Film Pertama Terbaik (New York Film Critics Circle Award)

Pemenang 

 1990an 
 Tahun Pemenang Sutradara1997  In the Company of Men  Neil LaBute1998  Love and Death on Long Island  Richard Kwietniowski1999  Being John Malkovich  Spike Jonze

 2000an 
 Tahun Pemenang Sutradara2000  George Washington  David Gordon Green2001  In the Bedroom  Todd Field2002  Roger Dodger  Dylan Kidd2003  American Splendor  Shari Springer Berman dan Robert Pulcini2004  Maria Full of Grace  Joshua Marston2005  Capote  Bennett Miller2006  Half Nelson  Ryan Fleck2007  Away from Her  Sarah Polley2008  Frozen River  Courtney Hunt2009  Hunger  Steve McQueen

 2010an 
 Tahun Pemenang Sutradara2010  Animal Kingdom  David Michôd2011  Margin Call  J. C. Chandor2012  How to Survive a Plague  David France2013  Fruitvale Station  Ryan Coogler2014  The Babadook  Jennifer Kent2015  Son of Saul  László Nemes2016  The Edge of Seventeen  || Kelly Fremon Craig
|-
| Krisha  || Trey Edward Shults
|- 
| align="center"|2017 || Get Out  Jordan Peele

Kategori:New York Film Critics Circle Awards