The Darkness and the Light (episode)

A hidden enemy systematically murders Kira's old Resistance comrades.
==Summary ==
===Teaser ===
Six vedeks are holding a ceremony. One of them, Latha Mabrin, is killed when the ceremonial candle issues a disruptor blast at him, throwing him back several meters and killing him instantly.
On Deep Space 9, Major Kira Nerys is examined by Doctor , who complains that she hasn't been taking the makara herb he had prescribed. She complains that it tastes "like it crawled out of Quark's ear", and that it counteracts sedatives. He says that she claimed she didn't need sedatives, and she gives a weak answer. Odo then arrives and tells Kira of Latha's death, explaining that a hunter probe was hidden in the candle which was responsible for firing the disruptor blast. Unfortunately, before he became a vedek, Latha was a former resistance companion of Kira's and a violent man who made no shortage of enemies leaving plenty of suspects. Kira sadly notes that despite his violent past, finding the Prophets helped him to change his life for the better.
On returning to the O'Brien's quarters, she receives a mysterious message just showing a picture of Latha, as well as a distorted voice saying "That's one".
=== Act One ===
In the security office, Kira reports the message to Odo and Captain Sisko, however, there is no point of origin for the message, so beginning an investigation is difficult. Although Kira believes it to be a general threat against the Shakaar resistance cell, none of the other members have received a message. Later in the replimat, she laments to Chief O'Brien that after everything he survived while fighting during the Occupation, Latha would be killed during a religious ceremony. She is also frustrated as she feels she should be on Bajor taking an active role in the investigation but, as she's in the late stages of pregnancy, is left unable to do much.
Kira is then called to Ops, as she is receiving another anonymous communication. However, this time it is Trentin Fala, a former ally of the resistance who is desperately paranoid that she is being watched following Latha's death. Kira decides to bring her aboard the station and arranges for Dax and Worf (on their way back from a trip to Starbase 63) to pick her up.
Aboard their runabout, Dax and Worf discuss Jadzia mocking a Captain for his tongo skills, only to lose two bars of latinum to him having not known he was a three-time champion of the game. The two then debate where she'll get the latinum to pay him before trying to beam Fala aboard. However, the transport goes badly wrong, as the pattern buffer suddenly suffers a power surge and is unable to reconstitute her pattern. Dax and Worf desperately try to correct the problem but it's no use and Fala dies painfully, leaving behind a smoking corpse.
=== Act Two ===
Kira goes to see what is left of Fala's body, as Odo reports that her death was caused by a remat detonator which she had unknowingly been carrying. Although the device is typically used by the Romulans, its availability on the black market does nothing to shed any light on who is responsible. This confirms for Kira that someone is targeting the members of the Shakaar cell, revealing that although Fala wasn't officially part of the cell, she passed information to them for years while working as a cleaner in a Cardassian records office in Dahkur Province. She also notes that Fala was constantly terrified of getting caught and executed, but never stopped helping the cell, and for that, Kira considered her to be braver than any of the Shakaar's members because she lived with her fear every day. Even after the Occupation was over, she didn't want anyone to know that she was secretly helping the Shakarr cell as she was worried that someone would come looking for her for revenge.
Walking down the Promenade and heading to the Bajoran temple, Kira hears the same voice from before saying "That's two" and finds it coming from a PADD Quark found in a shipment of Saurian brandy that he just received. Odo reasons that the killer is someone who was injured or lost family or a friend in an attack that was based on Fala's information in which Kira plays a principal role. Before they can start compiling a list, Odo's database is accessed, and a picture of Mobara, another resistance companion, appears with the same voice saying "That's three". Odo immediately sends an emergency message to the university in the Musilla Province where Mobara is studying, but he can't be immediately contacted, so a search party is put together. Kira is getting more and more frustrated with everything that's happening, so Odo has her return to quarters to rest, assigning a security detachment and a personal guard to her, Lieutenant Brilgar.
However, when she arrives and heads to bed, leaving Brilgar in the living room, she hears a thud. Guessing he has just been knocked unconscious, she gets her phaser out from a drawer and continues to listen.
=== Act Three ===
Kira opens the door and slowly peers around the dark room for the intruder. However, she finds her former Resistance colleagues Lupaza and Furel, who had broken into the O'Brien's quarters. They pledge to support her and hunt down the person responsible for the deaths of their friends. Kira tries to convince them to leave it to the authorities, but neither is happy with that solution. Lupaza then gives Kira some fresh makara herbs, and the major invites them to stay on the station. The two insist on staying near Kira, so she decides to let them stay in the quarters while Keiko and Molly are visiting Keiko's parents on Earth.
Odo reports to Sisko in his office that the remains of Mobara's body was found about two hours earlier, the man having died when a micro-explosive planted behind his right ear went off. Odo believes that the explosive was planted via a probe since the killer clearly has expertise with remote control devices. Although this sounds like the work of a professional assassin, Odo notes that a professional would never send anonymous messages… this is someone with a vendetta and is trying to make a point to Kira, and will then try to kill her after making that point.
In Ops, Kira and Dax enlist Nog (with his superior hearing) to help them with the messages. Upon listening, Nog notes that the messages are not complete sentences, but rather words from different speeches put together. Working from this basis, Dax assumes that as the first word is the same in all the messages then it was likely copied three times, which gives her a reference to start screening out the interference. As it starts to descramble, the three quickly recognize the voice… it's Kira's – the killer using the major's own voice in his messages.
The investigation is quickly halted when the sensors report an explosion in the habitat ring in the O'Brien's quarters, causing a hull breach. Dax puts the station to red alert and halts all traffic in and away from the station, as Sisko and Odo emerge from the captain's office. Dax reports what has happened; however, they suddenly realize Kira has left. The major, her fury blinding her actions, heads towards the quarters, fighting her way past all the security guards who try to stop her from exposing herself to the hull breach. Although she gets mere inches from the door panel, she suffers a placental hemorrhage that causes her to collapse.
=== Act Four ===
In the infirmary, Kira wakes up and Bashir tells her the baby is fine and Miles wasn't in his quarters when they exploded. However, Lupaza and Furel were killed. Her only comfort is that the two died instantly. Odo visits and Kira recounts her first days in the Resistance, how at the age of thirteen, she'd been hanging around the cell running errands and when a planned ambush needed an extra member, she volunteered. Lupaza stuck up for her despite everyone else thinking she was too small, and Shakaar decided to let her join the ambush which was a success. Afterward, she remembers how she couldn't stop smiling while Lupaza made Kira an earring from the skimmer that had just been ambushed – the one she continues to wear today – officially making Kira part of the resistance.
Kira then asks what happened, and Odo tells her that a hunter probe was attached to a freighter that docked at the station. The probe then detached and scanned each room in the habitat ring for its targets. Once it found Lupaza and Furel, it attached itself to the window and exploded. Odo has now compiled a list of twenty-five suspects who have the motive, expertise, and opportunity to commit the murders. Kira asks to see it, but Odo refuses, saying he'd like to narrow it down a little. Kira knows that Odo is worried that she'll go off on a personal vendetta mission and tells him he's right. Odo promises to find the killer and to keep Kira informed. As soon as he's gone, however, Kira uses an emergency transport program to beam herself to the security office. There, she downloads the list to a PADD, then beams herself to a runabout. Odo enters the office a few seconds after she's gone and notices his chair is out of place. Knowing he wouldn't leave it like that, Odo asks the computer to confirm Kira's location, and it reports she's no longer on the station.
As Kira prepares to track down the killer, Odo tells Sisko that Kira deleted the suspects from his database when she downloaded them, so they don't know where she is headed. Sisko tells Worf to prepare the to follow the runabout, however, tracking her will be difficult as Kira is masking its emissions with a polaron field.
After being satisfied that the first three suspects on Odo's list couldn't have been responsible for the killings, Kira visits a Cardassian named Silaran Prin living near the Demilitarized Zone. Once she beams down, Kira is stunned almost immediately by Prin.
=== Act Five ===
Kira awakens to find herself restrained on a medical bed by an energy field, while Prin gravely rants about her as if she were a vile creature of darkness, "afraid of the light" which Prin fancies himself to embody. He scoffs at her accusations that he is a murderer and insists that the former resistance members all deserved their fates.
Prin goes on to explain that he was a Cardassian civilian at the time of the Occupation, and he was burned and disfigured by a bomb used to assassinate Gul Pirak, who had executed fifteen Bajoran farmers for refusing to display the Cardassian banner outside their homes. Fala had shown the Resistance how to circumvent his defense system, Latha built the bomb, and the device was planted on a window by Kira herself while Lupaza and Furel stood guard. The bomb was much more powerful than necessary to kill only its target, and the resulting explosion claimed twelve lives in total, including Gul Pirak's entire family, and crippled twenty-three others who were servants in Pirak's home, including Prin, who merely laundered Pirak's clothes. Prin has grown more than a little insane since the attack: he continues his long monologues about darkness and light and explains that he was cautious in his murders to not hurt innocent bystanders, as he could have killed all the vedaks in the temple, Dax and Worf while aboard the runabout or half the people aboard Deep Space 9. Therefore, he logically intends to cut out Kira's baby, killing her and "saving" the child from being "corrupted by [her] darkness", so he can "raise it in the light". Prin feels that Kira is a murderer because she killed Cardassian civilians on Bajor along with soldiers and feels no regret for her actions. Kira responds by saying that the Cardassians had no right to be on Bajor in the first place, and for fifty years, they stole food from the land while enslaving, torturing, and killing its people for profit and pleasure. Therefore all the Cardassians, from soldiers to civilians, were equally guilty and all were legitimate targets.
Prin prepares to cut out the O'Brien's baby from Kira's body but consents to administer a sedative to Kira first, to show her a level of mercy she didn't show him. When he is satisfied that the sedative has taken effect, he deactivates the restraint field and approaches, and Kira, upon whom the sedative had no effect because of the makara herbs that she has been taking lately, quickly overpowers him and kills him by firing a phaser beam at his chest.
Later, when Sisko, Bashir, and Odo arrive to rescue her, Kira is found sitting silently next to Prin's body. She is initially unresponsive, and Doctor Bashir finds a large amount of sedatives in her system, which had been counteracted by the makara herb. When she finally talks, she does so in the same manner Prin had, claiming that for all his talk of light and darkness, innocence and guilt, he hadn't realized that "the light only shines in the darkness", and "innocence is often just an excuse for the guilty". The four officers leave the grim scene, and beam up to the Defiant.
=== Log entries ===
* Personal log, Kira Nerys
== Memorable quotes ==
"Those herbs taste like something that crawled out of Quark's ear."
:- Kira
"I'm sorry, Nerys."
"I'm hearing that a lot, lately."
:- Bashir, after the death of Trentin Fala, the latest of Kiras friends to be killed
"I've made it a policy never to argue with someone's lobes."
:- Dax to Nog
"Quark may lend you the money but remember Rule of Acquisition 111: 'Treat people in your debt like family… exploit them'."
"You know the Rules of Acquisition?"
"I am a graduate of Starfleet Academy. I know many things."
:- Worf and Dax
"None of you belonged on Bajor. It wasn't your world. For fifty years you raped our planet, and you killed our people. You lived on our land, and you took the food out of our mouths, and I don't care whether you held a phaser in your hand or you ironed shirts for a living. You were all guilty and you were all legitimate targets!"
"That's what makes you a murderer. Indiscriminate killing… no sense of morality… no thought given to the consequences of your action. That's what makes us different."
"I was a soldier! You're just a bitter old man out for revenge."
"I am bringing the guilty to justice. And unlike you, I take care to protect the innocent."
:- Kira and Prin
"Don't worry. I promise that I'll take care of the child… and that I'll teach him the difference between darkness and light."
:- Silaran Prin, planning to kill Kira and remove the O'Briens' unborn son from her womb
"He wanted to protect the innocent and separate the darkness from the light. But he didn't realize, the light only shines in the dark, and sometimes innocence is just an excuse for the guilty."
:- Kira, over Prin and his actions
== Background information ==
=== Story and script ===
*For this episode, Ronald D. Moore considered Kira's terrorist past and the series' depiction of it, commenting, "I really wanted to push that one. The idea at that point was Kira had this backstory that she was a terrorist, which was mostly just something she said. Like, 'Oh yeah, I used to be a terrorist.' It didn't have any real meaning to it, and I wanted to lean into that a bit. A terrorist is what? What do they actually do? What were some of the horrible things she did?" Rick Berman was was wary. Moore commented, "There was definitely some reluctance. Rick would get a little leery when you start making the characters look less than ideal, especially after Gene passed away. He would ask, 'Would Gene approve?" 
*For this, his first episode, writer Bryan Fuller originally based it on the 1939 novel (also known as Ten Little Indians). () Ron Moore commented, "I don't recall [Fuller's] exact involvement, the timeline there. But I do remember that he had gone to one of our writing seminars and we bought that pitch and then he did the story, but I wrote the script. Bryan is a genius. And we were lucky to get it because the episode premise was, at the time, for us, really wild and out there," 
*As in the previous episode, , First Minister Shakaar Edon was originally intended to appear in this episode. The idea was again dropped due to budgetary reasons. 
*The themes touched upon in the scenes with Prin and Kira are similar to several scenes in , in which a captured war criminal confronts her about her actions during the Occupation of Bajor.
===Production ===
*This is the first Star Trek episode to be directed by Mike Vejar since , his only TNG directorial credit, almost nine years earlier in . From this point onward, he remained one of the franchise's regular directors until the cancellation of Enterprise in .
*Sisko's combadge flips above and below his grey shoulder pad in between scenes in this episode due to the mixed-use of the incorrectly made jacket from and the new correct one that was used for the remainder of the series.
=== Reception ===
*Of all the episodes Ronald D. Moore worked on, this is one of his favorites, "It really came across as I intended it, and in some ways, much better, a powerful, dark piece of television that ends in a really unexpected way." Moore particularly liked the moral ambiguity of the debate between Kira and Silaran Prin. Of this scene, he commented, "both are right and both of them are wrong." Moore was also very happy that the fact that Kira remained fundamentally Kira in the scene with Prin, that she didn't apologize and acknowledge her own guilt. According to Moore, "typically, when you get into a scene like this in television or even film, your heroine is confronted by the man from her past who's been wronged by her in some way, and usually she'll say 'You know what? I feel bad, too. You're right. I wish I didn't have to do those things that I did. Can't we all just get along?' But that would have been so phony, especially in this situation. So I respect the fact that Kira looked at Prin and said 'Screw you! You expect me to feel sorry for you? Fifteen million Bajorans died in the Occupation. You people were on our land, you didn't belong there, and you were all guilty!' I mean that's pretty bold. You can't say whether it's right or wrong – it's the stance of a terrorist. But it's what I felt Kira absolutely believed at the core of her being." ()
*When Tony Dow directed , he was instructed to watch "The Darkness and the Light", as he was told it was "really the only other show of this type that they'd done." ()
*The Hollywood Reporter ran a retrospective on the episode in 2022. They named the episode as one of DS9′s best outings. The author wrote, "It's Star Treks disturbing take on Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None…, a gripping thriller that pits two murderers and war criminals against each other, with each believing they are 'heroes' in a story that has none — only casualties." 
=== Cast ===
*This episode is the second time the characters of Furel and Lupaza appear. Both had been introduced in the third season episode , and although they both die in this episode, Furel appeared again in s in the episode .
*Randy Oglesby, who plays Silaran Prin in this episode, previously played the Miradorn twins in the first season episode and went on to play Degra in several episodes of .
*Cirroc Lofton (Jake Sisko) does not appear in this episode.
=== Continuity ===
*Rules of Acquisition #111 ("Treat people in your debt like family… exploit them") is referenced.
=== Remastered version ===
*Remastered scenes from the episode are featured in the documentary What We Left Behind.
=== Video and DVD releases ===
*UK VHS release (two-episode tapes, CIC Video): Volume 5.6, 
*As part of the DS9 Season 5 DVD collection
== Links and references ==
=== Guest Stars ===
* Randy Oglesby as Silaran Prin
* William Lucking as Furel
* Diane Salinger as Lupaza
* Jennifer Savidge as Trentin Fala
* Aron Eisenberg as Nog
=== Co-Stars ===
* Matt Roe as Latha
* Christian Conrad as Brilgar
* Scott McElroy as Guard
* Judi Durand as Station Computer Voice
=== Uncredited Co-Stars ===
* Uriah Carr as operations officer
* Brian Demonbreun as sciences officer
* Chris Doyle as Vedek 
* Randy James as 
* Wade Kelley as sciences officer
* James R. Lowe as Bajoran civilian
* Cynthia Merrick as Bajoran civilian
* Chester E. Tripp III as operations lieutenant
* Unknown performers as
** Female sciences ensign
** Mobara
** Multi-colored alien
=== References ===
2356; 2371; ambush; assassination squad; attack; Bajor; Bajorans; Bajoran militia; Bajoran resistance; Bajoran transport ship; banner; black market; blood; Calash Monastery; carcass; Cardassia; Cardassians; Cardassian records office; chair; command code authorization; couch; counteragent; cripple; Dahkur Province; Days of Atonement; debris; Deep Space 9 levels; ; Demilitarized Zone; disruptor blast; dozen; emergency transport; engineering school; energizing coil; executed farmers; finger; freedom; gain; hand; hatch; Hathon; heart; hour; hull breach; hunter probe; informant; integration matrix; ; ion trail; ironing; joke; laceration; latinum; love; makara herb; merfadon; metal; micro-explosive; Mobara; morality; motive; murder; Musilla Province; name; needle; ; ; Occupation of Bajor; PADD; path; pattern buffer; personnel record; phase-divergent carrier wave; phaser; phaser rifle; phrasing; Pirak; placenta; plasma charge; polaron field; power cell; pregnancy; progesterone; Promenade; Prophets; Quark's; ; remat detonator; repentant; Romulans; Rules of Acquisition; runabout; Shakaar base camp; Saurian brandy; security protocol; Shakaar Edon; Shakaar resistance cell; shirt; Silaran Prin's planet; Silaran Prin's planet primary; sinoraptor; skimmer; smuggler; Starbase 63; Starfleet Academy; Stratos; student; subspace antenna; suspect; Talavian freighter; tongo; transport ship; transporter beam; transporter scrambler; transporter security system; tricorder; Vedek; velvet; ; weapon; weapons depot; week
=== Additional references ===
Bernay Prime; ; Cardassia Prime; ; Elkins Judy; Faralos III; ; Galloway sector; Grewler sector; Hoffmeister Ed; ; ; Lauritson Nebula; ; Posell VI; Regent Lipsett; Rossi April; ; 
=== External links ===
*
*
*
*
*
de:Dunkelheit und Licht
es:The Darkness and the Light
fr:The Darkness and the Light (épisode)
ja:一人、また一人、そして…（エピソード）
nl:The Darkness and the Light
pl:The Darkness and the Light
Darkness and the Light, The