Tambayar siyasa

A cikin dokar tsarin mulkin Amurka, koyarwar tambayar siyasa ta ɗauka cewa rigimar tsarin mulki da ke buƙatar sanin halin da ba na shari'a ba, dabarun da ba su dace da kotu ba, ko al'amuran da Kundin Tsarin Mulki ya ba wa 'yan majalisar dokoki ko na zartarwa a fili ya ta'allaka ne a fagen siyasa, maimakon shari'a. Alkalai a al'adance sun ƙi yin magana game da batutuwan da suka dace, suna tambayar ko kotunansu ta dace da shari'ar. Tambayoyin shari'a ana ganin sun dace, yayin da tambayoyin siyasa ba su da adalci. Huhn, Wilson R. American Constitutional Law Volume 1. 2016. wani malami ya bayyana cewa:

Koyarwar tambaya ta siyasa ta riki cewa wasu tambayoyi, a yanayin su, siyasa ne na asali, ba na shari'a ba, kuma idan tambaya ce ta asali ta siyasa ... to kotu za ta ki sauraron wannan karar. Zai yi iƙirarin cewa ba shi da hurumi. Kuma zai bar wannan tambayar ga wani bangare na tsarin siyasa don daidaitawa.John E. Finn (2016). "Civil Liberties and the Bill of Rights". The Teaching Company. Part I: Lecture 4: The Court and Constitutional Interpretation (see page 55 in the guidebook)
Asalin
Ana iya gano koyaswar zuwa ga hukuncin Kotun Koli a Marbury v. Madison (1803) [Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803)] A wannan yanayin, Babban Mai Shari'a John Marshall ya bambanta tsakanin aikin shari'a na Sakataren Harkokin Wajen Amurka da kuma ayyuka na siyasa kawai na hankali, wanda kawai wanda ya ƙunshi ƙa'idodin da za a iya gane su ta hanyar doka wanda kotu za ta iya dubawa. § 15 "Case or Controversy"—Political Questions, 20 Fed. Prac. & Proc. Deskbook § 15 (2d ed.) marsahal ya bayar da hujjar cewa bai kamata kotuna su saurari shari'o'in da suka shafi tambayoyin siyasa ba tare da sanya haƙƙoƙin mutum ɗaya ba, kodayake yanke shawara daga baya ya ba da izinin aikace-aikacen koyarwar a cikin lamuran da suka shafi haƙƙin mutum. ]Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803) Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186, 217 (1962).

Koyarwa
Sabanin ka’idojin tsayuwar daka, da balaga, da bacin rai, idan akidar tambayar siyasa ta shafi, wata tambaya ta musamman ta wuce cancantar shari’a, ko wanene ya taso da ita, ko yaya maslahar da ta shafi kai tsaye, ko kuma kona rigima§ 15 "Case or Controversy"—Political Questions, 20 Fed. Prac. & Proc. Deskbook § 15 (2d ]. Koyarwar ta ta’allaka ne a kan raba madafun iko, da kuma burin bangaren shari’a na tarayya na kaucewa shigar da kanta cikin rikici tsakanin sassan gwamnatin tarayya.§ 15 "Case or Controversy"—Political Questions, 20 Fed. Prac. & Proc. Deskbook § 15 (2d Yana da hujjar barin tambayoyin siyasa ga tsarin siyasa, wanda masu jefa ƙuri'a za su iya amincewa da shi a kaikaice ko kuma watsi da aikin da aka kalubalanci ta hanyar jefa kuri'a.§ 15 "Case or Controversy"—Political Questions, 20 Fed. Prac. & Proc. Deskbook § 15 (2d

Manazarta