Kabari na Shanganagh, inda aka binne mahaifiyarta. Wani shaida ya ji wata mace tana kuka da ƙarfi a cikin kabari. Shaidar ta ga matar, ta dace da bayanin O'Hara gabaɗaya, tana kuka a gefen tsohuwar kabari, amma ba ta iya gane ta a matsayin O'Hora ba. Daga baya aka gano motarta a kusa, kuma an ɗauka cewa, saboda tarihin tunanin ta, ta kashe kanta ta hanyar tsalle daga dutsen da ke kusa.

### Binciken shaidu
A ranar 10 ga Satumba 2013, kwana uku kafin gano jikin O'Hara, masu kamun kifi William Fegan, ɗan'uwansa, da wani mutum sun hango jaka da ke kwance a cikin ruwa a cikin Vartry Reservoir, kusa da Roundwood, County Wicklow .  Yawancin lokaci, zurfin ruwa a gadar inda aka sami shaidar ya kasance   zuwa  , amma a cikin 2013, bayan dogon lokacin zafi, ya kasance mai zurfi kamar 12 inci (30  zuwa 18 inci (46 , yana fallasa abubuwan da in ba haka ba za su kasance a ƙarƙashin farfajiya. A cikin jaka sun sami ƙuƙwalwar hannu, tufafi, ƙuƙwalwa, ƙuɓɓugar ƙafar ƙafa.

Kashegari, Fegan ya ba da abubuwan da ya samu zuwa tashar Roundwood Garda. Garda James O'Donoghue ya gudanar da bincike da yawa a wurin kuma a ranar 16 ga Satumba ya sami hannaye, makullin, abin rufe fuska na fata, wuka, inhaler da sarkar da ke da zobe a kai. An gano katin aminci na Dunnes Stores da aka samu a haɗe da maɓallin a matsayin na O'Hara.  Garda Water Unit ta bincika tafkin a ranar 17 ga Satumba da 7 ga Oktoba 2013, inda ta sami wayoyin hannu na Nokia guda biyu, batirin wayar hannu guda biyu, tabarau da tabarau na rana, da kuma jakar hannu. Adadi a kan firam na tabarau da takardar magani sun dace da bayanan O'Hara da aka gudanar a fayil a reshe na Specsavers a Dún Laoghaire . 

### Binciken jiki
Mai horar da karnuka Magali Vergnet a kai a kai yana tafiya da karnuka a kan ƙasar da ke kusa da Kilakee a ƙarƙashin tuddai na Dutsen Dublin.  Farawa a ranar 21 ga watan Agustan shekara ta 2013, daya daga cikin karnukanta zai ɓace a kai a kai kuma ya dawo tare da wasu ƙasusuwa yayin tafiya, wanda Vergnet da farko ya yi imanin cewa daga dabba ne. A ranar 13 ga Satumba 2013, wannan kare ya sake dawo da ƙarin ƙasusuwa, a wannan lokacin tare da tufafi. Da yake damuwa cewa waɗannan na iya zama ɗan adam, sai ta tuntubi mai mallakar ƙasa, Frank Doyle .  Sun koma ƙasar tare da wani mutum kuma a cikin wani fili mai nisa, sun sami ƙasusuwa da aka warwatsa kuma sun yi ƙusa, gami da ragowar haƙarƙari da ƙashin ƙashi. Da suka fahimci cewa gawar mutum ne, sai suka tuntubi Gardaí. Kashi 65 cikin 100 ne kawai na kwarangwal da aka gano. Daga baya aka gano jikin O'Hara ta hanyar bayanan hakora.

## Bincike
'Yan sanda sun gano cewa a ƙarshen 2007, O'Hara ya ziyarci gidan yanar gizon jima'i na manya Alt.com a ƙarƙashin sunan bayanan helpmelearn36/F kuma ya kalli bayanin martaba na architect72, wanda ke da alaƙa da adireshin Gmail mai suna fetishboy . [1] 'Yan sanda sun haɗa waɗannan da Graham Dwyer, masanin gine-gine.[2][3] Shaidar ta fito cewa Dwyer da O'Hara sun fara jima'i wanda ya haɗa da bautar, tashin hankali da wuƙaƙe.[4] Dangantakar ta kasance mai tsanani a cikin shekara ta 2008. An samo bidiyon jima'i na gida da raguwar imel daga kwamfyutocin su.[1]￼

Dangantakarsu ta ragu, amma an sake farfadowa a watan Maris na shekara ta 2011 lokacin da Dwyer ya tuntubi O'Hara ta hanyar wayar hannu da aka riga aka biya. Dwyer yana da lambar wayar hannu wanda ya fara da 083, kuma shi da O'Hara suna da wayoyin hannu tare da lambobi waɗanda suka fara 086. Rubutun da aka dawo da su, daga wayoyin Nokia da aka watsar, amma har yanzu suna aiki, wanda Dwyer ya aiko (a ƙarƙashin sunan "Master") zuwa O'Hara (a matsayin "Bawa") a wannan lokacin sun haɗa da:

## Manazarta