Kungiyar Sa Ido Kan Ayyukan Majalissar Dinkin Duniya

UN Watch ƙungiya ce mai zaman kanta a Geneva wanda aikinta ya bayyana shi ne "sa ido kan ayyukan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta hanyar ma'aunin Yarjejeniyarta ". Ƙungiya ce mai izini a cikin Matsayin Tattaunawa ta Musamman ga Majalisar Tattalin Arziƙi ta Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da kuma NGOan NGO da ke Ƙungiyar Ma'aikatar Watsa Labaru ta Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya. 

Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta yi rawar gani wajen yaki da take Haƙƙin bil adama a Jamhuriyar Demokradiyyar Kongo da Darfur, kuma ta yi kakkausar suka kan cin zarafin gwamnatoci irin su China, Cuba, Rasha da Venezuela, za a iya cewa galibi kan yi amfani da lokacin da aka ba ta a UNHRC don ba da dama ga masu adawa da masu rajin kare Haƙƙin dan adam su yi magana. Majalisar Dinkin Duniya Watch ne akai-akai m na abin da shi yake aukan kamar yadda anti-Isra'ila da kuma antisemitic jin zuciya a Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da kuma Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya-ta ɗauki nauyin events.  
Ƙungiyar ta sami yabo daga tsohon Sakatare Janar na Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya Kofi Annan, kuma Darakta Janar na Ofishin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a Geneva Sergei Ordzhonikidze ya amince da "aikin mai muhimmanci na Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya don tallafa wa aiwatar da adalci na ɗabi'u da ka'idoji na Yarjejeniyar Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da kuma tallafa wa 'yancin dan adam ga kowa. " Kamfanin dillancin labaran Faransa ya bayyana UN Watch duka a matsayin "ƙungiyar zaure wacce ke da kyakkyawar alaƙa da Isra'ila" sannan kuma a matsayin kungiyar da ke "kare Haƙƙin dan adam a duk duniya".

 Kafa 
An kafa UN Watch a cikin shekarata 1993 a ƙarƙashin jagorancin Morris B. Abram. Abram ya yi aiki a matsayin Shugaban Asusun Kwalejin Kwalejin United Negro kuma Shugaban Jami'ar Brandeis. Abram ya kasance ma'aikaci a cikin al'amuran al'umma a matsayin Shugaban Kwamitin Yahudawa na Amurka a shekarun (1963-1968); Shugaban Kungiyar Hadin Kan Ƙasa da Taimaka wa Yahudawan Soviet (1983–1988); da Shugaban taron Shugabannin Manyan Kungiyoyin Yahuda wa na Amurkawa (1986–1989). 

Abram ya goyi bayan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a matsayin hukuma. A shekarar 1999, Abram ya gabatar da jawabi a gaban Majalisar Dokokin Amurka kan batun yadda Isra'ila ta yi wa Isra'ila aiki inda ya ce "UN Watch ta nuna goyon bayanta ga Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya a matsayin cibiya mai matukar muhimmanci saboda yadda suka yi bincike. Ya kamata Amurka ta biya duk haƙƙinta na baya ga Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a matsayin abin girmamawa na ƙasa da girmama muhimmancin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya. Duk da kura-kuran Majalisar Dinkin Duniya, ba za a taba tunanin cewa Amurka ta hana tallafi daga ƙungiyar daya tilo ta duniya ba a irin wannan duniyar da ke dogaro da juna. ” United States. Congress. House. Committee on International Relations. 1999. The treatment of Israel by the United Nations [microform] : hearing before the Committee on International Relations, House of Representatives, One Hundred Sixth Congress, first session, 14 July 1999 U.S. G.P.O. : For sale by the U.S. G.P.O., Supt. of Docs., Congressional Sales Office, Washington : 1999 

Bayan da Abram ya mutu a shekara ta 2000, David A. Harris, Babban Darakta na Kwamitin Yahudawa na Amurka, an zabe shi Shugaban UN Watch. 

A cikin shekara ta 2001, Harris ya ba da sanarwar cewa UN Watch ta zama cikakken reshe na Kwamitin Yahudawa na Amurka. A cewar wata sanarwa da aka Raba wa manema labarai a lokacin, “an kafa Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ne tare da karimcin Edgar Bronfman, Shugaban Majalisar Yahudawa ta Duniya. Watanni goma sha takwas da suka gabata, Kwamitin Yahudawa na Amurka da Majalisar Yahudawa ta Duniya sun cimma wata yarjejeniya, wadda kwamitin kasa da kasa na UN Watch ya amince da ita, don mika cikakken ikon ƙungiyar ga AJC, yarjejeniyar da ta fara aiki a ranar 1 ga Janairun 2001. ” 

Tun a shekara ta 2013, UN Watch ta bayar da sanarwar cewa ba ta tare da Ƙungiyar AJC ta kuma ayyana kanta a matsayin Ƙungiyar mai zaman kanta.

 Tsarin da matsayi 
Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya ta shiga cikin Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya a matsayin mai zaman kanta wacce aka yarda da ita a Matsayin Tattaunawa ta Musamman ga Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kan Tattalin Arziƙi da Tattalin Arziki (ECOSOC) da kuma matsayin NGOan NGO mai haɗin gwiwa ga Sashen Kula da Jama'a na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya (DPI). Tana da alaƙa da Kwamitin Bayahude na Amurka,   wata ƙungiya mai zaman kanta da aka kafa a 1906, wacce ta kasance mai ba da shawara na farko game da Yarjejeniyar Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta haɗa da haƙƙin ɗan adam na ƙasa da ƙasa, da kuma ƙirƙirar matsayin Babban Kwamishina na 'Yancin Dan Adam. . 

Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta shiga cikin ayyukan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya masu zuwa: Kwamitin Kare Hakkin Dan-Adam, Tattaunawa kan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da Gabas ta Tsakiya, Tattaunawar Kwamiti kan Shawarwari don Sake Gyara Kwamitin Kan 'Yancin Dan Adam, karamin kwamiti don Ingantawa da Kariya na 'Yancin Dan-Adam, Kwamitin Kawar da Nuna Bambancin launin fata, da Rukunin Aiki kan' Yan tsiraru. Taron karawa juna sani na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a Geneva ya nuna zagayen Palais des Nations, da ziyarar Red Cross ta Duniya da Gidan Tarihi na Red Crescent, da kuma halartar taron kwamitin da ke yaki da azabtarwa (CAT) inda mataimakin shugaban ya yi bayani. 

A watan Oktoba na shekarata 2008, UNHCR ta lissafa kungiyar a matsayin mai dauke da mutane shida.  UN Watch tana da membobi 110 a 2007, an rarraba su a ƙasa kamar haka: 56% daga Turai, 38% daga Arewacin Amurka, da 4% daga Oceania. Labarin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kan al'amuran Majalisar Dinkin Duniya yanzu ya kai kusan masu biyan 5,000 a duk duniya. 

Sharhi wasucikin kungiyar ya bayyana a cikin BBC,  Al Jazeera,  Reuters,  Washington Post,  Agence France-Presse,  Muryar Amurka,  The Jerusalem Post, Gold vs Goldstone Jerusalem Post: Fox News,  JTA,  da sauransu.

 Board da kudade 
Membobin kwamitin na yanzu su ne: 

 Diego Arria, tsohon Wakilin din-din-din na kasar Venezuela a Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kuma Shugaban Kwamitin Tsaro
 Jean-Claude Buhrer
 Irwin Cotler, mai rajin kare hakkin dan adam, tsohon dan majalisar dokokin Canada, tsohon Ministan Shari’a kuma Babban Lauyan Kanada, wanda ya kafa kuma Shugaban Raoul Wallenberg Center for Human Rights .
 Yang Jianli, dan China mai adawa da izinin zama Amurka da mai rajin kare hakkin dan Adam
 Garry Kasparov ɗan adawa na Rasha kuma tsohon zakaran duniya dara
 Mark P. Lagon masanin kimiyyar siyasa kuma mai aikatawa, Babban Jami'in Manufofi a Abokan Kawancen Yaki da Cutar Kanjamau, tarin fuka, da zazzabin cizon sauro da kuma Babban Mashahurin Babban Malami a Makarantar Harkokin Waje ta Jami'ar Georgetown .
 Katrina Lantos Swett Shugabar Gidauniyar Lantos, tsohuwar Shugabar Hukumar Amurka kan ‘Yancin Addini ta Duniya
 David Trimble, tsohon Ministan Farko na Farko na Arewacin Ireland daga 1998 zuwa 2002 kuma shugaban Jam’iyyar Ulster Unionist Party
 Gert Weisskirchen, ɗan siyasan Jamus kuma tsohon memba na majalisar dokoki ta Bundestag

Tsoffin mambobin kwamitin sun hada da:

 Per Ahlmark, former Deputy Prime Minister of Sweden
 Max Jakobson, former Finnish Ambassador to the United Nations
 David A. Harris, Executive Director of the American Jewish Committee
 Alfred H. Moses, Attorney, former United States Ambassador to Romania and Presidential Emissary for the Cyprus Conflict, Special Counsel to President Jimmy Carter.

Majalisar Dinkin Duniya tana bana tallafi da gudummawar ga mutane masu zaman kansu da kuma sadaka. 

 Matsayi da ayyuka 

 Yankuna 

 Kwango 
A shekarar 2008, gidan na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya na musamman rubuta rahoto ga Congo da aka shafe ta da United Nations Human Rights Council. Kawancen an yi shi ne tare da goyon bayan kasashen Masar, Algeria, Tunisia, Russia da sauran kasashe, biyo bayan bukatar da gwamnatin Kwango ta Shugaba Joseph Kabila ta gabatar . A cewar wani rahoto na gaba wanda ofishin Sakatare Janar na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya Ban Ki-moon ya shirya, duka sojojin gwamnati da na 'yan tawaye sun ci gaba da aiwatar da kashe-kashe da yawa, fyade da azabtarwa. A watan Nuwamba na waccan shekarar, UN Watch ta yi kira ga UNHRC da ta nemi gafarar soke mukamin, sannan ta bayyana cewa ya kamata a ce UNHRC tana so ayi mata bayani akan yadda abin yake, ganin irin ta'asar da mutane ke yi a can. Babban Daraktan Daraktan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya Hillel Neuer ya fada a cikin wata sanarwa cewa, "A dabi'ance, wadannan kasashen (a cikin Majalisar) wadanda ke bayan kawar da dokar sanya ido a watan Maris ya kamata yanzu su nemi gafarar wadanda abin ya shafa a Congo. . . Ba za mu taba sanin ko mutane nawa ne za a iya ceto ba idan da Majalisar, ta koma ga gwamnatin Kwango, ba ta haifar da wannan gibin kariya ba wanda ba zai yiwu ba wanda ya rage wata hanyar gargadi da wuri lokacin da wadanda abin ya shafa suka fi bukata. " Sauran kungiyoyin kare hakkin dan adam sun yi kira da a sake kafa mukamin. Rights group calls for U.N. apology over Congo post, Reuters 26 November 2008

A ranar 1 ga Disambar na shekarata 2009, biyo bayan ta'asar da aka yi a gabashin lardin Congo na Arewacin Kivu, UNHRC ta la'anci cin zarafin fararen hula a Congo. Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta ce tana fatan ganin an sauya wani masanin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kan hakkoki a yankin, kuma ta ce cin zarafin "mai da gabashin Congo wani jahannama" na bukatar a gudanar da bincike yadda ya kamata. U.N. Human Rights Council condemns abuses in Congo, Reuters 1 December 2009 Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta ce jimillar kungiyoyi 50 ne suka sanya hannu kan wannan roko ga Sakatare Janar na Majalisar Ban Ki-moon da shugabar kare hakkin dan adam Navi Pillay, suna neman a maido da mukamin mai kula da hakkin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a can. Groups call for UN rights monitor for Congo, Reuters, 23 December 2009

 Darfur 
UN Watch ta jagoranci Taron Kungiyoyi masu rajin gwagwarmaya na Darfur a 2007. 

A ranar 27 ga Afrilu 2008, UN Watch ta shiga cikin kungiyoyin kare hakkin dan adam a duk duniya don kaddamar da yakin "Adalci ga Darfur ". Kungiyoyin da ke bayan kamfen din sun hada da Amnesty International, Human Rights First da Human Rights Watch . Gangamin ya yi kira ga Kwamitin Tsaro na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya, kungiyoyin yanki da gwamnatocin kasashe da su matsa wa Sudan lamba ta ba da hadin kai ga Kotun hukunta manyan laifuka ta kasa da kasa, tare da cafke wadanda ake zargi da aikata laifukan yaki Ali Kushayb da Ahmad Harun . Gwamnatin Sudan ta ki mika ko daya daga cikin wadanda ake zargin ga Kotu, kuma a zahiri ta daga Harun zuwa karamin Ministan kula da ayyukan jin kai. "Justice for Darfur" Campaign Launched , Amnesty International 25 April 2008

 Iran 
Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta yaba wa Amurka, Faransa da sauran kasashen dake akan turbar domokaradiya kan “kakkausar suka da suka yi” game da batun kare hakkin dan Adam na Iran a wani zaman da Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta yi a kwamitin kare hakkin dan Adam na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya (UNHRC) a watan Fabrairu 2010. A lokaci guda, babban darektan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya Hillel Neuer ya yi gargadin cewa sakamakon zaman majalisar zai iya takaita ga rahoton "mara hakori" da za a karba. Iran under fire at UNHRC, Jerusalem Post. 16 February 2010

 Haiti 
Bayan faruwar girgizar kasar ta Haiti a watan Janairun 2010, mambobin kwamitin kare hakkin dan adam na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya su 47 baki daya suka zartar da wani kuduri wanda ya nuna damuwa game da take hakki a yayin girgizar kuma sun bukaci gwamnati da kungiyoyin agaji da su kare yara daga tashin hankali da cin zarafi. Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta soki taron Majalisar Dinkin Duniya na Kare Hakkin Dan-Adam na kwanaki biyu na musamman kan Haiti a matsayin "barnatar da cutarwa na lokacin kungiyar, albarkatunta, da kuma halin kirki na kungiyar," ta kara da cewa majalisar "ba ta da kasafin kudi, hukuma ko kwarewa kan ayyukan agaji" da "yayi watsi da matsalolin haƙƙin ɗan adam". 

 Switzerland 
Bayan zaben Switzerland a shekarar 2009 don hana minarets, UN Watch ta bayyana cewa ta ji kunya musamman da gaskiyar kuma za ta yi aiki don sake ta. Daraktan kungiyar ta NGO Hillel Neuer ya ce haramtawa tsarin musulmai da wata gwamnati take nunawa ba daidai bane. A Swiss Ban on Minarets, New York Times, 18 December 2009

 Zaɓen UNHRC 
Tare da Freedom House, Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta yi adawa da takarar gwamnatocin jihohin da ba su da cikakkun bayanai game da 'yancin dan adam na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta' Yancin Dan Adam. Kudurin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya na 2006 da ya kafa kwamitin ya bukaci cewa, yayin zabar kasashe a kwamitin, mambobin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya "za su yi la'akari da irin gudummawar da 'yan takara ke bayarwa wajen daukakawa da kuma kare hakkin dan adam." States vie for seats on disputed UN rights body, Reuters 21 May 2008

 2007 
A watan Mayu na 2007, Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da kuma Freedom House sun gabatar da rahoto na hadin gwiwa game da zabe ga Kwamitin Kare Hakkin Dan-Adam na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya, yana mai cewa 'yan takarar Angola, Belarus, Masar da Qatar ba su cancanci zama a kan hukumar kare hakkin dan Adam ba, saboda su kansu sun keta hakkokin. Rahoton ya ce kasashen hudu "gwamnatocin kama-karya ne wadanda ke da rejistar kada kuri'ar Majalisar Dinkin Duniya (kan batun 'yancinsu) kuma ba su cancanci zama mambobin Majalisar ba". Rahoton ya kara bayyana ‘yan takarar kasashen Slovenia, Denmark, Italia da Netherlands a matsayin“ wadanda suka cancanta sosai ”don Majalisar, ta kuma kira‘ yan takarar Bolivia, India, Indonesia, Madagascar, Nicaragua, Philippines da Afirka ta Kudu a matsayin “abin tambaya”. Groups call 4 countries unfit for UN rights body, Reuters 7 May 2007

 2009 
A watan Mayun 2009, Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da kuma Freedom House sun sake gabatar da rahoto na hadin gwiwa game da zaben UNHRC. Rahoton ya bayyana 'yan takarar China, Cuba da Saudi Arabia a matsayin "mafi munin cikin munanan" ta fuskar' yancin dan adam. Rahoton ya kuma bayyana 'yan takarar Azerbaijan, Kamaru, Djibouti da Rasha a matsayin "wadanda ba su cancanta ba", sannan Bangladesh, Jordan, Kenya, Kyrgyzstan, Nigeria da Senegal a matsayin "masu tambaya". UN Watch da Freedom House sun bayyana tarihin majalisar a cikin shekaru ukun farko a matsayin mara kyau. Sun bayyana cewa kasashen musulmin da ke samun goyon bayan Cuba sun sake rubuta dokoki don sanya ido kan 'yancin fadin albarkacin baki ta yadda zai iyakance magana, kuma "kawancen gwamnatocin da ke kan gaba' 'sun yi nasarar dakatar da Majalisar ta soke masu binciken hakkin bil'adama na wuraren matsaloli kamar Belarus, Cuba Laberiya, Jamhuriyar Demokradiyyar Kongo da Darfur . Sun ce, sabanin haka, kawancen ya sa majalisar ta nada wani mai bincike wanda ke da hannu a kafa wata kyauta ta kare hakkin dan adam don girmama Muammar al-Gaddafi da kuma wani wanda ke ganin cewa harin na 9/11 aiki ne na cikin gida. Hillel Neuer ya ce, "Tunanin ya kasance cewa majalisar za ta kasance muryar wadanda abin ya shafa, amma yanzu tana cikin wani hali." 

 2010 
Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta bayyana karara game da wani rahoto da ke nuna cewa kasashen Asiya na iya saukaka zaben Iran a watan Mayun 2010 ga mambobi 47 na UNHRC. 

 2011 
An yaba wa Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da jagorantar kamfen din kin amincewa da bukatar Syria na samun kujera. Jordana Horn, "Syria may drop bid for Human Rights Council seat", Jerusalem Post, 10 May 2011.

 2014 
UN Watch ta yi kakkausar suka game da zaben shekarar 2014 na Saudiyya, China, Cuba, da Rasha ga kwamitin kare hakkin dan adam. A wata hira da France 24, babban darekta Hillel Neuer ya kira wannan a matsayin "ranar bakar rana ta 'yancin ɗan adam."  Yakin neman cire wadannan kasashe daga jiki, "HRC-ba mai mulkin kama-karya" yana gudana tare da koke a shafin yanar gizon kungiyar.  

 Other UN activities 

 Rahoton Goldstone 
Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta gabatar da takaddar doka mai shafi 29 ga Ofishin Binciken Gaskiya na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kan rikicin na Gaza inda ta nemi a kori memba Christine Chinkin saboda tana daya daga cikin malamai 31 da lauyoyi wadanda suka sanya hannu kan wata wasika da aka buga a jaridar Sunday Times kafin ta kasance wanda aka zaba don aikin da ya zargi Isra’ila da kin bin dokokin kasa da kasa na kare hakkin dan adam.  Wasikar ta bayyana harin sojan da Isra’ila ta yi a Gaza a matsayin “cin zali ne”, inda ta ce “mamayewa da jefa bam a Gaza daidai yake da hukuncin da aka yanke wa mazauna Gaza miliyan 1.5 wanda ya saba wa dokar kasa da kasa da ta‘ yancin dan adam ”, sannan ta kara da cewa“ toshewar taimakon jin kai, lalata kayayyakin more rayuwa na farar hula, da hana shigo da kayan masarufi kamar abinci da mai, manyan laifuka ne na yaki ". Israel’s bombardment of Gaza is not self-defence – it’s a war crime , The Sunday Times, 11 January 2009. Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta bayyana cewa, tunda Chinkin ya riga ya kafa kuma ya bayyana hukunci kan ainihin batutuwan da Ofishin Jakadancin ke son gudanar da bincike, ba za ta iya cika bukatar nuna son kai ba game da binciken gaskiya.  Takardar karar ta ambaci hukumomi na dokokin kasa da kasa, gami da na shekarar 2004 game da kotun kasa da kasa ta Saliyo, inda mai shari’a Geoffrey Robertson ya samu damar daga takwarorinsa na alkalai kan nuna son kai. NGO: Academic should quit Cast Lead inquiry, Jerusalem Post. 23 August 2009

Wakilin Deutsche Presse Agentur da jaridar Khaleej Times  da kuma Agence France Presse ne suka gabatar da bukatar ta Majalisar Dinkin Duniya.  UN Watch ta kara lura da cewa a wata ganawa da ta yi da kungiyoyi masu zaman kansu na Geneva a watan Mayun 2009, Chinkin ta musanta cewa ba a nuna wariyarta ba, tana mai cewa bayanin nata kawai ya yi magana ne kan jus ad bellum, kuma ba jus a bello ba ; duk da haka, a cewar Majalisar Dinkin Duniya, bayanin ba wai kawai ya kaddara cewa "ayyukan Isra'ila sun kai ga zalunci, ba kare kai ba," amma kuma an zarge su da cewa "sun saba wa dokokin kare hakkin dan adam na duniya da na 'yancin dan adam," kuma ya kasance "manyan laifukan yaki . " 

Wakilan binciken sun ki amincewa da karar kuma suka ce tawagar ta binciki ko Isra’ila, Hamas ko Hukumar Falasdinu sun yi sanadiyar mutuwa ko rauni ga fararen hula marasa laifi ta wasu ayyukan takamaiman makamai wadanda suka keta dokar jin kai ta kasa da kasa da dokar kare hakkin dan Adam ta duniya tana mai cewa “A kan wadannan batutuwan wasikar da farfesa Chinkin ya sanya hannu tare ba ta bayyana ra'ayi ba sam. " Dispute over 'biased' Gaza inquiry professor , TheJC.com, 27 August 2009.  Membobin sun kara rubutawa a cikin amsar da suka bayar cewa ba za a iya daukar kwamitin binciken na gaskiya a matsayin bangaren shari'a ba ko ma na shari'ar adalci. U.N. Goldstone inquiry rejects ’so-called petition of UN Watch’; denies mission is quasi-judicial , UN Watch, 30 August 2009 Hillel Neuer, darektan UN Watch, ya ce hujjojin da tawagar ta gabatar sun yi biris da kyakkyawan tsarin da aka kafa na ayyukan binciken kasa da kasa. Gold vs Goldstone, Jerusalem Post. 11 November 2009 Goldstone ya ce wasikar da Chinkin ya sanya wa hannu na iya zama dalilin rashin cancanta, in da manufa ta kasance binciken shari'a. Goldstone walks a fine line in an ancient war zone , BusinessDay, 4 August 2009.

 Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta nuna adawa da Isra'ila da nuna wariyar akida 
UN Watch tana aiki a Majalisar Dinkin Duniya wajen yaki da kin jinin Isra’ila da kin jinin yahudawa, da kuma abin da ke nuna irin zabin da siyasa ta yi wa Isra’ilawa da yawancin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya.  Kungiyar ta goyi bayan burin tsohon Sakatare Janar Kofi Annan da aka gabatar na kawo karshen rashin daidaito da Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ke nuna wa Isra’ila  kuma ta yi kakkausar suka ga Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kan ‘Yancin Dan Adam .    Kamfanin dillancin labarai na Yahudawa ya bayyana UN Watch a matsayin kungiyar da ke goyon bayan Isra'ila. 

 Maris 2007 jawabin UNHRC 
A ranar 23 ga Maris 2007, Hillel Neuer na UN Watch ya gabatar da wani kakkausar suka ga Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta Kare Hakkin Dan-Adam (UNHRC), yana mai cewa Majalisar ta ci amanar mafarkin wadanda suka kafa ta kuma ta zama "mummunan mafarki". Neuer ya zargi Majalisar da yin biris da take hakkin bil adama a duniya, inda ta zabi kafa "kuduri daya bayan daya da ke la'antar kasa daya: Isra'ila". Ya ci gaba da cewa matsalar da Majalisar ta nuna game da hakkin Falasdinawa na yaudara ce, kuma ya ba da misalai inda ta yi biris da cin zarafin Falasdinawa "saboda ba za a zargi Isra'ila ba. Desp Yan adawa wadanda ke gudanar da wannan Majalisar ba su damu da damuwa da Falasdinawa ba, ko kuma wani hakki na dan adam ba. Suna neman su bata demokradiyyar Isra’ila, su ba da izinin haramtacciyar kasar Isra’ila, don bata wa yahudawa rai. ” 

Jawabin Neuer ya sami yabo a cikin adadin edita da op-eds. Jaridar Wall Street Journal tayi nuni da cewa rashin gaskiya na Neuer ya dagula "obfuscation" na majalisar da "zamba". Your U.N. at Work, Wall Street Journal 30 March 2007 Wani marubuci ne wanda aka wallafa a jaridar The Post ta kasa ya bayyana cewa jawabin ya zama "babban abin da aka gani a YouTube" Degeneration in all but reputation, National Post 23 May 2009 A cikin edita, jaridar New York Sun ta kira ta wani "lokacin diflomasiyya da za a tuna", kuma ta buga cikakken bayanin nasa.  Alan Gold, dan rajin kare hakkin bil adama dan kasar Ostiraliya, ya ce jawabin Neuer "kungiya ce mai zaman kanta wacce ke nuna rashin da'a da nuna kyama ga wata babbar hukumar Majalisar Dinkin Duniya." "New name, but the shame is still the same", The Australian,

Ian Williams, yana rubutawa ga The Guardian, ya yarda da maganganun Neuer game da munafunci biyu a cikin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya game da Isra’ila da kasashe da yawa: Isra’ila ita ce abin la’anta, yayin da suka wuce gona da iri a kan kasashe masu yawa. Duk da haka munafuncin, ya kammala, ya faɗaɗa zuwa UN Watch kanta, wanda amincin sa yake, a ra'ayin sa, ya gurɓata gazawar ƙungiyar ta ba da hujja cewa ta taɓa la'antar 'bayyanannar laifuffukan Isra'ila na' yancin ɗan adam na Falasɗinawa. ' Ian Williams, 'Casting the first stone,' The Guardian 4 April 2007

 Sauran 

 Sexual exploitation 
UN Watch, World YWCA, da Worldungiyar YMCAs sun buga wata sanarwa game da lalata da lalata yara da batsa. "A yau da yawa yara da yawa ana cin zarafinsu ta hanyar lalata da lalata su suna haifar da lalacewar rayuwa. Fiye da miliyan biyu da yara suna maida su ba kome a cikin multibillion-dollar jima'i masana'antu a kowace shekara, kuma miliyan 1.2 yara suna safararsu a shekara ", a cewar sanarwar. NGO Statement on the Revision of the Council Framework Decision on combating the sexual abuse, sexual exploitation of children and child-pornography , repealing Framework Decision 2004/68/JHA

 Tarihin karba 
Former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan has said "I deeply appreciate the valuable work performed by UN Watch. I believe that informed and independent evaluation of the United Nations' activities will prove a vital source as we seek to adapt the Organization to the needs of a changing world." At the 2006 Centennial Anniversary of the American Jewish Committee, the Director-General of the UN Office in Geneva, Sergei Ordzhonikidze, praised the work of UN Watch by saying "allow me to also pay tribute to the valuable work of UN Watch in support of the just application of values and principles of the United Nations Charter and support for human rights for all."

Ian Williams, tsohon shugaban kungiyar 'yan Jaridu ta Majalisar Dinkin Duniya  kuma marubucin The UN For Beginners,  ya rubuta a cikin wani ra'ayi a cikin The Guardian a 2007 cewa babbar manufar UN Watch "ita ce a kai hari ga Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a Janar, da kuma majalisar kare haƙƙin bil'adama musamman, saboda zargin nuna son kai ga Isra'ila ". Williams ya goyi bayan Allah wadai da Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta yi wa Kwamitin Kare Hakkin Dan-Adam na Majalisar a matsayin kungiyar munafunci, amma kuma ya zargi ita kanta UN Watch da munafunci saboda ta yi Allah wadai da abin da ya kira "bayyanannun laifuffukan Isra'ila kan 'yancin dan adam na Falasdinawa." Casting the first stone The Guardian, 4 April 2007.

The New Republics Martin Peretz, in a 2007 blog piece, described the organization as "a truth-telling organization." Claudia Rosett, a journalist-in-residence with the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, praised UN Watch as "stalwart and invaluable".

The American journalist and political activist Phyllis Bennis described UN Watch as a "small Geneva-based right-wing organisation" that is "hardly known outside of UN headquarters". She stressed that "undermining and delegitimising" Richard Falk through "scurrilous accusations" has been an "obsession of UN Watch" when he became Special Rapporteur.

Kamfanin dillancin labaran Faransa ya bayyana UN Watch duka a matsayin "kungiya ce ta zare da ke da kyakkyawar alaka da Isra'ila"  da kuma kungiyar da ke "kare hakkin dan adam a duniya". 6 May 2008, NGOs say five nations unfit to serve on UN rights body, AFP 6 May 2008 Masanin tattalin arziki ya bayyana Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a matsayin "mai sa ido ga Isra'ila". 

 Bayani 


 Kara karantawa 

 Hillel Neuer na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya wanda aka yi hira da shi a Labaran Sadarwar Sadarwa
 Gwagwarmaya da kin jinin Isra'ila a Kwamitin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya kan 'Yancin Dan Adam - Hillel C. Neuer 

 Hanyoyin haɗin waje 

 Tashar yanar gizo
 UN Watch , Cibiyar Nazarin Manufofin - Yanar gizo na Dama, Kokarin bin sahun masu fafutuka don tasiri kan manufofin kasashen waje na Amurka.

Manazarta