I saw you posting a link to a study suggesting that a lot of the the way that it's talked about has been over hyped. What do you what do your beliefs about? Well I spent a lot of time I don't really have beliefs about climate change I wouldn't say I mean I think the climate is probably warming but it's been warming since the last ice age so I don't know which one would be accelerated in the last half of the decade. Yeah maybe possibly it's not so obvious I spent quite a bit of time going through the relevant literature I I read about 200 books on ecological what do you call it? On ecology and economy when I work for the UN for about a two-year period and it's not so obvious what's happening just like with any complex system. The problem I have fundamentally isn't really the climate change issue it's that I find it very difficult to distinguish valid environmental claims from environmental claims that are made as what would you call it secondary anti-capitalist front essentially.