Battle of Aachen

The Battle of Aachen was a major battle of Second World War. It was fought by American and German forces in and around Aachen, Germany, between 2–21 October 1944. The city was part of the Siegfried Line, the main defence line on Germany's western border. The Allies had hoped to capture it quickly and move into the Ruhr area.

Most of Aachen's civilian population was moved out before the battle began. Much of the city was destroyed and both sides had heavy losses. It was one of the largest urban battles fought by U.S. forces in World War II.

It was the first city in Germany to be captured by the Allies. The battle ended with a German surrender, but their defense slowed down Allied plans to advance into Germany.

Background
By September 1944 the Western Allies had reached Germany's western border.Ambrose (1997), p. 117 It was protected by the Siegfried Line.Ambrose (1997), p. 132 On 17 September, British, American, and Polish forces launched Operation Market Garden.Ambrose (1998), p. 238

This was an attempt to get around the Siegfried Line by crossing the Lower Rhine River in the Netherlands.Ambrose (1997), p. 118–119  The failure of this plan,Ambrose (1998), p. 247 and a supply problem caused by the long distances,Mansoor (1999), p. 178 stopped the Allied movement toward Berlin.(1999), p. 179

The number of German dead and wounded in France had been high. Field Marshal Walter Model said his 74 divisions had the strength of just 25.Cooper (1978), p. 513 The Western Allies' supply problems gave the Germans time to rebuild their strength.McCarthy & Syron (2002), pp. 219–220 In September, new troops were sent to the Siegfried Line. The total was 230,000 soldiers, including 100,000 new soldiers.Yeide (2005), p. 55

At the start of the month the Germans had had about 100 tanks in the West;Yeide (2005), p. 25 by the end they had 500. As men and equipment were moved into the Siegfried Line they were able to establish a depth of .Yeide (2005), pp. 25–26

The Allied force, under the command of General Dwight D. Eisenhower, wanted to capture the Ruhr. It was Germany's main industrial area.Whitlock (2008), p. 34

General George S. Patton's Third Army was ordered to occupy the French region of Lorraine.Ambrose (1998), p. 249Ambrose (1997), p. 136 General Courtney Hodges's First Army was ordered to attack near Aachen.Mansoor (1999), p. 181

Hodges had at first hoped to go around the city. He thought it was only defended by a small group of troops which would surrender once they were cut off.

The beautiful, old city Aachen was not an important military target, as it did not do much war production. Its population of around 165,000 had not been bombed by the Allies.Ambrose (1997), p. 146

It was an important symbol to the Nazi regime and the German people. It was the first German city threatened by an enemy during the Second World War. It was also the historic capital of Charlemagne, founder of the "First Reich".Whitlock (2008), p. 36; Hitler considered Charlemagne's Holy Roman Empire to be the First Reich. The city was very important to the Germans.Rule (2003), p. 59

The city's defenders fought on home ground for the first time; one German officer said, "Suddenly we were no longer the Nazis, we were German soldiers."Ambrose (1998), pp. 146–147

Aachen was protected by the Siegfried Line, a system of pillboxes, forts, and bunkers protected by anti-tank obstacles and barbed wire.Whiting (1976), p. 28 In several areas, German defenses were over  deep.Whiting (1976), pp. 28–29 It was the strongest defence ever built.Ambrose (1997), p. 144

Learning from their experiences on the Eastern Front, the Germans put their defences in the center of towns. They used narrow streets to make it hard for enemy armored vehicles to move around
.Ambrose (1997), pp. 144–145

Even though the troops defending Aachen and the Ruhr were of low quality, the fortifications protecting Aachen and the Ruhr were a major problem for the
American forces.Combined Arms in Battle Since 1939, pp. 163–164 Getting through Aachen was seen as important, because the land beyond Aachen was flat, and easy for the motorized Allied armies to travel on.Yeide (2005), p. 34


Fighting around Aachen began in the second week of September.Yeide (2005), p. 35 The city was defended by the 116th Panzer Division, under the command of General Gerhard von Schwerin.Whiting (1976), pp. 33–34

The closeness of Allied forces had caused the majority of the city's government officials to leave before the citizens were moved out.Whiting (1976), p. 35 (For this, Hitler had all Nazi officials who had fled sent to the Eastern front as privates.)Ambrose (1998), p. 147 von Schwerin wanted to surrender the city to Allied forces.Whiting (1976), pp. 35–37 However, on 13 September, before he could surrender, he was ordered to launch a counterattack against American forces southwest of Aachen. He attacked with his panzergrenadier forces.Whiting (1976), p. 43

The German general's attempt to surrender the city made Adolf Hitler, ordered the general's arrest. He was replaced by General Gerhard Wilck.Whitlock (2008), p. 37 The United States' VII Corps continued to try to get past German defenses, despite the fighting on 12–13 September.Hitler's Army, pp. 313–314

Between 14–16 September the US 1st Infantry Division advanced against strong defenses and attacks. Eventually, they had a circle around half the city.Hitler's Army, pp. 315–318

This slow advance stopped in late September, due to the supply problem, and the sending of fuel and ammunition for Operation Market Garden in the Netherlands.Hitler's Army, pp. 318–319

Comparison of forces

German defenders in Aachen

In October, Aachen's defense was assigned to General Friedrich Köchling's LXXXI Corps. These forces, along with the attached 506th Tank Battalion and 108th Tank Brigade, had 20,000 men and 11 tanks.Whiting (1976), p. 80  Köchling was also promised a new 116th Panzer Division and the 3rd Panzergrenadier Division, with 24,000 troops.Whiting (1976), p. 81

The 183rd Volksgrenadier Division and 49th Infantry Division defended the northern approaches. The 12th Infantry Division was positioned to the south.Ferrell (2000), pp. 31–32

On 7 October, the 1st SS Panzer Division Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler Panzer Division were sent to defend Aachen.Ferrell (2000), p. 32, claims it was a panzer corps; Whiting (1976), pp. 114–115, clarifies that this was the 1st Panzer Battalion of the 1st SS Panzer Division.

Although new troops continued to arrive, the 12th Infantry Division had lost half its combat strength between 16–23 September, and the 49th and 275th Infantry Divisions had had to be given time to rest.Hitler's Army, p. 320

While German infantry divisions had a strength of 15,000–17,000 soldiers at the start of World War II, this had been reduced to a size of 12,500. By November 1944, the average strength of a division was 8,761 men.Hitler's Army, p. 33Fighting Power, p. 56

To cope with the troop shortages, the Volksgrenadier divisions were created in 1944. Their average total strength was just over 10,000 men per division.Hitler's Army, pp. 33–34 Although about a quarter of these were experienced veterans, two-quarters were new soldiers and sick people while the rest were from the Luftwaffe and Kriegsmarine.Hitler's Army, p. 34

These divisions often received the newest small-arms, but they lacked artillery and motorization.Hitler's Army, pp. 34–35 The 183rd Volksgrenadier Division had not had time to train as a unit.Yeide (2005), p. 59  The 246th Volksgrenadier Division was in a similar situation. Many of its troops had fewer than ten days of infantry training.Yeide (2005), pp. 59–60Yeide (2005), p. 60 All of these weaknesses of the troops were made up for by the strong fortifications surrounding Aachen.Mansoor (1999), p. 182

American forces
The task of capturing Aachen was given to General Charles H. Corlett's XIX Corps' 30th Infantry Division and Joseph Collins' VII Corps' 1st Infantry Division.Rule (2003), p. 60

General Leland Hobbs' 30th Infantry Division would be assisted by the 2nd Armored Division, which would try to go the 30th Division's hole in the Siegfried Line. Their sides were protected by the 29th Infantry Division.Hitler's Army p. 321

In the south, 1st Infantry Division was supported by the 9th Infantry Division and the 3rd Armored Division.Whitlock (2008), pp. 37–38  These divisions took in a large number of new men.Whiting (1976), pp. 76–77

By 1 October over 70% of the men of General Clarence Huebner's 1st Infantry Division were new troops. The last two weeks of September were spent giving these men training in fighting and weapons training.Ambrose (1997), p. 145

The plan called for both infantry divisions to avoid street fighting in Aachen. The plan was for the two divisions to encircle the city. Then a small force would capture it while most of the US forces moved east.

Although American units were usually able to get new troops quickly, the replacements rarely had enough training. Many junior officers were lacked tactical and leadership abilities.Ambrose (1998), p. 260  Some tank drivers had never even driven a car before. Some tank commanders had to teach their men how to load and fire their tank guns in the field before missions.Ambrose (1998), p. 262

The US system meant that new troops reaching the front lines were not properly trained for combat.Ambrose (1998), pp. 262–263  Sometimes half of a unit's replacements would become dead or wounded within the first few days of combat.Ambrose (1998), p. 264

These losses required more troops to be brought into the fighting. A battalion of the US 28th Infantry Division was sent against Aachen to help the US 1st Infantry Division during 18–21 October.Stanton, Shelby, World War II Order of Battle: An Encyclopedic Reference to U.S. Army Ground Forces from Battalion through Division, 1939-1946, Stackpole Books (Revised Edition 2006), p. 105; other details of US unit commitments at Aachen can also be found on pp. 50, 51, and 76 of the same volume.

These forces were supported by the Ninth Air Force, which knew where 75% of the pillboxes were. They planned an opening bombing using 360 bombers and 72 fighters. New aircraft would be used for a second attack, which included napalm.Whiting (1976), p. 82

With the Germans having few anti-aircraft guns and severely limited support from the Luftwaffe, Allied forces controlled the skies over Aachen.Hitler's Army, p. 323

Battle
For six days before the American attack allied artillery bombed German defenses around Aachen.Ambrose (1997), p. 147  Although bombing German LXXXI Corps to stop all movements of troops and supplies, it did not harm the pillboxes and strongpoints.

The opening air bombing on 2 October also did little damage to German defences. The 450 aircraft did not hit any German pillbox.Rule (2003), pp. 60–61  Their targets had been hidden by thick smoke from the Allied artillery.Ambrose (1997), pp. 147–148  After the aircraft finished their bombing, the artillery fired 18,696 shells.Ambrose (1997), p. 148

Advance from the north: 2–8 October
The 30th Infantry Division moved forward on 2 October. They used artillery to destroy German pillboxes. It took thirty minutes to capture a pillbox.Ambrose (1997), pp. 148–149 Heavy fighting had not been expected, and one group lost 87 troops in an hour;Hitler's Army, pp. 323–324 another lost 93 out of 120 soldiers to a German artillery strike.Whiting (1976), p. 89

The attackers were slowly able to cross the Wurm River. They attacked German pillboxes with flamethrowers and explosives.Whiting (1976), pp. 89–90 By the afternoon of 2 October, the 30th Infantry Division had got past German defenses and reached the town of Palenberg.Whitlock (2008), p. 39

Here, US soldiers had to fight to get to each house.Whiting (1976), p. 91 (Private Harold G. Kiner was awarded the Medal of Honor for throwing himself on a German grenade saving the lives of two soldiers).Whitlock (2008), pp. 39–40

Fighting in the town of Rimburg was terrible. American armour could not cross the Wurm River, and it could not support infantrymen who were attacking the Germans.Whiting (1976), pp. 91–92 The 30th Infantry Division destroyed 50 German pillboxes on the first day.Rule (2003), pp. 61–62

The division's advance was helped by the 29th Infantry Division's attacks. The Germans thought that the 29th Division's attacks were the main attack.Rule (2003), p. 62

On the night of 2 October, the German 902nd Assault Gun Battalion was ordered to attack the 30th Infantry Division. Allied artillery made the German attack not start on time. The German attack failed.Hitler's Army, p. 324

American armor could help with the advance on 3 October. The US  attacks were stopped by German attacks. Rimburg was captured on the second day. Fighting had also begun in the town of Übach. American tanks tried to attack the town. However, they could not move due to German artillery fire.

American artillery fire stopped the Germans from recapturing it.Whitlock (2008), p. 40  By the end of the day the 30th Infantry Division had around 300 dead and wounded.Whiting (1976), p. 96


German forces continued their attacks on Übach. This stopped American troops from advancing.Hitler's Army, p. 326  On 4 October the Allies had only captured Hoverdor and Beggendorf. The Americans lost 1,800 soldiers in the past three days.Whiting (1976), p. 98 On 5 October, the 119th Regiment of the 30th Infantry Division captured Merkstein-Herbach.Yeide (2005), p. 68

The next day the Germans attacked Übach, but the attack was not a success.Yeide (2005), p. 70  The American had many more tanks.Whiting (1976), pp. 190–191  The Germans did not have extra troops.Whiting (1976), pp. 102–103 General Koechling did get a Tiger tank group to defend Aachen from the north.Yeide (2005), p. 71

The Germans attacked on 8 October with an infantry regiment, the 1st Assault Battalion, the 108th Panzer Brigade, and 40 armored vehicles.Hitler's Army, p. 327 The left side of the attack cut off an American platoon.Yeide (2005), pp. 71–72Yeide (2005), p. 72 The Germans had many losses and the Americans were getting closer.

Advance from the south: 8–11 October
In the south, the 1st Infantry Division attacked on 8 October. They wanted to capture the town of Verlautenheide.Whiting (1976), pp. 106–108  A big artillery attack helped them to capture the town.Rule (2003), pp. 62–63Whitlock (2008), p. 41

By 10 October, the 1st Infantry Division was in its planned position, where it could join with the 30th Infantry Division.Ferrell (2000), p. 33 The Germans attacked but they ended up with over 40 dead and 35 prisoners.Yeide (2005), p. 76  Despite repeated German attacks, the 1st Infantry Division was able to capture the high land around the city.Yeide (2005), pp. 76–77

On 10 October, the US threatened to bomb the city if it didn't surrender.Whiting (1976), p. 110  The German commander refused to surrender.Whiting (1976), p. 111  American artillery fired  5,000 shells and the city was bombed American aircraft.Whiting (1976), pp. 111-112

Link up: 11–16 October
American dead and wounded were increasing. This was caused by German attacks and the danger of attacking pillboxes.Whiting (1976), pp. 113–114 The   Germans in the town of Bardenberg made pillboxes to defend themselves. American attackers pulled back and shelled the town with artillery.Hitler's Army, p. 329

On 12 October, the Germans attacked the American 30th Infantry Division.Yeide (2005), p. 80 The Americans defended themselves with artillery fire and anti-tank defenses.Yeide (2005), pp. 80–81

At the village of Birk, there was a fight between German tanks and a single American Sherman tank. Then the 2nd Armored Division arrived and the Germans were pushed out of the town.Whiting (1976), pp. 115–116

The 30th Infantry Division had to defend itself over all the land they held.  They were ordered to move south to join with the 1st Infantry Division.Whiting (1976), pp. 117–118 Two infantry battalions from the 29th were sent to join the 30th.Yeide (2005), p. 81


The same day (12 October), two German infantry regiments attempted to recapture. Both regiments were almost completely destroyed.Yeide (2005), pp. 81–82  Between 11–13 October Allied aircraft bombed Aachen.Yeide (2005), p. 82

On 15 October, the Germans again attacked the 1st Infantry Division. Although a number of heavy tanks managed to break through American lines, most of German forces were destroyed by artillery and airplanes.Hitler's Army, p. 331

On the next day, the Germans attacked with the 3rd Panzergrenadier Division. They had heavy losses and they had to stop the attack.Hitler's Army, pp. 331–332

The 30th Infantry Division and parts of the 29th Infantry and 2nd Armored divisions moved southwards between 13–16 October. They could not get through German defenses and join up with allied forces to the south.Hitler's Army, p. 330

The Germans attacked with artillery. German tanks were hidden in houses.Yeide (2005), p. 83  General Hobbs, commander of the 30th Infantry Division, tried to get around the German defenses. He attacked with two infantry battalions.Whiting (1976), pp. 122–123  The attack was a success. The 30th and 1st Infantry Divisions joined up on 16 October.Yeide (2005), p. 87

The fighting had caused American XIX Corps over 400 dead and 2,000 wounded, with 72% from the 30th Infantry Division.Yeide (2005), p. 88  The Germans had 630 of their soldiers killed and 4,400 wounded;Yeide (2005), p. 84 another 600 were killed in the 3rd Panzergrenadier Division's attack on the US 1st Infantry Division on 16 October.Yeide (2005), pp. 87–88

Fight for the city: 13–21 October
The 1st Infantry Division had only a single regiment to capture the city.Combined Arms in Battle Since 1939, p. 164 They attacked with machine guns and flamethrowers. Only by a few tanks and one howitzer were used in the attack.Whitlock (2008), p. 42

The city was defended by 5,000 German troops, including navy, air force and city police.Combined Arms in Battle Since 1939, pp. 164–166  Most of these soldiers lacked experience and training. They were supported by a few tanks and assault guns.Rule (2003), p. 66  However, Aachen's defenders could use the narrow streets to defend the city.

The 26th Infantry's attack on 13 October was stopped by Germans firing from sewers and cellars. Sherman tanks could not move around in the narrow streets.Whiting (1976), pp. 137–139Combined Arms in Battle Since 1939, p. 167 The 26th Infantry Regiment used howitzers to destroy German fortifications.Rule (2003), pp. 66–67Whitlock (2008), pp. 42–43  Sherman tanks were attacked by German anti-tank guns.Whitlock (2008), p. 43

American tanks and other armored vehicles would shoot buildings to kill any defenders hiding inside.Combined Arms in Battle Since 1939, pp. 167–168  German infantry moved through sewers to attack Americans.Yeide (2005), p. 93

The Germans fought very hard.Yeide (2005), p. 92 They attacked the Americans and used armor to stop American movement.'Combined Arms in Battle Since 1939, p. 168

On 18 October, the 3rd Battalion of the 26th Infantry Regiment prepared to attack the Hotel Quellenhof. This was one of the last areas held by the Germans in the city.Whitlock (2008), p. 45  American tanks and other guns fired at the hotel.Whiting (1976), p. 148  That night, 300 new soldiers of the 1st SS Battalion moved into the hotel. They stopped several attacks on the building.Whiting (197), pp. 149–150

A violent German attack managed to get past American infantry companies outside of the hotel. The Germans were then stopped by American mortar fire.Whiting (1976), pp. 151–154

The Americans shelled German positions with  guns.Whiting (1976), p. 176 As well, a battalion of the 110th Infantry Regiment was used to fill gaps in the city. The new battalion was told on 19–20 October to attack the city.

On 21 October, soldiers of the 26th Infantry Regiment captured central Aachen.Stanton, Shelby, World War II Order of Battle: An Encyclopedic Reference to U.S. Army Ground Forces from Battalion through Division, 1939-1946, Stackpole Books (Revised Edition 2006), p. 105 The Germans in the Hotel Quellenhof surrendered, ending the battle for the city.Combed Arms in Battle Since 1939, p. 169

References

Bibliography

Category:1944 in Germany
Aachen
Aachen
Aachen
Category:Aachen
Category:October 1944 events