Secret Lovers Exchange

The Secret Lovers Exchange was a fic exchange in Supernatural fandom focused on the romantic, or platonic, moresome pairing of Castiel/Gabriel/Dean Winchester/Sam Winchester. Participants had to provide a list of five prompts and another participant would write a fic based on one of those prompts that was at least 2000 words in length.
==Masterlists==
===2010===
Title: After the Storm
Author: morganoconner 
Recipient: viridian_magpie
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Romance, hurt/comfort, Dean/Castiel/Gabriel/Sam
Spoilers: Vaguely through 6.01
Warnings: Foursome, some angst
Word Count: 2800
Notes/Prompts: For the following prompt: “Team Free Will might have been the first in a long time to trap Gabriel in a circle, but they weren't the last. They were, however, the people who found him hurt and bleeding and at the mercy of demons/evil angels/other.” I was given so many amazing prompts to work with, it was hard to choose!! And I’m not entirely sure I hit exactly what you were going for… *bites lip* But I hope you like it, viridian_magpie! :D As always, many thanks to jessebee for being such a wonderful beta!
Summary: Afterwards, Gabriel is pretty sure he’s too broken to be fixed. Team Free Will is going to give it their best shot anyway.
Title: Arise and Sing
Author: raths_kitten 
Recipient: princess_aleera
Rating: PG
Genre and/or Pairing: High School AU, Dean/Gabriel, Sam/Castiel
Spoilers: none
Warnings: none
Word Count: 5,263
Notes/Prompts: Prompt was along the lines of High School AU including a musical. I hope this comes anywhere close to what you wanted.
Summary: Sam and Dean just transferred to a new school and Dean has to join drama club to get some extra credits. Lucky for him, he gets chosen to play the led right away. They play? Dr. Horrible, the musical. Captain Hammer? Gabriel.
Title: Between a Rock and a Hard Place
Author: skyblueadvari 
Recipient: mab
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Sam, Dean/Cas
Spoilers: assuming you know Gabriel and have seen Mystery Spot and Hammer of the Gods, none
Warnings: frottage, rimming, language, mentions of non-con (but no actual)
Word Count: 3188
Notes/Prompts: Written for the prompt Gabe's plan to trap Dean and Cas in the beautiful room, the door only unlocking post-coitus backfires and he's trapped in the room with Sam. The recipient also wanted fluff or flangst, and I think I failed at that. XD The time period here’s pretty vague, but I figure it’s set post-apocalypse, when both Gabriel and Sam have been brought back, and the show’s most recent drama is nonexistent.
Summary: Some botched spellwork leads to trouble for Sam and Gabriel, and Sammy really isn’t too happy about what they’ve got to do to get free.
Title: Chicken Soup for the Hunter's Soul
Author: ratherastory 
Recipient: mizra
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: gen
Spoilers: Spoilers through 6.03, just to be on the safe side
Warnings: None.
Word Count: 7,024
Notes/Prompts: The prompter wanted something to do with a cold and chicken soup, banter between the four characters, and “big brothers and their boyfriends.” I managed two out of three, which I hope is enough. :)
I owe eternal and undying thanks to my two betas, claudiapriscus & yasminke, who are rockstars. They not only beta'd this on ridiculously short notice, but they performed elaborate reconstructive surgery on it and made into a story that was one hundred percent better than the one I originally had. You guys rock my world! *blows kisses*
Summary: A quest for an artifact goes a little off-track with the addition of a new member to the team.
Title: Conversationalists
Author: thinlizzy2
Recipient: placeofinsanity
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: If you know who Castiel and Gabriel are, I think you'll be okay.
Warnings: Dirty talk, smexings
Word Count: 2167
Notes/Prompts: My prompt was: Gabriel keeps things close to the vest; Sam hates it. Thanks to i_sudoku for beta reading this bit of insanity!
Summary: Communication with angelic boyfriends can be... difficult.
Title: Crystal Ball
Author: mithrel 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, implied Dean/Castiel, blink-and-you’ll miss it Michael/Lucifer.
Spoilers: None.
Warnings: Some disturbing imagery.
Word Count: 4,600
Notes/Prompts: Takes place after 5x16. “Something ala The Christmas Carol, where Gabriel is granted visions of his past (Archangel in Heaven), present (Trickster and Archangel on the run) and future (where any chance of redemption is gone if he doesn’t buck up and help out).” Thanks to sycophantastic for the beta.
Summary: He just wants the fighting to stop.
Title: Dewey Decimal Filing for Dummies
Author: gedry 
Recipient: jenab
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Always a girl Sam
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Public sex
Word Count: 2272
Notes/Prompts: library, always a girl Sam
Summary: Sam’s turn to do research; Gabriel tags along. He gets bored easily.
Title: Got My Wings
Author: mizra 
Recipient: a dropout
Beta: mrscastielftw
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Fluff, schmoop and with a dash of snarky humor; Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: Anything up to 5x19, really.
Warnings: Wink!kink, Chocolate Snack Pack, hatred for sparkly vampires and a jazzercise outfit (and warmers... of the leg kind.)
Word Count: ~4,200
Notes/Prompts: Pudding, Jazzercise, Twilight (hate) and wing!kink. First slash story I've ever written and also first fic exchange I've written for. May Chuck have mercy on my blasphemous soul. Title inspired by the song ‘Got My Wings’ by Hazy Malaze and ‘Crossfire’ by Brandon Flowers.
Summary: After a job well done, Dean decides it’s time for a mini-vacation with his brother.
Title: Halo
Author: vlbuehle
Recipient: miya_morana
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Um…halo sex?
Word Count: 2,718
Notes/Prompts: turns out archangels have a halo. Sam and/or Dean is/are fascinated by it, keep(s) asking to see it, to touch it... Castiel tries to warn him/them about how this would be considered inappropriate touching, but Gabriel doesn't mind. At all, if you see what I mean. ;)
Summary: The first time he sees it, it’s an accident.
Title: Heavy Communication
Author: tiptoe39 
Recipient: ladyeternal
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Sam/Gabriel/Castiel and lots of permutations thereof
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Lots of sex among consenting adult males (and angels)
Word Count: 21,200
Notes/Prompts: (Note: each chapter is based on a different prompt.)
1- Dean/Sam/Gabriel/Castiel: foursome PWP. Nekkid boys having nekkid tiems in one of Gabriel's posh little hideaways. Outright Wincest acceptable but not required.
2- Dean/Sam/Gabriel: Dean walks in on Gabriel and Sam; Gabriel invites him to join. Outright Wincest acceptable but not required.
3- Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel: Dean & Cas are having an active sexual relationship but Dean refuses to bottom for Cas. Cas goes to Gabriel for advice after it causes a fight between them. Bonus points if Dean’s reason has nothing to do with machismo/it making him ‘the girl’ or ‘really gay’/other traditional gender-role nonsense.
4- Writer’s choice on angel/Winchester pairs: Gabriel is boinking his Winchester into the mattress every night. Castiel envies him and decides to try seducing the other brother. Bonus points for clueless!Winchester, snarky brother repartee, Cas’ romantic gestures being rather old-fashioned, and Gabriel judiciously applying a clue-by-four before Castiel gives up from pure frustration.
5- Again, writer’s choice on angel/Winchester pairs: the boys either have to use their priest disguises while their angels are along for the hunt or the angels run across the cassocks while the boys are out. Kinks & smexy hijinks ensue. Bonus points for foursome-y pr0n but anything will do.
Thank you to mithrel for an amazing beta!
Summary: The proud few who stopped the apocalypse have a bond too deep for words. They need another form of communication.
Title: Here We Go Again
Author: sephirothflame 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: PG13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, minor Sam/Castiel, implied Sam/Castiel/Dean and Dean/Castiel/Gabriel/Sam
Spoilers: 5.08, “Changing Channels” – only because that’s the episode Gabriel is “introduced.” Canon-compliant, except where it’s not.
Warnings: Slash, Gabriel’s an ass, implied adult situations between more than two consenting adults, implied consensual incest/angelcest, adult language
Word Count: Approx. 2,200
Notes/Prompts: I have nothing to say beyond asdfg and that my beta was fallingemerald. The prompt was [Sam has to save Gabriel – some nice h/c fic. Doesn't really matter the plot as long as Sam has to do something to save Gabe from certain death .]. Like I said, asdfg.
Summary: Gabriel had a plan, but Sam always ruins things.
Title: Highballs and Hormones
Author: wolfish_willow 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Humor/Crack, Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: none
Warnings: excessive silliness
Word Count: ~2300
Notes/Prompts: Once the characters decided to cooperate, I had a ton of fun writing this. For the prompt: gabe finds some sort of liquid maybe holy water? that can get angels drunk hilarity ensues.
Beta’d by ladyeternal who is amazing!
Summary: In which Cas is a horny drunk and Sam finally appreciates Dean’s fear of flying… And it’s all Gabriel’s fault.
Title: Hit The Lights
Author: synnerxx 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: R
Genre: Action, drama, romance, angst, RPF/SPN crossover
Pairing: Misha/Richard
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Slash, kinda sorta sex scene, violence
Word Count: 4,152
Notes/Prompts: I just want to thank dr_jasley for all her help with this fic and I hope you enjoy it, (dropout). I've been a fan of yours, so it was awesome getting your prompt to write for. <3
Summary: Misha and Richard just want to have a nice, romantic week away from the set. Well, you know what they say about the best laid plans of mice and men, don't you?
Title: Household of Three
Author: gedry 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Cas/Sam
Spoilers: none
Warnings: Threesome
Word Count: 2999
Notes/Prompts: Recipient just wanted the pairing.
Summary: Gabriel needs something he can only get from Cas. But Cas is with Sam and isn’t willing to risk their relationship; even for his brother.
Title: An Inconvenient Visit
Author: theinsaneeraser 
Recipient: mithrel
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Slight-Angst, Humor, Schmoop. Gabriel/Sam, minor Dean/Cas (Mentions of past Gabriel/Kali, Gabriel/Sigyn, Gabriel/Svaðilfari). Bobby, Hel, Jörmungandr.
Spoilers: Season five..
Warnings: I tweaked 5x22(Swan Song)’s ending a bit.
Word Count: 2316
Notes/Prompt: Written for the team_free_love "Secret Lover's" Fic-Exchange. I had fun writing this, and thanks to my beta kimisgirl.
Prompt Gabriel’s kids (which ones is up to you) show up looking for him. He’s not at all happy about this, since Sam had no clue about any of them. Cue Sam throwing a jealous fit and Gabriel having to calm him down/convince him Sam’s the most important thing in his life right now.
Summary: Hel and Jörmungandr decide to pay Gabriel a visit, this does not bode well for the Archangel because he hasn’t exactly told Sam about them yet...
Title: In Oh So Many Ways
Author: blueskypenguin 
Recipient: mia6363
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: Up to and including My Bloody Valentine.
Warnings: Shameless PWP. Fluff. Blasphemy.
Word Count: 2025
Notes/Prompts: Based on the blanket forts prompt, and incorporating the wider requests for sleepy!sex, wingplay and a few other gems! Thanks to my epic beta, medium_density.
Summary: Team Free Will wakes in a brand new world and they take the time to enjoy the benefits of their moniker.
Title: It’s A Big Brother Thing
Author: highermagic 
Recipient: carma_baby
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, background Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: None beyond 5.08
Warnings: Smex, Gabriel being awkward, Sam being Sam, and Language
Word Count: 2077
Notes/Prompts: 1.) I'm sorry were not the words he expected to come from Gabriel's mouth. Especially not when followed by a graphic leer and pelvic thrust.
That’s the one I went with. Hope you like (: And…wow, this did NOT turn out, well, like I imagined. :/ I’ll happily write a collateral fic :P
Summary: It’s a big brother thing. Gabriel can’t expect Sam to understand, but he CAN make it up to the guy.
Title: It's Up That I Fell
Author: peppervl 
Recipient: technicallysane
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, minor Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: None
Word Count: 2,966
Notes/Prompts: The angels turn human due to a spell. Hurt/comfort and bumbling attempts by Sam and Dean to get them used to it ensue. This doesn't exactly meet that, but hopefully it's close enough.
Summary: Something turns Gabriel and Castiel human. The road to turning them back isn't exactly smooth.
Title: Just Desserts
Author: wolfling 
Recipient: vlbuehle
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Castiel/Gabriel, Sam/Gabriel, implied Dean/Castiel/Gabriel/Sam
Spoilers: None
Warnings: None
Word Count: 3535
Notes/Prompts: Based on the prompt: "Gabriel cut himself off from the Host and joined the Asgard as Loki. But the Pantheon fell apart as their worshippers waned, and he's spent hundreds of years wandering the world alone. Now he's part of Team Free Will, and for the first time in far too long, he's got a flock again. So how does he react when that flock is threatened?" Not sure if this is what you had in mind but I hope you like it anyway.
Summary: Raven makes inquiries about Gabriel's new companions.
Title: The Little Death
Author: gedry 
Recipient: thunder_nari
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Cas
Spoilers: none
Warnings: Wing fic
Word Count: 2149
Notes/Prompts: - Where do angels go when they die? Gabriel/Castiel if Castiel hadn't been resurrected or in the time before he was resurrected.
Summary: Castiel and Gabriel reconnect unexpectedly after Lucifer ends Cas’ life.
Title: Moral Holiday
Author: tiptoe39 
Recipient: savorvrymoment
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: PWP, Sam/girl!Gabriel
Spoilers: Up to 6x07, “Family Matters,” although it takes place long before then
Warnings: het!
Word Count: about 5500
Notes/Prompts: Gabriel genswap: either he transforms his body to that of a woman, or picks up a new female vessel when he returns from the dead. Then of course has wild, hot, heterosexual sex with Sam. :-D
Beta’d by miya_morana. Thanks hon!
Summary: Sam and Gabriel meet again. They’re both different than they were before.
Title: Of Diners and Mysteries
Author: carma_baby 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: PG
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: Up through Season 5 finale.
Warnings: Let there be boylove!
Word Count: 2,446
Notes/Prompts: The Winchesters sit in a diner discussing their respective angel lovers while Cas and Gabe sit somewhere decidedly more mystical discussing their human lovers. This turned out a little differently than I think you wanted, but I hope that you like it. There might even be some extra scenes cropping up for this later.
Summary: The boys find themselves idly talking about something very important in their life while the angels find themselves in the same situation.
Title: Old Dog
Author: jenab 
Recipient: neotoma
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: General season 5
Warnings: None
Word Count: 2700
Notes/Prompts: Sam and Dean insist that Gabriel stop killing if he's going to work with them. Gabriel finds himself off-kilter when he tries to comply—the Nephillim, the Flood, the firstborn of Egypt—he's been an Angel of Death for so long, what is he when he's not a killer?
Thank you to karaokegal for the beta.
Summary: The Winchesters always ask for too much
Title: The One Before You
Author: placeofinsanity 
Recipient: sephirothflame @ sansdatelimite
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Castiel, Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: Up to 5.08, Changing Channels
Warnings: rimming, some angst, devious!Cas, lack of sufficient preparation? (Is that a warning?)
Word Count: ~4,000
Notes/Prompts: For sephirothflame - who wanted matchmaking. I kind of took this one and ran off with it, so its *close* to what you asked for. With a little more Castiel. :D
Summary: Gabriel tells Cas to let Dean know how he feels, at a loss, Cas asks Sam for his unique understanding into Dean. Gabriel wanted his brother matched up, not Sam.
Title: Operation: Woo Sam Winchester
Author: mia6363 
Recipient: wolfish_willow
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Highschool AU, Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Cas, and some Crowley/Bobby pre-slash
Spoilers: none
Warnings: Warning for sexy times is redundant, right? Also, very mild pre-slash between student (of age) and teacher.
Word Count: about 12k
Notes/Prompts: High School/College AU - Gabriel wants to woo bookish Sam. He enlists the help of Castiel and Dean to do this. This sort of spiraled out of control… so I hope you like it …
Summary: It wasn’t everyday that the loudest kid in the school wooed the quietest nerd in the corner. Then again, not every school was Kripke High.
Title: The Other Channel
Author: dragonlit 
Recipient: raths_kitten
Rating: NC17
Characters/Pairings: Trickster(Gabriel)/Sam, hints of Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: Only if you haven’t seen Changing Channels
Warnings: Strictly PWP, coercion bordering on non-con and restraints, no schmoop, a bit of silliness
Word Count: 3230
Notes/Prompts: Changing Channels interlude, Gabriel pops Sam and Dean (or alternatively just one of them) into the (gay) porn channel, with him starring, of course. This focuses on Sam/Gabriel but definitely in the Trickster guise before Sam knew his real identity. I did throw in a little Dean/Cas hint (please forgive) but hopefully, the fact that Dean was watching Sam/Gabriel will satisfy the threesome request a little.
Summary: The boys find themselves in what Dean had hoped was a Dukes of Hazzard scene but the Trickster has something else in mind, foreshadowing his future role in Casa Erotica. Sam reveals more than he expects Dean ever wanted to know about his little brother and maybe just a little about himself.
Title: Paradise
Author: ladyeternal
Recipient: tiptoe39
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Gabriel, Sam/Castiel, Castiel/Gabriel, Dean/Sam/Castiel/Gabriel
Spoilers: Teeny tiny one for canon S6
Warnings: Wincest, angelcest, partner-swapping, voyeurism, D/s themes, hammock!slash, food!play, chain sex, double penetration, grace!pr0n, wing!pr0n, bondage, plug, threesome, foursome
Word Count: 23,338
Notes/Prompt: Combined prompt: “Send Team Free Will on Vacation” & “King for a Night”; Schmoop Bingo: Vacation
Beta’d by the incredibly supportive morganoconner. Without you, sweetie, I have no idea what I’d’ve done with my recalcitrant muse! ♥ ♥ ♥
Summary: What happens when you put four sexy, virile men (or two men and two angels) with apocalypse-frayed nerves on a secluded island?
Title: Playing Cupid
Author: lonelyphoenix85
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: R (some strong language in chapter 2, hints of naughtiness, but nothing even vaguely explicit – I just can’t seem to figure out how to write it unfortunately!)
Genre and/or Pairing: Total schmoop! Dean/Cas slash, Sam/Gabe slash
Spoilers: Right through to 5x22
Warnings: None
Word Count: 6712
Notes/Prompts: I used prompts 1 and 2 (Sam gets caught reading Fanfiction starring Gabriel, and Dean likes pie...). Also, I tried my best to fix the suckiness of season 5 :-D
Summary: It all started when Gabriel got bored...
Title: Private Showing
Author: moonofblindness 
Recipient: thinlizzy2
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Humor, schmoop, romance, slash Dean/Cas, pre-slash Sam/Gabe
Spoilers: absolutely none
Warnings: top!cas
Word Count: 3570
Notes/Prompts: Prompt: In trying to match Castiel up with the Winchester of his choice, Gabriel finds himself falling for the other one.
Summary: How Gabriel helps Dean realize how Cas feels for him using his usual Trickster style.
Title: The Ruined Bowers of Paradise
Author: neotoma 
Recipient: omphalos and wolfling
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: gen, with implied het
Spoilers: through Season 5
Warnings: disturbing themes and violent intent against infants
Word Count: 6232
Notes/Prompts: "post apoc - Cas and Gabriel protect an Edenlike safe haven and look for more survivors". Beta'd by mikhala_c.
Summary: For if God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down, what hope is there for Heaven?
Title: See You In My Dreams
Author: tinypinkmouse 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: Pg-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Gabriel, very slight Dean/Lisa
Spoilers: 5.22
Warnings: Nothing I can think off. Except a total lack of Sam and Castiel.
Word Count: 2159
Notes/Prompts: While living his apple pie life with Lisa and Ben, Dean discovers a human who looks really familiar. Is Gabriel back from the dead? Wing!Kink, Dean/Gabriel. Well, I'm not sure if I managed to fill the prompt on all accounts, but I did my best.
And huge thanks to [personal profile] unikorento for the amazingly quick beta work.
Summary: Even if Dean believed in coincidences, this would still be a bit too much.
Title: Sola Fide
Author: viridian_magpie
Recipient: jabber_moose
Rating: approaching NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: angst, hurt/comfort, action/adventure, firsttime; Sam/Castiel, Dean/Castiel, hints of Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: S5, mild spoilers for 6.03
Warnings: bonding/claiming, hint of forceful!Gabriel at one point
Word Count: 12,500 words
Notes/Prompts: I used your second prompt "Team Free Will foursome (Trickster!Gabriel style)- Ex: Cas, Dean and Sam need a reminder that they're stronger as a team." Plus a little of #3 "Sam/Cas, Dean/Gabriel (somehow becoming Dean/Cas, Sam/Gabriel)" (I didn't manage to include Dean/Gabriel. Sorry.)
Anyway, this fic goes AU at the end of 5.16: Castiel doesn't leave to drink a liquor store. Dean and Sam take him to a bar - it changes a few things.
Many thanks go to kodamasama for beta-ing.
Summary: "The beatings will continue until morale improves."
Title: Some Like it Hot
Author: gedry 
Recipient: jenab
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Sam
Spoilers: None
Warnings: None
Word Count: 2341
Notes/Prompts: Pagan or angelic courtship/rituals, hot summer nights
Summary: Sam goes for a walk and ends up with more than he planned on getting.
Title: Something Blessed This Way Comes
Author: mab 
Recipient: lonelyphoenix85
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: grace/soul bonding fic, H/C, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: Through season five
Warnings: Wing!kink, Rimming, OOC
Word Count: 2621
Notes/Prompts: Thank you to my fabulous beta nanoochka / the prompts requested were grace/soul bonding, H/C, wing!kink
Summary: Dean is broken and ready to end it all, when Cas comes to rescue him once more from himself by showing him his true worth.
Title: Somewhat Honorable Intentions
Author: princess_aleera 
Recipient: theinsaneeraser
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: angst, apocafic, fix-it!fic, crack, snark and a little fluff thrown in for good measure. Dean, Sam, Castiel, Gabriel, Lucifer, Crowley. Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel, implied Bobby/Crowley.
Spoilers: Through 5.19. AU from Changing Channels.
Warnings: angst, SOB!ish characters at times, death!fic(canon), some language, AU, wing!kink and explicit boy!sex. Um, and Skittles.
Word Count: 8100
Notes/Prompts: I used this prompt: Gabriel likes Sam, but has been hiding his feelings because A) he's pretty sure Sam’s not gay and B) he's an archangel and a Trickster, he doesn’t fall in love...until Sam finds out about Gabriel’s little "thing" and decides to show the archangel just how wrong he is. But! I've also thrown in a couple of the other prompts from the recipient as well. Hope you like it. ;) Thanks a bunch to my lovely betas, [redacted]. You guys are awesome.
Summary: It isn't really a question of when the Trickster started stalking the Winchesters. It's more a question of when they found out.
Title: Sweet Currents
Author: miya_morana 
Recipient: highermagic
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: Season 5
Warnings: None
Word Count: 2363
Notes/Prompts: Gabriel, through helping Team Free Will, gets injured. This involves a lot of blood, which apparently is Archangel joojoo. Sam gets covered in it and suddenly gets powers. Which powers he gets are totally up to you. It’s not exactly powers, but I hope you’ll like it. :)
Summary: What will it take for Dean to finally understand that Gabriel does actually care?
Title: Taming of the Shrew
Author: gedry 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Sam
Spoilers: none
Warnings: none
Word Count: 2113
Notes/Prompts: Sam/Gabriel, Gabriel is shy/reluctant/overthinking. Sam wants him.
Summary: Sam’s new roommate in college has a lot of layers; not all of them are pleasant but Sam wants what’s underneath.
Title: Thread the Light
Author: thunder_nari 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Castiel
Spoilers: up to 5.19 where it goes off track from the show
Warnings: none, I don't think
Word Count: ~3200
Notes/Prompts: I kind of used...hints from a few prompts: -Vulnerable Gabriel, maybe physically injured - Dean and/or Cas help/comfort him, -Team Free Will gets captured - one of them (up to you who) has a fear of restraints, and/or is claustrophobic, -Accidentally caught in a bonding spell, schmoop but also snarky banter follows, -Angels can be fierce and instinctive - what are they like when protective/riled? Wings flaring, losing control over Grace etc
But...seriously, only a bit of inspiration from each of these. Tried to get the likes in there as well. :D
Summary: The subconscious mind of angel's and what they fear the most.
Title: Unknown Territory (or 'You Don't Sext Gabriel Without Consequences, Sam Winchester')
Author: lilchibibunny 
Recipient: lonelyphoenix85
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing(s): Sam/Gabriel with a side of Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: If you've watched the fifth season, you're golden.
Warnings: Soulbonding with a painful start, a little wing!kink, cursing, and Gabriel texting like a third grader.
Word Count: 5,048
Notes/Prompts: The prompts I combined were "grace/soulbonding, Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Cas, and some h/c with wing!kink." I have never written soulbonding before, but it's a prompt I've always wanted to try. I'm a little bit shaky at writing Sam/Gabriel, but I do love them bantering so it's a nice change of pace to give them a go. Thank you for giving me the chance to write this and I hope you like it! :D
Summary: Apparently, Dean and Cas have decided to go ahead and soulbond without telling Sam. The younger Winchester goes to Gabriel for info and ends up getting a first-hand experience.
Title: We can't call people without wings angels (so we call them friends instead)
Author: jabber_moose 
Recipient: gedry
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: (preslash) Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: None
Word Count: 3007
Notes/Prompts: Brotherly bonding with both sets of brothers/ Sam and Dean are the angels.
Also, a huge thank you to zekkass for the beta for my first exchange
Summary: A comment in the heat of the moment turns Gabriel and Castiel human, while Sam and Dean become angels.
Title: Where The Pieces Fall
Author: miya_morana 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: Hammer of the Gods
Warnings: sex !magic, so dub-con for a part of it
Word Count: 2393
Notes/Prompts: For the prompt 1 (spoilers for the fic) Sam/Gabriel or Dean/Castiel in love but don't know it or won't admit it, caught in a sex!pollen and/or fuck or die scenario and don't deal well with it; the other pair must find a way to help them in the aftermath and so discover their own love. I went maybe a little bit off-prompt, and Dean and Castiel are more in the background than I was aiming for, but the spirit is there ! I hope you enjoy. :)
Summary: After being resurrected by God, Gabriel has joined Team Free Will as a penance for all the wrongs he’s done as Loki. On a hunt, he and Sam fall into a deadly magical trap. Fortunately, Gabriel manages to turn the curse into a sexual spell. But things will get worse before they can get better…
Title: “Why Did You Stay?”
Author: jabber_moose 
Recipient: blueskypenguin
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Castiel, Gabriel/Sam (pre-slash)
Spoilers: S5
Warnings: Language, handjob
Word Count: 2032
Notes/Prompts: For blueskypenguin. Many thanks to her for giving me so many prompt possibilities, and making writing this as enjoyable as it was! Why Did You Stay? By the Pipettes
Summary: After the Apocalypse was averted, Castiel and a newly-resurrected Gabriel should return to Heaven. They surprise themselves, as well as Sam and Dean, by staying on Earth
Title: Will the sun forever burn?
Author: sephirothflame 
Recipient: ratherastory
Rating: PG13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel, Bobby
Spoilers: Canon compliant through most of 5.22, “Swan Song” and it doesn’t get back on track after it breaks
Warnings: Slash, angst, hurt/comfort, canon character death, less than canon character deaths and character resurrection, Sam!whump like whoa, Limbo (as in the place), not so much a mental illness as an inability to retain memories caused by the situation, mild violence, vague sexual references, stupidly complicated relationships and brothers
Word Count: 15,363
Notes/Prompts: Firstly, this wouldn’t have been possible without the reassurances of sycophantastic or the amazing beta work by pandionpandeus. Secondly, the title is taken from Alexi Murdoch’s “Breathe”. Thirdly, this was the most amazing pinch hit I’ve ever written and I’m glad I had the chance to do it. I really hope you enjoy, ratherastory and if you don’t, I apologize profusely. The prompts I used were actually a bastardization of all of them, but the focus is mostly on a few key points and are very spoiler-y for the fic: Dean gets Sam back not from Hell, like was prompted, but still back from the dead but there is something wrong with him, Castiel goes incommunicado for long periods of time without warning or apology, Castiel and Dean have been circling around each other for over a year and a half and everyone is starting to get sick of it, Gabriel’s motives for sticking around are mostly unclear, and Sam dies but gets brought back to life. Finally, this was written in two days because I literally could not stop once I started.
Summary: Sam never expected to wake up. He never expected what followed to happen, either.
Title: Winging It
Author: wolfling & omphalos
Recipient: morganoconner
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Sam/Dean, Gabriel/Castiel, Dean/Castiel, Dean/Gabriel, hints
Spoilers: Up to the end of s5.
Warnings: some wincest
Word Count: 18,400
Prompt: 'Gabriel accidentally turns Dean into an angel. Dean is not amused.'
Notes: The 'accidentally' bit kind of got lost on the way, but hope you enjoy it anyway!
Summary: Gabriel teaches Dean a lesson, but everyone ends up learning it.
Title: Working Hard for the Money
Author: emerald_embers 
Recipient: moonofblindness
Rating: R for sex and bad language.
Genre and/or Pairings: Dean/Castiel, Sam/Castiel/Gabriel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: It's an AU, so really, I'd say 5x08 at the latest.
Warnings: Brief references to incest and tentacle porn, some minor drug use.
Disclaimer: This is non-profit fanfiction, I do not own these characters.
Word Count: 4015
Notes/Prompts: Written for the prompts "team free will = boy band" and (briefly) "tentacle porn – go to town".
Summary: Sam keeps attracting boyfriends with musical talent; Dean can't resist stealing one.
Title: You And Me And One Spot Light
Author: technicallysane 
Recipient: synnerxx
Rating: Hard R
Genre and/or Pairing: Mark Pellegrino/Richard Speight, Jr.
Spoilers: just 5x19
Warnings: language, minor sex scene, RPS
Word Count: 2783
Notes/Prompts: Prompt: I would really love some Mark/Richard fic, just because I've never read it, but am really intrigued about it. Perhaps something based on them shooting the death scene in "Hammer Of The Gods"? I based a lot of this—who am I kidding, I based this whole thing off this video of Richard from VanCon. I really hope you like it! I had the idea and then it just wouldn't leave me alone.I watched a bunch of interviews with Marksha but ajkslh I'm not sure if I got his personality right ;; The title is based off the song by Yellowcard.
Summary: "There's something very liberating about having breakfast with Lucifer after he kills you."
Title: You Can't Kill a Liar
Author: savorvrymoment 
Recipient: skyblueadvari
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: 5x22
Warnings: None
Word Count: ~3000
Notes/Prompts: This is fake, and written for skyblueadvari for the Secret Lover Exchange. Hope you enjoy!
Summary: Sam’s in a secret relationship with Gabriel. Dean knows his brother is keeping something from him, and having learned from past experience, he fears the worse. Tension runs high until, of course, the truth comes out.
===2011===
Title: Four's Company
Author: mistalagan 
Recipient: beatlemaniac9
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Cas, Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Cas/Sam/Gabe
Spoilers: Through 5x22, to be on the safe side. AU past 5x19.
Warnings: Polyamory.
Word Count: 2285
Notes/Prompts: Sam/Dean/Cas/Gabriel; They are in a four person relationship. Bobby (and/or John) find out/are told, and struggle to wrap their heads around it.
Summary: Bobby walks in on Dean and Gabriel. It goes downhill from there.
Title: One of Those Nights
Author: h4ppy_fun_b4ll 
Recipient: glenavera
Rating: PG-13 to be safe.
Genre and/or Pairing: Cas/Gabe, Dean, Sam, Crowley
Spoilers: mid-season 5
Warnings: angelcest kisses, mild implied bondage (handcuffs)
Word Count: ~5,500
Notes/Prompts: "A hunt gone wrong leaves Gabriel temporarily without his powers. Being helpless is a completely new experience for him and of course the former trickster gets in trouble and needs to get rescued." I tried to get as much ship as I could in here. XD Also includes a bit of another prompt, "The FBI catches up with the team." Title taken from a song by The Cab, which I listened to a lot during writing.
Summary: As it was, Gabriel was starting to understand the Winchester brothers' hatred of witches.
Title: The Fest Mistake
Author: thinlizzy2 
Recipient: princess_aleera
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Humor (I hope it's funny!) / Dean/Sam/Castiel/Gabriel and combinations therein
Spoilers: Up to 7.02
Warnings: Incest, angelcest, bad song parodies
Word Count: 2892
Notes/Prompts: 2. Foursome!story in any wrapping. Seriously. ANY.
3. Canon! or AU!boys get caught in a musical. Think Once More With Feeling.
The songs used for inspiration were:
1) Belle (Beauty and the Beast)
2) A Friend Like Me (Aladdin)
3) A Step Too Far (Aida)
4) The Internet is for Porn (Avenue Q)
Read them to these tunes; it'll make loads more sense that way! I apologize to the makers of these songs for the musical travesty within. And also to William Shakespeare. Sorry dude.
Summary: A somber reflection on the battle for love, a place in the world and decent ratings.
Title: The Horror of Moon Lake
Author: kijikun 
Recipient: skiing_pelican
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing:Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: none
Warnings: Season 5 AU, injured Sam, Lovecraftian influences
Word Count: 2062
Notes/Prompts: Written for the prompt: A story where they sit in deep shit and Cas goes BAMF. Gabriel is still joking and not taking things seriously at that point. But when Sam gets hurt and shit really hits the fan, Gabriel surprises everyone as he suddenly goes BAMF! and does some serious smiting, showing everyone that he has IS an archangel with angelic wrath.
Summary: It’s all fun and games until tentacle monsters show up.
Title: The Not Very Subtle Plans of Dean Winchester.
Author: sofiwick 
Recipient: mistalagan
Rating: PG-13.
Genre and/or Pairing: Romance, AU. Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel.
Spoilers: Up until stuff revealed in 5x08.
Warnings: mild-moderate profanity
Word Count: 3609.
Notes/Prompts: ‘Matchmaking fic, with Dean as the instigator.’
Betaed by kodamasama
Summary: Convinced his brother is pining after Gabriel, Dean decides to unleash his genius matchmaking plans on the world. Cas just nods along.
Title: haven’t you heard (winning the war)
Author: placeofinsanity 
Recipient: wolfish_willow
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: College!AU, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None, completely ignores canon entirely.
Warnings: Powers!Sam, Powers!Dean, Gabriel.
Word Count: ~4,300
Notes/Prompts: High School/College AU Sam is the shy/stuttering/blushing bookworm and other Gabriel is the awesome/cool/nice guy that he is stuck working with on a project (or some such nonsense :P) - well, I sort of got it right, instead of projects, we’ve got dorm mates.
Summary: Sam’s college experience can be summed up in pretty much one word: Gabriel.
Title: A Little Thing Called “Free Will”
Author: insatiablegrit 
Recipient: licklesoxy
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Lucifer/Gabriel, Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel (hinted)
Spoilers: Up to the end of S5. If you’ve seen Hammer Of The Gods or at least up to that episode then you’re golden.
Warnings: Slash, Wing!kink (if that’s not your thing), and Lucifer being a manipulative bastard (can potentially be read as dub-con)
Word Count: 2044
Notes/Prompts: Based on the prompt “Someone’s got sensitive wings.” This is the first time I’ve written any form Wing!Kink, so please bear with me, and I would like to thank ladyeternal for the beta. You’re awesome.
Summary: Lucifer corners Gabriel on a Winchester trip to the Grand Canyon, and proceeds to use Sam as the archangel's Achilles heel…
Title: Canyon
Author: beatlemaniac9
Recipient: last_winterrose
Rating: M
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: PTSD like symptoms
Word Count: 2,389
Notes/Prompts: I attempted to take all three given prompts: The Grand Canyon, Rainstorm, and Camping. Hopefully I managed it as well as I had hoped. Also, I meant to make it NC-17, but I just wasn’t feeling the sex once I started writing…
Summary: AU. The apocalypse is over, leaving Sam and Dean with their angelic boyfriends, a lot of free time, and a need to de-stress. A trip to the Grand Canyon is in order.
Title: Different Point of View
Author: thunder_nari 
Recipient: a dropout
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: AU; Gabriel/Castiel
Spoilers: none
Warnings: mild-moderate language
Word Count: ~5, 500
Notes/Prompts: A pre-series AU, from when the Winchesters were Weechesters. Sam is 14 in this fic, which puts Dean around 18. Based on this prompt: Castiel and Gabriel take a break from being angels and decide to live amongst humanity for a while. Curtain!fic! Complete with schmoop (I think) and happy endings. I hope you like it!
Beta'd by slartibartfast
Summary: Gabriel just wants to catch a break. Castiel makes the mistake of standing out. Sam and Zachariah both get duped by each other.
A tale of why angels shouldn't vacation on Earth.
Title: Blue Foil and Other Colors
Author: lenfantsavage 
Recipient: placeofinsanity
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Cas
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Slash and naked boys. Lots of implied sex. Handjob.
Word Count: 2004
Notes/Prompts: Sam/Castiel, Dean - how to break it to the other brother. I added an appearance by Gabriel, since this is Team Free Love.
Summary: Sam worries about telling Dean about himself and Cas.
Title: Unchained Memories
Author: glenavera 
Recipient: lynndyre
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: gen with a slight slash tendency between Castiel and Gabriel, Dean/Castiel implied, Sam, Bobby
Spoilers: it helps if you have seen all episodes up to Changing Channels, otherwise none
Warnings: angst, emotionally and physically hurt Gabriel
Word Count: 5.693
Notes/Prompts: Recipient wanted angel-focused hurt/comfort (especially if Gabriel is worse off than Castiel and less likely to tell anyone so). I tried (as requested) for hurt/comfort, brotherly caring, found/chosen families, banter, wings, pretty man fainting, Gabriel and Castiel seeing each other as family and rescues. Not sure if I managed to get it right, but I hope I didn’t miss the point completely.
Summary: Some stones are better left unturned.
Title: Meanings of Pride
Author: loveinstars 
Recipient: thunder_nari
Rating: PG-15
Genre and/or Pairing: Castiel/Sam, Dean, Gabriel, Bobby, Azazel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Uh, it’s a Lion King remake.
Word Count: 7,750
Notes/Prompts: I chose their last prompt which was just to pick any Disney movie and rewrite it. In turn, I picked the Lion King. I couldn’t resist. Huge thanks to my goddess of a beta, you know who you are! <3
Summary: The Pride Lands are in trouble and their king has gone missing. Gabriel could never have guessed that his dreams would be part of the key to saving everything.
Title: Sea Breezes and Sun Kissed Feathers
Author: jenab 
Recipient: ladyeternal
Rating: NC 17
Genre and/or Pairing: PWP, Dean/Castiel/Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Multiple partners, partner swapping, hints of Wincest.
Word Count: 6,000
Notes/Prompts: For the prompt: Nekkid boys having nekkid tiems in one of Gabriel's posh little hideaways.
Major thanks to krystalicekitsu and secondplatypus for their wonderful betaing services at the last moment. All mistakes are my own.
Summary: Gabriel and Castiel whisk Sam and Dean off for a much needed vacation.
Title: Simple Life
Author: moushkas 
Recipient: h4ppy_fun_b4ll
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Humor/Fluff Dean/Castiel, hints of Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: It’s a subtle AU of post Season 7, episode 1. You know, if things turned out happy in the end
Warnings: Just a bad story, awful, awful! I’m ashamed!
Word Count: 3400
Notes/Prompts: “TFW takes newly human Cas on a grocery shopping trip” and “Halloween candy”
Summary: “What is candy corn?” “It’s corn that tastes like candy.” “You mean candy that tastes like shit!”
Title: Ora e Sempre 
Author: ladyeternal 
Recipient: tiptoe39
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Castiel, Samifer/Gabriel (past), Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: Unlikely past Season 5, but all aired episodes to be safe
Warnings: Graphic violence, references to dub-con, temporary character death, angst out the kazoo, unapologetic Deus ex machina
Word Count: 3,760 – this part; 20,860 total
Notes/Prompts: Prompt: “2014!Dean and 2014!Cas meet up with Gabriel, who in this timeline never revealed himself as an angel. The ‘Trickster’ says he has valuable intel on how to beat the devil, but can he be trusted?”
I never thought I’d ever write a fic actually set in The End!verse; that timeline is usually too dystopian for my tastes. And then this prompt came along and smacked me in the head.
Summary: “If you want a happy ending, that depends, of course, on where you stop your story.” – Orson Welles
Title: Ship Wars
Author: aleishapotter 
Recipient: thinlizzy2
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel cracky gen with slight Gabriel/Becky, implied (on Becky’s part) Sam/Dean, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: for any episode that has aired to be safe. There are bits from random Cas episodes plus some made up scenes that should have been in the episodes, in my opinion. :-)
Warnings: oh boy... um, crack, language, very mild offscreen smut scene. Language. Don’t know why the f word comes out so much in my writing... shrug and the use of the word ‘cockzilla’. That totally deserves a warning.
Word Count: 2254
Notes/Prompts: “Gabriel was the one sending Chuck his visions. Would love Gabriel/Becky here.” I hope this is what you had in mind, or something close to it! Enjoy!
Summary: Gabriel and Becky go head to head when it comes to Supernatural OTP’s...
Title: Basic Control
Author: licklesoxy 
Recipient: insatiablegrit
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel (implied), Friendship, Angst
Spoilers: 07x01 (Meet the New Boss)
Warnings: Mild swearing
Word Count: 4,922
Notes/Prompts: Gabriel's soul was one of the many consumed by Castiel when he became God. The archangel takes advantage of the situation as he attempts to communicate with Castiel and bring him to his senses.
Summary: Castiel had not expected there to be anyone within Purgatory that he would recognise. When it turns out there is, he must figure out what to do.
Title: don’t mess with a dirt journalist
Author: skiing_pelican 
Recipient: loveinstars
Rating: T (some swearing)
Genre and/or Pairing: pre Sam/Gabe, pre Dean/Castiel, Chuck/Becky
Spoilers: some character spoilers
Warnings: AU, case!fic (kind of), humor, hurt/comfort, pre-slash,
Word Count: ~8000
Notes/Prompts: AU, Gabriel is a dirt journalist (digs up scandalous info on celebrities) and his best friend Chuck is a writer who has a really popular novel about two brother's struggles against an abusive father, traumatic occurrences and how they manage to stick together no matter what to overcome their childhood. Then Chuck introduces him to a childhood friend, Sam Winchester, a man who bares an odd familiarity for Gabriel until he realizes this man's life is one that inspired Chuck's book. Gabriel/Sam. Bonus: Dean/Castiel, Chuck/Becky
I really hope you like this story, that it's not too far off the prompt and that pre-slash is ok! I'm participating for the first time in an exchange, so I'm really nervous...
Note: The Winchesters are hunters, Gabriel and Castiel Novak are brothers. Crowley is not a demon.
Huge thanks to my beta lefty_spit and supernatgeekgrl!
Summary: Gabriel wants to get revenge on a fellow dirt journalist for a mean critique. When Gabe runs into unexpected troubles, Chuck calls an old friend for help.
Title: Just Breath
Author: dragonlit 
Recipient: lenfantsavage
Rating: PG13
Genre and/or Pairing: Angsty Dean/Gabriel, Pre Sam/Castiel
Spoilers: To 5.22
Warnings: Dean/Gabriel, Pre Sam/Castiel
Word Count: 2703
Notes/Prompts: AU set right after Season 5. This turned out a great deal more PG and angsty than I had anticipated and my apologies for that.
Prompts
* Dean/Gabriel
* Team four-way wherein the angels are surprised by Dean and Sam's comfortable Wincest.
* Pre-Season 6 finale, or AU from the end of Season 5.
* The angels are fascinated by the Winchester's scars in their own way. (Sam would have more since Cas healed all of Dean's old ones bringing him back from hell).
* Dean shows the others where his old scars where, and remembers the feel, size, and story behind all of them.
Summary: After the apocalypse was averted, Dean finds himself in the hospital. Sam has been pulled from Lucifer’s cage by a resurrected Castiel. In the drugged haze of the hospital stay, the also resurrected Gabriel visited Dean, a visit that Dean is unsure he wishes to remember.
Title: Monastic (Dis)Orders
Author: lynndyre 
Recipient: sofiwick
Rating: Teen
Genre and/or Pairing: Medieval AU, Gabriel/Sam, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: None beyond who Gabriel is.
Warnings: Descriptions of violence and Trickster-induced death.
Word Count: 3,077
Notes/Prompts: Sam should file a complaint for sexual harassment, not get off on Gabriel, his co-worker, inappropriately touching him. This turned out more 'investigation' than 'molestation', but I think Gabriel still came through pretty clear. ♥
All the drawings Gabriel does on Sam's work are taken from actual illuminated manuscripts. Even the bird.
Summary: In which Samuel and Dean answer Sheriff Robert's summons to investigate the abbey and town of Aberstoft, and Brother Gabriel is a very earthly monk.
Title: Secrets from Ourselves
Author: krystalicekitsu 
Recipient: aleishapotter
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: Season 5
Warnings: None
Word Count: 2,488
Notes/Prompts: See end; story spoilers.
Summary: Gabriel only stared, water dripping down his nose and off and Sam doesn't know, to this day, what made him stop and consider it, give it more than the three seconds consideration that his brain required to process the words and laugh at the absurdity of them.
He only remembers the hissing as the flames went out. Watching the drops pool and glide over an oily ring scorched into a warehouse floor. Being sure that this was going to top the list of Sam's Greatest Fuck-Ups. The alien feeling of his lips moving without his realization.
Title: All You Need Is Love
Author: last_winterrose 
Recipient: moushkas
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: SLASH, unprotected sex, and masturbation (Just to play it safe)
Word Count: 5,690
Prompts: Prompt 3: I'd like a human!AU where Sam/Gab and Dean live in an apartment where Dean may have some unresolved romantic issues for Gab but gets over it when he meets Cas. The interactions with Gab can be sexual or nonsexual, I just want him to sacrifice himself for Sam and then be more happy with Cas ~,^
Notes: First off I would like to say that I’m not that good with title. I would like to thanks ladyeternal for being such a wonderful beta and to moushkas I hope you like it. :D
Summary: human!AUAfter Dean's roommate moves out he agrees to let his younger brother Sam move in with him since it's Sam first year in collage. However when he agrees that Sam's boyfriend can move in too he never thought that it would be Gabriel, an old crush from school.
Title: I Could Love You For Tonight (and Tomorrow)
Author: princess_aleera 
Recipient: For a drop-out
Rating: NC-17 for graphic sex
Characters: Gabriel, Castiel, Sam, Dean, Balthazar, brief snake!Crowley(no, really)
Genre and/or Pairing: Gabriel/Castiel (graphic, main), Castiel/Sam(brief) Gabriel/Castiel/Sam, Dean/Balthazar (brief, not graphic)
Spoilers: Completely AU, so if the name Balthazar says anything, you’re good.
Warnings: all human!AU, discussions of past drunkenness, a lot of sex, threesome, drunk sex and discussions of a threesome relationship. Crack and fluff. Glasses!Castiel?
Disclaimer: Nope, I don't own SPN, or any of that.
Word count: ~ 5,000
Notes/Prompts: Vaguely a mix between these two: ‘The guys wake up after a night on the town, and have to find out what happened piece by piece’ and Dean, Sam, Gabriel, Castiel, Balthazar and Lucifer all on cruise/vacation… what do they get up to?’ I’m sorry, no Luci, but I did manage to put Crowley in there in a small role (pun intended), so I hope you forgive me.
Thanks to my beta, and so much thanks to the mods who bore with my lateness and other stuff. Especially ladyeternal who is awesome and even helped me get rid of the minor writer’s block I got on this story. (Even if she probably doesn’t know that. Heh.) <3
Summary: Where there is a snake in the cupboard, everyone is very hung over, and Gabriel just slept with his best friend.
Title: Missing You
Author: wolfish_willow
Recipient: jenab
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Angst // Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: The whole of season 5, specifically 5x19 and on.
Warnings: Canon character death, tweaking canon to suit my needs.
Word Count: 3,456
Notes/Prompts: I read all the prompts I was given and despite how sad this one is, it was the one that wouldn't let me go and kept ideas circling around in my head from the minute I looked at it. For the prompt: What happens to the one left behind in a bonded/mated relationship when the other dies.
Summary: Dean looks pained with deep lines crinkling his brow and his lips turned down at the corners. It's the face he wears when he wants to hold back and protect his little brother from whatever he has to say but knows there isn't any other choice.
Title: Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Angel Sex (but Were Afraid to Ask)
Author: tiptoe39 
Recipient: kijikun
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: Gabriel’s an angel. Surprise.
Warnings: MPREG-ish themes but not explicitly or specifically MPREG.
Word Count: about 4,000
Notes/Prompts: Wing grooming. Bonus points for oil glands. (also requested: egg!fic, fledgelings, wing!fic, bonding, mating) Thank you to cashay for the beta!
Summary: Gabriel gives Sam a lesson in the ins and outs of celestial biology.
Title: The Lengths I Would Go For You
Author: aleishapotter 
Recipient: dragonlit
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Cas, some mild pre/unrequited Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: all of season six, possibly for some part of 7.01, but not sure. If it’s there, it’s vague and by accident.
Warnings: m/m sex, rimming, dub/con, sex magic, sex pollen, Godstiel
Word Count: ~4700
Notes/Prompts: Gab, who has been floating around the ether after Lucifer ganked him, hears Dean's call. He wonders what the hell Dean means by "Cas is the new and twisted God" but pulls himself together to help the brothers and to help redeem Cas. It might involve seducing Cas, flashbacks to millennium ago when Cas's big brother mentioned something about not stepping on that fish. I couldn’t figure out how or when to put in the flashback, the muse just wasn’t cooperating. I hope this is what you were looking for! Enjoy bb!!
Summary: With nowhere left to turn, Dean prays and Gabriel answers. The Archangel brings more answers than Dean ever dared to hope for. A way to save both Sam and Cas. But, were things EVER this easy for him? What was the catch?
Title: Unhealthy Being the Operative Word
Author: princess_aleera 
Recipient: aleishapotter
Rating: NC-17/PWP-ish
Characters: Jensen Ackles, Misha Collins, Jared Padalecki, Richard Speight Jr.
Genre and/or Pairings: Misha/Jensen, or Castiel/Dean depending on how you see it, Jared/Richard
Spoilers: I think this takes place some vague place in season 6, but there are no real spoilers beyond Richard’s role. Also, just pretend there aren’t any wives in the picture, mkay?
Warnings: character bleed like whoa, rimming, lots of sex, brief mention of foursome!fic, very brief mention of wincest (fic, not actual), bottom!Misha/Cas, rimming, not-really—fuck-or-die, light tie-porn, implied priest!kink and spanking, crack.
Word count: ~ 4,000
Disclaimer: Nope, I don't own SPN, and I don’t know the guys that play in it either. Unfortunately, slavery is frowned upon in modern society.
Notes/Prompts: actors dealing with fandom; I’d love to see Misha or Richard caught writing slash fics with the Dean/Cas or Sam/Gabe pairing. I was also inspired by this, although I tweaked it a LOT: forced soulbonding. Love it when two are forced into sexytimes/bonds when neither really wants it.
- IDEK what happened here. Basically it’s porn. It’s Misha and Jensen having fuck-or-die sex as Dean and Cas. I’m sorry there isn’t more Jared and Rich. Hope you still like it!
Summary: Where Misha trolls the spn kink meme, he and Jensen give their characters a happy ending, Jared wants to be kinkier than his co-stars, and Richard is very happy with this development.
===2012===
Title: A Little R-Rated R&R
Author: dehavilland
Recipient: lover_of_angst
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Hurt/Comfort, Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Sexytimes, language.
Word Count: 4,358
Notes/Prompts: “A really nasty hunt leaves all four of the boys in need of a break. Physically and emotional drained they head to an old cabin Dean remembers from their childhood to 'get off the grid' for a few weeks. Fun and relaxing ensue. ;-)” Beta read by the lovely Mindelan! (Off-line, in the magical realm of real life. With actual red pens and everything.)
Summary: Dean figures a day or two off the grid after nearly being sacrificed in some kind of hoo-doo monster summoning is probably a good idea. Unfortunately, the old hunting cabin’s not exactly equipped to handle their kind of injuries. They might have to get creative.
Title: The Insurmountable Enemy
Author: thinlizzy2
Recipient: dehavilland
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Sam/Gabriel, crackfic
Spoilers: To the end of season 7
Warnings: Sexual innuendo, angst, mention of angst, full-frontal angst, angsting without a license to angst.
Word Count: 2345
Notes/Prompts: Written for the prompt “deprogramming.” Thanks to T for the beta read!
Summary: Gabriel has had enough of this bullshit.
Title: Carry On But Don't Blink
Author: moonbeamdancer
Recipient: licklesoxy
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Crack, pure and simple, no pairing.
Spoilers: None, really.
Warnings: If you know who Gabriel and the Doctor are, you're good to go.
Word Count: 2,057
Notes/Prompts: Changing Channels: Gabriel decides to send the brothers into Doctor Who, Stargate Atlantis, or Sherlock. Beta'd by cynassa.
Summary: Takes place during "Changing Channels", the Trickster throws the boys into a episode of Doctor Who.
Title: When Our Days Overlap
Author: sharys_aogail
Recipient: rubystandish
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Mild Language, kissing, and Diabetes-Inducing Fluff
Word Count: 3989
Notes/Prompts: I originally had two different stories, stemming from two of the three prompts given to me, but I hit a rut on both of them. Then an idea struck and I sort of mashed them together to get this. I give to you my first Supernatural Fanfic ever, so I hope it’s to your liking.
Summary: In which Sammy is suspicious, Gabe is being uncharacteristically responsible, Dean makes an attempt at being meaningful, and Cas clarifies the specifics.
Title: Of Harps And Halos.
Author: lilithrain
Recipient: lynndyre
Rating: NC-17.
Genre and/or Pairing: Lucifer/Sam.
Spoilers: None, it's AU.
Warnings: hurt/comfort, temporarily comatose Winchesters; both Sam and Dean.
Word Count: 6,528.
Notes/Prompts: Prompt: Xeno, angels as a different species that interacts with humanity.
Tropes/genres/kinks: Hurt/comfort, manly friendship, moments of intense emotional connection, non-sexual intimacy, angst that gets better, furry/xeno, moments of angels being genuinely holy/shiny/awesome, wings/haloes.
Summary: After an almost fatal hunt, the brothers Winchester; Sam and Dean, awoke to find themselves with some of the nicest creatures they could have ever found. Except the big fluffies found them. Tended and cared for them, like they were their own, and for one very simple reason. For one simple reason, that the Big Fluffies do what they do; Love. They love what they do, and love to help others. That isn't the only form of love going around in their territory either.
Title: Wedding Bells
Author: verucasalt123
Recipient: thinlizzy2
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: Het, Meg/Cas
Spoilers: S7 general
Warnings: curse words
Word Count: ~2,050
Notes/Prompts: Meg/Cas; my big fat angelic/demonic wedding
Summary: Team Free Love helps one of their members embark on a new journey.
Title: The One Ring Letter
Author: cashay
Recipient: princess_aleera
Rating: PG
Genre / Pairing: Curtain Fic/College!AU | Sam/Dean/Gabriel/Castiel
Spoilers: none
Warnings: none
Word Count: 2260
Notes/Prompts: I tried to combine your love for College!AUs and Curtain Foursome Fic, enjoy! <3
Thank you to my beta casness I have no clue what I'd do without you :)
Summary: Sam has waited month to hear back from Stanford, now that the letter has finally arrived he is anything but excited.
Title: The nature and kynde of a lyon.
Author: whit_merule
Recipient: sharys_aogail
Rating: NC-17.
Genre and/or pairing: Slash. Alpha/beta/flock fic. AU: all angels.
Sex scenes are Dean/Gabriel and Castiel/Dean. Other established relationships exist - most importantly, as Gabriel is the alpha of the flock, he and his two betas are in an established sexual relationship with everyone else in the flock (including each other), excepting the underaged characters.
Spoilers: None.
Warnings: Wow. This list looks heavy. See the notes below for a bit of context on how these things are handled and how they fit into the tone of the story. I promise it’s not actually as angsty as this makes it sound. Meanwhile, hover over underlined text for (spoilery) specifics about character and circumstance, if that’s likely to be a dealbreaker for any of these warnings.
The could-be-a-trigger warnings: Reference to past consensual sex between under-aged participants (both fifteen), and to past non-con and attempted non-con between under-aged participants (15) and an adult in a position of power. Sex used as a means of social dominance – negatively in the past, positively in the present, although there is a sense that it always has the potential for accidental or intentional abuse. Sex as a biological imperative (heat, in which the body demands sex with the flock alpha and/or betas).
The maybe-not-your-cup-of-tea warnings: Fraternal incest in a socially permitted context (between the alpha and his betas as a means of sealing social bonds). Alpha/beta/flock dynamics, including knotting, self-lubrication (in all sexually mature male characters), heat, biting and marking (sometimes breaking the skin, so slight bloodplay), sub/dom moments in sex scenes, and other negotiation of power dynamics (though with significant attempts from the leader of the flock to set up a system that eases the biological power imbalance). Virginity (more or less). Scenes of caring for infants, and one scene including some of the less dignified aspects of aged care.
Word count: 30 000.
Notes: Betaed by dywalgi.
... So. This world got away from me and grew Issues. The fic explores some of the problems of power dynamics implicit in the alpha/beta/flock social model, especially where sex can be used as a tool for emotional and social control. The characters are, therefore, working to find a balance between biology and culture, the innate and the learned, the body and the mind. Because I like my characters and I didn’t want to go that dark, all actual abuses of that power are firmly in the past, and the character who perpetuated them is dead. However, the central characters of this fic, and the community in which they live, are still working their way through the after-effects of this. The overall tone is a combination of porn-with-plot and fluff with bonus angst and protective-boys – no one is as badly broken as they are in canon or suffers from PTSD – but there are definitely references to past events that could be triggery for some people, and some of the characters’ ways of dealing with their history may also be difficult to deal with for anyone recovering from childhood or sexual abuse. (Sam, Castiel, and Dean were all minors at the time, and the effects of it on them were mostly to emphasise or develop character traits that we see in them in canon – Sam’s difficulties with trusting anyone outside his immediate family despite having charming and easy manners, for example, and Dean’s over-protectiveness when it comes to people who are ‘his’.)
Prompts:Answers to the ‘protective’, ‘flock fic’, ‘Gabe/Cas’, ‘hurt/comfort’, ‘fluff’, ‘angst with a happy ending’ and sort of ‘wing-kink’ and ‘light bondage’ prompts-and-requested-genres-and-kinks-and-so-on. May even contain traces of the ‘it takes a village to raise a child’ prompt, though probably not as it was intended!
Summary: Even at fifteen, slim-winged and slim-bodied and with bruises on his face and body that Gabriel didn’t have to ask about, Dean hadn’t been the kind of person you could laugh off when he made you a demand like that. Gabriel had given his promise, to this bedraggled bull-headed kid who’d walked into his land and told him what to do; had given it even though he’d known better than Dean what it meant. Come back with us. Challenge another alpha, one who’d made violence and power a way of life. Kill the angel who'd killed John Winchester. Step up to the plate in another broken flock, this one almost entirely made up of strangers who had no reason to trust Gabriel or to tolerate his mistakes (strangers to whom an alpha was a dangerous thing), and try to pull them together again. And never, never screw up. Never let down a single person.
Title: Burgers and Cuddles
Author: chef_geekier
Recipient: nicole_sill
Rating: PG
Genre and/or Pairing: College!AU polyamorous Dean/Gabe/Sam/Cas
Spoilers: N/A
Warnings: Incestuous foursome (nothing more graphic than snuggling), much rambling explanation of the situation.
Word Count: 2,010
Notes/Prompts: Sort of a mash-up of a prompt about Gabriel feeling short, and your like of college AU. Hope you enjoy!
Summary: “The only thing that really annoys him is the fact that there's no freaking privacy to lick your wounds in peace when you have three boyfriends living with you.” Gabriel is upset about feeling short. His partners don't like it when Gabriel's upset. This calls for burgers and cuddles.
Title: A Mission of Mercy
Author: dehavilland
Recipient: cashay
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Angst, Hurt/Comfort, Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Language, Slavery, Abuse
Word Count: 3,703
Notes/Prompts: “Sam and Dean have never supported Slavery (matter of fact they were part of the abolitionist movement) but when Dean comes across an abused angel he just has to buy him. Meanwhile Sam is busy with Gabriel, an angel they freed who doesn't feel like leaving.”
Beta read by the lovely Mindelan! (Off-line, in the magical realm of real life. With actual red pens and everything.)
Summary: After springing Sam’s angel out of the auction house, Dean returns to see what he can do with what little money they have left. Angels left in the dumpster are free, right?
Title: Mortal Angels
Author: sofiwick
Recipient: lilithrain
Beta: kodamasama
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Romance, angst. Dean/Castiel, possible pre-slash Sam/Gabriel?
Disclaimer: These characters do not belong to me. I am making no profit from this fanfiction.
Spoilers: Up to season 5
Warnings: None I can think of
Word Count: 2,040 words
Prompt: "Two angels in the pit of despair. It's not much fun when you're among the very few angels left in the world. Cue Winchesters being awesome with their respective angels."
Summary: Season 5-ish. In a lake in California, Castiel tries to cope with the fact his brothers and sisters are dead. Having Dean Winchester for a friend helps a lot.
Title: Like Winchesters for Chocolate
Author: tiptoe39
Recipient: xsnappapplex
Rating: R for heavy makeouts/extended but not explicit sex scenes
Genre and/or Pairing: Romance, Humor - Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Aphrodisiac-induced sex, potential dubcon.
Word Count: 9500
Notes/Prompts: Usually I try very hard to hit all the points in a prompt, but this time three of your prompts sort of melded together into an amorphous whole. This has elements of the candy shop AU idea and the sex-pollen idea, along with your four required lines. I hope you enjoy it. Thanks to akadougal for the beta!
Summary: Castiel doesn’t want to join his brother Gabriel in the family business (feeding people, sweetening things). So Gabriel hires Castiel’s crush, Dean, as a candy-making apprentice. But it turns out that when Dean makes sweets, they turn out... special.
Title: Third
Author: nicole_sill
Recipient: sofiwick
Rating: R
Genre and/or Pairing: College AU. Gabriel/Sam with Prince Dean/Knight Castiel in the background.
Spoilers: AU, so none
Warnings: happy fluff and badly imitated middle English.
Word Count: 2000+
Notes/Prompts: based off the recipient's love of AUs, fluff, medieval drama, and gay is okay universes. Mostly her first prompt asking for the tale of Prince Dean and his Knight Castiel and how they defeated the King of Hell so they could be married. Beta’d by chef_geekier
Summary: Sam Winchester fell in love with Gabriel when he taught him classic literature in college. How better to propose to the man he loves then through his favorite of the Bard's plays?
Title: Play Fair
Author: licklesoxy
Recipient: moonbeamdancer
Rating: PG
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Gabriel (implied)
Spoilers: None.
Warnings: Mild swearing.
Word Count: 3,879
Notes/Prompts: Betaed by lover_of_angst. Thank you! Prompts used: 'Halloween' and 'Vampires'.
Summary: Dean won a bet, meaning Sam has to celebrate Halloween with him. Castiel and Gabriel joining their celebration was not a part of the plan, but they end up coming along for the ride anyway.
Title: Coyote Dreams
Author: lynndyre
Recipient: chef_geekier
Rating: PG-13, along the lines of the show
Genre and/or Pairing: Elements of Dean/Gabriel and Dean/Castiel
Spoilers: None beyond S5, references some elements of 'The French Mistake'
Warnings: Portrayal of mythical figures that is based more on animal behavior and SPN ideas of pagan gods than actual mythology. SPN-level violence. Dream death, and dream angst, but happy endings. ^.^
Word Count: 3769
Notes/Prompts: This has elements of 'TFL as animals', 'Gabriel de-aged', 'TFL in college', and 'Gabriel wakes up in Misha's bedroom after Hammer of the Gods' all wrapped up as a fixit for HotG. I had ideas for so many of your prompts! I hope you like it. ♥
Lots and lots of thanks to my beta, who knows who she is.
Summary: Dean and Sam want Gabriel back. Kali knows a guy.
Title: Roles in the Show
Author: lover_of_angst
Recipient: mistalagan
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Gen, Humor
Spoilers: None, this just takes place at a random time, in a random place when the boys aren't trying to stop the world from ending and are just taking care of the family business.
Warnings: Language, we know how Dean & Gabriel are ;-)
Word Count: 3047
Notes/Prompts: “A gen fic, (maybe a casefic?) where we see the four work together/around each other with their own strengths, etc. without any pairing. Feel free to include other characters, but the focus should be on their relationship. (Angels can be depowered if needed.)” Beta'd by the wonderful Ladyofdarkness in the real world with a bright red sharpie (it was a bit frightening).
Summary: A simple hunt, with a simple monster shouldn't be anything to difficult for the brothers that have saved the world, literally, more times then they carried to remember. Now that the Winchester Brothers are not a hunting team of two, but four how will the jobs and roles on a hunt be divided. Can the boys and their angels learn to work together in a smooth, as smooth for them that is, unit?
Title: Let them be joyful: let them sing aloud upon their beds.
Author: whit_merule
Recipient: tiptoe39
Rating: Explicit
Genre and/or Pairing: Main pairings Castiel/Dean and Gabriel/Sam; but they are in the process of moving towards wholesale TFL. All the other permutations are in various stages of development in this fic, with Wincest being the least advanced - enough that Dean can pretend it isn’t there at all. Mouseover for participants in the sex scene, if desired.
Spoilers: Vague for season 5. Passing reference of two characters from season 7.
Warnings: Angelcest, and pre-Wincest thoughts. For those of Dean’s mindset regarding food, I should probably also include a warning for meat-free lasagne (Castiel’s still squeamish about red meat, I’m afraid!
Word Count: 7800.
Notes/Prompts: “Send the boys on vacation. Give them a break. Let them relax, let it all hang out, get their freak on a bit. Where and how is up to you. Just give them some time off and see where that utter lack of stress and danger takes them emotionally.” Note: This fic is set in my In His Image verse (LJ, AO3, DW), but, given the secret nature of this challenge, there isn't any prior knowledge required, or any specific reference to events that take place in the main fic or elsewhere in the verse. It's basically just edging-towards-foursome Christmas fluff.
Summary: In which it is their first Christmas together after sticking Michael and Lucifer into the Cage, and Gabriel decides that it is absolutely necessary to go carol-singing. Also there is now mistletoe growing all over every ceiling in the house, because who’s going to argue with mistletoe?
Title: Vier.
Author: xsnappapplex
Recipient: lethiaw77
Rating: NC-17
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Cas/Gabe/Sam
Spoilers: None
Warnings: Barebacking, oil!Kink, gland!kink, wing!kink, bottom!Sam (top Gabe), bottom!Cas (top Dean), could potentially be read dub-connish
Word Count: 3,520
Notes/Prompts: Take my prompts and run with them wherever they lead you: Wing!kink would love it if two were angels and the other two got wings from mating (can be 2 pairs, or poly amory SPN or RPS). Really with a focus on grooming and erotic play with the wings/ a four-way alpha/beta/omega polyamory.
Summary: Angels were created to hold all things in common and in an misguided attempt at helping, the boys call Gabriel in to deal with Castiel's seemingly sudden 'illness' and inadvertantly trigger a mating frenzy. (Nothing but smut, really.)
Title: Family Fun Day... or Something Like That
Author rubystandish
Recipient: last_winterrose
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: Humor, slight Sabriel & Destiel
Spoilers: None, just the angels having some fun and dragging their hunters along for the ride.
Warnings: Language, we've all heard Dean when he gets mad, and Cass has picked up some bad habits.
Word Count: 2,273
Notes/Prompts: Sam and Dean get a “day off” from hunting and just want to stay in bed but their angels have other plans. This could lead to a fun filled day in theme parks, the zoo, etc. with Sam and Dean trying to just get some sleep, or wherever else your mind takes you. Beta'd by the lovely viviantanner
Summary: A vampire nest, orders from Bobby and two months of none stop hunts have lead Sam and Dean to the plan of sleeping for a week, or two in their current hotel room. However their angels have other plans and a day full of adventures and fun soon reminds the winged lovers that their mates are only human and really do need to get some sleep.
Title: We’ll Find a Way
Author: last_winterrose
Recipient: jenab
Rating: PG-13
Genre and/or Pairing: A little bit of action, spell casting normal SPN. I guess you can say a little Pre!Slash between Gabriel and Sam, and the always wonderful UST Dean/Castiel.
Spoilers: This is kind of an AU of Season Five, so there are mentions of events that take place in Season One through Season Four.
Warnings: Not really, rating is just for adult themed subject and language, and Dean and Gabriel jokes.
Word Count: About 10,200
Notes/Prompts: This was written for team_free_love Secret Lover Exchange Round 3, as a gift for jenab. Using the prompts Sam is the one who needs or has to claim Gabriel. Switching it around from Gabriel doing the claiming.
Summary: While trying to help the Winchesters, Castiel learns of a way to at least slow Lucifer down until they can find a way to actually stop Lucifer for good. The problem is that it can only work with another Archangel and the only one that they can find isn't all too willing to help.
Title: The time for tricks is over.
Author: whit_merule
Recipient: verucasalt123
Rating: Teen.
Genre and/or Pairing: Theoretically fluff and crackfic, though Sam keeps trying to angst. Episode tag to 5x04. Trickster!Gabriel, temporarily-fem!Gabriel, pre-slash Dean/Castiel.
Spoilers: Up to 5x04 (“The End”).
Warnings: Gabriel using a glamour to appear female. References to 5x04, and other general season-five angst.
Word Count: 3400.
Notes/Prompts: “Dean/Cas, Sam and Gabriel trying to force them to acknowledge their feelings for each other” - and a bit of “the Trickster playing tricks”. Gabriel also tries to make the story fit the “crack” request, but alas, the boys aren’t really in the mood.
Beta: dywalgi
Summary: Set after 5x04. There are several things Sam doesn’t understand. One is pretty simple: how the hell (hah) are he and Dean meant to hold out against two sulky archangels who both want a ride to the prom? Others are “what on earth went down in that weird alternate reality Zachariah put Dean in,” “why is Dean looking at Castiel so strangely now,” and “who is this woman with pink hair who’s just turned up and decided they’re all going to take a day off to visit the zoo.”
Title: Strange Tides
Author: lethiaw77
Recipient: whit_merule
Rating: NC17
Genre and/or Pairing: Dean/Cas, non-explicit/implied: Sam/Gabriel, Dean/Gabriel, Sam/Cas
Spoilers: none (since you obviously know the angels)
Warnings: abuse of the F word, consensual partner swapping
Word Count: 2,500
Notes/Prompts: I combined “All the boys, pirate AU!” and Dean/Gabe snark. Beta’d by my RL best friend and editor D.
Summary: Dean and Cas distract themselves and they await the arrival of “The Trickster”.
===2013===
Title: The Lights Are Turned Way Down Low
Author: kototyph
Recipient: baredwolf
Pairing(s): All variations of Dean/Sam/Cas + Kevin and Charlie platonically
Rating: NC-17
Word Count: 6500
Warnings: Dubious consent
Summary: Far below their usual levels of deductive reasoning, it takes until Christmas Eve for Team Free Will to solve the case of the mysteriously mutual sex dreams.
Title: Firelight.
Author: whit_merule
Recipient: chef_geekier
Pairings: Dean/Sam, Castiel/Gabriel, Castiel/Dean/Gabriel/Sam, and variants thereon.
Rating: Explicit.
Word count: 5600.
Spoilers: None.
Warnings: Fraternal incest. Underage (Castiel is 16, Sam 17, Dean and Gabriel 19 - having presumably both had to repeat a year at some point). It’s implied that both Dean/Sam and Castiel/Gabriel have been having sex for some time, though how long isn’t specified.
Summary: “Seriously, you’ve never even kissed him with the lights on? Is it a kinky thing?” Gabriel asked Sam, all sympathetic and grinning like a loon, because apparently Sam was the weak link who would actually tell them things that were not for talking about. “It’s not really your brother you’re doing unless you can see his adorable girly face?”
Title: A Mid-Bunker Night’s Dream
Author: septembers_coda
Recipient: kdheart
Rating: PG-13
Pairings: Sam/Gabriel, Charlie/Gilda, Dean/Castiel
Word Count: 3,300
Summary: The Men of Letters bunker is full, and love is in the recycled, underground air! People are falling to Cupid’s arrows left and right—but who’s the crack shot behind the bow? A cute little redheaded hacker, or the King of Hell? Or could it be the cleverest trickster of them all?
Title: Just Like Gorram Cats
Author: chef_geekier
Recipient: kototyph
Rating: NC-17
Pairing: Team Free Love (Sam/Dean/Gabriel/Castiel)
Spoilers: None
Genres/tropes/tags: AU, college students, foursome
Word Count: 2026
Summary: Dean insists that Gabriel and Castiel are just like cats. Their behaviour directly after sex seems to back him up. (A getting-together foursome piece of smut.)
Title: Nothing Covered (That Shall Not Be Revealed)
Author: lysanatt
Recipient: ladyeternal
Rating: NC-17
Pairings: Sam/Gabriel, Cas/Dean relationships; Sam/Cas/Gabe/Dean in various combinations.
Word Count: 24,500
Summary: It all starts with a breakfast and an ordinary cleaning job in the bunker. But when Cas drops a jar of Veraperio dust, a dangerous sex-pollen, the morning turns... not so ordinary. With Castiel in mortal peril from an overdose of pollen, there is nothing Sam, Dean and Gabriel won't do to save him. The process, however, forces them to reveal truths about themselves, and about the feelings they share.
Title: The Back Door to Heaven
Author: linda92595
Recipient: last_winterrose
Rating: Teen
Pairing: Dean/Castiel, some slight Sam/Gabriel pre-slash
Spoilers: None
Word Count: 5700
Summary: Gabriel is resurrected when God returns and sent to keep Sam from abandoning Dean and Castiel in Purgatory.
Title: Growing Stronger Through the Ashes
Author: sharys_aogail
Recipient: linda92595
Rating: NC-17
Pairing: Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel
Characters: Dean, Sam, Castiel, Gabriel, Crowley, Benny, Kevin, Charlie, Ezekiel, a few OCs.
Spoilers: Minor Season 9 spoilers (primarily concepts/characters from episode 1, imagery, and expansions of the Bunker)
Word Count: 8822
Summary: Dean was still adjusting to having so many new faces living close quarters. Dean had spent years accommodating only one or two other people in his daily life, and now he was forced to deal with up to a dozen at any specific time, and some days it was all he could do to keep from snatching up the nearest piece of weaponry and lessening that number by at least one. Just another typical morning in the Men of Letters Bunker.
Title: Your kind prison
Author: whit_merule (I know, it was so subtle and not-obvious)
Recipient: lysanatt
Rating: Explicit
Pairings: Castiel/Dean, Dean/Gabriel, Gabriel/Sam (relationships are C/D and G/S, sex scenes are D/G and G/S. No cheating).
Genres/tropes/tags: BAMF!Gabriel and Castiel, in their various ways. Fallen angels. Getting Heaven back from Metatron. Unreliable narrator. Framed with the archangels’ stories. Casual sex.
Spoilers: Some character names from season 9
Warnings: Mild dubcon. Gabriel temporarily in female form.
Word Count: 30k
Summary: Humans talk of the Fall as if it were one finite event, one story alone. But Lucifer was not the only archangel to fall. Each of them fell, one by one, in their own way. Some of them fell many times. And now the sky is full of falling stars, falling angels. The last archangel watches them fall, and has to make a choice between continuing as he is and learning - teaching all of them - to write a new own story, to set against Metatron’s.
Title: Angel on My Shoulder
Author: kdheart
Recipient: pinkyapples
Rating: PG-13
Pairing: Sam/Gabriel
Characters: Sam, Gabriel, Lucifer, Dean, Castiel
Spoilers: 7.17
Warnings: S7 wasn’t that great for Sam’s mental health
Word Count: 3700
Summary: Sam’s in a bad place. He can barely keep track of what’s real and what isn’t and it really doesn’t help that his head is becoming a refuge for dead angels.
Title: What happened when Benny entered the ‘Twilight’ zone.
Author: pinkyapples
Recipient: septembers_coda
Rating: PG-13
Pairing: Implied Dean/Castiel, Sam/Gabriel, otherwise none.
Characters: Dean and Sam Winchester, Castiel, Benny, Kevin Tran, Elizabeth, OC’s and Gabriel’s ghost
Word Count: 5643
Summary: Dean and Sam now call the Men of Letters bunker home. Life is more or less harmonious for themselves and their extended family. Until Dean gets a call from a dead man, or rather a dead vamp and Sam has some explaining to do. / Benny meets some fans of sparkly vampires, and the whole phenomenon has to be explained to him.
Title: Kindling
Author: whit_merule
Recipient: sharys_aogail
Rating: G
Pairing: None (I know, weird right?)
Characters: Dean, Sam, Castiel, Gabriel, Kevin.
Spoilers: Set after 9x08. Spoilers up to there, and of character revelations in 9x09.
Word Count: c. 3000
Summary: The air in the bunker is too heavy with lies and suppressions. It would take very little to ignite the spark; and there are old things hidden down there in those archives, things that take exception to that kind of atmosphere.
Title: Say What You Wish
Author: baredwolf
Recipient: whit_merule
Rating: NC-17
Pairings: Dean Winchester/Sam Winchester, Castiel/Dean Winchester, Gabriel/Sam Winchester, Castiel/Gabriel/Dean Winchester/Sam Winchester
Word Count: ~24,000
Summary: A Disney’s Aladdin Team Free Love AU. Life on the streets of Agrabah isn't kind to Dean and his younger brother Sam as they struggle to scrape by. Meanwhile, Prince Castiel is being forced to marry by the ruthless Sultan, his older brother Raphael, as part of his war schemes. When a dark stranger and a twist of luck lead Dean to acquire the genie of the lamp, Gabriel, will he be able to use his three wishes to turn his life - and the kingdom - around?
==Resources==
* Collection at Archive of Our Own
Category:Gift Exchanges
Category:2010 Gift Exchanges
Category:2011 Gift Exchanges
Category:2012 Gift Exchanges
Category:2013 Gift Exchanges