BIP 0178

BIP: 178
 Layer: Applications
 Title: Version Extended WIF
 Author: Karl-Johan Alm <karljohan-alm@garage.co.jp>
 Comments-Summary: Discouraged for implementation (one person)
 Comments-URI: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/wiki/Comments:BIP-0178
 Status: Draft
 Type: Standards Track
 Created: 2018-04-04
 License: CC0-1.0
== Abstract ==
An extension to the Wallet Import Format (WIF) to specify what kind of bitcoin address the private key corresponds to.
== Motivation ==
There are several types of bitcoin addresses which can all be associated with a given private key: P2PKH (legacy 1... format), P2SH-P2WPKH (SegWit public key inside P2SH), P2WPKH (bech32), etc.
While private keys have a 1-byte suffix indicating whether the corresponding public key is compressed (0x01) or not (through suffix absence), there is no way of knowing what kind of bitcoin address were associated with the private key. As a result, when importing a private key, the wallet has to assume all kinds, and keep track of each possible alternative.
By extending the suffix, we can specify what kind of bitcoin address was associated with a given private key.
== Specification ==
Currently, private keys are stored as a uint256 (private key data) followed by an optional uint8 (compressed flag). The latter is extended to specify the address types:
Value 	Type 	Compr	Clarification
No suffix	P2PKH_UNCOMPRESSED	No 	Uncompressed legacy public key. Unknown public key format
0x01 	P2PKH_COMPRESSED 	Yes 	Compressed legacy public key. Unknown public key format
0x10 	P2PKH 	Yes 	Compressed legacy public key. Legacy public key format (1...)
0x11 	P2WPKH 	Yes 	Bech32 format (native Segwit)
0x12 	P2WPKH_P2SH 	Yes 	Segwit nested in BIP16 P2SH (3...)
When a wallet imports a private key, it will have two outcomes:
* the key is using one of the legacy types, in which case all types must be accounted for
* the key is using one of the extended types, in which case the wallet need only track the specific corresponding address
Note: the difference between `0x01` and `0x10` is that the former can correspond to any of the types above, whereas the latter *only* corresponds to a P2PKH (legacy non-segwit).
== Compatibility ==
This proposal is not backwards compatible, in that software that does not recognize the new types will not understand the compressed flag. It would be trivial to change this, by keeping the 'uncompressed' state as it is (no suffix) and changing 'compressed' to be 'anything not 0', as opposed to 'the value 1'.
The proposal is backwards compatible in that new wallet software will always understand the old WIF format, however. It will, as it does today, assume that any kind of bitcoin address is possible, and will have to track all of them, as it has to today.
== Acknowledgements ==
This BIP is based on the initial proposal by Thomas Voegtlin (thomasv at electrum dot org) on the Bitcoin Dev mailing listhttps://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2017-September/015007.html and the Electrum 3.0 implementationhttps://github.com/spesmilo/electrum/blob/82e88cb89df35288b80dfdbe071da74247351251/RELEASE-NOTES#L95-L108
== Reference implementation ==
There is a partial implementation which adds, but does not use, the types described in this BIP here: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/12869
== References ==
== Copyright ==
This document is licensed under the Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal license.