813

Live from the Gramercy Theater, Doug kicks off the New York edition of the 12 Guests of Christmas competition with John Hodgman, Bonnie McFarlane and 11 other guests.
==The Leonard Maltin Game==
Round	Category 	Player 	Names	Challenger 	Answer 	Person Eliminated
1 	The Skeleton Twins 	John Hodgman 	10 	Greg Wyshynski 	New York Minute 	John Hodgman
2 	Tickle Me Elmore 	Trey Galyon 	13 	Carmen Lynch 	Be Cool 	Trey Galyon
3 	LOL Cool J 	Ted Alexandro 	4 	Dan Schechter 	Woo 	Ted Alexandro
4 	The Films of Sarah Silverman 	Doogie Horner 	2 	Seth Herzog 	Sarah Silverman: Jesus Is Magic	Doogie Horner
5 	Voight or Wilson 	Greg Wyshynski	6 	Carmen Lynch 	Castaway 	Carmen Lynch
6 	Aidan Quinntessential 	Kris Tinkle 	10 	Jesse Pasternack	Benny & Joon 	Jesse Pasternack
7 	The Films of Woody Allen 	Dan Schechter 	3 	Ben Bailey 	Manhattan Murder Mystery 	Dan Schechter
8 	The Films of Bette Midler 	Ben Bailey 	3 	Rob Cantrell 	Beaches 	Ben Bailey
9 	Ethan Hawke Down 	Greg Wyshynski	0 	Seth Herzog 	Hamlet 	Greg Wyshynski
10 	Paper 	Kris Tinkle 	8 	Rob Cantrell 	Doom 	Kris Tinkle
11 	Do You Wanna Do Some Snow, Man?	Seth Herzog 	4 	Bonnie McFarlane	Scarface 	Bonnie McFarlane
12 	AsparagusP 	Seth Herzog 	-3 	Rob Cantrell 	Horrible Bosses 	Seth Herzog
Place	Player 	Movies Named
1 	Rob Cantrell 	0
2 	Seth Herzog 	1
3 	Bonnie McFarlane	0
4 	Kris Tinkle 	1
5 	Greg Wyshynski 	1
6 	Ben Bailey 	0
7 	Dan Schechter 	0
8 	Jesse Pasternack	0
9 	Carmen Lynch 	0
10 	Doogie Horner 	0
11 	Ted Alexandro 	0
12 	Trey Galyon 	0
13 	John Hodgman 	0