petdance/scratch — Issue #692: Add a vtable function to get arithmetic mode
Author: petdance
Created: 2011-11-14 06:01:35+00:00
State: open
Labels: core, Pri-normal, rfc, Sev-medium

After talking with Allison yesterday, I would like to suggest that we add a new VTABLE_get_numeric_mode(). This VTABLE would return a flag value to determine whether the PMC should be treated as an INTVAL or a FLOATVAL in an arithmetic calculation.
Currently we have a large series of mathematics vtables that are called from the math.ops. These mathematics vtables allow the PMC to determine how it participates in the operation. The downside to this setup is that we need a large number of vtables for all supported operations.

For every operation where we do not have a corresponding vtable, we must decide whether to treat the PMC as an INTVAL or a FLOATVAL, a decision which is going to create problems for some types.

Having a VTABLE interface that allows the PMC type to describe whether it is int-like or float-like will allow us to encapsulate more operations better, and make better decisions in more situations. Also, it will allow us to slim down the VTABLE structure to remove a few operations which are rarely used except in numerical types and only to make these decisions for us.

Alternatively to a new VTABLE function, we could have some sort of flag mechanism in the VTABLE structure and check it with a macro.

I suggest we need at least three outcomes: A PMC is either int-like, float-like, or non-numeric. Attempting to perform a non-overridden math op on a non-numeric PMC could throw a meaningful error instead of just falling back to the implementation in default.pmc.

Opinions and comments much appreciated

Originally http://trac.parrot.org/parrot/ticket/1433