Essays in development economics
By: by Sandip Rajeev Sukhtankar
Contributors: John F. Kennedy School of Government
Published: 2009
Language: eng
Number of pages: 124
Subjects: Development economics; Economic Policy; Politics and government
Description: This dissertation consists of three essays on the economics and politics of developing countries. The first essay examines the effect of political connections on firm outcomes. Political control of firms is prevalent across the world. While there is evidence that firms benefit from political connections, we know less about whether politicians profit from control over firms. I investigate whether and how politicians use firms to further their electoral goals, examining sugar mills in India--many of which have chairmen who are politicians. I find evidence of embezzlement in politically controlled mills during election years, which is reflected in lower reported output and/or lower input prices paid to farmers for cane. Misappropriation of mill resources might represent either pure theft, or indirect campaign contributions for which farmers receive compensation in later years. To distinguish between these interpretations, I examine whether farmers are recompensed after elections. I find that farmers receive higher cane prices after mill chairmen win elections, as well as when the mill chairman's party controls the state government. This result suggests that at least some of the theft is returned in the form of higher prices and may help explain why farmers would be willing to continue supporting politicians who engage in embezzlement.

The second essay studies dynamic incentives for corruption in one of the world's largest public transfer programs, India's National Rural Employment Guarantee Act. We uncover large-scale embezzlement along multiple margins: theft from beneficiaries and theft from taxpayers. Using exogenous changes in statutory wages, we then test a simple, dynamic model of rent extraction. We find evidence for a "golden goose" effect: when expected future opportunities for rent extraction are high, officials extract less rent today in order to preserve tomorrow's opportunities. This behavioral response tends to stabilize levels of corruption in the face of external shocks. The third essay examines the effect of ownership structure on farmer outcomes. The promotion of agricultural cooperatives has been an integral part of developing country governments' efforts to develop rural areas, yet whether governments should subsidize and promote cooperatives is an empirical question that has yet to be convincingly answered. This paper seeks to answer part of this question by examining the effect that different ownership structures have on the outcomes of sugarcane farmers in India. It exploits the zoning system--whereby farmers living within a zone are forced to sell sugar to the mill designated to that zone--to estimate this effect, by surveying farmers at the boundaries of the zones. I find that private mills encourage sugarcane production, but also draw in marginally poorer farmers. Farmers on the private mill side of the borders appear to invest less in cane development and have lower cane yields. Whether this is due to the composition of farmers or cooperative mill cane development efforts is unclear.
Notes: "May 2009."

Dissertation advisor: Sendhil Mullainathan.

Disservation acceptance certificate signed by: Sendhil Mullainathan, Rohini Pande, Andrei Shleifer.

Thesis (Ph.D., Granted by the Committee on Higher Degrees in Political Economy and Government)--Harvard University, 2009.

Includes bibliographical references.