The Yummiest Popes

The Yummiest Popes is an episode of Grub Listies (see S3E02).
The Yummiest Popes are:
1. St. Peter
2. John Paul I
3. John Paul II
4. St. Gregory 
5. Benedict XVI
This episode of Grub Listies was interrupted by a lost voice who calls out 'every time the record scratches I blink out of existence!'