G'day guys welcome back to my YouTube channel now today. I'm going to be ranking AFL commentators on Tiermaker. I did this about two years ago, so I thought I would do an updated version. I went on to Tiermaker.com and saw that there was one there, made by Riles Macker. Believe he makes YouTube videos as well, so get around his channel and support the great man. But anyway, let's get into the video and ranks an AFL commentator. But James Brayshore for me is one of the goats. Could be a little bit controversial. He's quite, he's quite take the piss at times, but I think his commentator voice is just unbelievable. I think his voice is probably what separates him from the rest and just some of the funny things it comes out of his mouth. I really rate Jimmy Brayshore. Bruce, I think, should be one of the goats, but for me he's fantastic. He's not. I understand that he's like one of the OG goats. Like he's one of the greatest commentators of all time. But for me in terms of personal taste, I have him just below James Brayshore. Luke Darcy is solid. He's a little bit annoying at times, Darcy. Luke Darcy, I think, started off as special comments and he's slowly but surely gone into more of the commentary and I don't think it suits him that well, but yeah, I've put Luke Darcy in solid. Hey, Mish, I'll put in solid as well. I think he sometimes tries to do the Dennis Committee analogies, but they seem more pre-written. Like Dennis Committee would just pop him off his head, but Hamish McLaughlin sort of has these one lineers that seem pre-meditated and it comes across a little bit forced for mine. Now, BT, I don't know where I had him a couple of years ago. I reckon he would have been up near the top. I loved him, but I think he's been, he's lost and he's lost the plot, BT. I think he's out of form. I'm almost gonna put BT in solid. I think he's lost a bit of his swagger or something or maybe he's just tried to go too far, comical, but he makes mistakes left, right, in the middle of the night and he says some bizarre stuff when you commentate, so I'm probably gonna put BT in solid, I'll be interested to see where I had him last time. Dermy, I don't want to do it to you, Dermy, but I think you're a little bit below average. I like listening to Dermy on the first crack. I like him talking about football, but in terms of commentating the game, he's not one of my favourites. Eddie McGuire, I think, is in fantastic. I think Eddie McGuire's commentary is underrated. He's so good to listen to. And there's nothing better than when you tune in and he's half whipping home your side. He sometimes gets behind sides and especially if it's an underdog or a young side coming up, he'll really get behind him and really get you excited for your team. So fair play to Ed. I'll put him in fantastic. Steven Quattamane, for me back in the day, Channel 10 was one of the goats. I loved Quattamane. Leo Barry U star, people power has spoken. I reckon Steve Quattamane is really, really up there in terms of commentary. No, I fenced a Nikki Dale, but I don't really like listening to Nikki Dale necessarily. Joey Montagna, a little bit annoying as well. He does the commentary play by play. I think his voice is a little bit annoying. I do like Joey Montagna on AFL360 and whatnot though. I think he's quite clever and quite good. So not counting him out necessarily, but yeah, I've probably put Joey Montagna in decent. Richo, for me, I reckon is great on the special comments. I absolutely love Richo. I love his passion for the tides, but yeah, I just think Richo's really, really solid on the special comments. So I'm going to put him in goat status as one of best. Nick Reewalt, as good as it gets on special comments for mine. Really, really, really good, Nick Reewalt. Howie, I think howie's solid. Gary Lyon for mine is one of the best special comments people in the league. He's one of the smartest football minds you'll ever listen to when him, John, and then Brown and Nick Reewalt on Friday nights on Fox footy is just so, so good to listen to. Jason Bennett is in fantastic. He's really, really solid. Jason Bennett and he's been getting some more AFL gigs recently, which is awesome. Daisy Pierce, I think, is arguably in the top echelon of special comment. And I'll put it in there. Yep, I was going to put it down one run, but I think she's one of the best special comments people out there as well. I think Daisy Pierce is unbelievable to listen to. Callie Underwood, I think, is decent. She gets a bit of a bad rap. I think her voice is good. Like, people sort of can be negative on her voice, but I think her footy-commentating voice is good. It's quite passionate and gravely at times. And I like that. It's just some of the things she says can be a little bit corny, sort of in the Hamish McLaughlin category a little bit, but Cosy Pickett kicked the girl and she goes, Cosy, the Mossy. And I was like, oh, that's a bit odd. But yeah, I don't dislike Callie Underwood, but I got her in decent. Wayne Carey, I think, is really, really good on the special comments. I really rate listening to the duck. I think he's funny on Triple M. So I've got, yeah, Wayne Carey right up there. Dennis Committee, he almost, he's got to be in goat category, doesn't he? He's probably got to be right up there. In terms of as good as it gets. Tim Watson, I think, is great. Yeah, Tim Watson's in fantastic. Very, very solid water. Tim Watson seems to have great rapport with anyone. He's great with Gary Lyne in the mornings on SCN and he's really, really good on the pre show on Sunday, Avow Footy. So Tim Watson is solid as a rock. Mark Rashudo, he's okay, he's very, very biased. I think some of his takes on Triple M Adelaide, just paying average, he'll pop players. He's never the bigger man, Mark Rashudo, in some of his stashes. He likes to dip his tail in it. So, oh, yeah, I'll probably got him in decent. Dwayne Russell is one of Connor Rogers' favourites and he's had some arguably very memorable lines. Oh baby, and that's gone class. Sort of stuff from Dwayne Russell. Remember the name. I'm gonna put Dwayne Russell in fantastic. Andy Mah is in fantastic, very solid operator. Andy Mah, a very smooth operator. He never says, um, he never says, ah, every word he says, he never studies. I think Andy Mah's brilliant in the media. Very good on front bar. He's very good in that comedic sense. It can bounce off anyone really, really well. So I've got Andy Mah right up there. Hado, great Hudson. Everyone froths Hado. He's sort of everyone's favourite commentator at the minute. I've got him one round below some of these guys. I think he's pretty good at summing up the moment. He's actually very good at summing up the moment. But it's probably not my favourite voice to listen to. But that's just my personal opinion. He's a very, very good commentator here than he had. And I once got him to sign my cap at Simmons to Hado. Back in the day. Hodgy, I reckon, solid. He can sometimes butcher people's names, which is quite funny. But whenever Hodgy says anything football related, it's very, very smart. And I like when Hodgy stands up to BT. BT can say some weird things on the telecast and Hodgy will pull him up. So I sort of like that. Chief Dunstle almost up there. As good as it gets really. I love the big Chiefton. Jared Healy. Solid. Brad Johnson. Decent. He's a bit of an odd operator. Brad Johnson. Always smiling, always happy. But I've got, yeah. John O'In the Decent category. Jordan Lewis. I love Jordan Lewis. But when I listen to his special comments, I think he's not quite there yet, Jordan Lewis. So I'm going to put him in below average. Probably a little bit harsh for Louis. Abbey Holmes, I've got him fantastic. Initially when Abbey Holmes started, the boundary writing I thought she was very clunky. Some of her questions were a little bit off. But in the last couple of years, she's really come into her own. And I think she's fantastic on the telecast. And whether she's doing Friday nights or Sunday Arvo, or whatever, I reckon Abbey Holmes is becoming one of the better boundary writers. Lingy, Lingy cops it. I'm going to put Lingy in solid. I think Lingy, BT and Dars, sort of some upset day at night football. And I liked back in the day when they'd all just have good rapport together. And I know Lingy can sometimes say obvious stuff in his special comments. But I think he's pretty harmless. He doesn't really have an ego. Like some of these guys have a real thick ego that can come across a little bit off putting. Lingy doesn't have an ego. He's quite harmless on the commentary. You can just say some things that are probably a little bit too obvious. But I don't mind Lingy. John of them Brown, I think, is in fantastic. I love Brownie. He's very, very good. As I said, with Nick Reewalt and Gary Lyon on the Friday night football. And then David King, if I had done this a couple of years ago, I reckon I would have put him right down because he would come out with weird headlines about three or four years ago. He'd come out with some weird sort of cane corns, click baity stuff. But I think he's come into his own and sort of chilled out a little bit, David King. And I like his analysis on AFL 360. He breaks down things as good as anyone else in the game. It's saying that I'm probably just gonna put King in solid. All right guys, that's it for my tier list of media personalities. All of these obviously in my opinion and you guys are entitled to your own. So comment down below if you think you would have changed anything. That's it for another video guys. I appreciate the support. I appreciate everyone watching and I'll see you all very soon for some more content. Thank you.