Nostalgia Critic-Old Vs New: A Star is Born

(shows intro)
NC:Hello I'm the Nostalgia Critic I remember it so you don't have to and welcome to another edition of Old Vs New
(shows Old Vs New Intro)
NC:Today were going to talk about a young star who became big and by that i mean A Star is Born
(shows many A Star is Born movies)
NC(VO):Sure i know what your thinking were going to do all 3 other films for A Star is Born no were doing the one from 1954.But in 2018 Another A Star is Born got rebooted for 2018 and i gotta say was a big hit but which one is better The 1954 version or the 2018 version