Twenty-sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution

The Twenty-sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution (Amendment XXVI) lowered the minimum voting age in the United States from 21 to 18.

The United States Congress approved the amendment on March 23, 1971, and sent it to the states to be ratified.  Within three months and eight days, the states had ratified the amendment, and it became part of the Constitution.  This was the quickest amendment to be ratified in United States history.

Text

Background

Earlier legislation
Lowering the minimum voting age was not a new idea.  In the United States, some people started trying to get the voting age lowered during World War II.  During the war, President Franklin D. Roosevelt lowered the military draft age to 18.  This meant that men as young as 18 could be forced to join the military.  To many people, it did not seem fair that the government thought these young men were old enough to fight a world war, but not old enough to vote in the country they were fighting for.  "Old enough to fight, old enough to vote" became a common slogan.

United States Senator Harley Kilgore had begun supporting a lowered voting age in 1941.Neale, Thomas H. "Lowering the Voting Age was not a New Idea". In Sylvia Engdahl (ed.) (2010). Amendment XXVI: Lowering the Voting Age. New York: Greenhaven Press. pp. 35-38. . Many other Senators, Representatives, and the First Lady, Eleanor Roosevelt, supported the idea.  However, Congress never made any changes.

Kilgore's ideas did interest some of the states.  In 1943, the Georgia state legislature passed a law lowering the voting age in the state to 18; in 1955, Kentucky did the same thing.

In his State of the Union address in 1954, President Dwight D. Eisenhower became the first president to say publicly that he supported letting people ages 18 and older vote.

In 1963, the President's Commission on Registration and Voting Participation made a report to President Lyndon B. Johnson.  The report encouraged Johnson to lower the voting age.

Support
During the 1960s, many Americans pushed both Congress and the state legislatures to lower the minimum voting age from 21 to 18.  This was mostly because of to the Vietnam War.  As the war went on, more and more people started to protest the war and become active.  During that war, many young men were drafted and sent to fight in the war before they were old enough to vote.  This meant they had no way to influence the people sending them off to risk their lives.  Protesters started to use the slogan "Old enough to fight, old enough to vote" again.

Supporters also argued that the law treated eighteen-year-olds as adults in many other ways.  For example, they had to pay income taxes.  Supporters argued that this was "taxation without representation"  meaning that 18- to 20-year-olds had to pay taxes, but had no say in what those taxes were or what they were spent on, because they could not vote.

In 1967, United States Representative William St. Onge pointed out: ""To tax our 18-, 19-, and 20-year-olds without giving them the right to vote ignores the great rallying cry of our War of Independence that there [should] be 'no taxation without representation.'"

Similarly, in 1970, in a committee that was debating a possible Constitutional amendment to lower the voting age, Representative Thomas Railsback said: ""Our laws tax these 18-year-olds but our voting laws do not permit them representation in enacting that tax law.  The Boston Tea Party was supposed to have been the spark that put that issue to rest in this country."

Opposition
Not everybody supported lowering the minimum voting age.  Opponents to giving younger people the vote had several arguments.  Many argued that teenagers were not mature or responsible enough to vote.Carleton, William G. "Teen Voting Would Accelerate Undesirable Changes in the Democratic Process." In Sylvia Engdahl (ed.) (2010). Amendment XXVI: Lowering the Voting Age. New York: Greenhaven Press. pp. 47-51. .

Other people argued that teenagers did not know enough to have the right to vote.  One historian writes:

Others criticized the "old enough to fight, old enough to vote" argument.  For example, in 1953, the popular magazine Collier's Weekly said this argument "doesn't justify giving young ladies of eighteen the right to franchise [vote]."  They added: "If a man if old enough to vote when he's old enough to fight, then logically the man who is too old to fight out to lose the right to vote."

Another example comes from an editorial written by the New York Times in 1967.  The paper wrote: "The requirements for a good soldier and for a good voter are not the same.  For the soldier, youthful enthusiasm and physical endurance are [of most] importance; for the voter, maturity of judgment far outweighs other qualifications."

Finally, some people thought lowering the voting age was not that important for the country, and that it should be left up to each individual state.

Amending the Voting Rights Act of 1965

In 1970, United States Senators Ted Kennedy and Mike Mansfield suggested changing the Voting Rights Act of 1965 to lower the voting age in the United States.

The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment says that the government has to give every person "the equal protection of its laws." People who supported the addition to the Voting Rights Act of 1965, like Ted Kennedy, said that by not allowing 18- to 20-year-olds to vote, the government not treating them equally by not letting them vote.Kennedy, Senator Edward M. "The Time Has Come to Let Young People Vote." In Sylvia Engdahl (ed.) (2010). Amendment XXVI: Lowering the Voting Age. New York: Greenhaven Press. pp. 56-64. .

President Nixon disagreed with Kennedy. He was not against lowering the voting age. However, he did not agree with Kennedy's legal argument. He also worried that if the Supreme Court thought the new Voting Rights Act was unconstitutional, they could overturn it  cancel the entire law. Nixon thought this could cause a lot of damage to the country.Nixon, President Richard M. "Changing the Voting Age Will Require a Constitutional Amendment." In Sylvia Engdahl (ed.) (2010). Amendment XXVI: Lowering the Voting Age. New York: Greenhaven Press. pp. 70-77. .

However, on June 22, 1970, President Richard Nixon signed an extension (an addition) to the Voting Rights Act of 1965.  The change required the voting age to be 18 in all federal, state, and local elections. After signing the change, Nixon said:

After Nixon signed this change, about 17 states refused to change their minimum voting ages to 18.

Oregon v. Mitchell
After Nixon signed the change to the Voting Rights Act, Oregon and Texas challenged the law in court.  The case, Oregon v. Mitchell, made it to the Supreme Court in October 1970.  This was just four months after Nixon signed the change.  By this time, four states had lowered their minimum voting ages: Georgia, Kentucky, Alaska, and Hawaii.

In Oregon v. Mitchell, the Supreme Court looked at whether the voting age changes that Congress added to the Voting Rights Act were constitutional.  This means they looked at whether the changes agreed with the rules in the Constitution, or broke them.  The judges on the Supreme Court strongly disagreed with each other in this case.  Eventually, five out of the nine judges agreed on a decision - just enough to reach the majority needed for a decision.  However, most of the judges did not agree on which legal reason was behind their decision.

The Court ruled that Congress could set a voting age for federal elections, but not state or local elections.  This meant that for state and local elections, states could keep the voting age at 21 if they wanted to.  However, they would have to keep two different voting registers (lists of people who had signed up to vote): one for federal elections, which would include people as young as 18, and another for state and local elections, which would only include people over age 20.Kilpatrick, James J. "The States are Being Exhorted into Ratifying the Twenty-sixth Amendment." In Sylvia Engdahl (ed.) (2010). Amendment XXVI: Lowering the Voting Age. New York: Greenhaven Press. pp. 123-127. .

The Amendment
After the Supreme Court's decision, both Congress and the states wanted to find a way to lower the minimum voting age throughout the country.  Congress decided to propose a Constitutional amendment that would set the minimum voting age at 18 everywhere in the country.  This would be different than the change to the Voting Rights Act in a few ways.

First of all, the states did not want to deal with the cost and difficulty of having to keep two different voting registers, so they supported the idea of a Constitutional amendment.  Also, when they changed the Voting Rights Act, Congress had made a law about state and local elections without the states having any say.  However, for an amendment to be added to the Constitution, two-thirds of both Houses of Congress, and then three-fourths of the state legislatures, have to agree on it.  (These rules are set out in Article Five of the Constitution.)  An amendment would be something that both Congress and the states agreed on.  Congress would not be over-using its power and breaking the Constitution by making laws for the states.

Opinion polls said that most Americans wanted the Twenty-sixth Amendment to pass.  Younger people were most likely to support the Amendment.  However, even in people over age 50, over half of Americans supported the Amendment.Gallup, George. "The Majority of Americans Favor the Twenty-sixth Amendment." In Sylvia Engdahl (ed.) (2010). Amendment XXVI: Lowering the Voting Age. New York: Greenhaven Press. pp. 128-130. .  Even the New York Times changed its official opinion and supported the Amendment.

Approval by Congress
On March 10, 1971, the United States Senate voted 94–0 in support of proposing an amendment that would lower the minimum voting age to 18 everywhere in the country."Senate Joint Resolution No. 1." In Congressional Record – Senate  (September 16, 2014). United States Government Printing Office. p. S5626. On March 23, the United States House of Representatives voted 401–19 for the amendment.  Congress sent the amendment to the states.

Ratification
For the Twenty-sixth Amendment to be added to the Constitution, three-fourths of the state legislatures (38 out of the 50) would have to ratify the Amendment.  It took just three months for 38 states to ratify the Amendment.  After the Amendment was added to the Constitution, another five states ratified it.  Seven states never did.

The states ratified the Amendment in this order:

 Order State Date 1-5  Connecticut, Delaware, Minnesota, Tennessee, Washington  March 23, 1971 6-7  Hawaii, Massachusetts  March 24, 1971 8  Montana  March 29, 1971 9-11  Arkansas, Idaho, Iowa  March 30, 1971 12  Nebraska  April 2, 1971 13  New Jersey  April 3, 1971 14-15  Kansas, Michigan  April 7, 1971 16-18  Alaska, Maryland, Indiana  April 8, 1971 19  Maine  April 9, 1971 20  Vermont  April 16, 1971 21  Louisiana  April 17, 1971 22  California  April 19, 1971 23-25  Colorado, Pennsylvania, Texas  April 27, 1971 26-27  South Carolina, West Virginia  April 28, 1971 28  New Hampshire  May 13, 1971 29  Arizona  May 14, 1971 30  Rhode Island  May 27, 1971 31  New York  June 2, 1971 32  Oregon  June 4, 1971 33  Missouri  June 14, 1971 34  Wisconsin  June 22, 1971 35  Illinois  June 29, 1971 36-37  Alabama, Ohio  June 30, 1971 38  North Carolina  July 1, 1971 Amendment added to the Constitution: July 1, 1971 39  Oklahoma  July 1, 1971 40-41  Virginia, Wyoming  July 8, 1971 42  Georgia  October 4, 1971 43  South Dakota  March 4, 2014 Never voted on the Amendment Florida, Kentucky, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico, North Dakota, Utah

Ceremony
On July 5, 1971, President Richard Nixon held a ceremony at the White House, where he signed the Twenty-sixth Amendment just to show his support.  (The President does not have to sign an amendment in order for it to be added to the Constitution.)  During the signing ceremony, he talked about his confidence in the United States' young people:

Notes

References

*26
Category:Voting in the United States