scipy-conference/SciPy-2014 — pull request #103 by codersquid (2014-04-03 14:15:10+00:00)
Title: provide more detailed review instructions with link to google form

I've copied the template over from the default symposion template and customized it with this content:

For this year's conference we are collecting reviewer comments at this google form, SciPy2014 Submission Reviews

At the form, please be prepared to rank these questions on scales from 1 to 10.

Applicability: How applicable is this submission to a General Track or Mini-Symposum Theme?

Novelty: How new and interesting is this submission?

General Impression: Does this paper concisely describe software of interest to the SciPy community, tools or techniques for more effective computing, or how scientific Python was applied to solve a research problem?

General Impression: Does it have a traditional background/motivation, methods, results, and conclusion structure?

General Impression: Does it optionally give links to project websites, source code repositories, figures, full papers, and evidence of public speaking?

At the form, please be prepared to provide these comments.

Comments for the author: Please include any responses and recommendations that should be communicated to the author if this submission is invited.

Comments for the Program Committee Chairs: What information would help us to correctly place this submission?

Your votes and comments are not public and will only be viewable by other reviewers.