maqetta/maqetta — Issue #1885: Major issues with Review and Commenting
Author: aerwin
Created: 2012-03-09 00:46:03+00:00
State: open
Labels: Priority High, Review and Commenting

With Chrome and lab9:50010, I'm seeing many issues with review and commenting. I almost think multi-user review and commenting is fairly well broken, so I'm going to list a few issues in this report. If we need separate issues as we investigate, I can open those.

1. User B's comments are not saved. (At first I thought maybe just User A couldn't see UserB's comments, but if I add some comments as UserB and then open/close the review as User B, none of the comments have been saved.)

Of course, # 1 is a show stopper and maybe make these irrelevant for now, but I also see:

2. User B can edit User A's comments, but not his own.
3. User B's comments are same color as User A's comments

Also... With Chrome and lab9:50020, there are no reviews in my Reviews tab despite having created a few. Thought I saw this on lab9:50010 at least once as well, but I think logging in and out fixed it.