Title: Ethics for Adversaries
First published: 1999
Description: Ethics for Adversaries is a philosophical inquiry into arguments that are offered to defend seemingly wrongful actions performed by those who occupy what Montaigne called "necessary offices.".

Applbaum begins by examining the career of Charles-Henri Sanson, who is appointed executioner of Paris by Louis XVI and serves the punitive needs of the ancien regime for decades. Come the French Revolution, the King's Executioner becomes the king's executioner, and he ministers with professional detachment to each defeated political faction throughout the Terror and its aftermath.

By exploring one extraordinary role and the arguments that can be offered in its defense, Applbaum raises unsettling doubts about arguments in defense of less sanguinary professions and their practices.

To justify harmful acts, adversaries appeal to arguments about the rules of the game, fair play, consent, the social construction of actions and actors, good outcomes in equilibrium, and the legitimate authority of institutions. Applbaum concludes that these arguments are weaker than supposed and do not morally justify much of the violation that professionals and public officials inflict.

Institutions and the roles they create ordinarily cannot mint moral permissions to do what otherwise would be morally prohibited.
Subjects: Ethics, Adversary system (Law), Professional ethics, Political ethics, Morale des affaires, Politieke ethiek, Éthique du travail, Éthique médicale, Système accusatoire (Droit), Morale, Système accusatoire et système inquisitoire, Juristes, Morale politique, Déontologie professionnelle, Beroepsethiek, Déontologie, Politique et morale
LC classification: BJ1031 .A65 1999