Alternate Alternates

* See also Rapture Alternates
* See also Excelsior (Fun)
* See also Columbia_Asylum
* See also Columbia_State_Sanitorium
* See also Noir_Columbia
* See also Foes_Of_Columbia
* See also Finks_experiments
* See also INFINITE-BS_REDO
* See also Burial_at_Sea_REDO
* See also BioShock_SOLO_Game_Redos
* See also Humor
* See also Paris and Going-To-Paris
* See also Nano-Shock
* See also Elizabeth_Should_Have_Destroyed_The_Luteces
* See also If_BioShock_Rapture_Had_Been_Fantasy
* See also Make_Columbia_A_City
* See also Zombies ???
* See also THOSE_CORPSES_ARENT_DEAD in Rapture
* See also Columbia_Cannibalism
* See also The_Quantum_Revolution - What really would have happened in the rest of the World.
Split This Page
==SEE RAPTURE ALTERNATIVES==
-
== Columbia and Burial At Sea Just CRY OUT for This Kind of Thing ... ==
SO MUCH Fun to be had with different/funny ideas in the multiverse type situations
 "Infinitosphere" - Embrace the Illogic for the Fun Of It (a little).
--- --- --- --- --- 
M-Worlds !!! That's Means Infinite Rapture's ( Assuming ... ) :
Think of all the happier Raptures where Fontaine/Atlas stayed locked up, and Ryan was allowed to clean up the whole ADAM mess ( or Fontaine quite early earned 'having his face blown off' by one of his victims who wouldn't put up with his crimes ). Rapture growing and accelerating ( and going on to the moon ? )
No Good To US - 'Shooting Up Things' (mindless violence) is what so many of these games are really simply about ...
-
ALTERNATE !!!!
Alternate Dimensions ( according to that largely-rejected Multi-verse 'theory' ) were INFINITE -- There would even be Dimensions where the Infinite BS game was Released-On-Time, and also actually contained what those Trailers promised at the Game Industry Show 'Promotionals'.
Also, reversals of character roles were ENTIRELY possible : Elizabeth was a gun-toting prostitute, who had sold her baby son to 'Wipe Away her Debts' ...
--- --- ---
Something Better Than Some Crazy SteamPunky Mess :
* Make Columbia a flying hill/mountain so you can have its subterranean part in contrast to the airy spaces above ( Big chunks of masonry/whatever - It is there under the building anyway, so why not do it properly ??? )
* The 'Underworld' is where the slaves live ( Levine assumes 'America' is that ante bellum plantation mentality anyway, so let's actually make proper use of it ).
* Now we can have the underground Fungus Farms which feed those workers - Using the effluvium from up above "BE GRATEFUL TO YOUR BETTERS !!!" ( Giant Signs ... except wouldn't READING be banned for the Slaves ? ).
* A proper mad scientist lair like in a 'Bond film' ...
* And the toiling masses to gratefully provide for 'the betters' up in Sunny Columbia
* All the hoarded Tear-stolen materials and pirated stuff to make an economy work
* Finally - a Source for all the power needed to run this 'Coney Island' topside ( with proper belching smoke trailing behind the flying city ). Toiling minions shoveling fuel into the huge furnace/boiler rooms.
* Lots of dark places for the Terrible Secrets and True Horrors hidden from the light ( Things which even Comstock doesn't know about, and OTHERS know too well ... )
--- --- ---
.
==Just Three Words : "Clown Vision Mode" ==
.
--- --- ---
Theme Me No Themes, Levine ... :
Columbia could have been filled with Faux-Freemason Cultists instead of Levine's Faux-Christian Cultists Faux-Jews for some reason were 'off the table' and not even considered - Its one of those 'Politically Correct' things I guess ... .
1892, the Freemasons finished a 19 story skyscraper (a Masonic Temple) in Chicago ( Oops, wouldn't match their 2nd rewrite Ludditehttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Luddite Plot theme ... )
Notice that Cultish Hebrews was 'not on the table' for Ken Levine's story - for some reason. ( Too controversial ?? ) Would be problematicGoogle "Political Correctness" to distort/misrepresent THAT branch of religion Imagine Columbia ("KOVANENT") with Jews in opposition To Muslims. Who would be the 'Oppressors' and who The 'Oppressed' --- TWIST !!!! = midway (through a Tear) they FLIP !!! Such an imaginative idea, no ? HEY LEVINE, I HAVE THE PLOT FOR YOUR STORY LEGOS. ??? I guess Levine is NOT as "Authentically Diversified" as he makes himself (and his 'works') out ...
--- --- --- 
Portal To An Alternate Reality :
Magic Tears : It is the Ultimate Story *Crutch*, which can get the Player/cohorts out of ANY peril/puzzle/situation without any difficulty whatsoever ( and no need for the writer to craft a logical/effort-taking/imaginative/clever resolution ). Only *VERY* weak writers employ such a mechanism in their story writing. 
We can ( in these Alternates ) satirize that kind of lame 'Crutch' for an Infinite REDO, employing it for our Improved Imagination-Land Columbia.
MORE IMAGINATIVE/LESS RESTRICTIVE - ( and having a "Game Over" type gameflow ) - You decide to use a Tear to try to Escape - but opening Tears is unpredictable - Even Worse things can come out of them ( or be on their 'otherside' ). A whole Infinite Sub-game could be built ontop of THIS Idea.
Perfect Entryway To The BAD Fan Fiction Contest Interactive World ( F.A.N.S.H.I.T.E ) 
--- --- ---
--- --- ---
The MMORPG Mechanism Could Allow Alot of "What If" Scenes :
We can have all the 'Dreamscapes', potentially handling anything you want ( after all, crazy Splicers can imagine/dream anything ... See, that's how we could even handle Purple Unicorn Infinite BS Fantasyland in a plausible way. )
What if : Atlas ( being a more the hands-on 'Man of the People' interactor - "Oh Thank you Mr Atlas for Helping Us ..." ) eventually personally faced some deranged insane Splicer, and was burned to death/slice-and-diced with meathooks/shotgun-blasted to the face -- resulting from the mental instability that HE had a major role in creating ? Simple Poetic Justice ...
Offer them food or ADAM ? But maybe it is simpler for them to kill and grab it ALL from this self-proclaimed 'big man' Atlas ? When you turn people into beasts, then it is the law of the jungle. And even Fontaine was only 'used to' a world largely still controlled by social conventions ( and used dodges around them ), and could EASILY be quickly outdone by greater ruthless/precipitous action.
How many different voices (accents) could Fontaine scream in, as his face was being gnawed/peeled off ? ( Would make the interrogation of Timmy H. 'Look like a Folkdance''Look like a Folkdance' - Captain Kirk dramatic line in the 'Roman' episode ... ) :
: Sullivan : "Where's your stash 'Atlas', me boy ?" 
: WHACK !!! 
: *Stunned Groan*
: Sullivan : "Give it to us, and we'll kill you quickly !!"
: *CRUNCH* !!!
: *Screams* 
: Sullivan : "Give it to us, or I'll give you to Fred here, who does violent and terrible things that even disgusts ME !!!" 
: Fred : "Yeah Boss, Having your finger digits bitten off one joint at a time can be quite effectively 'convincin'..."
: Sullivan : "I'm telling you Fontaine, you had best spill the beans ..."
: Sullivan : "No ? Fred, Go Fetch the man's own 'Pliers and Blowtorch', and meanwhile lets give Frank here a little time to think ..."
: Fred : "Oh look, he needs his nappies changed now."
: * Fadeout *
'Atlas' - Not quite the 'Savior of the People', when he has to be ringed by his own thugs, or largely avoids dealing directly with 'The People'.
--- --- ---
EXAMPLE What If : 
Delta got his armored gloved hands on Sofia Lamb ( long before that so emotionally touching ending scene where Eleanor drowns her ) ?? 
AND 'Little Sister' Delta coulda so easily/unexpectedly plunged ( with ape-like strength ) her ADAM-draining needle deep into the back of Sofia's head ( as she was blithely sitting at her Office desk planning what next bunch of her followers would be 'Utopianized' ). 
"Ding Dong The Witch Is Dead" ( just a song fragment so not to have Copyright issues ... ) is sung by all the Little Sisters (One of those envisioned 'scenes' the writers so love ...)
Now you (Delta) go on to rescue Sinclair, who then resumes his control of Persephone, and can start planning his return to The Surface ( unless he has had a change of heart through your brave actions ). Just then Andrew Ryan ( who hasn't been dead for these last 7 years ) calls and asks you to assist him in his restoration of Rapture ( after all you would only be an exhibit in a Freak Circus IF you went with Sinclair to The Surface World ).
A Glorious resurgence of Rapture starts to begin ... The crucible has burned the parasitics out of the Citizens ...
( Seriously some creative Players could build entire 'campaigns' of Missions of amusing 'alternate' story lines like this. All the Tools/resources the MMORPG system has would save them time/effort, allowing them to employ their creativity and ingenuity. )
--- --- ---
Lost Worlds OF BioShock :
The "Tesla Device" ( employed by the Luteces ) was frying brain neural-paths and acting like a hallucinogen ( the reason why Nikola Tesla had abandoned it ). But Columbia was 'flying' even though it never got an inch off the ground ... All the strange occurrences and behaviors and delusions were now easily explained ... No Time travel or Interdimensional 'Tear's, just a bunch of people whacked out of their skulls living in their twisted Eden On Earth 'utopia'.
Recreated by the Players of Rapture Reborn MMORPG - True brilliant imagination at work.
Bizarre and warped visual and sensory effects simulating the Citizen's environment. Taste colors and hear smells and all that ...
Templates ?? We no need no stinkin Templates .... Wrong. A caricature of Columbia once created could then just become a reuseable/multi-usable Prop ( a starting point ) for all the customized/Mod Weirdness that players can come up with. Use the same mechanism that the MMORPG uses ( keeps Players from having to 'reinvent the wheel' ) with Rapture in all its Flashback/Splicer-Delusion manifestations.
What IF Sander Cohen turned out to be Comstock, and then he hijacks a shipload of Plaster ???
What if The US Marines led by Teddy Roosevelt on the USS Eagle ( The American Flying Battleship ) arrive to take Columbia back for the US Government ???
What can YOU think of YOU would want to see happen ???
-
Columbia Floats Without Bad Faux-Physics
WHAT IF COLUMBIA WAS A GIANT WATER FLOATING CITY (OCEAN LINER) ????
Creepy Racist Cultists aren't necessarily afraid of the water, Are They ??
--- --- ---
Alternate Alternates : THREE STOOGE Luteces - If two were fun, then THREE would be even more !!!! 
--- --- ---
A Better Story :
So why DIDN'T Elizabeth go-back-in-time ( a planned Fink Mfg Vigor ? ) through a Tear ( helped by Luteces, who are Dimension gods now too ... ) to kill Tenenbaum before she discovers the Sea Slug. *OR* did the Luteces 'talk' to Tenenbaum like they did to Daisy Fitzroy - to have Elizabeth learn maturity, yada yada ... That WAS such a DIMWITTINGLY STUPID plot segment, so that Sally couldn't be turned into a Little Sister (no ADAM you see... no Gatherers, etc ... ). Makes as much sense as Elizabeth going after Booker-ex-Comstock ( more Lutece magicry - Hmmmmmm - Why didn't THEY just TRAVEL BACK IN TIME to have a talk with early Comstock X to avoid the whole head popping off incident ??? ).
SO this here was an evil child-decapitating Comstock, NOW converted to a 'Booker' who wants to forget it all by being sent to Rapture ( by the Luteces again --- so ***THEY*** are there AGAIN !! -- Why HASN'T Elizabeth killed the Luteces for causing the WHOLE fricken interdimensional crossover Mess-a-topia in the VERY first place ?????????? That's a good plot that was just staring Levine & Co in the face. But that opportunity, as so many others good things, was LOST. )
We can ditch all this stupidity for the MMORPG's fun (sarcastic parody ??) adaption, and enjoy the correction of Columbia AND fixes to that whole Columbia bad writing story-mess as well.
-
The Sad Truth is that your average Sunday Garfield Comic Strip has almost as much 'story' as BioShock had in it. There is a pretty low bar when computer game 'story' is considered. MMORPGs may have an advantage over the usual Solo Shooter Game like BioShock.
--- --- ---
Comstock getting an early start ...
Famous line from Teddy Roosevelt - "Of course you KNOW, This Means WAR !!!"
Most 'alternate universe' Columbias did NOT survive Teddy Roosevelt ...
--- --- ---
Things Can Go Wrong - List of not just Booker 'Failz' - But how Booker Failed 122 Times Previously :
* Face Shredded/Head Decapitated by Police at Stoning Event at Fair ( The Police have the expertise with those Skyhook things ).
* Ate garbage, got food poisoning - and while vomiting he was easily caught and so then was executed
* Thrown off edge/fell to death
* Cut in Two by Songbirds Beak, or merely stepped on 
* Fell 30 feet in Elizabeth's Library and broke neck ( or broke leg and gangrene took hold soon afterwards )
* A Tear Opened and Daleks emerged and EXTERMINATED him ( this eventuality goes for Comstock/Fink/Luteces/Elizabeth even more ).
* Elizabeth stabbed him with scissors in the neck - He soon bled to death
* A Tear leading into then interior of Sun ( Vaporized by million degree Plasma )
* Headshot by just one of the dozens of well armed opponents.
--- --- ---
Alternate Universe :
INSTEAD OF COMSTOCK - Columbia run by Sander Cohen !!!!!
Sander Cohen's "The White Theater" ( an alternate, might-have-been vision ... LOTS of gorgeous plaster ... )
We have our ZOMBIE GAME !!!!
--- --- ---
De Debil Made Me Doodit !! :
That book - "The Devil in the White City"https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/devil-in-the-white-city-erik-larson/1100666104 ( talked about for some reason by the Infinite BS game authors ).
So WE (the Player) become a mass murdererPlayer becomes a Mass Murderer : Ever notice that Ken Levine makes the Player play a character who is a homicidal maniac ??? BUT he it is a Mass Murderer 'with a heart' ... I sense some projection there ... set loose on an offshoot of the Columbian Exposition ( The White City - neoclassical, all painted white ). Hey THAT sounds like an even better game. Running about, Slaughtering lots and lots of people ( lots of them foreigners AND 'them rotten immigrant types' - and even some Catholics !!! ), and reaching no important conclusion in the end ( apparently it is "all a dream" ).
We get to collect skeletons of our victims in a trophy room. And don't forget the Slaked Lime (Calcium hydroxide) needed to strip the flesh off those corpses ( mini-game time !!!! ). H.H.Holmes ( a real serial killer in "Devil in the White City" ) was selling his 'harvested' skeletons to medical supply houses - It was a tradition that every medical student had their own human skeleton - and they weren't cheap.
All in all, not so much different from the activities of Booker and Lizzy.
---
H H HolmesH H Holmes of The White City" fame comes to Rapture : 
He perhaps escapes via Columbia - Apparently, he is another one of the Lutece's 'Toys'/Pawns. With Tears, all is made simple.
Elizabeth lodges in his 'Hotel' in Rapture with fatal results. A fun/fascinating romp through the mind of a mass murderer ( not much different than Elizabeths mind or Bookers ... Or Sofia Lamb's )
--- 
A Night To Remember :
Fink caused the Titanic Disaster (1912) to obtain the 'brainstems' he needed for his Automatons ( His "Cattle Replacements" ... ) The typical Namedropping Goodnesss is so easy ...
Fink CERTAINLY does not care about using involuntary 'Test Subjects' ( and with him being a 'scientific caveman' he probably used up quite a few - "Cattle" he figured would be replaced by Automatons anyway. He could joke about his "Abattoir" ...)
These 'Alternates' can be caricature, and DO NOT have to adhere to the Rapture_Reborn MMORPG strictness about avoiding Fantasy/BS.
--- --- ---
For That Floaty "Columbia" Built For the 1893 Exposition - "SHOW CITY" :
Earliest Columbia would be only a fraction of the size of what is supposed to exist in 1912 ( and in various Kinetoscope Shorts seen somewhat at earlier dates ). Columbia was originally a 'Show City', built within a budget AND within a VERY short timespan ( However THAT was achieved is pretty much a Fantasy as well, EVEN when it was shoddy 'Potemkin Village' fakery' -- the Plaster and Lathing and Chicken-wire - as almost all of those (REAL) Exposition Fairs' construction HAD TO be built with ).
How exactly was Columbia expanded so much during the period it was flying around visiting other locations in the World ( and was still run by the US Government ) to 'show the flag' ?? No need for any real 'population' for that - more would only complicate things. SO there most likely would only have been small enlargements/repairs/improvements/adjustments. It was still just full of 'actors', and the people/crew needed to operate it. Any expansion costs money, which the US taxpayers were LOATHE to pay ( particularly as a MAJOR Economic Depression was starting up at the time of the 1893 Exposition ).
After Comstock took it over, was it then greatly expanded ?? So WHO paid for THAT, and HOW exactly was this construction done ( enlarged to meet all the requirements of an appropriate population for the extent shown - and THAT can't be only be for the small numbers of people we see in the game ). 
(( Of course it is never mentioned how they supplied the place, even though they blathered on endlessly about their Fake Science. ))
Who are all the people who are living there later, or who somehow got aboard to be able to side with Comstock to 'take it over' ???? 
Who paid the huge amounts of CASH to expand it ? (( Riddle - How many Un-American cultists does it take to occupy Columbia ? It is implied so many were NOT the religious fanatics - seemingly ordinary folk. So how exactly did that work ? ))
AND What facilities were used to do so ??
The game story really doesn't explain these things - You'd think it would be important to make the backstory clearer, particularly when THAT was supposed to be a BIG element of "BioShock" genre games. Selective explanations ( most likely it would all collapse under its own illogic - WHEN they ever started to attempted to explain just the practical issues ).
-
"Its only a game" ... Yeah well then why did the dopey PR people/employee interviews then talk Infinite BS up as if it WAS more than just a game ???? Any idiot/hack can create BIG Impressive looking shit these days in games, but creating a logical "World" takes FAR more than that. Creating a proper Backstory takes more than that. Generic/vague cloud-obscured Floatyshit(tm), off in the distance - again ANYONE can do that.
--- --- ---
Elizabeth - The Homicidal Maniac :
* You (Booker) see her Dispatching someone with her Skyhook when you turn around
* Kicking corpses and cringing people, and Mutilating them 
* Making some REALLY disturbing comments
* Lizzie Borden ... 'gave a child 20 whacks'
* She runs out ahead and just shoots some inhabitant in the face ... You have to try to slow her down so you don't lose all your 'Element of Surprise'.
* Columbians running from her in alarm -- As if she has previously 'got loose' before to do such things ( a GOOD reason she is 'Locked In A Tower' ... )
Now you might realize WHY Elizabeth was locked away with a HUGE mechanical Jailer
--- --- ---
Since Infinite BS Was All About 'Scenes' : 
How much dramatic/awesome would Columbia be being seen in orbit around Saturn ???
With the Lala-land made-up Physics and chronic avoidance of Reality, THAT would have been fully possible. With 'Tears' and such mechanisms being used, floating around a billion miles away wouldn't be much more different that floating at 25000 feet. ( If a magic fantasy rocket could take you to 25000 ft Columbia, why not all the way to Saturn ? )
The whole rest of the weird nonsensical storyline and slaughter-fest game could have been left EXACTLY the same for all Columbia's location mattered -- Giant Statues AND The Rings OF Saturn !!!! ( SOOOO MUCH PRETTIER !!! ) Imagine THAT going onto the Denny's napkin used as the game's design document.
--- --- ---
Alternate Universes still could have got on without the stupid Faux-Science Quantum crap. A '3D' nightmare of thousands of balloons of THIS size - Oops, game engine difficulties with that ( and worse hard NPC scripting when the place is virtually all stairs ).
Tipis (Tee-Pees) would be a viable LIGHT WEIGHT shelter -- HEY !!! I just came up with another 'Authentic Diversity' thing for Ken Levine - New Cahokia the flying Native American Happy Hunting Grounds - escaping the evil Whiteman's clutches !!!! Mechanical 'Sitting Bulls' and such .... (( Oops, belittling and misrepresenting Christianity is 'Politically Correct', but making fun of 'Native Americans' is NOT ... ))
--- --- ---
"WE DON'T WANT THE IRISH" A line from Mel Brooks movie 'Blazing Saddles' satirizing bigotry :
Kinetoscope "Solving the Irish problem!" ( send them to Fink and then HE would really be in trouble ).
If there were still Irish in Columbia (as alluded), then it ALL never would have happened. Where is the Catholic Church they would demand to have ? Actually NO SIGN of anything Christian there in Columbia ( See Ken Levine's Strange Ideas About American Religion. The Irish would kill Comstock, or have long previously left/escaped, IF Comstock tried to impose his cultish idolotrous non-christian religion on them, or tried to enslave them. The Irish in that 1893 era were a large portion of America's policemen, and made up significant portions of the military ( like those put there onboard Columbia when the US Government ran the place ). THEY would have eliminated Comstock's little coup attempt -- Assisted by the rest of the Americans on-board, who did not and would not believe Comstock's 'Founder' Claptrap.
Comstock's supposed "Prophesies" ( as alleged used to convince people that he was some Great Prophet, and that they should follow him, and hand him money, etc ... ) couldn't impress/sway the Irish. What exactly those "Prophesies" were when they supposedly were made from looking into other dimensions, BUT looking at realities where OTHER/DIFFERENT things happened from in his timeline can't much help him. Comstock couldn't select or know whether anything he saw/was seeing was relevant to his world's future when he was looking through a mere keyhole to try to view a whole World ( and trying to spot something he could use to impress/swindle people ). And that's only if he could even find anything remotely resembling his own dimension. Elizabeth repeatedly opened Tears where significant changes existed, so the same would be with Comstock's attempts.
How he ever did this for his ( so ridiculously short ) Tent-Meeting 'got religion' days could only be explained by his sudden skill at being a Conman/Charlatan ( again its all somehow done in that amazing 3 years after Wounded Knee ... ) You see, ordinary people in those days were not as gullible as those 'smart' game writers assume they were. Most people in America would look on Comstock's Faux-Christianity with derision, and be able to quote Bible verses at his errors all day long. He would be 'passed off' instantly as a crank. The Luteces would distance themselves from that notoriety, or face the same denunciations. (( Seriously, How desperate were the writers to form such a rubbish storyline around such poor assumptions ? ))
SO 'Irish' in Columbia ?? NO. Not gonna happen. So here again the writers in their interviews (( "Look. Look. We have Racism against 'whites' TOO ... So we aren't singling out 'blacks' ... So WE aren't really Racists ... " -- NO, SOFT SELLING Racism is itself a kind of Racism. )) were TOUTING their utter Ignorance about what they assume they knew about real people, and that period of American history. I can only assume the head Ignoramus was Ken Levine himself, as he was the one who 'signed off' on it all. As one game reviewer wrote : "The game's Writers seems to be trying to show off how clever they were, when they really weren't very clever at all." 
---
== --- FANTASY --- ==
Issues :
The whole storyline basis from Infinite BS is severely flawed, and so very many problems flowing out of those flaws :
The most basic is : The continuing of the Quantum fantasy BS from Infinite. Quantum Physics is real, it just has nothing at all to do with things they try to explain in the Infinite BS game, and make use of for their storyline. The game in itself is based on scientific nonsense/misuse, and is inconsistent with its own rules and definitely inconsistent with any real Quantum Theory.
THEN there is That "There are Constants and Variables..." crap .... The MOST FUNDAMENTAL THING about (real) Quantum Mechanics is that THERE ARE NO 'Constants'. The theory about "Infinite" multiverses ( actually its called the "M-World - Multi-World/dimension/universe interpretation" ), which the writers claim to be using in the game ( or is spoken of in those interviews ), fundamentally means that Elizabeth could NEVER get to all the INFINITE number of Bookers/Comstocks. That is assuming we even allow the Interdimensional 'universe' Jumping, or the Time Travel to be possible ( It is only allowed by their *Fantasy* thing they label "Quantum Mechanics/Physics/Theory ).
--- --- ---
The Comstock Witch Project :
Battleship Bay doubled in purpose for Witch Drowning Events ( and a safe place to burn Crosses - Gots to keep flames away from all that highly combustible cheap false-stone and false-brick construction ).
Ordinary electric circuit wires of those times were hazardous enough, without being installed in a place that virtually was made of Papier-mâché.
--- --- ---
--- --- ---
My Columbia Tis of Thee, Sweet Place of Insanity, Of thee I Scream ... :
Oh !!! ( Captain Obvious Plot Arrives ) : Shouldn't all the Vigor (ADAM) users in Columbia now be insane Mutants tearing the place apart ??? Mass addiction and rioting when the Vigor "users" can't get their fix ???
Scenes of Godly Folk recoiling in horror from the transformed creatures sowing discord everywhere ? 
Rampages of demented crazies with (and without) a religious bent doing every sort of nasty thing.
See Comstock having Fink executed for bringing that unholy muck into his 'godly' utopia ??? ( Or he was the biggest user of all, and was attempting to restore his 'youth' ... )
Mass executions to 'Cleanse' the holy city of the dangerously insane ... Corpse Wagons ... "BRING OUT YOUR DEAD !!!"
Gotta be consistent with the logic - if they (BaSx) want to link All the Columbia magic potions into Rapture's ADAM Technology ... You DO see those Vigors being sold all over IN Columbia's vending machines ( and all those advertisements for them ), and that all would NOT be there if it didn't sell to lots of people. So, Columbia Citizens MUST have been using it - alot of it ( with the expected results - If you are honestly consistent ).
Or is LOGIC one of those things that Quantum Physics now has rendered obsolete ? ( "Quantum Indeterminancy Renders Logic Useless" ... Apparently only where Gamemakers are involved. )
WE Coulda had alot more FUN targets for us to slaughter, besides policemen and faceless Founder/Vox minions ( now become mutant Splicers AGAIN !!!! ).
--- --- ---
Opportunity MISSED KEN !!! :
Comstock in the Final Confrontation : His mask falls off, revealing what is virtually a Skeletal face - having further deteriorated from his 'Tear' activity 'aging' him ... - An Animated Mummified Corpse ( kept alive by the game's wondrous/unexplained Vigor/Nostrum/Salts fantasy magic potions - vital essence milked from Elizabeth by the 'Siphon'. ) 
The wages of evil ( with some creepy "I knew you would come" strangeness just before his death ... ) Allusions to 'The Picture of Dorian Gray' ( as another 'we are so clever' irrelevancy ).
Now why here couldn't we have some of that lovely brutal violence they slaved over providing earlier in the game ??? - Booker bludgeoning Comstock in bone-crunching realistic fashion ( hunks of brain/blood forming a Moire patternhttps://www.bing.com/search?q=Moire+pattern in the sunlight ) , and Elizabeth putting her high-heeled foot grinding into the mess left of Comstock's face ???? 
Take THAT Daddy Dearest !!!!
Oh that's right, it is about "Redemption" --- Then what the Hell was all the rest of the gratuitous violence in the game about ??? Oh, Was it just part of 1900s American there Ken ? ... Such BS.
---
Dream sequence of Lizzie in Columbia of gettin lobotomized, with characteristic bruising and vacant face.
Siphon is reestablished without further problems ...
--- --- ---
Religious Fanatics LOVE executing Witches ( Burn them, Hang them, Drown them ... )
"Thou Shalt Not Suffer A Witch To Live ..." 
Oh My. Elizabeth's magic powers make her a Witch. Where is Booker when she needs him ???
--- --- ---
Alternates ( Or Just A Splicer Delusion ) :
Gilbert Alexander became a Utopian Dimension god, and 'Cast the Hell of Columbia down from the Heavens' ( He stretched out his mind, sang a little song, and that foul place did plummet earthwards to its doom ). Badness was Cleansed.
Thus began the reign of 'Gil The Great'.
---
Alternate - the whole Infinite BS story 'played out' in Rapture ( Wellllll ... with all that multi-bullshit faux-science BS-spew eliminated ... )
--- --- ---
A Challenge Taken Up - Carnegie XTREME !!! :
The thing that ate 'Songbird'. The World moved past isolated/backward Columbia after the 'quantumz' technologies were discovered, improved and developed FAR beyond Comstock's limited means and incompetence.
When Columbia became a menace, Andrew Carnegie knew exactly what to do. He set up a bank account and set aside to accrue compound interest, and then hired some top-dollar mercenaries from the far future through a Tear ( He had spies steal all that Quantumz stuff way back in 1892 ) to obliterate the pesky cultists. He afterwards sold bits of Columbia for souvenirs. Across the World a Bright Future then was opening up, and dastardly people like Comstock and his Cultists had no place in it.
Alternate Story : Carnegie built his OWN Flying City, hiring the best engineers available and scientists to improve the 'Quantumz'. On its maiden flight, it pursued and destroyed the rogue 'Columbia', to much acclaim and an official thanks from the United States government and the people of the country for dealing with such an embarrassment.
"Carnegie" - The Steel Industrialists Rival 'Floating City'. :
With the US Government building Columbia, and the taxpayers not wanting to foot the bill, there is one place the money could have come from. Industrialists and Commercial Investors. Of course, those who invested expected to get their hands on the technology which made it possible. ( THAT would still be true if the Government paid and built Columbia. )
Carnegie's City would be steel.
-
Transportation WORTHY of being in a Flying City ( Columbia is more like a town anyway - perhaps this is like what Andrew Carnegie would have in HIS Flying City ... ) THIS looks like it is actually something that could work, and in a quite nice massively verticalized cityscape ( in a style/construction technologies concurrent with those times ). Not something made by game designers who were ready/able to ignore the basics of engineering and even of simple physical laws in their strange little "Politically Correct" rendition of American Exceptionalism.
--- --- ---
Infinite BS (Columbian) Splicerz (What Mighta Been) :
Some of the concept ideas had Columbia populated with their (Infinite BS) equivalent of the deformed/demented Splicers ( This was likely after the Quantumz Tear 'Merging' stuff ... or even the DLC implied ADAM-based 'Vigors' ).
The reason this was abandoned for the game may have been the extensive '3D' shape and animation work needed for character sets and possibly some variations ( greatly multiplying the cost of the '3D' Asset work the game would require ). Clever programming ( as would actually be done in the MMORPG, and not just be promotional hype ) to do this automatically might have been possible. But it would require some better programming talent, which might have been very expensive, and still may not have achieved/produced adequate results ( attempts at exploration down that path probably had had poor results ).
Later having too many ugly/creepy people wandering around didn't fit the Happy 'sorta-American-like' 'normal' Columbia, and would have been a story-line problem ( for the games thrice rewritten plot/setting ).
The Sanatorium ( with the looney 'Boys Of Silence' ) perhaps had some remnants of this concept, but that was supposedly 'later' Columbia, after when Elizabeth had mutated into the Evil Witch Queen.
Ditto, the First Lady graveyard, and its (NO DOUBT) Quantum Caused strangeness.
--- --- ---
Columbia's Part in the Spanish American War, 1898 :
So what did Columbia do now with that 'Patriotic' war ( back when Columbia was still US friendly, under command of the US Navy ) ? Remember The Maine !!! "What did YOU Do During the Spanish American War, Daddy ???" Nothing apparently.
Allegedly it was a 'flying a battleship' in time for the Boxers Rebellion (1899 and 1901)... ?? BTW, Why exactly could Comstock be in charge of American Government property ?? The Boxer Rebellion shit was also before the Secession Coup (1902) too, wasn't it ( again unlikely for things to be driven by Comstock while Columbia was under US control ).
(( Sorry Kenny, REAL things didn't work that way then - remember YOU SAID the taxpayers funded it ... DIDN'T YOU ??? Government Property. Some Cultists WOULD NOT be in charge of it. Your Serious lack of understanding of History is so mysterious and embarrassing - you try to make a game based on historic events to frame all your 'social relevancy' ??? BS BS BS ))
Perhaps (rather) Comstock wasn't involved at all, and any such 'history' is just more self-aggrandizement by him ? ( He has no problem making up his fake past, as all con-men do. ) Spaniards as bad guys shown as fiends in the War Museum might offend too many Players ??? Unintelligible to Players who don't even know what countries were involved in WW2 ?? Have the Museum have them dressed like Conquistadors ?? 
(( That would be par for the Faux-History in this game. ))
Did the City Just stay away because the Comstock clique were still planning their takeover, and the place was in a state of confusion ?? Or was Columbia by then so decrepit, and at that time moored in the Brooklyn Navy Yard waiting to be scrapped ( making it FAR easier for a bunch of cultists to steal it )?
--- --- ---
Radium-coated Electri-fed Lobotomy Tools used on Elizabeth ... :
The Healing Powers of Radium and Radiation were Well-Known in that Earlier Columbia time Era ( Atlas got HIS Quality Lobotomy Tools through a Tear ... )
It is always fun to make the limbs jump, and poke around to find where the electrode can make the subject do a funny face ...
I suspect this might make a FUN Mini-Game ...
--- --- ---
Cute Little Puppies :
Instead of saving children in the game, it would be 'Cute Little Puppies' ( Frog in a wheelchair ? .. Bah ).
Except Puppies can't mouth cute little sayings to their Big Daddies ('Master Doods').
Also not everyone likes Dogs ( Note - all the dog corpses got 'ate' ).
"Gimme your ADAM, or the Puppy Gets It !!!" ( NOTE - Shooting puppies isn't nearly as bad as Shooting Children )
Creepy glowing eyes on Puppies might not be too cute.
Unfortunately for some reason Tenenbaum/Suchong/Fontaine never bothered to test the Sea Slug symbiotic link on Puppies ... ( Fontaine smuggling in stray dogs from The Surface, etc ... )
"Break Ten Sweet Puppies Neck" ( Do you get the idea that Suchong didn't like puppies ??? )
--- --- ---
Telodynamics (real term) :
Definition - "A system of power transmission using wire ropes stretched between pulleys, effective over several miles."
Yeah, that sound about the speed of the Fink Power Company. We seriously needed more of the clutter of 'workings' which made Columbia operate - wires everywhere, pipes, conduits, etc ... Even if only shown 'behind the facade'. Gears and shafts ( watch you don't get your hair caught in them ... ) like proper Steam Punk, could be fun. 
Several GAME OVER moments possible when you blunder into the workings/machinery ...
--- --- ---
Cannibalism in Columbia was Much Exaggerated (Maybe) :
: "Southern-style" BBQ, or Irishman & Boiled Cabbage.
: "Would you like 'white meat' or 'dark meat' ????"
: "Those aren't jail cells -- THAT'S A STOCKYARD PEN !!!!"
: "You feel like eating Chinese, or Italian, or Greek today ???"
(( OH THE FUN WE COULD HAVE WITH THIS !! Player Creations should be fun ... Cliches a mile-a-minute ))
-
Why Columbia Had to Hide, and Why the Inhabitants Had Turned to Cannibalism :
Contemporary naval guns could reach any altitude Columbia could fly at ( that is WITHOUT quickly asphyxiating its inhabitants ), and that 1900s period was when they already made such large guns transportable by railway.
A pissed-off US government would have closed-off/imprisoned anybody materially supporting the stolen ( US Government owned ) flying city ( forcing it to go 'pirate', and then become an even bigger target for a concerted effort ).
SO the 'White People' in Columbia would have seen the need to consume the 'minorities' onboard once Finks's mechanical marvels ( the "Automatic Servitors" ) multiplied and made the serfs redundant. Soon they are swooping down and kidnapping them just for that reason. 
Example - "Irish Stew" is Literal.
Now THAT would have been a much more exciting storyline ( and grotesque cannibal white children are much more politically correct to shoot and blow up and dismember ).
Pamphlet : "Fink's Serving Columbia" ... ITS A COOKBOOK !!!!!!
---
Another Columbia ( the one that survived in some alternate universe ) sided with the Nazis during WW2 ( they had already eaten all the Vox - 'Soylent-Greened' them as Fink named it ...Fink musta seen that 70s movie ("Soylent Green") through a Tear... )
So Cannibal Nazis : The perfect 'Politically Correct' enemies ( 'Nazi Zombies' was already Trademarked )
( Ya, Das ist gute Schnitzel !!! Auch langes schwein !!! Es ist schön. )
--- --- ---
Village of the Stupid - Columbia ("Who dealt this mess ?") :
Infinite BS - Can we (in the MMORPG) harvest something good out of this miserable BioShock failure game ? :
* It is an Amusing Splicer nightmare might work - Those don't need to be logical/plausible.
* Redo and make Work that working Skyline extravaganza that Levine & Co simply could NOT deliver
* Add heaps of real Imagination ( How about a 'turnabout' allegory : A Black run Racist Hellhole ?? ) 
* Some Realistic 'What-Ifs' ( ie- Make it a proper Police State to show how miserably demented Punk 'Resistance' stories really are - Realism - THE PUNKS DIE AT THE END - THE STATE WINS )
* That Paris from the Start of BaSx - a great setting for a Zombie Apocalypse Scenario ( The 'little kid' is the first to scream "BRAINZZZZ !!!!" )
--- --- ---
Make Columbia a Real Amusement Park ( What Infinite BS SHOULD Have Been ) :
Fun and Fantasy and Thrills for the whole family ( as long as you're white ).
* Characters wandering around the 'Park' are all those weirdly costumed Creepies ( now with MORE quantum disturbance forms and attitudes ).
* "Firemen" dispense cold drinks and tea/coffee ( Or are portable BBQ grills ). 'Churros' haven't been invented yet.
* Skyline Rollercoaster (No changes required - except maybe to make the even more absurdly shaped and LESS circular).
* A B C D Ticket rides ( no E yet, that will be added when The Flying Pirates ride is added )
* Children vomiting from too much cotton candy - those servitors better be quick to clean it up ... ( or they get a day "in The Box' for not keeping their area cleared of vomit and other rubbish ).
* Ride the Fireman down main street and race the Automatic Horse things that look like they are out of the 'Wizard-of-Oz'
* Gunfight and Battle recreations - See how "Americans" handled those dirty foreigners ( take part in historic goodness ).
* Those rather odd 'Vigor' bottles seen in Infinite BS could be recycled as targets in a shooting gallery - "HIT FIVE AND WIN A GIMP-SUITED PIGEON DOLL !!!!" ( and combined with varying and amusing pyrotechnics on 'hits' ). Various other racist/prejudice-based fair games need to be created ( 'Cast The First Stone' ... ).
* Prop Mutations could be legion ( I smell a bottle design Tool for the MMORPG ... ) We can have New even more absurd ones (of course) to be added. Other weird props as well ( make the Boy-O-Silence's head spin ??? )
* Traitor Hangings, and Parades Twice a night, and Cannon Practice at Midnight ( Fireworks and Balloons just don't mix ... )
* Pioneer Island ( with real injun scalps ) Festively show : 'How the Whiteman Won America ...'
--- --- ---
Regurgitation Station - The DLC BS Express :
SOOOO MUCH POTENTIAL, SOOO LITTLE IMAGINATION USED
Infinite BS DLC - They really did not have to follow the same illogical plot elements as the main Infinite BS story IN RAPTURE ( There ARE infinite multiverses - remember ? ). But ( for them maybe ) it retroactively justifies even remotely calling that BS game "BioShock" ( after the fact - without any logical Rapture-linkage in Columbia itself in the primary game *OR* "Bio" anything ). (( Allegedly, the third game being set in Rapture again was what some of the writers REALLY wanted to do. ))
ANYWAY, For the DLC they could just have had more ( even some alternate ) Columbia adventures ( like what happened AFTER Comstock went insane ), and revisit a setting which the gamemakers had already done most of the work for ( something better/logical for a limited DLC budget ... with the potential for more/better DLC game scenes/plot to play through ), and maybe add somewhat more interesting activities in those places.
BUT NO. Instead, they spent alot of effort recreating all those Rapture game Assets. That is a whole lot of work/effort/time/money which COULD HAVE BEEN put into a Columbia-based DLC plot and events -- SO TO ALLOW a much-longer/more-interesting DLC game ( *OR* Hell, just have put all that effort into having done a less-sucky/less-short main Infinite BS game --- How much was worked on in parallel, Diverted from the main game ??? )
BTW, Why IS Booker there in Rapture ?? (( Beside 'cuz' the plot said so ))
* Are the Luteces just bored with their existence again, and are playing more of their twisted games ? ( Booker IS their PAWN/toy after all. )
* HE IS a developed character, and doesn't require so much backstory ( cheaper too for the gamemakers to recycle into the DLC ).
* SO Elizabeth is now seeking revenge on ANY/EVERY Booker/Comstock ? Who was it that told her this one Comstock was hiding in this Rapture place ? ( Another case of CONTRIVE-ITUS and CUZ-Fever ) That, despite it not really seeming to have anything to do with her storyline ... It is standard DLC-itus - Blehhh .
* WAS IT because One of the INFINITE number of Bookers fell thru a Tear ( escorted/assisted by the ever fun-loving Luteces ), and wound up in Rapture ( YET it being quite illogical that he happens to talk like a long-time resident who went thru the process of emigrating to Rapture ?? Typical DLC writers can be real dimwits, can't they ?? ) Just imagine (to be realistic) Booker's culture shock, WHEN he was dumped ~35 years into the future ... But Sorry, he's got to be 'savvy' to fit the story, don't he ? (His Growing up on the western plains, it is amazing he knows what a flush toilet is for, no ? )
* It is unfortunate DLC-laziness to have the Infinite BS plot-detail-stupidity carry over into our poor Rapture ?? Another element they missed elaborating upon : Now Booker P.I. somehow can frankly talk to Elizabeth ??? When he SHOULD know from his past ( whispers from the Luteces ) that she (Crazy Lizzie) is out to drown him (Booker=Comstock) again. That, AND that she is just a really-really twisted/revenge-driven person ( it is an obvious lie, as shown by her actions, that "saving Sally" isn't her real motive ). Having HIM KNOW that, and HIM try to kill her, THAT would have been much too interesting (I guess) for these writers to have come up with. ( A Twisted "Choice" would be YOU (Elizabeth) by reflex *HARVESTING* Sally, then making stupid excuses just before she turned on Booker - as part of the 'plot'.)
* We could also have had (for Rapture) fun ALTERNATE UNIVERSE changes like : Booker/Comstock is now Ryan ( or for that matter Rapture is now run by a female "Riana", an obviously different universe where a female might be a multi-millionaire industrialist ).
-
Because of that Multi-verse thing, which the writers originally chose to use, this ALL could have been an entirely different Booker/Elizabeth/Columbia -- With few connection to the bizarre events happening in the original Infinite BS story ( so little effort would be required in making it a whole 'nuther chapter in that already built Columbia setting -- EFFICIENT REAPPLICATION OF ASSETS - thus with MORE content ).
* A murderous Romp through Paris might also have been wondrous ( Nightmare Paris even MORE FUN ).
* Maybe Comstock Running Rapture !!! ( But please please please it should NOT have reused those lame Infinite BS type Combat and Controls and Props ).
* The Luteces of course are always available for another gig, playing their little games - have THEM F*ck around with Booker And Elizabeth and the whole story might have been made quite entertaining ( and difficulties overcome via easily choreographed via Cut Scenes ).
* With all the (more BS) claptrap about 'Merging Realities', this actually could be a case of Elizabeth imposing a 'Merging' into a completely innocent alternate Booker/Comstock ( How does she know that its not those troublesome Luteces just having more of their 'Fun' ??? ) No matter, she is bent on murderous revenge. (( Twist could have been another Elizabeth then seeking REVENGE on HER when its disclosed SHE is an ALTERNATE BOOKER/COMSTOCK !!! -- SERIOUSLY these writers have no imagination. ))
* With Tears and Infinite multiple universes, we can have whatever anybody wants appear anywhere, anytime, anyway, with no reason whatsoever required ( Just like Infinite BS, where physical laws and the writer's logic of thought simply CEASED ). Big Daddy - Handyman FIGHT !!!! Why is the Eiffel Tower underwater ?? Clowns ? FRENCH CLOWNS !!! Mimes to shoot wholesale ... who wouldn't love THAT ???
* Maybe we could have had a scene where a whole crowd of Bookers all gang up on Elizabeth and 'drown' HER this time ( If there's supposed to be Twists, then lets GIVE the Players TWISTS ... )
* OR she meets an alternate Elizabeth who tries to kill HER, or tried to prevent her killing Booker, or anything else they (we now) might think up. ( "NO, *I'M* THE REAL DIMENSION GOD" ... *PULLS HAIR*, *SCRATCHES AT EYES* ... )
* An imaginative item for a corrected plot would be : Mentioning that Suchong or Fink on looking into their 'Tear', get some other parallel dimension ( Note how convenient it was that these Tears, which could go to INFINITE places, always led right to the laboratories of a Super-Scientist "Super-Scientist" : See "Venture Brothers" on Adult Swim ).
* Perhaps, more amusingly : Having Suchong's 'Tear' opening into Comstock's butler's toilet where he hears some rather unsavory/unseeming gossip about Fink (or somesuch), and Suchong then uses that knowledge to blackmail Fink ( and ultimately Suchong escapes Rapture that way ).
* Suchong as the Player Character !!!!! ( "Suchong Teach that Arrogant Fink not to mess with Dr Yi !!!" )
The BETTER Alternatives are endless (INFINITE !!!). Too bad the writers imaginations were so meager.
-
[The Mega-Zeppelin -- "CONMAN-stock's Hands On Profit" - I will do that Fantasy Story one better, and have *ALL* of Columbia be ONE BIG AIRSHIP (( and its *not* a "Zeppelin", Kennyboi, that's the name of a German company brand - they are called "Dirigibles", "Air-Ships", "IT IS BALLOON" ( by certain Faux-Native Americans ) and "Lighter-Than-Air Craft" )).
If we are going to do this, then lets do it properly !!!
--- --- ---
Large Ground Crews Gimmick Scene ( replicating one of those pretentious Apple Company commercials ? ) :
Have the giant prattling Comstock Head while the huge Airship is coming in to land ... A Crowd of inhabitant drones standing in Awe.
The hydrogen filled (early) dirigibles were in-game mentioned ( the first "First Lady" ) can't be tiny ( not being FloatyShit(tm) ), so being large would need to have its facilities operate Real World like -- A REAL dirigible's size would dwarf even the gianourmous game scenery. 
Seriously, the writers were so desperate to be able to allegorically name drop "Hindenburg" in their story ( an icon the current crop of public school students might actually recognize ) that they carp-crap the story by not understanding from the start everything would be Quantumz-type floaters -- When the whole City itself was already floating, and many smaller test objects would have been made to DEMONSTRATE floating BEFORE the city was built (or even funded). 
Seriously, storyboards and 'good ideas' and effort wastage drove this game into its lameinocity.
--- --- ---
Damnation Alley 1893 :
Armored Trains on the Skyline ( In THOSE other dimensions the Vox never had a chance )
Maxim Gun firing Player Mini-Game ( like the gunship/helicopter scenarios in CoD Call Of Duty - a VERY successful game series )
--- --- ---
That Tear 'Reverse' Dimension ( in MMORPG redo which has lots of 'odd' *FUN* Tear dimension places ) :
Things happen backwards ( watch out when you used the restrooms ... Red Dwarf joke there )
OR the 'Up is Down' dimension ( The theoretical multiverse may allow different physical laws to exist ... This kind of thing is a sign of certain people "having way too much free time" hypothesizing ).
BTW - Technically this kind of multiverse thing is NOT 'theory', as per Science ( Something the usual mass-media wankers typically ignore for so many 'Science' things these days. 'Theory' is supposed to have some proof behind its possibility or real observable things to demonstrate the idea works ).
THAT'S NOT THEORY -- THAT'S LEROY !!! 
-
Could have lots of weird 'Tear' portal destinations where strange and wondrous things ( different laws of physics operate ) could take place, and Players could create unusual and fun effects in those 'Worlds' using the modifiable game mechanics ( I used to do this in Unreal Tournament by turning the Gravity really low ).
--- --- ---
The Real Deal ? :
The 1893 "Columbian" Exposition, commemorated the 400th Anniversary of Columbus' voyages to the New World. ( Oops, you thought it was that image of a White Woman, Manifest Destiny image wrapped in the 'Stars and Stripes' ?? )
SO giant robot Columbia ( he wore monks garb ) rampaging about on a giant flying wooden boat ?? ( Yah ... Kenny could make it a slaveship ) Screaming "I'll Nina, Pinta and Santa Maria YOU SUCKA !!!!"
Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show played in Chicago during the Exposition. We could have had alot of fun with THAT. ( Maybe some of those 'evil' injuns were kidnapped later for Comstock's racialist freakshow ??? )
--- --- ---
GAME IMAGINATION - Would Have Been : A Dr-Who Castrovalva-like Columbia :
Quantumz making everything every direction at once -- See THAT'S what you use Quantumz for, not some weak-kneed 'floatyshit'. One of those 'universes with different laws of Physics' which some Quantum Theorists sometimes talk about. ( This could/can be a Alternate "Many-Worlds" Columbia used as a Splicer Dream in the main MMORPG. )
Tears Used as Portals in an Escher-like city. Relative orientation localized ( You'll have to be clever to resolve the boundaries where the shifts happen for game mechanics ... including moving projectiles ).
Unfortunately, it does take real game mastery to provide a proper story within a free movement type (sandbox) game world ( or one with pretty sunny clouds and shiny buildings ).
--- --- --
Flying Bicycles for Columbia :
Some SteamPunk fan did a '3D' artwork version of something ( a anachronistic streamlined 1930s bike with Songbird-like type wings ).
Bicycles were just becoming big around the Turn of the Century. Makes far more sense then that Skyline stuff ( certainly as they did it in the game ). 'Chase Scenes', mounted weapons/accessories, sweeping maneuvers being possible, far more than with that 'Skyline'. Unfortunately, unrestricted movement is a No-No in a "Player to be led by the nose like a Steer" type shooter game ( so as with having other realistic vehicles in the Game Engine, it would take more complicated scripting/programming to do right ). The MMORPG system would be designed to support such features. 
--- --- ---
The Fink Music Gun Mk3 :
* Sound can KILL !!! ("But, But I only had it set on "Stun" Sergeant ...")
* With a cylinder sound option ( Heh, not some anachronistic record they shouldn't have used for those Vox-o-Phonez ) to switch affects.
* "LETS JEREMIAH HIS ASS !!!" (a saying)
* Weird sounding sounds for easy to vary Assets ( stay away from copyrighted sounds though ).
* "Do, Re, Mi, Fa, So, La, Ti, DIE !!!!!"
We can have this in the MMORPG Fantasy corner ( deranged Splicers have such very weird dreams ).
--- --- ---
Gibberish Made From Real Terms ( Reverse Attempts To 'BS' Real Science - It is Fantasy ) :
For your gaming pleasure : "Excitonic Condensation" ( great buzzword usable for just about anything you want - If you are hack gamewriters ). Add "Graphitic Bernal Stacked Configurations" and we can have a truly righteous techo-gibberish hootenanny.
Real terms variously related to superconductors and whatnot. But I'm sure that they could be exploited for game related things which they have little to do with ( Maybe they are the what caused the ghost of Lady Comstock to be such a pain ??? ... ) 
Maybe not. Infinite BS used buzzwords many people have heard ( and have been thrown around alot in fluff science 'shows' to be familiar ), but really are too esoteric to be explained and understood ( and for how they are misused/abused in the game ).
--- --- ---
Mary Poppins Physics :
Columbia should have been designed like a Giant Kite ( and with a 50 mile long kite string )
A number of catchy musical tunes would be required of course... ( dancing policemen and such ... )
At the end, Flame out Comstock's Umbrella, and send him to his Doom ...
Oops, that all would require talent to pull off successfully.
"It Takes A Spoonfull of Bullshit to make Fake BioShock Go Down, to make Fake BioShock Go Dowwwwwn ... Fake ...." 
--- --- ---
Sci-Fi Ideas To Add To Improve Columbia (the MMORPG Redo) : 
Columbia is powered from some sideways (multiverse) universe ( no not one about 'wine and whiney writer wannabees' ), and the truth is then shown that they are killing everything in that other dimension and the people in it ( and strangely it turns out to be *OUR* universe ... ) And then this team of scientists and soldiers go through a 'Tear' to put an end to it ( taking a Nuke with them to take out 'the fiends on the other side' ). Now THAT'S some original writing ...
--- --- ---
AS Einstein said in 1905 : "This is retarded !!!" :
After Einstein read Luteces Published Scientific Papers, and the proposals in it ... 
He later laughed at "Columbia : The High City" where alot of people were fooled/deluded by a clever application of Ergot Extract ( which was a natural form of LSD ). Comstock should have followed that rule about "Don't Get High On Your Own Supply" ...
--- --- ---
[pix]
Disney Did It Better :
The first part of Infinite BS was alot like entering old Disneyland ... Main Street, then you take a right to Tomorrowland, and all the 'behind the scenes' stuff. ( AHA. Them virtually cloning all those old fruit company posters/box-art was bad enough in BS1/BS2, but now ... ) Actually alot of it did look and feel like Coney Island. (( And how that is supposed to accord with 'New Eden' makes me wonder about Ken Levine's warped thinking processes - That he might attribute such to 'other people' in those evil days in American 'history' ))
--- --- ---
If You Wanna Do Real Stupid Fantasy Then ... :
Infinite Universes ?? SO let's have at least one 'micro' universe Up Elizabeth's Ass, and the one up Comstock's Ass ( and Booker's naturally ... and TWO Lutece Asses ? NO, THAT WOULD BE TOO STRANGE ), AND they are inter-dimensionally at War with each other. Seriously, that is more logical/interesting than what the BS game's plot turned out to be ...
--- --- ---
Consider Substituting an 'Alternate' Elizabeth ... : 
Elizabeth having an "Ugly As Sin" Ogre-like face/body might have given you a different game outlook, No ? No more leveraging the standard/endemic cartoon-prettiness to make the character extra-palatable to the typical Player demographic. That at least would present a new effect ( and allow a "Politically Correct" beratement of 'Players' for being repulsed and prejudiced ) rather than regurgitating the regurgitation that Infinite BS was.
While I'm being creative : have 'old' Comstock be the detective she comes to see, and have him decrepitly ( having been burned by the Tears ) wheezing and limping about, and squinting at things with his deteriorating Eyesight, and missing most shots fired in any fighting ( Comstock ... Catch !!!! SMACK !!! ) Combat would be MUCH more challenging then.
--- --- ---
Columbia - Could Have Been One Big Charnal House :
Somewhere in some high obscured spot - YOU find a large creepy pile of bones from the people that Songbird carried off and killed/tore apart/ate(?) (( Gothic Horror Columbia sounds alot better NOW, Don't it ? ))
We never did see a HUGE Bird Feeder full of giant seeds, did we ???
I suppose all the dead 'Untermenschen' ( worked to death or brutalized ) might get dumped at sea to dispose of 'the evidence'. ( How to hide all this from all the 'white' population's eyes ??? Preserving the pretense of good American Freedom/Equality and all that, in this flying Strawman of supposedly historic American culture ... Remember when I say "BS", It don't stand for 'Bird Seed' . )
Now it is explained - Songbird was fed on human corpses -- PROBLEM SOLVED.
--- --- ---
Just a Bit Too Unstable :
So much weirdness attributed to the Cultist loons in Columbia ?? Seeing the whole place crash spectacularly would be something EPIC, ( It wasn't really possible for you to be in the presented Columbia of that lame-assed game - as Columbia would have come apart LONG before 1912 - from inside or from the outsides World's reaction ).
Memories in some 'survivors' head, who is now in a Insane Asylum ( ranting about giant leather wearing pigeons ... And 'Ghosts' ... )
--- --- ---
Systematic Lobotomization of the Servile Classes ??? ( Lobotomies were done to 'calm' violent, diusruptive and argumentative patients ) :
How do you keep Irishmen ( the whitest of the serfs ) in such servitude otherwise ?? Why would they even come to this cultist police state [crapsack - https://evil.wikia.com/wiki/Crapsack_World : https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CrapSackWorld ? ) (( Oops, you forgot about American Freedom of Religion there, Kennyboi ))
How else could you KEEP anyone there in Columbia who did not like being there ( or rather was being abused and oppressed and tyrannized ) ????
Dissatisfied residents can sabotage things, and cause chunks of the city fall from the sky or ram into each other. You can quietly set fire to the wood lathing in a closet and whole building/block goes up like a bonfire.
Servants mingling with their betters ?? ( They must be kept in profound fear, so as to not simply chuck all their 'betters' over-the-side OR stab them while they sleep ??? -- The Social Pyramid requires big pile of 'workers' to support a few ruling elite and any middle class they have 'bought off'. )
Even Elites in a Police State are impinged upon. For all that pretty sunny airy space, Columbia is really quite small if you want/need 'safe zones' for "Whites Only" -- the 'Cattle' by Infinite BS's year-date are no longer 'cowed' or trusted, many of them having previously been Americans ( Unless Comstock has been kidnapping Columbia's serfs from other countries to replace a constant servile class attrition ). 
--- --- ---
Scene - Columbia Destroying NYC in 1984 ? :
I would think that a (real) single nuclear-tipped Air-to-Air missile fired from a single Air Force Interceptor Jet ( intended for Soviet Bombers ) could have ended that threat decades earlier. 
After Columbia was built, the World wouldn't stop, after all. ( All that is assuming Columbia wasn't finished off by the US Government LONG before then, maybe only a little after 1912. ) Fantasy plots, you see, can be quite stupid/illogical, even if the game scenes might 'Look Good' to The Suits. Another 'Good Scene' would be Booker doing the "Joker Pencil Trick" on Old Elizabeth ... dontcha think ? Far Better ... and shockingly amusing to boot - kind-of a jump scare thingee when it happens 'Out of the Blue' ( Then there's no need to get drowned, now is there ? -- This Optional Ending is activated by selecting the Deaths Head pendant for Elizabeth, when the Luteces offer it on a tray of dozens of other 'tokens' to choose ).
--- --- ---
WORD OF THE PROPHET : "How can I fool everyone ALL of the time" - Zachary Hale Comstock : 
Excerpt : "with the hallucinogen that Lutece woman cooked up, I could fool people into believing in anything I tell them ..."
A much simpler explanation (plot) without relying on the ridiculous faux-science component of the game ( and a better relevant story allegory for : 'How people are Willing to be deluded', rather than Levine's crap about the perfect alibi of "the quantumz made me do it" OR "It 'did' and 'did not' happen - both at the same time, and neither" ... ) 
Sorry Ken, people are not quantum particles ( and DONT behave following Quantum Mechanics ).
Mass hypnotism (drug-aided) ... "I'd pay a dollar to see that !!!" ( Actually with Booker NOT being yet affected, he would see through the lie (at first). )
--- --- ---
Scene we Might Have Seen ( Alternate Dimension ) :
Elizabeth (in Rapture BaS2 ) sees the dress she arrived in hanging in the store (Blue Fin ??) where the 'Tear' opened that brought her to Rapture -- and it is A CLOWN SUIT... ( modify that Audio Diary where Suchong seeing a Tear, sees a CLOWN appear ... ) OR she sees a 'Tear' open and an alien that looks like Fozzy Bear quickly grabs it - and maybe there is a tug-of-war through the Tear for it ( Tear closes suddenly, leaving half a Fozzy Bear dying on the floor ... ).
---
Anyway -- ALTERNATE CLOWN UNIVERSE !!!
Fink steals a book from Leonardo's De Vinci's workshop and tries to re-engineer what he thinks might be some great achievement, and he makes a Pasta Making Clockwork Mechanism - he had grabbed a cookbook, and because he couldn't read Italian ... ( Actually a good point for any other info for Tech that Fink might try to steal interdimensionally -- Heh, and another strike against Fink is : Most of the complex technical jargon he finds/hears/reads, he STILL really wouldn't know, EVEN if it WAS all in English ).
The Motorized Patriots actually have a midget inside controlling them ( Seriously, do you think clockworks can control any complex behavioral interactions ?? Levine & Co do apparently - Just because they attempt to make computer games doesn't mean they know anything about how "them magic 'com-pu-ter' boxes" operate ... Much of the real world has them mystified too. ) Heh- 80 midget clowns climb outta the Motorized Clown Patriot ( how'd they all fit ??? )
MUCH more logical to have Fink be a Thief and a Charlatan than for him to be able to understand/employ the Megaton of Knowledge he is alleged to make use of in MAKING even a few of the things seen in-game.
Another 'Fun scene' : Fink trying to offer candy to a Little Sister in Rapture to try to obtain some ADAM ( OR even trying to kidnap her ), and the resulting stain/mess on the ground after the Big Daddy is through with him. ( Remember with 'alternate universes' you can have INFINITE fun scenes like this ... )
--- --- ---
The World Moved On :
With Quantumz developments down below far in advance of backwater "Columbia", you would likely have teenage vandals and gangs from down below attacking Columbia with their Flying "Model T" cars - robbing and beating inhabitants, and laughing at the 'Police' and cretinous 'Firemen', and then simply fly off from them. If a 'barge' tried to pursue them, it would get quickly surrounded, disabled, and sent crashing to the ground to the delinquents merriment.
The Flying Cesspit has become such a joke that various Ground Dwellers take pot shots at it with their Tesla Death Ray guns, and carve off a chunk of Comstock's broken-down farce -- just for fun. Comstock can only shriek and pull out his hair at the contempt ordinary people hold for him.
--- --- ---
IF the game is actually about the social issues, then with such a Fantasy Presentation why not have ponies doing a lynching of a cow.
THIS Answer to Players who say its Fantasy, so that we don't expect logic in portraying historic lies to 'make a point'. If it is a Parable, then MAKE it a parable without alot of pseudo-historic claptrap.
--- --- ---
"The Flying Cannibals of Columbia" - by Jules Verne (Hoolio Vernandez)
* French genius destroys the incestuous maniac flying town which had been going about menacing and kidnapping unfortunate peoples from French colonies, with the inhuman purpose of consuming them.
* Inbred pagans from America empowered by evil inbred scientist pair 
* East Africa - the Heinous Harvest ( stopping only because they ran out of their foul Ketchup )
* The struggle in the abattoir and the barbaric feast ( mocking of the French most horribly )
* The Death Ray is Used - The Nightmare is Ended.
--- --- ---
WHERE ARE THE PRIVATE BLIMPS IN COLUMBIA ?? :
Modern technology is the rage after all, and AUTOMOBILES were the happening thing in 1912.
SO where were ALL the flying equivalents for Columbia ??
Just like the 'Bathyspheres' for Rapture not being anything like the automobile in a modern city, blimp-like airships should be there in Columbia. We are shown a system of disjoint passage in 'barges' and 'gondolas' and zeppelin-fails ( and odd wheel things attempting to run on isolated roads and impaired by multitudes of stairs ), but there are no personal air vehicles to try to link/traverse a city broken up by its wide air-gaps. 
Blimps are cheap choreographed effects. They coulda been floating about everywhere showing an active community - blithely floating about while our gun battles were going on.
--- --- ---
The Sunken Atlantis (Alegory ?) :
Various weird mystic stuff from prewar Germany ( certain Nazis were fanatics about that mythological/mysticism stuff ). More than just the mythological NAMING theme that Rapture employs, much weirdness ... 
Aryan Supermen in their Advanced City ( Except what destroyed them if they were so smart/powerful ?? - their arrogance/hubris was what the Atlantis myth said. )
Is this a Stage Play someone did in Rapture ? Bioluminous Paint Backdrops.
--- --- ---
Historical? Sorry. : 
If Levine wanted real cliche racism in Infinite BS then he shoulda had a Plantation 'thing' on Columbia ( made it all one big Floating Slave Hell Plantation ). Possibly have all the 'Black' people ( which includes Mediterranean-types to 'white' people of that era ) forced to go about in reverse minstrel paint (white-face) so as to not 'offend' the sensitivities of the "Founders". If you want to portray Racism, then portray it realistically instead in a timid Politically Correct manner.
IDEA - a Reverso Parable, with Black people In Charge, enslaving Whites ( It is supposed to be about the reprehensible societal ills of 'slavery' and 'bigotry' and 'racism', you know ... ) Shocking ? But then, it is supposed to be to actually 'MAKE THE POINT'. The Faux-History and Faux-Society just didn't cut it.
Sorry, but it was all so watered down, contrived milk-toast 'racism' there, mainly to pretend to be 'relevant' and 'edgy' to gun-crazed teenage gamers. Try flinging racial slurs if you really want to be edgy and realistic there, Ken. The provided ( pre-built into the 'city' slum ) "Shantytown" scene was particularly ridiculous. 
It was just a "Shooter Game" filled with cardboard cutouts and prattling puppets ( and a wonder to have cost $100 million and taken 5 years ). You would think it could have been done so much better.
--- --- ---
Some Things Which Comstock Saw In The Future Greatly Scared Him :
* A web of evil reaching to every house that was used to worship Talking Cats
* Disco Music ( an immigrant abomination bent on stealing Souls )
* Chia Pets ( the work of the demon lord himself )
* A further new Century where Freak Show Clothing was worn in the daylight.
* An abominable horror known as Carrot Top ( Playing nightly in the Casino of Hell )
He swore he would destroy Columbia before he let these things take root in his Holy floating city ... Hallelujah !!!!!
--- --- ---
Columbia Doesn't NEED to Be A Disjoint Bunch of Floating Buildings and Haphazard Blocks of 'Land' :
The Fantasy Technology they had in the game could make a whole lot more float in one big CHUNK, no? Quantumz Can DO Anything.
SO a big block of land floating - No edges everywhere ( with far fewer railings required ) preventing inhabitants from slipping and plummeting 10000 feet to their deaths - Nice SHORT paths to walk everywhere, Transportation all in one contiguous network for actual convenience ... If you want a 'higher place', just add a hill in the middle ( or the "Nine Hills of Columbia" if you wish ). Make the CHUNK thick enough and the 'Untermenschen' can be kept below in the bowels of the place - Hidden out of sight of their 'Betters', whom they serve.
Otherwise, I see severe problems when you want Columbia to 'move' and its in 80 different pieces all bumping into each other and getting tangled up. ( 'Artists' should stick to painting pretty pictures ... and leave realistic work to those who accept the need for engineering ).
OR do a proper 'Cloud City' Heaven -- all gossamer, airy and light, without that clunky Pseudo-Victorian Kludge Mess Columbia was turned into. Angle Wings for all ...
--- --- ---
Couldabeenwalking.jpg| What real difference did it make to the story for Columbia to 'Float in the Air ???
Imagination.jpg|Jenga Columbia ??? Comstock : "Stairway to Heaven ? Not quite. But they better like stairs if they are to come here !!!"
--- --- ---
 Elizabeth's "Twist" in Burial At Sea :
Turns out it was the EVIL Elizabeth (in BaSx) who sold Sally into Little Sister Slavery ( now THAT might've been an interesting 'Twist', No ? ) She is a ADAM-Pimp working with Sander Cohen, running her string of "Ho's", as she calls them. Creepy scenes of 'extracting' the ADAM from the children ...
Another : More than one Elizabeth at a time including Lizzy LecterFrom "Silence of the Lambs" , the cannibal psychopath. 
OR an OLD Elizabeth coming to take YOUNG Elizabeth to steal her body to rejuvenate herself ...
--- --- ---
1902 Secession - Of The Floating Carnival :
Dubious state of an old (by 1902) floating Show City, populated with actors/carnies. It is more likely to be in a decrepit state, floating/grounded at a junkyard, awaiting to be broken-up for scrap -- Years after it became "old-hat" and 'obsolete'. It is nine years later (after 1893) and the tech was long previously stolen and spread around the World ( There IS NO WAY IT WOULDN'T HAVE BEEN - directly/immediately possessed by the US Government ... just for starters ). 
The US Government would have CUT OFF funding for a now decrepit and embarrassing Columbia LONG before, and it could only survive by attending county fairs, carnivals and other events for CASH to keep it solvent ... barely ( possibly it could have been sold to some South American country as a 'cheap' item of prestige - advanced for THAT part of the World ). 
No problem for Charles-Manson-crazy Comstock, and his Cult to steal it, and go on their murderous crime spree ( Oh The Humanity !!! )
--- --- ---
Alternate Universes ...
Now THAT woulda been a 'Twist'. But the gamemakers were less 'Envelope Stretchers' than they loudly claimed themselves to be.
Holy Electra Complex, Batman !!! 
--- --- ---
Alternate Infinites (Horror-scape) :
Ben Franklin with his access to Lightning - reanimating dead ( isn't that what we were told the Vita-Chamber did, and then there's the magic juice Elizabeth injects into Booker ?? Zombase ... ) For the altered somewhat-better pseudo-science cliche Columbia - Now having their own Frankenstein ( An Even Neater Handyman ... )
Columbia could also have its own version of Vampires ( After all, isn't that what a Little Sister is ? ) Vampires would be quite at home in a nighttime floaty cityscape. Nice an bright and shiny by day, but once it gets dark ...
Now every other trashcan and corpse will have Garlic in them for loot. Silver Bullets being hard to come by.
The Bat ( perfect environment flying and all the lights to attract insects, along with the raw sewage of that era ).
Songbird (DemonWing) needs to be able to breath fire ( or shoot Lightning out of its arse ).
Ghosts ... of all the people Comstock/Booker/Fink killed ( half the place is a Cemetery - and you never DID get to see the catacombs ).
Loch Ness monster in Battleship Bay ( Och man !! Loook at thee Booones !!!"Monty Pyhon and the Holy Grail" movie reference ... )
Yes, and Zombies are by far the best -- Side effect of the metaphysical mumbo-jumbo Comstock tapped into by sacrificing His Daughter to the Devilz ( a Brother and Sister Team now ) ...
A Plantation (Jefferson and Washington ) connection means - Yes you guessed it - Voodoo !!! Throw in a few Irish Banshees just for fun.
All your classic ( and non-copyrighted baddies ) are fair game and can be interwoven into the horrorscape.
Are YOU starting to realize what a MMORPG game system like this is capable of ?? - Something we could actually have "some day".
--- --- ---
If ur gonna have a Dim plot ( for the BaSx regurigation ) - Go All The Way !!! :
Have 'Daisy' Fitzroy stab HERSELF in the back ( or back into the scissors held by Elizabeth ) to make the stupidly ( BaSx DLC ) revised scene even more dim. "I'm gonna cut ya whitey bitch!!!" ( to Finks child --- Oh, Fink was married ?? (( The MMORPG Redo might examine THAT )) )
Yeah right, just because 'Two Honkeys' tell her (Daisy) it 'Will be Better This Way', Daisy ( the murderous firebrand ) will sacrifice herself for 'The Good of All' ... 
WHAT FRICKEN BULLSHIT these third rank DLC writers came up with !!!
Stupidest writing in the whole series ( a Crescendo of Derpy hack writing )
--- --- ---
Vampire Columbia (alternate #6525) : 
Count Comstock is attempting to fly the city to the eternal night of the center of the earth ( through a volcano ventOr the opening at the South Pole - according to the Flat Earthers. ... or at least THATS the plan ). Columbia unfortunately cannot fly fast enough to keep up with the day-night terminator.
Of course Teddy Roosevelt will have the US Marines attack in the morning and blow open all buildings to the Sunlight.
--- --- ---
Kinetoscope Analysis : "Uncanny Mystery in Columbia" 
* You see a woman staring bewildered at a hazy disruption in the air
* "Columbia marvels and fears at unfamiliar sights..."
* You see a woman cover her face at the unnatural phenomenon --
* "What is it ?!"
* A shimmering haze appears on the pediment of a building --
* "What are these astonishments which appear and disappear ?"
* Rosalind Lutece stands against/next to a gate separating a clamoring crowd --
* "Columbia's greatest mind isn't saying..."
FIN
.
SO, Mysterious visages (Tears) are seen constantly in Columbia ? So Columbia is 'Hainted' and Prophet Comstock cannot or WONT stop it ? Witches are pointed out ( "That one there with the ankles showing is of the Devil !!!" ), are to be seized and burned alive. 
* People Shriek : "Why did Comstock bring us to this Evil Place ?" 
* They all yell : "Kill Him, AND his Satanic Minions!!!!" 
* One man foaming at the mouth screams : "BURN THE FALSE PROPHET !!!" 
* Crowd with torches heads towards Comstock House : "He is a Warlock !!! .... BURN HIM NOW !!!!!!"
* Scene of the Luteces being beaten to death with farm implements ...
* Scene of a man's Corpse being Burned at the Stake ( and a merry crowd singing "Ding Dong The Witch is Dead a song stolen from a 1939 movie" )
FIN
--- --- ---
A more fatal game where mishaps bring the 'GAME OVER' screen overlay. You now have to protect Elizabeth, who being a shutin isn't familiar with hazardous things like gunfire, dropoffs, leaping out into space and 'Tear' side effects.
--- --- ---
Murder - BE DE WHITE THANG :
Columbia ( something to have for their typical allusion to Real World stuff ) shoulda had its own mass-murderer ( like the H H Holmes guy ) with a creepy scene Elizabeth and Booker come upon in their wanderings - Vats dissolving bodies to sell the skeletons down below to raise money --- even Nazi-esque Soap made from the reduced body fat of the victims --- 'Lay the horror on thick' to pretend this is a 'Whites is da Debil' that all of America was -- according to Levine & Co.
--- --- ---
ALTERNATE ELIZABETH :
The Player won't quite have the same relation as they did with the Disney Princess Elizabeth, but maybe this one can help during all the gunbattles.
--- --- ---
--- --- ---
Elizabeth Learns to Use the Bidet ... :
Alternate Dimension where Columbia was created by the French, so Elizabeth gets to go to Paris after all ... Except she finds out that there are large parts/aspects of Paris which In-Reality are very dark and sinister and dangerous ( and the French are Rude !!! ). Comstock wears a beret and forces Elizabeth to eat those thick sauces ( and speaks with an Outrageous Accent... And then he taunts her for 'a second time' ... ).
We get to see all 'The Social Ills of France' caricatured ( real and imagined ).
--- --- ---
Stoning the Miscegenationists at the Fair ... :
Next Day it would be 'Impaling the Sodomites', and Once a Month its 'The Burning of The Unbelievers' ( Few of those are left in the upper-classes to be worthy of the Spectacle, and so SIMULTANEOUS MULTIPLE BURNINGS would have to be substituted for more ordinary transgressors ).
Lynching of a black boy that simply LOOKED at a White woman ( That would be Real Southern Style Racism -- Which Levine apparently thinks of as 'America' - Yet, HE cowardly, never bothered to show something 'THAT REAL' in this game ).
--- --- ---
In April of 1934 the First Laundromat Opened in Fort Worth, TX. :
Ohhhh Noooooos !!! With all the washing-machines needed in Columbia ( for the 'White peoples' clothes at least ... and their servants, and all those hooded 'Meetin' Robes ), how exactly could it all possibly 'Float' ?? Washtubs are just so pre-1893, and would make the Great Prophet's promises a DAMNED Lie !!!! (( Hmm Idea : Every White person in Columbia is dressed like a Klansman so the writers can make it very clear that the place is Racist - wouldn't be less subtle than so many other things that WERE done in the game. ))
--- --- ---
Comstocks Calcu-latrix (Comp-u-tor) ? :
pix
The 'Columbia Calcu-latrix Machine' takes up an entire city block section by itself ( called Fink's Folly by Comstock - NOTE only 13 workers were killed building this amazing machine and 117 maimed, but who's counting ? )
It was actually a make-work project to keep certain suspicious people busy while always being under observation ( Kindof a Gulag-While-U-Wait ).
It successfully calculated how much money was wasted making the game, when it was redesigned twice and then micromanaged into incohesiveness.
--- --- ---
Dimwit Investigations ( a Weird Dream for the MMORPG ) :
Relive at least the first part of Infinite BS ( or both BaS ) except with a personification of 'Dimwit' replaces Booker ...
Amusing voice and clumsy actions and suicidal decisions ( which AREN'T REALLY YOUR DECISIONS )
A WHOLE VARIETY OF AMUSING Slo-mo death scenes ( alot like those 'stupid things' people do videos of - Except much more fatal, cringeworthy and fun ).
--- --- ---
Alternate Infinites ( It is Fantasy - We Can Do Anything We Want ... ) :
Aha !! The 'Vampire' Columbia theme ( They don't like immigrants because 'too much garlic', and the threat of "Teddy Roosevelt, Vampire Shredder" ... )
Graveyards and weird 'Shrieker' things ... could be And no, the hood-ornament Boys of Silence don't "cut it" - What were they smoking when they came up with that ? And worse, that it was even LESS than what they first showed in the Trailers ( lost most of the potential for its weirdness after that ). What exactly was the Quantumz reasoning for all that ? Sir Issac Newton would hardly recognize Physics these days ...
While visiting (over) Transylvania, Columbia had an unexpected visitor, who never left ...
Dracula(Vampires/Nosferatu) can fly - so perfect environment for him in Columbia ( Player needs the flying rig, that was obvious and never provided in the game ). Forget that stupid thimble, are those teeth marks on Elizabeth's neck ?? Now the Luteces are only seen at night, or seem to always be wearing sunglasses ...
-
Before we knew the "I am me" twisty meagerness ( I'm NOT your Father!! I'm HER Father!! He's her Father... He's her Grand-Father ... She's My Sister and She's My Daughter... I am your Father AND Mother !!!! )
( Now THAT would have been a strange scene - Comstock in the dress with that beard...) -- Simply too many "Chinatown" vibes here ... ).
-
Elizabeth is all screwed up ( Dimensionally "hit on the head" ) -- In THIS dimension Booker and Comstock ARE different people ... ( You see the trauma of unfortunates alive/dead as part of Elizabeth's 'Tear' activities, then what might it have done to her to exist in a universe she STILL existed in ?? ) She keeps throwing things at Booker because she thinks its the dog that keeps stealing her cookies. Derp!!
--- --- ---
We Would Prefer Better DLC ( Rather Than Trashing Rapture's Canon ) :
AND MAKE IT AS AMUSING AS POSSIBLE...
* Songbird (in Rapture) chasing Booker and Elizabeth like a Giant Parakeet thru those Gerbil Habitat tubes ...
* Columbia Crashed on the Ground - Wreckage all out of kilter for yet another movement style - climbing ( besides your trusty Skyline Grip and its strange magnetic qualities ). Movable Scenery Props with a puzzle element.
* You play as Hank the Handyman, and you get some backstory on Columbia and for Hank. Maybe you go up against the evil collectivist 'Bitchypoo' ( who sees Biggyman Hank as bad ) because she is murdering and enslaving and creating her own cult which everyone is forced to worship. In the end, her daughter Eleanor (oops) Ilene takes off with you in a 'LifeRaft' where YOU manage to fall out of it and drown to death, after saving whatever ...
Play as Elizabeth ( the following is not original ) :
ELIZABETH CONTROLS :
* Press A to Toss stuff to Booker
* Press Y to Cry and question Booker about his moral standings
* Press B to Marvel at the outside world
* Press X to Open Tears and do cool girl stuff.
* Press Reset to start talking normal after a horrendous bloody gut-wrenching firefight where Booker slaughtered over a dozen human beings
? What button do you press for 'Skipping', or is that Elizabeth's default movement ?
Your job Playing is mainly to remove yourself from the hail of bullets while Booker exterminates yet another Zerg Rush of baddies.
* Press 'X' 'Y' 'Z' 'Z' 'Y' to stab baddie in the back with pair of scissors (limited special maneuver)
* BioShock Infinite 2 - not sure what plot there is left for a Prequel or Sequel - The cat is already 'out of the box' ( to coin a phrase ). Maybe make the most of the convenient 'anything can happen' multiverse and reuse Columbia Assets -- But have it invaded by a multitude of different opponents groups ( one flavor at a time ) -- Predators, Killer Clowns, Spider Splicers, Psychedelic Gummy Bear Cannibals, US Marines, The French, Robot Unicorns, Chainsaw-wielding Raptors, Apache Lychathropes ( Were-Jackrabbits ), etc ...
* You play Rosalind and Robert Lutece in their last 24 seconds as they fry in their Sabotaged "Transdimensional Contraption" - Slo-mo boiling brains and smoke pouring out of ears.
* How about that we are microbes walking around in a giant organism named 'Ken' ?
* MP with Skylines? Problem : Does it move TOO fast and the latency would mess up the Skyline action too severely. Either it is too slow, making you a target on a 'track' too far away like a duck in a shooting gallery, or whipping about and in so fast that opponents don't see you coming especially now that it is more '3D' ) ?
Already, other idiot developers, like for "CoD ModernWar2 MW3", who have actually sped up MP movement rates, making the latency effects even worse -- they cater to a crack-monkey 14-year old mentality. Actually, I found BS2 MP more realistic in many ways ( which itself could have used more character HitPoints and far less/no Insta-kills so that fighting could develop tactics a little, rather than largely being a coin-toss ).
* Running Trainz on Skylines - What they were meant for BEFORE they turned them into bizarro-land Rollercoasters, and worse, illogical small circular tracks within the level.
* Blooper Reel for the Infinite BS game ( all your favorite scenes with stupid things happen - the usual stuff they have in the Blooper content - now made specifically/intentionally for many movies ).
* Use the same idea as the "Little Sisters Crazy Dollhouse" ( the delusion LS see, which we saw in BS2 ) - Columbia is just such a delusion which Booker drops into, and the whole place is actually a charnel house (corpse carnival) - Everyone already dead but pretending they aren't. The big moment : "I see Dead People" ... (?)
* Somehow warp back to the story point in BS2 -- Where, in the end, you weren't allowed to "get your hands on" Sofia Lamb to NOW have a proper "moral choice" to 'kill her' or 'let her live' and then face what Eleanor would have thought about it. Scene could be stretched with interactive Flashbacks with all the nasty things Sofia Lamb said and did.
* A 3000 year old Witch cursed a Village named Columbia to be forced to wander the world 'in stupidity forever' ( Hey that's a better plot than Ole Kenny came up with ... ) The quantum physics thing was just a cover by Comstock up to prevent the witchcraft making all "the damned" on Columbia revolt or commit suicide. Now "with an 'ending' unlike any seen before" - Elizabeth may be 3000 years old and IS THAT Witch or Demon ( ... Who cares at this point ? If you get to shoot at them and turn them into an explosion of blood and jibs ? ).
* A Columbia Public Service Instructional sequence of 'Proper and Safe use of the Sky-Lines'.... ( From the times before things "went to pot" in Columbia ).
* A room full of Automatic Gentlemen coming alive and coming at the Player would be a memorable situation. Not all of them have to attack the Player but the Player doesn't know which ones are the 'evil ones' ...
* Crawling up walls is something 'foreigners' do ... NOT upstanding citizens. ( So no Spider Splicers or Cat Crazies in Columbia ).
* New 'Heavy Hitter' - The Mini-Zeppelin would be really tiny -- Like the guys body is suspended from it like a mini-parachute ( shoulder straps, not a one-handed Mary Poppins ) - The balloon just over his head and the propeller on his back, weapons maybe on a tray in front of him. Small enough to maneuver thru alot of scenery (up in the air) but at a slower pace than running. Flag streaming behind would be a neat visual effect ... Pilot wearing flying helmet and goggles ( to hide their face and dehumanize them so you can slaughter/exterminate without guilt ).
--- --- ---
Alternate Where Elizabeth Looks Like a Leprerous Mini-Ogre (Gollum-Ugly).
You (Booker) spend the game trying to get rid of her - Sorry you aren't allowed to shoot her yourself ( But IF she just 'winds up dead somehow, you might wrangle a partial payment ? If you produce a head and shrug alot and have a 'good story' ...)
--- --- ---
Boxer Rebellion BS ? :
That is Assuming Comstock was even in Control of Columbia at that point he is 'in charge' -- The Chinese Boxer Rebellion was between 1899 and 1901 ( vs 1902 Secession ). The US Government wasn't amused, and with Public Outcry shouting at the politicians, action was taken for that situation ... 
( Many Alternate Comstocks doing that Mutiny were Publicly Hung within 6 months in MOST universes having similar events ).
--- --- ---
A 'odd' Columbia which is ONE BIG FERRIS WHEELNot just a measly 250 feet in diameter but 2500 feet across !! !!
Now that RollerCoaster Skyline actually makes sense.
--- --- ---
Jack is Delta ? Probably Not :
Heh, it would be Sofia Lamb then that Eleanor might have been reconstituting from 10 year-old rotted corpse tissue, instead of Johnny Topside (or whoever). Jack would have fried Sofia on the spot if she tried to pull her little escapade on him. ( Actually that's a pretty good 'alternate universe' plot with sufficient Twisty-ness/novelty, worthy of a Might-Have-Been Flashback scenario ).
We really don't know what happened to Jack. For all we know he had a massive mental breakdown after Atlas was destroyed and those 'Endings' were just delusions he had. The still living Ryan probably would have tried to reconstitute his 'son', but after much effort there wasn't enough there ( a 4 year old mutant with every though placed by Fontaine ... and brain-melted by a huge amount of ADAM and Plasmids he had been exposed to ). And so Jack was relegated to the Big Daddy Program to make him into a useful individual in the City ( and hence into Protectorism and Sofia's actions and reconstitution years later as Delta ). Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda ??? Alternate Alternates are possible with the MMORPG.
--- --- ---
The Tear Adventures Alternate Alternates : 
Think up every weird thing you can do with Tears, and implement them as MMORPG Player Creations to have a more weird and fun/entertaining Columbia ( which becomes a 'hub' for such things. ) It doesn't have to be real. All the fantasy crap from that game (and more) can simply be explained away as being a Splicer Dream/Delusion, or story told for amusement during the long long days.
The MMORPG mechanism (as specified) could handle that ( with them being Player Created Assets ).
* 'PortalHalf-Life Spinoff game-like' fun ( the physics would need to be handled by the Client program to be fast enough )
* "What's On The Other Side" with *GAME OVER* moment when it is something horrific and deadly
* "Yes, Lets Go To Paris ( Hey, Vampires in Paris ??? OR WORSE - Frenchmen !! )
* Now with story overlaps as much as you want - Big Daddy Vs Handyman Arena fighting ... Elizabeth vs Eleanor Catfight !!! Your favorite weapons from Rapture used to mow down Comstock's henchmen.
* VelociRaptors with Machineguns !!
* An Actual HISTORIC AMERICAN SETTING ( the horror !!! )
* Pony - "My Little Baptism"
--- --- ---
Blast-Fests SHOOTING SPREE TIME FOR THE MMORPG :
This special sub-game would have the MMORPG's more details, more interactions, more potential tactics ( more things to solve ) than the BS1/BS2.
Imagine a Chaos Period (Pre-New Rapture) Street Fight Mini-Campaign. Some corner of the City as unfortunate as most of the rest.
* The more there is in small places, the larger the game world seems. In reality it cannot be more than a caricature ( reality can be too boring anyway ).
* Splicers are expected to use more tricks(tactics/strategies) to make them better opponents and often will 'get away'.
* Partial results to campaign goals will happen. It is not just the loot but the experience that will be interesting ( and a goal of the Player ).
* More decisions to make with multiple goals involved and potentially more unexpected outcomes.
* More varying situations, more surprises ...
-
Consider : If there is enough interest the BS2 Multiplayer scenarios can be reworked and made playable.
--- --- ---
An Alternate Universe where the 'C's and 'K's are reversed ( and that's all ... ) :
The simple differences in spelling mistakes makes it a far different place ( that's alot of Quantum Font Quarks to flip )
Little Johnny failed at spelling and became the next Hitler ... Such is the nature of the 'multiverse'
An Aberration of 'Q' added in to alternate universes ??? - ***NO*** that would be ABSURD !!!!
Note - this is applicable to any of the games.
--- --- ---
Alternate Alternates Fun :
Battlestar Galactica ( "Cattle Car Laxative" in another Multi-verse ) had its ADAM-A ( This really doesn't make sense .. must have something to do with Infinite BS then ... Insanity caused by Tears ??? )
Flying about in a floating monstrosity - LAUNCH THE FIGHTERS !!!! ( BTW, them Zeppelin things hardly qualify as 'fighters' -- maybe if they were pyramid shaped ??? Pyramid Power (google it) was about as real as this Quantum Floaty Shit is portrayed in this verkakte game. )
The MMORPG needs to have lotsa fun ( to keep Players playing ), and Splicer Delusions is the Gateway ...
--- --- ---
You want a Happy Story - Here's a Happy Story :
Lets add to the 'wonders' of Columbia the Lutece Regenerative Machine (LRM) which used Lutece Particles to pull energy from a different dimension ( probably eventually killing everyone over on the other side ) which then could be used to power their various other 'Wonder-Devices'As the Columbia Chronicle constantly reported upon.. Unfortunately, in the various multiple parallel dimensions where this was attempted, the devices ( having to maintain an open Tear continually ) malfunctioned, went Out Of Control(tm), and caused a rip in dimensional continuum reality. Not only were countless people exposed now to dimensions where they were dead (or worse, were Mimes The most hated of the Politically Correct game target opponents ... ), but also ones where they had never existed -- Causing their heads to explode. The open Tears then absorbed further 'Lutece' energy, and expanded/collapsed until they simultaneously contained the dimensions they bridged, now completely devoid of life. It is only a matter of time for the entire continuum to collapse - utter Obliteration. 
Did you ever wonder what happened in the other dimensions where 'the coin' DIDN'T come up 'Heads' ???? Now you know. The Luteces have much to answer for.
--- --- ---
A Creepy Plot :
In the "Rapture" Novel, John Shirley had Fontaine and Tenenbaum have intimate relations.
Now a *Twisted Twist* would be that Ryan, learning of Fontaine's assassin pawn ( employing Ryan's own genetics - allegedly to get past rather poor genetically coded Security ), THEN had Tenenbaum do something similar to Fontaine - to create a Doppleganger clone of Fontaine's for some nefarious/sneaky project of his own.
--- --- ---
Creepy Alternate - 'Went to incest-ville' 
Booker tries it on with Elizabeth (a "Chinatown"Movie "Chinatown" (1974) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0071315/ moment)
--- --- ---
Plot Element (Imagineering Alternate Stories) :
Columbia had monstrous wind chimes ( stolen from Peking ? ) like 'Yah neva seen befaw' Similar line to A promotional intervie spew that Levine gave about Infinite before it came out. Put it this way : There WAS aloot of talking, but the delivery didn't live up to it.. Comstock insisted on looting them, and they drove the population batshit crazy ... A plausible Explanation for that different Universe ( through the Tear leading to ) - Where the Revolution has begun. ( The Mandatory Sing-a-longs of Hymns in Praise of Comstock also helped ).
The large Wind Chimes can also double as Execution Scaffolds for handling 'Un-mutual' people in Columbia.
--- --- ---
Limited Ideas (For Fun) :
ALL of Rapture now being Sander Cohen Water World
Imagine ALL of the Underwater City being Fort Frolic 
Sound like more "A Its A Small World" on Cocaine, with SHOTGUNS type Scenario.
Grab the Absinthe Bottles to keep the Vision going ...
Plaster Splicers are your friend ... REMEMBER what Sander Cohen does to 'friends' ...
The 'Little Moth' Experience.
--- --- ---
Infinite Infinity (alternate fun)
Fontaine/Atlas kills Jack and invades Columbia, making quick work to take over ( with a Splicer army )
Bizarre plan to make Rapture a flying city !!!!
--- --- --- 
Columbia could have just been an enormous ( flying or otherwise ) cult-controlled Ocean Liner. ( Maybe just add a giant Zeppelin gasbag above it ? ... )
 NOTE - It would NOT have changed any of the Players "shootem-up" activities ONE IOTA. Seriously - DITCH the stupid contorted QUANTUMZ plot, and have better bang-bangs -- and maybe you could actually have had the game make a profit. 
--- --- ---
Plague Outbreak in Los Angeles 1924 :
So why not in Columbia ? Some of those dodgy imports Fink steals ... Corpses EVERYWHERE.
Rats with Fleas and Contagion and Death - "DONT COME NEAR ME" (fear rampant) ...
Watch a City fall apart for REAL reasons.
--- --- ---
Another Alternate : the breaking story by Rapture's Free Press of what Fontaine was doing to the 'orphans', leading to him being LYNCHED by the population ( children cannot 'volunteer', you see ).
--- --- ---
Roosevelt's RaptorRiders invaded Columbia and slaughtered the Traitors. Ole Teddy shot Comstock through the head himself.
--- --- ---
Stabbing Daisy Fitzroy was Just the Natural Thing :
You find out Elizabeth was the heinous "Scissors Stabber" of Columbia the Police had been after for years ( and her Father for his own reasons hid her away to save her from paying for her criminal insanity ).
Her magic powers made it easy for "Crazy Lizzy" to commit her murderous crimes in multiple Columbias. Her trademark was the cut off pinky of the victims which would have been caused by a traumatic childhood event which turned her into a psychopath.
--- --- ---
World Also Advanced - Rivals :
Carnegie's flying City might 'come after' the "Flying Pirates Den".
Shouldn't Columbia's Earnest Eagle have killed and eaten 'Songbird' ( the obvious 'prey' type bird ).
Seems really wrong - Haven't they watched all those Disney Wildlife shows to know about this ?
--- --- ---
Luteces Found A New Distraction for Their Boring Immortality :
After a while the whole Columbia place should have been populated by no one but Fail Bookers. 
Bringing in 'interesting' variants from the parallel universes just to see what happens.
--- --- ---
Different Kind of Float :
Floating Rapture - or is this Columbia ( minus the magic Quantumz Floaty BS ) is now upon water ? Kinda makes it like that Jim Jone's Jonestown built in the middle of swamps in Guiana. (( Did Comstock have some Koolaid Ready ??? ))
It can still be Isolated, and Move/Migrate about the World, and have its different dystopic society without intervention of 'the outside'.
Skipping all the strange faux-science, they could concentrate of the people STORY without the distractions and magical plot crutches.
--- --- ---
Columbia coulda been a community with canals you floated around on. Maybe it actually was, and everyone in Columbia was simply 'High as a Kite' on Hallucinogens that Rosalind Lutece produced, instead of that impossible Quantumz BS.
Look - 'Gondoliers' propelling floating things. Shouldn't they have had big mechanical one for vehicles in Columbia ( Booker could use his hand chainsaw thing to fight against their long stabbing poles ).
--- --- ---
"Tiny Rapture" :
( Like that commemorative display we see in the Lighthouse ) ? or the 'Foundation' building at Ryan Amusements Museum display ? 
Some of the game developers art pictures do make Rapture look small in area ( Sander Cohen really lives only 130 feet from YOU ? Oh great !! ) I've used a Disneyland example as a way to illustrate that size ... ( original park was 180 acres ).
Much smaller sized City means trains can be in Tunnels ( and not out in the Sea - Though there would be some site-seeing routes that would extend outside ) or have them hanging/running above the crowded streets below. 
Most things would be within easy walking distance ( and elevator travel (400+ feet) is a higher percentage - with vertical movement in all those tall buildings ). You might as well have Big Daddies pulling rickshaws in the 'streets'. Networks of moving walkways would be possible/plausible.
With the way Players could create things in this MMORPG ( and using alot of Assets that would already exist ) a few 'alternate reality' versions of Rapture could be built up by creative Players with nothing better to do.
Consider a Rapture with nothing but Clones of Andrew Ryan walking about ... (easy enough ...). Whose nightmare would that be ? ( The EULA would state that no external Copyrighted characters can be used ... but face input to put on your avatar is something I hadn't mentioned as a feature ... hmmmm ).
-
As a Single PvP 'Sandbox' ??? Hmmmmm.
---
'Nano Mechanical' - Clockpunk miniature tech ( required by robots and any complex controlled machinery )
?? Use for Splicer Dream Strangeness ( as we saw in BioShock and even later in Infinite BS, that turning gears are easy animations (rotations) within standard scenery - wheels-within-wheels ... 3-Dimensional arrays of gears/shafts/chain-belts/rod-interlocks/clutches/etc ... ) 
--- --- ---
Frightening Alternates :
Go thru a Tear and Booker 'merges' with his clown self - various gyrations and puffs of confetti
One of the infinite Clown universe where 'The Columbia Circus' is "the city"
Once the dimensions 'collapse' (or whatever ...) There Is NO Undoing It !!!
We already know from th elike of Sander Cohen how sinister Clown-type characters can be.
-
Lesser Extent : So Comstock ordered everyone into their Clown outfits to make the False Shepherd stand out ...
--- --- ---
Infinite BS Was All About WOW Scenes :
So how about one of those WW1/WW2 type scenes of the Searchlights searching the skies and it suddenly illuminating a chunk of Columbia - And then the Anti-Aircraft Artillery Open Up and start striking and blowing chunks out of it. THAT would be a WOW scene. Later one of the Nuclear Missile Striking Columbia ( dimension where it lasted that long ) and Incinerating it.
--- --- ---
Browser Flash BS3 :
Picture is of a town in Alaska, which basically was built as one building ( an industry-related construction, and of the town ).
So the whole game takes place in a building like this ( with only a 'howling' cold wilderness outside ). With Zombies as the 'Enemy' ( or somesuch - and untrustworthy 'other' inhabitants ... ). 
Every room is about the same in such a building , so you can use simplistic 'Flash' detail add-ins, while the artificial voice ( provided by the operating system ) reads the 'Story' to you. Press one button to 'Loot', Press another button to 'Attack Enemy'. Press upto 4 direction buttons to move (to next screen).
Consider that Infinite BS, with its linear map paths, was about the same as this. You could then produce the game for like 100th the cost. and 'Voilà' PROFIT !!!! ( Simplicity == available on Smart Phones !!! )
Actually years ago, someone online commented after seeing Infinite BS - that with the degrading/simplification of the BioShock game, that "the NEXT BioiShock game would probably be a FLASH App ..."
--- --- --- --- ---
.
.