Vid Commentary

Inspired by SDWolfpup and the dvd_commentary community, the Vid Commentary community describes itself as "The Multifandom VID Commentary Community! Home of the Vid Commentary Challenge, and the Vidder Profile Series." The purpose of this challenge community is to solicit commentary and analysis on vids. As the profile page notes, "This community is not looking for reviews, critiques, or recommendations, and we don't want to know what the vidder's own intentions were, we want to know what you believe the vid is doing; how and why it works."
This community is also home to the Vidder Profile series of short documentary films by vidders about vidders. They are directed by bradcpu. 
Vids reviewed:
* ...and The Ladies With Pretty Hair by hollywoodgrrl, commentary by deejay
* 45 by Dragonchic, commentary by Dragonchic
* Above and Below by Counteragent, commentary by Countessmary
* American Tune by Greensilver, commentary by Nestra
* Angie by chaila43, commentary by chaila43
* Are We The Lucky Ones? by Jagwriter78, commentary by Jagwriter78
* Attention: Gotham City by Cherryice, commentary by Zephyrprince
* Babies by Aycheb, commentary by Aycheb
* Beautiful by Castorfate, commentary by Zephyrprince
* Becoming Brothers by Kass, commentary by here's luck
* Blackout by Humansrsuperior, commentary by Hollywoodgrrl
* Brick House by deirdre_c, commentary by yourlibrarian
* Burning Bridges by sisabet, commentary by here's luck and renenet
* Caged Bird by Luminosity, commentary by renenet
* Cathedrals by Chaila43, commentary by Beccatoria
* Clint Eastwood by Bop-radar, commentary by Acridnym
* Coming to Your City by blissfire, commentary by schneefink
* Companions Wanted by Rhoboat, commentary by Rhoboat
* Counting Bodies by Millylicious, commentary by Alchemise
* DLZ by bop_radar, commentary by chaila
* Day Carry Night by tearful_eye, commentary by amnisias
* Ding! Dong! by kiki_miserychic, commentary by thuviaptarth
* Elemental by wistful_fever (Fabella), commentary by tearful_eye
*Enter the Void Luminosity, commentary by renenet
* Everything's Not Lost by Greensilver, commentary by Charmax
* Ghosts (Battlestar Galactica vid) by Beccatoria, commentary by Chaila43
* Gloria by sweetestdrain, Commentary by zephyrprince
* Glorious by Such_heights, commentary by Mresundance
* Half Acre by Jarrow & Laura Shapiro, commentary by aycheb
* Hard Sun by Bradcpu & Laura Shapiro, commentary by AbsoluteDestiny
* History of My Future by Clucking Belles, commentary by killabeez
* Hurricane by Laura Shapiro, commentary by cozzybob
* In My Veins by Millylicious, commentary by Millylicious
* Jolene by Nicole Anell, commentary by Nicole Anell
*Land by sweetestdrain, commentary by sweetestdrain
* Lightning Field by bradcpu, commentary by such heights
* Marble House by Hollywoodgrrl, commentary by Such_heights
* Middleman by Bop_radar, commentary by Bop_radar
* On Nights Like Tonight by chesauroshin, commentary by cozzybob
* Out Here by Heresluck, Commentary by Sisabet
* Patterns by Lithiumdoll, commentary by Deathisyourart
* Peacekeeper by Sisabet, commentary by Heresluck
* Respectable by Charmax, commentary by cozzybob
* Save You by Kazbaby, commentary by cozzybob
* Scarlet Ribbons by Aycheb, commentary by Alchemise
*Some Time Around Midnight by bop_radar, commentary by tree
* So Sad, So Lonely by sdwolfpup, and commentary by cozzybob
* So What'cha Want by bradcpu, commentary by cozzybob
* Tear You Apart by Bradcpu, commentary by Bop_radar
* That Was Another Country by Kassrachel, commentary by Kassrachel
* The Pinky and the Brain - Doctor Style by Chayiana, commentary by rhoboat
* The Test by heresluck, commentary by killabeez
* The Wizard and I by chasarumba, commentary by theanonsisters
* This World by Buffyann, commentary by Nushanakt
* Underdog by Fabella, commentary by cozzybob
* Unnatural Selection by Charmax, commentary by Kiki_miserychic
* Weak by Charmax. Commentary by Ebonypsyche
* West of Her Spine by Sweetestdrain, commentary by Joyo
* What We Had by cherryice, commentary by hollywoodgrrl
* Who Found Mr. Fabulous? by kuwdora, commentary by ciaan
* Why by Humansrsuperior, commentary by Phantomviola
Non community commentary that the Vid Commentary moderators found notable:
*Agnus Dei by hollywoodgrrl, commentary by Hollywoodgrrl 
*Change by Obsessive24, commentary by Obsessive24 
*Desert Rose by phoenixchilde, commentary by 12_12_12 
*Headlights by Buffyann, commentary by Buffyann 
*Here I Dreamt I Was an Architect by Kuwdora, commentary by Kuwdora 
*New Dawn Fades by Obsessive24, commentary by Obsessive24 
*People Get Ready by heresluck, commentary by 12_12_12 
*Pour Lui by chasarumba, commentary by chasarumba 
*Red by Obsessive24, commentary by deathisyourart
*Stronger Forest by kiki_miserychic, commentary by kiki_miserychic
*This is your Life by Humansrsuperior, commentary by Humansrsuperior 
Category:Vidding
Category:2009Category:2010Category:2011